The time-translation Killing vector field of the Schwarzschild metric gives a conserved Killing energy per unit rest mass,
For unit rest mass, this is the total energy relative to infinity, including rest energy. At release , so the four-velocity normalization gives and
Substitution into the radial four-velocity normalization yields
Choosing the inward square root and evaluating at the ground proves
This identity is exact within the assumed Schwarzschild metric, despite its familiar Newtonian mechanics form. The quantity is not exactly the locally measured speed. A Schwarzschild static observer measures . Thus the distinction disappears in the stated weak-field approximation, giving for .
Write and . The Christoffel symbols follow from
The relevant time and radial entries, using , are
For the angular geodesic equations, , , and . Thus, with primes on coordinates here denoting proper time derivatives,
Initial conditions are preserved by these ordinary differential equations. The motion is therefore radial, with constant angular coordinates. Choose the polar axis so the apple is away from the angular coordinate singularities.
The exact remaining radial geodesic equation and four-velocity normalization are
Eliminating gives the particularly simple exact result . The supported observer's proper time differs from the apple's proper time by relative corrections of order and . Consequently, to leading order in the weak-field approximation and , , with and zero initial radial velocity. Hence
The proper height measured along a static radial ruler is at this accuracy. The use of means the ground clock's elapsed time, with propagation delays corrected; raw visual arrival times include the changing light travel time.
If variation of over the fall is retained but relativistic corrections are neglected, a useful parametric solution is
Its small- expansion gives the same constant- result. For an exact check on the choice of clock, the initial coordinate acceleration measured using is , which reduces to the displayed approximation.
Approximate Earth by an isolated, nonrotating, spherically symmetric body. By Birkhoff's theorem, the exterior vacuum metric tensor is the Schwarzschild metric. With it is
Here is the areal radius, and are spherical angles, is Schwarzschild time normalized to the proper time of a static observer at infinity, is Earth's mass, the gravitational constant, and the speed of light. The nonzero diagonal metric tensor components are , , , .
The apple is a test particle; neglect its effect on the metric tensor, air resistance, Earth's rotation and nonspherical structure, and external tidal forces. Near Earth's surface, , , and the falling speed remains much smaller than . Thus the Newtonian limit of this metric tensor is appropriate, while the exact radial geodesic is available as a check. A static observer under the tree has proper time , up to an additive constant. Such an observer is supported by the ground and has nonzero proper acceleration; the released apple instead has zero proper acceleration.
The apple's proper time is the time read by a clock carried with it, with for metric signature . At any event choose a local inertial frame with coordinates , in which free motion satisfies at that event. The chain rule gives
Multiplying by the inverse coordinate Jacobian matrix yields the exact geodesic equation
Here are the observer's coordinates, is the apple's four-velocity, and the Christoffel symbols describe the Levi-Civita connection. The last expression applies when the coordinates are locally inertial at the event considered; one such chart need not remain inertial throughout a finite region.
Choose , so . In the weak-field approximation and at small spatial speed compared with , the leading spatial geodesic equation is
It is exact at the release event when all spatial vanish, and is the intended approximation to the displayed expression in the source. Terms and cannot generally be dropped; the time component must also be retained to find changing . For a concrete counterexample to the unrestricted expression, a straight free trajectory , in flat spacetime has polar radius and , although . The missing angular term supplies that radial coordinate acceleration.
Use the observed present photon temperature . This is an additional observational input, consistent with [ref]. Standard neutrino decoupling and electron-positron entropy transfer give
For nonrelativistic relic neutrinos this is the temperature parameter of the redshifted momentum distribution, not the temperature of a newly thermalized gas of massive particles.
The photon number density from part b is
One neutrino mass eigenstate and its antineutrino have two populated helicity states. Thus
The total over three species is about , including antineutrinos. Comoving number conservation preserves these abundances after the particles become nonrelativistic.
For the supplied ,
Assuming nonnegative other energy components, relic neutrino rest-mass density cannot exceed the near-critical total density. With the common per-species abundance ,
Using the total would instead bound the mean mass, not the sum. This critical-density bound on the sum of relic neutrino masses is deliberately conservative: baryons, dark matter and dark energy leave less density available. It assumes the standard thermal abundance, negligible chemical potentials, no later dilution or extra populated states, and the idealized decoupling count. Small non-instantaneous-decoupling corrections do not matter for this estimate.
As the plasma cools through electron-positron annihilation, the pairs transfer their entropy to the coupled photons. Neutrinos have largely decoupled and do not share that heating in the instantaneous-decoupling approximation. Before annihilation the electromagnetic entropy count is
while after it . Conservation of electromagnetic comoving entropy, , gives the relative photon heating factor
Equivalently afterward. The exact count compares an asymptotic relativistic pair bath with the pair-free bath; at the supplied temperature some finite-electron-mass entropy loss has already begun.
The word “rises” requires care. The photons become hotter than an otherwise freely redshifting bath at the same scale factor; their absolute temperature need not rise during the expansion. In the smooth equilibrium process,
since the pair contribution grows with temperature. This monotonic photon cooling during pair annihilation is slower than while increases. The factor compares the photon temperature with the freely redshifting neutrino bath, not two consecutive absolute temperatures along the expanding history.
For zero chemical potential, each species contributes . Thus
Entropy density scales as at fixed relativistic particle content; total entropy also includes the changing proper volume. An isolated adiabatically expanding comoving gas has conserved total entropy and constant, rather than its total entropy falling as .
At equal temperature, single electrons and photons each have two spin/polarization states. In the ultrarelativistic approximation,
Positrons are a separate species with the same contribution, so . This distinction is needed for the heating count in part d. At the exact supplied temperature the electron rest mass gives corrections to the ideal ratio; it is the limiting relativistic value requested by the problem.
There is also a sign convention issue in the introductory entropy formula. With the chemical-potential convention used in the supplied distribution, the Euler relation is , so . Its chemical-potential term has the opposite sign to the printed one. For a concrete counterexample, a dilute monatomic ideal gas with one internal state and , where is the thermal de Broglie wavelength, has , and . Its entropy is ; the printed plus sign would instead give . All chemical potentials have been neglected here, so this source error does not change any of the above results.
Let be proper volume, let count the populated internal states, and take and . Spherical integration in momentum space gives
Using the fermion-to-boson thermal integral ratio, the minus-denominator boson integral is and the plus-denominator fermion integral is . Hence
The energy integral has one extra factor :
The supplied distribution identity gives the fermion integral as . Therefore
For an isotropic ultrarelativistic gas, momentum flux gives . Since and ,
Photons have , electrons and Positrons each have , and each neutrino or antineutrino species has one populated helicity in the standard thermal bath.
For a photon gas in thermal and chemical equilibrium, photon number is not a conserved thermodynamic charge. Number-changing processes can create and absorb photons without a corresponding conserved-number constraint, so the equilibrium photon chemical potential is zero.
At , . The other light species are electrons, Positrons, three neutrino species and their antiparticles. Neutrinos are ultrarelativistic; electrons and Positrons are only moderately relativistic at this particular temperature because . The later simple counting formulas use the intended ultrarelativistic approximation for them. Baryons, muons and heavier particles are not an abundant relativistic bath at this temperature.
Pair equilibrium implies . Approximate charge symmetry, with the net electron excess tied to the much smaller baryon asymmetry, then makes both electron and Positron chemical potentials small compared with . For neutrinos one additionally assumes negligible lepton asymmetry. Their near-zero chemical potentials are not implied merely by their statistics. After neutrino decoupling, a distribution initially having negligible chemical potential retains a redshifted Fermi-Dirac distribution, with its own temperature.
Spatial flatness constrains the total density, not matter alone. A flat model can have
with a substantial dark energy component. A positive cosmological constant has pressure and does not dilute like matter; it can produce the observed accelerated expansion.
If positive persists, becomes exponential and the future conformal time interval
is finite. For two comoving civilisations separated by , each one-way signal consumes . Thus a message completing legs at finite time requires
Only finitely many legs, and hence finitely many full exchanges, can then occur. A reply to even the first new message requires , the cosmological round-trip communication horizon condition. Depending on the density parameters, the initial outward message might arrive while its reply can never reach us, as in the right-hand panel of part d.
The source gives no matter and dark-energy fractions, so it does not specify an exact count for the pair in the real Universe. Flatness and lack of matter dominance alone do not prove a finite horizon: a radiation-dominated flat universe, for example, has divergent future conformal time if that power-law expansion persists. The finite-message conclusion uses persistent accelerated expansion such as positive constant .
In an Einstein-de Sitter universe, take and . The galaxy seen today at emitted the light now reaching us when , so . Its fixed comoving radial distance is
Put . A new message sent now reaches the galaxy at , where
Assume an immediate reply and negligible local handling delays. The return consumes the same additional conformal time, giving the Einstein-de Sitter round-trip message time
For the numerical value supplied later in the paper, and the waiting time is about . The age here belongs to the stipulated matter-only model, not a claim about the actual measured cosmic age.
After one-way legs, . Since , every finite number of messages is possible and there is no finite fundamental upper count. The exchange takes arbitrarily long, with successively longer intervals; infinitely many messages are not completed in finite cosmic time.
Figure 1.
Message exchange depends on the remaining conformal time, not just the present expansion rate
. The left conformal spacetime diagram shows repeated light-signal legs between two comoving galaxies in an Einstein-de Sitter model. The right diagram illustrates a finite future conformal interval: one outward leg fits but a complete round trip does not. The right interval is a schematic example, not a parameter estimate for our Universe. Details.
Use standardized Type Ia supernovae as distance indicators and measure their redshifts. The curvature of the luminosity-distance relation constrains the deceleration parameter:
Fainter supernovae at a given redshift imply larger distances, and comparison with the predicted curve tests accelerated expansion. In practice one fits the full expansion history over the observed redshift range and controls luminosity evolution, extinction and calibration, rather than relying only on a short low- series.
The cosmological fate from local expansion data is conditional on a matter model. For the spatially flat model of part b, if the only relevant components are pressureless matter and a constant , put . The two Friedmann equations give
Here follows the sign of the supplied Friedmann equations, where positive contributes positive acceleration. These fix the parameters governing subsequent evolution. Positive yields eternal late-time accelerated expansion; zero gives the flat matter solution; negative leads to eventual recollapse in this dust model. If instead one assumes dust and zero while allowing curvature, determines whether the matter universe is closed and recollapsing or expands indefinitely.
Without a fixed equation of state and its future evolution, two present derivatives do not uniquely fix the future. For a concrete counterexample in units with , the positive scale factors and have the same now. The former expands forever; the latter turns around and later reaches zero. Different time-dependent matter stresses can support their different flat expansion histories. Thus the printed sufficiency statement needs the cosmological-model assumption.
Normalize the scale factor to , with . Along a radial null geodesic, . Two successive wave crests sent by the same comoving emitter and received by the same comoving observer traverse the same comoving distance, so
To first order, . Frequencies are inverse proper periods for the comoving observers, giving the cosmological redshift
Expansion stretches wavelengths, so a spectral line of known rest wavelength gives .
At small , the light travel time is short compared with the expansion time. Expanding gives and , hence
Combine independently calibrated luminosity distances with galaxy spectral redshifts and fit the slope. Nearby peculiar velocities must be allowed for, while high-redshift data require the full distance-redshift relation rather than the linear approximation.
The cosmic distance ladder starts by calibrating a physical baseline. Radar echoes from planets or spacecraft give a round-trip light time and hence a distance , after accounting for orbital motion and propagation delays. Combining this with orbital geometry fixes the Earth-Sun orbital scale; directly timing a reflected pulse from the solar surface is not required.
That baseline supplies annual stellar parallax: for small parallax angle , , or in parsecs equals when is in arcseconds and is one astronomical unit. Nearby parallax distances calibrate stellar absolute magnitudes. Main-sequence fitting extends the scale to star clusters, and the calibrated Cepheid period-luminosity relation gives luminosities for Cepheids visible in nearby galaxies.
Cepheid-host galaxies then calibrate Type Ia supernovae. After light-curve and colour standardization, their high luminosities permit distances to much more remote galaxies. For a source of calibrated luminosity and observed bolometric flux ,
with consistent bandpass definitions and corrections. Interstellar extinction, composition, stellar-population differences and calibration uncertainty must be propagated through the steps. Redshift can subsequently provide a distance within a fitted cosmological model; using it alone cannot independently calibrate the Hubble constant.
Outside the core, and the metric is locally flat: set . Static test particles have no Newtonian-like attraction because is constant and . Local trajectories are straight lines in locally unwrapped coordinates, so a very thin dark core is hard to identify through ordinary orbital accelerations or local tidal forces.
The global angular range is nevertheless rather than . The missing angle can give gravitational lensing with two nearly identical, essentially undistorted images of a background galaxy, and multiple such pairs aligned along the projected object. For a small deficit, a straight string and favourable geometry, their angular separation is of order , with an additional inclination factor for a tilted string. The matching spectra and common line of image pairs distinguish this from an ordinary compact lens.
A moving cosmic string can also induce a step in the cosmic microwave background temperature across its path. That signature needs motion in addition to the static geometry supplied here. These are consequences of the exterior conical geometry; interpreting the inferred deficit as a positive mass per length requires the regular-axis/core assumptions distinguished in part b.
Assume has period , in the regular bulk, and consider a unit proper length in . The proper transverse area element is , while the mass density is . The axial boundary term in the mass of a cylindrical spacetime is therefore
Choose the usual deficit branch , so . Continuity of the induced metric requires . If there is no distributional thin shell at , continuity of the extrinsic curvature also requires . A jump in would add a surface-layer stress and cannot simply be discarded.
Using the printed inner condition , these assumptions yield
This is the literal smooth-bulk answer. It is negative for the ordinary deficit range, so it must not be silently replaced by the usual positive cosmic-string mass formula.
For comparison, a regular axis with proper radial coordinate and angular period requires and , since the circumference-to-radius ratio must approach . Under that different regular-axis condition the same integral gives
The original PDF really prints the derivative limit zero. It describes either a nonregular axis or an inner geometry different from an ordinary smooth string core; any additional singular-axis matter is not included in the bulk integral above and would need its own stress specification. Standard regular-core matching can also require an offset in the exterior radial origin. Thus the regular-axis formula is a qualified physical interpretation, not a derivation from the printed zero. For a general exterior branch replace by in the boundary derivative.
In coordinates the diagonal metric tensor is , and only depends on position. Substitution into the connection formula gives
with all other Christoffel symbols zero away from singular axes.
Use the explicit Ricci tensor formula and the Einstein equation sign printed on the source formula sheet. They give
For example, in the two terms proportional to cancel. For the derivative of contributes , the product terms contribute , and the determinant term contributes .
Formula-sheet qualification. Directly contracting the separately printed Riemann curvature tensor as instructed on that sheet instead gives , the opposite sign. For the concrete example , that contraction gives , whereas the explicit Ricci tensor formula gives . The two source formulas cannot both hold with the stated contraction. The calculation here uses the explicit Ricci tensor formula, whose pairing with the negative Einstein equation coupling yields the requested stress-energy tensor.
The desired matter tensor assumes ; otherwise the cosmological-constant contribution must also be included. With that assumption,
and raising both indices gives
The static observer measures energy density and equal-magnitude negative axial pressure when that energy is positive. The axial stress is a tension. Keeping the source's curvature sign and its negative Einstein-equation coupling together is essential to this result.
For radial motion outside the Schwarzschild event horizon, the equations needed to determine the acceleration components are
They are respectively the four-velocity norm, velocity-acceleration orthogonality, and the maximum proper acceleration norm. Together with part d they give the stated thrust equation; no integration of the trajectory is required. The positive radial sign corresponds to outward thrust.
Let . A first transition from inward to outward motion requires at a minimum radius and there. The largest possible radial derivative at such an event is
At , this is
Thus the ship cannot reverse its inward motion there. It cannot reverse at any smaller exterior radius either: grows while decreases. If it first reaches while falling inward, it cannot return home using the stipulated bounded radial thrust. If , it would instead have reached the black-hole horizon before that radius, which already prevents escape.
The minimum radius for radial turnaround with bounded proper acceleration lies strictly outside the proposed radius. Define by
The right side is the proper acceleration required to hover, decreases monotonically from infinity to zero, and exceeds . A genuine turnaround needs ; equality gives no positive initial outward acceleration at rest. A sufficiently early burn is also needed to remove the pre-existing inward velocity. The failure at follows from the turning-point condition, not from treating the moving ship as static throughout its fall.
Figure 1.
The Newtonian proposed radius lies inside the bounded-thrust turnaround limit
. For the illustrative ratio rs/rI equal to 0.4, the curve is the required hovering proper acceleration divided by the maximum onboard acceleration. At rI it exceeds one. Its crossing with one determines the critical radius rc; the outer side is necessary for radial reversal. The black-hole interior is excluded from this static-coordinate comparison. Details.

Pinned article: Introduction to the OurBigBook Project

Welcome to the OurBigBook Project! Our goal is to create the perfect publishing platform for STEM subjects, and get university-level students to write the best free STEM tutorials ever.
Everyone is welcome to create an account and play with the site: ourbigbook.com/go/register. We belive that students themselves can write amazing tutorials, but teachers are welcome too. You can write about anything you want, it doesn't have to be STEM or even educational. Silly test content is very welcome and you won't be penalized in any way. Just keep it legal!
We have two killer features:
  1. topics: topics group articles by different users with the same title, e.g. here is the topic for the "Fundamental Theorem of Calculus" ourbigbook.com/go/topic/fundamental-theorem-of-calculus
    Articles of different users are sorted by upvote within each article page. This feature is a bit like:
    • a Wikipedia where each user can have their own version of each article
    • a Q&A website like Stack Overflow, where multiple people can give their views on a given topic, and the best ones are sorted by upvote. Except you don't need to wait for someone to ask first, and any topic goes, no matter how narrow or broad
    This feature makes it possible for readers to find better explanations of any topic created by other writers. And it allows writers to create an explanation in a place that readers might actually find it.
    Figure 1.
    Screenshot of the "Derivative" topic page
    . View it live at: ourbigbook.com/go/topic/derivative
  2. local editing: you can store all your personal knowledge base content locally in a plaintext markup format that can be edited locally and published either:
    This way you can be sure that even if OurBigBook.com were to go down one day (which we have no plans to do as it is quite cheap to host!), your content will still be perfectly readable as a static site.
    Figure 5. . You can also edit articles on the Web editor without installing anything locally.
    Video 3.
    Edit locally and publish demo
    . Source. This shows editing OurBigBook Markup and publishing it using the Visual Studio Code extension.
  3. https://raw.githubusercontent.com/ourbigbook/ourbigbook-media/master/feature/x/hilbert-space-arrow.png
  4. Infinitely deep tables of contents:
    Figure 6.
    Dynamic article tree with infinitely deep table of contents
    .
    Descendant pages can also show up as toplevel e.g.: ourbigbook.com/cirosantilli/chordate-subclade
All our software is open source and hosted at: github.com/ourbigbook/ourbigbook
Further documentation can be found at: docs.ourbigbook.com
Feel free to reach our to us for any help or suggestions: docs.ourbigbook.com/#contact