Substitution of gives
The phase velocity is negative for all nonzero wavenumbers, so crests travel left. The group velocity is negative for , zero at , and positive for . Its minimum is at zero and maximum at ; it tends to zero from above at infinity. The odd dispersion relation has extrema at , with .
The Fourier solution is . The stationary-phase statements require enough amplitude regularity and decay, for example smooth and rapidly decreasing; realness and evenness alone do not guarantee a convergent integral or a stationary-phase expansion. For , set and solve implicitly.
For an axisymmetric vertical mode of a shearing sheet in this Boussinesq approximation, the perturbations have no horizontal gradients, so background-shear advection vanishes. The linear Coriolis acceleration and perturbation advection of the background shear give
while thermal conduction and incompressibility give
Here is the thermal diffusion rate of a Fourier mode, not the cooling exponent in Question 2. Since , incompressibility forces , and the vertical momentum equation then forces for this nonzero-wavenumber amplitude.
The three remaining amplitudes satisfy
A nontrivial solution requires the determinant to vanish, giving the convective overstability dispersion relation
No division by or was needed, so the thermal energy mode of a shearing sheet is retained. The notation denotes a signed buoyancy frequency squared and can be negative for an adverse stratification; it must not be restricted to the square of a real positive frequency.
Treat as a signed small parameter, with , as printed in the original PDF. At , the dispersion relation factors as
Thus the two epicyclic motion modes have , while the thermal energy mode of a shearing sheet has
It decays on the thermal diffusion time . For completeness, its next correction is at fixed .
For either epicyclic motion root, the implicit function theorem applied to the dispersion relation gives
Hence
Since , the oscillations undergo overstability precisely when
The convective overstability growth rate tends to zero both for very slow diffusion and for very fast diffusion. Differentiating shows that its maximum occurs at , corresponding to . Therefore
This is the growth rate of the perturbation amplitude; a quadratic perturbation energy grows at twice that rate. The convective overstability arises when an adverse radial specific entropy gradient couples to epicyclic motion with a finite thermal conduction lag.
Let , , and use the four regional amplitudes above. Continuity of at the two jumps gives
Pressure continuity, using vorticity-jump matching for an inviscid shear flow, gives the other two equations:
These are the required homogeneous four equations. As a useful reduction, put , , and . Eliminating leaves
The vanishing determinant gives , which expands to the printed dispersion relation.
For fixed , and . The factored dispersion relation therefore gives
where the latter follows from and . A real negative yields a growing branch for positive . Thus gives instability at sufficiently small nonzero wavenumber.
For the converse, monotonicity toward the limiting value one would suffice, as permitted in the question. In fact a direct sign argument avoids this extra assumption. With , , so . If , then and . Hence , so for every . We obtain the exact instability threshold for a bounded piecewise-linear shear layer:
At the long-wave limiting value is zero, but every finite positive wavenumber has .
Take in the injection direction and along the flat interface. The specified must be a Darcy velocity, so the pore-fluid velocity and unperturbed interface speed are . Write the perturbed interface as , with , and choose the normal from fluid 1 into fluid 2. The background pressure gradients from Darcy law are .
By incompressibility and uniform permeability of a porous medium, pressure perturbations are harmonic functions. A transverse Fourier mode with positive wavenumber has the decaying forms
The kinematic boundary condition and equal normal Darcy flux imply
Without capillarity the pressure is continuous at the displaced interface. Its linear perturbation is therefore
Consequently the planar viscous-fingering dispersion relation reduces to
This is the Saffman–Taylor instability: less viscous fluid advances preferentially through protrusions. Without a short-wave regularizing mechanism the idealized rate has no finite maximum.
For the prescribed apparent capillary pressure, the chosen normal is , so . Subtract the flat-front pressure jump . Linearization of the jump at gives
There is no first-order product of the surface-tension perturbation and the perturbed macroscopic curvature. Thus
Using the capillary number convention and , this is
If is measured from the unperturbed front and denotes its local apparent tension, set to obtain the usual fixed-coefficient expression. For a physically fixed spatial gradient, and the displayed rate is an instantaneous, generally time-dependent growth rate; the amplitude solves , rather than one constant exponential law for the entire displacement. The parameter has dimensions of inverse length; the absolute tension gradient is .
Assume , as required for positive apparent surface tension, and define . If , unstable modes satisfy . Differentiating the cubic dispersion relation gives the fastest-growing mode
When , every nonzero mode decays, with a neutral zero-wavenumber translation in the infinite-domain limit. For , surface-tension-gradient stabilization of viscous fingering suppresses the instability entirely at positive injection speeds satisfying
If , no positive injection speed eliminates every long-wave unstable mode in an unbounded interface. The prescribed wetting variation is treated as an effective normal pressure law for porous-media flow.
Write , with the upper sign referring to , and use an f-plane with Coriolis parameter for the stated directions. The formulas retain the signed ; a positive Rossby deformation radius means . Let be the constant fluid density.
Far from the depth step the problem is independent of . The linearized shallow water equations imply conservation of . Initially this is . In geostrophic balance, and , so
Boundedness and matching of height and its derivative at give geostrophic adjustment of a surface-height jump:
The potential energy release per unit length in is the finite difference between two individually infinite energies:
For comparison, the final kinetic energy is , so the energy radiated in inertia-gravity waves is . Integrating the depth-weighted velocity over gives the volume transports
For , is towards the step and is away from it. Their difference is ; a global steady state cannot simply join the two far-field currents without additional transport along the step.
To obtain the rotating shallow-water height equation with variable depth, set and . Direct differentiation of the original momentum and continuity equations gives
Consequently
At the step, is a Dirac delta distribution; the original matching conditions are used rather than assuming a smooth depth there. Velocity elimination raises the time order: initially and , as well as the prescribed initial height.
For a decaying harmonic disturbance, the height equation on each constant-depth side gives
Solving the two momentum equations yields
Continuity of at the step gives the implicit step-trapped topographic Rossby wave dispersion relation
This derivation assumes and positive decay rates; it describes the low-frequency trapped branch, rather than the radiating inertia-gravity waves.
In the quasi-geostrophic approximation, replace by . The resulting explicit frequency, and then its leading small- form, are
For , the phase velocity has the sign of . Thus propagation is eastward in the Northern Hemisphere, with the shallower side on the right. Differentiating the leading dispersion relation gives
In the long-wave limit the group velocity and phase velocity coincide:
To find the slow amplitude, integrate the low-frequency height equation across the step. This gives , where brackets mean the upper-side minus lower-side value. For the given exponentially trapped outer profile, and . Hence long-wave transport along a depth step obeys
The method of characteristics, interpreted for the Dirac delta distribution source, gives
For this is in and zero outside: a surface depression is left in the wake of the wave. The sharp -jump is a long-wave outer approximation. The fast adjustment region of width near the origin, and the detailed wavefront, are unresolved. Keeping a smoothed background instead would give and at this order.
The along-step geostrophic flow is . Integrating separately over the two sides gives
In the wake, and . The shallow-side transport is eastward and the deep-side transport westward, with magnitudes equal to the respective far-field currents. The net along-step transport is , balancing their mismatch. These comparisons use the stated leading long-wave and small-depth-contrast approximations.
Let denote the fluid pressure perturbation divided by the reference mass density, and let be the buoyancy perturbation. The buoyancy frequency satisfies . Linearization requires small boundary slope , small displacements compared with the vertical scales of the disturbance and background, and advection small compared with the oscillatory acceleration. For a propagating internal gravity wave this includes ; boundary slope alone is insufficient when . The Boussinesq approximation also requires small relative mass density differences over the region of interest. These conditions must hold for the resulting disturbance, including any amplification by resonance.
The inviscid Linearized Boussinesq equations and linear kinematic boundary condition are
Write the velocity field as . Incompressibility and horizontal momentum balance give
The vertical momentum balance therefore yields
For a real vertical wavenumber , this gives the dispersion relation
When , define . The radiation condition selects , because energy must leave the boundary upward. The boundary-forced internal gravity wave is
Its wavevector is , its phase velocity is , and its group velocity is
Thus the phase velocity points down and right, while the group velocity points up and right. They are perpendicular. Internal-wave polarization makes the particle motion an oscillation along the group velocity direction, with zero first-order mean transport. The constant-phase lines of an internal gravity wave are also parallel to the group velocity. Their inclination above the horizontal satisfies .
When , set . Boundedness at infinity selects the evanescent wave
The horizontal and vertical velocity components are in quadrature: fluid particles describe small ellipses, and the response decays over . There is no upward time-averaged energy flux, because and are in quadrature. A real vertical group velocity is not defined for this evanescent wave. The pattern travels horizontally with phase velocity .
For the response is the evanescent wave with ; the ratios should not be used. At the cutoff , the bounded harmonic solution has , : it neither decays nor has nonzero upward group velocity. It is the limiting cutoff response, rather than a localized radiating disturbance. A uniform nonzero buoyancy frequency in an infinitely deep Boussinesq approximation is itself a local idealization of the background mass density.
Figure 1.
Propagating and evanescent responses
.
The arrows distinguish the phase velocity, group velocity, and oscillatory particle motion of the internal gravity wave. The right panel shows the decay envelope and particle ellipses of the evanescent wave.
Eliminate the transport amplitudes in the linear stability analysis. For a general bed shear response , the dispersion relation is
This is the most specific result available without adding the missing hydrodynamic closure. With , set
Multiplication by gives the growth rate and migration velocity
The packed-bed volume fraction cancels. For a real physical closure the negative wavenumber response is the complex conjugate; the displayed formulas cover the independent normal modes.
If , are treated as constants, the upstream shear stress phase lead promotes growth, while the inclined-bed sediment threshold reduces it and the finite saturation length delays sediment transport. There is an unstable band precisely when : . Within this band , so the growing bedforms migrate downstream. The fastest normal mode satisfies
This last maximization assumes constant ; if the hydrodynamic coefficients vary with wavenumber, their derivatives also enter the selection condition. When and , all nonzero normal modes decay.
Just above the sediment entrainment threshold,
Thus the common regime is stable near onset: the slope penalty overwhelms the hydrodynamic phase lead. This conclusion is conditional on that inequality, not universal. For constant , instability begins only when as well as . The transport sensitivity vanishes at onset for , is finite for , and is singular for . Exactly at threshold, the positive-part transport law needs separate treatment; the above linearization with perturbations small compared with is unavailable.
Far above the sediment entrainment threshold, . If , the unstable cutoff tends to , and the dominant wavelength is set by the saturation length. Both growth rate and migration velocity scale with , apart from their length factors. Their numerical values and any detailed dependence on wavenumber still require a flow closure.
For example, prescribing uniform shear stress independently of the bed gives and
This equally admissible closure illustrates why instability cannot be asserted from the printed sediment equations alone.
Figure 1.
Conditional bedform growth and migration
.
The plots use constant and three illustrative ratios . They show how the sign of the shear phase lead minus the slope correction determines stability; they are not numerical predictions for unspecified flow conditions.
Let a slowly varying wave have phase , wavevector , and angular frequency . The local dispersion relation is the Hamilton-Jacobi equation . Equality of mixed derivatives, followed along a curve with velocity , gives the Hamiltonian ray-tracing equations
Here is the total derivative evaluated along a ray, and is the group velocity.
For , , , and are conserved. If is the angle between the ray and the -axis, then and . Hence Snell's law is
For the ray launched with at , this constant is . Therefore
which proves
For , write . Since the ray and wavevector are parallel,
Near the upper turning point, put . Expansion gives
If at the turn, integration yields the local ray path
The ray is tangent to the line , turns smoothly, crosses , and repeats symmetrically between and . Increasing decreases , while sends the turning level outward.
Melting raises permeability of a porous medium. An advancing protrusion therefore offers a less resistive path to hot liquid, attracting larger Darcy flux and receiving more heat. The resulting faster melting reinforces the protrusion: this is a reactive infiltration instability. A permeability decrease would reverse this feedback, while zero contrast gives no growth in this ideal model.
For positive contrast, the growth rate is proportional to transverse wavenumber, so the model has no finite fastest-growing wavelength. The latent-to-sensible heat ratio slows the front but supplies no short-wave cutoff. Finite thermal transport and a resolved melting zone can introduce a length scale; pore geometry eventually limits the continuum description. If interface curvature changes the equilibrium melting temperature through the Gibbs--Thomson relation, that can also oppose short-wave corrugations. The modified dispersion relation must include such effects before a preferred wavelength can be calculated; a length scale alone does not guarantee that every added mechanism selects one.
The linear dispersion relation for a mode is . The proposed modes share phase velocity , so . A quadratic wave interaction generates the second harmonic and the difference harmonic. With only two positive wavenumbers, phase matching for a quadratic wave interaction requires . Equating their phase velocities gives
and therefore
This is a two-to-one resonance of dispersive waves. Its amplitude changes accumulate on . Choose the slow time ; this harmless constant rescaling makes the later amplitude formulas simple. With , the leading real field is .
For the fundamental, the order- cross derivative in is , while the fundamental coefficient in is . For the second harmonic the corresponding terms are and . The solvability condition in the method of multiple scales removes the resonant forcing and gives
The nonresonant third and fourth harmonics enter the correction. They do not change these leading amplitude equations.
Write , and . Taking real and imaginary parts gives the explosive two-to-one amplitude system in polar form:
The polar phases are used where their corresponding amplitudes are nonzero. These equations imply
For the second identity, differentiate using : the terms proportional to cancel. Therefore
are first integrals, and in particular
For constant phases with , these real equations reduce to and . The initial data give , so the Riccati equation for is . Integrating and using gives
The tangent and secant function have a pole at , corresponding to . Both modes grow through their locked resonant interaction. This is formal finite-time blowup of the reduced amplitude equations; the weakly nonlinear expansion loses validity as the amplitudes become large, so it cannot establish a singularity of the full partial differential equation.
Take and assume an initially propagating mode, . Put and . Neglecting as stipulated, the Scorer parameter and stationary internal-wave WKB solution are
The positive root selects upward group velocity for the negative intrinsic frequency branch . The WKB approximation needs a slowly varying background relative to the local vertical wavelength, in particular and , away from a turning level or singular mean profile.
The local dispersion relation is . Its intrinsic and laboratory group velocities are, with ,
Thus intrinsic energy propagation is upstream and upward, while laboratory energy propagation is downstream and upward, parallel to . Constant-phase lines of an internal gravity wave have slope and normal spacing ; the horizontal spacing remains .
If , grows with height. The wavevector and laboratory energy ray become more vertical; phase lines become flatter and closer together. For finite nonzero , the height
is a critical level of an internal gravity wave: and the vertical wavenumber diverges. The laboratory group velocity tends to zero. Importantly, , so the formal WKB condition need not deteriorate before this level if that ratio is small. Nevertheless the stationary equation is singular at the level, the phase has no finite limit, and the horizontal perturbation velocity grows as ; the inviscid linear wave cannot be continued uniformly through it without additional physics.
If , decreases to zero at
The wavevector and laboratory ray become horizontal, the phase lines become vertical, and the normal spacing increases. Above , and the disturbance is an evanescent wave. Here diverges, so the WKB approximation fails in a turning region and must be replaced by a local connection solution.
Figure 1.
Rays of a stationary wave pattern
. Original WKB phase contours for decreasing and increasing . Red curves and arrows show laboratory energy rays; blue arrows show the local wavevector. The dashed levels mark the critical level and turning level, where a propagating WKB description cannot be continued unchanged.
For a progressive plane wave, write
The momentum equation gives , while the dispersion relation is . Therefore the pressure and longitudinal velocity amplitudes obey
The constant is the acoustic impedance.
The physical rapid phase is
Define the local wavevector, angular frequency, and group velocity by
The equality of mixed partial derivatives gives the phase-compatibility equations
A ray is defined to move with the local group velocity:
Differentiate the local dispersion relation
with respect to . Along a ray,
The last two terms cancel because is a gradient. Similarly,
Finally,
Thus the Hamiltonian ray-tracing equations are
At , the two free-surface conditions for a normal mode give
Eliminating yields
For the vertical factor found in part (b),
Thus the gravity-wave dispersion relation is
where
Take a linear combination of the P- and SV-fields from part (b). The rigid boundary condition at gives
The conditions at are the same because the horizontal displacement is even and the vertical displacement is odd. A nonzero pair exists exactly when the determinant vanishes:
Therefore the rigid elastic waveguide mode dispersion relation is
Figure 1.
Dispersion relation branches in an elastic waveguide
.
As increases, both and increase without bound. The two sides consequently have infinitely many alternating tangent branches and poles. On successive continuity intervals their relative ordering reverses, so the intermediate value theorem gives infinitely many intersections, corresponding to infinitely many propagating waveguide modes.
The condition , together with transversality , selects polarization along away from the normal-incidence degeneracy. Phase matching at a planar wave interface gives
The two dispersion relations give . Choosing propagation into therefore yields
Equivalently, this is Snell law for electromagnetic waves with refractive index proportional to because the two media have equal magnetic permeability.
In a vacuum with no charge or current, the Maxwell equations are
For the proposed plane electromagnetic wave, gives
The Ampère-Maxwell equation gives
and substituting this into Faraday's law gives the dispersion relation
Thus both fields have transverse polarization relative to , and the corresponding real electric field is
For incidence in the positive -direction, choose the incident fields
The perfect conductor requires the tangential electric field to vanish at . The reflected wave therefore has
This is normal reflection of an electromagnetic wave from a perfect conductor. The magnetic field in is
so its tangential value at the surface is