For a ferromagnetic nearest-neighbour Ising model on a chain let , and . The dimensionless Hamiltonian is . In one dimension, decimating every other spin closes exactly within the nearest-neighbour family, including its additive constant. This is the exact chain building block of the Migdal-Kadanoff approach; bond moving becomes an additional approximation in higher-dimensional lattices.
For exact zero-field Ising-chain decimation, sum over an intermediate spin between two retained spins:Parallel and antiparallel end spins give and . HenceFor an even periodic chain, . Rescaling the lattice spacing back to completes the renormalization step. Decimation of successive links gives , as follows by multiplying the transfer matrix times.
Let . Then on . The infinite-temperature renormalization-group fixed point attracts every ; the zero-temperature renormalization-group fixed point is unstable to heating, with slope two. There is no intermediate ferromagnetic renormalization-group fixed point. Equivalently for small , while for large finite . Thus there is no finite-temperature ordered thermodynamic phase in the short-range chain.
The domain-wall scaling coordinate of an Ising chain near is the domain-wall Boltzmann factor . Its recursion and the zero-field correlation length areSince , the recursion has the correct length scaling. Its exponent is one with respect to ; it is not a finite power of physical temperature about . In the thermodynamic limit, a bond is a domain wall with probability , giving the same exponentially large length scale. Their finite energy allows entropy to proliferate walls at any positive temperature.
Exact Ising-chain decimation and length
. Original one-dimensional recursion v'=v squared, finite-temperature iterates flowing to zero and the exact correlation length with its low-temperature asymptote. The coordinate v is tanh(J/kBT); no finite-temperature critical point is introduced. Details.The Ising-chain decimation constant matters for thermodynamics. With dimensionless free energy per spin ,The second expression follows independently from transfer eigenvalues and and satisfies the recursion. Multiplying it by restores the physical free energy. Dropping would preserve normalized retained-spin probabilities but lose the eliminated-spin entropy.
Finite-field Ising-chain decimation is also exact. Use the symmetric transfer matrixand read the new couplings fromHere , and . The latter off-diagonal entry, the field convention split between adjacent bonds and the constant must all be tracked consistently. Near the zero-temperature zero-field renormalization-group fixed point , while at the independent-spin field is unchanged.
In the higher-dimensional Migdal-Kadanoff approximation, moving bonds creates chains that can be decimated. With bond moving first on a -dimensional hypercubic lattice and length factor , the strengthened links have , giving the conventionFor no transverse bonds move, so this reduces to the exact chain result. In higher dimensions it discards geometric correlations and is generally approximate on the original lattice; moving and decimating in another order yields another approximation, not a contradictory exact chain formula.[ref]
Position Space Renormalization Group by Mehran Kardar. lecture 13, printed pp. 79–81, equations V.18–V.27: exact chain; lecture 14, printed pp. 86–87, equations V.51–V.54: bond-moving convention
Configurational entropy counts the arrangements compatible with a macroscopic configuration: . Let , and . The multiplicity is . Stirling's approximation therefore givesWith downward positive, the gravitational potential energy is . Minimizing the Helmholtz free energy gives , henceRaising temperature reduces the extension: the entropic preference for many up/down arrangements opposes alignment by the load. For small loads, .
For the positive-feedback entropic chain with replacement force , , the conservative potential is . Using would overcount it by a factor two. The stationary equation becomesExpansion about givesFor the stable extension is zero. Below , nonzero minima appear, with close to the transition and as . Restricting to downward extensions selects the positive branch. The onset is continuous in this model, with a nonanalytic mean-field change at ; a finite jump in does not follow from the printed force law, despite the question's discontinuity wording. A finite chain has rounded fluctuations rather than a literal thermodynamic singularity.
This is the same self-consistency equation as the zero-field mean-field treatment of the Ising model: the segment orientation corresponds to a spin, extension to magnetization, and the extension-dependent force to the self-consistent molecular field. The competition between alignment energy and binary configurational entropy explains the shared temperature dependence.
Past exam of the theoretical physics I course of the University of Cambridge 2022 3 b Solution 2026-10-18
The square lattice has coordination number of a lattice . The mean-field decoupling isAccounting for the factor in the directed-neighbour sum gives the Hamiltonian in the mean-field approximation:The constant term is necessary to correct the double counting of the interaction. Let . The one-site partition function isso . The Helmholtz free energy is thereforeThe equilibrium mean-field approximation is obtained by minimizing this expression over the allowed . The state supplies the extra in ; omitting it would instead describe the two-state Ising model. This is the Blume-Capel mean-field transition at zero single-ion anisotropy.
For the sawtooth Ising chain, there is a source inconsistency: the printed Ising spin values are , with no definition of . The requested transfer matrix follows for , namely the usual Ising model with values . For arbitrary , summing an apex spin actually givesFor example, , and give the bracket , whereas the claimed hyperbolic cosine gives . Thus the printed identity is false literally. The rest of Question 1 uses the intended symmetric Ising spin values, .
For a fixed configuration of base spins, each apex spin appears in only one local Boltzmann factor. The apex spins are therefore conditionally independent, and their finite sums factorize:Only the base spins carry information from one triangle to the next. The apex spins have already been summed out, so no apex index remains in the transfer matrix; the final trace implements the periodic boundary condition.
Let be the coordination number of a lattice, the number of nearest neighbours of each cell away from boundaries. Define an effective chemical potential incorporating the cell's translational entropy:Use for an unordered nearest-neighbour bond, counted once. The occupation Hamiltonian including the chemical-potential term isUnder , one bond contributesIn a regular lattice with periodic boundary conditions, the number of bonds is , and each spin occurs in linear bond terms. ThereforeThe pair sum equals one half of the ordered sum used in the paper. Consequently the effective field isThus is the Ising model partition sum, including the displayed spin-independent constant if its absolute normalization is required. Dropping that constant changes by a multiplicative factor but leaves spin probabilities and the phase-transition argument unchanged. For simple cubic cells in three dimensions, and the first term in is . Open boundaries replace by the local coordination near the surface; the stated uniform field is the bulk or periodic-lattice result.
For attractive nearest-neighbour interactions, , the transformed model is a ferromagnetic Ising model. In three dimensions and at , its infinite-volume spontaneous magnetization has two branches. As the effective field crosses zero, the equilibrium mean spin changes discontinuously from a negative value to a positive value. Since , varying the physical chemical potential crosses this same first-order phase transition.
The particle-hole-symmetric coexistence line isThe mean Ising spin is a rescaled occupation density. Writing for the physical number density,The negative-spin phase is a dilute gas and the positive-spin phase is a dense, liquid-like phase. If the spontaneous spin magnitude at coexistence is , their number densities areThus the physical order parameter is a density or occupation imbalance, not an actual magnetic moment of these particles. In a closed system with an intermediate mean density, the same transition appears as phase coexistence between the two densities. At the density contrast vanishes continuously; above , sweeping the chemical potential gives no coexistence jump. A true discontinuity requires the thermodynamic limit; a finite sum over finitely many cells remains analytic.
Positive-feedback entropic chain Created 2026-10-20 Updated 2026-10-20
A chain of up/down segments of length has extension and binary configurational entropy. An external force has potential , obtained by integrating the force. Its mean-field free-energy minima obey the displayed equation. Expansion gives , so the ordered extension emerges continuously, , rather than jumping. The equation matches zero-field mean-field theory of the Ising model; finite systems round the ideal singular behavior.
P. W. Kasteleyn 2026-11-05
P. W. Kasteleyn coauthored the FKG inequality with C. M. Fortuin and J. Ginibre. Their theorem gives positive association for increasing functions on a finite distributive lattice when the probability weights satisfy the required lattice condition. It provides a rigorous correlation tool for Ising models and the random-cluster model.[ref]
Renormalization group Created 2026-09-24 Updated 2026-10-18
A renormalization group compares models at different observation lengths. A Wilsonian coarse-grained statistical Hamiltonian sums over short-distance fluctuations; a renormalization-group transformation rescales coordinates and fields for comparison. Kenneth Geddes Wilson's 1982 lecture treats fluctuations across successive length scales to explain critical phenomena.[ref]
The Renormalization Group and Critical Phenomena by Kenneth Geddes Wilson. Section II, pp. 103–104: successive scale integration; inspected in an AGH-hosted reproduction
The experimental motivation is Andrews's carbon dioxide experiment. Dried carbon dioxide occupied a capillary tube above mercury; a screw compressed the transmitting water. A second air-filled tube gauged pressure. Flowing water controlled temperature, and a cathetometer read column positions for volume. The liquid meniscus vanished near the liquid-gas critical point. Residual air and imperfect air-gauge corrections limited accuracy.[ref]
The Bakerian Lecture: On the Continuity of the Gaseous and Liquid States of Matter by Thomas Andrews. pp. 576–578: preparation, apparatus, calibration and pressure caveats; pp. 583–584: critical-temperature observations
These observations motivate critical-point theory without determining a correlation-length critical exponent. The renormalization group explains how critical measurements can become insensitive to many molecular details.In 1972, Kenneth Geddes Wilson and Michael Ellis Fisher used an epsilon expansion about to compute nonclassical critical exponents. Their paper distinguishes a Gaussian fixed point from an interacting renormalization-group fixed point, tunes the thermal parameter, and extracts powers from a linearized recursion. Its Ising-like result is for .[ref]
Critical Exponents in 3.99 Dimensions by Kenneth Geddes Wilson and Michael Ellis Fisher. Critical Exponents in 3.99 Dimensions, Physical Review Letters 28 (1972), pp. 240–242, abstract and equations (7), (10)–(14); p. 243 discusses the more general interaction and accuracy of the approximation
The worked model below isolates this mechanism with chosen coefficients; it is not a precision calculation for the three-dimensional Ising model. Rudolf Peierls Created 2026-10-18 Updated 2026-11-05
Rudolf Peierls introduced an argument explaining how a two-dimensional Ising model can sustain magnetic order at low temperature. A reversed island of spins has a boundary whose energy cost grows with its length. The number of possible boundaries also grows, but sufficiently low temperature suppresses their Boltzmann weights strongly enough for order to survive. The Peierls argument makes the competition between energy and the number of fluctuations explicit, helping explain why dimensionality changes collective magnetic behavior.[ref]
On Ising's model of ferromagnetism by Rudolf Peierls. Proceedings of the Cambridge Philosophical Society 32, 477–481 (1936), low-temperature contour argument
Portrait of Rudolf Peierls
. GFHund; photograph from Friedrich Hund's estate, prepared by Gerhard Hund. CC BY 3.0, via Wikimedia Commons. Source. Sawtooth Ising chain 2026-10-25
An Ising model on a chain of corner-sharing triangles, with one base spin and one apex spin per cell. If the apex interacts only with the two base corners, summing each apex independently gives a two-by-two transfer matrix on base spins. For symmetric Ising spins and energy , its entries are .
Spin-connectivity identity for the Potts model Created 2026-10-14 Updated 2026-11-05
For integer , given a random-cluster configuration, its components receive independent uniform colors under the Edwards-Sokal coupling. Two vertices have equal Potts spins with probability if connected and otherwise. Averaging proves the identity. With a wired component fixed to color , the same argument gives normalized spontaneous magnetization in infinite volume. Thus its onset is the wired random-cluster critical probability, with dimensionless Potts model coupling in the convention of the Edwards-Sokal coupling.
For , the equal-spin probability is identically one and the first identity reduces to . The normalized magnetization expression divides by and therefore does not apply to that degenerate one-color case. The conversion to a physical Ising model inverse temperature must also account for the interaction convention.
Spin lattice 2026-11-05
A spin lattice assigns a classical or quantum spin degree of freedom to each site of a specified crystal lattice. The lattice specifies spatial organization, while the interaction graph specifies which spins couple. Nearest-neighbor models couple adjacent sites, but longer-range interactions are also possible.
For an Ising model, each site carries a two-valued spin variable. For a quantum Heisenberg model, spin operators have noncommuting components, and a typical interaction is . The sign and geometry of the couplings determine whether neighboring preferences can be satisfied together or produce geometric frustration.
Statistical Hamiltonian 2026-10-06
A statistical Hamiltonian assigns an energy to a microscopic configuration. Its Boltzmann weight defines the canonical ensemble, and summing or integrating that weight gives a partition function. A reduced Hamiltonian absorbs inverse temperature into its coefficients, so the weight is . An Ising model uses discrete Ising spin configurations, while Landau-Ginzburg theory uses a coarse scalar field.
Statistical physics Created 2026-09-24 Updated 2026-10-13
Statistical physics explains collective behavior using probability distributions over microscopic possibilities. Its central surprise is that incomplete microscopic knowledge can still produce precise predictions for internal energy, entropy and heat capacity. The bridge is statistical mechanics: specify the available microstates, assign their probabilities, then compute the expected values of measured quantities.
A two-level system already displays the idea. Warming it makes its higher energy more likely; its heat capacity first rises, then falls as the two probabilities approach equality. With two distinguishable units, merely counting microstates explains why the middle energy has twice the state degeneracy. These small examples expose the machinery before the much larger sums needed for a photon gas or an Ising model.
The appeal is economical: the same microscopic energies and probabilities explain both an average reading and its variance. A measurement's spread therefore becomes useful physical information rather than an inconvenience to discard.
Surface-code decoding as a random-bond Ising model Created 2026-09-28 Updated 2026-11-05
For independent bit flips, summing the probabilities of all error chains in one syndrome and logical class equals, up to a class-independent factor, the partition function of a random-bond Ising model. A reference error fixes bond signs and products of star stabilizers become Ising spin configurations.
For finite-range interactions and bounded wall couplings, only sites within an interaction range of the wall have altered local environments. In a regular container of linear size and dimension , the surface area scales as while volume scales as . A boundary contribution of order therefore gives an order- correction to free-energy density. Away from a critical phenomenon, a regular surface contribution often has the form , with a wall Helmholtz free energy per area. Critical finite-size rounding, edges and long-range interactions require separate care; vanishing relative boundary size does not guarantee a simple surface expansion in every regime.
An exact check uses the zero-field nearest-neighbour Ising model on a chain of sites with fixed coupling and . The open chain has bonds, while the periodic ring has . Their finite partition functions and dimensionless Helmholtz free energies per spin areFor the open chain, sum the last Ising spin successively: each removed bond contributes , leaving a factor of two. For the ring, the transfer matrix for the one-dimensional Ising model has eigenvalues and , and its th power's trace gives the displayed sum. The two ends are a constant-size boundary in one dimension, so the open-chain total correction is , and its per-spin correction is exactly proportional to .
Both sets of finite results approach the same at the fixed plotted . Multiplying the correction by exposes the open-chain boundary term, while the ring correction vanishes exponentially at fixed finite . This model's thermodynamic limit remains a real analytic function at every positive temperature: having a thermodynamic limit does not require a phase transition.
Swendsen-Wang algorithm 2026-11-05
The Swendsen-Wang algorithm is a cluster Markov chain Monte Carlo method that updates connected groups of variables together. For the ferromagnetic Ising model with no external field, let and , where and is inverse temperature. One step places a bond on each equal-spin edge independently with probability , leaves unequal-spin edges unbonded, then assigns each connected bond cluster an independent uniformly chosen sign.[ref]
Nonuniversal critical dynamics in Monte Carlo simulations by Robert H. Swendsen and Jian-Sheng Wang. 1987, cluster construction
The bond and spin updates are conditional draws from a joint spin-bond distribution. Summing out the bonds recovers the Boltzmann distribution, so alternating the two conditional draws preserves the intended equilibrium law.[ref]
Generalization of the Fortuin-Kasteleyn-Swendsen-Wang representation and Monte Carlo algorithm by R. G. Edwards and A. D. Sokal. Joint representation and alternating conditional updates
For two connected vertices initially carrying equal spins, the next spins agree with probability : a retained bond forces agreement, while an absent bond permits independent signs. Unlike a single-spin update, one step can reverse a large correlated region. This often reduces critical slowing down, although efficiency depends on the model and the observable. The Ising formula above should not be applied unchanged to a frustrated interaction or an external field.
Symmetry-breaking order of limits 2026-10-14
At zero field and with spin inversion symmetry in its boundary conditions, a finite Ising model pairs every configuration with its spin-reversed configuration. Their equal Boltzmann weights force the expected value of its spin magnetization to vanish. Below a model's ordering critical temperature, an arbitrarily small positive field can instead select the positive spontaneous magnetization if size is taken to infinity first:The distinction is the order of limits and the stated symmetric boundary conditions; plus boundary conditions already break spin inversion symmetry. A zero-field symmetric mixture of the two ordered states can retain zero mean spin magnetization even in the thermodynamic limit. Also, in a finite system is not by itself proof of spontaneous symmetry breaking.[ref]
1 From Spins to Fields. §1.2.1, Spontaneous Symmetry Breaking: displayed nested limit and the immediately following explanation
Thermodynamic limit Created 2026-09-28 Updated 2026-10-13
The thermodynamic limit describes a sequence of larger systems, not a single enormous specimen: particle number and volume tend to infinity with number density fixed. Hold the chosen intensive and extensive thermodynamic quantities such as temperature and an applied magnetic field fixed along that sequence. In the canonical ensemble the controls are ; in the grand canonical ensemble one instead fixes and chemical potential, and the limiting number density is a result, possibly with a jump at phase coexistence. These are different specifications of a limiting experiment.
The useful limit is usually an intensive and extensive thermodynamic quantities normalization of the Helmholtz free energy, not a finite limit of the total extensive quantity itself:Here is the canonical partition function, is the Boltzmann constant, is free-energy density, and is Helmholtz free energy per particle. Thus when the limit exists; finite systems need not be exactly extensive quantities because of the surface correction to thermodynamic free energy.
Specify the interactions and the growing containers too. For a conventional fluid, use a fixed stable pair potential with a tempered pair potential tail, and containers whose boundary layer of any fixed thickness occupies a vanishing fraction of the volume; uniformly enlarged cubes work, a tube of fixed cross-section does not give the same bulk limit. For a finite-range Ising model, keep the lattice spacing and bond coupling fixed while enlarging all intended spatial directions. Ordinary bounded wall interactions or periodic boundary conditions can then give the same bulk free-energy density, although boundary conditions can select different spontaneous symmetry breaking states. This is a set of hypotheses, not a theorem that every interaction has a boundary-independent limit.[ref]
The large deviation approach to statistical mechanics by Hugo Touchette. §V.F, printed pp. 55–57: stable and tempered interactions and existence of the thermodynamic limit
The Curie–Weiss model below deliberately uses a different limiting prescription: its all-to-all coupling is divided by . Without that factor its interaction energy would grow as , rather than as an extensive quantity. The model has no spatial wall or correlation length to compare with a container; it is an exactly summable illustration of finite-size rounding, not a quantitative model of the fluid experiment below.



