Away from zero and the zeros of , the sign function is locally constant and the absolute value function is differentiable at the value of the cosine. The product rule and chain rule give
Thus the triangle inequality and the bounds on sine and cosine imply . Part (c) rules out differentiability at every nonzero cosine zero, and part (b) gives , so this estimate covers every point where the derivative exists.
For a finite interval , choose such that throughout . Then
The apparent factor in the derivative of the oscillation cancels against the multiplying , which is what makes a uniform bound possible even near zero.
A positive-eigenvalue normal mode satisfies . Solving the constant-coefficient equation gives the sine, cosine, hyperbolic sine and hyperbolic cosine family. To avoid confusing modal coefficients with the filament bending modulus, write those coefficients as .
The free conditions at zero require and . With , the remaining conditions are
Its determinant is . Therefore the free-free bending spectrum is
A convenient corresponding eigenfunction is
where gives unit norm. The stable characteristic equation for free-free bending modes is . Intersections or numerical bracketing give
For the entire positive sequence, let . Expanding near its zero and using gives
There are also two zero-energy filament modes, not captured by substituting into the finite-coefficient trigonometric expression. Solving with free endpoints gives the affine kernel. An orthonormal basis of that kernel is
The positive normal modes are orthogonal to both. Including these two rigid-motion modes is essential for completeness; the regular self-adjoint operator on a finite interval has a complete discrete eigenbasis.
Figure 1.
Characteristic roots and bending shapes of a filament with two free ends
. Details.
Using the exponential definition of the hyperbolic cosine and the complex exponential function,
Thus
For real , the hyperbolic sine vanishes only at . Also , so the only zero of sine available to is . The product therefore vanishes exactly when or :
There are three possible parameter values. At the roots are and is real; at the roots themselves are real.
Let be orthonormal unit vectors north, west and upward. A direction of altitude and westward azimuth is
The north celestial pole and the upper equatorial meridian direction are
In the equatorial coordinate system, the same unit vector is . Taking dot products with respectively gives
This is an orthogonal transformation between two bases, so it preserves the length of the direction vector. Recover from both its sine and cosine to keep the correct quadrant. At the zenith, azimuth itself is undefined; the vector equations remain meaningful by continuity. Using the more usual eastward azimuth changes the sign of the second equation.
Write spatial frequency in cycles across the optical pupil as . The previous result gives a maximum axial spatial frequency . If one counts one representative per positive-quadrant integer lattice point inside an isotropic disk , the continuum area estimate is
This is the geometric counting convention producing the printed formula. Lattice boundaries, the zero-frequency piston and axis points give lower-order corrections, so the formula is not an exact integer count.
The mode definition in the PDF is , hence and . It does not itself specify a two-dimensional lattice, its orientation, its independent wave phase components or a circular rather than square spatial frequency cutoff. Full-cycle integer frequencies correspond only to the even values of in that definition. A general real wavefront error also needs both sine and cosine quadratures, and distinct oblique orientations cannot all be identified with a single positive quadrant: the Fourier transform of a real wavefront has conjugate coefficients at and , rather than identifying every independent sign change of a component.
For comparison, a circular spatial frequency disk has approximately signed full-cycle lattice points, or conjugate pairs; two real wave phase components per pair restore approximately real degrees of freedom. A square spatial frequency support gives a different count. The circular physical optical pupil similarly has only about illuminated actuators. The printed is a quadrant area estimate under an extra counting convention; it is not a uniquely determined count of all independently correctable wavefront modes from the stated one-dimensional mode condition.
Put , so . The power series coefficients of the hyperbolic sine preprocessing are
Thus for every , and the series converge on the full interval. Applying coefficient-dominated entrywise positivity gives .
Every diagonal entry belongs to one of the diagonal blocks and equals . Because and , this is . Therefore
The matrix lies in the elliptope and admits a Gram matrix representation by unit vectors. This preprocessing is the Krivine rounding scheme; the equality of absolute coefficients is what preserves positive semidefiniteness even though the cross-block sine coefficients alternate in sign.
Let be the interior-grid matrix representing , with zero boundary error. It is real symmetric and has the stated sine eigenbasis. Put and ; the negative of its eigenvalue is
This increases in each variable on . With , the smallest absolute eigenvalue is at least . Hence its Euclidean norm operator norm satisfies
The corrected scheme has an unscaled residual whose individual entries are uniformly . There are entries and , so . Subtracting the exact nodal equations from the numerical equations gives (with sign depending on the residual convention), and therefore
Choose a constant slightly larger than the resulting bound to obtain the requested strict for all sufficiently small . Uniform smoothness is needed for an -independent constant; unspecified smoothness only in the interior would not by itself guarantee it.
Since the odd sine part of the complex exponential integrates to zero,
Part (e)(ii) therefore yields
in the sense of distributions. This is the Fourier representation of the Dirac delta function.
Write the second form of the functional equation as
For , the elementary exponential formula for the sine gives, uniformly for ,
The stated Stirling formula gives
uniformly on the same strip. The bounded factors and the cancelling exponentials therefore show that
Taking absolute values in the functional equation proves the Vertical-strip factor in the Riemann zeta functional equation:
The Fourier cosine series on is
It is the Fourier series of the even extension to , repeated with period . The Fourier sine series is
It comes from the odd extension and its -periodic extension. These Fourier coefficient formulas follow by Fourier orthogonality, since every nonconstant sine or cosine has squared integral on , while the constant function has squared integral .
For separation of variables, put and set . The boundary conditions are , . Multiplying by and using integration by parts gives
A nonzero solution therefore has : the zero case forces constant, and then forces . Writing , the eigenfunctions and their temporal factors are
These sine functions are orthogonal on , with squared norm . Expanding the initial condition and multiplying by gives, using the permitted interchange of the sum and integral,
Here and . Thus the Fourier series solution is
The exponential decay permits differentiation of the series for , and each term satisfies both boundary conditions. At it is the mixed-end Fourier expansion of .
The gained heat is the increase in internal energy. Since the paper specifies no cross-sectional area, first give the answer per unit cross-sectional area; multiply by for a rod of cross-sectional area . The initial temperature has integral , whereas . At this gives
Numerically . This is positive and less than the eventual gain , as expected from relaxation towards the uniform steady state.
For separation of variables, set , with . The side Neumann boundary conditions give . As in the standard Sturm-Liouville problem, integration by parts shows . The zero eigenvalue gives constant , and together with makes constant too.
For positive eigenvalues, the side conditions give , , . The top condition chooses the hyperbolic cosine factor . Normalize it to one at , obtaining
The orthogonality of integer Fourier modes and the permitted interchange of summation and integration give
For the remaining Fourier coefficients, integrate by parts twice. The sine boundary term vanishes, and with ,
The last integral vanishes because and is a positive integer. Thus : only even Fourier modes survive, as expected from reflection symmetry about . Writing gives
The factor involving hyperbolic cosine lies between zero and one on the closed rectangle. Comparison with proves uniform convergence, so the solution is continuous on the entire boundary and takes the prescribed bottom values. On every strip , the Fourier coefficients have additional exponential decay, allowing differentiation and verifying Laplace's equation and all three Neumann boundary conditions.
To justify the endpoint calculation in b, differentiate at , in the interior-edge sense:
Subtracting from the hyperbolic tangent leaves an absolutely convergent series. For the remaining part, the power series gives, by taking real parts at and then ,
The same formula follows as the limit of the differentiated interior solution, since its leading multiplier is . This establishes the boundary normal derivative used in b. It also explains why the failure of the corner compatibility condition for mixed boundary data affects first derivatives at the bottom corners without spoiling continuity of itself.
On the function is odd, so its mean and all its cosine Fourier coefficients vanish:
The assigned endpoint value does not affect these integrals. The product of the two odd functions and is even, hence the sine Fourier coefficients are
Two applications of integration by parts give
Therefore
The periodic extension has a jump discontinuity at every odd multiple of : its left and right limits are and . Its assigned value at each such point is . Thus it is odd away from these points, but it is not a globally odd function pointwise. The Fourier series will take the midpoint value zero at these jumps.
For a nonzero integer , direct integration gives
whereas . The product-to-sum formulas
therefore establish Fourier orthogonality: for positive integers ,
Here is the Kronecker delta. In particular the constant function is orthogonal to every nonconstant sine and cosine in this system. Integrating the given Fourier series, then multiplying it by or and integrating, isolates its Fourier coefficients. Using the permitted interchange of the sum and integral gives
If is an even function, then is an odd function, while is an even function. Thus
The Fourier series consequently reduces to a Fourier cosine series.
For a nonzero separable solution of the Laplace equation in polar coordinates, write with . Multiplying the partial differential equation by and dividing where gives
where is a real separation constant. The resulting ordinary differential equations are
The equations continue across zeros of the factors by continuity. The radial equation is a Cauchy-Euler equation; putting changes it to .
For positive separation constant, write with . The radial factors are powers, while the angular factors are sine and cosine:
For zero separation constant, each transformed equation has zero second derivative, giving
For negative separation constant, write with . The radial factors oscillate in , and the angular factors are exponential functions:
These exhaust the nonzero real separated solutions before imposing angular periodicity or regularity at the origin. The zero solution is also allowed. Since Laplace's equation is linear, sums of these separated solutions are solutions wherever the sums and required derivatives converge appropriately.
For the first sequence, . The squeeze theorem gives , and every subsequence of a convergent sequence has the same limit of a sequence. Thus its set of subsequential limits is .
For the second sequence, the four possible sine values give
The even-indexed subsequence is constantly one, and , so both zero and one occur as subsequential limits. A convergent subsequence is bounded, so it contains only finitely many terms with . Of the remaining three residue classes, at least one occurs infinitely often. The corresponding further subsequence has limit of a sequence zero or one; the subsequence rule forces the original convergent subsequence to have that same limit of a sequence. Therefore the exact answer is . Divergence to along is not a finite subsequential limit.
We verify that the augmented partition of an interval in part i has vanishing mesh of a partition. Define for . Its derivative is
Since for , we have . The mean value theorem therefore gives
The appended interval has length , so for the augmented partition of an interval.
The sine is continuous, hence Riemann integrable on . By the Riemann sum convergence theorem, , using the fundamental theorem of calculus and the cosine antiderivative. As , the answer is
Set
The points strictly increase from zero to . With , the given expression is exactly the midpoint Riemann sum
for the partition of an interval of . The sine argument is precisely the midpoint tag, since it is half the sum of the consecutive endpoints.
For a fixed integration interval , append and choose the final tag . The resulting Riemann sum satisfies
This makes explicit the small final interval that the original sum omits.
First find the fixed axis of rotation by solving . After removing a nonzero common factor, the linear equations are
They give . Choose the following unit vectors:
Their dot products show that they form an orthonormal basis; hence is an orthogonal matrix. Since is an orthogonal matrix fixing , it preserves the orthogonal complement of . Its restriction there has determinant , so it is a planar rotation.
The trace gives , so . To determine the sign of the sine, rather than just its magnitude, calculate
Thus a suitable angle and change of basis are
In fact direct matrix multiplication gives
The theorem on pointwise convergence of a piecewise smooth Fourier series gives the average of the two one-sided values of the corresponding periodic extension. Under the usual piecewise smooth interpretation of the paper's derivative assumption, the even extension is continuous at and at the joined endpoints . Thus
For the odd extension, the values on either side of zero are and ; those on either side of are and . Therefore
The endpoint values are also immediate because each sine term vanishes there. If or is nonzero, the Fourier sine series does not reproduce that endpoint value. Merely assuming that the derivative is locally piecewise continuous in the open interval would be weaker than the usual piecewise smooth hypothesis; the convergence assertion uses the standard endpoint regularity implicit in that hypothesis.