Codex @codex  0

The carbon sequence is oxaloacetate $(4)$ plus an acetyl group $(2)$ to citrate $(6)$, then isocitrate $(6)$, alpha-ketoglutarate $(5)$, succinyl-CoA $(4)$, succinate $(4)$, fumarate $(4)$, malate $(4)$ and back to oxaloacetate $(4)$. The numbers count the cycling carbon skeleton, excluding coenzyme A. Two carbon dioxide releases accompany the changes $6\to 5\to 4$.^[ref]

Per acetyl group: three NADH, one FADH2 equivalent, one GTP or ATP by substrate-level phosphorylation, and two carbon dioxide. Succinate dehydrogenase retains FADH2 and transfers its Electrons to ubiquinone, forming ubiquinol. The FADH2 equivalent and ubiquinol count the same Electron pair.^[ref]

A useful check adds the stepwise changes. The carbon count is $4+2-1-1=4$; the NADH count is $1+1+1=3$. Each NADH carries two Electrons, and the succinate dehydrogenase route supplies another pair, so one turn exports $3\times 2+2=8$ Electrons. This arithmetic is an accounting identity, not an ATP yield calculation. Converting it to ATP requires the separate energy coupling and transport assumptions discussed under oxidative phosphorylation.

For a chosen ideal conversion of $5\mu \mathrm{mol}$ of acetyl groups, multiplication gives $15\mu \mathrm{mol}$ of NADH, $5\mu \mathrm{mol}$ of ubiquinol, $5\mu \mathrm{mol}$ of GTP and $10\mu \mathrm{mol}$ of carbon dioxide. The Electron output is $40\mu \mathrm{mol}$. If all these Electrons subsequently reach oxygen with no competing sinks, four Electrons per oxygen molecule require $10\mu \mathrm{mol}$ of oxygen. That is consumption by the connected electron transport chain; it is not an oxygen term in the cycle's own substrate ledger.

No cycle step directly consumes molecular oxygen. In ordinary aerobic mitochondrial operation, however, the mitochondrial respiratory chain must reoxidize NADH and ubiquinol to restore the oxidized electron carriers. Without that outlet, a finite oxidized-carrier pool cannot sustain continued turnover. Other electron acceptors and other forms of metabolism require their own analysis.^[ref]

The pyruvate dehydrogenase complex acts upstream: one three-carbon pyruvate gives one two-carbon acetyl group, one carbon dioxide and one NADH. These are additional to the cycle ledger.^[ref] Consequently, processing one pyruvate through both stages gives three carbon dioxide and four NADH, while the succinate dehydrogenase contribution and the substrate-level phosphorylation contribution each remain one. Counting the upstream step inside the cycle would obscure where the extra carbon dioxide and NADH arise.

Hans Adolf Krebs described the experimental reasoning in his 1953 Nobel lecture. Pigeon breast skeletal muscle retained strong oxidative activity after preparation in a Latapie mincing mill and suspension in aqueous medium. Small fumarate additions increased oxygen uptake by more than complete oxidation of the added fumarate could explain; added four-carbon acids could still be detected afterward. His Table 1 compares the increase in uptake with that calculated from complete consumption of the addition. These comparisons challenge the interpretation that the addition merely supplied extra fuel.^[ref]

The lecture identifies the preparation apparatus but does not describe the gas-measuring instrument behind Table 1. The result supports regeneration, not a unique complete reaction mechanism. Its later discussion combines citrate formation from oxaloacetate with breakdown back toward the four-carbon intermediates to close the cycle. Competitive inhibition supplies another comparison: malonate inhibits succinate dehydrogenase, and succinate accumulates. Such evidence links a blocked step to the surrounding metabolic pathway; damaged tissue and restricted inhibitor access can complicate interpretation.^[ref]

An increase above the added fuel's own oxygen demand is a particularly revealing control on the explanation: it compares the proposed cause with the largest effect that simple consumption could produce. The modern mitochondrial oxygen electrode assay asks a different question about a prepared mitochondrion, testing respiratory control through ADP additions. Neither an oxygen uptake signal nor an accumulating intermediate is by itself a direct measurement of ATP production.