Bertrand's theorem Created 2026-10-20 Updated 2026-10-24
Joseph Bertrand's theorem states that, among smooth attractive central potentials admitting stable circular orbits, requiring every bound orbit to be closed singles out the inverse-distance potential energy and the isotropic quadratic potential energy, up to additive constants. Rational radial-to-angular frequency ratios near a circular orbit provide only a necessary local closure test; finite-amplitude closure is the additional content. In , the radial-to-angular frequency ratio near a stable circle is , and stability requires and . The all-bound-orbit cases are and .
Bound orbit 2026-10-20
An orbit that remains within a bounded spatial region for all times for which the motion is defined. In an attractive inverse-distance central potential with zero potential energy at infinity, a noncolliding orbit is bound when its total mechanical energy is negative. That sign test depends on the potential and its energy origin; it is not a universal definition of bounded motion. A closed orbit repeats its position and velocity, whereas a general bound orbit can precess without closing.
Circular-orbit energy ratio in a power-law potential Created 2026-10-18 Updated 2026-10-20
A circular orbit in a central potential requires inward force . Thus , giving for the specified zero of potential. The ratio depends on that choice of zero; adding a constant to leaves the orbit unchanged but changes . This is the circular special case of the virial theorem.
For regular low-energy elastic scattering by a finite-range central potential, higher partial waves are suppressed by their centrifugal barriers. Matching the regular interior radial solution to small-argument exterior spherical Bessel functions gives the displayed scaling of scattering phase shift, in the generic absence of a threshold singularity. Since the channel amplitude is proportional to , it scales as . The term is isotropic and normally leads. A tuned vanishing leading amplitude or a threshold resonance requires examining the next terms rather than applying the generic statement blindly.
Partial wave Created 2026-10-03 Updated 2026-10-14
A partial wave is a component of a scattering state with definite orbital angular momentum. A central potential preserves each angular-momentum channel, so the scattering problem decomposes into independent partial waves.
At incident wave number , low kinetic energy means : the de Broglie wavelength is much larger than the scattering region. A generic finite-range scatterer can then be described to leading order without resolving its angular structure. In partial-wave scattering, this is leading S-wave scattering. The spherical harmonic is constant, whereas the centrifugal term impedes penetration to the potential for .
For a central potential with regular threshold behaviour, the finite-range partial-wave threshold law gives . Thus
which is independent of scattering angle. For finite nonzero scattering length , and is isotropic. The potential range and scattering length are different quantities. The claim describes the generic leading S-wave scattering limit; tuned vanishing S-wave scattering amplitude or exceptional threshold resonances require separate analysis rather than a universal angular conclusion.
The rotational invariance of a central-potential Hamiltonian allows a simultaneous eigenstate of energy and the two-dimensional orbital angular momentum . For a separated wavefunction , the Laplacian in polar coordinates gives
The term must be a constant; write . The angular eigenfunctions can be chosen as . Single-valuedness under imposes , hence . The radial equation in the separation of a two-dimensional central-potential eigenstate is
For a real central potential and the usual real self-adjoint radial boundary conditions, the radial equation admits a basis of real solutions: real and imaginary parts of a complex solution obey the same equation and boundary conditions. Choose a real normalized radial eigenfunction. Since the plane area element in plane polar coordinates is , the normalization is
This establishes the intended separated simultaneous eigenstate form. It is not the form of every stationary state. The radial equation depends on , so the and sectors have the same energy. For , their normalized superposition
is a single-valued stationary state with that energy but is not a single angular exponential. Quantum degeneracy is precisely why separation of variables selects a convenient eigenstate basis rather than all vectors in an energy eigenspace. The printed assertion needs this qualification. The printed polar-coordinate aid also labels a gradient component tuple as a divergence; the gradient used below is the two-dimensional vector .
In the classical experiment, particles whose impact parameter lies between and occupy an incident annulus of area
For a spherically symmetric potential, azimuthal symmetry scatters this annulus into the solid-angle strip
Thus the central-potential classical differential cross-section is
If the relation between and has several branches, one sums this expression over every branch. The corresponding diagram consists of an incoming line offset by from the centre, an outgoing asymptote making angle with the incident direction, and the annulus and solid-angle strip just described.
For quantum scattering by a central potential, the far-field wavefunction is
where is the scattering amplitude. The incident plane wave has probability current
To leading order in , the scattered spherical wave has radial current
The scattered rate through area divided by the incident flux is therefore the quantum differential cross-section from a scattering amplitude:
For a differentiable central potential, the force is . The angular momentum is , so
This proves conservation of angular momentum. For , the trajectory lies in the fixed plane perpendicular to . In plane polar coordinates, . Substituting this into the kinetic energy gives the radial energy equation
The second term is the centrifugal contribution to the effective potential. Its radial derivative reproduces . Purely radial motion is the case.
For the satellite, write , with Earth's mass and the satellite's mass. At apogee and perigee, the radial velocity is zero, so angular momentum conservation and conservation of energy give
Eliminating yields
For an elliptic orbit, . Therefore the vis-viva equation at apogee is
Substitution into the orbital energy gives . The circular case follows by continuity, or directly from the radial force balance.
An instantaneous tangential retrograde burn at apogee leaves the position unchanged. For the speed change , the orbital energy change is
Differentiating gives to first order. Since , the vis-viva equation implies . Hence
The factor of two distinguishes the major axis from the semimajor axis. As a finite-change check, the new semimajor axis is exactly
within the instantaneous-burn, unchanged-mass model. Expanding this expression gives the stated result.
For motion in a central potential, conservation of angular momentum gives . In polar coordinates, the conserved mechanical energy is
Consequently, for ,
The sign in distinguishes inward and outward motion. Choosing the orientation so , it is also the sign of . The expression under the square root must be nonnegative. If , the motion is radial and is constant, so cannot be parametrized by this way.
For the power law central potential , differentiate the effective potential:
The circular orbit condition is . Thus, when , and ,
The sign condition expresses attraction. At the force vanishes and there is no nontrivial circular orbit. At , attraction requires and the condition reduces to . In that exceptional case the effective potential is identically zero and every is a possible circular radius for the tuned ; there is no isolated preferred radius. A small radial velocity then gives , rather than an oscillation.
Apply the radial momentum operator to a smooth radial test function. More generally , giving the first two labelled identities. Expanding the square gives the third:
The kinetic-energy decomposition is . A central potential commutes with and , so choose simultaneous angular eigenfunctions , with and . The radial Hamiltonian consequently has the stated centrifugal term. The radial inner product uses measure ; adjoints below are taken on compatible regular bound-state domains. The formal radial momentum is not thereby asserted to be a self-adjoint observable on a half-line.
Set , and . Since formally and ,
The hydrogen radial Hamiltonian factorization follows by matching the Coulomb coefficient, which fixes the Bohr radius
For the second pair of labelled relations, the opposite product changes the sign of , hence
Using in the factorization then gives
This Coulomb angular-momentum intertwining means applying to an energy eigenstate either gives zero or an eigenstate of with the same energy. For a normalized negative-energy state,
At fixed this would become negative if raising continued indefinitely. The bound-state ladder termination by norm positivity occurs at some with , giving
The terminating radial function is proportional to , regular and normalizable; adjoint intertwiners generate lower values at fixed . Positive-energy scattering states are not subject to this terminating negative-energy argument. Here is the mass in the supplied Hamiltonian; including nuclear motion replaces it by the reduced mass.
A continuous symmetry is represented by a unitary family with a self-adjoint conserved generator of a continuous quantum symmetry . If for all , differentiating gives . Thus, for no explicit time dependence,
translation invariance conserves the corresponding momentum component; rotational invariance about one axis conserves that angular-momentum component. A central potential conserves all components and , but the components need not be simultaneously measurable because . Time-translation invariance of a closed system gives a time-independent Hamiltonian and energy conservation.
A discrete symmetry need not have a continuously varying generator. For parity, lets stationary states be chosen even or odd, and preserves parity sectors. symmetry does not force every state to be an eigenstate of its conserved observable. Explicit time dependence adds to the conservation equation, and an external symmetry-breaking potential generally permits exchange with the environment. Degenerate eigenspaces require choosing a compatible common basis rather than assuming every eigenvector already diagonalizes every commuting operator.
orbital angular momentum generates spatial rotations and is . With , its components satisfy
Thus and one component, conventionally , have simultaneous eigenstates, while all three components cannot generally have sharp values. On ordinary single-valued spatial wavefunctions,
The spherical harmonics form an orthonormal angular basis. The integer restriction is specific to orbital wavefunctions; half-integer spin is an intrinsic degree of freedom, not the angular dependence of a scalar spatial wavefunction.
The angular momentum ladder operators obey
The ladder ends at , producing states. A state with specified has a sharp projection , but the angular momentum magnitude is , not . No classical picture of a vector with simultaneously fixed Cartesian components reproduces all these measurement properties.
In a central potential, rotational symmetry gives . separation of variables yields . The radial Schrödinger equation includes a centrifugal potential , which suppresses small-radius amplitude for nonzero . The energy is independent of when rotational symmetry is intact, but need not be independent of . A magnetic field can break that degeneracy. Spatial inversion gives , connecting orbital angular momentum to parity and to the even/odd rotational restriction for the hydrogen spin isomers.
The orbital angular momentum of a particle is the operator , with in the position representation. Its angular momentum commutation relations are
Thus one may specify and one component, conventionally , simultaneously. One generally cannot assign sharp values to all three components, because they do not commute. The common angular eigenfunctions are the spherical harmonics:
For a scalar orbital wavefunction, single-valuedness in the azimuthal angle gives integer , and regularity on the sphere and termination of the ladder give integer . Half-integer angular momenta describe intrinsic spin rather than scalar orbital motion.
The ladder operators obey . Their normalized action is
The coefficient vanishes at the top or bottom of the multiplet. Its squared magnitude follows from , and positivity of the resulting norm constrains the allowed values.
For a central potential, the Hamiltonian commutes with and every component of . Stationary states can be separated as , and rotational symmetry makes the energy independent of , giving a quantum degeneracy at fixed radial label and . Additional degeneracy between distinct values requires additional structure, as in the Coulomb potential. The parity of is . These results organize atomic orbitals and their selection rules. They describe quantized rotation and symmetry, without assigning the electron a classical orbit or a simultaneously definite three-component angular momentum vector.
A central potential conserves angular momentum and confines a nonradial orbit to a plane. With reduced mass , the radial motion obeys
Turning points satisfy . A radially bounded allowed interval gives bound motion, whereas an interval reaching infinity permits escape. The energy sign alone classifies these only with suitable assumptions about and barriers. Circular orbits satisfy and are radially stable when . Bound orbits in a general central potential need not close: successive periapses can precess.
For attractive inverse-square gravity, and
Ellipses have , , and the attracting centre at a focus; parabolic and hyperbolic escape have and . Conservation of angular momentum gives equal swept areas in equal times. The inverse-square law additionally yields . These are Kepler's laws; a harmonic central potential is another example with closed bound orbits, while generic central laws produce precession.
In a gravitational assist, a spacecraft's asymptotic speed relative to a planet is approximately unchanged but its direction turns. Transforming to the frame in which the planet has velocity gives
The spacecraft can gain or lose orbital energy; the planet supplies the compensating energy and momentum, with a very small velocity change because of its large mass.
Repulsive Coulomb scattering instead has . For incident relative kinetic energy and impact parameter , the hyperbolic orbit gives
This Rutherford scattering formula follows by equating the incident annulus to the scattered solid-angle ring. It assumes classical elastic scattering by a point Coulomb centre; screening, finite nuclear size or quantum effects can change the applicable regime.
For a central potential, angular momentum is conserved and the motion lies in a plane. With , radial energy conservation becomes
Allowed radii have ; equality gives radial turning points. A well with two finite turning points gives regular radially bound motion. Access to arbitrarily large radii gives an unbound branch, while access to the origin can lead to collision in a singular potential. Stationary points are circular-orbit candidates; a strict local minimum gives radial stability. For a potential tending to zero at infinity, energy relative to that asymptote is useful, but a singular inner potential and centrifugal barrier must still be examined.
Integrating the angular-momentum relation with the origin of angle at gives
For at , the effective potential is . It is exactly the Kepler effective potential with , provided that expression is real. Equal radial energy and initial radial phase therefore give identical , although the angular motion differs. Writing for the Kepler angle, . With matched periapsis origins,
Here and the eccentricity is fixed by radial energy. For , and successive periapses are separated by , so there is retrograde apsidal motion relative to a closed Kepler ellipse. The radial equivalence is the relevant content of the Newton's theorem of revolving orbits.
For the pure inverse-cube central force set . The free-particle reference orbit at is a straight line, , not a finite- conic with its old held fixed. To cover attractive as well as repulsive cases completely, put
where primes denote angle derivatives and . The inverse-cube central orbit classification gives the following physically positive-radius branches.
For , write with , so . These are scattering orbits with positive energy and an inner turning radius ; the angular interval between the two infinite-radius ends is . Repulsion () gives an interval smaller than ; weak attraction () gives a larger interval and can cause winding. The limit is the straight line.
For , . If , reciprocal-linear spirals connect an infinite-radius end to collision at infinite accumulated angle. If and , every radius admits a circular solution at zero energy: attraction exactly balances centrifugal acceleration. Each is a marginal circular orbit under an inverse-cube force, with no radial restoring force.
For , put and . Up to angle shifts and reversal, the three energy classes are
with positive-radius domains understood. The negative-energy branch is radially bounded but reaches the singular centre on either side of its outer turning point; it is not a regular closed orbit. Collision requires additional physics to continue through . Zero angular momentum gives radial trajectories and is excluded from the angular parametrization above.
Figure 1.
Original representative inverse-cube orbit branches, with force sign and critical attraction distinguished
. Details.
For a central potential use . An infinitesimal rotation about any constant unit vector has and . Noether's theorem gives , where . Since is arbitrary, every component of angular momentum is conserved. A time-translation symmetry has , , giving and
as conserved quantities.
A scattering phase shift measures the change of a partial wave's outgoing phase relative to the free radial solution. For a real central potential and elastic scattering, probability conservation gives a unit-modulus Partial-wave S-matrix . Indeed
so the incoming amplitude is unchanged and the outgoing one acquires .
Expanding an incident plane wave in Legendre polynomials and comparing the outgoing spherical wave gives
Use and to remove cross terms:
This is the elastic total scattering cross-section for the one-particle central-potential problem, with no identical-particle symmetrization factor.