This cannot be the sole symmetry-breaking sector of the Standard Model. Its gauge-boson mass matrix has two zero eigenvalues, so besides the electromagnetic photon it predicts an extra massless neutral gauge boson. Every linear combination of and , including the combination normally called , is massless. The observed massive Z boson is a concrete contradiction. Choosing differently cannot change these two zero eigenvalues.
A real scalar triplet can occur as an additional sector, but a further vacuum expectation value, for example that of a Higgs doublet, is then necessary to obtain the observed neutral gauge boson mass pattern. This does not rescue the triplet-only model posed here.
The two one-loop Feynman diagrams are fermion loops with three photon interaction vertices. Fix vertex 1; the two cyclic orders are and . A cyclic rotation does not produce another Feynman diagram. Keeping all three external labels in the same positions, these two orders can be represented by the same triangle with opposite fermion flow, as in the first two panels.
Original Feynman diagrams for the two orientations of the three-photon fermion loop and a representative four-photon box diagram
. Details. The photons are labelled , , , with all four-momenta incoming and . The amputation of external propagators removes the three external photon propagators, leaving their Lorentz indices open. There are no other connected one-loop Feynman diagrams with only three external photons in QED.
The first panel is the one-particle-irreducible Feynman diagram for photon vacuum polarization. The two internal Dirac propagators carry and , and the external photons carry . The other panels fix the routings used in parts c and d.
Original labelled one-loop QED Feynman diagrams: photon vacuum polarization, fermion self-energy, and the electromagnetic interaction vertex
. Details. The closed fermion loop sign contributes a minus sign; there is no extra symmetry factor. Applying the given Feynman rules, with the external propagators amputated,Equivalently, the required amplitude isThe Feynman slash notation is and in the chosen dimensional regularization convention.
The Ward identity implies . Lorentz invariance then gives , so . The gamma matrices satisfy . Odd traces vanish, and thereforeSubstituting gives the requested scalar coefficient:To extract the ultraviolet divergence without introducing a Feynman parameter, set , and useTranslation invariance of dimensional regularization gives . ConsequentlyIn the pole coefficient one may set : the bracket becomesThus the ultraviolet pole of QED vacuum polarization isThe cancellation of the apparent divergence is essential: gauge invariance forbids a photon mass counterterm. The scalar result at is understood by continuation after this cancellation.
The middle panel in part a has an internal photon of momentum joining two points on a fermion line; the internal fermion has momentum . It is a one-particle-irreducible Feynman diagram with no closed fermion loop sign. In Feynman gauge,orThe decomposition in the source gives . In particular,For a direct ultraviolet divergence extraction, use a Feynman parameter multiplying the massive denominator, shift , and define . Then andOdd terms integrate to zero. Taking the trace explicitly supplies the weight , whose integral tends to . HenceAs a check on the same fermion self-energy calculation,This is the ultraviolet pole of QED fermion self-energy. It is safe to extract it at generic external momentum; an on shell or massless limit must distinguish any infrared divergence from this ultraviolet divergence.
In the right panel of part a, enters the fermion line, leaves it, and a virtual photon of momentum bridges the external photon vertex. Write and . The one-loop amplitude isThis Feynman integral has a logarithmic superficial degree of divergence. Its ultraviolet pole is independent of the external momenta and , because every such numerator insertion or denominator correction lowers the large- degree. Preserve an auxiliary positive mass while extracting the ultraviolet pole; setting everything to zero would create a scaleless integral and conceal the cancellation of ultraviolet and infrared divergences.
The leading numerator is . Symmetric integration replaces by . Two contractions of gamma matrices then giveFor the auxiliary-mass extraction of ultraviolet poles,The second term is ultraviolet convergent. ThusThe ultraviolet pole of the QED vertex is therefore . The Pauli structure has zero trace against and no ultraviolet pole at this order.
Form-factor qualification. The two electron electromagnetic vertex form factors in the source describe matrix elements between external on shell Dirac spinors. A general off shell vertex has more structures, so the unprojected trace is not a projector for the complete finite on-shell . It does correctly isolate the divergent local coefficient, which is all that is required here.
Stimulated emission adds a photon to an already occupied radiation mode; spontaneous emission can occur when that mode initially contains no photons. In the electric-dipole approximation the atom-field interaction is . Quantizing the radiation field makes the emission matrix element into a mode with occupation proportional toThis photon occupation enhancement of emission makes the emission rate into that mode proportional to : the part proportional to is stimulated and the remaining part is spontaneous. Absorption is proportional to . The photon energy is the atomic energy difference, up to any specified recoil or line broadening.
The stimulated contribution preferentially populates the stimulating mode, including its propagation direction and polarization; it provides optical gain. Spontaneous photons populate the available modes according to the transition's dipole matrix elements and radiation environment. They are not universally isotropic. An excited bare atom with the field vacuum is not an eigenstate of the fully coupled Hamiltonian, which resolves the apparent paradox of a nominally stationary excited state radiating.[ref]
Topics in Quantum Mechanics by David Tong. §4.3.2, why the electromagnetic field must be included to describe spontaneous decay
Original two-level transition diagrams and the versus occupation factors for photon absorption and emission
. Details. For lower and upper levels 1 and 2, with radiation spectral energy density per unit ordinary frequency, the rates areThermal detailed balance with the Planck spectrum givesThe statistical weights here are level degeneracies, not Landé g-factors. A definition of multiplying intensity or angular-frequency density would change the normalization factors.
For a specified free-space electric-dipole transition, summing radiation modes givesAppropriate sums over final magnetic substates and averages over initial substates are needed for an unresolved degenerate level. The radiative lifetime is only when this is the sole decay channel. In a laser, net stimulated gain requires , as well as sufficient gain to overcome cavity loss; population inversion alone does not specify the lasing threshold.
Neglect hyperfine structure and use the electronic weak-field Zeeman splitting regime, where is small compared with the spin-orbit interaction splitting. The sodium levels are , and . The Landé g-factor formula givesFor example, inserting gives . Each sublevel with magnetic quantum number shifts by . Thus the lower level has shifts , the upper level has shifts , and the upper level has shifts and .
The electric-dipole selection rule allows except , and . Both fine structure branches are allowed. The emitted photon energy isAll the allowed components of the sodium D-line Zeeman pattern are listed below; the last column is the photon shift in units of :These are four components of D1 and six of D2. Their strengths need not be equal; the table and arrows specify allowed transitions, not intensities.
The level lies above , so D2 has the larger zero-field photon energy. [ref]
https://physics.nist.gov/PhysRefData/Handbook/Tables/sodiumtable5.htm. NIST, Energy levels of Neutral Sodium, 3p fine-structure ordering
In the stated weak-field regime its most positive shift is . Since , the shortest wavelength is therefore produced byThe tempting pair has a larger difference of level shifts but is forbidden because .Stellar radiation and nebular ionization. The planetary-nebula spectral energy distribution is constrained by a shared radiation and thermal balance. The central star's effective temperature, luminosity and evolutionary state set its continuum and ionizing-photon supply. A hotter star shifts the ionizing spectrum and allows higher ionization stages; the total recombination output also depends on how many ionizing photons the gas actually absorbs. In an ionization-bounded nebula, approximate photoionization balance iswhereas a density-bounded nebula can leak photons. Dust absorption of ionizing photons changes this relation further. Stellar-atmosphere and wind effects make a blackbody an approximation, especially in the extreme ultraviolet. A changing core temperature and expanding envelope explain why nebular spectra evolve.
Nebular continua and recombination lines. Their strength depends on the emission measure, roughly , electron temperature, ionic abundances and radiative branching probabilities. For a recombination line,Case-B line ratios assume appropriate trapping of Lyman-series photons and escape of the lower-series radiation. Density, optical-depth effects and extinction can alter observed ratios. The free-free emissivity has the schematic dependence ; the nebular free-bound continuum also carries ionization thresholds and recombination cross-sections. Two-photon emission depends on the population of the hydrogen state and can be reduced by collisional mixing into . Density clumping matters because these rates are weighted approximately by density squared, not simply by total gas mass.
Collisionally excited lines. Below a line's critical density of an atomic transition,Elemental abundance, ionic fraction and electron temperature therefore all enter. The ionizing spectrum and local ionization parameter help determine which ion is present. Above the critical density of an atomic transition, collisional de-excitation competes with radiative decay and can suppress a forbidden line. Low-energy infrared fine-structure lines are generally less exponentially temperature sensitive than high-excitation optical/ultraviolet lines. Metal-line cooling also helps set the temperature, so changing an abundance changes both the number of emitters and the thermal balance; line luminosity need not be proportional to abundance at fixed everything else.
Dust and molecules. Nebular dust spectral features identify the carriers as well as contributing to the integrated luminosity. In an optically thin dust component,The grain mass sets its normalization, while the radiation field, stellar distance, grain size and absorption efficiency determine its temperature distribution. For approximately grey heating, radiative equilibrium suggests ; non-grey grains change this scaling. Long-wavelength opacity is often approximated as . Small aromatic grains undergo transient heating, so one equilibrium temperature is not adequate for every infrared feature. Carbon-to-oxygen chemistry, grain processing and shielding affect aromatic versus silicate bands. Molecular line emission further depends on molecule abundance, collisional density, kinetic temperature, ultraviolet pumping and shocks, while shielding and dissociation set whether molecules survive at all.
Finally, interstellar extinction preferentially suppresses ultraviolet and optical light, and dust reradiates some absorbed energy in the infrared. Aperture, angular resolution and distance must be treated consistently before comparing stellar, nebular and dust components. These dependencies make the combined spectrum an energy and abundance diagnostic, but also prevent a unique reconstruction from a single broad-band colour.
A planetary nebula combines a hot post-asymptotic-giant-branch stellar core, its ionized expelled envelope, neutral/molecular material and interstellar dust. Its ultraviolet-to-infrared spectral energy distribution is therefore not a single-temperature blackbody. The principal components are:
- Central-star continuum. A hot stellar photosphere emits strongly in the ultraviolet, especially the ionizing extreme ultraviolet, with its longer-wavelength tail extending through the optical and near infrared. Stellar-atmosphere absorption features and wind lines can be superposed. A companion can add a distinct cool stellar continuum.
- Nebular continuum. Thermal bremsstrahlung, nebular free-bound continuum emission and hydrogen two-photon emission produce a broad continuum. Free-bound edges, especially the Balmer discontinuity at 364.6 nm and the Paschen discontinuity near 820 nm, can be apparent. Hydrogen two-photon decay redistributes the Ly-alpha transition energy into a continuum of pairs rather than one 121.6-nm photon.
- Gas emission lines. Hydrogen and helium recombination lines include H-alpha, H-beta and He II 468.6 nm. Collisionally excited lines of metal ions can dominate individual bands: examples include optical [O III] 495.9/500.7 nm and [N II] 654.8/658.3 nm, ultraviolet C III] near 190.9 nm, and infrared fine-structure transitions such as [Ne II] 12.8 micrometres. A broad-band photometric peak may therefore be a line rather than continuum.
- Dust emission and solid-state structure. Grains absorb stellar/nebular radiation and reradiate it as a broad infrared continuum, often from a distribution of temperatures of order tens to hundreds of kelvin; compact hot dust can add near-infrared emission. Carbon-rich material may show aromatic bands around 3.3, 6.2, 7.7, 8.6 and 11.3 micrometres, while oxygen-rich material may show silicate features near 9.7 and 18 micrometres. These are compositional alternatives, not mandatory features of every nebula.
- Neutral and molecular emission. Surviving molecular material in dense clumps or a photodissociation region can contribute infrared rotational/rovibrational lines, notably molecular-hydrogen emission such as the 2.12-micrometre line. Shocks as well as ultraviolet pumping can excite it. Colder dust continues into the far infrared, and low-lying CO rotational lines extend the overall spectrum into the submillimetre/millimetre range.
Schematic stellar, nebular and dust components of a planetary-nebula spectrum; arbitrary relative normalizations
. Details. The observed mixture also contains attenuation by internal and foreground interstellar extinction. A spectrum containing all these components need not spatially coincide: stellar light, ionized gas, dusty clumps and the molecular envelope sample different regions.
Inverse Compton scattering transfers energy from fast electrons to lower-energy photons. In the Thomson scattering limit the scattering is approximately elastic in the electron's instantaneous rest frame, but the transformations into and out of that frame can greatly increase the photon energy in the original frame.
In a blazar, relativistic jet electrons can scatter their own synchrotron radiation, producing synchrotron self-Compton radiation, or scatter photons from an accretion disk and its surrounding reprocessing material. The two spectral humps constrain electron Lorentz factors, the electron distribution and, with assumptions about geometry and relativistic beaming, the magnetic field. For the same electron population in the Thomson regime, the ratio of inverse-Compton to synchrotron power scales as in the plasma rest frame. It does not determine the field without information about the photon energy density and beaming.
In a galaxy cluster, hot thermal electrons scatter cosmic microwave background photons and slightly raise their mean energy, producing the thermal Sunyaev-Zeldovich effect. The spectral distortion measures the line-of-sight integral of electron pressure, approximately for nonrelativistic thermal electrons. Combined with X-ray emission, which weights density approximately quadratically, it constrains the gas density, temperature and mass distribution. These are distinct source populations and seed photon fields from the blazar example.
For the power derivation, use an isotropic incident radiation field of total photon energy density in the laboratory frame. Its stress-energy tensor has and , with zero mean flux. Boosting to an electron moving at along givesThe radiation energy flux in this rest frame is . Elastic Thomson scattering exerts the drag . The parallel three-force has the same value in the laboratory frame, so the electron's positive energy loss rate isThis isotropic inverse-Compton drag assumes photon energies small compared with in the electron rest frame, negligible recoil and an isotropic seed field in the specified frame. An anisotropic photon field requires its directional moments; the recoil-dependent differential scattering cross-section of Compton scattering becomes necessary at larger rest-frame energies.
There are two conventions to qualify in the printed expression. First, the density multiplying must be , not literally only the magnetic part of a propagating electromagnetic field. That field has equal electric and magnetic energy densities, so and the corresponding formula is . Second, this is net electron energy loss, rather than all incident plus scattered photon energy. At an electron still scatters power , but transfers no kinetic energy to the photons, so the inverse-Compton gain is zero.
For an individual incident photon of energy , the electron-frame energy is . For a head-on photon followed by forward emission in the laboratory,Averaging an isotropic seed field gives for ultrarelativistic electrons. The original plot has an inverse-Compton maximum of order , a synchrotron maximum around and a disk component around . ThusThe head-on maximum gives the same order of magnitude, about to . These are approximate readings of a broad spectrum, not precise fitted parameters. Disk and synchrotron seed photons need not be scattered by the same part of the electron distribution, and bulk jet Doppler factors also enter the observed peak relation. The indicated rest-frame seed energies remain well below the electron rest energy in this estimate.
For an optically thin collisionally excited line, the volume emissivity is approximately below the transition's critical density. The excitation coefficient includes a factor , so temperature is needed to convert luminosity into an ionic abundance. Density is needed both to assess collisional quenching of a metastable line and to convert an emission measure into a gas mass. For a uniform recombining ion, for example, . Temperature structure, density clumping, extinction and unobserved ionization stages introduce further corrections.
A useful density doublet has closely spaced upper energies but different spontaneous decay rates and hence different critical densities. Nearly equal excitation energies reduce temperature dependence of the ratio; similar wavelengths reduce differential extinction and relative calibration errors. Metastable upper levels have sufficiently small Einstein coefficients for collisional de-excitation to compete at nebular densities.
Use statistical weights , . The source's O II ground-state term has a typographical error: it is , not . A term has , so the printed term is internally inconsistent. The tabulated values, wavelengths and rates can still be used.[ref]
Handbook of Basic Atomic Spectroscopic Data by Jean E. Sansonetti and William C. Martin. O II energy-level table: ground state at zero and the two metastable D levels near 26810.55 and 26830.57 inverse centimetres
At high density, collisions establish a Boltzmann distribution between the upper states. Their energy splitting is small compared with , so . If both lines escape without absorption,The exact ratio includes , an approximately correction at .
At low density, assume excitation from the common ground state and radiative decay back to it dominate, with no substantial collisional transfer between upper states. Statistical equilibrium gives . Detailed balance relates excitation to the supplied de-excitation coefficient, yieldingEach excitation then produces one line photon, so the spontaneous rate cancels:At high density the upper populations are collisionally thermalized and the ratio retains the radiative lifetimes; at low density radiative escape is nearly certain and the ratio is set by the excitation probabilities instead.
At , the two de-excitation coefficients are and . ThusThe useful density range lies between and around these scales. In the independent-upper-level approximation,The density sensitivity of a metastable doublet depends on the error measure. The fractional response is maximal atIf absolute ratio errors are constant, maximizing instead gives . An unspecified experimental noise model therefore does not define a unique sharper optimum than this transition-density range.
For Ne IV, the same calculation gives critical densities and , with fractional sensitivity peaking near . This is a useful higher-density diagnostic when O II is saturated. However, Ne and O need not occupy the same ionization zone, so their inferred densities need not describe the same gas. The ultraviolet Ne IV pair also needs suitable observations and extinction correction. The proposal is useful with these qualifications, not a guaranteed replacement for the density of the O II emitting zone.
Metastable doublets probe different density ranges
. Original optically thin independent-upper-level calculation from the supplied rates. Dashed vertical lines mark the density of maximum fractional sensitivity; temperature is fixed at kelvin. Details.The density contrast is , and is one spatial Fourier mode with comoving wavevector . The scale factor is , is the Hubble parameter, is the physical sound speed, the mean matter density, and the gravitational constant. For each fixed the displayed equation is an ordinary differential equation in cosmic time. It compares pressure restoration, self-gravity and expansion-induced damping:The pressure term resists compression; self-gravity enhances an overdensity; the term slows the motion relative to a static background. The Newtonian treatment is appropriate to small perturbations on subhorizon scales within the specified fluid model, rather than an arbitrary gauge-independent treatment of superhorizon perturbations.
The physical Jeans length follows by equating pressure and gravity:The comoving Jeans wavenumber is . Perturbations well below the physical Jeans length are pressure-supported acoustic oscillations whose amplitude is modified by expansion; those above it admit gravitational growth when the background evolution permits. Pressureless matter in a matter-dominated universe is the example below. Merely having a large wavelength is not sufficient to apply this Newtonian equation outside the horizon.
For a gas of particle mass and temperature , write , with for the isothermal sound-speed convention or the appropriate adiabatic heat-capacity ratio otherwise. ThenAt fixed density it is larger for hotter or lighter particles, and it decreases with increasing density. Numerical coefficients differ between sound-crossing and self-gravitating-sphere conventions; the expression here uses the Fourier instability boundary of the stated equation.
In an Einstein-de Sitter universe, the spatially flat Friedmann-Lemaître-Robertson-Walker metric is . Conservation of pressureless matter gives ; the Friedmann equation then gives , and . With ,Trying gives . Hence the Einstein-de Sitter density-growth modes areThe growing mode increases only as a power law because the expansion dilutes and slows the collapsing matter.
Conformal time is defined by , so the metric becomes . Choosing its origin at the big bang gives and . ThereforeEquivalently the equation is , where primes denote conformal-time derivatives.
Before and through cosmological recombination, photons diffuse between hotter and cooler parts of the tightly coupled photon–baryon fluid. Radiative viscosity and heat transport erase short-wavelength acoustic perturbations. As free electrons disappear, the photon mean free path grows, enhancing this diffusion before decoupling. Silk damping can be represented by a factor approximately in the linear acoustic amplitude. The comoving Silk wavelength may be defined as ; the associated diffusion-length convention is .
A random-walk estimate is up to transport and baryon-loading factors, with physical . Scales much shorter than the damping wavelength are strongly suppressed. This is photon diffusion, not the Jeans boundary and not erasure of every cold-dark-matter perturbation. After decoupling, photon free streaming is a distinct part of the evolution.
An H II region is photoionized interstellar gas around young massive stars. Its optical spectrum contains hydrogen and helium recombination lines, collisionally excited forbidden metal lines, and weaker free-free, free-bound and two-photon continua. Typical hot main-sequence ionizing stars have effective temperatures of a few ; their ultraviolet output, age and metallicity determine the ionization balance. Gas and dust can also emit strongly outside the visible band.
A planetary nebula is expelled evolved-star material illuminated by a much hotter exposed stellar core. Its central star can reach temperatures of order , allowing higher ionization stages and prominent He II emission. The gas may carry nucleosynthetic enrichment from its progenitor, while expansion lowers density and changes line strengths with age. Both object classes produce nebular spectra, but their ionizing sources and evolutionary contexts differ; neither spectrum is simply the blackbody spectrum of the exciting star.
For an optically thin recombination line under Case B recombination, the line emissivity isThe effective coefficient includes recombination cascades feeding the line. For approximately common conditions and matching sampled volumes,The wavelength factor is essential because the tabulated energy flux counts photons weighted by their energies. More generally the result is an emissivity-weighted ionic ratio, not an unweighted pointwise abundance.
Assume corrected extinction and underlying stellar absorption, suitable electron temperature and density, negligible additional collisional or optical-depth effects on the chosen lines, and essentially ionized hydrogen. The total helium abundance is thenprovided neutral helium is negligible or an ionization correction is applied. A line emitted by neutral He after recombination measures the recombining He population; He II measures recombining He.
Using the supplied line coefficients and fluxes givesThereforeIf hydrogen and helium dominate the mass, this corresponds to helium mass fraction , with . It is an approximate elemental estimate under the ionization assumptions, not merely a ratio of two observed line fluxes.
An ordinary H II region would typically have – by number, with metallicity-dependent enrichment, rather than necessarily the larger value inferred here for an evolved-star nebula. Hydrogen ionization requires , neutral helium and He . Typical H II region stars often produce little He, so He II can be extremely weak or absent despite substantial helium. He I relative to H can still be useful, but neutral helium inside the H zone may require an ionization correction. A very hot planetary-nebula core is more favorable for observing both ionic stages, although ionization structure must still be checked.
The main evidence combines a large luminosity with a compact source and a massive central gravitating object. Rapid continuum variability bounds the emitting size by a light-crossing scale, while broad emission lines and reverberation delays constrain the gas orbital speeds and characteristic radii. Their virial masses, together with stellar and gas dynamics in galactic nuclei, imply compact central masses far larger than ordinary stars. Thermal optical/ultraviolet disk emission, a high-energy coronal component, jets and relativistically broadened inner-disk features are naturally associated with an accretion flow. No one signature alone is a unique proof, but the combined compactness, mass and energy requirements strongly favor accretion onto supermassive black holes. Gravitational accretion releases a much larger fraction of rest energy than ordinary stellar burning, without requiring the luminosity to come from the black-hole interior.
For a fully ionized pure-hydrogen plasma, each electron receiving Thomson radiation force is coupled electrostatically to a proton carrying almost all the mass. With spherical isotropic luminosity , the outward force per electron is , while gravity per electron–proton pair is approximately . Equality defines the Eddington luminosity:Here is the gravitational constant, the proton mass, the speed of light, the central mass and the Thomson cross-section. The estimate assumes electron-scattering opacity, tight electron–ion coupling and no other dominant force. Geometry, beaming, other opacities and photon trapping can change the relevant luminosity limit.
If is the supplied rest-mass rate and a fraction of its rest energy is radiated, . The associated Eddington accretion rate is consequentlyThis is a supply rate. The black-hole growth rate is if the remaining supplied energy increases the hole's mass. Confusing these rates loses a factor relevant to the growth-time calculation.
The order-of-magnitude efficiency is motivated by orbital binding energy released near the innermost stable orbit. A Newtonian orbit at has binding energy per unit mass ; the exact nonspinning thin-disk value is . Black-hole spin changes the innermost stable orbit and can raise or lower the efficiency. Thus is a useful radiatively efficient accretion estimate, not a universal constant; an advective or jet-dominated flow can have a different radiative efficiency.
Using the stipulated luminosity and ,The source's redshift and age are treated as its supplied data; its record wording is historical, not a present-day claim about the most distant known quasar.
At continuous Eddington luminosity and fixed efficiency, growth is exponential:This is the Salpeter time, including retained-mass efficiency. Even granting all since the big bang permits only about 15.4 e-folds, requiring a seed of at least roughly . A seed would take about under these assumptions, before allowing any formation delay; a seed takes about . These numbers motivate early massive seeds, sustained high duty-cycle accretion, lower radiative efficiencies, super-Eddington phases or contributions from mergers. They do not prove a unique seed channel, since the luminosity-to-mass conversion and accretion history are model-dependent.
A hydrogen recombination line is a discrete spectral line produced when radiative recombination captures an electron into an excited bound level and a subsequent radiative cascade emits photons. The free-to-bound capture itself produces a continuum; the later bound-to-bound transitions produce the recombination lines. For example, H-alpha is the transition in the Balmer series.
For the neutral hydrogen absorbing an ionizing stellar continuum, the principal bound-free transition is photoionization from the ground state into the continuum. Most neutral hydrogen is in its ground state, and the photoionization cross section is largest near its threshold, falling approximately as above it. Dominance of the population-weighted opacity is intended here; this does not mean that every excited-state microscopic cross section is smaller at every frequency.
In an ionization-bounded, optically thick nebula, direct radiative recombination into emits an ionizing photon that promptly photoionizes another hydrogen atom. One ion disappears and another is created: there is no net removal of an ion from the global budget. Case B recombination therefore uses , with local recycling of ground-state recombination photons. This is the on-the-spot approximation, rather than an unconditional property of radiative recombination: if those photons escape, direct capture does produce net neutralization and a Case A treatment is appropriate.
Write for the hydrogen-ionizing photon production rate, counting only photons above the hydrogen ionization energy, not all stellar photons. In steady photoionization equilibrium, the external supply balances the volume integral of net Case B recombination:For uniform, almost completely ionized pure hydrogen, . HenceThe final approximation requires . The Strömgren sphere also assumes spherical symmetry, a sharp ionization front, a steady source older than the recombination time, uniform number density and temperature so that is constant, negligible dust absorption of ionizing photons, negligible leakage, and no important helium correction or collisional ionization. Clumping would replace by a volume average of .
An additional atomic input is needed: the total Case B recombination coefficient does not specify the number of H-alpha photons per net radiative recombination. Let , where is the effective recombination coefficient. At the approximately temperature implicit in the supplied , take . The coefficient 2.2 used later in the paper corresponds to , which we use consistently here.
For an unextinguished, fully filled Strömgren sphere with negligible central cavity, the H-alpha luminosity and observed radiative flux satisfySubstitution eliminates and givesConvert the angular diameter to radians: . Also . ThusThe implied hydrogen-ionizing photon production rate is . Using instead gives . These values use the printed milliarcseconds and integrated line observed radiative flux. Assuming one H-alpha photon per recombination would give a different, unjustified distance. An appreciable cavity or a nonunit filling factor must also enter the emitting volume.
The Brackett series consists of transitions ending at , at infrared wavelengths. They suffer much less interstellar extinction than H-alpha, so their corrected observed radiative fluxes can give a more reliable version of the same inference. At fixed measured angular size and number density, the formula has : uncorrected interstellar extinction therefore makes this particular distance estimate too small. Infrared lines are weaker and need their own effective recombination coefficients; their advantage is reduced sensitivity to dust.
Work in the source rest frame and neglect the source's small cosmological redshift. Over an emission interval , a ballistic relativistic jet feature travels , advancing toward the observer and across the sky. The second photon has a shorter journey, so its arrival is delayed by onlyDividing the projected displacement by this arrival interval givesApparent superluminal motion is a combination of projection and light-travel delay. The feature's local speed remains ; its inferred transverse displacement divided by the observer's arrival interval is not a local signal velocity.
The Einstein-de Sitter universe has and . Normalizing therefore gives . Differentiating givesIn the local comoving rest frame, a photon crosses proper path length . Galaxies with proper number density and geometric cross section contribute the mean number of intersections . The infinitesimal probability of an intersection is the same to first order, givingThe radius is a physical radius, and is a proper number density evaluated at epoch , rather than a density already multiplied by . For a finite path with overlaps, the integrated mean count need not itself be the probability of at least one intersection.






