The supplied matter-era solution has , so the source reduces to . Put and . The integrating factor for the streaming equation gives the exact matter-era photon endpoint solution
For , the integral is . Substitution and collection of endpoint terms gives
At the original source is zero and the expression has the continuous limit . The integral form is numerically preferable near that limit, where the separated endpoint terms cancel.
The last two terms are respectively a local observer monopole and dipole. For measured higher angular multipoles, remove them. The remaining emission bracket contains initial brightness, an emission velocity-type term, and a gravitational Sachs-Wolfe effect term. Under ordinary adiabatic initial conditions for the growing synchronous matter mode, , while the velocity endpoint scales as . Relative to these are suppressed by and respectively. Thus for modes outside the horizon at last scattering,
Its amplitude is the scale-invariant large-angle contribution. In Newtonian language it is the ordinary endpoint Sachs-Wolfe effect, not a late integrated effect in a constant-potential matter universe. With completely arbitrary prescribed , no unconditional dominance theorem is possible: an independently large initial anisotropy could dominate. The exact solution above remains valid without that adiabatic assumption.
To match the positive source printed in the question, choose synchronous gauge metric
The commonly used convention with gives the opposite source sign; switching conventions means replacing and by their negatives together. This distinction is necessary when comparing with the usual synchronous photon brightness equation.
Let be the photon tangent for an affine parameter. The covariant geodesic equation is
For , the homogeneous scale-factor contributions cancel by the null geodesic condition, leaving . Since and , use the background in this first-order term to obtain
Using the affine form also avoids confusing a covariant with the contravariant factor required when changing the geodesic parameter to coordinate time.
In conformal time, the equation from part(a) becomes . A Fourier mode proportional to has streaming term . Multiply by ; its prefactor is background-time independent. With ,
Contracting the scalar decomposition explicitly gives
so
This is the photon brightness equation for a negative spatial perturbation. For a perturbation of blackbody-temperature form, , so is the photon brightness perturbation. A more general initial spectral distortion can retain dependence; the gravitational forcing is still independent of in this linear massless equation.
Use physical momentum and conserved-background comoving momentum . At fixed , the homogeneous collisionless phase-space distribution function is , with no spatial or angular dependence and no explicit background time derivative. The printed relation cannot have this meaning: freely propagating physical momentum redshifts as , so it should read . Keeping the printed relation literally would give and a nonzero zeroth-order redshift, inconsistent with the target equation. The standard definition is positively confirmed by the phase-space convention in Ma and Bertschinger's perturbation treatment.
With this conserved , the orders of the factors are:
  • is first order; the zeroth-order collisionless equation has already made .
  • is first order, while has a zeroth-order free-streaming velocity and first-order corrections. Their product contributes at first order only through that background velocity.
  • begins at zeroth order; begins at first order. Its leading product is .
  • begins at first order, and begins at first order because background trajectories keep their direction. Their product is second order and drops out.
Thus the linear Collisionless Boltzmann equation is
For photons . For a particle of mass , . The order counting does not assume that the first-order angular deflection itself vanishes; only its multiplication by an already perturbed angular distribution makes it higher order.
Three distinct low-redshift nonlinear contributions are:
Gravitational lensing supplies another nonlinear modification by remapping pre-existing temperature and polarization patterns. It preserves the local blackbody spectrum; it does not generate temperature differences by lensing a perfectly isotropic background.
Thomson scattering generates linear Cosmic microwave background polarization when the incident radiation has a photon quadrupole. The cross-section prefers electric fields perpendicular to the scattering direction. Contributions from an isotropic field cancel, and a dipole alone does not supply the required spin-two angular pattern. Schematically the outgoing Stokes combination is proportional to
which selects the incident quadrupolar angular dependence. Tight coupling nearly isotropizes the radiation, making the quadrupole small; it develops when the photon mean free path becomes finite near decoupling. At leading tight-coupling order its size scales as .
The polarization is therefore weaker than the temperature anisotropy: a characteristic amplitude is of order a few percent to roughly ten percent of the temperature signal, or several microkelvin compared with temperature fluctuations of several tens of microkelvin on acoustic scales. This is an order-of-magnitude comparison, not a scale-independent ratio of every power-spectrum multipole.
The photon monopole follows the acoustic displacement, approximately ; the velocity sourcing the quadrupole follows . Hence polarization maxima occur near displacement zeros, between the main temperature peaks. In the leading coherent-oscillator approximation the shift is half the peak spacing, , although projection and gravitational driving modify exact locations. Scalar perturbations generate E-mode polarization at linear order, not B-mode polarization. Tensor perturbations and lensing can give B modes, and reionization generates an additional large-angle polarization feature.
The first mechanism is Silk damping: finite photon mean free paths allow radiation to diffuse out of compressions, while velocity slip and radiation shear dissipate acoustic motion. A Fourier diffusion equation has , hence . For the polarization-inclusive tightly coupled plasma, a useful expression is
The positive scattering rate is , and is the baryon loading parameter. The two terms represent heat conduction from velocity slip and photon shear viscosity. The mode amplitude has an approximately Gaussian cutoff in ; power is suppressed by . The formula assumes tight coupling and slowly varying coefficients before decoupling.
The second mechanism is finite-width last-scattering damping. Photons emerge from a range of times and depths, so rapidly varying sources are averaged rather than observed at one sharply defined phase. Approximate the normalized cosmological visibility function by a Gaussian of width . For a radial plane-wave phase,
The associated power factor is . An acoustic factor is likewise averaged, replacing by in the constant-sound-speed approximation. Thus fine radial structure and rapid acoustic time oscillations are suppressed once their phase changes substantially across the visibility width. This is an averaging effect after the perturbations exist; Silk damping physically erases them by diffusion. Angular projection and the evolving source determine the final isotropic damping envelope, so the radial dependence must not be silently discarded.
For adiabatic initial conditions, the coupled photon-baryon fluid begins with a coherent displacement and approximately zero initial acoustic velocity. Neglecting slowly varying gravitational driving, its effective temperature satisfies an oscillator equation with phase , where
Thus the Sachs-Wolfe combination has a dominant cosine phase, while the velocity has a sine phase. At last scattering, the first three temperature Cosmic microwave background acoustic peaks correspond approximately to : first compression, first rarefaction, and second compression of the initially displaced plasma in a potential well. Baryon inertia shifts the oscillator's equilibrium and enhances compressions relative to rarefactions, producing the familiar odd/even peak contrast. Potential decay and radiation driving alter the amplitudes, especially of the earliest peaks.
Adjacent displacement extrema differ by , so
Here is the transverse comoving distance to last scattering; in a flat model it is . If is treated as constant, this reduces to . No numerical spacing is determined without a cosmological distance and sound horizon. Gravitational phase shifts, baryon loading and projection displace the exact peak locations from integer multiples of this spacing. These are primarily coherent density-plus-potential acoustic peaks; the label “Doppler peaks” does not mean the velocity term alone creates their sequence.
Use Newtonian gauge with scalar metric perturbations
Let point from the observer toward the emitter, , and evaluate the unperturbed ray at . In the sudden-decoupling approximation the Sachs-Wolfe effect and its linear companions give
Here is the intrinsic photon monopole; is the emission gravitational redshift; the velocity term is the Doppler CMB anisotropy of the baryon-photon plasma; and the integral is the Integrated Sachs-Wolfe effect from evolving potentials during travel. The last two local terms are an observer monopole and dipole, removed when discussing the higher measured multipoles. Changing the direction convention reverses both velocity signs. A finite cosmological visibility function replaces the sharp emission surface by a weighted source integral.
For scale-invariant primordial potentials, is constant before transfer effects. In matter domination, the adiabatic superhorizon relation is , so the observable Sachs-Wolfe combination is . Its amplitude per logarithmic scale is therefore approximately independent of angle. In a flat geometry and , and projection gives the Sachs-Wolfe plateau
Both the intrinsic and gravitational emission terms have this leading large-angle scaling; they must be combined, not treated as unrelated random sources.
The Euler equation gives for the growing large-scale matter mode. Thus the Doppler amplitude grows roughly as relative to the large-scale potential amplitude, while its logarithmic power grows as , until acoustic dynamics and damping invalidate that simple estimate. On subhorizon pressureless scales the Poisson equation gives : the corresponding density amplitude has the often-used scaling. This is a matter-density estimate, not a universal small-angle photon-temperature law; the actual intrinsic photon source undergoes the oscillations in part(b). On superhorizon scales it instead has the constant-potential behavior just described.
The integrated source vanishes for constant linear potentials in pure matter domination. Potential decay during radiation domination or late accelerated expansion makes it nonzero. Its broad, slowly evolving sources favor large angular scales and give a potential-sized contribution there; crossings of many structures cancel progressively on small scales. Scale invariance alone fixes no universal power of angle for the integrated term: its time evolution and transfer functions are also required. Consequently the large-angle plateau, velocity-gradient enhancement and subhorizon density-gradient estimate describe distinct physical regimes, rather than one extrapolated power law across the whole spectrum.
The first derivative of a scalar is a covector, so
Commuting partial derivatives and the torsion-free connection give , the symmetric Hessian of a scalar field. Its next covariant derivative is
In particular, tensor index symmetrization over adds nothing: . This does not make the third index interchangeable with the first two. Applying the lower-index Ricci identity to the covector yields the requested tensor index antisymmetrization:
Parentheses and brackets include the usual averaging factors. To make the remaining symmetry explicit, let . Since the first two derivative indices are already symmetric,
The two commutator identities give and . Thus the third covariant derivatives of a scalar can also be written
The right-hand side displays exactly the obstruction to total symmetry. At a point where the scalar gradient vanishes, or where these curvature contractions vanish, the third derivative is totally symmetric.
For the final contraction use . The arbitrary-valence formula gives
The Ricci tensor of the Levi-Civita connection is symmetric, whereas the last factor is antisymmetric. Their contraction is zero, proving
No symmetry of was assumed. This double divergence of a contravariant tensor identity uses the metric-compatible connection of general relativity: zero torsion alone for an arbitrary affine connection does not guarantee a symmetric Ricci tensor and would not suffice for this final step.
There is a sign error in the printed synchronous line-of-sight integrand. Direct contraction of the stated decomposition gives , with a plus sign in its last term. In the positive spatial-perturbation convention of part a, the redshift term is half this contraction. The printed minus sign cannot yield the requested Newtonian expression with the supplied transformations.
The consistent identity can be derived explicitly. Work mode by mode with , along the unperturbed ray; the shift of the phase origin is immaterial. Put . Part a gives , while . Therefore . The corrected synchronous integral is
since . This is the photon redshift identity with positive spatial perturbations.
The supplied fluid shifts are and . At emission, the synchronous intrinsic and Doppler terms are consequently . Adding the lower integral endpoint cancels the velocity shift and leaves . The upper endpoint is the local observer monopole/dipole , removed by temperature calibration and the observer-rest-frame convention. With zero anisotropic stress, , the observable higher-multipole result is
All fields are evaluated along the ray; the integral contains the time derivative at fixed spatial position. Retaining the printed negative angular term would leave the additional , generally a gauge-dependent, nonzero term. It is therefore not repaired merely by discarding observer monopole and dipole.
The first term is the intrinsic photon temperature perturbation, important in acoustic compressions and rarefactions. The velocity term is the Doppler shift and is prominent near acoustic, roughly degree and subdegree, scales; it is suppressed on very large scales. The potential at emission is the ordinary Sachs-Wolfe effect; combined with the intrinsic term it gives the familiar large-angle adiabatic matter-era result . The final term is the Integrated Sachs-Wolfe effect, caused by changing potentials. It vanishes for constant matter-era potentials, receives an early contribution near radiation-matter transition, and has an important late large-angle contribution when curvature or dark energy causes potentials to evolve. The sign of the Doppler term follows the photon-propagation direction convention used in the ray; reversing that direction reverses it consistently.
Use the convention consistent with the supplied fluid transformations: , so the synchronous spatial metric is . For a passive coordinate displacement , , the metric perturbation changes by . Computing its components gives
The Newtonian gauge has no mixed component and no traceless spatial part. Thus
Matching and gives
This is the synchronous-to-Newtonian transformation with positive spatial perturbations. The original PDF uses in the spatial displacement; the converted TeX loses the hat. Using would require instead. The nonzero modes are understood.
For , the dominant term is
This is the positive-frequency harmonic-oscillator normalization with the physical box volume . Over a period much shorter than , the scale factor and physical frequency are effectively constant. Equivalently, the rescaled field approaches exactly in the short-wavelength limit.
For , and , so the growing field mode freezes. A single Fourier coefficient has variance proportional to , which by itself is not scale-independent. The number of modes in a logarithmic shell is proportional to . Their product gives
Thus equal logarithmic intervals have equal variance in exact de Sitter. Slow evolution of or nonnegligible effective mass produces a tilt. Integrating an exactly flat spectrum over arbitrarily many logarithmic intervals still requires infrared and ultraviolet cutoffs; the statement concerns power per interval, not a finite all-scale total variance.
Take a periodic comoving box of volume , with . A real field has the expansion
where and the other ladder-operator commutators vanish. The coefficient of is therefore . This opposite momentum is required by reality; the single-oscillator shorthand with the same label on both operators must not be read literally as every traveling-wave Fourier coefficient.
The quadratic action has canonical momentum . Its equal-time field commutator requires
Choose the vacuum annihilated by all and the subhorizon positive-frequency condition. For constant and negligible effective mass, put , . The candidate is . Since ,
Direct substitution makes identically zero. Its Wronskian is , which has the required normalization. Thus
This is the existing Bunch-Davies mode normalization in a finite comoving volume. It is exact for a massless minimally coupled test field in de Sitter and the leading approximation for a light slowly evolving field. The homogeneous zero mode needs separate treatment.
Holding the background metric fixed, the linearized homogeneous-field equation is
Consequently each comoving Fourier coefficient obeys
The unscaled Laplacian in the starting equation must be interpreted as the physical spatial Laplacian; for the explicitly comoving wavevector it gives , not . Metric fluctuations have been discarded as permitted. The mode written later is a massless, minimally coupled approximation, requiring ; it is not a solution for an arbitrary potential curvature.
For small baryon fraction the CDM growing mode is , and its gravity forces
For an adiabatic cosmological perturbation to follow the unsuppressed growing mode, pressure must be below the gravitational forcing frequency: . With physical wavelength , this becomes
This is Jeans support versus forced baryon response. The wording “only grow” must refer to unsuppressed gravitational structure growth; it is not a theorem that all shorter-wavelength baryon perturbations are absent or constant. In the pressure-dominated regime a forced response remains. In particular, a falling sound speed can make this small response grow even before it catches up to CDM.
Before photon decoupling, the photon-baryon fluid has sound speed of order . Its Jeans scale is roughly a horizon scale, so smaller perturbations oscillate acoustically instead of freely following the growing CDM structures. After decoupling the baryon sound speed drops sharply. Above the new Jeans scale, pressure is negligible and subtraction of the CDM equation gives . For , the difference is a constant plus a decaying term; its ratio to the growing CDM contrast tends to zero. Baryons therefore catch up. Under the stipulated post-decoupling , the physical Jeans length scales as , the comoving scale as and the corresponding Jeans mass as .
For the requested instantaneous mass estimates, define the baryonic Jeans mass as the baryon content of a sphere of radius :
Using the supplied matter-era age gives s and . Then
The drop is by . A definition using the total gravitating mass instead of baryon content gives values about ten times larger. The pre-decoupling number is an acoustic Jeans order estimate, not an accurate application of the nonrelativistic equations from part a when .
Put and choose the residual synchronous frame comoving with cold dark matter, so . Its Euler equation preserves this choice. The continuity equation then gives . Neglect background baryon pressure and all unenhanced corrections of order , but retain because a short wavelength can make it important. The trace equation becomes
Using proves
For baryons let . The retained continuity and Euler terms are and . Differentiate the first and substitute the second:
Hence
The pressure sign is stabilizing. The drag terms contain first derivatives of the density perturbations, as printed in the PDF; those primes are lost in the converted TeX. The approximation assumes slowly varying nonrelativistic background baryon pressure and the growing physical mode, not a residual synchronous gauge mode.
There is no minimum about which this scalar can undergo the damped oscillations normally used for reheating. Its slow-roll parameters are constant, so an inflating exponential solution has no automatic exit. An independent stopping and energy-transfer mechanism is needed.
At the assumed exit, . Equating this to the thermal radiation density gives
for . Corrections from the small kinetic fraction do not change this rough estimate.
Curvature obeys . For constant and , its suppression during cosmic inflation is . Starting from order-one curvature and requiring present curvature no larger than order one gives
After instantaneous reheating, entropy conservation implies , with . Present scales make the numerator roughly ; using the literal approximate units from question2 gives about . A tighter present curvature tolerance adds its corresponding half-logarithm. In slow-roll approximation this is the conventional requirement of roughly sixty e-folds.
Because the field increases toward , enough expansion requires
This is the flatness bound on the initial field in exponential inflation. It is an upper bound on the initial field, not a nonzero minimum: starting earlier at a smaller field produces more expansion. If one additionally restricts the initial potential below , then supplies a lower bound, but that is a separate restriction. Without initial-curvature and final-tolerance choices there is no unique numerical initial-field value.
Write , where the stated model has , and take . Slow roll gives
Thus . Absorb the integration constant into to obtain
It follows that , so
The exponential potential has constant and . Inflation requires , whereas reliable slow-roll approximation requires . This is the slow-roll normalization for exponential inflation.
The stated field normalization is a slow-roll result, not an exact solution of the original full equations. Keeping the acceleration and kinetic terms yields the same but , as follows by substituting into both full equations. It agrees to leading order for small slope and is the exponential-potential power-law inflation solution.
For a homogeneous canonical scalar, and . The acceleration equation requires for cosmic inflation, equivalently in the flat scalar-dominated limit. Inflation need not be exactly de Sitter.
A standard sufficient regime for a long period is positive potential energy dominating the kinetic energy, physical gradient energy and curvature. Homogeneity over an expanding approximately Hubble-sized patch allows the gradient term to redshift away. In comoving coordinates the gradient energy is ; the gradient in the displayed energy formula must be interpreted physically if no is written there. Require
The slow-roll equations are then and . Sufficient potential conditions are
The potential must remain sufficiently flat over a large enough field interval to produce the required expansion. These slow-roll conditions are stronger than the bare necessary condition for acceleration.
Set in the parametric solution. With ,
Consequently
The endpoint values are obtained by limits. A particularly direct proof of the age bound avoids subtracting nearly equal terms: from the Friedmann equation,
For nonnegative component densities, and . The integrand lies between and . Integrating therefore gives
Equality holds for pure matter and pure coasting fluid, respectively. These are the age of a flat matter-coasting-fluid universe and the coasting-fluid age bound; the positivity range is necessary for the stated universal inequality.

Pinned article: Introduction to the OurBigBook Project

Welcome to the OurBigBook Project! Our goal is to create the perfect publishing platform for STEM subjects, and get university-level students to write the best free STEM tutorials ever.
Everyone is welcome to create an account and play with the site: ourbigbook.com/go/register. We belive that students themselves can write amazing tutorials, but teachers are welcome too. You can write about anything you want, it doesn't have to be STEM or even educational. Silly test content is very welcome and you won't be penalized in any way. Just keep it legal!
We have two killer features:
  1. topics: topics group articles by different users with the same title, e.g. here is the topic for the "Fundamental Theorem of Calculus" ourbigbook.com/go/topic/fundamental-theorem-of-calculus
    Articles of different users are sorted by upvote within each article page. This feature is a bit like:
    • a Wikipedia where each user can have their own version of each article
    • a Q&A website like Stack Overflow, where multiple people can give their views on a given topic, and the best ones are sorted by upvote. Except you don't need to wait for someone to ask first, and any topic goes, no matter how narrow or broad
    This feature makes it possible for readers to find better explanations of any topic created by other writers. And it allows writers to create an explanation in a place that readers might actually find it.
    Figure 1.
    Screenshot of the "Derivative" topic page
    . View it live at: ourbigbook.com/go/topic/derivative
  2. local editing: you can store all your personal knowledge base content locally in a plaintext markup format that can be edited locally and published either:
    This way you can be sure that even if OurBigBook.com were to go down one day (which we have no plans to do as it is quite cheap to host!), your content will still be perfectly readable as a static site.
    Figure 5. . You can also edit articles on the Web editor without installing anything locally.
    Video 3.
    Edit locally and publish demo
    . Source. This shows editing OurBigBook Markup and publishing it using the Visual Studio Code extension.
  3. https://raw.githubusercontent.com/ourbigbook/ourbigbook-media/master/feature/x/hilbert-space-arrow.png
  4. Infinitely deep tables of contents:
    Figure 6.
    Dynamic article tree with infinitely deep table of contents
    .
    Descendant pages can also show up as toplevel e.g.: ourbigbook.com/cirosantilli/chordate-subclade
All our software is open source and hosted at: github.com/ourbigbook/ourbigbook
Further documentation can be found at: docs.ourbigbook.com
Feel free to reach our to us for any help or suggestions: docs.ourbigbook.com/#contact