Euclidean action 2026-10-05
A Wick rotation from real time to imaginary time replaces the oscillatory weight by . For a real scalar with positive kinetic normalization, . Positivity of its kinetic term does not ensure convergence if the potential is unbounded below. Fermionic integrals instead use independent Grassmann fields and need not define a positive measure.
In units , a smooth Wick rotation of the four-dimensional static patch of de Sitter spacetime has Euclidean time period . Its compact geometry is a round four-sphere of radius . The Einstein field equations give , and direct integration gives volume , hence gravitational Euclidean action . With zero assigned internal energy, gives Bekenstein-Hawking entropy .
Euclidean path integral 2026-10-06
A path integral with weight uses the Euclidean action obtained by Wick rotation. Bosonic convergence requires appropriate positivity and boundary conditions.
For a normalized static metric with a simple outer zero at , set . The Wick rotation and give to leading order, so smoothness fixes period . In an ingoing null chart, on the future horizon; the outgoing chart gives the opposite sign on the past branch. The Hawking temperature is and uses the time generator normalized at infinity.
Massless scalar bubble pole Created 2026-10-07 Updated 2026-10-14
With a mostly-plus metric signature, define . Wick rotation and a Feynman parameter give . At nonzero Euclidean , the Gamma function supplies the pole. Exceptional massless momentum can introduce infrared ambiguity.
For a connected amputated Feynman diagram, let denote its independent loops, internal scalar lines, interaction vertices and external lines. Its superficial degree of divergence counts the simultaneous ultraviolet scaling of all loop momenta: each loop integration contributes powers and each scalar propagator removes two. A nonderivative interaction adds no numerator powers, so . The graph identities are
The kinetic term gives and . Eliminating proves the monomial scalar interaction power-counting identity:
For a graph with connected components the first is replaced by , after removing the corresponding overall momentum delta functions. Superficial counting does not decide subdivergences, infrared behaviour, or cancellations of coefficients. In a massive scalar theory, indicates possible logarithmic divergence and possible power divergence; negative overall degree still permits divergent proper subgraphs.
Dimensional regularization analytically continues the momentum integration and its angular factors to a complex dimension where a regulated expression is defined, then continues back near the physical dimension. Introduce a scale to keep the renormalized coupling in fixed units. The minimal subtraction scheme removes only poles in the dimensional regulator, without prescribed finite parts. It differs from modified minimal subtraction scheme, which also absorbs the conventional combination.
For the cubic calculation, write , so the interaction is and the vertex is . Use and the vertex . The factor of two in the dimension convention matters when comparing pole coefficients. In six dimensions , and a proper two-point graph has .
The one-loop bubble diagram has Feynman-diagram symmetry factor two. Define its amputated insertion explicitly by
Combine denominators with a Feynman parameter and shift . With , the dimensionally continued integral gives
This identity follows by Wick rotation and a Schwinger parameterization, giving the angular Gaussian factor and the remaining gamma integral. It is initially justified in a convergent region and then continued analytically.
Here and . Thus the one-loop two-point divergence in six-dimensional cubic scalar theory is
Writing , the proper-bubble contribution to the propagator is
With the defined , resummation gives . If instead an insertion is called , then and the denominator is . These naming conventions must not reverse the calculated graph.
For example, the minimal-subtraction two-point counterterms in cubic scalar theory can be written
Their insertion cancels the bubble pole. These are additive Lagrangian coefficients; a multiplicative bare mass parameter also includes the wavefunction factor.
There is a vacuum convention to specify because a cubic interaction does not preserve a zero mean field automatically. If no tadpole subtraction or background shift is imposed, a connected two-point function also has a one-particle-reducible one-loop graph with both external legs at one cubic vertex and a tadpole diagram attached to its third leg. For , the amputated one-point tadpole diagram is
This uses . Its mean-field pole is . The tadpole contribution to a cubic-theory two-point function is therefore
In that unshifted convention, the total connected one-loop propagator pole is
A linear counterterm imposing cancels the attached tadpole diagram, leaving the usual proper-bubble result above. Vacuum bubbles cancel by normalization. A disconnected product belongs to the unconnected two-point function and has two tadpole diagram loops, so it is outside the requested connected one-loop propagator correction. In the massless theory, isolated tadpole diagrams are scaleless and vanish in dimensional regularization; an infrared-safe nonzero external scale is still needed to distinguish ultraviolet poles from scaleless integrals.
An instanton is a localized finite-action classical solution of a Euclidean field theory. Its role differs from that of a static spatial classical field-theory soliton: an instanton is localized in Euclidean spacetime and contributes to quantum transition amplitudes, rather than persisting as a stationary real-time particle. Wick rotation changes the oscillatory weight into when the continuation and boundary conditions are valid. The Euclidean path integral is consequently dominated semiclassically by stationary Euclidean configurations. Perturbation theory around one vacuum misses other saddles whose weights have the nonanalytic form .
A useful first example is quantum tunnelling between two degenerate minima in quantum mechanics. For coordinate with mass , the Euclidean action is
with the vacuum energy subtracted from . Its Euler-Lagrange equation is , equivalent to motion in the inverted potential . A finite-action trajectory joining zero-energy minima has conserved Euclidean energy . A forward instanton therefore satisfies , while an anti-instanton has the opposite orientation. Completing the square gives the action bound
which these zero-energy paths saturate. This is the Euclidean counterpart of the first-order kink argument, with Euclidean time replacing the spatial coordinate.
For the quartic double-well instanton, choose
The first-order equation in the interval is . Separation gives
The center is arbitrary. Its derivative is an instanton translation zero mode: differentiating the Euclidean field equation shows that it lies in the kernel of the quadratic fluctuation operator . A naive Gaussian determinant therefore has a zero eigenvalue. Replace its integration by the collective-coordinate integral over , and take the determinant only over nonzero modes. The resulting instanton fluctuation prefactor combines that Jacobian with the determinant ratio against the vacuum. The action controls the exponential suppression; the prefactor is essential for a quantitative rate or splitting.
When , crossings are rare and their typical separations greatly exceed their widths. In the dilute instanton gas, ordered center integrals for well-separated crossings over Euclidean duration produce . If a single-crossing rate is , a symmetric two-well system has even-crossing and odd-crossing sums proportional to and . The spectral interpretation gives levels and
This is a real tunnelling level splitting. A Euclidean bounce instead describes false vacuum decay: it leaves and returns to a metastable vacuum, and a characteristic negative fluctuation mode supplies the imaginary part interpreted as decay. A bounce must not be confused with a stable double-well instanton merely because both use Euclidean saddles.
The central gauge-theory example is a Yang-Mills instanton on Euclidean four-space. State conventions carefully: take anti-Hermitian generators , with , connection , and gauge curvature . With coupling , the positive Yang-Mills action is
The Hodge star operator squares to one on Euclidean two-forms. Under the usual finite-action boundary conditions, the connection approaches a pure gauge at infinity, defining a map . Its winding degree is the integer instanton number
This is unchanged by smooth deformations preserving the boundary sector. Geometrically this is, up to the stated sign convention, the second Chern number of the compactified bundle. Different sign conventions for trace, curvature or orientation must be changed together.
Use the positive norm . Decomposition into self-dual and anti-self-dual curvature gives
The Yang-Mills instanton Bogomolny bound is saturated by for positive , or for negative . These first-order equations imply the full Yang-Mills equations: the Bianchi identity becomes when . Thus the topological minimum is a genuine classical saddle, not just an arbitrary field with integer charge. Self-duality alone is a local differential condition; finite action is an additional requirement.
An explicit unit-charge example is the BPST instanton. Let , , and choose the self-dual symbols , and for , using orientation . In regular gauge,
The curvature is self-dual. Since , its squared component curvature is . Radial integration yields
so . Replacing self-dual symbols by anti-self-dual ones produces the opposite charge with the same positive action.
The center has four coordinates and is an instanton size modulus. Classical four-dimensional Yang-Mills action is scale invariant, so varying changes the action-density width but not the total action. If gauge transformations must tend to the identity at infinity, three global gauge orientations also remain, giving eight parameters for the one-instanton framed instanton moduli space. If those global orientations are quotiented out, the unframed one-instanton space has five parameters. A zero-size limit is a singular concentration of curvature, not another smooth instanton. Higher-charge solutions likewise possess instanton moduli spaces; their collective-coordinate integrals replace the corresponding zero-mode determinants.
In a Euclidean-time description, topologically distinct gauge vacua are separated by a change of Chern-Simons number; an instanton interpolates between them, with the change equal to in compatible orientation conventions. Theta-weighted instanton sectors give , connecting topology to the vacuum angle. With fermions, the gauge-field topology also controls fermionic zero modes and chiral selection rules through the chiral anomaly. These phenomena explain why instantons encode physics beyond small fluctuations around a single vacuum.
Instantons link Euclidean classical solutions, topological sectors and exponentially suppressed quantum effects. Their interpretation requires the boundary conditions, normalization, fluctuation spectrum and measure over collective coordinates. A dilute approximation is controlled only when its individual-action suppression and separation assumptions hold; classical scale moduli and their quantum corrections can make size integrals delicate rather than automatically finite.
Use units and put . The static patch of de Sitter spacetime has radial factor . A Wick rotation makes its radial-time metric positive:
Near the cosmological horizon, write . Then and
in the radial-time directions. Thus must be an angle of period . A larger integer multiple would give a conical excess rather than a smooth origin. The Euclidean black-hole regularity condition gives
This de Sitter horizon temperature uses the time normalization at , where is proper time; static observers at other radii see the corresponding Tolman temperature law redshift.
Vary the gravitational Euclidean action with respect to . The identities and the integrated variation of the scalar curvature yield, after discarding the assumed boundary term,
The resulting vacuum Einstein field equations are therefore
Tracing in four dimensions gives , and substitution gives .
The smooth Euclidean geometry is compact. Explicitly, in Euclidean five-space use
These obey and induce precisely the above metric, so with the identified Euclidean time covers a round four-sphere once. Neither the collapsing two-sphere at nor the collapsing time circle at is a physical boundary. Since , its volume and on-shell Euclidean action are
The semiclassical partition function is , and follows from the free energy relation . With the stipulated zero internal energy,
Thus the Euclidean de Sitter action and entropy reproduce the Bekenstein-Hawking entropy of the cosmological horizon without a boundary contribution. Restoring constants, .
Use the mostly-minus Minkowski metric, quantum field theory propagator and dimensionally continued interaction , with . Take all four external momenta incoming, so , and set , , .
The three one-loop one-particle-irreducible Feynman diagrams are the bubble graphs with external pairings , and . Their external quantum field theory propagators are omitted by amputation. Each Feynman diagram has symmetry factor from exchanging the two internal lines; the fixed external labels are already accounted for by the three distinct channels.
Figure 1.
The three labeled one-loop scalar four-point bubble channels with all external momenta incoming
. Details.
For a channel carrying momentum , its amplitude is
The signs in the last equality follow from the two vertices and two quantum field theory propagators. Apply the Feynman parameter identity
After shifting the loop momentum, the denominator is , with . For positive Euclidean , Wick rotation and the Schwinger representation give
Analytic continuation to physical momenta keeps the prescription . Thus dimensional regularization evaluates the channel as
Use and expand the other factors. The minimal-subtraction scalar four-point bubble channels result through the finite part is
The parameter integral is left unevaluated, as requested. The three channel contributions are . Their pole is momentum independent and is cancelled by the four-point counterterm , with
After pure minimal subtraction scheme subtraction, the complete vertex through one loop is the tree vertex plus
Here the limit has been taken. The modified minimal subtraction scheme would also absorb ; it is not identical to the specified pure MS finite part.
The bare coupling is scale independent and satisfies
Writing and differentiating at fixed gives
At order , the finite coefficient is , so the one-loop quartic scalar beta function is
The factor two relative to the pole residue follows from using . With the residue doubles, but the four-dimensional beta function is unchanged.
For pure nonabelian gauge theory, the corresponding pure Yang-Mills one-loop beta function has the opposite sign:
Gauge-boson self-interactions and the gauge-consistency ghost contributions give antiscreening. For a compact nonabelian simple factor , the coupling decreases at high energy: asymptotic freedom. In contrast, positive scalar increases toward the ultraviolet. Its one-loop extrapolation has a Landau pole, indicating breakdown of weak-coupling perturbation theory, not a proof by itself of nonperturbative triviality. Ultraviolet poles should be extracted at infrared-safe mass or nonexceptional kinematics; a scaleless massless zero-momentum integral cannot be used to read off this ultraviolet counterterm without separating its infrared behavior.
The Wick rotation gives the radial Euclidean metric . For a simple root, write and choose the side with V positive. There for , so and
The leading geometry is a plane in polar coordinates with angle . For a time identification of period beta, the circumference/proper-radius ratio approaches . Unless it is exactly , the origin is a conical singularity, with deficit or an excess if this is negative. This is the Euclidean metric near a simple static horizon, rather than a divergent Lorentzian curvature invariant at the horizon. The side with V negative does not give a positive-definite metric under this real Wick rotation.
With signature , the momentum-space Feynman rules for phi-fourth theory follow by expanding the interaction exponential and using free-field Wick contractions. Every internal scalar propagator supplies , every quartic Feynman vertex supplies , and each vertex conserves four-momentum. Integrate every independent loop momentum with and divide by the Feynman-diagram symmetry factor . Equivalently, assign momenta to all lines and attach at each vertex before eliminating constrained integrations. A connected amputated graph therefore has the form
with the remaining overall momentum-conservation delta function understood. For an unamputated correlation function, retain the external propagators; scattering amplitudes instead use LSZ reduction. The factor in the interaction cancels the number of ways to attach the four identical fields at a vertex, leaving the stated vertex factor.
For a connected Feynman diagram, . The superficial degree of divergence is the power under simultaneous large rescaling of all independent loop momenta before considering cancellations or divergent subgraphs. Since each integration contributes four powers and each internal propagator removes two,
Counting vertex half-edges gives . Substitution yields
The connectedness assumption matters: a disconnected interaction graph with components instead has the corresponding count . Tree graphs have no loop integral even when this formal power count is nonnegative.
In four dimensions the possible primitively divergent proper vertices have or , with or ; odd vertices vanish by the symmetry. The divergent local structures are a mass term, a kinetic term and a quartic coupling term. If vacuum diagrams are retained, a vacuum-energy term is also required. Thus one can renormalize using a finite family of operators already allowed by the theory's symmetries: four-dimensional phi-fourth theory is perturbatively renormalizable. The superficial count alone is not an all-orders convergence proof. After divergent subgraphs are subtracted with these counterterms, higher-point graphs have no new overall ultraviolet divergence; a negative overall does not by itself exclude subdivergences.
The requested lowest-order graphs and the three channels needed for the coupling correction are shown here:
Figure 1.
Original quartic-scalar diagrams: free line, tadpole, four-point contact and three bubble channels, ultraviolet-finite six-point triangle and all free four-point pairings
. Details.
For the two-point function, the free propagator is order one, while its first interacting correction is the tadpole diagram, with , , and . Its loop integral behaves as and is quadratically divergent. For the connected four-point function, the lowest graph is the order- contact vertex, with and formal but no loop divergence. The first loop correction comprises the bubble diagrams. Each has , , and , matching its logarithmic integral .
If the full four-point correlation function rather than its connected part is considered, there is also an order-one contribution: the sum of the three Wick contractions into two free propagators, with pairings . Explicitly, , with the free scalar propagator between insertions . These disconnected pairings are drawn in the bottom row of the plate. They contain no loop integral and are not contributions to the proper four-point vertex.
A six-point amplitude in phi-fourth theory has a one-loop triangle Feynman diagram with two external legs at each of three vertices. It has , , and . For a fixed external-leg partition its loop integral contains three scalar denominators, for example
After Wick rotation, its ultraviolet radial behavior is , which converges. The triangle has no proper loop subgraph, so no ultraviolet subdivergence is hidden in this example. It generates no new six-field counterterm. Nonzero mass avoids a separate infrared issue; with massless propagators exceptional external momenta can produce infrared singularities without changing this ultraviolet conclusion.
The bare mass is a coefficient in the regulated action, whereas the physical mass is the pole position of the full propagator. Write the amputated two-point insertion as . Summing its insertions gives
At order , only the tadpole contributes. Its factor one half follows directly from Wick pairing: of the four fields at the vertex, choices attach the two labeled external lines and the remaining pair closes the loop, so . Thus
Rotate through the Feynman contour. The from the measure and the in the propagator, together with the denominator sign, give a positive Euclidean integral. With spherical cutoff ,
This is the Wick-rotated cutoff tadpole mass shift, and it is independent of external momentum. Hence to first order,
For a positive stable quartic coupling the first-order shift is positive. Keeping the measured pole fixed while changing the cutoff requires adjusting the bare mass. At the bracket is understood by its finite limit . There is no momentum-dependent wave-function correction from this one-loop tadpole; such corrections begin at higher order.
Use and normalize the time-translation Killing vector field at infinity. The simple outer zero and positivity on its exterior imply . Near the horizon, write ; then . The Wick rotation gives the radial Euclidean metric
Define , so . Its leading near-horizon form is
Thus is a polar angle. Smoothness at the origin requires period , rather than a cone or a multiple cover with a branched origin. The Euclidean black-hole regularity condition is
A thermal quantum state has imaginary-time period . Since , this time coordinate is normalized to the clocks at infinity, and the Hawking temperature is
A static clock at radius measures the redshifted local temperature ; that local quantity is not the temperature requested with the asymptotic normalization.
The static coordinates are singular on the horizon, so calculate its surface gravity in a regular ingoing chart. With , the metric and the same normalized Killing vector field are
The inverse radial block has , , . Direct calculation gives
Since has constant coordinate components, its acceleration is
On the future horizon, and is null, so the defining equation gives . In the outgoing chart regular on the past branch, the radial cross-term is and the same calculation gives for . Hence the branch-independent physical statement is
This proves the Euclidean temperature and signed horizon surface gravity relation directly. Rescaling the Killing vector field would rescale its surface gravity; the condition at infinity fixes that otherwise arbitrary normalization.
Use the mostly-plus Minkowski metric, so , and the source term . Define the vacuum-normalized generating functional, connected generating functional, and quantum effective action by
The Legendre transform is taken after expressing in terms of , locally where this relation is invertible. Varying it gives and . The logarithm generates connected graphs; the Legendre transform removes graphs joined by a single propagator, leaving one-particle-irreducible vertices. This sign convention is important: its classical limit is , consistent with the positive vertices in this question.
For the free real scalar field, integration by parts puts the action into the form , where has Fourier symbol . Include the Feynman i-epsilon prescription . Completing the square yields
and consequently
The physical scalar propagator is , whereas the inverse quadratic kernel appearing in is . Differentiating this quadratic functional and Fourier transforming gives
The infinitesimal prescription specifies propagators and is dropped when quoting the local vertex kernel.
At the order represented by tree-level Feynman diagrams, stationary phase gives , with the classical field equation . The Legendre transform cancels the source term, so
Thus
Other connected tree graphs with several quartic vertices are one-particle reducible and belong to , not to the proper vertices of . This explains why no extra tree correction is hidden in these formulas.
The one-loop proper two-point graph is the tadpole diagram. The one-loop proper four-point graphs are the three bubble diagrams, with pairings , and of the external legs. Each has Feynman-diagram symmetry factor . The figure shows the topologies and every four-point channel; external momenta are incoming.
Figure 1.
One-loop scalar proper vertices: the two-point tadpole and all three four-point bubble channels
. Details.
The tadpole factor can also be counted directly: there are assignments of two labeled external legs to one quartic vertex, while its normalization leaves . For a fixed four-point partition, the interchange of the two internal lines gives the same factor ; there are three distinct partitions. Graphs with an external self-energy insertion are one-particle reducible and are not additional contributions to .
For the two-point divergence, perform a Wick rotation. The Euclidean tadpole contribution to the proper inverse kernel is
Assume to separate the ultraviolet calculation from infrared issues. A Schwinger parameterization gives . Using the supplied Gaussian integral, initially in the convergence region, gives
The last expression provides the meromorphic dimensional regularization continuation. Set . Since ,
If the coupling is written as , that factor multiplies the intermediate integral but does not change the displayed pole residue. The negative pole is a property of analytic continuation; it must not be inferred from the positive cutoff integrand without carrying out the continuation.
The added mass counterterm contributes to , because and its Lagrangian term is . Hence cancellation requires
up to an arbitrary finite subtraction specifying the renormalization scheme. No external momentum occurs in the tadpole, so no one-loop wave-function renormalization is needed. At the unregulated tadpole is scaleless and vanishes in dimensional regularization; the massive calculation identifies the mass-dependent ultraviolet pole without conflating it with a massless infrared limit.
For completeness, the signs of the four-point graphs in this effective-action convention can be read from the Euclidean one-loop functional . Its expansion has terms and . Differentiating four times gives
This is the Euclidean form, analytically continued to the physical external momenta. It confirms the three channel diagrams and their symmetry factors; evaluating its divergence is not needed for the requested mass counterterm.
The Polyakov action is invariant under worldsheet diffeomorphisms and Weyl transformations, . A two-dimensional metric has three local components: two coordinate transformations and one Weyl function remove these locally. In conformal gauge the factor is independent of the conformal scale, and on a flat coordinate patch the matter action is
Thus it is the action of free scalar fields, with their target-space contractions using the Minkowski metric. On a Euclidean sphere there are no unpunctured conformal moduli: a metric can be put into the conformal class of the round metric, and in stereographic patches the scalar action has this free-field form. This does not mean that the sphere has a globally flat metric. A spherical worldsheet here is understood after Wick rotation; it has no nonsingular global Lorentzian metric. The residual Möbius transformations and their zero modes still have to be divided out or fixed by vertex positions.
To derive the worldsheet ghost action, consider an infinitesimal diffeomorphism generated by and a Weyl variation . The metric variation separates as
Integration over the Weyl parameter removes the trace gauge condition. The trace-free part produces the Faddeev-Popov determinant of an operator mapping vectors to symmetric traceless tensors. This is trace elimination in string Faddeev-Popov gauge fixing. The stated Grassmann Gaussian integral exponentiates this determinant with an odd vector and an odd symmetric trace-free antighost .
The normalization of the operator and antighost can be chosen to match the printed convention. For example, in a flat patch take . It differs from the orbit operator only by a field-independent determinant factor. Tracelessness and symmetry give . Integration by parts, followed by exchanging two odd factors, gives . Consequently the determinant exponent is with
Overall constant normalization does not affect the determinant's dependence on the fields. The Faddeev-Popov ghost fields are vectors, while the antighost fields are symmetric trace-free tensors; they are not extra target-space string excitations.
Now use , and . In these coordinates and . Tracelessness implies , so directly
Therefore
For a Cartesian check, and , reproduce the same result.
The original PDF repeats for its final ghost transformation. The second occurrence must be ; otherwise the displayed rules give two incompatible transformations for one ghost and none for the other. Write the corrected transformation as , with on the left. Then the odd left-acting BRST differential satisfies the graded Leibniz rule . Its local rules are
The last two expressions are with the matter-plus-ghost worldsheet stress tensor in the question.
Here is an off-shell check of the action variation, including the Grassmann signs. Temporarily set , , , , and . Apart from the common factor , the total Lagrangian is . Its matter variation is
The matter terms in and give the ghost-action contribution . Combining these terms with the last two matter terms produces .
The remaining contribution from the sector is
where subscripts denote derivatives. In the last equality the terms and cancel by anticommutation. The sector has the same identity with . Thus
where
Hence the total action is BRST invariant up to a boundary term, which vanishes on a closed worldsheet or under the usual compatible boundary and time-end conditions. This calculation requires no equations of motion.
Nilpotence needs a qualification for these particular chiral rules. For either ghost, , because . Thus algebraically. For the embedding, however, the graded calculation gives
Mixed second derivatives of cancel because . The remaining terms vanish on the ghost equations of motion, , which follow by varying the antighosts in the chiral ghost action. They need not vanish off shell. An explicit counterexample uses independent Grassmann variables : take , and one coordinate . Then .
For the antighosts, use the permitted stress-tensor identity on the classical solution space. Then . Indeed direct variation of the displayed stress tensors gives
which vanish using the ghost equations and the free matter wave equation. Therefore two successive BRST transformations annihilate every field on shell. This is chiral conformal-gauge BRST nilpotence is on shell, not an unrestricted off-shell identity for arbitrary ghosts. Quantum BRST nilpotence additionally requires cancellation of the worldsheet anomaly, giving in the critical bosonic theory.
For and initially , Schwinger parameterization and the supplied Gaussian integral give
Substitute to obtain the Euclidean massive loop integral
For a positive integer , . Outside the convergence region this expression defines its meromorphic continuation, used in dimensional regularization.
Combine the two denominators with a Feynman parameter and shift by . This gives
The Gamma function has , and the remaining factors tend to and one. Hence the massive scalar bubble pole in four dimensions is
The pole is independent of the external momentum, as required for a local quartic counterterm.
Use the mostly-plus Minkowski metric and expand . The momentum-space Feynman rules are: an internal scalar propagator ; a four-scalar interaction vertex ; a momentum conservation delta function at each vertex; and per independent loop momentum. Divide by the Feynman-diagram symmetry factor. All momenta can be taken incoming. External propagators are omitted when computing an amputated one-particle-irreducible vertex.
The connected one-loop one-particle-irreducible Feynman diagrams are the two-point tadpole diagram and the three four-point bubble diagrams, in the channels. Each has symmetry factor . A tadpole attached to an external leg through a single bridge would be reducible, so is excluded here.
Figure 1.
One-loop two-point and four-point one-particle-irreducible graphs in quartic scalar theory
. Details.
The Euclidean massive loop integral at has , so . Wick rotation and the propagator/vertex factors give the two-point loop amplitude , whose pole is . A mass counterterm contributes and cancels it when .
Each four-point bubble diagram has pole , with the external coupling-dimension factor restored in the local vertex. Summing its three channels gives the quartic counterterm . Therefore the one-loop massive phi-fourth counterterms are exactly
There is no one-loop wave-function renormalization, since the tadpole is independent of external momentum. Vacuum graphs would additionally require a vacuum-energy subtraction.
In the minimal subtraction scheme, the bare coupling is
Its dimension is ; the renormalized is dimensionless. Differentiate at fixed , writing :
Solving through quadratic order gives the engineering term in a dimensionally continued beta function and the one-loop quartic scalar beta function
The first term comes from the coupling's engineering dimension; the second is the quantum contribution to the renormalization-group beta function.
For fixed , the whole is not literally as : its linear term is present. Interpret the final instruction as keeping terms through quadratic order. Set . Then is an upward parabola, negative between its two zeros and positive above the interacting zero.
Figure 2.
Quartic beta function below four dimensions, with arrows toward increasing renormalization scale
. Details.
For positive initial coupling , the quartic running coupling below four dimensions follows by solving the linear equation for :
If , then as and as . If it stays fixed; the zero solution also stays fixed. If , the infrared limit is still , but the ultraviolet evolution reaches a Landau pole at the finite scale
Thus this branch cannot be continued physically to using the one-loop approximation. These are statements about the quartic coupling direction. The Wilson-Fisher fixed point of the full scalar theory also has a thermal relevant direction at the Wilson-Fisher fixed point; approaching the critical theory requires mass tuning. For negative initial coupling, the quartic potential is unstable: the same formula tends to zero from below in the ultraviolet and reaches a pole at finite scale toward the infrared.
With , the logarithm is the connected generating functional. Its derivative is the mean field. The specified Legendre transform satisfies , and the quantum effective action generates amputated one-particle-irreducible vertices by further functional derivatives. In this question is the negative of the commonly used Minkowski effective-action convention; consequently its tree term is . Its diagrammatic content is unchanged if the convention is used consistently.
Expand the action around a stationary background in the presence of the source. For , integration by parts gives
The linear term vanishes at the tree-level saddle, . Keeping the Gaussian fluctuation approximation, and fixing the field-independent normalization, gives
to one-loop order. The shift from the tree saddle to the exact mean field cancels from the tree Legendre transform at this order. Hence the one-loop scalar effective action in the question's convention is
The functional determinant has a Feynman i-epsilon prescription before Wick rotation. Higher loops come from the omitted cubic and higher fluctuation vertices.
To see the one-loop one-particle-irreducible Feynman diagrams, write . Its determinant expansion is
Each trace closes a single scalar loop, with propagators and background insertions . No internal edge is a bridge, so these graphs are one-particle irreducible. Expanding the background factors produces their external legs.
For a constant , set . The quantum effective potential is defined here by . A plane-wave basis diagonalizes , and the supplied Wick rotation converts its correction per unit volume to
Here the power of the renormalization scale keeps the continued integral in four-dimensional units. The Gamma function recurrence and expansion give
Consequently
The divergence is local, so subtract it with a potential counterterm. In the modified minimal subtraction scheme, remove its associated constants as well. The one-loop scalar effective potential becomes
up to an arbitrary field-independent vacuum-energy constant. Another allowed finite subtraction replaces the nonlogarithmic constant. Restoring a loop-counting parameter would multiply the displayed correction by . The logarithm assumes positive curvature ; a background with negative curvature requires an analytic continuation and can have an imaginary part signalling instability.
The quartic case is special because of quartic closure of scalar effective-potential counterterms. If has degree at most four, then has degree at most two and has degree at most four: its pole is removable by the original polynomial couplings and a constant. For example, gives
The last two terms reproduce the one-loop massive phi-fourth counterterms, and the first is a vacuum-energy subtraction. A degree- potential with instead generates degree , forcing new operators. This is the potential-level manifestation of power counting in quantum field theory and four-dimensional renormalizability, even though the finite effective potential itself need not remain polynomial.
Without gauge fixing, gauge-equivalent configurations are integrated repeatedly, and the quadratic gauge-field operator has zero modes along infinitesimal gauge transformations. It therefore has no inverse with which to define perturbative propagators. A gauge condition removes these directions locally in the perturbative expansion. The associated Faddeev-Popov determinant can be represented by anticommuting Faddeev-Popov ghost fields and Faddeev-Popov antighost fields.
First make the normalization explicit. For the fields literally occurring in the action with overall , put
The resulting kinetic terms are canonical, and the interaction terms carry powers of . We use signature and incoming Fourier modes , consistent with the displayed denominators. The quadratic action in the canonical fields is
Color indices are diagonal. Introduce the longitudinal and transverse projectors and . The gauge kinetic matrix is , with inverse . The ghost kinetic operator is . The Gaussian functional integral and Grassmann integral therefore give
The longitudinal formula is understood as the Feynman-prescribed inverse of the kinetic operator; away from its poles the projector inversion is ordinary algebra. The propagators for the original unrescaled fields are times these expressions. Using and gives
with either normalization. This is the longitudinal gauge propagator contraction.
The canonical ghost interaction comes directly from the covariant derivative:
For incoming antighost momentum , the derivative supplies ; the expansion of supplies another . Thus the ghost-gluon vertex is , as requested. For unrescaled fields its coefficient is instead . The printed order- rule presupposes canonical normalization; keeping the overall and an order- vertex for the same unrescaled variables would mix conventions. Choosing Fourier modes instead reverses the vertex sign and must be done consistently for all momentum assignments.
In Feynman gauge, , the one-loop ghost two-point graph has one internal ghost line and one internal gauge line joined by two such vertices. The external ghost line is open, so it does not carry a closed ghost-loop minus sign. With an orthonormal adjoint basis, the structure constants are totally antisymmetric, and the color product along this line is . The two internal propagators supply , leaving a positive color-and-vertex factor for the amputated insertion. Define
The amputated insertion is . Restoring the two external canonical ghost propagators gives the one-loop contribution
The literal unrescaled correlator in the question is , hence of order , whereas its tree term is . In the dimensionless renormalized coupling convention adds multiplying in the canonical loop term.
To evaluate the Feynman integral, combine the denominators with a Feynman parameter:
Shift . The denominator becomes , and the numerator is . The odd term vanishes in translation-invariant dimensional regularization. For spacelike , a Wick rotation converts the remaining integral into a Euclidean one and cancels the prefactor . The needed radial integral is
Indeed, spherical coordinates and leave a beta integral ; the angular factor cancels . Establish this first in a convergent range and then analytically continue in . Substituting yields
This is the printed result, including the factor in its Minkowski-space definition. Equivalently the parameter integral is . Symmetry under also gives as times the massless scalar bubble, independently checking the numerator factor.
Write . Since and the parameter integral tends to , the pole is
Here is off shell and nonzero, separating the ultraviolet pole from massless infrared issues. The unrescaled amplitude has an extra factor . The divergence is proportional to the existing ghost kinetic operator, so the one-loop ghost kinetic counterterm in Feynman gauge is local:
It inserts into the inverse propagator, cancelling the divergent insertion . With the two external propagators attached, its contribution is , cancelling the displayed connected amplitude pole. In the original variables the same action term is . If instead one defines dimensional regularization by , the identical counterterm is written ; the factor of two is purely the regulator convention.
The superficial degree of divergence is the power of a common large-momentum scale obtained by scaling all independent internal momenta together, before cancellations or subtraction of divergent subdiagrams. In a scalar field theory with a standard quadratic kinetic term and non-derivative interactions, each loop momentum integral supplies powers of momentum and each internal propagator supplies minus two. Thus
For a connected Feynman diagram, counting vertex half-edges and applying the stated identity for the loop order gives
It follows that . Meanwhile, . Substitution proves
This power counting in quantum field theory concerns the overall scaling: even a Feynman diagram with can contain divergent subdiagrams, and cancellations may improve convergence when .
The canonical mass dimensions are and . A finite polynomial scalar field theory has power-counting renormalizability when its interactions have nonnegative mass dimensions and the allowed local counterterms form a finite set closed under subtraction of divergent subdiagrams. For , non-derivative interactions therefore satisfy . Equivalently,
so adding vertices of such interactions cannot force an indefinitely increasing number of external legs or derivatives in divergent counterterms. In dimensions a fixed finite polynomial still has this favorable power counting in quantum field theory; the displayed upper bound on is intended only for .
For six-dimensional cubic scalar field theory, and yield
The coupling has zero mass dimension. The possible overall divergences have : vacuum energy, a linear tadpole diagram term, a mass term, a kinetic term, and a cubic interaction. These are finitely many local counterterms. Divergent subdiagrams of higher-point Feynman diagrams are removed by the same counterterms, establishing perturbative renormalizability of cubic scalar theory in six dimensions. A real cubic potential is unbounded below, so this claim is one of perturbative quantum field theory, not a claim that the polynomial defines a stable nonperturbative vacuum.
After Wick rotation, use the Euclidean action with positive kinetic and mass terms and interaction . The Euclidean momentum-space Feynman rules are: an internal scalar propagator , a vertex , momentum conservation at each vertex, integration for each independent loop, and division by the Feynman-diagram symmetry factor. Strip the overall momentum-conserving delta function and external propagators when computing an amputated Green's function.
The one-particle-irreducible two-point vertex at one loop is the bubble:
Figure 1.
One-loop cubic scalar two-point bubble with symmetry factor two
. Details.
Interchanging its two internal lines is an automorphism, giving Feynman-diagram symmetry factor two. In the normalization of the printed Minkowski amputated Green's function, the two vertices contribute , the two internal propagators contribute , and Wick rotation supplies the overall already factored out there. Thus the Euclidean bubble contribution is
For this self-energy calculation we impose a vanishing one-point function, so tadpole diagram insertions are canceled by the linear counterterm. Without that convention a connected but one-particle-reducible Feynman diagram with a tadpole insertion is also possible: both external legs attach to one vertex, a zero-momentum line joins it to a second vertex, and that second vertex has a self-loop. Its amputated contribution is , independent of . It is not the bubble drawn above; keeping it without a tadpole subtraction would add this constant to the full amputated answer.
To find the bubble's local divergence, put and expand at large :
Odd terms vanish under the angular integral. Rotational symmetry gives . The terms through order are therefore
and the coefficient approaches . Terms of order and higher are integrable at infinity in six dimensions; subtracting the two displayed terms leaves an ultraviolet-convergent integral. Hence the divergent part is a local polynomial , with momentum-independent coefficients. For example, when its logarithmically divergent coefficient is
Changing the reference scale in this logarithm only changes a finite local term.
At zero external momentum the spherical ultraviolet cutoff and give
With , integrate . This gives the momentum-cutoff two-point function in six-dimensional cubic scalar theory
In particular, the divergent part of this constant is
while the last term in tends to a finite constant. For the zero-momentum integral gives directly. The finite parts of a local subtraction can depend on the regularization prescription; the conclusion about mass and kinetic counterterms does not.