Write , , and denote the slow density and velocity field amplitudes by and . Acting on the rapid phase, gives , where . Spatial differentiation gives , while derivatives of the amplitudes and the mean shear flow are . The leading continuity equation and linearized Euler equations therefore become
Eliminating on the nonzero acoustic branch gives the acoustic eikonal equation in a shear flow:
The mean-shear term is small here because ; retaining advection does not require retaining that gradient in the leading phase equation. The positive intrinsic-frequency acoustic dispersion relation is , with group velocity .
In a stationary wall boundary layer, horizontal homogeneity preserves and along a Hamiltonian ray-tracing equations trajectory. For a two-dimensional ray,
Suppose increases from zero at the wall to a positive free-stream value. For a downstream-directed wave normal, , increasing decreases and . The wave normal bends towards the wall, and the ray becomes more nearly parallel to it. If reaches , then : the ray turns and returns towards the wall rather than reaching the free stream. With launch angle above the wall and free-stream Mach number , the escape condition is
For upstream-directed wave normals, , and increase through the layer; there is no such downstream turning barrier on this branch. A wavefront normal is parallel to , while the energy ray follows the group velocity: advection makes their directions different. In particular, a wall-normal wave normal with can still have a ray drifting downstream. The ordinary WKB method needs a local turning-point continuation at ; the ray sketch depicts that qualitative continuation.
Figure 1.
Acoustic energy rays through a wall shear layer, showing downstream escape, downstream turning and downstream drift of a wall-normal wave normal
. Details.
The initial Fourier transform is . Initial rest gives zero time derivative, so each wave mode evolves by . Fourier inversion therefore gives
On , the product of cosines produces phases with prefactor . Only the minus phase has a stationary point:
Expanding quadratically there and evaluating the Gaussian oscillatory integral gives the stationary-phase factor and phase shift . The other phase has no stationary point. Using makes both endpoint phases smooth with nonzero endpoint derivative and amplitude vanishing at zero, so endpoint contributions are smaller. Thus
The selected wavenumber has group velocity , explaining why it determines the long-time signal on this ray.
The free surface is a material surface. For , the material derivative vanishes on . Since the velocity is , this gives the exact kinematic boundary condition for a free-surface graph
At the surface the pressure equals the constant atmospheric pressure. Absorbing that constant into the time-dependent potential gauge in Unsteady Bernoulli equation yields the exact dynamic boundary condition for an inviscid interface
There is no surface-tension term in this model.
Write and linearize in the small perturbation and the surface displacement. The base value is , and evaluation at the displaced surface can be replaced by evaluation at zero to first order. Thus
Incompressibility requires Laplace's equation . For , the complex perturbation satisfies this equation and decays with depth. Put and . The linear boundary conditions become
They are consistent precisely when
Consequently the two laboratory phase velocities of a deep-water gravity wave are
If propagation of a wave packet is intended, its group velocities are instead .
For , put . The dispersion relation permits . On the positive-frequency branch, for ,
The radiation condition therefore selects , since energy must travel into the fluid. Substitution into the internal-wave polarization relations gives the complex fields
The physical fields are their real parts; . The vertical component of group velocity is negative, so this positive- plane internal gravity wave carries energy down and right, although its phase propagates in a different direction.
In the Boussinesq approximation, density departures from a constant reference density are small enough to neglect in inertia and mass continuity, but their gravitational effect is retained. Write the total buoyancy acceleration as , choose a hydrostatic background , and set . Thus is the buoyancy perturbation, positive for a parcel lighter than the background at its present height. The squared buoyancy frequency is
Stable stratification has . A small vertical displacement of a parcel conserving its buoyancy gives , explaining the restoring acceleration and the name of .
Let be pressure with the background hydrostatic pressure removed, , and the material derivative. The ideal, nonrotating Boussinesq equations are
The last equation is equivalent to . There is neither viscosity nor buoyancy diffusion. The reference density occurs in the pressure normalization, while the small density anomaly occurs only through buoyancy.
For the two-dimensional disturbance, linearization about rest gives
A plane internal gravity wave proportional to therefore satisfies
These internal-wave polarization relations and the dispersion relation determine the individual responses in parts i and ii. A radiating response has no incoming internal gravity wave from ; an evanescent response is bounded there. The harmonic solutions describe the response after excluding arbitrary initial transients.
For the localized oscillatory boundary, define and . Both signs of vertical wavenumber must radiate into . Their horizontal wavenumber is , so the positive- contribution involves and the negative- contribution involves . Consequently the complex horizontal velocity is
Taking its real part proves
The positive- internal-wave polarization has and the negative- one has . Hence
In particular, , so the boundary condition is recovered exactly. This is two-beam radiation from a localized oscillating boundary.
Take a smooth localized profile, for example . Its effective support is a neighbourhood of width a few ; increasing that neighbourhood makes the tails arbitrarily small. The boundary displacement is to first order, so at it is flat and moving at maximum speed. At that instant,
There are two narrow oblique beams centered on and . Away from their overlap, the velocity is parallel to the relevant beam, in the directions and . The figure uses and measures velocities in units of .
Figure 1.
Velocity in two internal-wave beams when the oscillating boundary is flat and moving fastest
. Details.
At other phases the terms contribute. For the positive-frequency convention above, is the Hilbert transform of ; it generally has longer tails than . Thus even when the boundary is nearly stationary, the interior need not be stationary or confined to the bright cores shown here. Half a period later all velocities reverse. The beam directions remain the same, but the instantaneous velocity profile and its quadrature component change.
A short pulse has a broad frequency spectrum. Frequencies below produce outgoing internal gravity wave packets with frequency-dependent ray slopes ; frequencies above contribute an evanescent near-boundary response. Moreover the group velocity depends on wavelength as well as direction. The radiated packet therefore spreads into a dispersive fan or wake, with different frequencies traveling at different angles and different scales separating along those directions. After the forcing ends the propagating packet travels away, rather than maintaining the two permanently driven monochromatic beams.
Use the streamfunction convention , , and take . With , the material derivative is . This convention differs from the horizontal quasi-geostrophic streamfunction convention used below. The nonlinear Boussinesq equations are
The component of vorticity is . Differentiate the first momentum equation in and subtract the derivative of the second. The pressure terms cancel; the derivatives of the advecting velocity cancel by . Thus , or
Conservation of total buoyancy, with background gradient , gives
Both equations retain the nonlinear advection terms.
Write , with , and take the background buoyancy anomaly to be zero. The linear equations for are
For a normal mode , the second equation gives . Substitute this into the first to obtain the Taylor–Goldstein equation
Here and the calculation is initially away from critical levels . The first term is the restoring effect of stable buoyancy on vertically displaced parcels. The second comes from advection of the background vorticity gradient : a displacement creates a vorticity anomaly, whose induced velocity acts back on the displacement. This is the shear-flow counterpart of a Rossby wave restoring mechanism; its sign can also permit instability, so it is not invariably stabilizing.
Rigid boundaries imply , hence . For a real, regular normal mode, multiply the Taylor–Goldstein equation by , integrate, and integrate its second derivative by parts. The endpoint term vanishes, leaving
For a smooth real dispersion branch, differentiate this identity with respect to . The stated stationarity of removes the term involving , so . Direct differentiation at fixed gives
Since the frequency is , the group velocity is , and therefore
This is variational group velocity of a Taylor-Goldstein mode. Singular critical levels or a vanishing denominator require separate limiting analysis; no stationarity proof is needed here.
For the sinusoidal profiles, choose . In the interior,
The profile ratios extend to the endpoints in this reduced equation. Thus always gives a nonzero real , with . For this normal mode,
The denominator in the group velocity expression is . It follows that
Although vanishes at the endpoints, this weighted integral is finite; the vanishing of supplies the required cancellation. The formula is the limiting derivative approached from the regular real branch with , before any interior critical level is encountered.
If instead and are constant, still take . The same vertical eigenfunctions satisfy the Taylor–Goldstein equation, now with
There is no value of guaranteed to give real for arbitrary positive parameters: if , all these squared wavenumbers are negative. A nonzero real exists exactly when ; equality gives only the degenerate , limit. For a real branch the same group velocity calculation gives .
To test exact nonlinear validity, take a real normal mode and its corresponding buoyancy perturbation , where . Because
the quadratic vorticity self-advection is zero: . The quadratic buoyancy self-advection, however, is
This nonlinear exactness test for a stratified streamfunction mode distinguishes the cases. For constant , is constant, so both quadratic terms vanish. The background-mode terms already satisfy the linear equations, hence the constant-profile modes are exact finite-amplitude solutions of the ideal Boussinesq equations. Pressure can be recovered from the momentum equations: the vorticity equation supplies their compatibility condition in this simply connected strip.
For the sinusoidal profiles, has a nonzero derivative in the interior. For every nonzero and nonzero real , is not identically zero; it produces a second horizontal harmonic that is absent from the proposed solution. Thus none of these nontrivial sinusoidal-profile modes is an exact finite-amplitude solution. A field is merely an added horizontal shear with no vertical motion and is a degenerate exception to the wave calculation, not a propagating member of it.
Take shear-horizontal waves with displacement . This is divergence-free, so the elastic equation reduces to . Rigid boundaries require at , giving modes , . With shear speed , the dispersion relation is
For , the phase velocity is and the group velocity is , with .
The kinetic energy density is . The only strains are and , together with their symmetric counterparts; thus the isotropic linear-elastic energy density is . Average over one temporal period and integrate across the layer. The sine- and cosine-squared transverse integrals are both , giving
The guided shear-horizontal mode has average equipartition after both operations; a time average at a fixed transverse point alone need not give equality.
Let the rapidly varying phase be , so and . The dispersion law is the Hamilton-Jacobi equation . Differentiating it and following a path with group velocity gives the ray tracing equations
The final relation is obtained by the chain rule along that path; its two spatial terms cancel.
The medium is stationary and independent of , so and are conserved. For deep water far from shore, . Choose the incident branch with and ; choosing the opposite alongshore direction changes its sign. Since the dispersion relation depends on direction only through , the group-velocity component ratio is . Hence the required implicit ray equation is
Near shore, and . Thus , whose integral gives
The rays approach the shoreline normally. A crest is a level set of . Its slope is , so crests become parallel to the shoreline. Their separation in the shore-normal direction is and decreases to zero. These are formal ray asymptotics; for , the slow-variation assumption eventually fails arbitrarily close to the shoreline. The sketch shows a representative shallow-water case ; it illustrates these limiting directions rather than assuming that value in the derivation.
Figure 1.
Near-shore wavecrests become parallel to the shoreline while incident rays approach normally
. Details.
Label the two displacements in cell by , with cell length . Choose the spring within a cell and the spring between cells. The equations are
A Bloch wave gives a two-by-two eigenvalue problem, whose determinant is
Thus the alternating-spring chain dispersion relation is
Periodic boundaries require , so modulo . There are distinct wavenumbers in the Brillouin zone and two branches, accounting for modes. The minus branch is acoustic, with zero frequency and in-phase motion at the centre; the plus branch is optical, with opposite cell displacements.
Expanding the square root near zero gives
At the zone boundary the square root is , so the acoustic maximum is and the optical minimum is . The frequency gap is therefore
Quantizing each harmonic mode gives phonons, bosonic excitations of energy and crystal momentum defined modulo a reciprocal lattice vector. Their group velocity is ; acoustic phonons carry long-wavelength sound, while optical phonons have a nonzero centre frequency. There is one longitudinal polarization per branch here, and phonon number is not conserved in thermal equilibrium.
In the Boussinesq approximation, replace density by a constant reference density in inertia and incompressible flow, retaining the small density departure only in the gravitational force. Write and subtract the resting hydrostatic pressure. The upward buoyancy perturbation acceleration and squared buoyancy frequency are
Thus stable density stratification has . Let henceforth denote the pressure anomaly divided by . The ideal, nonrotating Boussinesq equations are
The buoyancy equation follows by materially conserving the total buoyancy , where ; it does not assume constant .
For an -periodic flow of period , define . An infinite-domain average with vanishing end contributions works as well. The necessary pressure condition is no mean zonal pressure gradient, : periodic pressure satisfies it, whereas a pressure containing a term proportional to does not. Use incompressible flow to write the zonal momentum equation in conservative form,
Averaging its zonal derivative terms yields the exact Reynolds stress relation
For two-dimensional small disturbances about rest, the Linearized Boussinesq equations are , , , and . Differentiate the two momentum equations to eliminate pressure: . Differentiating in and using gives . One further time derivative gives
The equation remains valid for . No vertical derivative of was taken: .
For constant and , a plane internal gravity wave has
Both signs give the prescribed lower-boundary velocity. The radiation condition excludes energy arriving from infinity. At positive frequency, the vertical group velocity is
For a source below the fluid, energy must propagate upward, so the outgoing solution has , even though its vertical phase velocity is downward.
To obtain this selection causally, let and , and replace the constant amplitude by . The method of multiple scales treats as independent during differentiation: the carrier derivatives hold fixed, while holds fixed and holds fixed. Only after differentiating do we restrict to , . Acting on the complex wave, the operators become
With , the wave equation has residual
The zeroth-order term is the dispersion relation; the first-order term vanishes precisely when
If is the switched-on boundary amplitude, with for , the outgoing envelope is for . Its characteristics carry the boundary signal into initially undisturbed fluid. If , characteristics instead arrive from the upper half-space; zero initial disturbances and no incoming signal cannot establish the proposed boundary-forced wavetrain. This is the internal-wave envelope radiation condition.
The leading incompressible flow polarization gives . Hence, to second order in amplitude and leading order in the slow modulation,
There is no meridional transport here. Envelope transport gives , so an initially vanishing mean develops as
These are the leading expressions for internal-wave momentum deposition; higher slow-modulation corrections to the stress are beyond the displayed approximation. In particular, a spatially uniform fully established wavetrain has zero stress divergence, but the front has already produced its mean flow.
The mean wave energy density per unit mass follows from :
Thus . In the original frame the mean kinetic energy is . In a frame translating at , the undisturbed velocity is , and the change in mean kinetic energy is . Indeed at this order behind the front. Mean-flow energy is therefore essential at the same order as wave energy in the translating frame. This follows also from the frame transformation of energy, up to the fixed background constant, and is why conservation of momentum cannot be omitted from the moving-frame conservation of energy budget.
A precise stratification–rotation analogy uses constant , ideal fluid, and independence of one horizontal coordinate. For the stratified system take , , and allow prescribed forces . The possibly nonlinear Boussinesq equations are
For the unstratified system choose right-handed coordinates , rotation , and . Its rotating Euler equations, with the static gravitational and centrifugal contributions absorbed into the background pressure, are
where . The identification is
Then , , and , proving the component-by-component equivalence. In particular, buoyancy perturbation maps to transverse rotating velocity, and stratified horizontal velocity maps to rotation-axis velocity. The mapping permits arbitrary prescribed forces in the two-dimensional plane, but no transverse force: a transverse force in the rotating problem would create a source in the stratified buoyancy equation. A transverse stratified force would also invalidate . Constant is essential to this constant-rotation equivalence.
A physical free surface introduces extra structure beyond the interior equations. After subtracting hydrostatic pressure, its zero total pressure condition gives to first order, together with the kinematic condition for the stratified vertical displacement. The mapping takes this normal velocity into , whereas an actual rotating free surface normal to its physical vertical has normal velocity and a displacement along . The image of the stratified horizontal surface is a vertical surface in the rotating coordinates. Consequently the physical free-surface problems are not analogous, although deliberately mapped rigid boundaries or mathematical boundary data can be.
For the first prescribed force, the steady linear stratified equations are satisfied by
Real parts are understood. The horizontal pressure gradient balances the force; the vertical pressure gradient is balanced by buoyancy; and satisfies buoyancy conservation and incompressible flow. Thus neither nor is fixed by the steady equations alone.
Initial rest and switching on in the unbounded fluid remove this ambiguity by causal pressure adjustment by internal waves. Work with the coefficient and let be the horizontal Fourier transform of . For an abrupt switch at time zero, elimination in the linear equations gives
At the bracket cancels the apparent singularity at every finite time. The persistent pressure term is the symmetric antiderivative of the force: the inverse transform of , interpreted as a Cauchy principal value, is . The oscillatory part propagates away. To see why its zero-frequency part does not leave an arbitrary offset, note that with ; its long-wave contribution consists of oppositely moving fronts. At fixed , the two far-field values of are and , whose average is zero. Nonzero horizontal wavenumbers give dispersive transients that decay locally. Smooth finite-duration switching changes the transient, not this selected steady limit. Therefore
A spatially constant pressure gauge is immaterial. The long-wave group velocity gives the adjustment scale: the elapsed time since switching must satisfy and , and exceed the switching duration. These are asymptotic conditions, not an assertion of exact equilibration after a finite time; the full dispersion relation allows tails. The same long-wave limit gives if desired. Equal-amplitude outward fronts leave opposite pressure offsets and the same velocity on their two sides.
For the force depending instead on , any steady linear horizontal momentum balance requires and . Their mixed derivatives disagree wherever , since but . Hence no steady linear velocity field can satisfy the equations, irrespective of whether it is -independent. This statement concerns the linearized problem; nonlinear inertial balances were excluded by the assumptions.
For an unsteady solution put and take . Its horizontal divergence is zero. The pressure derivatives needed in momentum balance are
Their compatibility is exactly
Thus the Poisson equation supplies an actual pressure and the proposed velocity solves both momentum equations; the vertical momentum and buoyancy equations hold because . This flow grows linearly in time, so it remains a valid small-disturbance prediction only while its velocities are small.
As with total force fixed, . Set . Away from the source , and decay at both ends requires . Integrating across the source gives the jump . Since this jump is , , so
This verifies the distributional source as well as the decay condition.
The corresponding rotating problem is not expected to reproduce this evanescent accelerating flow. Its forcing varies in , precisely the coordinate whose independence was required in the stratification–rotation analogy. Moreover, maps to the rotation-axis coordinate . At small Rossby number, the Taylor–Proudman theorem gives in the unforced exterior regions. Such nonzero columns cannot decay with , hence cannot reproduce an tail. There is also a direct unsteady obstruction to copying the proposed flow: in a homogeneous fluid rotating about the mapped axis, a mode with nonzero axial wavenumber has inertial wave frequency of magnitude , rather than the zero-frequency horizontal vortical response of the stratified problem. The steady or slowly varying exterior rotating response must be columnar or accompanied by outgoing inertial waves; the decaying stratified solution is outside the partial analogy.
Substitution of in the Klein-Gordon equation gives . On the positive-frequency branch, the phase velocity is for , and the group velocity is . The group speed is less than one, although the phase speed exceeds one in magnitude.
With Fourier transform convention , the initial velocity has transform . Each Fourier mode solves a harmonic-oscillator equation, giving
For , symmetry makes this the imaginary part of . When , the phase has a unique stationary point , with phase value and positive second derivative . The stationary phase method gives
For there is no real stationary point. More precisely, finite propagation speed makes the solution at depend only on the initial data on . On that half-line the initial velocity is , and exactly solves the equation with zero initial displacement. Uniqueness on the domain of dependence therefore gives
This exponential initial-velocity tail for the Klein-Gordon equation is exponentially small, rather than identically zero: the initial data already have a nonzero tail outside the origin.
The vacuum Maxwell equations are , and . Taking the curl of Faraday's equation and using gives . The same calculation for Ampère's equation gives . Hence each Cartesian component satisfies the electromagnetic wave equation.
Model the walls as a perfect conductor, with no oscillating fields in its interior. The tangential electric field is zero at the surface, otherwise it would drive unbounded conductor currents. The normal magnetic field is zero, since the divergence-free field has a continuous normal component and the interior oscillating field is zero. Thus and . Normal and tangential may be nonzero because surface charge and surface current support their jumps.
The PDF writes the full magnetic field as . Taken literally, this cannot be a nonzero travelling wave: , so for it forces . The subsequent requests require transverse components. The consistent intended reading is , with transverse fields determined by the Maxwell equations. Use that reading below.
All fields have the same factor. Put . The harmonic Maxwell equations are and . Their and components give
together with and . Substitution and solving, for , gives
The corresponding electric components are
For a transverse electric mode of a rectangular waveguide, . The electromagnetic wave equation becomes
At , the tangential component vanishes, so ; at , the corresponding condition gives . These are Neumann boundary conditions, and the normal- conditions give the same conclusions through the displayed transverse magnetic components. Separation gives
where are integers and . The constant candidate is not a physical oscillating mode: its transverse derivatives vanish, so it has and Faraday's equation forces for . More generally a hollow single-conductor guide has no transverse-electromagnetic zero-cutoff mode: its transverse electrostatic potential is harmonic with the same constant boundary value, hence constant, leaving zero transverse field.
The dispersion relation is . The waveguide cutoff frequency for this mode is ; below it is imaginary and the field is evanescent. Since , the lowest cutoff occurs at :
For a mode propagating in the positive direction (), above its own cutoff , the phase velocity and group velocity are
These waveguide phase and group velocities have product . The superluminal phase speed describes motion of a constant phase, while a narrow wave packet travels at the subluminal group velocity; it does not transmit information faster than light. At cutoff there is no travelling mode with nonzero longitudinal flux.
Assume small-amplitude motion, a thin uniform elastic plate, no prestress, and inviscid, irrotational deep water. Write the upward displacement as , the ice mass per unit area as , and its flexural rigidity as
where is Young's modulus and is Poisson's ratio. The plate equation is , where is the perturbation of upward water pressure.
Let the water velocity potential be below the mean surface , with . This solves the Laplace equation and decays at depth. For , the kinematic boundary condition gives . The linear Bernoulli equation gives
Eliminating proves the dispersion relation of a floating elastic plate:
Thus the desired wavenumber is the positive root of
For positive and , this root is unique: the polynomial is negative at zero and positive eventually; if its derivative starts negative, that derivative crosses zero only once, at a negative-valued minimum before the positive root. If a finite water depth is required, the corresponding relation is .
Put and . Differentiation gives the group velocity
For long periods, the surface gravity wave limit gives . At sufficiently short periods, plate inertia and bending dominate, and . Consequently the curve has a group-velocity minimum of a flexural-gravity wave between branches that rise toward both long and short periods, within the formal deep-water plate model. Very short waves eventually fall outside the thin-plate approximation.
Figure 1.
Group and phase speed for an illustrative elastic ice sheet
. Details.
The plot is an original model illustration with , , , , , and . Its two minima occur at different periods.
A wave packet near the group-speed minimum carries energy away relatively slowly, so sustained forcing can concentrate energy in that period band. However, wind generation cannot be decided from alone. A steadily translating pressure pattern resonates through its phase velocity ; it must reach the minimum phase speed of a flexural-gravity wave. Actual wind-wave growth also requires suitable pressure coupling and enough energy input to overcome damping. A coherent cover suppresses ordinary free-surface wave generation, while incoming ocean swell can still excite bending and break the cover.
For disconnected pancake ice or frazil ice, remove the assumption of coherent elastic bending and retain the effective mass loading as a first conservative approximation. Setting gives . To describe damping as well, replace the elastic layer by a viscous suspension and match velocity and stress to the water beneath: the resulting viscous layer model of frazil-pancake ice has complex , whose real part gives dispersion and imaginary part gives attenuation. Keller's 1998 two-layer model implements this replacement. Effective viscosity and connectedness must reflect the particular cover; zero rigidity alone does not model attenuation.
Assume small-amplitude, nonrotating, inviscid Boussinesq approximation motion about a fluid at rest, with stable background stratification. In either uniform layer let be the buoyancy perturbation and . The linear equations are
For a plane internal gravity wave proportional to , continuity gives , and horizontal momentum gives . Substituting these into vertical momentum and buoyancy evolution gives
Choose , . Its group velocity is
Thus downward energy propagation has . If is the acute angle between the ray and the vertical in its direction of propagation, then , so
The phase velocity is parallel to , while : phase and group velocities are perpendicular, and their vertical components have opposite signs. Propagating incident waves require ; both layers support propagating waves only when . At or above , the lower layer cannot carry a propagating downward internal wave.
For the amplitude convention used below, multiplies the unit particle-displacement vector along the ray, with positive horizontal component. That vector is for a downward wave and for an upward wave. Stating this polarization convention is important when assigning a sign to a reflection coefficient.
Start from , , and . The stationary background obeys . Linearize in small perturbations and use the Boussinesq approximation: replace the density by a reference value in inertia but retain the density perturbation in the buoyancy force. With and ,
This is the Brunt–Väisälä frequency. Its assumed constancy requires a locally uniform stable density gradient in this approximation; rotation and viscosity are neglected.
For a plane wave with wavevector , project the momentum equation onto the space perpendicular to to eliminate pressure. Its vertical component is , while . Eliminating yields
For , a small oscillating body radiates upward and downward conical internal gravity wave beams. In a vertical section the beams make a St Andrew's cross, with angle to the horizontal satisfying . Indeed the group velocity is perpendicular to the wavevector and has ratio of vertical to horizontal magnitudes . Thus wave energy follows the cones, rather than the direction normal to a fixed-radius spherical wavefront. There are no such propagating beams for .
For the shear-flow calculation choose the positive intrinsic-frequency branch and , conditions needed for the printed critical-level formula. The slowly varying local dispersion relation is
Stationarity and horizontal homogeneity conserve and . The Hamiltonian ray equations for a local dispersion relation give
Thus stays negative and the ray propagates upward. Conservation of frequency gives
If the shear reaches the required velocity difference, its first zero is the critical level of an internal gravity wave,
As , the intrinsic frequency tends to zero, , the vertical wavelength tends to zero and the vertical group velocity tends to zero. The ideal ray cannot cross this level. For finite , , so it approaches the level only asymptotically in time. The disturbance develops short scales; even weak viscosity can then absorb it, and nonlinear effects can invalidate the small-amplitude approximation.
The printed sign and existence hypotheses are incomplete. On the positive-frequency branch, instead gives and eventually a turning point when the intrinsic frequency reaches . As a concrete counterexample to the stated universal height bound, take , , , and with any small . At the printed height , the intrinsic frequency is and , so the vertical group velocity is still positive and the ray crosses that height. Also, alone does not ensure that the displayed velocity difference is ever reached; an increasing bounded may have no finite critical level. The qualified derivation above gives the intended positive- result whenever that level exists.