Past exam of the mathematics course of the University of Cambridge 2008 iii Paper 65 2 Solution Created 2026-10-03 Updated 2026-10-14
For a Lie group , Left translation on a Lie group and right translation on a Lie group are the diffeomorphisms and . Their differentials identify the tangent space at the identity with every tangent space. Translating a basis of the Lie algebra gives global left-invariant vector fields and right-invariant vector fields . Left and right translations commute. If , thenThe opposite sign for the right-invariant frame is essential.
Define an affine connection by declaring the parallel. Explicitly, . Its curvature form of a connection vanishes, since successive derivatives of the component functions satisfy the vector-field commutator identity. Its torsion tensor isSimilarly, declaring the parallel gives another flat affine connection , with . In a left-invariant frame the latter connection obeysTo see this, express . Along , differentiation of gives , producing the displayed bracket. Consequently for left-invariant . These are the flat translation connections on a Lie group. They have opposite torsion; if is Abelian, both torsion tensors vanish and the two connections coincide. The phrase “with torsion” does not mean nonzero torsion for Abelian groups.
The average is again an affine connection and satisfies for left-invariant fields. Its torsion tensor is zero. With the curvature convention , the Jacobi identity givesDefine the Ricci tensor by . Since , this giveswhere is the Killing form. Thus the canonical torsion-free connection on a Lie group is generally curved. Its exact flatness criterion is : Abelian and two-step nilpotent groups are exceptions. A vanishing Ricci tensor alone does not prove flatness.
For a semisimple Lie algebra, the Killing form is nondegenerate. Its adjoint invariance gives , so translating it defines a bi-invariant pseudo-Riemannian metric . For left-invariant fields,A metric-compatible torsion-free connection is uniquely the Levi-Civita connection; therefore is its Levi-Civita connection. Moreover,The special feature is a canonical nondegenerate metric and an Einstein manifold structure. The metric need not be positive definite: noncompact semisimple groups generally require indefinite signature. For compact semisimple groups, using gives a bi-invariant Riemannian metric with instead.
Past exam of the mathematics course of the University of Cambridge 2008 iii Paper 65 5 Solution Created 2026-10-03 Updated 2026-10-14
Identify the ambient real four-dimensional vector space with real matrices byFor , the linear action preserves this quadratic form. It gives a group homomorphism to the special orthogonal group of signature ; its determinant on matrix space is . The group is connected: an oriented Gram–Schmidt factorization writes every element as a rotation times an upper triangular matrix with positive diagonal and determinant one, and each factor varies in a connected space. Thus the image lies in the identity component .
If for every , taking gives . A matrix commuting with every real matrix is scalar, and its determinant-one condition then gives . The kernel is therefore exactly . Infinitesimally the action is , with traceless. If this vanishes for every , then and it is scalar and traceless, hence zero. The differential is injective; source and target Lie algebras each have dimension six, so it is an isomorphism. The image is therefore an open subgroup of the connected target, which must be the entire target. ConsequentlyThe finite quotient is by the diagonal central subgroup, not by a sign in just one factor. The connected-component subscript is a genuine qualification of the source's displayed formula: the full is disconnected and cannot be isomorphic to a quotient of the connected product.
Let the anti-de Sitter radius be . Its quadric is , or . Thus the map identifies this quadric smoothly and globally with . This is the group model of three-dimensional anti-de Sitter spacetime. The induced Lorentzian metric is bi-invariant, since the two matrix multiplication actions preserve the ambient quadratic form. At the identity, tangent matrices are traceless andIndeed, for a traceless matrix , , and polarizing gives this metric. For the Killing form is : in the basis , and , the brackets are , , , giving , and the remaining independent pairings zero. Therefore .
The canonical torsion-free connection on a Lie group is the Levi-Civita connection of this bi-invariant pseudo-Riemannian metric. Its Ricci tensor, already calculated from the double bracket, isSubstitution into the vacuum Einstein field equations givesThus the group metric solves the three-dimensional vacuum equations with negative cosmological constant.
The antipodal map is , multiplication by the central element . Hence the antipodal quotient is , with the same local curvature and cosmological constant. To see the global time issue, useThe induced metric isOn the quadric has period ; curves with fixed are closed timelike curves. The antipodal identification is , and does not eliminate this problem. At , even the half-period time shift closes after the antipodal quotient.
If global time is not identified, take the universal cover, with . The topology of is , as follows from the same rotation–triangular decomposition, so the universal cover is diffeomorphic to and carries the lifted group structure . The metric and Einstein equation are unchanged locally. Here is a global time function with timelike gradient, excluding closed causal curves. Unwrapped anti-de Sitter spacetime is the universal covering group, rather than the original embedded quadric or its antipodal quotient; retaining the antipodal time-shift identification would wrap time again.
Past exam of the mathematics course of the University of Cambridge 2009 iii Paper 45 2 Solution Created 2026-10-03 Updated 2026-10-14
Let , where . In the given basis, the Adjoint representation of a Lie algebra isThe Jacobi identity gives , so , as required for a Lie algebra representation. The Killing form is the symmetric Trace form of a Lie algebra representationCyclicity of the trace proves its invariance directly:In components this is precisely , so the Killing form is an invariant bilinear form on a Lie algebra.
Choose the infinitesimal gauge transformation convention , with , and write . A gauge covariant derivative must satisfy for ; henceEquivalently . Expanding makes the cancellation transparent:Thus : it transforms in the same representation as . In adjoint covariant derivative notation, .
The commutator of two gauge covariant derivatives defines the gauge field strength:ThusConjugating the derivative commutator gives , so the gauge field strength transforms homogeneously in the Adjoint representation:Even if the matrices in a particular matter representation are not faithful, the displayed component formula defines the Lie-algebra-valued curvature independently of that representation.
Only contributes to the Yang-Mills theory Lagrangian, since is symmetric in . Thus take to be a constant real symmetric bilinear form. Its infinitesimal variation isArbitrary local field strengths and gauge parameters give the necessary and sufficient invariant gauge kinetic form conditionAn antisymmetric part is unconstrained but contributes nothing. A nondegenerate kinetic term additionally needs a nondegenerate bilinear form; positive energy additionally needs a positive internal metric in the signature convention. Neither extra condition follows solely from gauge invariance. For a compact simple real Lie algebra, is positive definite and is the standard choice up to a positive factor.
For the intended complex-simple setting, the Killing form is nondegenerate. Consequently write any invariant bilinear form on a Lie algebra uniquely as . Invariance of both forms impliesfor every , so commutes with the Adjoint representation. A subspace invariant under all adjoint maps is an ideal, hence simplicity makes the adjoint representation irreducible. By Schur lemma, , giving the uniqueness of an invariant bilinear form on a simple Lie algebra:The same conclusion holds for compact simple real algebras by complexification, with real; nondegeneracy excludes , and positive energy selects in the stated convention.
There is a genuine real-simple exception to uniqueness of the Killing form if “simple” is read as an arbitrary real simple algebra. Regard as real. It is real simple: its complexification consists of two complex simple factors exchanged by conjugation, so a conjugation-stable ideal is zero or the whole algebra. Both and are real symmetric invariant forms, while . With , the Killing form of the special linear Lie algebra gives and . Therefore the imaginary part cannot be a real multiple of . The uniqueness conclusion requires the customary complex-simple or compact-real interpretation.
Past exam of the mathematics course of the University of Cambridge 2009 iii Paper 58 3 Solution Created 2026-10-03 Updated 2026-10-14
Use matrix multiplication together with the wedge product of differential forms, suppressing wedge symbols in this calculation. Set and . The gauge field strength varies as , the covariant exterior derivative of . The matrix trace has graded cyclicity, for forms of degrees . Thus the Chern-Simons 5-form can be expanded asFor example, the two cross terms in both become ; combining the remaining two terms gives the displayed coefficients. This expansion keeps track of the noncommuting products rather than treating as a scalar one-form.
Put . Vary the first term and use the graded exterior derivative to move derivatives off :Here . For the next term use . Graded cyclicity then givesFinally all five contributions to are equal under the matrix trace, giving . Combining these results proves the variation of the Chern-Simons 5-form:Consequently, on an oriented five-manifold ,The boundary term vanishes for a closed manifold, for variations supported in its interior, or when the tangential boundary connection is held fixed. A different boundary variational problem would require boundary conditions or a boundary action as well.
Write in a basis of the Lie algebra. Independent compactly supported variations of each component yield the bulk Euler-Lagrange equationsEquivalently, with , these are . The symmetry of the two curvature two-forms accounts for the anticommutator. Writing simply as a full matrix equation requires an additional assumption: variations must span a matrix algebra paired nondegenerately by the matrix trace. For a smaller Lie algebra, only its trace-paired projection is constrained. If the trace is literally taken in the adjoint representation of a semisimple Lie algebra, its symmetric cubic invariant vanishes, and these bulk equations are identically zero. Indeed, the adjoint generators are skew with respect to the nondegenerate invariant Killing form; transposition in this pairing reverses the sign of the symmetrized trace of three generators. The usual nontrivial five-dimensional theory therefore needs an invariant cubic trace that does not vanish; saying that the gauge field transforms in the adjoint alone does not specify such a trace.
Under a Yang-Mills gauge transformation, use , so . For any Lie-algebra element ,Since is still in the Lie algebra, the right-hand side vanishes whenever the original field satisfies every equation. Every gauge transform of a bulk solution remains a bulk solution. This conclusion follows from covariance of the field equations; it does not require the action itself to be exactly invariant under all large gauge transformations or under transformations changing prescribed boundary data.
Past exam of the mathematics course of the University of Cambridge 2009 iii Paper 6 2 Solution Created 2026-10-03 Updated 2026-10-14
Let be the given invariant bilinear form on a Lie algebra. Choose a basis and its -dual basis , so . The Casimir element isThe tensor is the inverse tensor of , so it is independent of the chosen basis. Multiplication in the universal enveloping algebra therefore makes independent of that choice as well.
For , write . Invariance means , whence . Thereforeby interchanging in the second sum. Since generates its universal enveloping algebra, is central. This argument does not require adding a symmetry assumption to the given bilinear form.
For the sl2 Lie algebra, takeThe cyclic identity for the trace gives . The form is nondegenerate, since , , and all the other pairings except are zero. The dual of is , soBy the classification of finite-dimensional sl2 representations, an irreducible of dimension has a highest-weight vector with and , where . Since , one obtainsCentrality and the Schur lemma then give the answer on the entire representation:This Casimir eigenvalue for sl2 depends on normalization. Choosing the Killing form instead, , scales the dual basis and the Casimir element by , giving .
Past exam of the mathematics course of the University of Cambridge 2012 iii Paper 1 3 Solution Created 2026-10-03 Updated 2026-10-07
A finite-dimensional complex Lie algebra is a semisimple Lie algebra when its solvable radical is zero, equivalently when it has no nonzero solvable ideals. Its Killing form is the symmetric bilinear formThe cyclic trace identity and giveThus the Killing form is an invariant bilinear form on a Lie algebra. In particular its radical is an ideal.
We supply the trace argument needed for nondegeneracy rather than assuming the Cartan criterion for semisimplicity. The matrix form of the Cartan solvability criterion says: if and for every , , then is solvable. To prove this direction, fix . Let be its generalized eigenspace decomposition, and define to act on by the scalar . On , the semisimple part of has eigenvalue , whereas acts by . Polynomial interpolation on the finitely many eigenvalues, with all derivatives through the sizes of the nilpotent blocks set to zero, therefore givesHere the same difference always has the same conjugate, so the interpolation is consistent; the prescribed zero derivatives remove every nilpotent block. Since , it follows that .
Write . By cyclicity and the trace hypothesis,On the other hand, . Thus all eigenvalues of vanish, and every element of is nilpotent. The Engel theorem makes nilpotent as a Lie algebra, hence solvable; is abelian, so is solvable. This is the Conjugate-spectrum proof of Cartan solvability.
Apply this to the Killing radical . For , the adjoint actions preserve and act as zero on , because is an ideal. Computing traces in a basis adapted to givesThe matrix Lie algebra consequently satisfies the trace criterion and is solvable. Its kernel is , an abelian ideal; a central extension of a solvable algebra is solvable. Thus is solvable. This proves the reusable assertion that the Killing radical is a solvable ideal. Semisimplicity forces , and hence is nondegenerate.
A Cartan subalgebra is a nilpotent subalgebra which is self-normalizing:For a complex semisimple algebra this is equivalently a maximal toral subalgebra. The nilpotent, self-normalizing definition permits a proof of the restricted nondegeneracy without first assuming the toral characterization.
Use the generalized-weight decomposition for a nilpotent Lie algebra for the adjoint action of :For completeness, the stability underlying this decomposition follows directly from nilpotence of . For fixed , every on is nilpotent. If and in a finite-dimensional representation, then for sufficiently large . The identityshows that preserves each generalized eigenspace of . Starting with a basis of , refine these primary decompositions successively; all summands remain -invariant. Each resulting summand has only one eigenvalue for each basis element. The Lie theorem triangularizes the action on that summand, so those eigenvalues extend to a single linear character on all of . This proves the displayed decomposition and nilpotence of all shifted operators there.
Since is nilpotent, . The space is a subalgebra: repeated use of the derivation rule for shows that the bracket of two generalized zero-eigenvectors is another such vector. If , the adjoint action of on this quotient consists entirely of nilpotent maps. The Engel theorem supplies a nonzero coset with , contradicting self-normalization. Therefore the zero generalized weight space of a Cartan subalgebra is exactly .
Finally, when . Choose with and put . On , a power vanishes. On , is invertible. For and , write ; invariance givesIf is orthogonal to , it is now orthogonal to every summand of , so nondegeneracy of implies . The restriction is nondegenerate. This establishes the nondegeneracy of the Killing form on a Cartan subalgebra for every Cartan subalgebra, without requiring a chosen root basis.
Past exam of the mathematics course of the University of Cambridge 2012 iii Paper 1 4 Solution Created 2026-10-03 Updated 2026-10-07
A Lie algebra representation is completely reducible when it is a direct sum of irreducible submodules. In finite dimension this is equivalent to saying that every submodule has an invariant complementary subspace. Indeed, one may split off a minimal nonzero submodule and induct on dimension; conversely, if is a finite sum of simple submodules, choose a maximal sum of these with . If , some simple summand is not contained in . Then by simplicity, so is a larger sum disjoint from , a contradiction. Thus .
We prove the required splitting by Haar averaging produces invariant complements. The structural input is the compact real form of a complex semisimple Lie algebra: there is a real semisimple algebra with , whose simply connected integrating Lie group is compact. This structural fact is independent of the complete-reducibility assertion. One standard construction uses root vectors normalized so that , with real structure constants compatible with the involution and . The real spanis closed under brackets, complexifies to , and has negative-definite Killing form. The compactness criterion for real semisimple Lie algebras then gives a compact simply connected . Thus this route uses root structure and compact integration, not the theorem being proved.
Restrict to . The integration of a Lie-algebra representation gives a representation , since is simply connected. Choose any positive-definite Hermitian inner product and average using normalized Haar measure:The integral exists by compactness. It is positive-definite because for , and it is -invariant by translation invariance of Haar measure. Equivalently, every with is skew-Hermitian for this inner product.
Let be an -submodule. It is invariant under , hence under the exponentials generating the connected group . For , and ,Consequently the orthogonal complement is -invariant, and differentiation makes it -invariant. It is a complex vector subspace, so it is also invariant under and hence under . Therefore as -modules.
Induction on now expresses as a finite direct sum of irreducible submodules. Every finite-dimensional representation of a finite-dimensional complex semisimple Lie algebra is completely reducible. The compact real form need not be the real form originally used to present ; in particular the averaging argument does not require the given presentation to be unitary.
Past exam of the mathematics course of the University of Cambridge 2012 iii Paper 48 3 Solution Created 2026-10-03 Updated 2026-10-07
Use a real Lie algebra convention . Its Adjoint representation of a Lie algebra acts on itself:Linearity is immediate. The Jacobi identity givesso , the defining Lie algebra representation condition. In the basis , its matrix entries areThus the adjoint generators are the structure constants arranged as matrices. The representation has kernel equal to the center of a Lie algebra; it need not be faithful for an arbitrary algebra.
The Adjoint representation of a Lie group is . It satisfies , preserves the identity, and sends inverses to inverse matrices. Differentiating gives , soConsequently the positive adjoint exponentials furnish the representation on elements and their products, and the intrinsic conjugation action defines it globally.
The inverse-conjugation formula in the PDF needs a minus adjoint exponent with this standard definition. Its first-order term is , whereas has first-order term . For example in a nonabelian algebra with already distinguishes the two. The inverse conjugation and adjoint antirepresentations identity explains the group-order issue as well: satisfies . Retaining the printed inverse conjugation as a left action without this order reversal would not give an ordinary group representation.
The Killing form is the symmetric bilinear formTo prove degeneracy for a non-semisimple Lie algebra, take its nonzero solvable radical and the last nonzero member of its derived series of a Lie algebra. This is a nonzero abelian ideal of a Lie algebra. For , maps into and kills . Every preserves . Hence maps the full space into and has zero restriction there, so its trace is zero. Thus for every . This is the abelian ideals lie in the radical of the Killing form argument, and establishes a nonzero kernel and vanishing determinant.
For a compact real semisimple Lie algebra, the adjoint action is unitary in an invariant positive inner product. Its infinitesimal generators are skew-Hermitian, givingStrictness follows because the adjoint kernel is the zero center. This explains the compactness criterion from the Killing form: “strictly negative” means negative-definite, not that every entry of its matrix is negative.
In the first three-generator example, take columns to be images of the basis . Direct use of the brackets givesTaking traces of products yields the Killing form for cyclic three-generator bracketsIt is nondegenerate, hence semisimple by the preceding degeneracy result, but it has mixed signature and is not compact. An explicit realization iswhich span the real traceless two-by-two matrices and satisfy exactly these brackets.
Past exam of the mathematics course of the University of Cambridge 2013 iii Paper 1 3 Solution Created 2026-10-03 Updated 2026-10-07
A finite-dimensional Lie algebra over the complex numbers is a semisimple Lie algebra when its solvable radical is zero, equivalently when it has no nonzero solvable ideals. Its Killing form isThe cyclic property of the trace makes this bilinear form symmetric and gives its invariance of a bilinear form on a Lie algebra:It follows that is an ideal of a Lie algebra. For , induces the zero map on . Therefore, for , the matrix trace splits over the invariant subspace and the quotient to give . In particular . The Cartan solvability criterion implies that is solvable. Since is semisimple, : the Killing form is nondegenerate.
For completeness, the trace step in the Cartan solvability criterion is precisely the mechanism of the previous solution. For a complex matrix Lie algebra with for , , set and . If and , then , since . Linearity and the trace orthogonality nilpotence lemma show that every member of is nilpotent. The Engel theorem makes nilpotent and hence solvable. Apply this to ; the kernel of this Adjoint representation of a Lie algebra is the abelian center of , so is solvable as claimed.
For an arbitrary complex Lie algebra, a Cartan subalgebra means a nilpotent Lie algebra that is self-normalizing: . This definition does not assume that is abelian. We prove that it is abelian when is semisimple.
Use the generalized-weight decomposition for a nilpotent Lie algebra for the action of on . Its zero generalized weight space isWe have , since is nilpotent. If , the Engel theorem gives a nonzero coset annihilated by every . Its representative satisfies , contradicting . Thus .
For a nonzero generalized weight , choose with . The operator is invertible on and nilpotent on . For , , write with large enough that . Invariance of the Killing form givesOn the other hand, is solvable, so the Lie theorem triangularizes its action on . For , the matrix is strictly upper triangular, while is upper triangular. Thus . Together with , this yields . Nondegeneracy gives .
Finally, if commutes with , it normalizes , hence lies in . Any abelian subalgebra containing consists of such elements. Thus is a maximal abelian subalgebra, indeed .
Past exam of the mathematics course of the University of Cambridge 2013 iii Paper 1 6 Solution Created 2026-10-03 Updated 2026-10-07
The complexification of a Lie algebra is , with the Lie bracket extended complex-bilinearly. Equivalently write , whereComplex conjugation is an antilinear map and a Lie algebra automorphism whose fixed subalgebra is .
If the solvable radical of is nonzero, its complexification is a nonzero solvable ideal of . Conversely the solvable radical of is preserved by complex conjugation, because it is the unique largest solvable ideal. Consequentlyfor , both and belong to . If , is a solvable ideal of . This proves is semisimple if and only if is semisimple. Consistently, the complex Killing form is just the complex-bilinear extension of the real one; its determinant in a real basis is unchanged by extending scalars.
Take the sl2R Lie algebra and the special unitary Lie algebra . Both complexify to . This is immediate for the former; for the latter, the real basis consists of traceless matrices that are skew-Hermitian matrices and is also a complex basis of .
They are not isomorphic as real Lie algebras. Their Killing forms are , but on this is negative definite. On the basis has a diagonal Gram matrix with entries , so the signature of a quadratic form is . A Lie algebra isomorphism preserves the Killing form and therefore its signature.
A real split semisimple Lie algebra has a Cartan subalgebra whose Adjoint representation of a Lie algebra is simultaneously diagonalizable over , so its root-space decomposition is defined over . The example is split: the diagonal Cartan subalgebra has eigenvalues and real root spaces . The example is not split. Invariance makes every skew-adjoint for the positive definite inner product , so its eigenvalues are purely imaginary. If it were diagonalizable over , all these eigenvalues would be zero and . The center is zero, so only has this property; no nonzero split Cartan subalgebra exists. Thus is split and is not.
Past exam of the mathematics course of the University of Cambridge 2014 iii Paper 2 2 Solution Created 2026-10-03 Updated 2026-10-06
The Weyl complete reducibility theorem states that every finite-dimensional Lie algebra representation of a finite-dimensional complex semisimple Lie algebra is a direct sum of Irreducible Lie algebra representations. Equivalently, every invariant vector subspace has an invariant complement.
We use the permitted Casimir operator properties in the following precise form. There is a central quadratic operator commuting with the action on every module; it is zero on the trivial Lie algebra representation, and on every nontrivial finite-dimensional Irreducible Lie algebra representation it is a nonzero scalar . This follows from the Schur lemma and the Casimir eigenvalue , using the Killing form normalization. We also use the permitted one-dimensional-representation fact: a complex semisimple Lie algebra has only trivial one-dimensional representations. Equivalently, it is a perfect Lie algebra, , so a character annihilating brackets must vanish. Neither fact assumes complete reducibility of the module being proved reducible.
First prove that every finite-dimensional short exact sequencewith trivial quotient splits. If is nontrivial irreducible, the Casimir operator has image in and restricts to there. Consequently is a one-dimensional invariant complement to . If is trivial irreducible, has a basis in which every action is . The Lie algebra representation identity makes , so the one-dimensional-representation fact gives and again the sequence splits.
For general , induct on . Choose an irreducible submodule . The induced sequence with kernel and middle term splits by induction. The inverse image of its invariant complement is a submodule fitting into . The irreducible-kernel case gives an invariant line in mapping isomorphically to the quotient. It is also an invariant complement to in . The case starts this induction. This proves splitting of a trivial quotient for a semisimple Lie algebra, including kernels that are not assumed completely reducible.
Now let be any invariant subspace. On the Hom representation the action isLet consist of the maps whose restriction to is a scalar multiple of . This is a submodule, and restriction givesThe right-hand map is surjective because an ordinary linear projection exists; its quotient action is trivial because a commutator with is zero. The splitting just proved supplies an invariant with . Thus intertwines the actions, , andThe cases and are immediate. Choosing an irreducible submodule and repeating this complement construction proves the Weyl complete reducibility theorem. This last step is invariant complement from an equivariant projection.
Dropping finite dimensionality gives an example with the complex simple Lie algebra . Its Verma module of highest weight zero has a basis withwhere . These actions obey , , . The span of is a proper submodule and the quotient is trivial. It has no invariant complement: such a complement would be a trivial line, while is injective on the entire module. Thus a simple Lie algebra can have an infinite-dimensional representation that is not completely reducible, even over .
Past exam of the mathematics course of the University of Cambridge 2014 iii Paper 2 5 Solution Created 2026-10-03 Updated 2026-10-07
Let be a finite-dimensional Lie algebra representation. The form denoted isIt is the Trace form of a Lie algebra representation; the Killing form without a subscript is specifically the case , . The distinction matters: the form of the trivial representation cannot detect whether the algebra is semisimple.
Linearity of and trace proves bilinearity, and cyclicity of the trace gives symmetry. With , and , the representation identity givesThus it is an invariant bilinear form on a Lie algebra, and in particular the Adjoint representation preserves the Killing form.
The Cartan solvability criterion has two useful formulations. For a finite-dimensional complex Lie algebra ,Its matrix version says that a Lie subalgebra is solvable precisely when for all and . We prove the matrix version first, with ordinary trace in .
If is solvable, the Lie theorem makes all its matrices upper triangular. Their commutators are strictly upper triangular, so multiplying such a matrix by an upper triangular one still has zero diagonal and hence zero trace. This proves the easy direction.
Conversely assume the trace-orthogonality condition and fix . We show that all eigenvalues of vanish. Use its Additive Jordan decomposition with . On the generalized eigenspace of , define an auxiliary endomorphism to be . This need not be in ; we only need control of its commutator with .
On , acts by and by . Choose a polynomial with and at the finitely many distinct differences. Polynomial interpolation supplies it because equal differences have equal conjugates. Therefore .
The adjoint compatibility of additive Jordan decomposition identifies as the semisimple part of . Elementary Jordan–Chevalley decomposition gives for a polynomial with . Hence is a polynomial in with zero constant term. Since maps into and preserves that Lie algebra ideal, we obtainNo assumption that , or belongs to was made.
Write with . Cyclicity and the assumed orthogonality now giveOn the other hand the nilpotent parts have zero trace on each generalized eigenspace, soThus all are zero and is a nilpotent endomorphism. This is the Conjugate-spectrum proof of Cartan solvability.
The permitted Engel theorem, in the form needed here, states: a finite-dimensional Lie subalgebra of endomorphisms in which every element is nilpotent has a nonzero vector annihilated by all its elements, and iteration on quotients makes every element simultaneously strictly upper triangular. Apply it to . The strictly upper triangular algebra is nilpotent, so is a nilpotent Lie algebra and therefore solvable. Since is abelian, the derived series of a Lie algebra of terminates too. This proves the matrix criterion.
Apply it to . The condition on is exactly the matrix condition on . Thus is solvable. The kernel of is the center of a Lie algebra, which is abelian, so is solvable as well: once the derived series maps to zero it is central, and its next term vanishes. Conversely a solvable has solvable adjoint image, proving the abstract Cartan solvability criterion in both directions.
A finite-dimensional Lie algebra is a semisimple Lie algebra when it has no nonzero solvable Lie algebra ideal, equivalently its solvable radical is zero. Let . Invariance makes an ideal. For , induces zero on , and the block trace gives , where is the adjoint Killing form of itself. The Cartan solvability criterion therefore makes solvable. If is semisimple, .
Conversely suppose is a nondegenerate bilinear form. If a nonzero solvable ideal existed, its last nonzero derived term would be an abelian ideal of . For and , the operator has image in and is zero on , so its square and its trace are zero. Thus , contradicting nondegeneracy. This is Abelian ideals lie in the radical of the Killing form. We conclude the Cartan criterion for semisimplicity: