If the Poincare inequality with a boundary trace failed, after normalization there would be with
As in part 1(c)(i), a subsequence converges strongly in and weakly in to a constant function . The Sobolev trace theorem is a bounded linear map, so the traces converge weakly while their norms tend to zero; hence the trace of is zero. A constant with zero trace is zero, contradicting . Consequently
Suppose the claimed Poincare-Wirtinger inequality were false. There would be such that, after setting
we have , , and . The sequence is bounded in , so part 1(b)(ii) supplies a subsequence converging strongly in and weakly in to some .
The weak gradient of is zero. Because is connected, is a constant function; its mean is zero, so . Strong convergence would then give , contradicting . Therefore
For , the function is differentiable at if there is a linear map such that
The linear map is unique and is the Fréchet derivative . The function is continuously differentiable at if it is differentiable on a neighbourhood of and the map , with values in the space of linear maps equipped with the operator norm, is continuous at .
If is linear, then
Consequently at every . The derivative is a constant function of , hence is continuous, so every linear map is continuously differentiable everywhere.
The mean value inequality says that if the line segment lies in and
then
To prove it, put . The claim is immediate if . Otherwise set and apply the one-dimensional mean value theorem to the real-valued function
For some , the chain rule gives
as required.
Now suppose that is open and connected and that for every . Every point has an open ball contained in . The mean value inequality with shows that is constant on each such ball, so is locally constant. Fix . The level set
is nonempty and open in ; its complement is also open because is locally constant. Since is connected, . This proves the zero derivative on a connected open set result: is constant.
The inverse function theorem states that if is continuously differentiable, , and is an invertible linear map, then there are open neighbourhoods of and of such that is a bijection whose inverse is continuously differentiable.
For the curve in the question, define the continuously differentiable function
Then
The implicit function theorem, which follows from the inverse function theorem applied to , therefore gives an open interval containing , an open neighbourhood of , and a continuously differentiable, hence continuous, function such that
Fix . The property defining depends only on the partial function computed, so it is an index set. It is nontrivial: an index of the nowhere-defined function is outside it, whereas an index of the total constant function has infinite domain and range , and hence lies in it. The Rice theorem now shows that this infinite-domain range-restriction index set is not computable.
No. Take the constant function , which has . The claimed inequality becomes , false whenever .
Testing the weak formulation with the constant function proves the necessary compatibility condition
Assume first that is connected and this condition holds. On the mean-zero Sobolev space
use the norm . To prove the needed Poincare-Wirtinger inequality, suppose it failed. There would be with and . The Rellich-Kondrachov compactness theorem gives a subsequence converging strongly in and weakly in to a function . Its weak derivative vanishes, so connectedness makes constant; its zero mean makes it zero. This contradicts . Hence is an equivalent Hilbert space norm on .
Define
Boundedness of makes a bounded bilinear form, while uniform ellipticity gives
so it is a coercive bilinear form. The Cauchy-Schwarz inequality and the Poincare-Wirtinger inequality make a bounded linear functional. The Lax-Milgram theorem supplies a unique satisfying for every mean-zero . For arbitrary , subtract its mean; the omitted constant contributes zero on both sides because and . Thus solves the original problem.
If two solutions exist, their difference satisfies , so uniform ellipticity gives . It is therefore constant on . The solution is unique up to an additive constant, and its mean-zero representative is unique. If is disconnected, the precise condition is on every connected component , and one independent additive constant remains on each component.
Suppose the claimed Poincare inequality with a partial Dirichlet boundary fails. There are with
After the normalization ,
Thus is bounded in the Sobolev space . The Rellich-Kondrashov compactness theorem and the corresponding compact embedding for a bounded domain give a subsequence that converges strongly in and weakly in to some . The Sobolev space with a partial Dirichlet condition is a closed vector subspace, hence weakly closed, so . Moreover , and connectedness of makes a constant function. Its trace vanishes on the positive-measure set , so that constant is zero. This contradicts
Therefore some satisfies
Since the reverse bound is immediate,
The gradient seminorm is a norm on because equality to zero would make a constant whose trace on is zero.
True. The first of Green's identities and the Robin boundary condition give
Both integrands are nonnegative, so in and on the boundary. By path connectedness, is a constant function, and its boundary value makes that constant zero. Therefore .
False. The constant function is a harmonic function and has zero normal derivative on every smooth boundary, but it is nonzero in .
In fact, the first of Green's identities gives
Hence ; path connectedness makes constant throughout . Thus this homogeneous Neumann boundary condition determines a harmonic function only up to an additive constant.
The Fourier cosine series on is
It is the Fourier series of the even extension to , repeated with period . The Fourier sine series is
It comes from the odd extension and its -periodic extension. These Fourier coefficient formulas follow by Fourier orthogonality, since every nonconstant sine or cosine has squared integral on , while the constant function has squared integral .
For a nonzero integer , direct integration gives
whereas . The product-to-sum formulas
therefore establish Fourier orthogonality: for positive integers ,
Here is the Kronecker delta. In particular the constant function is orthogonal to every nonconstant sine and cosine in this system. Integrating the given Fourier series, then multiplying it by or and integrating, isolates its Fourier coefficients. Using the permitted interchange of the sum and integral gives
If is an even function, then is an odd function, while is an even function. Thus
The Fourier series consequently reduces to a Fourier cosine series.
A maximum or minimum can occur at an endpoint. The rule that a derivative vanishes at an extremum requires an interior extremum and differentiability there. The hypotheses give no two-sided derivative at the endpoints, and even an existing one-sided derivative need not vanish there.
For example, on has at and at , but at every interior point; its endpoint one-sided derivatives are also one. Its graph meets both horizontal bounding lines without being tangent to either. Thus the claimed conclusion about two zeros of the derivative fails.
There is a second logical issue: the argument never establishes two distinct extremizing points. For a constant function, the maximum and minimum coincide and may be represented by the same point. The constant function does have many stationary points, but that needs its own argument; it does not follow from counting the same selected point twice. In Rolle's theorem, equal endpoint values ensure an interior extremum when the function is nonconstant, which is the missing mechanism here.
For the log-cosh energy on a Sobolev space, the elementary inequalities follow by integrating from zero. Thus
so the energy is well-defined on . For a fixed , its proposed derivative is linear in the direction and bounded, because gives
To justify differentiation, use . Taylor's integral remainder pointwise, combined with the exact quadratic gradient expansion, gives
Every term is integrable by the displayed bounds. The remainder is quadratic in the norm, so the functional is even Fréchet differentiable, and in particular Gâteaux differentiable with the required derivative. This also proves that belongs to the stated dual space.
For ,
Both terms are nonnegative, and the integrand in the second is strictly positive wherever , since is strictly increasing. Distinct Sobolev elements differ on a set of positive measure, so the expression is positive. Hence is strictly monotone.
This gives strict monotonicity without coercivity on H1: it is not coercive on . For constant functions with , the norm is and
which is finite. In contrast it is coercive on : if , then
Dividing by the norm proves growth to infinity. On this smaller space the operator is understood by restricting its dual action to zero-trace test functions. Removing the constant directions by the boundary condition is what restores coercivity.
Use the nonpolynomial function on . Its exact integral is
because the sine is an odd function.
For every uniform partition of an interval with panels, the quadrature nodes satisfy . Their composite trapezoidal rule quadrature weights agree, so the two sampled sine values cancel. If there is a node at zero its sine value is already zero. The constant term is integrated exactly, giving
This is symmetric trapezoidal exactness for odd functions, applied after adding a constant function so that the resulting definite integral is nonzero. It is exactness for this particular integrand, rather than a claim that every nonpolynomial function is integrated exactly.
Let be the inclusion map and the retraction. Since is contractible, choose a contraction of a topological space
The function composition
is a continuous map. Its endpoints satisfy
Consequently is a homotopy from the identity map of to a constant function. This proves
The contracting point of need not belong to : applying the retraction sends it to the contracting point of . This is the retract of a contractible space principle.
Yes. Take , the circle, and . The constant function is a continuous map and satisfies , so is a retract of .
However, their fundamental groups are
A homotopy equivalence between path-connected spaces induces a group isomorphism of their fundamental groups, allowing the usual change of base point. The infinite cyclic group is not the trivial group. Therefore a retract need not have the homotopy type of its ambient space.
With local path connectedness, the intended conclusion holds. Choose a base point and the standard covering map
The fundamental group of the circle is . Since the image of a finite group under a group homomorphism is finite and has no nontrivial finite subgroups,
is trivial. If is also locally path-connected, the lifting criterion for a covering space supplies a continuous map with , because . The homotopy
runs from to the constant function . This proves the claimed null-homotopy under that additional hypothesis, in particular for CW complexes and the topological graphs considered later in the paper.
For arbitrary path-connected spaces, the printed assertion is false. Here is an explicit Warsaw circle counterexample, including the obstruction that the usual lifting argument misses. In the Euclidean plane take
Join to by the polygonal arc passing successively through , and put with its subspace topology. The arc meets only at . The topologist's sine curve has two path components, but the added arc joins them, making path-connected.
Every loop in is contained in
for some . To justify the assertion, a path cannot reach along the oscillating tail: the intermediate value theorem for its -coordinate would force its -coordinate to attain both and arbitrarily close to the supposed arrival time, contradicting continuity. The only alternative route from the tail to uses and the joining arc. If a loop visited tail points with , a convergent subsequence of their parameter values would approach a time at which the loop lies in . On a sufficiently small parameter interval around that time its image avoids . That would give a forbidden path from into the tail without passing through . Thus those tail coordinates have a positive lower bound. The space is a finite tree, in fact a single arc, so every such loop contracts. Consequently
Now define a continuous map to be on , and to make one full turn on : for a parametrization from to , set . The pieces and are closed in , and the formulas agree at , so the pasting lemma for closed subspaces proves continuity.
There is no continuous lift . Any such lift is integer-valued on , so it is constant on each of the connected spaces . Since accumulates on , continuity forces those two constants to be the same. But along a lift of has the form , giving values at and differing by , a contradiction. Finally, if had a null-homotopy, the homotopy lifting theorem for a covering map, starting with a lift of the final constant function and reversing time, would produce a continuous lift of . This theorem needs no local path connectedness of the parameter space. Hence is not null-homotopic, although has finite, indeed trivial, fundamental group.
The native PDF explicitly assumes only path connectedness here. The missing local path connectedness cannot be inferred from the finiteness of the fundamental group.
Fix . For a continuous function , every coordinate slice is continuous, because the maps and into the product topology are continuous. Their target is Hausdorff. Part (a)(i) gives
Therefore every such is a constant function. This is the two-factor case of continuous maps from products of cofinite spaces to Hausdorff spaces are constant.
The second coordinate projection is continuous and nonconstant. If a homeomorphism existed, would be a nonconstant continuous function, contradicting the preceding conclusion. Hence
For the half-plane, put as a set, so . Its two ambient topologies give different answers:
In , if were closed, its inverse image under the continuous map would be closed in . That inverse image is , which is neither a finite set nor all of , so it is not closed in the cofinite topology. Thus is not closed.
To establish compactness, note that the subspace topology on any subset of a topological space with the cofinite topology is again cofinite. An open cover of a nonempty such has a nonempty member omitting at most finitely many points; finitely many more members cover those points. Hence every subset of a cofinite space is compact. In particular both and with its cofinite subspace topology are compact. The subspace topology on is their product topology, as one checks by tracing basis rectangles. The product of two compact spaces is compact, so is compact here.
For clarity, the finite-product compactness result needs no Hausdorff condition. Given an open cover of , cover each point by a basis rectangle lying in one covering member. For fixed , use compactness of to select finitely many rectangles whose second factors cover , and intersect their first factors to get an open neighbourhood of . Those finitely many original members cover . Finally finitely many cover , producing a finite subcover of .
In , the second coordinate projection has
Since the ray is closed in the usual real line, is closed. It is not compact: its image under a continuous map under is , which is not compact. For an explicit obstruction, the open intervals , , cover this ray but have no finite subcover.
Finally consider the diagonal in . Define
This is a bijection. The identity function from the usual real line to is continuous: each nonempty cofinite open set is the complement of a finite set, and finite sets are closed in the usual real line. Both coordinates of are therefore continuous, so is continuous for the product topology and the subspace topology of . Its inverse is the restricted second coordinate projection, which is continuous. Therefore
For the second conclusion, is compact whereas is not compact; homeomorphisms preserve compactness. The diagonal in a product with cofinite and Euclidean topologies thus inherits the usual topology, despite one cofinite factor.
Include zero when forming this set, even though a period of a function is normally required to be nonzero. For , is a subgroup of the additive group of the real numbers: composing two preserving shifts adds them, and reversing a preserving shift negates it. A constant function has period group . A nonconstant continuous real-valued function that is periodic has period group , where is its fundamental period.
Periodic function Created 2026-09-24 Updated 2026-10-14
A periodic function repeats exactly after a nonzero shift of its input. For , a positive period of a function satisfies
One interval of length therefore determines the whole function. For another domain of a function , a period must also preserve the domain, ; equality only where two domains happen to overlap is weaker. Periodicity is an exact translation of a function symmetry, rather than merely two similar-looking pieces of its graph.
The sine has fundamental period one. The function repeats after half a unit: the sine changes sign under that shift, but squaring removes the sign. The mixed function again has fundamental period one. All positive integer multiples of a period are periods, so specifying one period need not identify the shortest repetition.
Figure 1.
Mixed harmonics, a squared sine, and a constant have different sets of periods
. Details.
If the input is time and is the fundamental period, the frequency is and the angular frequency is . Repetition lets a Fourier series describe a cycle using sines and cosines; the period average separates the reference level from the oscillating terms. Strang develops this representation and its Fourier coefficients in §4.1 of Computational Science and Engineering by Gilbert Strang.[ref]
This connection grew out of a physical problem. In his 1822 book Théorie analytique de la chaleur by Joseph Fourier, Joseph Fourier used periodic functions to extend profiles beyond their initial interval while treating heat conduction. Chapter III, §§233–234 combines even functions and odd functions into sine–cosine expansions and rescales their period.[ref] A modern Fourier series interpretation still requires the appropriate convergence conditions.
A constant function has every real shift as a period and no fundamental period. Without continuity, even a nonconstant periodic function can lack a smallest positive period; periodic function without a least positive period gives a concrete example. The period group of a function organizes all these possibilities.