Use and set
For unit particle mass, is both the number density and the mass density in the number convention of c. A fixed reference scale inside the logarithm changes by a constant multiple of the conserved total mass, leaving its derivative unchanged.
Both prefactors in the source's part (d) need correction. Multiplication of the mean-field alignment equation by and integration by parts gives
Exchange and , use the symmetry of , and average the two expressions:
The printed right-hand side omits . This corrected velocity-alignment energy dissipation agrees with the pair-counting calculation in a.
For velocity-alignment entropy production, let . The velocity-space divergence is . Assuming and sufficient decay, integration by parts yields
The printed formula omits the factor from the three velocity components. In spatial dimensions, that factor would be . Zeros of can be treated by a regularized entropy calculation when the required integrability holds.
A concrete smooth counterexample to both printed coefficients is and , where is a positive normalized Gaussian distribution. The total mass is one, the total momentum is zero, and initially. The kinetic energy derivative is , whereas the printed formula gives . The entropy functional derivative is , whereas the printed formula gives .
The signs describe cooling of relative velocities and contraction in phase space: increases, so the fine-grained Gibbs entropy decreases. These dissipative particle dynamics are not an isolated Hamiltonian system; there is no contradiction with Liouville's theorem or the Boltzmann equation's usual entropy increase. The microscopic mechanism removing kinetic energy is outside this alignment model.
For a regular thermal and noise at , the susceptibility is small at thermal phase velocities: its scale is . To leading order the electrons cannot appreciably screen such short-scale fields, and b becomes independent of velocity:
The electron kinetic energy per unit volume is . Assume and vanish at infinity. One integration by parts gives the general heating formula
For constant , a second integration by parts and give
This is the leading short-wavelength result. With vanishing boundary flux, the diffusion equation also conserves particle number; constant conserves the mean momentum while increasing the random kinetic energy.
The long-wavelength limit in d is resonant heating. Most electrons screen the slowly varying spatial field. The noise nevertheless excites collective Langmuir waves, whose sharp temporal spectrum lies near . Electrons with remain in phase with a wave and exchange energy with it. A stable tail absorbs net wave energy through Landau damping. The heating is initially deposited in narrow tail regions of velocity space, even though the volume-integrated rate equals that in c.
The short-wavelength limit in c is stochastic heating in the terminology intended here. With , the imposed electric field is essentially unscreened. Its temporally uncorrelated kicks cause a random walk of electron velocity, so . Electrons throughout the thermal population contribute to the resulting kinetic energy increase; no narrow collective wave peak selects a small tail population.
Both mechanisms are driven by white noise, and the formal condition enters the stationary quasilinear diffusion calculation in both cases. The physical distinction is the sharp collective resonance in d versus the broad direct random forcing in c, rather than the mere presence of randomness. In collisionless theory this heating is an increase of the averaged kinetic energy; subsequent collisions can establish thermal equilibrium.
Normalize the symmetric -particle phase-space distribution function to one and write , . The number-normalized one- and two-particle distribution functions are
Thus and . These conventions absorb the otherwise explicit factor in the first BBGKY hierarchy equation.
Separate the Hamiltonian into kinetic energy, external potential energy, and pair potential terms. Their Hamilton's equations give
The sign follows directly from the stated Poisson bracket: . The Hamiltonian Liouville equation is consequently
Integrate over and multiply by . Assume sufficient decay in velocity space and either decay or periodic boundary conditions in position, so that integration by parts removes all transport terms with . The surviving interaction term is
where indistinguishability makes all terms equal. Relabeling as yields the exact result
No assumption of molecular chaos for the Boltzmann equation has entered: the dependence on the two-particle distribution function is still exact.
To obtain the Boltzmann equation, take a dilute gas with a short-range pair potential. Its interaction range is small compared with the mean free path and the spatial scale on which the phase-space distribution function changes. The binary collision approximation treats encounters as isolated elastic collisions; simultaneous encounters involving three or more particles can be neglected. The encounter duration is short compared with the collision relaxation time and macroscopic evolution time, and the external force changes negligibly during an encounter. This permits local, effectively instantaneous scattering at one position .
The essential statistical closure is molecular chaos for the Boltzmann equation: the distribution of incoming pairs factorizes as . Outgoing pairs need not be independent. Follow each incoming pair through its two-body scattering, and use conservation of momentum and kinetic energy, together with time reversal and the invariant scattering measure, to express both gain and loss in the same variables. This gives
Here ; when the measure is written as , its Jacobian is included in the Boltzmann scattering kernel. In a scattering-angle convention, that kernel contains relative speed times differential scattering cross-section. The hemisphere prevents double counting equivalent outcomes for indistinguishable particles; the precise factor is included in . The primed velocities are connected to the unprimed ones by the reversible elastic collision map. This closure is appropriate for a dilute short-range gas, rather than a generic long-range interacting system with an important collective mean-field theory contribution.
The further replacement by the BGK model is a phenomenological relaxation closure. Replace the full nonlinear Boltzmann collision operator by relaxation towards a local Maxwellian, with a single, velocity-independent collision relaxation time :
It models relaxation towards a local Maxwellian without resolving the detailed scattering. Treating as constant is an additional simplification; it is of the order of a mean time between effective collisions. Near a local Maxwellian, departures in the nonconserved velocity moments decay on this timescale.
Choose to match the collision invariants , and of . For unit particle mass, this means
Here is the mass density, is the mean velocity, and is the temperature in squared-velocity units, before setting . In particular,
Thus relaxation preserves local mass, momentum and kinetic energy rather than relaxing them to externally prescribed values.
Write and introduce the raw third velocity moment and the third central velocity moment :
The expansion of their product gives
The heat flux is for unit mass.
Multiply the BGK model by . The external force term is
Therefore the raw second velocity moment satisfies
The matching local Maxwellian has , so
To remove the bulk motion, let be the material derivative. The continuity equation and the momentum conservation equation imply
and hence
Subtract this identity from the raw second velocity moment equation and insert the expansion of . The terms and cancel by the product rule. The external force terms also cancel, since a common acceleration changes the local mean velocity without directly changing the relative velocities. What remains is
The trace of the relaxation term is zero because . Thus the BGK model relaxes anisotropy of the pressure tensor while preserving the local random kinetic energy. The evolution is still a velocity-moment hierarchy, since requires further information about .
Hooke's law and Newton's second law give , so . The initial conditions select the simple harmonic motion
The kinetic energy and elastic potential energy exchange periodically while their sum is constant.
Use positions and . Their squared speeds are and . Summing their kinetic energies gives
No small-angle approximation has been used here.
The total kinetic energy and small-slope elastic potential energy are
Orthogonality removes cross terms between the two distinct sine or cosine modes. A mode of amplitude contributes and . For amplitudes and , the prefactors agree. Writing ,
Thus
independent of time. This is another instance of equal modal energies for inverse-harmonic string amplitudes. An explicit initial amplitude multiplies every energy by .
Figure 1.
Two-harmonic string displacement and exchange between kinetic and potential energy
. Details.
In the small-slope string model, the additional elastic potential energy is . For the fundamental mode, . Since ,
Using from the dispersion relation gives
The expression vanishes as the string passes through its straight equilibrium shape and is maximal at the turning shapes, when the corresponding kinetic energy is zero.
Parametrize any actual particle trajectory by time, with and acceleration . The chain rule gives
Integrating from the origin to the endpoint gives
Here is specific kinetic energy, because the source defines it without a mass factor. Equivalently, in the chosen units. The individual initial or final speeds are not fixed by this result. For a particle of mass , the change of ordinary kinetic energy would be .
Interpret “held” and then “released” as zero initial velocity. In the small-slope wave equation on a string model, the elastic energy is and the initial kinetic energy is zero. The given profile has
The two cosine functions are orthogonal on and each has squared integral . Thus
The implicit leading displacement amplitude is one in the source's chosen length units. If that amplitude is written explicitly as , all energies here and below acquire a factor .
The two positions are and . Differentiating and summing their kinetic energies gives the exact expression
In the linear small-oscillation approximation, set the cosine to one in this quadratic velocity expression:
The cross term arises because the lower mass participates in motion generated by both rods.
A symmetric quadratic form has twice its off-diagonal entry as the coefficient of the mixed product. Comparing with the preceding potential energy and kinetic energy expressions gives
Here is the stiffness matrix and the mass matrix in angular coordinates; their units differ accordingly. The dimensionless mass-matrix determinant is and its first diagonal entry is positive, so the kinetic energy is positive for every nonzero angular velocity.
For a single normal mode , the kinetic energy is the integral of . Using gives
The extra string length is . Multiplying by tension gives the quadratic potential energy, so implies
Since , the sum is time independent:
For the released shape, and , so
The second mode's smaller displacement is offset by its doubled spatial wavenumber and angular frequency. orthogonality of distinct sine and cosine spatial modes eliminates cross terms in the integrated energies, so the total is their sum. Initially the kinetic energy is zero and all the energy is stored in the string's deformation; during the motion the total remains constant.
For small transverse displacements, the string's kinetic energy and extra elastic potential energy are
The orthogonality of trigonometric functions removes cross terms between the two normal modes. For a mode , use and to obtain
Consequently the modal energy distribution is
The second mode contributes more total energy at every time, despite its smaller displacement amplitude. The total energy is , with fractions and in the first and second modes. Each mode exchanges kinetic energy and potential energy, while its sum is conserved; the comparison is of these sums, not of instantaneous kinetic energies alone.
Figure 1.
String modal coordinates and separate kinetic and potential energies, showing the larger energy of the second mode
. Details.
For a short length , the kinetic energy is . For small slope, its increase in length is , so its elastic potential energy is . For a travelling wave , and . Using gives
Writing a pulse as yields . Thus energy is proportional to amplitude squared for a fixed shape and width. Width must also be retained when comparing pulses on different strings.
Let . The inextensible-string constraint gives the upward displacement . Thus the quadratic potential energy is . The vertical velocity of the second mass is of second order in the small motion, so the quadratic kinetic energy is .
The Euler-Lagrange equations for this quadratic Lagrangian give
Small displacements are used both in the quadratic approximation to the gravitational potential energy and in neglecting the higher-order vertical kinetic energy. These are the spring-supported pendulum normal modes at linear order. The corresponding force picture sets the string tension to at leading order and its horizontal angle to .
At , the two triangular pulses coincide with opposite signs:
The instantaneous sketch is the straight equilibrium line. This is destructive interference, not the disappearance of the wave energy. For example, on the transverse velocity is , so the mechanical string is passing through equilibrium with nonzero kinetic energy.
A reference string segment has mass and transverse velocity . Its kinetic energy is . In the small-slope approximation its extra arc length is
The work against constant tension supplies the corresponding elastic potential energy . To quadratic order, the energy density per unit reference length is therefore
For the travelling wave , the wave equation implies . Its kinetic energy density and elastic energy density are equal, so
The energy per wavelength of a transverse string wave comes from integration over any full wavelength :
The printed expression for energy per wavelength is missing a factor . Its right-hand side is the mean energy density, with units of energy per length. For a concrete counterexample within the small-slope regime, take , , and . Then and direct integration gives , whereas the printed right-hand side is . It cannot equal an energy.