Multiply the equation of motion by and integrate. The conserved mechanical energy is
The initial conditions , give , so
Initially , so the particle starts moving towards the origin. For , factor its kinetic energy as
The quadratic function has maximum at . Consequently kinetic energy is strictly positive throughout exactly when . Thus the collision threshold is
For there is no intervening turning point, and the particle collides with the fixed particle. The collision takes finite time: near zero, , so the remaining time is bounded by a constant times .
For , the first turning point encountered is
The particle oscillates periodically between and , around the larger stable equilibrium, without collision. The zeros of at the two endpoints of this allowed region are simple, so travel to each turning point takes finite time. At the boundary , is a double zero of and an unstable equilibrium; the inward trajectory approaches it only as .
Figure 1.
The energy barrier distinguishes collision, asymptotic approach, and bounded oscillation
. Details.
Use as the gravitational acceleration, so the weights are and , consistently with the requested equations. The printed introductory phrase calling a force magnitude omits the factor .
For the particle on a cone coupled to a hanging mass, write and use the cylindrical coordinates unit vectors . The ideal string segment from the cone particle to the hole has length and direction . If is the downward length of the hanging segment and the fixed total length, then
The light ideal string and smooth hole give the same tension on both sides. Applying the vertical component of Newton's second law to the hanging particle gives
Write the normal reaction on the cone particle as , allowing to be signed according to the side of the ideal constraining surface. The acceleration in cylindrical coordinates and Newton's second law give
There is no azimuthal force. Multiplying the middle equation by proves
where the positive angular direction is chosen along the initial velocity. This is conservation of angular momentum about the vertical axis.
Subtract the radial equation from the vertical equation to eliminate the normal reaction. Since , this gives
Substitute the tension and the conserved angular momentum, using :
Multiplication by now gives an exact time derivative:
Initially and , because the initial velocity is horizontal. Therefore
This is also total mechanical energy divided by , with an irrelevant constant removed: the two particles contribute to the radial and vertical kinetic energy, while their combined gravitational potential energy is plus a constant.
Initially and , so the total gravitational potential energy is
If the given velocity is understood as a full tangential vector , put . The string length constraint gives , and hence
This formula accounts for both particles' kinetic energies, including that of the hanging particle.
If denotes only the initial speed, the printed wording does not specify its direction within the tangent plane. To make that dependence explicit, let be the angle from the downward generator of the cone towards the azimuthal unit vector, so
Then , and
For a launch along a generator, or , this reduces to . For a horizontal azimuthal launch, , it instead gives . A scalar speed alone does not determine a unique energy here. Both directions are tangent to the surface; “along the surface” does not distinguish them. The assumed configuration also requires so the second particle hangs below the apex.
Differentiate the sum of kinetic energy and potential energy using the dot product product rule:
The equations of motion make the bracket zero. Hence the mechanical energy is constant in time. The central restoring force can exchange kinetic and potential energy but supplies no change in their sum.
The volume form in cylindrical coordinates is . Integrating around the axis and over the height gives cylindrical-shell volume . Hence the volume integral is
For unit density, this is the kinetic energy of the rotational motion.
General definitions. The Euler-Lagrange equation gives . Write and . A normal mode has fixed displacement pattern and common time factor, ; its normal frequency satisfies
Here is angular frequency. A normal coordinate is the coefficient of one pattern in a complete modal expansion, so these coordinates decouple the equations. Since is positive definite, the change turns the mode equation into the ordinary symmetric eigenvalue problem for .
Three-mass equations. Let be horizontal displacements from the unstretched equilibrium, ordered left to right. The kinetic energy and potential energy are
Differentiating the potential energy gives
Thus and
Frequencies and patterns. Put . Expansion of the generalized eigenvalue problem for small oscillations gives
Solving at each root gives
The zero normal mode is uniform translation. In the lower nonzero mode, the central mass stays fixed, the two end masses move oppositely, and their unequal displacements balance both the end-mass momenta and the forces on the central mass. In the upper mode the end masses move together and the centre oppositely. Both vibrating modes leave the centre of mass fixed.
Orthogonality. Because is symmetric, two mode equations imply
Distinct eigenvalues therefore give the mass-matrix orthogonality of normal modes:
The Euclidean dot product need not vanish for unequal masses; for example , while . The modal squared norms are .
Figure 1.
The three normal modes of the unequal free mass chain
. Masses from left to right are m, 2m and 3m, joined by springs k and 3k. Arrow lengths show the modal amplitude ratios (1,1,1), (-3,0,1), and (1,-2,1). Details.
Normal coordinates. Expand . Project using the mass-weighted inner product and divide by each modal norm to obtain
For example, the inverse equations are , , . They reduce the energies to
and hence
The first coordinate is the centre of mass and has free linear motion. Multiplying by respectively gives mass-normalized normal coordinates if desired.
Use the equilibrium coordinates specified in the paper; their distances from the origin are one and their mutual separation is . Let be the small displacements. Each initially unstretched spring has, to first order, extension equal to the relative displacement projected along its original bond. Choose the three oriented extensions
The kinetic energy is exact in these displacement coordinates, while the potential energy needed for small oscillations is its quadratic part:
The factor in the equilibrium bond length cancels when forming the unit bond directions. Applying the Euler-Lagrange equation, or differentiating for the force on each mass, gives
The total force vanishes componentwise, as expected for three masses coupled only by internal spring forces.
Use the ordered displacement vector , and define by . For an unstretched spring, the extension to first order is the dot product of the relative displacement with its equilibrium unit vector. Summing its squared extensions gives the central spring stiffness matrix. The four side springs and two diagonal springs give
Therefore
The kinetic energy is , so a normal mode satisfies . Keeping the factor in the definition of fixes the normalization of and the resulting frequencies.
Figure 1.
Rigid rotation, breathing and modes with reflection symmetry
. Original displacement diagrams. Grey lines show all six equilibrium springs; arrows show representative mode vectors. The rotation has zero frequency, the breathing mode has squared frequency 4k/m, and the two other modes have squared frequency 2k/m. Details.
A normal mode has all coordinates following one fixed displacement pattern with a common time factor. Its normal frequency is that factor's oscillation frequency; normal mode coordinates are amplitudes in a basis of such patterns, making the linear equations independent. A zero-frequency mode can instead have constant velocity along a symmetry direction.
For the unit circle, each angular displacement equals its corresponding arc displacement. The kinetic energy and change in potential energy are
Any common spring prestress changes only the constant , because the sum of the three arc lengths is fixed. The Euler-Lagrange equations give
These are the normal modes of three beads connected by springs on a circular hoop, with third mass . For , their three mode vectors and squared angular frequencies are
The zero mode rotates the entire configuration without stretching a spring. The antisymmetric mode moves the equal masses oppositely while leaving the third fixed. In the symmetric mode the equal masses move together against the third, with zero total angular momentum. These vectors are orthogonal in the mass inner product with matrix .
Writing gives independent equations , , . In particular , retaining possible slow common rotation. For , the two positive frequencies coincide at ; their two-dimensional space is all patterns with .
Figure 1.
Rigid rotation and the two oscillatory patterns of three spring-coupled beads
. Original illustrations for the example . Arrows are tangent displacements at the equilibrium positions; spring extensions depend on differences of neighboring angular displacements. Details.
The kinetic energy is . Differentiating the given potential and applying Newton's second law gives
These are the normal modes of a symmetric three-mass string, with mass matrix and stiffness matrix . The coordinate order here is , although the spatial order along the string is .
Reflection symmetry splits the generalized eigenvalue problem into an antisymmetric mode , , with , and symmetric modes . Writing , these obey and . Thus . The three results are
The displacement vectors are mutually orthogonal under the mass-weighted inner product , as required for these conservative normal modes.
Figure 1.
The three transverse normal modes in their physical order along the string
. Original mode shapes with segment length . The moving particles have masses from left to right and positions . Vertical displacements are normalized independently in each panel; straight string segments join the particles and fixed endpoints. Details.
For a conservative system near a stable equilibrium, the quadratic Lagrangian has the form , with symmetric mass matrix and stiffness matrix . A normal mode satisfies the generalized eigenvalue problem for small oscillations , so the frequency equation is .
To quadratic order, vertical velocities contribute only fourth-order corrections to the kinetic energy, leaving . A string of length with small horizontal difference shortens its vertical projection by . The upper segment carries all three masses, the middle segment two, and the lower segment one. Hence their increases in gravitational potential energy sum to
Subtracting from gives the stated approximate Lagrangian. Here and
For a mode with middle displacement zero, write . The middle row requires , so . A nonzero mode then has , and the outer rows require . Therefore the necessary and sufficient condition is
When it holds, the mode shape is with . This is the force-cancellation mechanism of the stationary middle mass in a three-mass spring chain, applied to the equivalent quadratic stiffnesses here.
The quadratic Lagrangian gives and . Thus the Euler-Lagrange equations are
A nonzero mode vector has a common harmonic time factor and satisfies the generalized eigenvalue problem for small oscillations ; is its normal frequency. A zero-frequency mode instead admits a constant or linear time factor.
Measure the three coordinates as displacements from a configuration with both springs unstretched. The kinetic energy is , and the potential energy is . Expansion gives
For , direct substitution yields the three normal modes:
The three vectors are independent and orthogonal in the mass inner product , so they exhaust the motion. Their squared mass norms are ; division by the corresponding square roots gives normalized modes. This is the unit-spring, unit-outer-mass case of the normal modes of three masses connected by two equal springs.
As , the central displacement in the symmetric oscillatory mode tends to zero and both nonzero frequencies tend to one. The two limiting shapes and span independent motions of the outer masses against an effectively fixed centre; each unit mass has its own unit spring frequency. The translational mode remains at zero frequency. Under a bounded kinetic-energy condition its common velocity tends to zero as , while a static common displacement is still an equilibrium shift. One must specify that energy condition before concluding that an arbitrary freely translating heavy mass remains stationary.
Figure 1.
Mode shapes of a free three-mass chain, including the zero-frequency translation
. Details.
Put , with . Direct integration confirms the normalization:
The kinetic energy and potential energy terms in the dimensionless Rayleigh quotient are
Thus . Differentiating with respect to gives , so the unique minimizing width is . The two energy contributions are equal there, and the compact parabolic trial bound for the quantum harmonic oscillator is
The trial is continuous and zero at , so its weak first derivative is inside and zero outside. The jumps of that derivative do not add delta terms to the first derivative, and its squared norm is finite. The energy-form calculation is therefore valid even though the trial does not belong to the operator domain of the harmonic oscillator. Applying the second-derivative operator naively and omitting its endpoint distributions would be incorrect.
Use displacements of the left oxygen, carbon and right oxygen along a common positive direction. In this harmonic model the kinetic energy and elastic potential energy are
Thus the generalized eigenvalue problem for small oscillations is , where
The normal modes of three masses connected by two equal springs give the three independent solutions
The second row follows by holding the centre fixed and moving the end masses oppositely. In the remaining internal mode the end displacements are equal, and zero displacement of the centre of mass gives , yielding the third row; substitution verifies its frequency. Both nonzero modes have fixed centre of mass. In the symmetric stretch the two bond-length changes are equal; in the antisymmetric stretch they are opposite.
Figure 1.
Longitudinal mode directions of the free three-mass molecular model; the zero mode translates every mass together
. Details.
The zero mode occurs because a uniform translation changes neither spring length, so . It represents free center-of-mass motion, not an additional restoring vibration. Its general time amplitude is . Only one translational zero mode exists in the restricted one-dimensional model; transverse and rotational motion are outside its specified coordinates.
For the initial impulse, all displacement amplitudes at zero time vanish. Resolve the initial velocity into these three mode shapes:
Writing and gives the impulse on an end mass of a free symmetric three-mass chain:
In particular
where . The initial derivatives are , as required. The carbon dioxide model therefore drifts uniformly while undergoing both internal stretches. Its total momentum is the initial ; omitting the zero mode would incorrectly hold the centre of mass fixed.
Take both displacement coordinates positive to the right. The kinetic energy and elastic potential energy are
Thus the equations of motion are and . With , the generalized eigenvalue problem for small oscillations is
Its determinant gives . Put . The two-mass three-spring normal modes have
Both squared frequencies are positive because . Also , so and : the lower mode moves the masses in phase, and the higher mode moves them oppositely. A general mode is an arbitrary sinusoidal amplitude multiplying its fixed shape.
For equal masses these reduce to , and , . For unequal masses the vectors need not be Euclidean-orthogonal; they are orthogonal in the mass inner product, .
Figure 1.
In-phase and out-of-phase mode directions for an illustrative unequal-mass system; arrow lengths show relative displacements
. Details.
The kinetic energy is . Differentiating the quadratic potential energy gives the equations for small oscillations,
Put and . The eigenvalue problem is . Its characteristic polynomial is
Thus a convenient set of normal modes is
Each shape can be multiplied by an arbitrary sinusoidal time amplitude. In the lowest mode all beads move in phase. In the middle mode the central bead is fixed and the outer beads move oppositely. In the highest mode the two outer beads move together against the centre. These vectors are mutually orthogonal and span the three displacement coordinates.
Figure 1.
The three transverse string modes; the dashed line is equilibrium and bead displacements share one arbitrary scale
. Details.
These are the three-mass case of the normal modes of a uniformly loaded finite string, with discrete sine shapes . The sketches use straight string segments between masses and fixed zero displacements at the walls. The small-slope and constant-tension assumptions justify the quadratic energy and linear equations.
Take downward vertical distances from the support. The climber positions are , and . Their kinetic energy is therefore
Integrating the tension-extension relation gives the elastic potential energy for each taut rope. Because downward displacement lowers gravitational potential,
An arbitrary additive constant in is immaterial. This is the vertical-motion model implicit in using only rope lengths as generalized coordinates; swinging angles are not additional degrees of freedom in this model.
Assume the struck interval lies within the string, so . The initially stationary straight string has . Write its initial velocity as a Fourier sine series . Then
Thus . Immediately after the strike all the energy is kinetic energy:
The orthogonality integral assigns energy to mode . Since the ideal modes evolve independently, their total kinetic-plus-elastic energies remain constant. Therefore the modal energy of a localized velocity impulse on a string gives
The centre factor selects modes having significant motion at the impact location; the width factor accounts for cancellation across the finite hammer footprint. Parseval's identity ensures . The velocity discontinuities are understood in the mean-square sense and do not alter the energy integrals.
Use displacements from an equilibrium, so the two spring extensions are and . The kinetic energy and elastic potential energy are
Thus and , with the small-oscillation mass and stiffness matrices
If instead denote absolute positions, the appropriate natural spring lengths must first be subtracted from the differences in . They do not affect the equations for displacements.
Euler-Lagrange equations give , so a normal mode obeys the generalized eigenvalue problem for small oscillations . Reflection symmetry separates antisymmetric shapes from symmetric shapes . In the antisymmetric sector the end equation is , giving . In the symmetric sector the two independent equations are
Twice the first plus the second gives . If , then . Otherwise , and substitution into the first equation gives . Thus the three independent shapes are:
For both springs retain their lengths, so this is uniform translation. For the end masses move oppositely and their forces on the middle mass cancel. For the end masses move together, while the middle mass moves oppositely so the centre of mass remains fixed. Direct substitution verifies all three eigenpairs; for positive the three eigenvalues are distinct and exhaust the three degrees of freedom. These are the normal modes of three masses connected by two equal springs.
A useful normalization is the weighted inner product induced by . Since the squared mass norms are , and , respectively, take
If ordinary Euclidean unit eigenvectors are intended instead, divide by , respectively. The frequencies and physical motions are independent of this normalization choice. The zero-frequency coordinate has general motion rather than an oscillation.
Choose positive so the bob is displaced to the right relative to the cart. Its Cartesian coordinates are
Differentiation gives . Thus the exact kinetic energy and potential energy are
Retain quadratic terms, using in the kinetic cross term and in the potential. The Lagrangian is
Its Euler-Lagrange equations give
The kinetic cross term is essential: acceleration of the support couples the pendulum and cart. These equations define the normal modes of a spring-mounted pendulum cart.