QCD supplies the underlying strong interaction; Skyrmions provide a mesonic effective description of baryons, and quantized multi-Skyrmions can model nuclei. These are related descriptions at different scales, not three identical theories.
In QCD, quarks carry color charge and interact through gluons, the gauge fields of the color special unitary group . Its Lagrangian density has the form
Asymptotic freedom makes short-distance processes accessible through small-coupling expansions, but nuclear scales involve strongly coupled, confined dynamics. Observable hadrons are color singlets. A nucleon, either a proton or a neutron, is a baryon with baryon number one; a nucleus contains such units of baryon number. Directly extracting all nuclear binding energies, spectra and interactions from QCD is difficult, motivating low-energy effective field theories that preserve its symmetries and relevant degrees of freedom.
For the two light quark flavours, the small-mass limit has approximate chiral symmetry . Chiral symmetry breaking leaves its vector subgroup , the approximate isospin symmetry. The three pions are the associated Goldstone bosons in the massless limit and pseudo-Goldstone bosons when the light quark masses are retained. Package these pions into a special unitary group field
where is the pion decay constant in this normalization and are the Pauli matrices. The nonlinear sigma model is the leading two-derivative mesonic theory. The Skyrme model adds a specific four-derivative stabilizing interaction. One conventional normalization is
Here is a dimensionless model coupling, not electric charge. The last term accounts for a common pion mass and preserves vector isospin. It vanishes in the chiral massless limit. This effective field theory uses color-singlet mesonic fields and does not resolve constituent quarks or gluons inside a baryon.
The condition at spatial infinity compactifies physical space to . Since is itself a three-sphere, the field defines a map with integer topological charge in . This is identified with the topological baryon number in the Skyrme model:
The associated topological current is identically conserved. A single Skyrmion has , and a multi-Skyrmion with is a candidate intrinsic configuration for an ordinary nucleus; negative charge describes antibaryonic sectors. Integer topology prevents a smooth finite-energy unwinding into the classical vacuum, but it does not by itself guarantee a nonzero-size energy minimum.
The energetic reason for the Skyrme term is Derrick scaling. For the rescaled field in three dimensions, let be the quadratic-gradient, quartic-gradient, and potential energies. Their scale dependence is
The two-derivative nonlinear sigma model alone can lower its static energy by shrinking. The positive quartic Skyrme term instead grows under shrinking, permitting a balance and a stable soliton size. Without the mass term, this balance gives . The displayed scaling convention uses , so it is the inverse of the equally common convention.
The connection with QCD is strengthened by large-Nc baryon scaling. Generalize the number of colors to while keeping fixed. Meson masses remain of order one, their interactions weaken, and an effective mesonic action has an overall scale of order . In the Skyrme model this corresponds to and of order , so the soliton mass and rotational moment of inertia are also of order , whereas rotational level splittings are of order . These are the expected baryon scaling properties of large- QCD. A massive, semiclassical soliton built from meson fields is therefore consistent with the underlying theory, even though physical is only a finite value and the simplest Skyrme model is not uniquely determined by this argument.
To represent a nucleon, a classical Skyrmion must be quantized. The unit Skyrmion hedgehog ansatz ties spatial rotations to isospin rotations. Its collective coordinates include its position and orientation; rotational quantization of a unit Skyrmion gives the rotor spectrum
in units with . The Finkelstein-Rubinstein constraints impose the correct fermionic sign under a nontrivial configuration-space loop. In particular a spatial rotation acts on a charge- state by in the physical odd-color theory: odd admits half-integer spin, while even has integer spin. For , the lowest allowed doublet represents the proton and neutron; the rotor state represents the Delta baryon resonance. A bosonic pion field can therefore describe fermionic baryons because the quantum wavefunction carries this nontrivial topological sign.
For nuclei, minimize the classical energy in a fixed baryon number sector, then quantize the permitted rotations, isospin rotations, and relevant vibrations or relative motions. The toroidal two-Skyrmion has a lowest nuclear state with , identifying it with the deuteron. The cubic four-Skyrmion has an allowed state appropriate to the alpha particle. The rational map approximation for Skyrmions makes these intrinsic symmetries easier to construct, while collective-rotation constraints for a Skyrmion select allowed nuclear quantum numbers. A spin-zero state has rotationally invariant laboratory expectation values; a classical cubic intrinsic field should not be interpreted as a fixed cube visible in every orientation. Collective-coordinate quantization restores this distinction between intrinsic shape and a physical quantum state.
The nuclear force also has a mesonic interpretation. At large separation the tails of Skyrmions are weak pion fields; with nonzero mass their multipole falloff derives from derivatives of the Yukawa potential. Their interaction depends on relative orientation, and after quantization generates the familiar spin- and isospin-dependent pion-exchange structure of the nuclear force. Attractive channels allow several unit Skyrmions to form a lower-energy multi-Skyrmion. In nuclear language the positive nuclear binding energy is the difference between the separated nucleon masses and the mass of the quantized bound state, not just a count of topological units.
The limitations remain physical. The simplest Skyrme model retains only selected terms in a derivative expansion, and finite solitons probe gradients where omitted terms can matter. Its parameters require matching or calibration; predicted binding can be too strong, and masses, radii and spectra are not all fixed correctly by topology. Rotational quantization alone neglects quantum and vibrational corrections, especially when clustering or breakup channels are important. More general mesonic interactions, additional meson fields, and less restrictive classical ansätze can improve the description, but they introduce further low-energy information. The organizing relation is therefore
It links underlying quark and gluon dynamics to a geometric, symmetry-based account of baryons and nuclei, while keeping the distinction between an effective approximation and a full derivation from QCD.
The flavour-diagonal weak neutral current coupled to the real Z boson has real vector and axial current couplings. With , part (e) shows that this tree-level interaction is invariant under CP symmetry, although the simultaneous presence of the Dirac current and axial current generally violates charge conjugation and parity symmetry in quantum field theory separately. This conclusion concerns the tree-level weak neutral current, rather than every interaction or radiative effect in the Standard Model.
The weak charged current couples distinct quark flavours and involves the Cabibbo-Kobayashi-Maskawa matrix:
Here and are left-handed quark fields. A CP symmetry transformation exchanges the two conjugate-field operators; because it acts through a unitary operator, it does not complex-conjugate their numerical coefficients. Equality with the original interaction therefore requires a Cabibbo-Kobayashi-Maskawa matrix that can be made real by quantum field rephasings. With three generations, a physical CP-violating phase remains in general, measured by the Jarlskog invariant. Therefore the W boson interactions can violate CP symmetry. Merely seeing a complex coefficient is insufficient: the phase must survive quantum field rephasing, unlike the real two-generation Cabibbo angle rotation.
A leading short-distance Standard Model contribution to neutral D-meson mixing is a box Feynman diagram with two W bosons and two internal down-type quark lines:
Figure 1.
Short-distance box contribution to neutral D-meson mixing
. Details.
The incoming pair becomes ; the internal labels run over the down quark, strange quark and bottom quark. Each corner is a weak charged current vertex. Four such vertices make the contribution of order . Summing the internal flavours produces Cabibbo-Kobayashi-Maskawa matrix factors and the Glashow-Iliopoulos-Maiani mechanism: the flavour-independent term cancels by . This box Feynman diagram is one contribution; long-distance intermediate hadron states can also contribute to neutral D-meson mixing.
The deep inelastic scattering process contains a virtual photon exchanged between the electron and the hadron:
Use an electromagnetic vector current containing the dimensionless quark charges, with the coupling factored out. The scattering amplitude, up to an irrelevant phase, is
To match the printed prefactor, define the leptonic tensor with a spin sum over both electron spins and keep the initial spin average outside it. The gamma-matrix trace gives
For a stationary target and massless electron, the invariant flux factor is . The inclusive final-state Lorentz-invariant phase-space measure and target spin average are contained in . Thus the differential scattering cross-section is
Here means . If the initial spin average is instead built into the leptonic tensor, its normalization is and the displayed cross-section prefactor must be doubled. The two conventions give the same observable.
Use the massless collinear parton approximation in a high-energy frame: , , and with . This neglects target-mass corrections to the parton model; it does not literally set a stationary massive target to a massless particle in the earlier flux formula.
For a quark of dimensionless charge , the electromagnetic vector current matrix element is . The spin average and gamma-matrix trace give
Integrating the three-momentum Dirac delta function in the parton hadronic tensor leaves
Since , this is
For the massless electron momenta, and . Substitution into the leptonic tensor gives
and likewise . These Ward identities eliminate every term with an exposed index in the contraction. Therefore
Here means equality after contraction with the leptonic tensor. The shortened tensor is not itself conserved; the omitted terms restore current conservation in the full hadronic tensor.
All three interactions respect color charge; quark flavor is conserved by the strong interaction and the electromagnetic interaction, but can change in the weak interaction. These statements concern charges and net numbers, rather than an unchanging inventory of particles.
A quark transforms in the fundamental representation of the color charge gauge group . The strong interaction can change an individual quark's colour by exchanging a gluon, which itself carries color charge. For example, the colour flow is allowed: demanding that the outgoing quark remain red would be incorrect. At each interaction vertex the full colour flow is conserved. The colourless photon, W boson, and Z boson instead couple to a quark with an identity factor in colour space. A weak charged current can therefore change to , but cannot turn into without another coloured participant. External isolated hadrons are colour singlets; confinement prevents direct observation of a free coloured state.
For each quark flavor , define the net quark flavor number . The strong interaction and electromagnetic interaction preserve every : pair creation , for example, changes neither net strangeness nor any other . Their quark couplings are diagonal in quark flavor. The weak charged current contains , where is the Cabibbo-Kobayashi-Maskawa matrix, and changes these net numbers. Weak neutral currents are diagonal in tree-level Feynman diagrams; flavor-changing neutral currents can occur through higher-order Feynman diagrams.
The observed hierarchy of mean lifetimes and decay channels supplies evidence: associated strange-particle production through the strong interaction preserves net strangeness, whereas a kaon's weak interaction decay to pions changes it. The electromagnetic interaction process has zero net quark flavor before and after annihilation. Neutrino oscillations show that individual lepton family numbers are not exact conserved quantities. Within the usual effectively massless-neutrino approximation, charged current decays such as preserve family numbers only when the emitted neutrinos are counted.
Evidence for three colours includes the hadronic R ratio , the colour multiplicities in W boson decay widths, and three-jet events revealing gluon radiation. These test Quantum chromodynamics and its colour structure together; they are not direct measurements of a named red or blue charge on a free quark.
For a purely electromagnetic interaction continuum with five active quark flavors, the usual estimate is . The unspecified particle resonance and the word “total” require qualifications before this can be treated as a unique physical prediction.
In natural units, neglecting final masses, single-photon annihilation gives
Here is the fine-structure constant, the quark electric charge in elementary-charge units, and the factor three counts orthogonal colour final states. Consequently the inverse hadronic R ratio is
With accessible, the denominator is . The corresponding values for and are and . Inclusive Quantum chromodynamics corrections increase the hadronic denominator, approximately by away from thresholds and particle resonances. These are annihilation ratios before selection and detection efficiency corrections, not ratios of uncorrected detector counts.
A future muon-collider Higgs resonance is a plausible reading of part (c), since its narrow decay width makes a detuning of a few relevant. Even then, two further assumptions are necessary. First, being a few below the Higgs boson peak does not eliminate it: for detuning , the ideal narrow Breit-Wigner resonance cross section retains the relative factor
For and this is , not zero. Resonant hadronic production can still change the requested denominator substantially.
Second, at the Z boson continuum is not negligible. A more complete annihilation estimate including both tree-level Feynman diagrams uses
Here is the squared sine of the weak mixing angle, is weak isospin, and is one for a lepton and three for a quark. Thus the continuum ratio is , rather than necessarily . For example, , and give approximately at before Quantum chromodynamics corrections.
If the unspecified particle resonance instead means the Z boson, detuning by a few is tiny compared with its decay width. The resonant ratio remains approximately .[ref] This is a concrete counterexample to treating any slight downward detuning as permission to discard the particle resonance. The source supplies neither its identity nor the detuning and selection needed for a unique all-process ratio. The boxed continuum formula is the charge-counting answer under its stated approximation; a literal total must also include remaining resonant and other accepted hadronic channels.
In ordinary perturbative Standard Model reactions all three interactions conserve electric charge, four-momentum, total angular momentum, baryon number, and total lepton number. The last two are accidental conservation laws of these perturbative processes, not exact nonperturbative statements: electroweak sphalerons violate while preserving baryon-minus-lepton number. Total color charge is respected throughout.
The strong interaction and electromagnetic interaction also conserve each net quark flavor number, including strangeness, charm and bottom flavour. The weak charged current can change them through the Cabibbo-Kobayashi-Maskawa matrix. Isospin is an approximate strong interaction symmetry in the small light-quark mass difference limit; the different electric charges of and break it in the electromagnetic interaction. Approximate flavor symmetry is distinct from exact net-flavour-number conservation by those interactions.
Parity conservation and charge conjugation symmetry hold for the electromagnetic interaction and, assuming a negligible strong CP parameter, the strong interaction. The weak interaction violates both, and also violates CP symmetry in suitable processes. CPT symmetry holds under the usual local Lorentz invariant quantum field theory assumptions. Individual lepton family numbers are conserved in the conventional massless-neutrino approximation but not in neutrino oscillations; an assertion of exact family conservation in all observed reactions would therefore be false.
With the valence quark assignments and , neutral kaon mixing changes strangeness by two units. A representative leading Standard Model contribution is a box Feynman diagram with two W bosons and two internal up-type quarks:
The two lines exchange the two W bosons. There are four weak charged current interaction vertices, so the scattering amplitude is fourth order in the weak gauge coupling, or second order in the Fermi constant. The full result sums the internal quark flavors with their Cabibbo-Kobayashi-Maskawa matrix factors; one box alone illustrates the mechanism.
Figure 1.
Representative charged-current box and two- and three-pion kaon decay diagrams
. Details.
For a three-body leptonic decay through the Fermi interaction, neglecting daughter masses and radiative corrections, lepton universality gives
in natural units. Therefore scaling the muon decay rate by predicts only one leptonic channel, not the total tau lepton decay rate.
The tau lepton has two allowed charged-lepton channels, and , as well as hadronic channels from . Each allowed quark channel has three color charge choices and its Cabibbo-Kobayashi-Maskawa matrix factor. Charm production is kinematically inaccessible in a physical hadronic final state at this mass. Treating the inclusive hadronic channels by a simple quark-hadron duality estimate,
Thus, using and ,
Finite daughter masses, hadronic decay thresholds and resonances, Quantum chromodynamics radiative corrections, and electroweak radiative corrections refine this estimate. The threefold color multiplicity in a decay width and extra decay channels are the main correction to naive fifth-power scaling.
Each quark has baryon number , and each antiquark has baryon number . A strange quark has strangeness , a strange antiquark has strangeness , and the light have zero strangeness. The isospin projections of are , with the opposite values for their antiquarks. Thus
For three valence quarks, and . The baryon octet is reproduced by the following quark model assignments:
BaryonValence quarks
Neutron
Proton
Sigma baryon
Sigma baryon
Lambda baryon
Sigma baryon
Xi baryon
Xi baryon
Consequently the top-left and top-right states in the source diagram are . Here the source's label means the unknown particle at the top right; the conventional symbol elsewhere in this solution denotes flavor hypercharge.
Both central baryons have valence quarks , baryon number , strangeness and isospin projection zero. Their total isospins differ:
The flavor part is symmetric for the Sigma baryon and antisymmetric for the Lambda baryon. In the usual ground state coupling, the associated pair has spin one for and spin zero for , with the strange quark giving total spin in both cases. Distinct total isospin makes these orthogonal states despite their coincident position in the weight diagram.
Measured half-integer spin and fermionic behavior rule out a simple quark-antiquark pair: two spin- constituents have integer total spin, and adding integer orbital angular momentum does not change that. Their measured baryon number , inferred through production and conservation bookkeeping, corresponds to . Their pattern of electric charges, strangeness and isospin then agrees with three light valence quarks.
Baryon magnetic moments provide a more detailed check. The additive quark model gives, for example,
Approximately equal up and down constituent masses give , hence , close to the measured ratio of about .
These observations support three valence quarks; they do not prove the absence of extra quark-antiquark pairs. For instance, also has and can have half-integer spin. Ordinary Quantum chromodynamics baryons also contain sea pairs and gluons. The stronger interpretation that the measurements exclude every antiquark component is therefore false.
Write the charge in units of as . The proton and neutron have and , so their measured charges imply and . Thus , :
This is the Gell-Mann--Nishijima formula, with the full flavor hypercharge . Applying the quark baryon number and the isospin and strangeness assignments from part (a),
Physical electric charges are these numbers multiplied by the positive elementary charge .
beta decay is a weak charged current process. At quark level , with amplitude proportional to at low momentum transfer. A neutron in a nucleus can thereby become a proton:
The second reaction denotes an energetically allowed nuclear conversion, not a decay of an isolated free proton. In a nuclear beta transition the mass number stays fixed and the atomic number changes by one. baryon number and electric charge are conserved; the neutrino or antineutrino supplies the missing energy, momentum and angular momentum. The three-body final state produces a continuous electron spectrum rather than a single electron energy. Neglecting neutrino mass and recoil, an allowed spectrum in electron total energy is
The Fermi function accounts for the electron's Coulomb interaction with the daughter; is the electron total-energy endpoint. forbidden beta decay adds momentum-dependent nuclear shape factors. The V-A interaction violates parity: it couples left-chiral fermion fields, not an equal mixture of left and right currents.
For allowed beta decay the leading leptons have zero orbital angular momentum. Fermi transitions have ; Gamow-Teller transitions have with excluded. Both preserve nuclear parity. Higher lepton partial waves permit forbidden transitions with extra suppression. Nuclear matrix elements and phase space, as well as these selection rules, determine lifetimes. Particle-physics examples include free-neutron decay and pion beta decay, . semileptonic decays test quark mixing and the universality of the weak charged current. beta decay changes quark flavour through virtual W exchange; its continuous spectrum reflects an additional lepton in the final state.
A Feynman diagram specifies a term in the perturbative scattering amplitude, not a measured microscopic trajectory. Assign external spinors or polarization vectors, an interaction factor to each Feynman vertex and a propagator to each internal line; impose four-momentum conservation and integrate over independent loop momenta. Sum amplitudes for indistinguishable alternatives, then square, sum final spins and average unpolarized initial spins. A decay rate uses in natural units; a cross section also divides by incident flux. interference means probabilities of individual diagrams must not simply be added.
The electromagnetic fermion vertex is , with coupling proportional to ; it preserves fermion flavour. There is no elementary three-photon or four-photon vertex in quantum electrodynamics. The weak charged current has and vertices, with a left-chiral projector and a Cabibbo-Kobayashi-Maskawa matrix element at the quark vertex. The weak neutral current has vertices with vector and axial couplings; it includes neutrinos and is flavour diagonal at tree level. Electroweak gauge interactions also include , and quartic , , and vertices. Higgs-fermion and Higgs-vector interactions complete the mass-related scalar sector.[ref]
Quantum chromodynamics has vertices proportional to , plus three-gluon and four-gluon Feynman vertices because gluons carry color charge. A quark-gluon vertex preserves quark flavour. Internal particles need not be on their mass shells, but electric charge and four-momentum are conserved at each vertex. The figures below show representative leading flavour topologies; binding and hadronization are implicit, and additional strong-interaction contributions can modify hadronic amplitudes.
For the neutral strange B meson, a charged-current tree amplitude has followed by , while the initial is a spectator. The pair forms the J/psi meson and the pair forms the phi meson. Charge and quark flavour flow are conserved at each vertex except for the permitted weak flavour change. antiquark arrows point opposite their physical propagation direction.
Figure 1.
Original quark-level charged-current contribution to the neutral strange B-meson decay; arrows show fermion flow
. Details.
Useful reconstruction modes are or , through a virtual photon, and , a strong decay. The latter is the largest individual mode, with also important. For the , the inclusive branching fraction versus reconstruction mode distinction matters: hadronic decays dominate inclusively, principally through three gluons; each charged-lepton pair accounts for about 6%, not most decays. The charm pair lies below open-charm threshold. These distinctions are confirmed by the official particle listings.[ref]
For the lowest spatial state, orbital angular momentum is zero and the spatial wavefunction is symmetric. A three-quark colour singlet is antisymmetric, proportional to . The Pauli exclusion principle for quarks therefore requires a symmetric spin–flavour factor. Colour and flavour are different degrees of freedom even though both use three-dimensional group representations.
The tensor product flavour decomposition is . Three spin-one-half particles have a symmetric spin- quartet and mixed-symmetry spin- sectors. The symmetric spin quartet combines with symmetric flavour factors to give a baryon decuplet. Mixed spin and mixed flavour factors instead combine to a symmetric spin–flavour state, giving one physical ground-state baryon octet, not two independent ground-state octets. Equivalently the symmetric spin-flavour SU6 representation has dimension . The antisymmetric flavour singlet would require a fully antisymmetric three-spin state, which does not exist for only two single-quark spin components.
The spin-one-half baryon octet contains , , and . The spin-three-halves baryon decuplet contains the four charge states, three states, two states and . Both have positive parity in this approximation. Strange-quark mass breaks the approximate flavour symmetry and splits multiplets.
In the baryon hyperfine mass formula, the constituent-mass sum accounts phenomenologically for common confinement energy. A colour-magnetic spin–spin interaction contributes a contact-type term proportional to : each magnetic moment supplies one inverse mass. The common colour and spatial-overlap factors are absorbed into . These are effective constituent masses, not short-distance current-quark masses. Use dimensionless spin operators with , as implicit in the supplied formula and coefficient.
Label the identical up quarks 1 and 2. Their flavour and spatial factors are symmetric, and their colour pair is antisymmetric, so their spin is a triplet, . Thus
Coupling the strange spin gives
The two up–strange denominators are identical. Hence
With the supplied masses expressed in GeV units, the common mass is . The predicted values are
They are about and below the stated measurements, respectively. The predicted splitting is , compared with . The agreement is useful for such a simple model, but a common overlap constant neglects flavour-dependent spatial structure and other residual interactions.
For the weak decay, one contribution is , . The two spectator up quarks combine with into the proton, and the new supplies the neutral pion's corresponding component. This changes strangeness. In the strong decay, a gluon creates ; rearrangement gives and without changing strangeness.
Figure 1.
Original weak and strong quark-level contributions to the two charged Sigma-baryon decays; final groupings show the hadrons
. Details.
The strong channel conserves parity: the positive-parity daughter baryon and negative-parity pion require odd relative orbital angular momentum, with a wave sufficient. The weak channel need not conserve parity. Using the mean lifetime relation ,
The widths differ by about , principally because one is weak and flavour changing and the other is an open strong decay. They are not comparable transitions differing only by a small spin factor.
A physical baryon is a colour singlet. Its three-quark colour factor is antisymmetric, proportional to . In the hypothetical scalar-quark theory, the quarks obey Bose-Einstein statistics, so the complete three-particle state must be symmetric under exchange. At the spatial factor is symmetric, and three zero spins supply no nontrivial spin factor. The flavour factor must therefore be antisymmetric to cancel the antisymmetry of the colour factor.
There is exactly one completely antisymmetric state made from three flavour basis states: the flavour singlet of three scalar quarks,
Equivalently, . A repeated flavour gives zero under complete antisymmetrization. Only one ground-state flavour singlet, containing and having , remains. Keeping fermionic exchange antisymmetry while changing the spins to zero would contradict the assumed Spin-statistics theorem. The standard antisymmetric colour factor and the ordinary-quark flavour decomposition are documented in the quark-model review.[ref]
Evidence for quarks comes from several kinds of observation that test different aspects of their interpretation. The light meson and baryon spectra organize into approximate flavour multiplets with the charges and strangeness expected for and . In particular, the baryon octet and baryon decuplet encode the three light quark flavours and their spin couplings. This is an economical account of hadron quantum numbers, but spectroscopy alone would not establish that the constituents behave as localized scattering centers.
Deep inelastic scattering supplies that second test. In energetic electron–proton scattering the outgoing lepton measures the energy and momentum transferred through a virtual photon, while the broken-up target is summed over. Approximate Bjorken scaling means the structure functions depend primarily on rather than varying rapidly with the resolving momentum scale . It indicates nearly pointlike constituents. In the leading spin-half parton model,
The charge-squared weights and the second relation test the constituents' fractional charges and spin-half nature. Scaling violations reflect quark and gluon radiation rather than a failure of the constituent picture.[ref]
Particle jets give complementary final-state evidence. A high-energy quark produces a collimated spray of hadrons because confinement prevents it from emerging as an isolated particle. Back-to-back jets fit quark–antiquark production; three-jet events show hard gluon radiation. Their angular correlations test a spin-one radiated parton. This distinguishes constituents of hadrons from a literal observation of free fractional-charge particles.
Three independent arguments identify an additional threefold colour degree of freedom. First, the spin-aligned state of a ground-state would have symmetric space, spin and flavour factors. The Pauli exclusion principle requires an antisymmetric additional factor. The three-quark colour singlet supplies it. The same construction accommodates the spin-aligned state of the without altering its measured quantum numbers.
Second, the inclusive hadronic R ratio, away from thresholds and narrow resonances, is at leading electromagnetic order
Each quark flavour has distinguishable colour final states. With , the predicted plateaux for three, four and five accessible flavours are , and ; without the factor three they would be a third as large. The measured inclusive normalization is therefore a colour-counting test, with radiative and threshold corrections included in precision comparisons.[ref]
Figure 1.
Leading colour-counting predictions for the hadronic R ratio; these are model values, not plotted measurements
. Details.
Third, the neutral pion's two-photon amplitude contains a quark-loop colour sum, proportional to ; its rate and the other evidence are consistent with three colours. Quantum chromodynamics identifies this degree of freedom as a gauge charge, with eight gluons. Observed hadrons are colour singlets; the evidence for colour is its quantitative and symmetry consequences, not visible colours or isolated coloured quarks.