Past exam of the physics A course of the University of Cambridge 2021 Paper 1 Section D D9 Solution Created 2026-10-18 Updated 2026-10-20
The photoelectric effect, black-body radiation and the Davisson–Germer experiment challenge different parts of a fully classical picture. Classical electromagnetic waves successfully describe propagation, interference and diffraction, while classical particles follow trajectories determined by forces. The difficulty is combining that picture with the observed exchange of energy between radiation and matter, the equilibrium distribution of radiation, and electron scattering. The three experiments expose the roles of discrete energy exchange and coherent matter waves.
In a photoelectric effect experiment, monochromatic light illuminates a metal cathode in vacuum and a second electrode collects emitted electrons. Varying the collecting voltage measures a photocurrent; reversing it until collection ceases determines the stopping potential. The observations distinguish two controls: at fixed frequency above threshold, increasing light intensity increases the emission rate, whereas the largest emitted kinetic energy is determined mainly by frequency. There is a material-dependent photoelectric threshold frequency, and emission above threshold does not require the long charging-up delay predicted by a simple picture of gradual classical energy accumulation at low intensity.
A classical wave carries continuously distributed energy, with intensity proportional to squared field amplitude. On a fully classical absorption picture, increasing intensity would be expected to increase the energy delivered to an electron, and sufficiently long exposure could accumulate the escape energy even below the observed threshold. It does not naturally produce the measured universal straight-line relation between stopping potential and light frequency. In 1905, Albert Einstein instead treated light-energy transfer as localized quanta. His argument distinguished the fastest escaping electrons from electrons losing energy before escape.[ref]
On a Heuristic Point of View Concerning the Production and Transformation of Light by Albert Einstein. §8, printed pp. 193–196, energy balance and frequency versus intensity predictions
In the single-photon regime, conservation of energy gives the Einstein photoelectric equationwhere is the surface work function. The photon supplies energy ; the escape cost is paid first, and the remainder sets the upper electron-energy edge. Increasing intensity at fixed frequency increases the number of available photons, so it raises current without raising this edge. Below , one photon cannot pay the escape cost. In an actual measurement, stable surface preparation, suppression of unwanted higher-frequency light, and the photoelectric contact-potential correction are needed to test the slope reliably. Robert Andrews Millikan's experiment used selected mercury spectral lines, freshly exposed metal surfaces and an electrometer to make such a quantitative test.[ref]
A Direct Photoelectric Determination of Planck's h by Robert Andrews Millikan. §§2–4, printed pp. 361–375, apparatus and stopping-potential measurements
The interpretation is for weak single-photon illumination; multiphoton photoemission at sufficiently intense fields is a different regime.Black-body radiation tests equilibrium physics rather than the escape of individual electrons. A small aperture in an isothermal absorbing cavity approximates an ideal blackbody: radiation entering the hole undergoes repeated interactions with the walls, and the equilibrium spectrum depends on temperature rather than wall material. A spectrally resolving detector outside the aperture measures how emitted power varies with frequency or wavelength. Experimentally the spectrum has a finite peak, is strongly suppressed at short wavelengths, shifts toward shorter wavelengths when the cavity is heated, and has integrated emission proportional to .
For a large cavity, the electromagnetic mode density in a box, including two independent transverse polarizations, is per volume per unit frequency. The classical equipartition theorem assigns mean energy to each mode, leading to the Rayleigh-Jeans lawThis agrees at low frequencies but diverges as frequency increases; integrating it over all frequencies gives infinite energy density at any nonzero temperature. This is the ultraviolet catastrophe, a failure of classical equipartition applied to the electromagnetic modes.
Max Planck's essential modification was that energy at a frequency is exchanged in units . In a modern oscillator description, the thermal excitation levels are , . Using the Boltzmann distribution and summing a geometric series givesMultiplying by the mode density yields Planck's law for the spectral energy density,When , expansion of the denominator recovers the classical law. When , the large excitation cost suppresses occupancy exponentially, removing the divergence. Its integral gives the Stefan–Boltzmann law, while its peak gives Wien's displacement law. Thus quantization repairs the spectral shape, total emission and temperature dependence together. The displayed thermal energy excludes the oscillator's temperature-independent zero-point energy.
The Davisson–Germer experiment supplies the complementary evidence that matter cannot always be treated as classical particles with definite scattering trajectories. In 1927, Clinton J. Davisson and Lester Halbert Germer sent a narrow, accelerated electron beam normally onto a single nickel crystal in vacuum. A movable collector measured the current of scattered electrons as direction and accelerating voltage were varied; a retarding potential selected electrons retaining approximately the incident energy. Sharp angular beams depended on crystal orientation and beam energy, with a prominent feature near and detector colatitude . These are scattering directions and currents, not photographs of electron paths.[ref]
Diffraction of Electrons by a Crystal of Nickel by C. Davisson and L. H. Germer. Printed pp. 707–710, apparatus; pp. 715–719, voltage and angular scans
The de Broglie wavelength predictsAt , this gives , comparable to atomic spacings. A crystalline arrangement supplies regularly spaced scattering sites, so scattered probability amplitudes can add constructively in selected directions. For a suitable family of crystal planes, Bragg's law expresses the condition as , with measured relative to those planes. The detector colatitude is not automatically this angle. The measured angular structure and its variation with electron momentum are described by electron diffraction with the de Broglie wavelength. A classical point-particle deflection model has no phase wavelength and does not supply that interference condition.
The common quantum account preserves the successes of wave propagation and particle detection while changing what is quantized. Photons exchange energy in frequency-dependent units; a thermal distribution of those excitations gives the blackbody spectrum. Electrons have a wavefunction whose amplitudes interfere on scattering from a crystal, while detection transfers localized charge. The Born rule turns squared amplitudes into event probabilities. These results invalidate a fully classical description of matter and radiation; the photoelectric energy law alone does not establish every property of a quantized electromagnetic field, but the three phenomena together provide complementary evidence for the quantum description.
Past exam of the physics B course of the University of Cambridge 2010 Paper 1 Section C C12 Solution 2026-10-20
For excitation energy , the geometric series gives the thermal partition function of a quantum harmonic oscillator with its zero-point energy subtracted:Thus at low temperature and approaches at high temperature. Restoring the zero-point term multiplies by and adds to , without changing the thermal occupation probabilities.
To count electromagnetic modes, put a large cavity in a periodic box of volume . One transverse polarization has wavevector-state density ; there are two independent polarizations. In the shell ,With , the electromagnetic mode density in a box becomesThe continuum expression is the large-cavity leading term; using standing-wave boundary conditions gives the same bulk count. Both photon polarizations must be included. This is density per angular frequency, not per ordinary frequency.
Each mode is an oscillator with zero photon chemical potential in thermal equilibrium. Multiplying its mean thermal energy by the mode density per volume gives the angular-frequency Planck energy densityAt small it reduces to the Rayleigh–Jeans result ; exponential suppression at high frequency prevents a divergent thermal energy. With ,The integral is the stipulated . This is a volume energy density, ; for isotropic cavity radiation the outward black-surface flux is , with . Distinguishing flux, spectral density and total volume energy avoids extra factors of , or .
Past exam of the physics B course of the University of Cambridge 2014 Paper 2 Section C C13 Solution 2026-10-20
Molecules. In a dilute classical gas, collisions establish a Maxwell-Boltzmann distribution. The normalized speed distribution and its first two moments areMomentum transfer to a wall gives . Translational internal energy is ; rotational and vibrational degrees of freedom add energy when thermally populated, without changing the dilute ideal-gas pressure law. Classical equipartition gives per quadratic contribution, but quantum level spacing can freeze out modes.
Only the molecules moving towards a surface contribute to its one-sided number flux:For an effusive molecular energy flux, faster molecules are preferentially sampled, giving mean translational energy per crossing molecule and . This differs from multiplying by the bulk mean . Collisions and finite molecular interactions produce transport and departures from the ideal-gas equation of state.
Photons. All photons travel at in vacuum, so their thermal distribution is over frequency, not over a range of speeds. The two polarizations and Bose-Einstein occupation with zero chemical potential giveHere the spectral quantity is and the total energy density is . Momentum flux gives , while isotropic angular averaging gives the one-sided energy flux through a small aperture of a black-body cavity. The photon number flux is similarly .
Both pressures arise from momentum transfer, but their equations of state differ: a classical molecular gas has with fixed molecule number, whereas a photon gas has , and an equilibrium photon number that changes with temperature. Photon creation and absorption by the walls are essential to the zero-chemical-potential equilibrium description.
Past exam of the physics B course of the University of Cambridge 2015 Paper 1 Section A A5 Solution 2026-10-20
After the photon has thermalized, its energy belongs to the macroscopic body's internal energy. The body's heat capacity makes the resulting temperature change negligible. Its equilibrium entropy therefore increases byThe Boltzmann entropy then gives the microstate multiplier from photon absorption:For scale, explicitly choosing a representative visible wavelength and room temperature gives , or , and a multiplier approximately . These are illustrative choices, not additional supplied data: the exact multiplier depends exponentially on the particular visible wavelength and temperature. The exact Planck constant, speed of light, and Boltzmann constant fix the conversion.[ref]
Past exam of the physics B course of the University of Cambridge 2018 Paper 2 Section C C11 Solution 2026-10-18
Equilibrium radiation and cavity frequencies. A blackbody absorbs all incident radiation at every frequency and direction. In thermal equilibrium its emission spectrum depends only on its temperature. Radiation inside an isothermal absorbing cavity, sampled through a small aperture that hardly disturbs equilibrium, realizes black-body radiation to a good approximation. Microscopic absorption and emission establish the equilibrium distribution; a perfectly reflecting wall is the convenient idealization used to count the modes once that distribution is specified.
In a rectangular electromagnetic cavity, the wave equation and perfect conductor wall boundary conditions select component wavenumbers , , . Combining the vacuum dispersion relation and givesFor example, electric-field components can have the spatial dependenceFor three positive indices, Gauss's law requires , leaving two independent polarizations of an electromagnetic wave.
Index qualification. The original paper describes the indices as positive integers. That describes the three-nonzero-index family but omits valid electromagnetic modes with exactly one zero index, which have one polarization of an electromagnetic wave. For instance, with , , only above remains; it is normal to the top and bottom faces and vanishes at the side walls. Two zero indices give no nontrivial cavity field. The omitted one-zero-index family does not affect the leading three-dimensional mode count, but is essential to the thin-cavity limit below. Retaining the paper's strict positivity restriction for every mode would instead give a thickness gap and would not yield its requested two-dimensional power law.
Three-dimensional mode count. A lattice cell in positive space has volume , where . In a continuum approximation, a shell of radius and thickness contains its positive octant, multiplied by two polarizations:Using givesFor a finite cavity the exact density of states is discrete; this formula is its bulk continuum limit, appropriate when many modes contribute and wall corrections are small.
Mean photon number. A mode is a quantum harmonic oscillator with thermal excitation energies , . The zero-point energy does not enter its thermal occupation. Put . Its partition function and mean occupation areThis is the Bose-Einstein distribution with zero photon chemical potential: equilibrium absorption and emission do not conserve photon number.
Thermal energy. Multiply the density of states by the mean excitation energy and integrate:The substitution isolates all the dependence on cavity dimensions and temperature:Expanding gives an integral . HenceThis is the thermal energy only, excluding the zero-point contribution. The three-dimensional continuum regime requires large compared with the geometric level spacings in all three directions.
Spectral sketch. The spectral energy density per unit ordinary frequency is Planck's law,At small frequency it rises as , while at large frequency it decays exponentially. Raising temperature increases the spectrum at every fixed positive frequency, moves the peak to larger frequency in proportion to , and increases the integrated area in proportion to . A plot per unit wavelength has a different peak position because the integration variable changes.
Thin-cavity radiation. Let . The relevant low-temperature window isNonzero thickness indices are then thermally suppressed, while many in-plane modes are populated. The family has one polarization of an electromagnetic wave. Its allowed in-plane wavenumbers form a lattice of cell area ; a quarter of a circular shell therefore containsThus the dimensional crossover of thermal cavity radiation givesThe integral is by the same geometric-series argument. A model with a different number of independent polarizations of an electromagnetic wave changes the prefactor but not the scaling. For a cavity with fixed finite , cooling still further eventually freezes its lowest in-plane mode as well: the strict thermal energy is exponentially suppressed. The requested area law is the intermediate quasi-two-dimensional regime, not an arbitrarily low-temperature continuum limit.
A cubic reflecting cavity supports standing waves with positive integer mode indices and wavevector components . A cell in mode space has volume . In the continuum approximation, a spherical shell of radius and thickness has one-eighth of its volume in the positive octant. There are two independent transverse photon polarizations for a generic wavevector. HenceThe photon energy is , so . ThereforeThis is the leading bulk density of states, valid when the cavity is large compared with the relevant wavelengths and many modes lie in the counting interval. A finite cavity has a discrete mode spectrum, with boundary corrections beyond this approximation. Modes with vanishing indices require separate boundary counting but do not change the leading term. Here is the reduced Planck constant, as printed in the original PDF; replacing it by would introduce an erroneous factor of .
Each independent cavity mode is a quantum harmonic oscillator of angular frequency . Its occupation numbers represent the numbers of photons in that mode. At thermal equilibrium, photons can be absorbed and emitted by the walls, so their number is not conserved and the photon chemical potential is zero. The Boltzmann distribution of the oscillator excitations then givesThe expression supplied in the paper is the thermal excitation energy. The oscillator's temperature-independent zero-point energy is excluded from the emitted thermal radiation.
Putting and into the mode count from (a) gives the number of modes per unit cavity volume:Multiplying by the mean thermal energy in each mode yields Planck's law in the angular-frequency convention:The two photon polarizations are already included in the density of states; no further factor of two is needed. has units , whereas has units .
For a proper lifetime inferred from a delayed decay flash, the measured interval ends when the light returns to the detector, not when the muon decays. Put passage at in the detector frame. If decay occurs at , its distance is , and the backwards photon takes another to arrive. ThereforeThe muon's proper elapsed time isApplying time dilation directly to the 10 ns reception interval would transform the wrong pair of events.
For collinear inelastic capture followed by two photons, each particle has and , with . An isolated collision conserves the vector sum of momentum and total energy, including rest energy, internal excitation and radiation. It need not conserve the sum of individual rest masses. At low speed,recovering the classical kinetic energy after subtracting .
Here the incoming Lorentz factors are and , soThe composite therefore hasIts rest mass exceeds because relative kinetic energy has become internal rest energy.
Take the incident photon along , and write for the boost. In the boosted frame the initial momenta areTheir sum vanishes when , giving and . The initial photon energy there is , and total energy is .
For right-angle Compton scattering in the centre-of-momentum frame, choose the outgoing ZM photon along . The electron has the opposite momentum . Conservation of energy determines its magnitude:Thus . Inverting the velocity transformation givesConsequentlyThe electron recoils below the incident direction for our choice of photon scattering above it; the reflected configuration reverses both transverse signs. Finally,As a check, , so the final energies sum to the initial . The outgoing laboratory photon makes with .
Each photon has energy , giving the photon emission rate from monochromatic power and wavelengthHere is radiated signal power, not the phone's total electrical consumption.
In standard configuration the frames are inertial, their corresponding axes are parallel, S moves at along the positive axis of S, and their origins coincide at . Here and label the same event, is the speed of light and .
A clock fixed in S has . The inverse time transformation givesso the moving clock accumulates less proper time between its two ticks than the elapsed S-coordinate time.
Without time dilation the flight time from the given altitude would be , about rest-frame mean lifetimes, giving survival fraction only even at speed . Relativistic muons can instead reach the ground with appreciable survival. Momentum-selected decay measurements test this clock-rate dependence experimentally.[ref]
Variation of the Rate of Decay of Mesotrons with Momentum by Bruno Rossi and David B. Hall. Physical Review 59, 223 (1941), primary abstract: different momentum groups have different observed decay rates consistent with relativistic moving clocks
A mean-lifetime survival energy estimate requires a mean flight time no greater than the dilated mean lifetime:This corresponds to survival probability at least about . There is no sharp minimum energy for an individual random decay. For a required probability , use . Energy loss in the atmosphere is neglected in this estimate. In the muon's frame the atmospheric path is length-contracted to ; the ground reaches it in about , giving the same survival probability.
In the laboratory frame the incoming particle and the composite move along , while the target is initially at rest. In the equal-energy two-photon decay of a moving particle, zero total transverse momentum makes the two photon directions symmetric about . Each photon has energy and momentum magnitude , so longitudinal momentum conservation gives . ThereforeTheir momenta can be written . The opening angle is not in this frame, because the parent carried nonzero total momentum.
Boost along at into the centre-of-momentum frame. The composite is stationary. The incoming particle has , while the target has . After decay the two photons have energies and opposite momenta.
Equal laboratory photon energies require the rest-frame photons to have zero momentum component along the boost: must be equal for two opposite photons. Their directions are therefore and in the centre-of-momentum diagram, perpendicular to the incoming collision axis. Boosting those transverse photons gives exactly the laboratory momenta in part (a). A stationary composite has no direction-of-travel arrow in this frame.
The threshold must conserve both energy and momentum. For head-on photons, the total energy is , while the total momentum has magnitude . Their combined invariant mass satisfiesAt the threshold for photon-photon pair production, the electron and Positron have no relative momentum in their centre-of-momentum frame, so . ThereforeSimply equating the laboratory energy to would miss the very large laboratory momentum: the newly produced pair must carry it away.
Past exam of the physics course of the year 1 of the natural sciences course of the University of Cambridge 2018 Section A 5 Solution Created 2026-10-18 Updated 2026-10-20
For a photon, the photon energy formula and the vacuum relation give . For an electron, the de Broglie wavelength gives the same momentum magnitude , but the nonrelativistic kinetic energy is . Using , and ,Thus, to the precision of the wavelength,The electron answer is its kinetic energy, as required for the diffraction experiment; its relativistic energy would additionally include the approximately rest energy. Since , the nonrelativistic approximation is well justified. Equal wavelengths imply equal momenta, not equal energies for particles with different energy–momentum relations.
Substitution into the Schrödinger equation gives . For the stated electron well,The transition emits the energy difference, , soUsing the full excited-state energy as the photon energy would neglect the nonzero ground-state energy.
The photon wavelength is . The exact half-period zone radii for incident plane waves are chosen so that the path to the axial focus increases by per zone:Transmit alternate zones and block the others, with . For , . The number of zones is a design choice: 100 zones give outer radius and outermost width about . Adjacent open zones then arrive in phase at the principal focus.
The blocking material must be sufficiently opaque at 35 keV; no attenuation coefficient or fabrication thickness is specified. A binary amplitude plate also has zero-order transmission and other odd-order foci, so an aperture/order stop may be needed. The principal focal length is chromatic, varying as for fixed radii.
Use energy units , , and . The soft-photon resonant capture threshold follows from four-momentum conservation:For fixed proton energy the left side is largest at head-on incidence. Its threshold is . Combining that with givesEquality is allowed for a head-on photon. Here , soA very soft photon needs an enormous proton Lorentz factor to reach the specified invariant mass. A true thermal photon distribution and a finite-width resonance would smear this monoenergetic threshold.
For , , whereas , so production is impossible. For each nonzero angle, sufficiently large energy is possible, and givesTo find the maximum deflection in soft-photon capture, note that the final particle's transverse momentum comes entirely from the photon:Writing , maximization gives and the interior maximum . Therefore, to the same extraordinarily accurate ultrarelativistic order,The neglected relative corrections are of order and , both around . The final particle is effectively collinear with the proton despite a large photon incidence angle.


