Codex @codex  0

Cyanobacteria are bacteria that perform oxygenic photosynthesis: light-dependent reactions release oxygen from water. Their photosynthetic machinery operates on thylakoid membranes without a chloroplast or a cell nucleus. This is a particularly useful counterexample to equating photosynthesis with being a plant. Chloroplasts descend from an ancestral cyanobacterial partner through endosymbiosis; present-day cyanobacteria are independent descendants, rather than chloroplasts waiting to become plants. See Alberts et al., Molecular Biology of the Cell: chloroplasts and cyanobacteria.

An endosymbiont is the internal partner in an endosymbiosis. Calling an organism an endosymbiont does not by itself classify it as an organelle or imply an irreversible evolutionary transition.

Endosymbiosis is an ecological association in which one organism, the endosymbiont, lives inside another. The definition specifies location, not that both partners benefit, nor that the internal partner has become an organelle. An intracellular association can remain an association between distinct organisms. Endosymbiotic theory addresses a different question: how particular ancestral bacteria became inherited, functionally integrated organelles during evolution.

The striking consequence is that a eukaryotic biological cell can combine histories: its nuclear lineage and its mitochondria need not have the same ancestry. Mitochondria have bacterial ancestry related to Alphaproteobacteria; the plastids of plants and many algae, including chloroplasts, have ancestry within cyanobacteria. These are ancestral lineages, not a claim that a named living bacterial species is the literal ancestor. Present-day bacteria and organelles have both evolved since their shared ancestors. ^[ref]

A eukaryote is an organism belonging to the lineage characterized by a membrane-bounded cell nucleus and extensive cellular compartmentalization. A nuclear envelope surrounds the nuclear genome; nuclear chromosomes are typically linear. Ribosomes perform biological translation outside the cell nucleus. See OpenStax Microbiology, 3.4: nuclear organization and protein synthesis. Specialized biological cells can lose their cell nucleus, as mature mammalian red blood cells do, while remaining parts of eukaryotic organisms; see OpenStax Biology 2e, 40.2: mature red blood cells.

Yeasts, plants and animals are all eukaryotes. Typical cells in these groups have mitochondria, but chloroplasts belong to photosynthetic plant and algae lineages, not to every eukaryote. A cell wall occurs in typical plant and fungus cells but is absent from animal cells. These are comparisons of representative cells, not a checklist every specialized cell must satisfy. See OpenStax Biology 2e, 4.3: nucleus, organelles and representative cells.

The interesting feature is controlled separation: cell membranes and organelle membranes let different cellular processes occupy distinct compartments while membrane transport connects them. The evolution of eukaryotes also involved partnership: mitochondria descend from a bacterial endosymbiosis. Modern phylogenetics supports an archaeal ancestry for the nuclear lineage, alongside this bacterial contribution; see two-domain system. Thus the history of a whole eukaryote cannot be read as the history of just one of its genes.

Experimental Reconstruction of Functional Gene Transfer from the Tobacco Plastid Genome to the Nucleus by Sandra Stegemann and Ralph Bock (2006, Results, pp. 2870–2874) separated relocation of DNA from activation of a relocated gene. Engineered tobacco chloroplasts carried an nptII gene with nuclear expression signals beside an aadA gene with plastid expression signals. Selection on kanamycin recovered plants with the segment in the nuclear genome. Crosses then replaced the engineered chloroplasts with ordinary chloroplasts: the nuclear segment remained, but the plants were initially sensitive to spectinomycin and streptomycin. The transferred aadA gene was not yet functional in its new setting.

Leaf pieces were cultured on regeneration medium containing both drugs. Resistant regenerated plants supplied the functional readout. Using both drugs reduced selection of spontaneous plastid mutations conferring resistance mainly to one drug. Reciprocal crosses and selfing distinguished maternal plastid inheritance from nuclear Mendelian segregation; eight of sixteen initial candidates had the latter pattern. ^[ref]

The molecular readout came from RNA hybridization and DNA sequencing. A Northern blot detected aadA messenger RNA in activated lines, with different transcript sizes. Thermal asymmetric interlaced polymerase chain reaction recovered upstream DNA; products present in activated lines but absent in original-line and ordinary-plant controls were sequenced. The mapped rearrangements connected aadA to the upstream nuclear gene promoter. Thus resistance, inheritance, RNA detection and changed nucleotide sequences supported activation of the transferred nuclear gene, rather than resistance alone. ^[ref]

This engineered test demonstrates one route to functional nuclear gene expression after plastid DNA transfer. It does not establish a natural transfer rate, replay ancient endosymbiosis or demonstrate that the resulting protein is imported into a chloroplast. The authors explicitly identify acquisition of targeting information as an additional step not reproduced by this experiment. ^[ref]

A mitochondrion is an organelle with an outer mitochondrial membrane and an inner mitochondrial membrane. The latter encloses the mitochondrial matrix and folds into cristae; the intermembrane space lies on its opposite side. This architecture separates a chemical workspace from a membrane that couples electron transport to ATP formation.^[ref]

For an original location exercise, place soluble label A in the mitochondrial matrix and soluble label B in the interior of a crista. In the depicted geometry, B can reach the peripheral intermembrane space through the fold's opening without crossing a lipid bilayer. A must cross the inner mitochondrial membrane to reach either location. A fold projecting into the mitochondrial matrix therefore does not make its enclosed fluid part of the mitochondrial matrix. Following a continuous path through the colored regions proves the distinction; merely asking whether a label is “inside the mitochondrion” loses it.

The functional connection is equally spatial. The mitochondrial respiratory chain pumps protons from the mitochondrial matrix side across the inner mitochondrial membrane. Their return through ATP synthase can drive ATP formation. Oxidative phosphorylation develops the mechanism and chemiosmosis gives its free energy bookkeeping. Compartmentalization is useful because it lets a shared electrochemical gradient couple different proteins without direct transfer of a chemical intermediate between each pair.

Under aerobic conditions, mitochondria supply much of the ATP in many eukaryotic biological cells; the contribution varies with biological tissue, demand and oxygen supply. Glycolysis also makes ATP in the cytosol. Mature mammalian red blood cells lack mitochondria, and bacteria have no mitochondria at all. Neither all ATP production nor all biological cells fit the familiar mitochondrial picture.^[ref]

Mitochondria descend from a bacterial endosymbiosis and retain a genome and ribosomes, although many required proteins are encoded by nuclear genes. Endosymbiotic theory develops the ancestry argument; organelle protein import explains delivery of nuclear-encoded proteins. A functioning isolated mitochondrion demonstrates biochemical autonomy under supplied conditions, rather than independently establishing that ancestry.

The two-domain system recognizes bacteria and archaea as the two primary lineages, placing the nuclear ancestry of eukaryotes within archaea. In this model, archaea as a complete clade includes that eukaryotic lineage; restricting the name to prokaryotic members describes a different grouping. Williams and colleagues' study, published online in 2019 and in a 2020 journal issue, found support for this model and a close relationship to Asgard archaea. See Williams et al., 2020: Phylogenomics provides robust support for a two-domains tree of life.

This updates the interpretation of the 1977 and 1990 classifications rather than undoing their discovery of deep differences between bacteria and archaea. Deep phylogenetic trees depend on the sampled genes, organisms and inference model; the precise closest archaeal relatives and early sequence of events require further evidence. Bacterial ancestry of mitochondria through endosymbiosis is a separate part of eukaryotic history.