Past exam of the physics A course of the University of Cambridge 2012 Paper 1 Section B B6 Solution 2026-10-20
The canonical commutation relations are , with . Operators from different Cartesian modes commute, so and . Thus is Hermitian and represents an observable on the usual oscillator domain.
Introduce annihilation operators and similarly . Set , and . The Schwinger boson representation givesFor and , and . ThereforeThe two-mode oscillator Casimir identity isSince , , and is conserved. However, is not the zero operator, so there is no general joint eigenbasis. The exception is important: a common eigenstate of two angular-momentum components must satisfy , then the other commutators force . Thus only the sector admits a common state; here that is the oscillator ground state.
Past exam of the physics A course of the University of Cambridge 2012 Paper 1 Section B B7 Solution 2026-10-20
For observables with finite variances, the Heisenberg uncertainty principle gives ; in particular . It concerns the spreads of measurements in a prepared state, rather than only disturbance by a measuring device. Identical integer-spin particles have symmetric full states and Bose-Einstein statistics; half-integer-spin particles have antisymmetric full states and Fermi-Dirac statistics. The latter imply Pauli exclusion from one complete single-particle state, including spin.
Inside an infinite square well, solutions satisfying both zero boundary conditions arewith zero wavefunction outside. For the ground state, direct integration givesThe infinite-well ground-state uncertainty product follows:The ground state is not a minimum-uncertainty Gaussian. Here momentum variance is the usual kinetic-momentum second moment of the confined state; the hard-wall momentum operator has domain subtleties that do not alter this kinetic-energy result.
For spin degeneracy in filling a one-dimensional well, let and assume the spin levels are degenerate and available. Four spin-zero bosons all occupy the lowest orbital, giving . Four spin- fermions fill two spin states in each of , giving . Spin- fermions have four spin projections, so all four can occupy in different complete states, giving . These fillings do not impose full spin polarization.
The Time-dependent Schrödinger equation governs unitary evolution of a closed system. If is independent of time, expand in its energy eigenstates:An individual energy eigenstate changes only by a phase, so its probability density and time-independent-observable expectations are stationary. Superpositions can have interference terms oscillating at ; fixed energy populations do not imply that every observable is constant.
For general , requires time ordering unless Quantum Hamiltonians at different times commute. The equivalent Heisenberg description evolves observables rather than the state, giving . Explicit time dependence can transfer energy from an applied perturbation.
For a weak perturbation to a known , the first-order transition amplitude from to isIts squared modulus gives the leading transition probability while depletion remains small. A nearly monochromatic perturbation emphasizes energy differences near its quantum of frequency; a continuum and suitable long-time limit yield Fermi's golden rule. These approximations have stated weak-coupling and time-resolution limits; they do not replace exact unitary dynamics in every regime.
A continuous symmetry is represented by a unitary family with a self-adjoint conserved generator of a continuous quantum symmetry . If for all , differentiating gives . Thus, for no explicit time dependence,translation invariance conserves the corresponding momentum component; rotational invariance about one axis conserves that angular-momentum component. A central potential conserves all components and , but the components need not be simultaneously measurable because . Time-translation invariance of a closed system gives a time-independent Hamiltonian and energy conservation.
A discrete symmetry need not have a continuously varying generator. For parity, lets stationary states be chosen even or odd, and preserves parity sectors. symmetry does not force every state to be an eigenstate of its conserved observable. Explicit time dependence adds to the conservation equation, and an external symmetry-breaking potential generally permits exchange with the environment. Degenerate eigenspaces require choosing a compatible common basis rather than assuming every eigenvector already diagonalizes every commuting operator.
Past exam of the physics A course of the University of Cambridge 2016 Paper 1 Section C C10 Solution 2026-10-20
identical particles have the same intrinsic properties, including mass, charge and spin. Their labels are bookkeeping devices rather than measurable identities. When wave functions overlap, quantum mechanics supplies no observable trajectory that permanently identifies “particle 1” independently of “particle 2”. A many-particle description must therefore treat exchange consistently. The Hamiltonian and physical observables are invariant under relabelling identical particles.
For two particles, the exchange operator obeys . The usual three-dimensional symmetrization postulate selects states symmetric under exchange for bosons and antisymmetric for fermions. In relativistic quantum theory, the Spin-statistics theorem associates integer spin with bosons and half-integer spin with fermions under its locality and positivity assumptions; the connection is not derived merely from in elementary nonrelativistic mechanics. For orthonormal one-particle states and , the two-particle spatial combinations areThe sign concerns the complete state, including spin and other internal variables, not necessarily the spatial factor alone.
The antisymmetric state vanishes if both fermions occupy the same one-particle state: this is the Pauli exclusion principle. For fermions in orthonormal spin orbitals , the normalized Slater determinant supplies the required exchange sign. Bosonic occupation has no corresponding upper limit, and symmetrized products describe many bosons. Fermionic occupation is zero or one per complete one-particle state; two electrons can still occupy the same spatial atomic orbital with opposite spin.
Spin and spatial symmetry are linked. A two-electron spin singlet state is antisymmetric, so its spatial factor must be symmetric. A symmetric triplet state instead requires an antisymmetric spatial factor. Exchange then changes pair correlations and the energies available when interactions depend on particle separation, even without introducing a new classical “exchange force”. It contributes to atomic shell structure, bonding and magnetic behaviour.
Symmetric and antisymmetric two-particle spatial states have different joint-position correlations
. Source. Details. In an occupation-number description, bosonic creation and annihilation operators satisfy , whereas fermionic operators satisfy and anticommute among themselves. The latter imply . This formalism implements the same exchange constraints without assigning permanent particle labels.
For noninteracting particles in thermal equilibrium, the mean occupation of a state of energy isFermi-Dirac statistics produces a filled Fermi sea at zero temperature and degeneracy pressure; Bose-Einstein statistics permits macroscopic Ground state occupation when the density of available states and thermodynamic conditions allow condensation. The different statistics therefore have measurable collective consequences, not just different notation.[ref]
Statistical Physics by David Tong. Chapter 3, §§3.5–3.6: Bose and Fermi distributions, condensation and degenerate Fermi gases
When phase-space occupation is dilute, both distributions reduce to the Maxwell–Boltzmann statistics limit. Likewise, well-separated localized wave packets have negligible overlap and small exchange corrections, so effectively labelled classical trajectories can become a useful approximation. In two spatial dimensions more general exchange statistics are possible; the standard boson/fermion account here concerns ordinary three-dimensional particles and their total states.
Ehrenfest theorem relates the dynamics of quantum expectation values to operator commutators. For a normalized state obeying and a possibly time-dependent observable , differentiate . Using the adjoint Schrödinger equation for the bra givesThusThe identity assumes a common domain on which the required products and derivatives are defined.
For , the canonical commutation relation gives and . ThereforeThese resemble Hamilton's equations and Newton's second law, but generally . If the state is localized about , a local expansion givesThe classical trajectory equation for the mean is accurate when the force changes little across the wave packet. For a quadratic harmonic potential, is linear and this closure is exact for every state with the relevant finite moments: . This exact classical evolution of the centroid does not eliminate its quantum position uncertainty or make every state a point particle.
The correspondence principle is broader: quantum predictions recover classical ones in an appropriate limit, such as large action compared with and observations that cannot resolve individual quantum levels. It is not the assertion that every large quantum number automatically makes every possible state classical. Delocalized superpositions and interference can remain significant unless the physical preparation and measurement justify a classical description.
A spectral example is useful. For a quantum harmonic oscillator, neighboring levels differ by , giving transition frequency , equal to its classical oscillation frequency. A coherent state makes the connection more concrete: its mean position and momentum oscillate classically while the finite-width Gaussian profile retains its quantum uncertainty. For hydrogenic Bohr levels , transitions between nearby large have , which equals the classical circular orbital angular frequency in that model. Ehrenfest's theorem supplies an exact expectation-value bridge; a classical trajectory follows only when the force can also be evaluated at the mean position.
In the Schrödinger picture, a time-independent Hamiltonian gives , where . The Heisenberg picture transfers this evolution to each observable:Both pictures give the same probabilities and expectation values. Differentiating yields the Heisenberg equation of motionThe last term is an explicit change of the measured operator. If it is absent and , the observable is conserved.
The corresponding classical equation is . The correspondence principle relates the Poisson bracket to , with suitable operator ordering and a classical limit. For , the canonical commutation relation givesTaking means gives Ehrenfest theorem. Its second equation contains , which need not equal . A narrow wave packet in a slowly varying force field can follow the classical equations approximately; a quadratic potential makes the equality exact for the means.
For a quantum harmonic oscillator, direct solution gives and . These have the classical form as operator identities. A coherent state supplies a localized center moving on the classical orbit, whereas an energy eigenstate has stationary density and , even at large excitation. Thus large quantum numbers alone do not create a localized classical trajectory. Classical behavior also concerns state preparation, relative fluctuations and the resolution of the measurements.
An observable is represented by a self-adjoint operator. For an ideal projective measurement, let be its spectral projector for outcome . The Born rule gives , or for a density matrix . Conditional on obtaining , the Lüders rule givesFor a degenerate outcome this projects onto the whole associated eigenspace, rather than arbitrarily selecting a vector within it. An immediate repeated ideal measurement returns the same outcome, provided there is no intervening evolution or disturbance.
Commuting finite-dimensional observables admit a common orthonormal eigenbasis; their projectors commute and ideal joint measurements are compatible. Noncommuting observables generally have no complete common eigenbasis, and measurement order can affect the subsequent statistics. Particular common eigenvectors can nevertheless exist, so a nonzero commutator does not mean that every state has a nonzero uncertainty in both quantities.
For a quantitative constraint, apply the Cauchy-Schwarz inequality to and . The imaginary part of their inner product is , giving the Robertson uncertainty principleThe canonical commutation relation gives . Retaining the real part of the same inner product gives the stronger Robertson-Schrödinger uncertainty relation, including a covariance term. These are constraints on the preparation of a quantum state, not simply statements about a poorly calibrated instrument.
A sequential spin one-half example makes the change in statistics explicit. Prepare . An immediate measurement is certainly positive. If an measurement is inserted first, its outcomes each have probability and leave states . Each then yields either result with probability , so the final positive fraction is . The change reflects projection onto incompatible spin eigenstates, even with ideal measuring apparatus. The theory of measurement in quantum mechanics allows more general state-update rules, but the operator description and the Born rule still constrain their probabilities.
Set . Taking the Hermitian adjoint reverses the order of products, so . Complex conjugation also reverses the sign of , and thereforeThus is a self-adjoint operator on the usual oscillator states.
Using the coefficients in part (a), products containing two position operators or two momentum operators cancel in the difference. Cross-coordinate operators commute, leavingHenceIt is the component of orbital angular momentum perpendicular to the plane, with units (equivalently ). The rotational symmetry of the two-dimensional isotropic harmonic oscillator makes this a conserved observable; directly, each term in preserves , so .
Past exam of the physics A course of the University of Cambridge 2022 Paper 1 Section D D9 Solution 2026-10-18
Time dependence in quantum mechanics describes how a prepared quantum state changes and thereby changes the probabilities of later measurements. For an isolated system, the Schrödinger picture assigns this evolution to a state vector , governed by the Time-dependent Schrödinger equationThe Hamiltonian is a self-adjoint operator; it has units of energy, while has units of action, so has units of inverse time. For a particle with potential energy , this becomesGiven a suitable initial wavefunction and the physical boundary conditions, this first-order equation determines its subsequent propagation. Its linearity means that the evolution of a quantum superposition is the corresponding quantum superposition of evolved states.
For a real potential energy, this equation and its complex conjugate imply the local continuity equationHere is the probability density and the probability current. Vanishing net boundary flux preserves wavefunction normalization, as required by the Born rule.
The time-evolution operator packages the solution for every initial state:Because , differentiation givesTherefore : this is unitary time evolution, preserving inner products and all state norms. It is reversible, with , and obeys the composition law .
For a time-independent Hamiltonian, the solution is the operator exponentialIf the Hamiltonian varies with time, the analogous simple exponential of its integral is valid when for all relevant times. Otherwise time ordering is essential:The meaning is explicit in the first terms of the ordered series,the later-time operator stands on the left. In the position representation, the same propagation is expressed by the quantum-mechanical propagatorIts initial value is the Dirac delta function .
A time-independent Hamiltonian has energy eigenstates satisfying . A single such initial state evolves asIt is a stationary state: its global phase changes, but its probability density and the distributions of time-independent observables do not. Its energy is sharp. Any quantum superposition entirely within one degenerate energy eigenspace also acquires one common global phase and is stationary. Stationarity does not require zero probability current; for instance, on the ring has a constant density and persistent circulation when .
An arbitrary normalized state can instead contain different energy eigenvalues:A continuous spectrum requires corresponding integrals. For the discrete case, an energy measurement gives with fixed probability (summed over degeneracies), but relative quantum phases change with time. ConsequentlyThe interference terms can oscillate at angular frequencies . For two populated energy levels, this supplies a characteristic period when the interference term is nonzero. Thus fixed energy populations do not imply a stationary spatial distribution.
For a normalized state and an observable , its expectation value isThis is the statistical mean over repeated preparations and measurements. In an eigenbasis of energy eigenstates for a time-independent Hamiltonian and a time-independent ,Only matrix elements connecting different energies can generate these oscillations. If , its expectation value is constant for every initial state, provided it has no explicit time dependence.
Differentiating the expectation value and substituting the Schrödinger equation for both the bra and ket proves the general Ehrenfest theorem:Equivalently,These manipulations require the state to lie in the relevant operator domains. Taking gives , so energy is conserved under a time-independent Hamiltonian.
For , the canonical commutation relation givesHence the particularly useful position-and-momentum form of Ehrenfest theorem isIt resembles Newton's second law, but the mean force generally differs from the force at the mean position. If a narrow wave packet samples a region where the force varies little, gives approximate classical motion. For a quadratic potential energy this replacement is exact. In particular the quantum harmonic oscillator obeysThe centroid follows the classical harmonic oscillator, although this does not specify the full evolving wavefunction or its width.
The Heisenberg picture expresses the same physics by assigning evolution to observables instead:The expectation value is unchanged, and differentiation yields . Thus state propagation, evolving expectation values, and the classical correspondence in Ehrenfest theorem are mutually consistent descriptions of the same unitary time evolution.
Past exam of the quantum information course of the University of Cambridge 2016 Paper 1 1 Solution 2026-10-20
An eigenvalue of an observable in a known corresponding eigenstate is a simple example satisfying the Einstein–Podolsky–Rosen criterion of reality: its value is predictable with certainty. For example, a spin angular momentum component in a prepared spin-up eigenstate has a definite predicted value. For a distant system, Albert Einstein, Boris Podolsky and Nathan Rosen invoked locality: a measurement performed on a sufficiently separated, noninteracting partner should not disturb that system. In the relativistic version here, the measurement events have spacelike separation.
The Pauli matrices obey , soTheir nondegenerate eigenstates are incompatible: an eigenstate has equal probabilities for the two outcomes, and conversely. Thus no single quantum state has both components sharply determined. The Robertson uncertainty relation gives , but its right-hand side may be zero; that alone is not a proof that simultaneous zero uncertainties exist. The absence of a common eigenstate supplies the stronger conclusion for this spin-half pair.
For the specified Bell state, Bob obtains or with probability when he measures . Conditional on his result, Alice obtains the same sign with certainty if she measures . Under the EPR locality premise, this certainty supplies an element of reality for her ; it is a conditional prediction after Bob learns his own random result, not a premeasurement prediction of its sign.
The normalized eigenstates are and . Expanding their tensor products givesConsequently the same Bell state has equal, perfectly correlated outcomes. Bob's two outcomes again each have probability , and the same locality-and-certainty argument applies separately to Alice's .
The disputed step is to combine predictions conditional on two incompatible choices into two simultaneous, measurement-independent pre-existing values. Quantum theory provides the two conditional ensembles, not a joint sharp assignment of and . This is quantum steering. Bob cannot measure both incompatible observables sharply on the same member of the pair. Nor does conditional steering allow signalling: ignoring his result leaves Alice's reduced density matrix equal to for either measurement choice, by the no-communication theorem.
To test the stronger claim of a local hidden-variable theory, Alice needs several correlation settings, not just perfect agreement along the two common axes. For the CHSH inequality, choose observables with outcomes :In the given Bell state, and the crossed correlations vanish. Henceexceeding the local bound . The bound assumes Bell local causality and measurement independence, with the appropriate treatment of sampling and settings.
Experimental Bell tests support violations rather than that local assignment. The Aspect switching experiment changed analyzer settings during separated photon flights, while leaving sampling and switching limitations. By the time of this examination, the Delft electron-spin Bell test had used electron spins at stations apart, efficient spin readout and rapid random basis choices. The combination addressed both detection and locality loopholes, providing evidence against the tested local model class.[ref]
Experimental loophole-free violation of a Bell inequality by Bas Hensen and others. 2015 abstract: separated electron spins, efficient readout and fast random settings
This does not prove that every conceivable notion of reality is false, or that noncommutation alone rules out every hidden-variable theory. A nonlocal theory can evade the local premise. What Alice can challenge is Bob's claim that locality, measurement-independent simultaneous values and all observed correlations can be retained together. An ordinary measurement disturbance at Bob's lab is not by itself a local explanation of Alice's conditional ensemble.
Past exam of the quantum information course of the University of Cambridge 2016 Paper 1 3 a Solution 2026-10-20
A weak measurement couples an observable only weakly to a meter, so the pointer distributions associated with its different eigenvalues overlap strongly. One trial supplies little information and a small disturbance; an ensemble is needed to estimate a small mean shift. It is not an exact determination of a previously hidden eigenvalue with no disturbance.
For pointer position and conjugate momentum , a short von Neumann measurement interaction has unitary . An eigenvalue translates the pointer by . The weak regime requires those translations to be small relative to the pointer width. Without postselection the first-order mean displacement is for an initially uncorrelated, suitably centered meter.
If the system is prepared in and postselected in , the unnormalized meter state isFor a real centered Gaussian pointer with no position–momentum correlation, the conditional position shift is ; the imaginary part affects the conjugate momentum distribution. The weak value can be complex or have a real part outside the observable's eigenvalue interval, because it is a conditional transition-amplitude ratio, not an eigenvalue.
An example apparatus uses photon polarization as the two-level system, a weak polarization-dependent transverse displacement as the interaction, and an output polarizer for postselection. Repeated position detections estimate the selected beam's displacement. Nearly orthogonal selection can make the conditional shift large, but also reduces the accepted sample and eventually invalidates the first-order expansion. The original weak-value proposal emphasized preselection, a weak coupling and postselection, rather than an anomalous result from an ordinary sharp spin measurement.[ref]
Weak values by Yakir Aharonov, David Z. Albert and Lev Vaidman. 1988 primary paper: preselected and postselected spin ensemble and conditional weak value
Weak coupling limits quantum measurement backaction per trial; it does not abolish the information–disturbance tradeoff. Repeating weak observations can accumulate substantial backaction, and discarding rejected trials cannot automatically improve the information available per prepared system. Conditional pointer amplification and a statistically improved parameter estimate are distinct claims.
For a nonzero quantum state and a self-adjoint operator , the expectation value and standard deviation of its measurement areThe squared deviation is also called the variance of the observable. All displayed products are understood on quantum states for which the relevant moments exist. Self-adjointness gives , so is real. Expanding the squared norm gives the variance expression. A norm is nonnegative and is zero exactly for the zero vector, hence precisely when . Thus zero dispersion is equivalent to being an eigenstate.
For bounded , the operator exponential is the norm-convergent power seriesFor a general unbounded self-adjoint Hamiltonian operator, the spectral theorem defines the same notation byThis definition does not require the power series to converge on every quantum state. complex conjugation of the spectral multiplier gives , and multiplication of the phases gives . Thus is unitary, preserves the quantum state norm, and has .
For initial data in the domain of , differentiating the spectral expression yields . Consequentlysolves the Schrödinger equation with the prescribed initial quantum state. Uniqueness follows by differentiating : the two terms cancel, leaving the constant .
In the two-dimensional energy basis, expand the initial quantum state as . Each energy eigenvector receives its own phase under the operator exponential, givingThis is the general solution because every initial vector has a unique basis expansion.
In that orthonormal basis the other observable has the real symmetric matrixIts conjugate transpose equals itself, so it is self-adjoint. Also and , giving eigenvalues and . Direct substitution gives the normalized orthogonal eigenvectorsAn irrelevant global phase may multiply either vector. With the chosen lower eigenstate initially,The Born rule says that the probability for the higher eigenstate is . Its amplitude is . Using givesThis is the transition probability for a rotated two-level observable. Its time dependence comes from the relative phase between two energy eigenstates. If their energies coincide, or if the measured observable has the energy eigenvectors as its eigenvectors, this transition probability is zero at all times.
A pure state is a unit vector in a complex Hilbert space, with vectors differing by a global phase representing the same physical state. An observable is a self-adjoint operator, with measurement probabilities determined by its spectral projections. For vectors in the relevant operator domains,A squared norm vanishes exactly when its vector vanishes. Therefore zero dispersion is equivalent to .
For two observables set , , . For real ,If , nonpositivity of its discriminant yields . Equality holds exactly when the minimum squared norm vanishes, namelyThe degenerate case must also be included: if , then and equality holds for every . Thus the complete criterion is that , or that the displayed real- relation holds. This includes by choosing when .
Apply the inequality to centred operators , . Their squared norms are the variances and their commutator is , givingAn eigenvector of either operator would have its corresponding dispersion zero, contradicting this positive lower bound if the other dispersion were finite and the stated domain conditions held. In the usual representation there are in fact no normalizable exact position or momentum eigenvectors; their generalized eigenvectors are not counterexamples. The equality condition above is the uncentered second-moment commutator inequality.
Let and write in the Schrödinger picture, with observables constant unless they have an explicit time dependence. In the Heisenberg picture the state is andDifferentiate the two unitary factors to obtain the equation. Unitarity gives .
For the interaction picture choose a reference split , put , and define , . Then , , while evolves with (and its explicit time dependence). AgainThese are different unitary allocations of the same dynamics between states and observables, so measured expectations agree.
The canonical commutation relation now givesMultiplication of the last equation by and integration givesSince and , both initial expectations of vanish. ThereforeThe printed positive displacement endpoint has the wrong sign for the Hamiltonian's positive term. The two turning values are and ; their ordering depends on the sign of . The result oscillates about the displaced equilibrium , exactly as the force predicts.
Let and write in the Schrödinger picture, with observables constant unless they have an explicit time dependence. In the Heisenberg picture the state is andDifferentiate the two unitary factors to obtain the equation. Unitarity gives .
For the interaction picture choose a reference split , put , and define , . Then , , while evolves with (and its explicit time dependence). AgainThese are different unitary allocations of the same dynamics between states and observables, so measured expectations agree.
The canonical commutation relation now givesMultiplication of the last equation by and integration givesSince and , both initial expectations of vanish. ThereforeThe printed positive displacement endpoint has the wrong sign for the Hamiltonian's positive term. The two turning values are and ; their ordering depends on the sign of . The result oscillates about the displaced equilibrium , exactly as the force predicts.
Diagonalizing the matrix gives the normalized eigenvectorswith eigenvalues , respectively. The first projective measurement prepares up to global phase, regardless of the earlier state, conditional on obtaining .
The unitary time evolution under gives, with ,The probability amplitudes for the second projective measurement areThe Born rule therefore gives the general spin-one transverse measurement after axial precession:At the specified times , , soFor even , the result is certainly ; for odd , it is certainly . Although zero belongs to the spectrum of the observable, it never occurs at these times. Indeed, for even the evolved vector is , while for odd it is , where the minus sign is a global phase.
Along Hamiltonian motion,Substituting and givesFor the printed there is no explicit time term. In particular, an autonomous observable is conserved when its Poisson bracket with vanishes. Taking or recovers Hamilton's equations.
An invertible change is canonical when it preserves the Poisson bracket. Its fundamental brackets must beThe chain rule then makes the bracket of any two observables identical in the old and new coordinates. Consequently Hamilton's equations retain their canonical form. A time-dependent canonical transformation also requires the corresponding extra term in the transformed Hamiltonian; bracket preservation by itself concerns each fixed time.
An ensemble of normalized quantum states with probabilities is represented by the density operatorIt determines every observable expectation value through . The ensemble decomposition need not be unique; the operator specifies the measurement statistics.
