TODO: measure the relative-distance offset from an intact source figure or its numerical photometry.
For corresponding populations whose intrinsic absolute magnitudes are calibrated to match, the distance modulus in the same filter is
where is interstellar extinction in that filter. Subtracting the two equations yields
Here , , and . For a matched horizontal branch after a metallicity correction, or matched unevolved main sequences after correcting colour and composition, . Neglecting differential interstellar extinction then gives . A one-astronomical magnitude shift would mean a factor in distance, illustrating the calibration rather than measuring these panels.
A defensible numerical ratio cannot be extracted from the surviving figure. The corresponding sequences and most of the vertical scales are hidden by the corrupted image. Different bottom-axis labels or limiting astronomical magnitudes do not establish a common-population vertical offset: exposure depth and intrinsic population differences can also change them. An intact figure or numerical photometry is needed to measure , then correct and . The equation above is the quantitative inference supported by the available source; inventing an offset would not solve the missing-data problem.
TODO: identify the actual plotted branches from an intact source figure. The descriptions below explain how to do so.
In an old globular cluster's colour-magnitude diagram, the expected principal sequences are the main sequence below the main-sequence turnoff, the subgiant branch leading to the red giant branch, the horizontal branch above the main-sequence turnoff and extending across colour, and an Asymptotic giant branch above the horizontal branch, generally near and somewhat blueward of the red giant branch. A sufficiently deep diagram can also show a faint blue white dwarf cooling sequence; blue stragglers may lie above and blueward of the old main-sequence turnoff.
The two panels use the colour index , increasing toward cooler, redder stars. On a conventional apparent-astronomical magnitude vertical axis, brighter stars are higher. These coordinate conventions locate the branches just described.
The supplied PDF does not permit a complete identification of the plotted branches. Its upper image data are corrupt and render as a grey rectangle, covering the main-sequence turnoffs and evolved populations; only lower fragments and axes survive. Thus the list above identifies the relevant stellar evolution phases and how to recognize them on an intact plot, rather than claiming that every listed sequence is visibly present in this damaged source. In particular, neither a plotted white dwarf sequence nor individual blue stragglers can be confirmed from it.
Use the dimensionally correct flat Friedmann-Lemaître-Robertson-Walker metric
The source's is missing a factor , and its angular term must mean the unit-sphere line element , not the solid angle element . For example, has dimensions length times time, while has dimensions length squared. The corrected convention above removes both ambiguities.
A radial light ray has and . Thus
A proper shell volume at emission is . Multiplying by cancels the expansion factors, equivalently using the comoving volume element directly. Hence
This counts every galaxy in the shell per solid angle, rather than intersections weighted by individual galaxy areas. Near it reduces to , as expected for a Euclidean volume shell.
Conservation of the comoving galaxy population gives . Holding the proper galaxy radius fixed, integrate a:
With , , and , set . Consequently
For random uncorrelated intersections, the zero-intersection probability is from the Poisson distribution, so the fraction of the sky covered by foreground galaxies out to is
Ignoring overlaps gives . A literal shell of zero thickness exactly at has zero coverage; the integrated foreground interpretation is needed. Clustering changes the exact overlap probability, although the mean optical depth above still follows from the mean number density.
Finally,
At this optical depth, the Poisson sky coverage is , not . The large inferred cosmological redshift extrapolates conserved galaxy counts and fixed radii far beyond their plausible physical range; it is the answer within the prescribed toy model.
The Einstein-de Sitter universe has and . Normalizing therefore gives . Differentiating gives
In the local comoving rest frame, a photon crosses proper path length . Galaxies with proper number density and geometric cross section contribute the mean number of intersections . The infinitesimal probability of an intersection is the same to first order, giving
The radius is a physical radius, and is a proper number density evaluated at epoch , rather than a density already multiplied by . For a finite path with overlaps, the integrated mean count need not itself be the probability of at least one intersection.
Apply the same symmetric-ejection and causality argument to the launch proper motions, when the proposed ejecta are fastest. One obtains
and
The fitted angular decelerations describe subsequent evolution; they do not relax the bound already imposed at launch. They are observer-time phenomenological coefficients, not directly identical physical decelerations in the source frame.
The stellar parallax distance is compatible with the constant-velocity bound , but its central value exceeds the decelerating-launch bound by , or about quoted standard deviations if the uncertainty is treated as symmetric Gaussian. Even its one-standard-deviation lower endpoint, , exceeds . At the respective inferred intrinsic speeds are and . The latter is a concrete violation of causality under the symmetric model assumptions.
Thus the supplied distance favours the constant-velocity fit. This is a consistency comparison, not a full statistical model selection: uncertainties in the fitted proper motions, their correlations, intrinsic asymmetry and the distance likelihood would be required for that.
The Doppler factors for the two discrete blobs are . Their ratio is . Lorentz-invariant specific intensity means is unchanged; with and the same rest-frame power-law spectrum,
The brightness ratio at the common observed frequency therefore gives
The stated identical intrinsic specific intensities must refer to comparable intrinsic states. If the blobs fade with their proper ages, equal observer times sample different ages and need that correction. A steady continuous jet has a different boosting exponent, ; the discrete ejecta and the specified specific intensity transformation justify here.
For optically thin synchrotron radiation from an isotropic electron distribution , the characteristic emitted frequency scales as and the total single-particle power as . Thus ; integration over the full single-particle spectrum preserves this exponent. Hence
The test-particle strong nonrelativistic diffusive shock acceleration prediction is for compression ratio , giving . The inferred spectrum is steeper. If interpreted literally within that uncooled formula, would correspond to , but cooling, escape, and other acceleration conditions can also steepen it.
The observed Galactic cosmic ray differential energy spectrum below the knee is approximately , steeper still; its formal synchrotron radiation equivalent would be . Thus lies between the simplest source prediction and the propagated cosmic ray slope. The comparison is qualitative: most measured cosmic rays are nuclei, whereas the radio slope here probes electrons, and propagation and radiative losses alter the spectra differently.
For intrinsically symmetric oppositely directed relativistic jets, their proper motions are
The ratio removes and yields
Taking the product instead gives
Causality requires , so the limiting distance and inclination are
Here and in e, “maximum” denotes the limiting bound; massive ejecta obey strict inequalities. The conversion is , hence
Both bounds occur together in the light-speed limit. At any specified smaller distance, determines the intrinsic speed.
For fixed , differentiate the apparent speed with respect to angle:
The maximum lies at and has value . Hence strict apparent superluminal motion requires
The threshold is an infimum: equality yields exactly at , rather than a strictly superluminal value. For a chosen larger , the optimal inclination is , and the full superluminal interval satisfies .
Work in the source rest frame and neglect the source's small cosmological redshift. Over an emission interval , a ballistic relativistic jet feature travels , advancing toward the observer and across the sky. The second photon has a shorter journey, so its arrival is delayed by only
Dividing the projected displacement by this arrival interval gives
Apparent superluminal motion is a combination of projection and light-travel delay. The feature's local speed remains ; its inferred transverse displacement divided by the observer's arrival interval is not a local signal velocity.
In the growing-mode spherical-collapse model, use and . Their ratio in c gives . Meanwhile , and the linear growing density contrast scales as . Matching at small therefore fixes
This is a linearly extrapolated growing-mode amplitude at any epoch, including epochs where the actual density contrast is nonlinear. It carries the initial-condition qualification in c.
Numerical comparison is
The last column measures the fractional underestimate of the actual density contrast. Linear theory is accurate at , but substantially underpredicts it by the time approaches unity. At , the shell reaches spherical-collapse turnaround; .
At , and the ideal pressureless density diverges at finite time . Yet the extrapolated linear value remains finite:
This is the linear spherical-collapse threshold, not the true density contrast at collapse. Actual nonspherical collisionless systems undergo shell crossing and virialization rather than becoming uniform point singularities. The ideal virial theorem and conservation of energy estimate a final radius if the structural form is preserved.
Figure 1.
Parametric spherical collapse and the failure of the extrapolated linear density contrast
. Details.
First retain the exact initial normalization. The scale factor obeys , so the cosmological redshift is
Also and . Using gives
These equations exactly accommodate the finite-time initial conditions in b.
Now neglect and retain leading order in . Since , the cosmological redshift relation reduces to
Define . Then
The second equality is exact for the ideal common-bang growing-mode spherical-collapse model; it is approximate for the paper's finite-time initial Hubble-velocity data.
The factor has a physical origin. Linear mass conservation gives when the initial local expansion equals the background Hubble flow. The general linear dust solution is . Imposing and yields
Thus is the present extrapolation of the growing component, after neglecting the decaying transient. It is not the exact present value of the full linear solution for finite .
For and , differentiation gives
Comparison with proves . Substitution into the conserved specific orbital energy gives . Therefore
These constants exactly reproduce both the initial radius and expanding velocity. The initial parameter obeys
In an Einstein-de Sitter universe whose background big bang is , . Thus the exact required offset is
Expanding gives
One cannot set exactly at finite while retaining the stated initial Hubble velocity and background time origin. For example , gives . Shifting to removes the offset from the local orbit, but the background then scales as , not . Setting is justified in the early-initial-time limit for subsequent evolution; the following standard growing-mode formulae use that approximation.
Take the initially expanding branch ; the printed squared velocity alone also permits an initially contracting branch, which would not reach a future maximum radius. Multiply the equation of motion by and integrate. The conserved outer-shell specific orbital energy is
The initial mass follows from the background critical density:
Consequently
If means the energy of a test shell of mass , . If it means the total energy of the entire uniform, homologously moving perturbation, direct integration instead gives , and
The common convention of writing the first integral as is therefore an energy per unit shell mass, not the total energy of the sphere.
At spherical-collapse turnaround, , so . Hence
Any positive initial density contrast binds this pressureless perturbation in the stated Einstein-de Sitter universe.
Retain the consistent of d. Across a sufficiently thin layer, the neutral hydrogen column density is . The direct stellar continuum acquires optical depth . Define the photon-weighted second moment
Expanding the attenuating exponential in the photoionization rate gives
The second cross section moment appears because the radiation both undergoes absorption and is weighted by the photoionization cross section in computing the rate.
In a local plane-parallel approximation that suppresses geometrical dilution, set
Then local photoionization equilibrium becomes , so
This gives the requested algebraic dependence, with the corrected definition of . Besides , linear attenuation requires over the frequencies contributing appreciably to the rate. In particular must remain positive.
The source's neglects , which is also first order in layer thickness. A consistent spherical first-order answer uses in the same root. Neglecting dilution relative to absorption additionally requires . As a concrete limiting test, with negligible absorption the source's predicts no change, while inverse-square dilution still decreases and thus .
Let be the photoionization rate per neutral hydrogen atom just outside the empty cavity. With an isotropic central source and no attenuation inside that cavity,
The cross section is zero below threshold; this permits the lower integration limit zero. Pure hydrogen with hydrogen ionization fraction has and . Local photoionization equilibrium is therefore
Define the dimensionless quantity . Solving the resulting quadratic equation, , gives the physical root
The rationalized form avoids numerical cancellation for small . Strong illumination gives ; weak illumination gives .
Eliminating with the H-alpha luminosity, , yields
The printed definition of is inconsistent with the defined radii. The source calls a physical stellar radius, but its factor gives units of length to the fourth power, rather than a dimensionless value. It also omits the physically necessary cavity radius . For a concrete counterexample, double while holding the source, , and fixed: the incident photoionization rate falls by four, so rises by four; the printed expression does not change. The root has the requested form with the corrected above. There is no supplied relation allowing to be replaced by .
An additional atomic input is needed: the total Case B recombination coefficient does not specify the number of H-alpha photons per net radiative recombination. Let , where is the effective recombination coefficient. At the approximately temperature implicit in the supplied , take . The coefficient 2.2 used later in the paper corresponds to , which we use consistently here.
For an unextinguished, fully filled Strömgren sphere with negligible central cavity, the H-alpha luminosity and observed radiative flux satisfy
Substitution eliminates and gives
Convert the angular diameter to radians: . Also . Thus
The implied hydrogen-ionizing photon production rate is . Using instead gives . These values use the printed milliarcseconds and integrated line observed radiative flux. Assuming one H-alpha photon per recombination would give a different, unjustified distance. An appreciable cavity or a nonunit filling factor must also enter the emitting volume.
The Brackett series consists of transitions ending at , at infrared wavelengths. They suffer much less interstellar extinction than H-alpha, so their corrected observed radiative fluxes can give a more reliable version of the same inference. At fixed measured angular size and number density, the formula has : uncorrected interstellar extinction therefore makes this particular distance estimate too small. Infrared lines are weaker and need their own effective recombination coefficients; their advantage is reduced sensitivity to dust.
Write for the hydrogen-ionizing photon production rate, counting only photons above the hydrogen ionization energy, not all stellar photons. In steady photoionization equilibrium, the external supply balances the volume integral of net Case B recombination:
For uniform, almost completely ionized pure hydrogen, . Hence
The final approximation requires . The Strömgren sphere also assumes spherical symmetry, a sharp ionization front, a steady source older than the recombination time, uniform number density and temperature so that is constant, negligible dust absorption of ionizing photons, negligible leakage, and no important helium correction or collisional ionization. Clumping would replace by a volume average of .
A hydrogen recombination line is a discrete spectral line produced when radiative recombination captures an electron into an excited bound level and a subsequent radiative cascade emits photons. The free-to-bound capture itself produces a continuum; the later bound-to-bound transitions produce the recombination lines. For example, H-alpha is the transition in the Balmer series.
For the neutral hydrogen absorbing an ionizing stellar continuum, the principal bound-free transition is photoionization from the ground state into the continuum. Most neutral hydrogen is in its ground state, and the photoionization cross section is largest near its threshold, falling approximately as above it. Dominance of the population-weighted opacity is intended here; this does not mean that every excited-state microscopic cross section is smaller at every frequency.
In an ionization-bounded, optically thick nebula, direct radiative recombination into emits an ionizing photon that promptly photoionizes another hydrogen atom. One ion disappears and another is created: there is no net removal of an ion from the global budget. Case B recombination therefore uses , with local recycling of ground-state recombination photons. This is the on-the-spot approximation, rather than an unconditional property of radiative recombination: if those photons escape, direct capture does produce net neutralization and a Case A treatment is appropriate.
Write for the retained fraction and for an opposite kick. With more than half the mass lost, . A same-direction kick cannot bind the pair, because . An opposite kick can reduce the relative speed enough to leave negative energy:
Both endpoints are marginal zero-energy cases. Kicks somewhat larger than can still satisfy this interval, but then the direction of the relative orbital motion is reversed.
At , the two surviving stars have identical instantaneous velocities, so their relative velocity and orbital angular momentum vanish. Their energy is nevertheless negative,
They fall radially toward each other from rest in their new centre-of-mass frame. In the point-mass idealization the collision orbit has semimajor axis and zero pericentre; real finite-size stars collide or interact before reaching zero separation. It is not a stable circular binary. Zero relative angular momentum, rather than the negative energy alone, determines this plunge outcome.
Figure 1.
Binding after instantaneous mass loss for parallel and opposite natal kicks
. The retained mass fraction is and the kick magnitude is normalized to the original relative speed. Blue regions have negative orbital energy. The curves mark marginal escape. At an opposite normalized kick of one, the relative angular momentum vanishes and the survivors plunge together. Details.

Pinned article: Introduction to the OurBigBook Project

Welcome to the OurBigBook Project! Our goal is to create the perfect publishing platform for STEM subjects, and get university-level students to write the best free STEM tutorials ever.
Everyone is welcome to create an account and play with the site: ourbigbook.com/go/register. We belive that students themselves can write amazing tutorials, but teachers are welcome too. You can write about anything you want, it doesn't have to be STEM or even educational. Silly test content is very welcome and you won't be penalized in any way. Just keep it legal!
We have two killer features:
  1. topics: topics group articles by different users with the same title, e.g. here is the topic for the "Fundamental Theorem of Calculus" ourbigbook.com/go/topic/fundamental-theorem-of-calculus
    Articles of different users are sorted by upvote within each article page. This feature is a bit like:
    • a Wikipedia where each user can have their own version of each article
    • a Q&A website like Stack Overflow, where multiple people can give their views on a given topic, and the best ones are sorted by upvote. Except you don't need to wait for someone to ask first, and any topic goes, no matter how narrow or broad
    This feature makes it possible for readers to find better explanations of any topic created by other writers. And it allows writers to create an explanation in a place that readers might actually find it.
    Figure 1.
    Screenshot of the "Derivative" topic page
    . View it live at: ourbigbook.com/go/topic/derivative
  2. local editing: you can store all your personal knowledge base content locally in a plaintext markup format that can be edited locally and published either:
    This way you can be sure that even if OurBigBook.com were to go down one day (which we have no plans to do as it is quite cheap to host!), your content will still be perfectly readable as a static site.
    Figure 5. . You can also edit articles on the Web editor without installing anything locally.
    Video 3.
    Edit locally and publish demo
    . Source. This shows editing OurBigBook Markup and publishing it using the Visual Studio Code extension.
  3. https://raw.githubusercontent.com/ourbigbook/ourbigbook-media/master/feature/x/hilbert-space-arrow.png
  4. Infinitely deep tables of contents:
    Figure 6.
    Dynamic article tree with infinitely deep table of contents
    .
    Descendant pages can also show up as toplevel e.g.: ourbigbook.com/cirosantilli/chordate-subclade
All our software is open source and hosted at: github.com/ourbigbook/ourbigbook
Further documentation can be found at: docs.ourbigbook.com
Feel free to reach our to us for any help or suggestions: docs.ourbigbook.com/#contact