Insert the diagonal covariance from a into the two-point function and apply the spherical harmonic addition theorem:
The Legendre polynomials encode the angular separation. Since , the zero-separation value is the total variance. For measured Cosmic microwave background anisotropy, remove the monopole and usually the kinematic dipole, so the corresponding sum starts at ; an instrument's angular response supplies an additional window function.
Primordial density contrasts perturb the intrinsic photon temperature, the gravitational potential, and the velocity of the last-scattering material. Intrinsic photon-density fluctuations obey because ; adiabatic initial conditions relate these to matter density contrasts. Subsequent acoustic evolution, Doppler effect and gravitational frequency shifts determine the observed Cosmic microwave background anisotropy. There is no scale-independent identification of the final sky map with matter density contrast alone.
The spherical harmonic coefficients are random variables inherited from these perturbations. After subtracting the mean sky temperature, for the anisotropy modes. Gaussian primordial perturbations give approximately Gaussian random variables; this extra Gaussian assumption is not needed for diagonal covariance. Reality of the sky map implies .
For a statistically isotropic sky, its two-point function depends only on . Rotations mix the components at fixed and do not mix different irreducible spaces. A rotation-invariant covariance matrix is therefore a multiple of the identity in each block:
On our one sky, average the angular components at fixed , or equivalently suitable rotated sky pairs, rather than treating different universes as observed samples. The CMB angular power spectrum is estimated by
Under the Gaussian, full-sky, noiseless assumptions, there are independent real degrees of freedom and . This cosmic variance remains even with perfect detectors; a finite sky mask and detector noise add further uncertainty. The estimator is unbiased, , but does not turn one realization into the exact ensemble mean.
For a gas-pressure-supported stellar core of fixed mass and composition, neglect boundary terms for the illustrative whole-core estimate. The virial theorem gives , and the monatomic gas gives . Thus the effective heat capacity along the equilibrium sequence is
This negative heat capacity of a virialized gravitational system means that net energy loss makes a self-gravitating core contract and heat. It is different from the positive local material specific heat capacity. On the main sequence, hydrogen burning supplies most of the radiated energy, so rapid contraction is arrested. Hydrogen depletion increases the mean molecular weight; slow structural readjustment usually raises the central temperature rather than making it fall.
After core hydrogen exhaustion, a massive stellar core contracts and heats more rapidly until a later nuclear fuel ignites. There is no general reversal to cooling simply upon leaving the main sequence. If radiation pressure becomes dominant, the internal energy becomes with . The virial theorem therefore gives ; the radiation-dominated limit is marginally bound and its effective adiabatic index approaches .
Quasistatic contraction can still maintain virial equilibrium. It fails dynamically only when sufficient support is lost, for example if pair creation reduces the effective adiabatic index below , or when an iron core undergoes electron capture and photodisintegration. A fixed-composition gas-dominated contracting core with is already a counterexample to any assertion that leaving the main sequence alone reverses the heating or destroys virial equilibrium.
For a regular spherical star, let and . The stellar mass conservation equation and stellar hydrostatic equation are
Assuming the smoothness needed for the requested Taylor series, write . There is no point mass at the centre, so , and matching the stellar mass conservation equation gives , . Substitution in the stellar hydrostatic equation gives , hence
The remainder orders use a smooth spherically symmetric scalar density, for which . Merely finite continuous density gives the same leading coefficients with and remainders. In particular , despite the apparent in the stellar hydrostatic equation.
For a family of spherical profiles with a fixed dimensionless shape, write the gravitational potential energy as , where depends on that shape. The virial theorem in b and the sphere volume give
For a uniform density, ; formally integrating for gives . Neither the virial theorem nor the initial profile guarantees a specific final shape, so the proportionality requires the stated homologous-profile assumption. Surface pressure must be handled consistently with b before using either coefficient as an equilibrium model.
Assume an isolated, bound, nonrotating Newtonian gas cloud, negligible surface pressure, negligible magnetic and radiation stresses, no persistent bulk flow, and a stationary or time-averaged virialized state. The stellar virial theorem then reduces to
where is the total gravitational potential energy. Define the volume-averaged pressure and average gravitational energy density . Hence
Equivalently, for a nonrelativistic monatomic gas, the thermal internal energy obeys . This second derivation must not count the thermal motions again as a separate bulk kinetic energy. If the external pressure is , the correct result is ; non-negligible bulk motion adds to the virial theorem. The initial sharp-edged profile need not survive virialization; maintaining that profile hydrostatically to its edge would generally require a surface term.
There are two different physical interpretations. The supplied logarithmic integral signals free fall in a fixed singular isothermal sphere, with a test particle moving through a frozen background. Write . By the shell theorem, the enclosed mass is and the radial equation of motion is
The second equality follows by multiplying by and using the initial rest condition. The free fall trajectory is given implicitly by
Thus the intended fixed-profile answer is
A collapsing material shell gives a different answer. If the entire cloud undergoes pressureless gravitational collapse from rest, the edge follows the fixed enclosed mass , not the instantaneous fixed-profile value . With no shell crossing, , so
This is a concrete counterexample to treating the fixed-profile result as the exact collapse time of the whole nebula. The initial mean density inside is , consistent with the usual free-fall time of a uniform sphere expressed using that mean density. The logarithmic integral is valid for the explicitly frozen background approximation.
Adopt the stipulated neutral fraction , independently of the equilibrium estimate in e. For pure hydrogen, . The thermal Sunyaev-Zeldovich effect measures integrated electron pressure:
Using the same absorbing line of sight as in d,
Thus one such filament is below the stated measurement sensitivity. If the number density inferred transversely is instead used to view the same cylinder end-on, its path is twenty times longer and , still below the stated sensitivity. Changing the assumed path of the original absorption measurement while keeping its column density fixed does not change its predicted . The quoted neutral-fraction floor is a premise of this estimate, not a universal bound derivable from thermal equilibrium.
True thermal equilibrium requires a thermal ionizing radiation field as well as chemical balance; equality of photoionization and recombination rates alone would require a specified external radiation field. Under the stronger equilibrium assumption, apply the Saha equation to pure hydrogen. The electron spin factor cancels the ground-state electronic degeneracy, giving
At , and . Charge neutrality gives . Importantly, the known quantity from d is the neutral number density, not the total number density; use Saha neutral fraction from a measured neutral density to obtain . Therefore
This extraordinarily small neutral fraction is the result of applying thermal equilibrium to dilute intergalactic gas; it is not a realistic inference from photoionization equilibrium with a nonthermal cosmic background. For the axial geometry of d, the equilibrium neutral fraction is smaller by .
For the unresolved Lyman-alpha line, the lower and combined upper state degeneracies are and , so the Einstein coefficients give
The measured equivalent width then implies
Assume a central transverse line of sight through a uniform filament, so . Nearly all neutral hydrogen is in its ground state at this temperature, hence
The cylinder's length determines its total volume but does not enter a transverse column density. Geometry must be specified: an axial line of sight has and gives for the same measured equivalent width. Intermediate chords give intermediate path-dependent estimates. The numbers above treat as a rest-frame equivalent width; an observed value at redshift must first be divided by .
With the spontaneous emission term suppressed, . A uniform absorption coefficient over length gives directly
The normalized specific intensity deficit is unchanged by conversion between wavelength and frequency, since both numerator and denominator acquire the same Jacobian determinant. The Boltzmann distribution and the Einstein coefficients give . Consequently, in the optically thin limit,
Here is the column density, and has been used in slowly varying factors. This linear relation between equivalent width and column density fails once the central optical depth becomes appreciable.
Use the Einstein coefficients convention in which multiplies spectral radiation energy density , with . A normalized spectral line profile obeys . The spontaneous emission probability per upper-state atom per unit time is ; the stimulated emission and upward absorption rates per atom are respectively and .
For isotropic spontaneous emission, transitions occur per unit volume and time, each supplying photon energy . Dividing among steradians gives
For a small incident beam, its contribution to is . Absorption removes and stimulated emission adds photons in the incident direction. Matching the net loss to therefore gives
Replacing by across the narrow spectral line profile gives the printed expressions. The negative sign is essential: an inverted population can amplify the incident specific intensity. Thermal equilibrium and the Planck function imply and , where is the state degeneracy. A convention using mean intensity instead changes both coefficients by .
The specific intensity is energy transported per unit time, projected area, solid angle and frequency. The path coordinate increases along the ray. The emission coefficient is emitted energy per unit time, volume, solid angle and frequency, whereas the absorption coefficient has units of inverse length. Thus adds specific intensity and removes it. Stimulated emission can be included as negative absorption.
Define the optical depth between two points by . Multiplying the radiative transfer equation by the integrating factor and integrating gives
Each local contribution is attenuated only by the material between its emission point and the observer. Where , the source function is and the same formal solution of the radiative transfer equation is . A constant source function gives .
Let the uniform thin galactic disk have outer radius and surface mass density , where is the mass calculated in a. If the redistribution retains the stated outer radius, set ; otherwise alone does not determine both and .
A ring of radius and width has mass . By axial symmetry its transverse gravitational force components cancel. At signed height , its vertical force on a star of mass is
Integrating the rings gives, for ,
Thus
For a positive distance above the plane, this is , directed toward the disk. With , the inferred sets its normalization.
The far-field expansion gives , as required for a point-like total mass. Close to either face, , the infinite-sheet limit. The ideal zero-thickness model has a jump in gravitational field at ; the formula is understood through its one-sided limits. Its symmetric mean is zero on the plane, and a disk of finite thickness resolves the discontinuity.
At large radius , so the spherical enclosed mass is . A spherical mass density satisfies , and hence
Equivalently, a local power law with enclosed mass dominated by that extended profile has and . A flat galaxy rotation curve requires .
Differentiating the exact mass profile verifies the limit and the finite central density:
As , the bracket is , so . As , it tends to one, recovering the tail. Extending the flat galaxy rotation curve to infinity makes total mass diverge linearly; a real finite halo must eventually depart from this idealization.
Put . A Taylor expansion near the centre gives
Therefore the circular angular frequency is
Thus the central motion approaches solid-body rotation. Numerically , and the central orbital period tends to
The finite limit of accompanies at ; it does not imply a finite central linear speed.
For a spherical mass distribution, the shell theorem says the circular gravitational acceleration is . Balancing it against the centripetal acceleration gives
At , the galaxy rotation curve gives . With ,
This is the total dynamically inferred enclosed mass, including any dark matter; the galaxy rotation curve alone does not separate its components.
For ordinary single stars in these old globular clusters, no current core-collapse supernovae are expected, and no new black holes are expected from the normal plotted population. Their main-sequence turnoff masses are typically around , far below the roughly initial-mass scale for advanced burning and core collapse. More massive original stars exhausted their much shorter main-sequence lifetimes long ago. The precise transition mass depends on composition and mass loss, but this large separation makes the conclusion robust.
The low-mass stars now leaving the main sequence evolve through the red giant branch, helium ignition, horizontal branch and Asymptotic giant branch. They lose their envelopes and leave mainly carbon-oxygen white dwarfs, typically around – for current old-cluster progenitors, supported by electron degeneracy pressure. A visible planetary nebula is possible if the exposed core heats before the ejecta disperse; it is not guaranteed for every low-mass remnant. Lower-mass main-sequence stars repeat this evolution only much later, and the very lowest-mass isolated stars can ultimately leave helium-rich degenerate remnants without igniting helium.
The clusters may already contain neutron stars and black holes made by their original massive stars; these remnants need not appear on an optical colour-magnitude diagram. Binary interactions can instead produce stripped helium white dwarfs, mergers or a possible Type Ia supernova; such exceptions are distinct from normal single-star core collapse. No such special progenitor can be established from the damaged plots. In particular, a luminous red giant is not by itself evidence for a massive core-collapse supernova progenitor.
On the main sequence, central hydrogen burning converts four protons into helium, positrons, neutrinos and released energy. The net reaction is , with positron annihilation contributing to the total roughly release before subtracting escaping neutrino energy. In the low-mass main-sequence stars of an old globular cluster, the proton–proton chain generally dominates. The CNO cycle makes the same net conversion and becomes important in hotter burning regions.
After central hydrogen exhaustion, a subgiant contracts its helium core and establishes a hydrogen-burning shell. On the red giant branch, that shell supplies most of the luminosity, commonly through the temperature-sensitive CNO cycle, while the inert helium core grows and becomes supported mainly by electron degeneracy pressure. The envelope expands and its surface cools. The helium core is not yet powered by helium nuclear fusion.
Helium ignition in a sufficiently low-mass degenerate core produces the helium flash, removing the strong electron degeneracy pressure dominance. A horizontal-branch star subsequently burns helium in its core through the Triple-alpha process, , and through . A surrounding hydrogen-burning shell can continue simultaneously.
After central helium exhaustion, the Asymptotic giant branch has an inert carbon-oxygen core with a helium-burning shell and an outer hydrogen-burning shell. Alternation between quiescent burning and helium-shell thermal pulses drives mixing and substantial mass loss. Subsequent post-asymptotic giant branch evolution exposes a hot core that may ionize its expelled envelope as a planetary nebula. Finally a white dwarf cools mainly by loss of stored thermal energy, rather than sustained central nuclear fusion.
TODO: assign the physical differences to the actual two panels once the missing evolved-star sequences are recovered.
The main intrinsic parameters for old globular clusters are age, metallicity, helium abundance and the distribution of envelope masses after red giant branch mass loss. Distance and foreground interstellar extinction alter the appearance and must first be removed before assigning intrinsic differences.
Age controls the main-sequence turnoff: a more massive star has a shorter main-sequence lifetime, approximately fuel divided by luminosity. An older coeval population therefore has a smaller turnoff mass and a fainter, generally redder main-sequence turnoff. The separation in astronomical magnitude between the main-sequence turnoff and horizontal branch is useful because a common distance modulus cancels.
At comparable age, larger metallicity increases stellar-envelope opacity and atmospheric line blanketing. This generally makes the red giant branch and main sequence redder; metal-poor populations tend to have hotter, bluer red giant branches. Metallicity also affects hydrogen burning through the CNO cycle, so a quantitative age inference needs composition-dependent stellar models.
The horizontal branch is especially sensitive to envelope mass: at similar helium-core mass, a thinner hydrogen envelope gives a higher effective temperature and hence a bluer location. Red giant branch mass loss, age and helium abundance all influence that envelope and produce the familiar “second parameter” complexity. Enhanced helium also changes mean molecular weight, luminosity and evolutionary lifetime, and can shift main sequences and horizontal branches.
Interstellar extinction dims the diagram, while wavelength-dependent interstellar extinction reddens ; distance primarily supplies a vertical distance modulus shift. A systematic bend or different horizontal branch colour distribution cannot be explained by distance alone. Because the source hides the evolved branches, it is not possible to assign “older”, “more metal rich”, or “bluer horizontal branch” to a particular panel reliably. The preceding mechanisms give the warranted physical interpretation without inventing the lost observational differences.

Pinned article: Introduction to the OurBigBook Project

Welcome to the OurBigBook Project! Our goal is to create the perfect publishing platform for STEM subjects, and get university-level students to write the best free STEM tutorials ever.
Everyone is welcome to create an account and play with the site: ourbigbook.com/go/register. We belive that students themselves can write amazing tutorials, but teachers are welcome too. You can write about anything you want, it doesn't have to be STEM or even educational. Silly test content is very welcome and you won't be penalized in any way. Just keep it legal!
We have two killer features:
  1. topics: topics group articles by different users with the same title, e.g. here is the topic for the "Fundamental Theorem of Calculus" ourbigbook.com/go/topic/fundamental-theorem-of-calculus
    Articles of different users are sorted by upvote within each article page. This feature is a bit like:
    • a Wikipedia where each user can have their own version of each article
    • a Q&A website like Stack Overflow, where multiple people can give their views on a given topic, and the best ones are sorted by upvote. Except you don't need to wait for someone to ask first, and any topic goes, no matter how narrow or broad
    This feature makes it possible for readers to find better explanations of any topic created by other writers. And it allows writers to create an explanation in a place that readers might actually find it.
    Figure 1.
    Screenshot of the "Derivative" topic page
    . View it live at: ourbigbook.com/go/topic/derivative
  2. local editing: you can store all your personal knowledge base content locally in a plaintext markup format that can be edited locally and published either:
    This way you can be sure that even if OurBigBook.com were to go down one day (which we have no plans to do as it is quite cheap to host!), your content will still be perfectly readable as a static site.
    Figure 5. . You can also edit articles on the Web editor without installing anything locally.
    Video 3.
    Edit locally and publish demo
    . Source. This shows editing OurBigBook Markup and publishing it using the Visual Studio Code extension.
  3. https://raw.githubusercontent.com/ourbigbook/ourbigbook-media/master/feature/x/hilbert-space-arrow.png
  4. Infinitely deep tables of contents:
    Figure 6.
    Dynamic article tree with infinitely deep table of contents
    .
    Descendant pages can also show up as toplevel e.g.: ourbigbook.com/cirosantilli/chordate-subclade
All our software is open source and hosted at: github.com/ourbigbook/ourbigbook
Further documentation can be found at: docs.ourbigbook.com
Feel free to reach our to us for any help or suggestions: docs.ourbigbook.com/#contact