Past exam of the atomic and laser physics course of the University of Oxford 2021 1 c Solution 2026-10-25
Write and retain the nuclear Coulomb potential. In spherical coordinates, the total potential energy iswhen ; is a Legendre polynomial. Treat the added term using quadratic anisotropic perturbation of hydrogen and degenerate perturbation theory in the hydrogen energy eigenbasis. It preserves parity and , so it cannot mix with , or distinct magnetic sublevels.
For a hydrogen atom, the hydrogen radial second moment givesThe angular expectation values of are for an orbital, for , and for , obtained by integrating the squared spherical harmonics. Therefore the five lowest spatial quantum states, counting statistical weight, have first-order energy levelsEach spatial quantum state has two electron spin states when spin-orbit coupling and the magnetic field are omitted. Thus these are five spatial states but only three distinct first-order energies; five distinct energies would be an incorrect reading. The accidental equality can be lifted at higher order. Quantitatively the added shifts must also be small compared with neighboring principal-shell gaps; is an asymptotic condition, not a guarantee for arbitrary large .
First-order spatial levels of locally perturbed hydrogen; the gap between principal shells is compressed
. Details. For general , the expectation value isIt does not cancel every order. At , couples to orbitals. For example its angular matrix element with is , and the radial matrix element is nonzero. The second-order nondegenerate perturbation theory sum has negative denominators, so this is a concrete nonzero higher-order contribution.
There is also a global limitation: for either negative above, . A localized wavepacket translated far along has fixed kinetic energy but arbitrarily negative potential energy, proving there is no true lowest energy level. The results describe local perturbative resonance poles, or a potential completed to a confining form far from the atomic nucleus. No globally exact ground-state cancellation exists for the potential as printed.
Use the condensate wavefunction convention , so is the number density and is a normalized one-particle orbital. The contact interaction strength is for dilute atoms with s-wave scattering length . The chemical potential fixes the stationary time dependence and enforces normalization when minimizing the energy. The Gross–Pitaevskii equation follows from an energy functional that contains the pair-counting factor :Varying gives the stationary Gross–Pitaevskii equation; the interaction contribution to that equation is , without the factor .
For the broadening discussed here assume repulsive interactions, . The Thomas–Fermi approximation for a condensate neglects the gradient kinetic energy compared with the trapping and interaction energies. At fixed spatial scale, increasing increases the mean-field potential. Expansion then reduces the kinetic energy further: for a cloud radius , its scale per atom is , whereas the trap energy scale is . Their ratio decreases as . In the weak-interaction limit the kinetic energy instead balances confinement, giving the Gaussian wave packet ground state of the quantum harmonic oscillator.
The spherical Thomas–Fermi condensate hasIntegrating this density gives . ThusAt fixed , stronger repulsion produces a wider, lower wavefunction: the Gaussian wave packet crosses over towards the square root of an inverted parabola, with an almost flat central region and a steeper outer drop. The density is the inverted parabola; the wavefunction is its square root. The exact wavefunction remains smooth and has a tail, since kinetic energy cannot be neglected near the Thomas–Fermi condensate edge rounding region. The healing length must be small compared with the cloud size in the bulk. Attractive interactions would not follow this large- expansion argument.
The original plot compares the noninteracting endpoint with two normalized repulsive spherical Thomas–Fermi condensate profiles. The latter are asymptotic shapes, rather than exact intermediate solutions of the Gross–Pitaevskii equation. Each has the same integrated atom number; labels the illustrative interaction strengths.
Choose real and positive. The Gaussian integral givesThe three zero-point energies add for each atom. The ideal-gas chemical potential is a one-atom energy; the total energy includes all atoms.
For weak interactions, the first-order correction in perturbation theory is the energy functional of the contact interaction evaluated on the unperturbed Gaussian wave packet. The integral needed isConsequently the Gaussian interaction energy of a trapped condensate isHere . These are the mean-field expressions consistent with the supplied equation and . Exact first-order perturbation theory for precisely atoms in one orbital replaces by through the number of distinct pairs; this distinction is negligible in the large- regime of the crossover estimate.
To judge the ideal-gas approximation, compare the interaction energy with the total ideal energy, or compare the interaction energy per atom with :Thus the crossover from Gaussian to Thomas–Fermi condensate is governed by : perturbation theory is reliable for , while the regime of the Thomas–Fermi approximation for a condensate requires . The characteristic crossover number is ; there is no sharp critical atom number here. If one specifically defines crossover by using the weak-interaction expression, it gives . That prefactor is a convention-dependent estimate extrapolated to the edge of perturbation theory, not a phase transition. Comparing itself to a single would incorrectly omit a factor of .
Laser cooling removes atomic kinetic energy through a velocity-dependent optical force, with scattered photons carrying away energy and entropy. For two counterpropagating beams detuned below resonance, motion towards one beam shifts that light closer to resonance, so the atom preferentially absorbs momentum opposite its velocity. At small velocity the net force is with . Three orthogonal beam pairs form optical molasses. Spontaneous emission has zero mean recoil in a symmetric distribution, but its momentum variance is nonzero: random absorption and emission cause heating. The cooling and heating balance sets a finite temperature.
For a weakly saturated two-level transition, write and let be the excited-state population decay rate. A useful one-axis Doppler cooling expression isThis limit belongs to the weak-intensity Doppler cooling model, with recoil energy small compared with . Experimentally, released sodium molasses clouds were probed by time of flight; the unusually small expansion demonstrated temperatures below that limit. This distinguishes an observed failure of a two-level cooling model from a failure of conservation of energy.[ref]
Nobel Lecture: Laser cooling and trapping of neutral atoms by William D. Phillips. pp. 729–732, Doppler limit, optical molasses, and release/time-of-flight thermometry
Multilevel atoms permit polarization-gradient cooling: spatially varying light polarization produces different light shifts of ground-state sublevels. In Sisyphus cooling, atoms climb a light-shift potential and are preferentially optically pumped near its top into a lower-energy sublevel, repeatedly losing kinetic energy. The optical pumping and emitted light supply dissipation. This can reach below the Doppler cooling limit; the recoil scalethen becomes important. The definition of a recoil temperature sometimes differs by a factor of two, so the energy definition is the unambiguous comparison. Recoil is not a universal lower bound for every cooling protocol: suitable dark-state or resolved sideband cooling schemes can suppress scattering near the desired motional state. Resolved sideband cooling preferentially excites a transition lowering the vibrational quantum number, followed by decay that on average preserves it in the Lamb-Dicke regime.[ref]
Nobel Lecture: Superposition, entanglement, and raising Schrödinger’s cat by David J. Wineland. Section IV, cooling of quantized ion motion
Optical molasses supplies damping rather than a position-restoring force. A magneto-optical trap adds a magnetic-field gradient and appropriately chosen circular polarizations; the position-dependent Zeeman splitting gives a restoring radiation pressure imbalance as well as damping. In real alkali atoms, repumping light returns population that would otherwise accumulate in an uncoupled hyperfine level. Magnetic and optical dipole traps can subsequently hold the cold sample without continuous resonant scattering.
Applications include long-interrogation atomic clocks, precision spectroscopy, atom interferometry, and preparation for quantum simulation and Bose-Einstein condensation. Cooling reduces motion-induced frequency shifts and allows longer coherent interrogation; deeper quantum degeneracy commonly needs subsequent evaporative cooling of atoms. Finite capture velocity, available transitions, recoil heating, stray magnetic fields, and loss or heating from unwanted scattering constrain a real experiment.
For a free-space electric dipole transition, the spontaneous emission rate in SI units isHere includes the relevant dipole components; a specified single polarization requires its corresponding matrix element.
A complete scattering cycle returns the internal state to the ground state and changes the atomic momentum to . ThusFor photon-scattering recoil heating with isotropic emission of fixed momentum magnitude, , givingThe first term is the velocity-dependent work of absorption and can cool an atom if the photon opposes its motion. The last two are positive absorption and emission recoil energies. If the actual absorbed directions are also isotropic and independent of , the first term averages to zero. For approximately equal incoming and outgoing photon momenta ,Isotropic incident illumination alone would not guarantee isotropic absorption if Doppler-dependent excitation selected directions.
Source qualification for the trapped calculation. Set for the same atom. The printed Gaussian has the wrong width for the specified harmonic oscillator: the printed ground and first-excited functions have squared norms and , respectively. The normalized oscillator states fixed by the given instead useAlso, one common complex phase multiplying both off-diagonal terms does not make the Hamiltonian a Hermitian operator. Use an absorption matrix element and its Hermitian conjugate for emission; choosing the opposite propagation convention reverses the imaginary sideband phase but not a transition probability. The physical results below use these explicitly stated corrections. Parts (i) and (ii) also give the literal integrals of the printed functions.
Conditional motional heating and recoil averaging. With , an oscillator eigenstate has . Therefore the absorption outcomes haveThe same statements hold for the specified emission outcomes and . Internal excitation energy goes into, or comes from, the photon and is distinct from this external energy change. Emission into the first motional state makes the emitted photon correspondingly less energetic.
A sudden recoil from gives probabilities , so while . The rare first sideband transfers a whole trap quantum, much larger than ; the mean is neverthelessThe emission average is the same for a one-dimensional recoil of the same magnitude. Projecting isotropic three-dimensional emission onto one axis instead gives a factor for that axis.
A sudden unobserved kick initially raises kinetic energy by and leaves the position distribution, hence potential energy, unchanged. It creates a coherent superposition of motional states. The equal kinetic/potential increments above concern energy-eigenstate-conditioned outcomes, or time-averaged/dephased motion; these are different measurement conditions. There is no contradiction.
With , motional sidebands are not cleanly resolved, and a short-lived excited atom has little time to move before decay. In the stronger sudden limit the recoil-kick picture is direct. For only the stated inequality, finite linewidth weights can change numerical factors; it does not fix an exact continuous-wave scattering rate. The average heating remains of recoil order per absorption or emission, and of order when both absorption and emission kicks are counted at full magnitude. For the axial component of isotropic three-dimensional emission, the emission contribution instead carries the factor noted above. Strong confinement suppresses the chance of changing , but does not make its averaged recoil energy disappear. This agrees with free-space recoil heating while replacing small continuous energy changes by rare quantized motional changes.
The two-level Doppler limit, , balances velocity-dependent scattering friction with momentum diffusion. Multilevel atoms have additional, slower internal dynamics. Counterpropagating beams with orthogonal linear polarizations create a spatially varying polarization, giving different position-dependent light shifts for ground-state magnetic sublevels. A moving atom climbs a light-shift hill, loses kinetic energy and is optically pumped into a lower-energy sublevel: this repeated Sisyphus cooling cycle dissipates motion through emitted light.
Optical pumping responds with a finite delay. Its rate, rather than only the excited-state linewidth, sets the low-velocity response scale. In the opposite-circular-polarization arrangement, motion instead produces unequal sublevel populations and unbalanced radiation pressure. Both mechanisms can cool below the two-level Doppler temperature; diffusion heating still balances the cooling, and recoil matters at the lowest temperatures.[ref]
Laser cooling below the Doppler limit by polarization gradients: simple theoretical models by Jean Dalibard and Claude Cohen-Tannoudji. 1989, pages 2023–2025, two polarization-gradient mechanisms and pumping timescale
Ground-state substructure, optical pumping and polarization gradients enable the extra cooling. Magnetic fields that disturb the required sublevel dynamics can suppress it. Optical molasses damps velocity but does not by itself provide position-restoring confinement.
For an ideal weakly driven two-level atom, opposing red-detuned beams give velocity-dependent absorption and a friction force near zero velocity. Random photon recoils also cause momentum diffusion. Their balance gives the minimum Doppler temperatureat detuning in the low-saturation model, where is the spontaneous population-decay rate, equivalently the natural full linewidth expressed as an angular frequency. This limit assumes the atom has no useful ground-state internal structure.
Real atoms possess magnetic sublevels. In a suitable multilevel transition, position-dependent polarization gives different optical couplings and different AC Stark energy shifts for those sublevels. Counterpropagating beams with orthogonal linear polarizations have nearly uniform total intensity but a periodically varying polarization. Thus spatially varying light shifts can exist even without an intensity standing wave.
In Sisyphus cooling, an atom on one ground-state branch climbs a light-shift hill and loses kinetic energy. Near the upper part of the hill, optical pumping tends to transfer population to a lower branch. spontaneous emission makes this transfer dissipative and randomizes the emitted photon direction. The atom can then climb another hill. Finite pumping time is essential: instantaneous local equilibration would remove the delayed internal-state response that produces friction. The original multilevel analysis relates these optical-pumping cycles to the spatially displaced light shifts.[ref]
For large detuning compared with the natural linewidth, useful scales areup to angular-coupling and Rabi-frequency convention factors. Here is the optical Rabi angular frequency. The slow-atom capture range is of order . Typical energies in the Sisyphus regime track the light-shift scale rather than only , so reducing intensity can lower temperature below the Doppler limit. Capture becomes narrower, however, and recoil heating, imperfect polarization, magnetic fields and scattered light eventually matter. Define recoil energy ; this is an important scale, not a claim that every sub-Doppler method has the same universal final temperature.[ref]
Manipulating Atoms with Photons by Claude Cohen-Tannoudji. §2, Sub-Doppler cooling; §2.1, Sisyphus effect
The experimental test must establish a narrow velocity distribution independently of fluorescence brightness. William D. Phillips's account describes moving a time-of-flight probe above and below the cloud, deliberately heating the atoms to check a previously absent signal, and release-and-recapture comparisons that included gravity and finite beam geometry. These tests separated very cold atoms from an insensitive detector or a faulty thermometer.[ref]
Nobel Lecture: Laser cooling and trapping of neutral atoms by William D. Phillips. pp. 731–732, Figs. 15–16; pp. 733–734, multilevel interpretation
In a modern implementation, field cancellation and polarization checks test the mechanism, while independent expansion thermometry checks the inferred temperature. sub-Doppler cooling exploits internal-state dynamics omitted from the two-level Doppler model; it does not contradict that model within its assumptions.Write , , and take . The Bogoliubov spectrum is gapless and positive for . Its small- and large-momentum limits areThe low-energy excitations are collective sound modes; high-energy excitations approach particles with a mean-field energy offset. With healing length and ,The crossover occurs at of order one, not at an additional energy gap.
The critical velocity of a homogeneous condensate follows because the Landau criterion compares an excitation energy with the energy that flow can release by transferring its momentum. Creating a mode is energetically possible when . For this isotropic spectrum,The infimum is the long-wavelength speed of sound. This tests energetic stability against the stated excitations; it is not a calculation of a dissipation rate or a universal vortex-nucleation threshold.
For an external potential varying slowly on the healing scale, the Thomas–Fermi approximation for a condensate neglects density-gradient kinetic energy in the stationary Gross–Pitaevskii equation. In occupied regions it givesHere is the appropriate local number density; in the ring it is a linear density and is the one-dimensional coupling. This is the local-density sound speed of a condensate. The formula applies where , not in an empty region where its square root would be imaginary.
Normalize the condensate order parameter to the atom number:up to an arbitrary constant phase. A wavefunction normalized to one instead has amplitude , with then providing density. Acting with gives angular momentum per atom and in total for the uniform ring. The superfluid velocity isThe interaction chemical potential is ; a flowing uniform state also has the constant kinetic contribution to its total chemical potential. Its speed of sound is set by the interaction term. Applying givesFor a uniform ring condensate, this is the continuum phonon criterion used here. Quantization of the available excitation wavelengths in a very small ring can modify a finite-size threshold.
For the nonrotating equilibrium with a raised left half, let and be the bulk linear densities. Within the same Thomas–Fermi approximation for a condensate,When both halves are occupied, normalization fixesand thereforeThese expressions require . Beyond that threshold, extending them would give a negative left density and is unphysical. Instead the left bulk empties, all atoms occupy a segment of length , andAt equality the left bulk just reaches zero density. kinetic energy rounds the interface and produces tails beyond the Thomas–Fermi approximation for a condensate, so an exactly empty half is the idealized bulk result.
A nonconstant breaks rotational symmetry:Consequently angular momentum is no longer a good quantum number, and an eigenfunction need not be times a constant amplitude. Nevertheless, while the order parameter is nonzero around the whole ring, single-valuedness requiresThe integer is a phase winding of a condensate, not an assertion that the inhomogeneous state remains an angular-momentum eigenstate. A superfluid phase slip can change it if the amplitude vanishes locally.
Conservation of particles gives . For steady density the one-dimensional particle current is constant. Since the two halves have equal lengths,The current bottleneck in an inhomogeneous condensate occurs because a lower-density region has faster flow at the same current; it also has a smaller speed of sound. This makes the raised half the limiting region.
For the equilibrium approximation givesThe winding condition and equal lengths requireThus the left-hand sound-speed test isThe right-hand condition is only , so it is less restrictive.
This local sound-speed estimate for ring-flow stability uses the step-potential equilibrium in a ring condensate densities together with the local sound-speed test, as suggested by the preceding approximations. A quantitatively self-consistent finite-current solution also includes and the quantum pressure of a condensate in the stationary Gross–Pitaevskii equation, allowing flow to change the density. Smooth steps suppress reflection but do not alone remove those terms. The result is the stated local-density estimate; it should not be promoted to an exact stability theorem for every finite interacting ring.
Past exam of the chemistry A course of the University of Cambridge 2021 Paper 1 A2 c iv Solution 2026-10-20
Integration by parts and the zero endpoint values turn the Rayleigh quotient into a positive kinetic energy integral:This is the parabolic variational trial for a particle in a box. The potential energy vanishes inside the box.
Past exam of the chemistry A course of the University of Cambridge 2023 Paper 1 A2 b iii Solution 2026-10-20
For any , the Gaussian function is the exact nodeless ground wavefunction of a quantum harmonic oscillator withDirect substitution cancels the terms. An additive constant in the potential would simply shift the eigenvalue.
A natural comparison uses the same optimized width as part (i), . The harmonic ground energy is then , compared with the quartic Gaussian function expectation . For this common normalized trial,while the kinetic energy expectation value is in both cases. The quartic potential lies below this harmonic potential for and above it for ; the difference weighted by the Gaussian function is negative, giving the lower expectation.
If the standard unit-frequency oscillator is chosen instead, gives , below the optimized quartic upper bound. These are different harmonic comparison potentials, not contradictory answers. Crossing potential curves cannot be ordered globally; the comparison must specify the frequency or Gaussian function width used.
Original comparison of the quartic potential with harmonic potentials at unit frequency and at the optimized Gaussian width
. Details. Past exam of the chemistry A course of the University of Cambridge 2023 Paper 1 A2 b i Solution 2026-10-20
Wavefunction normalization requires . For the normalized probability weight proportional to , the Gaussian integral and its derivatives giveSince , the kinetic energy and potential energy expectations areThusThe second derivative is positive, and the energy diverges at both ends of , so this is the global minimum within the Gaussian function family. The best Gaussian function upper bound isThis is an upper bound, not the exact quartic ground energy.
Past exam of the chemistry A course of the University of Cambridge 2025 Paper 1 A1 a i Solution 2026-10-20
Take with real , and . The operator domain matters: use sufficiently smooth wavefunctions for which the following boundary terms vanish at both infinities. A real multiplication operator givesTwo applications of integration by parts giveThus the potential energy and kinetic energy operators obey the stated Hermitian operator identity on this common domain. For , one application of integration by parts instead givesThe derivative is anti-Hermitian, rather than Hermitian; the minus sign cannot generally be removed. Multiplication by makes the corresponding momentum operator Hermitian. These integrations establish the requested symmetry identities; full self-adjointness of an unbounded operator additionally requires equality of its domain with its adjoint's domain.
Quantum tunnelling is penetration of, or transmission through, a finite potential barrier into a classically forbidden region, where the total energy is less than the potential energy. The wavefunction generally remains nonzero there, so the Born rule assigns a nonzero probability of detection. This does not require an increase in total energy; it is the classical relation between a definite position and a definite kinetic energy that cannot be imposed on the quantum state. For a bound quantum harmonic oscillator, the relevant quantity is the probability of finding the particle beyond its classical turning points; it is not an escaping transmitted beam.
Inside the infinite square well, the Hamiltonian is purely the kinetic energy operator,Its admissible wavefunctions obey the boundary conditions and vanish outside the interval. Equivalently write with inside and an infinite confining wall outside. The boundary conditions are part of the specification of this Hamiltonian; the differential expression alone does not determine the spectrum.
Choose mass-weighted coordinates , , and two triplets for the two copies. About a stationary equilibrium geometry, the allowed harmonic potential isThe kinetic energy is one-half the sum of the squared conjugate momenta. Cross terms between inequivalent irreducible representations are forbidden, but the two equivalent triplets permit the displayed scalar-product term. This is equivalent-mode harmonic coupling. An orthogonal rotation between the two triplets diagonalizes their force-constant matrix. In molecular normal coordinates the complete Hamiltonian becomesSymmetry enforces degeneracies within each multiplet; it does not require equal frequencies for the two distinct normal modes.
Fixed entrance retardation and fixed pass energy select the same pre-retardation kinetic energy, 111.4 eV. The required photon energy is thereforeIt is lower than the original excitation by exactly the difference between the two core binding energies, 114.4 eV.
Define the retard ratio using the kinetic energy at the analyser entrance before the deliberate retardation: . Initially . With the original excitation, a carbon photoelectron arrives with . ThusThe new deliberate retardation is . For fixed slits, angular acceptance and hemisphere radii, the geometrical fractional energy width is approximately constant, so the absolute analyser width grows in proportion to pass energy: about 2.03 times poorer absolute energy resolution. Counts may improve, but closely separated chemical shifts become harder to resolve. An alternative definition gives 0.114 rather than 1.114 for the same physical setting and leads to the same final pass energy when used consistently.
Treat the marble as a frictionless point particle; no size, rolling constraint or friction law is supplied. Neglect its vertical kinetic energy as requested, but retain the gravitational potential energy .
For completeness keep the general constant cup rotation rate . In cup components the center's velocity is . With , the horizontal velocity norm is . ThusIn the nonrotating translating case , this reduces toThe time-only constant may be dropped. Integrating the cross-velocity term by parts gives an equivalent LagrangianIt differs by a total derivative and a time-only term, so gives the same trajectories but different expressions for the canonical momenta. The small-vertical-velocity approximation is typically consistent at small surface slope ; it need not remain valid during unlimited resonant growth.
Past exam of the classical mechanics course of Part B of the physics course of the University of Oxford 2016 1 d Solution Created 2026-10-25 Updated 2026-11-05
For the original Lagrangian of solution, differentiation with respect to the generalized velocities givesIn contrast, using in the nonrotating case gives , ; this is the expected momentum shift under adding a total derivative.
The Euler-Lagrange equations in the general cup frame areThese include the Coriolis and centrifugal terms when the cup axes really rotate. Set to obtainFor , its complete solution iswhere the two complex constants provide the four real initial data. The driving denominator is independent of cup-axis rotation: rotation changes the coordinate description, not the physical trap frequency.
In the requested special case , an equivalent real form isFor example , , and determine the constants.
At resonance with nonzero , replace the particular term byIn the nonrotating cup frame this has components , plus the homogeneous solution. Secular growth eventually invalidates a finite cup or the neglected vertical kinetic energy. If the ride does not rotate, its forcing vanishes and ordinary free oscillations remain.
For a truly isolated Hamiltonian bunch, Liouville's theorem preserves the fine-grained volume in its full -dimensional phase space. Hamiltonian manipulation cannot increase its full phase-space density by compressing all canonical position and momentum directions simultaneously. Merely focusing the beam to a smaller transverse spot generally increases angular or momentum divergence; it does not by itself reduce beam emittance.
The distinction between full volume and projected spreads matters. Coupling transverse and longitudinal degrees of freedom can exchange emittance or move spread into other coordinates and correlations, so a projected transverse quantity may decrease without reducing the complete phase volume. That is redistribution, not cooling of every degree of freedom. In linear uncoupled optics, preservation of each transverse canonical area makes the spot-size/divergence tradeoff particularly direct.
Actual cooling allows the beam to exchange energy and entropy with other systems. In electron cooling, a colder comoving electron population receives the protons' random kinetic energy and is subsequently renewed or cooled. In stochastic cooling, a pickup measures deviations and a downstream kicker applies feedback corrections; the electronics, measurement noise and environment belong to the enlarged system. CERN's description identifies exactly this pickup-and-kicker arrangement.[ref]
Stochastic cooling by CERN. Feedback and corrections: pickup measurement of sample motion and downstream electric-field correction
Thus these methods relax the idealization that the proton bunch alone is isolated. Including the cooling apparatus does not require the complete closed dynamics to violate Liouville's theorem. For protons, direct radiative damping is much weaker than for electrons, so stochastic or electron cooling is a more relevant practical suggestion than relying on strong synchrotron damping.
Past exam of the classical mechanics course of the University of Oxford 2023 1 c Solution 2026-10-25
Write . The initial conditions on the normal mode coordinates are and . Solving the two harmonic oscillator equations and recovering the original angles gives the exact solution within the harmonic approximation:Their angular velocities are and , which verify all four initial conditions.
To expose the beat, define and . Replacing by changes each angle by uniformly in time. The sum-to-product identities then giveThe displayed angular velocities are exact in the linear system. The absolute and signed beat envelopes have leading amplitudes and . Because , at we have and . HenceThe first simple pendulum has negligible oscillation amplitude. Its kinetic energy is , while the second has . Thus, to the retained order, all instantaneous kinetic energy belongs to the second simple pendulum. The fast phase can make that kinetic energy small: the whole initial energy is transferred as the second simple pendulum's combined kinetic energy and gravitational potential energy, sinceThis is energy transfer after an impulse in two weakly coupled oscillators. It does not require .
At , , so the beat has returned the oscillation to the first simple pendulum:The energy localization returns, although the fast oscillation phase need not equal its initial phase. The exact first minimum of the leading beat envelope is at , whose leading value is . Keeping the slow phase is essential: expanding at fixed and then using would lose the energy exchange. Although angles are retained only to order , their leading energies are of order .






