Past exam of the symmetry and relativity course of the University of Oxford 2015 1 a Solution 2026-10-25
Choose the source motion along , write , and let primes denote its instantaneous rest frame. A photon with rest-frame energy and direction has and transverse momentum . A Lorentz boost to the laboratory givesSince , the relativistic aberration relation and its inverse areThe mapping is monotone. The boundary of the rest-frame forward hemisphere, , therefore maps to . An isotropic photon count assigns exactly half the photons to that hemisphere, provingThe photon count inside a relativistic beaming cone concerns an emitted ensemble and counts photons, not their total energy or the arrival-time-weighted power at a detector. The laboratory photon energies depend on direction, so “half the photons” need not mean half the radiated energy. At large the angular scale is .
Past exam of the symmetry and relativity course of the University of Oxford 2015 1 c v Solution 2026-10-25
Using the conventional critical scale rather than guessing a precise Fourier-width coefficient,This is extreme ultraviolet and the very soft X-ray boundary, with a broad spectrum extending on either side; it is not a hard, multi-keV X-ray source at the stated large bending radius. The characteristic energy is not a sharp upper cutoff. For orientation, the standard angle-integrated spectral power per unit frequency peaks near eV, also in the extreme ultraviolet; a particular angular acceptance weights that spectrum differently.
The crucial scale follows from both the GeV energy and the m radius. Using only the fact that synchrotron sources can make X-rays, or replacing the bending radius by a much smaller unstated value, would misidentify the characteristic photon energies here. The critical-energy convention and the broadband character are described by the primary radiation model.[ref]
Synchrotron Radiation in the Geant4 Physics Reference Manual by Geant4 Collaboration. photon-spectrum section, equation (209), and Properties of the Power Spectra
Past exam of the symmetry and relativity course of the University of Oxford 2015 3 b Solution 2026-10-25
The covariance of a selected particle momentum sum follows because, for a fixed set of particle four-momenta, their sum is a four-vector by linearity of the Lorentz transformation. Thereforeis invariant. The subset need not comprise the entire plasma, and its particles need not move together. This expression includes cross terms between different particles; it is not the sum of their individual rest-mass squares in a.
The comparison must use the same subset and the transformed four-momenta at the same chosen events. Selecting “the lowest-energy half” anew in each frame need not do that. For example, take four photons along , with energies in each direction. The two lowest in the original frame are an opposite pair and have invariant energy squared . After a boost at along , both forward photons are redshifted enough to become the lowest pair; that new collinear pair has zero invariant mass. This does not contradict covariance, because the subset changed.
If energies are resampled on a different simultaneity slice in an interacting plasma, they can also refer to different events. A physical conserved subsystem total must then include exchanged field energy and any boundary flux as appropriate. Such operational conservation requirements are distinct from the exact algebraic covariance of a sum of fixed four-vectors.
Past exam of the symmetry and relativity course of the University of Oxford 2015 4 d Solution 2026-10-25
The photon leaves the front rocket at and moves toward decreasing , so its laboratory path is . Intersect it with the rear hyperbola, keeping the future root. Squaring and cancelling givesThe rear rocket's speed there isAt emission the front rocket is instantaneously at rest in S, so the photon laboratory frequency is . At reception the rear rocket moves in while the photon travels in . The Doppler factor for this head-on reception isThe receiver sees a blueshift. It is essential to use the front velocity at emission and the rear velocity at reception; comparing the two velocities at one laboratory time would describe the wrong pair of measurements. The result also agrees with the Rindler light-transfer frequency ratio for static accelerated observers at radii and . In the weak-acceleration limit , the shift is , and the arrival time approaches , providing useful checks.
Past exam of the symmetry and relativity course of the University of Oxford 2016 2 c a Solution 2026-10-25
Each photon has energy . Their total four-momentum isIts squared invariant is . Therefore the system's rest energy isTwo individually massless particles can thus have positive total invariant mass. Back-to-back photons give rest energy , whereas exactly parallel photons have zero invariant mass and no massive-system rest frame.
Past exam of the symmetry and relativity course of the University of Oxford 2016 4 c b Solution 2026-10-25
In a transparent uniform medium, constructive phase interference along the trajectory requires . Since , the Cherenkov cone angle obeysHere , so emission is allowed andThe electron is not an isolated vacuum particle: it interacts with the dielectric polarization of the medium. Here the angle describes the photon direction relative to the trajectory; the conical wavefront surface has the complementary angle.
This angle is the classical or negligible-recoil result. At finite photon energy, energy-momentum bookkeeping in a nondispersive medium gives a recoil correction proportional to ; no photon frequency is supplied for such a correction. In a dispersive medium use separately for each transparent frequency band.
Past exam of the symmetry and relativity course of the University of Oxford 2017 1 a Solution 2026-10-25
For a massive particle on a timelike world line, the four-velocity is , with . Its four-momentum is and its four-force is . Here is proper time. A massless trajectory does not admit this massive-particle proper-time parametrization.
The asserted classification of arbitrary orthogonal vectors is false. With the chosen Minkowski metric, and are nonzero, orthogonal and both spacelike vectors. Also and are orthogonal null vectors. The valid statement is that a nonzero vector orthogonal to a timelike vector is spacelike. To prove it, choose the rest frame of the timelike vector, ; then forces , so .
The relativistic energy-momentum relation givesTherefore . A photon is an example: . A collection of photons need not itself have zero invariant mass.
Past exam of the symmetry and relativity course of the University of Oxford 2017 1 d Solution 2026-10-25
The equal and opposite incoming momenta make the laboratory the centre-of-mass frame. The initial total four-momentum is timelike. One outgoing photon would have null four-momentum, so an isolated two-body annihilation cannot produce exactly one photon. Two photons are kinematically possible and must have opposite momenta and equal energies:The quoted is the rest energy , not a mass in SI units. The energy balance includes both rest energies as well as the total kinetic energy.
Past exam of the symmetry and relativity course of the University of Oxford 2017 2 a Solution 2026-10-25
For a vacuum electromagnetic wave, the four-wavevector is with and . Its phase can be writtenBecause and transform as Lorentz four-vectors, their contraction is a Lorentz scalar. This proves phase invariance, with the same phase convention in both frames.
For a hypothetical free emission , four-momentum conservation gives . The initial and final electrons have , and . Squaring gives . In the final electron's rest frame, however, for a nonzero future-directed photon. ThusAn external field, another body or a medium can exchange momentum and change this conclusion; those are different systems.
Past exam of the symmetry and relativity course of the University of Oxford 2017 2 c a Solution 2026-10-25
Put . The total four-momentum of the perpendicular photons isAlthough each constituent is massless, the sum has . Its invariant mass is thereforeThe rest energy is the total energy in the frame where the two photon momenta cancel, not the sum of individual photon rest energies.
Past exam of the symmetry and relativity course of the University of Oxford 2017 2 c b Solution 2026-10-25
Past exam of the symmetry and relativity course of the University of Oxford 2017 2 e Solution 2026-10-25
With , the total four-momentum is . A sum of Lorentz four-vectors transforms as a four-vector, sois a Lorentz invariant. Its value is the squared invariant mass of the complete system, irrespective of whether its constituents interact. Isolation makes the total four-momentum constant in time.
For a photon gas, write with . Its individual null norms do not make the total norm vanish:For an isotropic gas in its momentum rest frame, and . Zero is possible only when all nonzero photons propagate in the same direction. Two equal-energy photons at right angles, for example, give , rather than zero. Without an angular distribution, the pairwise expression is the general answer; isotropy is an additional assumption.
Past exam of the symmetry and relativity course of the University of Oxford 2017 3 a Solution 2026-10-25
Three relevant observable effects are the relativistic Doppler effect in spectral-line shifts, including the transverse time-dilation contribution; relativistic aberration, observable as a change of apparent light direction with observer motion; and relativistic beaming of moving emitters, associated with strongly asymmetric jet brightness. Apparent superluminal motion supplies a related light-travel-time test: can exceed one without a material speed exceeding . These interpretations require an emission and source-motion model; a cosmological or gravitational redshift by itself is not a direct test of special-relativistic kinematics.
For Compton scattering from an initially stationary electron, let incoming and outgoing photon energies be and and their mutual angle be . Four-momentum conservation gives . Squaring and using both electron mass shells and both photon null norms givesConsequently the outgoing angular frequency and shift areEquivalently, the Compton wavelength shift is . The electron recoil is essential; treating its energy as unchanged would suppress the effect.
Past exam of the symmetry and relativity course of the University of Oxford 2017 4 e Solution 2026-10-25
Let and . For a head-on photon and particle collision, boost to the particle's initial rest frame. The incident photon energy is . On the inverse-Compton branch , the maximal outgoing lab energy corresponds to rest-frame backscattering into the particle's forward direction. The exact Compton scattering recoil formula gives . Boosting the backscattered photon back to the lab givesFor this becomesOnly in the additional Thomson scattering limit may the denominator be neglected, yielding the printed estimate . Ultrarelativistic motion alone does not justify it. For example and would give from that estimate, exceeding the available total energy; the recoil-corrected maximum is about .
For an arbitrarily hard incident photon, maximizing over direction needs a further qualification: if , the largest outgoing photon energy is the unchanged , rather than this amplified backscattering branch. The exact photon energy gain is . Calling the outgoing energy the gain is accurate only when amplification is large. These distinctions prevent the inverse Compton scattering estimate from violating conservation of energy outside its low-rest-frame-photon-energy regime.
Past exam of the symmetry and relativity course of the University of Oxford 2019 2 b Solution 2026-10-25
Let label the reception event in the source reference frame. Its distance from the source and the relevant retarded time areThe received phase is . Because the observer's proper time obeys , its measured frequency isEquivalently, write and . The incoming Doppler factor is , obtained also by contracting the photon four-momentum with the observer's four-velocity. The frequency decreases monotonically, withIn particular, the instant of closest approach is not the zero-shift point: a moving receiver looking perpendicular to its motion sees a factor , not . The latter factor applies to a different moving-emitter geometry. The graph uses source-frame reception time, with observer proper time .
Past exam of the symmetry and relativity course of the University of Oxford 2019 2 c i Solution 2026-10-25
A useful plot must keep three different times separate: source emission , atomic absorption or re-emission , and return reception . For the cloud centroid,Let . Resonant excitation requires . Since decreases from to , its zero-width resonance first becomes possible atAt equality the line centre is reached only at infinite approach distance, where illumination vanishes. A finite source start time further limits how closely that ideal threshold is approached. For the line-centre event satisfiesThere is a second useful critical speed,for which excitation is centred on closest approach, . For it occurs on approach; for it occurs after closest approach. Even a receding ultra-relativistic atom can see the incident light blueshifted because is large.
A photon emitted toward the origin near the atomic rest-frame frequency has return Doppler factorThe sign differs from that in because the returning ray travels in the opposite direction. The returning line centre decreases from on early approach to on late recession, and is at closest-approach emission. The origin receives that closest-approach radiation at , not at zero. Prompt re-emission at exact resonance would giveIt is above below , equal at , and below above it. A finite fluorescence lifetime shifts emission later along the orbit and therefore usually toward a lower return frequency.
The following plots adopt a compact, optically thin cloud, weak excitation, isotropic incoherent spontaneous emission in the atomic rest frame, and negligible velocity dispersion. They show an intensity envelope as the observable amplitude; its rms electric-field amplitude is proportional to the square root of this intensity. An incoherent fluorescence signal has no fixed optical phase. The four rows include a nonrelativistic speed, both critical speeds, and an ultra-relativistic speed. All rows share one intensity normalization, so off-resonant signals remain visibly weak.
Illustrative returning fluorescence for slow motion, both resonance thresholds, and ultra-relativistic motion
. Left panels show the returned atomic line centre and its finite-width band; a dashed line marks the source frequency. Right panels show received intensity on a common logarithmic scale, with a thin curve for the zero-lifetime comparison. The model uses f0/f equal to 0.8, proper lifetime c tau/L equal to 0.4, fractional natural full width 0.02, and a finite source turn-on. Solid curves include the population decay, retarded reception and beaming. Details.A model for fluorescence from a uniformly moving cloud generating the plotted envelopes iswhere is a Lorentz line shape of full width . The factor is the incident photon-flux correction per source-frame time. The population is an exponential memory of earlier absorption events, not an instantaneous resonance indicator. For a detector of fixed small area at the origin, its received bolometric intensity scales asTwo powers of come from aberration of light, one from photon energy, and one from arrival-rate compression. Finite lifetime is dilated to in the source frame; over an interval with slowly changing geometry its observed decay time is . Thus approach can compress and amplify a pulse, while recession stretches and redshifts it. Illumination and collection each supply an inverse-square geometric factor in the prompt weak-excitation limit. Strong forward beaming can even make a detuned approaching precursor brighter than the later line-centre feature, as in the ultra-relativistic row; the intensity maximum need not occur at exact resonance.
Absolute amplitude and a unique detailed spectral line profile cannot be inferred from alone: cloud size, atom number, source power, optical depth, angular emission pattern and saturation were not specified. Finite cloud size convolves these point-centroid curves with additional delays. The plots describe incoherent, frequency-redistributed emission near ; a coherent Rayleigh scattering component would instead retain the driving frequency in the atom frame and add a different spectral component. These qualifications do not change the kinematic resonance thresholds or return-time relations.
Past exam of the symmetry and relativity course of the University of Oxford 2019 4 b ii Solution 2026-10-25
At atomic separations both massive exchange potentials are exponentially negligible. Molecular binding needs an interaction that survives at atomic distances; actual chemical bonds is governed principally by electromagnetism and quantum mechanics, with a massless photon rather than a scalar mediator. A hypothetical massless scalar would also have an unscreened potential, but its coupling and spin-dependent phenomenology would be different. The Higgs mechanism affects particle masses; that does not imply an appreciable direct Higgs-exchange force between atoms separated by .
Past exam of the symmetry and relativity course of the University of Oxford 2021 1 c Solution 2026-10-25
With the reversed electric field, reflection about exchanges the electron and Positron. They therefore meet there with equal and opposite momenta. Each travels , and the work-energy theorem gives its kinetic energy:Their combined kinetic energy is , while each total relativistic energy is . The laboratory is the center-of-momentum frame of the colliding pair.
Local four-momentum conservation in the electron-positron annihilation excludes one real photon: the incoming total four-momentum is timelike, with zero spatial component and positive energy, while a single photon's four-momentum is null and has . Two photons can balance their momenta by travelling in opposite directions, soThe equal photon energies follow from opposite equal momenta, not merely from sharing the incoming energy arbitrarily. Here . This is the free local annihilation idealization implicit in the question; significant momentum transfer to the external apparatus would change the kinematic system being considered.
Past exam of the symmetry and relativity course of the University of Oxford 2022 2 a Solution 2026-10-25
Use and define the total four-momentum . For an inertial frame moving with velocity relative to the laboratory, the Lorentz boost givesChoose parallel to and require zero total three-momentum. ThenThis requires , so that the total four-momentum is timelike. Its invariant mass is , the total relativistic energy in the center-of-momentum frame. If all particles are exactly parallel photons, the total four-momentum is null and no finite-velocity center-of-momentum frame exists.
Sign qualification. The minus sign printed in the source describes the laboratory's velocity in the center-of-momentum frame, or the parameter of an active Lorentz boost with a plus-sign spatial rule. It is not the velocity of the center-of-momentum frame relative to the laboratory under question 1's passive convention. For example, a single particle with has its rest frame moving at . The printed would give , which is not zero. This explicitly resolves the sign rather than assigning a rest frame moving away from the particle.
Past exam of the symmetry and relativity course of the University of Oxford 2022 2 b Solution 2026-10-25
By four-momentum conservation, . With the Minkowski metric, the neutral pion has , while each photon has and . Taking the Minkowski norm givesThe half-angle identity therefore yieldsThis is a measurement of the diphoton invariant mass using two photon energies and their opening angle, independent of the neutral pion's laboratory velocity.


