For a bipartite state , let a local operation on A have Kraus operators satisfying . Without selecting its outcome, the state becomes
For every remote observable , cyclicity of the trace gives
Therefore the remote partial trace is unchanged:
This proves quantum no-signalling for local trace-preserving quantum channels, including choices between different such operations. It makes no assumption that is separable.
Conditioning on one outcome instead uses an unnormalized state with only that outcome's Kraus operators and then divides by its probability. Its remote conditional state can change, yielding quantum steering. However, the outcome cannot be selected deterministically by choosing the measurement setting, and the remote observer needs an ordinary message identifying the selected ensemble. Ignoring the outcome restores the unchanged marginal. No-signalling thus concerns operationally accessible unconditional statistics, not equality of every conditional probability.
The proof presupposes that the intervention is genuinely confined to A and is trace-preserving when outcomes are ignored. A nonlocal operation or setting-dependent postselection does not meet those premises. In field theory local algebras need not come with a simple finite-dimensional tensor factorization; the corresponding statement is expressed using commuting local algebras and local operations, as below.
A free nonrelativistic Gaussian wave packet with initial position variance has wave function
The free dispersion relation makes its different momentum components acquire different phases. Fourier evolution gives a position variance
This spreading is ordinary unitary dynamics. A Gaussian already has nonzero tails initially, so its width increase alone is not an example of information suddenly appearing outside an initially compact support.
For genuinely compactly supported nonzero initial data, the nonrelativistic free kernel yields
At , the integral is an entire Fourier transform of a compactly supported function. It cannot vanish on an open exterior interval unless the whole transform, and hence the initial state, vanishes. Thus this theory has no strict finite propagation cone for nonzero compact initial wave functions. It is a nonrelativistic theory, so that result is not a contradiction in a fundamental relativistic field theory.
Positive-energy relativistic particle descriptions raise a subtler issue. The Hegerfeldt theorem concerns a Hamiltonian bounded below and a positive localization effect . The function either vanishes identically or is nonzero for almost every time. Vanishing for an open interval makes the analytic continuation of the vector matrix elements vanish identically. A sharp exterior localization probability which remains zero for a nonzero time interval but becomes positive later is therefore incompatible with those assumptions.
The conclusion restricts simultaneous assumptions about positive energy and sharp particle localization. It does not establish an admissible procedure for controllable superluminal messaging. A particle-position projection need not belong to the algebra of a physically local relativistic measurement, and strictly localized one-particle preparation can fail the required assumptions. In field theory the appropriate locality test concerns local operations and observables, not merely pointwise values of a one-particle wave function. Localization, propagation of field disturbances and transmission of information must be distinguished.
Locality in quantum theory is not one interchangeable condition. Spatial concentration of a wave packet concerns a state description. Quantum no-signalling restricts operational changes of remote statistics. Microcausality concerns commutation of spacelike observable algebras. The spectrum condition constrains energy-momentum and stability, while primitive causality concerns determination of future-domain expectations by initial-region data. The distinctions are clearest when all five are discussed; none should be replaced silently by the Bell factorization examined elsewhere.
Wave-function tails and entangled correlations are not by themselves controllable signals. Conversely, absence of signals does not by itself supply a local initial-value dynamics or positive-energy spectrum. Each claim must specify the observable algebras, allowed operations and relevant causal regions.
Primitive causality is an initial-region completeness requirement. A state's full restriction to a suitable region determines expectations of observables in its future domain of dependence. The domain of dependence is not the whole causal future: it contains points whose past-inextendible causal curves all meet the specified initial data region. Merely being reachable by one causal curve from is not enough.
A standard local time-slice axiom makes this precise when contains a neighbourhood of a Cauchy slice of its causal development:
with the regions and algebra identifications understood in the specified local net. Definitions applying primitive causality to all bounded open regions can be stronger than a time-slice property stated only for suitable causally convex Cauchy neighbourhoods; these formulations should not be conflated without extra hypotheses.
For a local hyperbolic Klein–Gordon equation, a later field is determined by the field and its normal derivative, or canonical momentum, on a Cauchy slice. Its value can be written using the causal fundamental solution, with integration supported where the past light cone meets the initial slice. If that support lies in the initial patch, the later smeared field is generated by the patch's initial field and momentum operators. Their algebra therefore generates the observables of the patch's domain of dependence. This is the local differential-equation mechanism behind the time-slice property.
The required information is the entire restricted quantum state: it assigns expectations to every observable and product in the initial algebra. Mean values of the initial field and momentum alone do not determine their fluctuations or higher correlations and thus are insufficient. Knowledge of the restricted state fixes later probability distributions and correlations; it does not fix which individual outcome a future measurement will produce.
Finally, primitive causality concerns propagation of information already encoded in initial data, while microcausality controls compatibility of spacelike measurements and quantum no-signalling controls possible interventions. The spectrum condition adds a separate positivity restriction. A causal initial-value evolution, positive energy and no-signalling are complementary requirements, not equivalent definitions of quantum locality.
The target specifies the desired output; the controller selects a control input; an actuator realizes it on the system; and the sensor returns a measured output. The environment supplies additional interactions and disturbances. A simple loop is:
Figure 1.
Quantum control loop, showing the measurement record and measurement backaction
. Details.
For a quantum sensor, a measurement in quantum mechanics has statistical outcomes and generally changes the state through measurement backaction. For example, outcome of an instrument with operator has probability and conditional state
A single unknown quantum state cannot generally supply its complete instantaneous state vector to a controller. Noncommuting observables cannot be read simultaneously with arbitrary precision, and reliable quantum state tomography normally needs many reproducible preparations. A conditional state estimate can instead be updated from a continuous record, with its disturbance included in the model.
Quantum actuators change a Quantum Hamiltonian through applied electromagnetic fields, tunable interactions or couplings to auxiliary systems. A closed-system actuator implements unitary operators, so it preserves the spectrum and purity of a density operator; it cannot arbitrarily overwrite a state as a classical assignment operation could. Dissipative actuators or measurement in quantum measurements can change these invariants, but their dynamics must be accounted for.
The environment can entangle with the system, causing decoherence and dissipation when unobserved degrees of freedom are traced out. It is consequently part of the dynamical model, rather than just an additive classical disturbance. Conversely, Markovian reservoir engineering uses such coupling constructively to prepare and stabilize states.
In open-loop control the applied waveform is prescribed without using measurements from the current evolution. In closed-loop control it depends on the available measurement record or inferred state. Measurement-based quantum feedback is one realization of the latter; experimental adaptation across repeated preparations is another. The measurement record is classical information, but its production has quantum backaction.
Three standard objectives are state preparation, observable optimization and process implementation. All optimizations are over admissible control inputs and a specified final time .
For state preparation, steer an initial density operator to a target . An exact goal is , or one may minimize the squared Hilbert-Schmidt distance
For a pure target , maximizing is a useful alternative. The target must be physically attainable: Hamiltonian engineering alone preserves the initial spectrum of the density operator.
For an observable objective, choose a Hermitian operator and maximize its expected final value:
Population transfer is a special case with the projector onto the desired level or subspace; suppressing an unwanted population reverses the sign or minimizes this quantity.
For coherent process engineering, implement a target unitary operator on every input, rather than merely arranging one state transfer. If the propagator is , a phase-insensitive error is
The error vanishes precisely when : equality in the Hilbert-Schmidt inner product Cauchy-Schwarz inequality bound makes the two operators proportional. For an open-system process, the analogous objective compares the implemented quantum channel with the target channel. These objectives can be supplemented by pulse-energy, amplitude, bandwidth and duration constraints in quantum optimal control.
Replace evaluation in a possibly inaccurate dynamical model by an experimental objective. Parametrize an admissible pulse as , with collecting time-slice amplitudes or basis-function coefficients. Prepare the same initial state, apply the pulse, measure performance, and update before the next run. This is adaptive experimental quantum control: the loop closes through experimental results, even though each individual pulse is applied open loop.
For example, minimize
for a pure target , with a nonempty closed convex set enforcing amplitude and bandwidth bounds. The overlap is an experimentally estimable probability. An observable objective can use its measured expectation instead; a gate objective generally needs more input states and measurement settings. The true dynamics constrain the physically produced , but no accurate formula for those dynamics is required to evaluate this objective.
A direct search compares measured scores for candidate pulses, accepts improvements and refines the search region. Alternatively estimate a gradient experimentally by finite differences,
where is the Euclidean projection onto a convex set. Population-based searches can also explore several candidates in parallel. These methods use experimental data rather than simulated propagation or a model-derived adjoint gradient.
Each score needs enough repeated preparations to manage measurement noise; uncertainty in score differences should determine replication and stopping decisions. Excessively small finite-difference steps amplify that noise. A model-based pulse can provide a useful starting point, but adaptation corrects its systematic mismatch using the device itself. This mitigates model uncertainty, not arbitrary fluctuations: reproducible preparation, calibrated measurements and sufficiently slow drift remain necessary. Nor does a local numerical search guarantee a global optimum.
The Lyapunov quantum control law requires an exact instantaneous expectation value. Cyclicity writes it as
where is a known Hermitian observable. A measurement on one system produces a random outcome, not its exact ensemble expectation, and changes the system state. Repeated measurements for state estimation or continuous weak measurements introduce noise and backaction absent from the assumed closed-system equation. Thus the law cannot be implemented unchanged as exact measurement-based quantum feedback while retaining the dynamics and guarantee in part (a). A conditional-state feedback scheme must include the measurement evolution and rederive its stability properties.
If the initial density operator and Hamiltonian model are known, we can instead solve the deterministic equations in a computer, calculate along the simulated trajectory, and apply that precomputed waveform in the laboratory as open-loop control. Ensemble measurements can help calibrate such a waveform, but they do not supply nondisturbing instantaneous feedback from an individual evolving system.
Apply the modulo operation to the eigenvalues of . The product eigenstates have ordinary eigenvalues , respectively, and residues modulo . The resulting observable is
Use the entanglement-assisted nondemolition parity measurement from part (a). Equal local meter records give ; unequal records give . Its conditional quantum measurement maps are and , with normalization by their probabilities. The quantum nondemolition measurement preserves every vector within each degenerate eigenspace, including superpositions of and . Measuring the two system spins separately would destroy that even-sector coherence and would therefore not realize the same Lüders rule instrument. The nonlocal eigenvalue again becomes known only after local operations and classical communication compares the local records.
Assume the proposed device distinguishes the four displayed eigenstates, as an ideal rank-one projective measurement. This assumption matters: if all four had the same eigenvalue, the identity observable would admit that eigenbasis but its Lüders rule measurement would do nothing and could not signal. The printed eigenvectors alone do not exclude this degeneracy.
For the complete resolving measurement, let , , and be the four rank-one projectors. If the nonlocal outcome is ignored, the nonselective projective measurement channel is . Each listed state's local reduced density matrix is diagonal in , with expectation for either plus state and for either minus state. Consequently
Compute in its even and odd two-dimensional blocks: both have diagonal entries and off-diagonal entries . Thus
and
To signal, prepare Alice in and Bob initially in . Bob encodes a bit by either doing nothing or applying a local Pauli Z gate, which changes his state to . Alice's input reduced density matrix is identical in both cases, but after the hypothetical instantaneous measurement her local expectation is
The two probabilities for Alice's outcome are , so their difference is . It is strictly positive for . Repeated trials let Alice infer Bob's bit while their operations are still spacelike, violating quantum no-signalling and relativistic causality. The relativistic causality constraint on an ideal nonlocal measurement therefore permits only
within the specified interval. The argument requires no rapid communication of the hypothetical nonlocal outcome: Alice reads her own changed local statistics. It rules out the full ideal instrument, not merely the later classical comparison of locally obtained records.
The expectation value is the mean outcome over many identically prepared measurements of the observable. For real , positivity of the norm in the Hilbert space gives
This real quadratic has nonpositive quadratic discriminant, so
Apply this to the centered observables and to obtain the Robertson uncertainty principle
For the quantum harmonic oscillator, and
The arithmetic-geometric mean inequality and now give
Write the expectation value as
Differentiating and retaining the possible explicit time dependence of the observable gives
The Schrödinger equation and its adjoint are
where the Hamiltonian operator is Hermitian. Substitution yields
This is the proof of Ehrenfest theorem from the Schrodinger equation.
For a normalized state, the uncertainty of a Hermitian observable is
Let a projective measurement have mutually orthogonal projections satisfying . On a density operator , the Born rule and the Lüders rule give
conditional on outcome . On the first part of a bipartite quantum system, replace by .
The subsystems are isolated when there is no interaction term coupling them. Their Hamiltonian operator has the form
so their subsequent unitary time evolution factorizes as .
The reduced density matrix of subsystem 1 is
where the partial trace is characterized by
for every local observable . Thus contains exactly the statistics accessible by measurements on subsystem 1.
Suppose a projective measurement is performed on subsystem 2 and its outcome is not communicated. The resulting nonselective state is
For every , the cyclic property of the trace and give
Hence . No local projective measurement on subsystem 1 can reveal whether the remote unreported measurement occurred. This is quantum no-signalling, which prevents a choice made at a spacelike separation from transmitting information faster than light and makes the measurement formalism compatible with relativistic causality.
The proposed nondisturbing device would violate no information without disturbance. In an ordinary quantum instrument, let be the Kraus operators associated with classical output . If every pure state remains unchanged even conditional on the displayed outcome, every nonzero must be parallel to . A linear operator for which every vector is an eigenvector is a scalar multiple of the identity, so . Its output probability
is independent of the state. It cannot equal for arbitrary projectors. Equivalently, repeated nondisturbing samples would permit quantum state tomography of one specimen and then quantum cloning, contradicting ordinary quantum theory.
Such devices would not necessarily enable superluminal signalling. One consistent operational extension could make every sequence of outputs depend only on the local reduced density matrix and local settings. Since an unreported remote measurement leaves that matrix unchanged, all local device statistics would remain unchanged too. Other extensions could add nonlocal outcome-dependent rules and permit signalling, but that behavior is additional to the device specification rather than forced by it.
Quantum decoherence explains the practical stability of records and suppression of observable interference; it does not alone select one outcome. The measurement problem arises when universal unitary time evolution, a complete wave function description and a unique definite outcome are all demanded. A theory must explain which commitment is changed or supplemented, not merely replace a pure composite description by a reduced one.
Model an ideal quantum measurement and its environment by
Taking the partial trace over the environment gives the system–apparatus reduced density matrix
Environmental records make very small for macroscopically distinct alternatives. If independent fragments have overlaps , their combined overlap is , explaining the rapid suppression. The apparatus interaction also favours robust records, giving environment-induced pointer-basis selection rather than an arbitrary choice of basis.[ref]
What follows is approximate agreement, for local apparatus observables, with a classical probabilistic mixture. What does not follow is that either term has ceased to exist. Even with orthogonal environmental records, the global quantum state is a pure state with quantum entanglement. For orthogonal branches , the global observable has expectation in the superposition and zero in the corresponding incoherent mixture. Its practical inaccessibility is not its mathematical disappearance. The reduced state is an improper mixed state, not proof that an unknown single branch was selected.
Different interpretations use this result differently. In Bohmian mechanics, disjoint environmental configurations make one occupied branch an effective description of the actual apparatus. In the many-worlds interpretation, robust branches supply approximately autonomous relative records, without a unique global outcome. In the GRW model, a separate stochastic change of the wave function selects a dominant component; environmental decoherence helps explain ordinary records but is not the collapse law. These are different completions of the argument.
Nor does diagonality derive the Born rule. Interpreting the diagonal entries as experienced outcome probabilities requires a probability rule or an interpretive argument. Extremely small overlaps also leave approximations and possible quantum recoherence; a finite controlled environment can in principle be manipulated to reveal the global coherence. The appropriate verdict is that decoherence resolves much of the preferred-record-basis and effective-classicality problem while leaving the unique-outcome and probability problems dependent on further theory. It is an essential physical mechanism in many accounts, not a self-contained solution by relabelling a partial trace as collapse.
Quantum mechanics is compatible with quantum no-signalling, but its full correlations are incompatible with Bell local causality under the usual additional assumptions. The answer depends on which locality condition is meant. A local operational prohibition on controllable faster-than-light communication is weaker than a causal explanation of correlations by a complete shared past.
Let be outcomes, local settings and a complete relevant past specification. Bell factorization and measurement independence demand
Neither assumes deterministic response. Put and similarly , so . Pointwise,
Averaging with the same for all settings gives the CHSH inequality . For a spin singlet state, . Choose , , , ; the magnitude becomes . Thus the assumptions cannot all be maintained.[ref]
There is nevertheless no signalling contradiction. If a local unread measurement has Kraus operators with , then
The equality follows by testing both sides against any distant observable and using cyclicity of the trace. Distant conditional states can differ after selecting , but communicating that selection needs an ordinary message. The microcausality condition in quantum field theory similarly ensures commutation of spacelike-separated local observables; it does not make the vacuum or other entangled quantum states Bell-factorizable.
One can preserve different notions of locality by changing premises. Bohmian mechanics retains unique outcomes but its guidance equation is nonlocal for entangled systems; quantum equilibrium equivariance preserves the equilibrium distribution which masks that dependence from signalling. The many-worlds interpretation can combine local interaction equations with no unique global outcome, but a claim of locality must explain its branch-relative correlations; it has not thereby constructed the above Bell-local single-outcome model. The measurement-independence loophole, including suitable retrocausal or correlated-setting models, drops the shared setting-independent premise. Such models are logical possibilities, not demonstrations that the ordinary locality assumptions survive unchanged.
The justified answer is therefore conditional rather than an unqualified yes or no. Operational locality is retained by the quantum formalism. A theory reproducing all its correlations cannot retain Bell factorization, independent settings and the ordinary joint-outcome framework together. Neither denial of hidden variables nor an appeal to relativity alone removes the probabilistic contradiction.
For normalized amplitudes and a time-independent observable , the Schrödinger equation gives
The interference term therefore has
This is the period of two-state quantum interference. If the off-diagonal matrix element or either amplitude vanishes, the expectation value is constant, so this is not its unique fundamental period. Equal energies likewise give no beat.
For a time-independent Hamiltonian operator, a symmetry operator satisfies , or . Thus applying to an energy eigenstate preserves its energy. Commuting Hermitian observables can be diagonalized within each degenerate energy eigenspace, allowing states to be labelled by symmetry quantum numbers.
A continuous unitary symmetry has Hermitian generator . Differentiating the invariance condition gives . The Heisenberg equation of motion then yields
when has no explicit time dependence. spatial translations connect to momentum conservation, rotations to angular-momentum conservation, and time-translation invariance to energy conservation. A central potential energy conserves all components of angular momentum, but they cannot all be assigned sharp simultaneous values because they do not commute; are a compatible choice. Discrete reflection symmetry gives parity labels without a continuously variable generator. A quantum degeneracy can be protected by a symmetry, but a quantum degeneracy alone does not identify its physical origin.
A pure stationary state of a time-independent Hamiltonian operator is . Its probability density and all expectations of time-independent observables are constant. This does not require zero probability current.
For real scalar potential energy and no vector potential, substitute and its complex conjugate into . The potential terms cancel:
Thus the probability current is . In a stationary state : flow may circulate without changing the density.
Here only the azimuthal phase contributes an imaginary logarithmic derivative. Since ,
There is no radial or polar flow; the azimuthal current is independent of , so its divergence vanishes. The apparent coordinate singularity at cancels in the final expression.
The z-component of orbital angular momentum follows from the moment of the mass current:
Indeed . This agrees with acting on the wavefunction.
For observables , nonzero obstructs a complete common eigenbasis. In a finite-dimensional system, commuting Hermitian operators can be simultaneously diagonalized; quantum degeneracy may require choosing an appropriate basis inside the degenerate eigenspace. Noncommuting observables can still share particular eigenvectors, so incompatibility is not a claim that every individual state must have nonzero spreads in both quantities.
The Robertson uncertainty relation follows by applying Cauchy-Schwarz inequality to and :
In particular gives . These are preparation spreads, not necessarily measurement errors. A zero commutator expectation can make this bound zero even when the linear operators do not commute.
Measurement order can matter: preparing , measuring , then measuring gives both z outcomes with probability when the intermediate result is ignored. A direct z measurement would give certainly. Finally the Heisenberg equation of motion relates commutation to conservation: an observable with no explicit time dependence and is conserved. For unbounded self-adjoint operators these statements require the appropriate common domains; a formal commutator calculation alone need not justify simultaneous spectral measurements.