For two Stokes flows and of the same dynamic viscosity in the same region, with no volume force, the Lorentz reciprocal theorem states
Indeed, the divergence of their cross-work difference is
The pressure terms vanish by incompressible flow, and the derivatives of the Cauchy stress tensors vanish by the Stokes equation. The divergence theorem proves the result.
Use the convention that are the force and torque exerted by the body on the fluid. By Linearity of Stokes flow, . Applying the Lorentz reciprocal theorem to two independent rigid motions gives , so the hydrodynamic resistance matrix is a symmetric matrix. The boundary-power identity gives
This is strictly positive for nonzero rigid motion: equality would imply , hence a rigid motion throughout the connected fluid, which must vanish since the fluid is at rest at infinity. The no-slip boundary condition would then force . Therefore is a positive-definite matrix. Reversing to the fluid-on-body force changes the sign of the force law, not the positive resistance coefficients.
For the two rods, take the torque about and use body axes. On the -rod, , , and its slender-body force density is
On the -rod it is
Integrate and along both rods, using , and . A convenient dimensionally uniform statement of the complete right-angle two-rod resistance matrix is
In physical coordinates this means translation–translation entries scale as , the two translation–rotation blocks as , and rotation–rotation entries as . The planar block has inverse
This verifies the printed hydrodynamic mobility matrix with its third velocity component ; the TeX aid's is an OCR error.
Take laboratory vertical velocity positive upwards. The body axes are and . In quasistatic sedimentation the force and torque exerted on the fluid equal the gravitational resultants on the body:
The out-of-plane block is unforced, so its positive hydrodynamic resistance matrix gives . Substitution in the planar hydrodynamic mobility matrix gives
and
For , this ordinary differential equation has positive right side on , with a stable zero at . Uniqueness prevents crossing that equilibrium in finite time. For the initial angular velocity is negative, and the stable equilibrium reached from zero is . The heavier-end body turns clockwise through ; it does not settle at . More explicitly, with ,
where the continuous branch has . At , remains zero.
Transforming the translational velocity back to laboratory axes gives
For , eliminate time between and the angular velocity:
At either limiting orientation . Thus both cases have the same net horizontal displacement,
For the drift is monotonically rightwards. For it first moves left, reaching at , then reverses. The total horizontal path length in this second case is , whereas its net displacement is rightwards. At it falls vertically without rotation or drift; taking the infinite-time limit before is consequently singular.
For the requested sedimentation drift of a weighted two-rod body sketch, a full parametric trajectory follows by also integrating . Put and set the initial height to zero:
It tends to in either case while tends to . At both rods end pointing upwards from symmetrically; at they end pointing downwards symmetrically. The asymptotic downward speed is .
Figure 1.
Falling two-rod bodies: trajectory of O and successive orientations for lighter and heavier end masses
. Details.
The area element in plane polar coordinates is . Thus the axial moment of inertia is
For the removed material, the angular width is , and
Its moment of inertia is therefore , leaving
The torque equation gives constant angular acceleration, so the time to reach the prescribed angular speed from rest is
To find the centre of mass after removing material, let point along the bisector of the missing sector in the disc. The original disc has zero first mass moment about its centre. The missing sector has zero transverse first moment by reflection symmetry, while its component along is
because the radial integral is . The remaining first moment is . Dividing by the given mass gives the body-fixed centre of mass
It lies away from the missing sector. In the inertial frame, let be the moment the applied torque stops and let give the orientation of that sector's bisector. Then, with ,
The centre of mass has inward centripetal acceleration of magnitude . The required real force is the constraint reaction exerted by the fixed rod and its support. Its horizontal resultant is ; a zero applied axial torque does not imply a zero resultant force.
A Stokeslet is the flow produced by a point force. With , its tensor is . A separated pair of equal and opposite forces has no force monopole. Expanding their difference in the separation gives a directional derivative of this tensor. For an axial pair, choose the sign of the strength so that
The trace part of does not affect the flow because . The remaining symmetric force-dipole contribution is the stresslet, decaying as instead of the Stokeslet's . A force-free swimming cell has thrust balanced by drag, so this is typically its leading far field. With it is a pusher microswimmer: axial outflow and transverse inflow. It is distinct from the antisymmetric torque singularity, the rotlet.
The rotlet is the point-torque fundamental solution of Stokes flow. Its torque strength is an axial vector, and its circulating velocity decays as . A freely swimming cell with no external torque is torque-free. The motor applies opposite internal torques to its body and flagellar apparatus, so the net torque monopole satisfies
Individual body and flagellar torques need not vanish. A spatially separated pair can therefore leave a rotlet dipole even though there is no far-field rotlet monopole.
A flagellar bundle and the counterrotating body supply oppositely signed axial torques separated along the swimming direction. Their leading torque moments cancel, and the next term is a rotlet dipole, decaying as . For the ideal axisymmetric bacterium the torque vector is parallel or antiparallel to .
To fix the sign convention, define a signed dipole strength with units torque times length and set
Differentiating gives
More generally, differentiating gives ; the first term vanishes when . A derivative with respect to source position instead of observation position changes the definition of the signed moment. The physical handedness depends on which torque is ahead, so it cannot be fixed without that convention.
Take and the surface normal . Under reflection in the free surface, polar vectors transform by and an axial torque transforms by . A parallel torque therefore reverses sign, while the separation direction does not. The free-surface image of a rotlet dipole is a dipole of strength at .
The observation point at the cell is directly below the image, so and the image velocity vanishes. A symmetry proof of the vanishing normal drift is also useful: reflection in the vertical plane containing reverses the axial dipole moment, preserves the normal component of a polar velocity, and leaves the geometry unchanged. Linearity would make that same component change sign with , forcing it to be zero. Thus this singularity alone produces no attraction or repulsion.
Write relative to the image, so the cell is at . The image field is
Although its value at the cell is zero, its velocity gradient is not. In particular, the surface-induced yaw of a rotlet dipole has
A spherical torque-free body rotates with the local fluid angular velocity . Its swimming direction therefore turns in the surface plane and, at fixed height and speed, it traces a circle with radius . The sign of sets the sense of turning in this convention. An elongated swimmer also responds to strain; its rotation coefficient depends on its shape and need not equal one half of the vorticity. When the stresslet is included, its changing height produces a changing turning rate rather than an exactly fixed-radius circle.
In plane polar coordinates, use and . Their derivatives are and . Differentiating gives the velocity and acceleration in polar coordinates:
Both the electrostatic inverse-square force and the drag point radially, so the torque about the origin is zero even though the force depends on radial velocity. The vector angular momentum is constant. For , every position lies in the fixed plane perpendicular to it; if , the trajectory is radial and still lies in a plane. In the nonzero case the transverse equation is , giving
The signed depends on the plane orientation. The stipulated ratio requires .
Set and use primes for differentiation with respect to . Then , and . The radial equation is , so
This damped Binet equation has the general solution, for ,
It is used on the physical interval where . For either sign of , introduce the forward angular distance ; then the exponential is . Thus damping acts forward in time for both orientations, not just when .
For unit mass, the kinetic energy is and the electrostatic potential energy is . Therefore
Using the damped Binet equation,
and multiplication by gives
This is also the drag force times the radial speed. Energy is nonincreasing in time, strictly decreasing while radial motion occurs; a circular trajectory already has constant energy. The sign of alone would be misleading for negative .
To justify circularization under radial inverse-square drag, suppose the forward trajectory remains bounded, . Since and the effective radial potential energy tends to as , the radius is also bounded away from zero. Velocity then stays bounded, so the solution continues for all forward time without collision. Moreover , so . The decaying general solution gives and . Consequently
The tangential motion remains, so the limiting orbit is circular. The convergence is asymptotic; boundedness is needed because a physical solution could otherwise reach and escape rather than complete indefinitely many turns.
Figure 1.
Bounded inverse-square orbit with radial drag approaching a circular orbit, with nonincreasing energy converging to the circular-orbit value
. Details.
The example uses , and , which stays positive. Radial oscillations decay while angular momentum stays fixed.
The work done by a force is . By the work-energy theorem, this has the same physical dimension as energy. Thus
Although torque and energy have the same physical dimension, they represent different physical quantities.
The torque about an origin is . A cross product multiplies the dimensions of its factors, so torque has the physical dimension of length times force:
Let be the rate-of-strain tensor and the Newtonian fluid stress tensor. The viscous dissipation is . The Minimum-dissipation theorem for Stokes flow compares the Stokes flow with every sufficiently regular incompressible flow in the same domain having the same prescribed boundary velocity, with no body force or with a conservative body force absorbed into the fluid pressure. A trial field need not satisfy the Stokes flow equations. Write it as , with and on the boundary. Integration by parts, the symmetry of the Newtonian fluid stress tensor, and give
Consequently the Stokes flow minimizes dissipation:
Equality requires a rigid body motion of , which the prescribed boundary eliminates. Extending the flow inside the inserted particle as its rigid body velocity produces an admissible comparison field with zero internal rate-of-strain tensor; hence the extra dissipation due to a rigid inclusion is nonnegative.
Here and below on points into the particle, so the traction represents force exerted by the particle on the fluid. Apply the Lorentz reciprocal theorem for Stokes flow in the fluid region to and the restriction of . The equal outer boundary velocities yield
The boundary-work formula for viscous dissipation therefore gives . The last integral is zero: is symmetric and divergence-free throughout the particle's original volume, so its total force and torque there vanish, and on is a rigid body velocity. This also allows the sign of this zero-work term to be reversed, giving exactly
With the particle's centre as origin, define , and the particle stresslet tensor . Contracting the linear background velocity with the traction gives
The background rate-of-strain tensor is symmetric and trace-free; the trace of this unprojected particle stresslet tensor does not affect the contraction.
For the straight-rod resistance in a linear flow, write , , , and , . The slender-body force density becomes . The integrals of and are and , respectively, so
For a force-free, torque-free rod, and the perpendicular component of is . Axial spin is not determined by this leading, zero-thickness slender-body theory; it has no effect on . Put . The vector identity gives
The force-free straight-rod orientation equation combines the background rotation with the part of strain that turns the rod; removing preserves its unit length. A rigid body cannot undergo the axial extension or compression imposed by , so opposite axial forces resist that deformation. No leading slender-body force density is needed when , even though the rod may rotate. Its particle stresslet tensor and viscous dissipation are
In the simple shear flow, , and . Thus the rod excess dissipation in shear is
The maxima at correspond to strongest axial extension and compression. The zeros at correspond to zero axial strain: a rod aligned with the velocity or its gradient needs no leading force at that instant. For , with the continuous branch and . Reversing the shear flow reverses the traversal. Substitution gives
The tails make the total finite; the instantaneous zero at lies between two maxima.
Figure 1.
Rod excess dissipation versus orientation and time in simple shear
. Details.
For a dilute rod suspension, the added bulk stress is the number density times the orientation average of the particle stresslet tensor. In this ideal infinitely slender, non-interacting model, rods approach alignment with the shear flow and their excess viscous dissipation decays. A real finite-aspect-ratio rod continues to tumble; rotational diffusion and interactions also maintain a spread of orientations. One therefore expects increased effective viscosity, with alignment offering a mechanism for reduced excess viscosity at strong shear flow. This is a qualitative expectation, not a claim that a finite rod suspension has zero steady excess stress.
A central force has no component in the angular direction. The angular component of the acceleration in polar coordinates therefore gives , or
For unit mass, is the signed angular momentum perpendicular to the orbital plane, so its magnitude is conserved. Equivalently, the torque vanishes, which also fixes that plane.
The given potential energy is , whose radial force is : positive is repulsive and negative attractive. The kinetic energy in polar coordinates is , so conservation of energy gives
For and , the effective potential is positive, strictly decreasing from to , and has no stationary point. For , it still tends to at zero, crosses zero at , and has its unique minimum at
It then approaches zero from below. The minimum corresponds to a stable circular orbit. If , the centrifugal barrier disappears; the attractive effective potential is simply and has no minimum.
Figure 1. . Effective potentials with unit angular momentum and k equal to plus or minus one. The attractive minimum and zero are marked. Details.
Linearity of Stokes flow and rotational symmetry, including reflection in mathematics invariance of the spherical geometry, determine the possible rigid motions before any calculation. Translation is a polar vector; its linear dependence on a single vector must be . A traceless second-rank tensor cannot produce a polar vector by an isotropic linear map: tensor contraction with the identity matrix vanishes and tensor contraction with the totally antisymmetric tensor vanishes because is a symmetric second-rank tensor. Angular velocity is an axial vector. Neither nor a symmetric can produce one by an isotropic linear map. Products such as are excluded by Linearity of Stokes flow. Thus .
Use the Unscaled Papkovich–Neuber representation, with harmonic functions and :
Indeed and because each potential is a harmonic function. Put and . The decaying harmonic functions with the necessary angular dependence are , and . The last is a harmonic function precisely because . A Stokeslet is excluded by the force-free condition, and a rotlet by the torque-free condition. Try
The resulting Stokes flow is
At , the coefficient of fixes ; the remaining constant vector gives . In the mode, matching gives and . Therefore the complete two-mode tensorial squirmer flow is
The boundary condition is satisfied in the laboratory frame, so the Stokes flow tends to zero at infinity. The potential dipole in the mode gives an irrotational flow and decays as ; the leading mode is a stresslet, decaying as . Neither carries a net force or torque. Direct surface integral averaging with the surface slip velocity formula gives the same translation, providing an independent check. Uniqueness of Stokes flow then identifies this decaying solution.
Let , , and . Applied forces and couples below are forces and torques on the solid; by force balance their values are also the strengths exerted by that solid on the fluid. This fixes the signs in Faxén's first law and Faxén's rotational law. To hold the passive sphere fixed, set its translation and angular velocity to zero in those laws. The incident two-mode tensorial squirmer flow gives
Only the stresslet part has vorticity:
Consequently, for fixed as ,
The leading force is the radial stresslet force. Its next correction, , comes from the incident potential dipole. The next correction, , contains both the swimmer's field and the Laplacian term in Faxén's first law. If the relevant coefficient vanishes, these next terms must be retained instead of calling the vanished term a nonzero leading approximation. Further exchanges in the method of reflections for Stokes flow are smaller still.
The passive sphere reflects primarily a Stokeslet with strength . At the swimmer, its velocity is . The unchanged surface slip velocity adds the free swimming velocity to the incident-flow contribution in Faxén's first law. Thus
The leading change is ; its next correction is the displayed term. Finite-radius Faxén's first law corrections, the passive sphere's reflected stresslet, and its rotlet contribute at order to translation.
For a Stokeslet at the origin,
The curl of the first term is ; that of the second is also , before multiplying by . Hence . At the swimmer use displacement . The leading force is parallel to , so its Stokeslet has zero vorticity there. This eliminates the putative rotation. The potential dipole itself has no vorticity, but the holding force it induces is not radial. Applying Faxén's rotational law to its reflected Stokeslet yields
The passive sphere's rotlet and reflected stresslet can affect that last order, so they cannot restore the larger missing rotation. When , the boxed coefficient is zero and the higher-order terms determine any rotation.
The exact gap between the plane and the circle is
In the narrow region relevant to lubrication theory,
so changes occur over the streamwise scale ; below use .
Choose the positive direction to be the direction of the cylinder surface velocity in the gap, and write for the dynamic viscosity. The lubrication velocity profile and volume flux per unit axial length are
Since is constant and the pressure returns to the same ambient value as , . Therefore
Using and the supplied integrals gives
in the direction of the cylinder surface motion.
The shear stress exerted by the fluid on the cylinder is opposite to
Eliminating and inserting gives
where the sign is relative to . Since
the resisting torque per unit axial length is
Finally, the ratio of streamwise fluid inertia to transverse viscous acceleration is of order
The stated restriction makes this lubrication-scale Reynolds number small, justifying neglect of inertia.
Reflection in preserves the prescribed translational velocity and axial angular velocity. A force transforms as a polar vector, whereas a torque transforms as an axial vector; consequently . Reflection in reverses both imposed motions but preserves the normal force component. The linearity of Stokes flow then gives . Thus only and can be nonzero.
There is a sign inconsistency in the printed question. In right-handed coordinates, gives a rotational velocity at the sphere's lowest point. The printed shear and force formulas instead use the opposite rotational sense. Below, let be the right-handed component along ; the paper's displayed formulas are recovered by setting .
In the translating frame, the parabolic gap and leading boundary velocities are
The no-slip boundary condition and lubrication theory give
The gap is stationary in this frame, so . The Reynolds lubrication equation is therefore
Since and ,
Differentiating the velocity profile gives the leading shear stresses
The first expression becomes the printed formula after .
For the logarithmic lubrication resistance of a sphere near a wall, write . The logarithmic region is , where . Consequently
These follow from and , with a fixed small outer cutoff. The general logarithmic radial numerator is over ; the numerator in the printed integration hint appears to have a typographical error.
The force exerted on the fluid through the upper gap boundary includes pressure acting on its slope:
The pressure cancels the term, giving
Pressure exerts no torque about the centre of a sphere because its traction is radial. To logarithmic order, the shear has lever arm , so
The other components vanish by parity: involves an integral of the term, and has an integrand odd in . The combined hydrodynamic resistance matrix is
Its equal off-diagonal coefficients are required by the Lorentz reciprocal theorem for Stokes flow. It is a positive-definite matrix, as required by viscous dissipation.
In the rotational convention of the printed force formula, set and measure the scalar couple along , so . Then
For sedimentation under the buoyancy-adjusted weight , a uniform sphere is torque-free. Thus , and the force balance gives
The rotational scalar in the paper's displayed-force convention is . The sphere rolls in the right-handed sense but still slips: its lowest point has laboratory velocity . The signs and coefficients of the right-handed resistance agree with the rigid-wall terms of Bertin et al., equations (4.4)–(4.5), after reversing the forces and torques there from fluid-on-sphere to sphere-on-fluid.
Assume nonrelativistic pressureless matter, an initial irrotational vector field of growing-mode linear cosmological density perturbations, a homogeneous expanding background, and no shell crossing. All gradients below refer to initial comoving coordinates. Let , with , and normalize the linear growth factor by . The paper calls a growth rate, but it is the dimensionless growth factor; is its time derivative.
Writing for the actual position at , the Zeldovich approximation is, to first order,
This explicitly gives . The usual notation instead uses the uniform reference Lagrangian coordinate , with . The two labels can be interchanged inside a first-order displacement, but not in the unperturbed position without the initial displacement correction.
To determine , mass conservation between the initial and current positions gives
Demanding gives . The irrotational vector field assumption makes a gradient; the initial cosmological Poisson equation is . With the same boundary conditions for these potential equations, and after removing an irrelevant uniform translation,
The evolution of follows from the linearized peculiar-motion equation . Since cosmological Poisson equation gives to this order, substitution yields the linear growth equation
Thus the approximation extrapolates the linear growing displacement along a fixed initial direction, even as its density mapping becomes nonlinear.
The early spin of a dark matter halo comes from an external gravitational torque on its nonspherical initial mass region. A uniform external acceleration moves its centre of mass without spinning it; the spatially varying tidal tensor exerts different forces on different parts. The tidal torque theory requires misalignment of the region's shape and the surrounding tidal field. A local irrotational vector field of velocity does not imply zero integrated angular momentum for a nonspherical region.
Put and use the physical peculiar velocity . The physical lever arm is , while a leading-order mass element is . Substituting the velocity formula into the supplied definition of angular momentum about the centre of mass gives
Terms from the perturbed mass measure are higher order. Subtracting the barycentre's velocity also changes nothing because at this order.
Apply the divergence theorem componentwise:
The antisymmetry of the Levi-Civita symbol kills the last term. Consequently, for the ordinary oriented comoving surface element ,
The original PDF prints a different coefficient, . That coefficient does not follow from its own mass measure and velocity equation and has the wrong dimensions for total angular momentum. The corrected coefficient above also gives the time dependence consistent with the paper's later tensor expression; this is a source typo, not a TeX transcription issue.
For a spherical centered on its barycentre, the outward normal is parallel to , so pointwise. Hence
For an equipotential surface, on , and
Therefore
The second conclusion holds for any boundary shape at this order, not just a sphere.
To extract the leading tidal torque, expand the initial peculiar gravitational potential about the barycentre using its Taylor series:
The constant has no force; has zero integrated torque because the first mass moment vanishes. With the mass second-moment tensor
we obtain
The second equality swaps the indices and uses the symmetry of both tensors. Define the initial acceleration tidal tensor by
Then the formula in the question has exactly the stated sign:
If one defines as the positive Hessian matrix of instead, the displayed contraction has a plus sign. Defining the convention is essential. Also, the paper's is a mass second-moment tensor; the mechanical inertia tensor is .
Only the anisotropic parts contribute: a multiple of the identity produces zero contraction with the Levi-Civita symbol. In axes where , for example,
Thus a spherical region or tensors sharing principal axes have zero leading torque; unequal principal moments together with off-diagonal tidal components create spin. The Taylor series truncation assumes that higher spatial derivatives of the tidal field are sufficiently small across the region.
In an Einstein-de Sitter universe, , , and . The initial and are time independent, so
This is early-time growth for fixed initial matter, before collapse invalidates the extrapolation. It does not predict indefinite linear spin growth for a virialized halo.
Two reasons for only approximate agreement with simulations are that nonlinear collapse and shell crossing change the trajectories and the tidal field, invalidating the first-order displacement and fixed leading tidal tensor; and that real halos undergo dark-matter halo mergers, anisotropic accretion, and exchange of material and angular momentum, so the halo identified at a later time need not be the same isolated collection of initial particles. These processes can change both the magnitude and the direction of the spin.
Let the heavier block move downward, so no slip gives linear acceleration . Newton's equations and the pulley torque equation are
Eliminating the tensions gives the first-order equation
With , its solution is
For a thin slice of the solid of revolution, and its axial moment of inertia is . Consequently
The torque about the origin is
Since , the angular momentum is conserved. The force is the negative gradient of the inverse-square potential
so the conserved energy is
Directly, .
Let be the center of mass and the uniform gravitational acceleration. The gravitational torque about is
Choose body-fixed principal axes of inertia. The inertial derivative of the angular momentum is
For torque-free motion and , giving the Euler equations for a torque-free rigid body
For a symmetric top, let and let be the axial moment. Then is constant and
Thus is constant and the transverse angular-velocity vector rotates uniformly about the body symmetry axis. Its rate is ; it precesses in the positive axial sense when and in the opposite sense when this product is negative.
The work law means that friction exerts a constant opposing torque of magnitude . Until the cone stops,
Its initial angular speed is , and uniform angular deceleration gives
Therefore