First realize the free isometric action. Choose generators of the finitely presented group . In every dimension , the connected sum
has fundamental group the free group . Map its generators onto the and take the connected regular covering corresponding to the kernel. Its deck transformation group is . Lift any Riemannian metric on to . Deck transformations are then Riemannian isometries, and a deck transformation fixing one point is the identity by uniqueness of lifts. This gives the free isometric realization of a finitely generated group. For the trivial group use . If is infinite the covering manifold need not be compact, which is allowed in this first construction. Simple connectivity of is not being asserted here.
The requested nonhomeomorphism conclusion needs an extra hypothesis. For a counterexample even with distinct subgroups, take , and . They are conjugate and therefore Gassman equivalent. For every free isometric action of , the conjugating element induces a Riemannian isometry . These quotients cannot be nonhomeomorphic. Identical subgroups give an even simpler obstruction. Thus the stated equivalence condition alone cannot imply the claimed topology.
A sufficient version is: for a finite with Gassmann equivalent, nonisomorphic subgroups , there are closed isospectral manifolds with fundamental groups , and hence they are not homeomorphic. To prove it, realize as the fundamental group of a closed smooth manifold of dimension four. Here is the needed closed-manifold realization of a finitely presented fundamental group. Start with a four-dimensional zero-handle and one one-handle for each generator. Attach two-handles along disjoint embedded boundary circles representing the relators, with arbitrary framings. The boundary is three-dimensional, so finitely many such loops can be chosen disjoint. The resulting compact handle manifold has by the Seifert-van Kampen theorem.
The inclusion is surjective on fundamental groups: relative to the boundary the dual handle decomposition uses only handles of indices two, three and four, none of which introduces a fundamental-group generator. Double along its boundary. In the amalgamated product for the double, both boundary maps are the same surjection onto , so the two copies of are identified completely and . The double is closed, connected and smooth after smoothing its collar. This construction works in any dimension at least four; it does not claim that every finitely presented group is a closed three-manifold group.
Let now be the universal cover of with the lifted metric. Since is finite, is compact and simply connected, with a free isometric deck action of . By Sunada theorem, are isospectral. Because is their universal cover, . Nonisomorphic fundamental groups rule out a homeomorphism. For an infinite the same qualified argument applies to finite-index subgroups with equal coset characters: divide first by the intersection of their finite-index subgroup cores, producing a compact intermediate cover and a finite isometry group to which Sunada applies.
For explicit nonhomeomorphic examples, let be an odd prime. Let , and let be the Heisenberg group over a prime field, whose elements are triples with multiplication
Both have order , and every nonidentity element has order . For , induction gives
so the assertion follows at , since is odd. But is abelian and is not: and do not commute.
Embed both groups regularly in . Every nonidentity element in either regular representation has cycle type . Hence both embedded subgroups meet the identity class once, the class of that cycle type times, and all other classes zero times. They are nonisomorphic Gassmann equivalent regular subgroups. Taking and using the closed four-manifold construction with gives an explicit pair of isospectral nonhomeomorphic quotients, completing the intended construction under a sufficient hypothesis.
Finally choose distinct odd primes and take
Conjugacy classes in a direct product are products of classes, so their intersection counts factor. Thus all subgroups are Gassmann equivalent. They are pairwise nonisomorphic: the unique Sylow -subgroup of is its th factor, and whether it is abelian records . Realize as the fundamental group of a closed four-manifold and quotient its universal cover by these subgroups. The binary family of nonhomeomorphic Sunada quotients gives
This existence statement is valid; the earlier universal nonhomeomorphism assertion from Gassmann equivalence alone is not.
Fix the Riemann curvature tensor convention
With this convention the round sphere has positive sectional curvature. Write . We use skew-symmetry in the first and last pairs, pair interchange , and the first Bianchi identity. These are the standard curvature symmetries of the Levi-Civita connection.
For an orthonormal basis of , the Ricci curvature is the trace
For a plane spanned by linearly independent vectors , its sectional curvature is
Both definitions are independent of the chosen basis. The first is the trace of ; the second is unchanged by replacing with another basis of their plane, because numerator and denominator both scale by the square of the change-of-basis determinant. For , , the denominator is one. The terms with vanish, so
The ordered-pair sum counts every unoriented coordinate plane twice.
For , pair interchange immediately gives
Thus is self-adjoint, including when . The usual Jacobi curvature operator is its negative and is self-adjoint as well. Keeping these two signs distinct will also fix the Jacobi field equation below.
The Bonnet-Myers theorem states that a connected, complete -dimensional Riemannian manifold, , with for a constant has diameter at most and is compact. Completeness is required; a pointwise positive Ricci tensor without a uniform positive lower bound would not suffice for this stated conclusion.
A left-invariant metric on a Lie group is a Riemannian metric for which every left translation is an isometry, equivalently . It is determined by an inner product on the Lie algebra . If the metric is also right-invariant, this inner product is invariant under the adjoint action; differentiating yields
Use left-invariant vector fields and the permitted formula . The Jacobi identity gives
Adjoint skew-symmetry then implies
This is the Ricci curvature of a bi-invariant Riemannian metric. The last expression vanishes precisely when belongs to the center of the Lie algebra. If that center is zero, it is positive for every nonzero . Its minimum on the unit sphere in is therefore positive. Left invariance transfers this bound to every point: .
Work in the identity component , since . It is compact and hence complete. Give its universal cover the lifted metric. The cover is complete: a geodesic projects to a geodesic in , extends for all time there, and its extension lifts through any prescribed starting point. The local isometry also preserves Ricci curvature, so the same uniform bound holds on the cover. Applying Bonnet-Myers with makes compact. The fiber above is closed and discrete, and hence finite in this compact space; its cardinality equals . Consequently is finite. This is the finite fundamental group from a uniform positive Ricci bound. If , the identity component is a point and the conclusion is immediate; a one-dimensional Lie algebra cannot have zero center.
The multiplicative norm first rules out zero divisors: if and , then forces . If the dimension is zero the claimed bound already holds, so suppose it is positive.
It is worth checking that the printed description of a ring with an underlying real vector space really permits differentiation of multiplication. This follows from the norm identity even if compatibility with real scalars is not separately stated. For fixed , the map is additive by distributivity, and
It is therefore continuous. Additivity gives rational linearity. Approximating a real number by rationals and using continuity proves for every real . The same argument holds in the other variable. This is automatic real bilinearity from a multiplicative norm, so multiplication is a bilinear map between finite-dimensional vector spaces, and hence is smooth.
Let be the unit sphere of the given positive-definite bilinear form. It is a copy of . The squaring map
is well defined because , and is smooth. Commutativity gives its derivative
For and , the norm identity gives , so the derivative is injective, including on the tangent space . It takes tangent vectors into since maps the sphere to itself. Alternatively, polarization of gives , so directly.
The only identifications under squaring are antipodal:
The factorization uses commutativity, and the last implication uses the absence of zero divisors. Conversely . It follows that induces an injective smooth map
The antipodal quotient map is a local diffeomorphism, so the injectivity of implies injectivity of . Since Real projective space is compact, the stated compact injective immersion is an embedding theorem makes a closed embedding.
For its source and target have the same dimension . The inverse function theorem makes its image open as well as closed in the connected sphere . It is nonempty, so the image is the whole sphere; consequently is a diffeomorphism. But for this is impossible:
Indeed, the antipodal two-sheeted covering map has simply connected total space in this range, and is its universal cover, with deck group . A sphere of dimension at least two is simply connected. These fundamental groups cannot be those of homeomorphic spaces.
We have obtained the dimension bound for a commutative Euclidean normed algebra:
The real numbers and complex numbers with their usual products and Euclidean norms attain dimensions one and two. In dimension two, the induced map is entirely compatible with the argument: the circle squaring map identifies exactly the two antipodal preimages. We neither assume a multiplicative identity nor use a classification of real division algebras; the squaring argument proves the bound from the supplied hypotheses.
Call this simultaneous antipodal quotient of two spheres . The simultaneous antipodal map acts freely on , so is a connected closed manifold of dimension four. Each antipodal factor has mapping degree ; their product preserves orientation. Hence is orientable.
The product is simply connected, so this double covering space is the universal cover. Consequently
using the abelianization of the fundamental group. The Euler characteristic under a finite covering gives . Its rational first Betti number is zero, and Poincare duality gives and . Thus as well.
The universal coefficient theorem for cohomology now gives and
Here because . Integral Poincare duality further gives , and .
Let generate these groups in degrees respectively. The only potentially nonzero positive-degree cup product is . But , while has no nonzero torsion subgroup, so . Every other positive product vanishes by dimension. Thus
with every product of positive-degree elements equal to zero. The degree-three torsion is essential: it would be lost by computing only rational cohomology.
The Bonnet-Myers theorem says that a connected geodesically complete -dimensional Riemannian manifold, with and for a constant , has
The dimension and positive lower bound are essential: in dimension one the Ricci condition is vacuous, and a zero lower bound does not imply bounded diameter.
By Hopf-Rinow, any two distinct points have a unit-speed minimizing geodesic . Choose parallel orthonormal fields perpendicular to its tangent . For the endpoint-vanishing fields , the second variation of geodesic energy gives nonnegative index forms
Summing and using the Ricci lower bound produces the sine index-form bound for positive Ricci curvature:
If , the last expression is negative, a contradiction. This proves the diameter bound. Hopf-Rinow makes closed bounded sets compact, so the entire manifold is compact.
Give the universal cover the pullback metric. Local isometry preserves its Ricci bound, and lifting complete base geodesics proves completeness of the cover. The same diameter and compactness argument applies there. A fiber of the covering is closed and discrete, hence finite in this compact cover; its cardinality is that of the fundamental group. This proves the final assertion.
For a counterexample that also breaks the diameter conclusion, use the incomplete positively curved strip with infinite diameter
The map is a local isometry to the round unit sphere: its coordinate derivatives are orthogonal, with squared lengths one and . Thus and , satisfying the required lower bound with , .
The meridian is a unit-speed geodesic and reaches the excluded boundary at , so this metric is incomplete. Every curve joining to has length at least , because on the strip. Therefore despite the positive Ricci bound. Completeness cannot be omitted.
Let be the rationalized universal class of degree . The rational cohomology of an integral Eilenberg–MacLane space is
Here is an exterior algebra. For , . The standard path-loop spectral-sequence calculation supplies the induction: in
the total space is contractible and the fundamental fiber class transgresses to . An odd exterior fiber generator gives an even polynomial base generator. An even polynomial fiber generator gives an odd exterior base generator; the differential on its th power has coefficient , which is invertible over . The multiplicative spectral sequence then has no remaining positive-degree classes in the total space. This is the rational transgression calculation for Eilenberg–MacLane spaces; it includes the absence of additional base generators.
For , choose representing the integral fundamental class. The ring calculation shows that this map is a rational homology equivalence: both spaces have rational cohomology only in degrees zero and . The rational Whitehead theorem for simply connected spaces identifies their rational homotopy groups. Since the target has only , the rational homotopy groups of a sphere in odd dimension are
For , this follows directly from and the contractible universal cover of the circle, which makes every higher homotopy group zero.
Let , with the standard complex orientations. It is simply connected by the Seifert-van Kampen theorem applied to the punctured summands. Classes can be chosen from the two summands. Their cross product vanishes, while their squares equal the oriented top class:
Thus the cohomology ring of the connected sum of two complex projective planes is
The two relations also kill all cubic monomials, so its dimensions are in degrees and zero otherwise.
We use the Sullivan minimal model dictionary: for a simply connected finite-type space, the dual of its degree- generator space is . The following free graded-commutative differential algebra is the Sullivan model of the connected sum of two complex projective planes:
It is minimal because all differentials of generators are decomposable.
To verify that no further generators are required, observe that is a regular sequence in . The first polynomial is a nonzerodivisor. If is divisible by , restricting to each coordinate axis forces to vanish on both axes, hence to be divisible by . The second polynomial is therefore a nonzerodivisor modulo the first. The Koszul complex of this regular sequence is exactly , so its cohomology is the quotient ring above, with no additional odd cohomology.
For completeness, choose rational polynomial forms representing on . Their product and the difference of their squares are exact; choose degree-three primitives for them. Sending to those primitives defines a differential-algebra map from to the rational polynomial forms on . It induces the specified cohomology-ring isomorphism and hence is a quasi-isomorphism. This verifies the model directly, rather than assuming that a cohomology presentation alone automatically determines all rational homotopy.
The model has exactly two degree-two and two degree-three generators. Consequently the rational homotopy groups of the connected sum of two complex projective planes are
A covering map is a continuous surjection for which each point has an open neighbourhood with a disjoint union of open sets, each mapped homeomorphically onto . A connected simply connected covering space is a universal cover.
There is a necessary connectedness qualification in the printed conclusion. Let be the path component of in . Then : one inclusion follows by projecting paths, and the other by lifting a path in from . Thus the asserted surjection onto all of requires to be path connected. Without it, take to be the identity of and to be two disjoint intervals; a selected component cannot cover both.
To prove the assertion about a component of a pulled-back universal cover, choose an evenly covered neighbourhood in . Local path connectedness of supplies a path-connected relatively open neighbourhood . Each inverse sheet over is path connected, so it lies wholly in or is disjoint from it. These sheets evenly cover under . Therefore is a covering map.
Under the classification of connected covering spaces, its subgroup consists of based loops in whose lifts close at . A loop viewed in closes in the universal cover exactly when its class in is trivial. Hence the subgroup is
Here , so the subgroup formula itself needs no change. Injectivity of the covering's induced fundamental-group map is the usual homotopy-lifting property.
Take and the complete analytic function generated by a logarithm germ. Its continuation surface identifies with via with and logarithm value . Thus . It is a universal cover; the deck transformations act transitively on each fibre, so it is also a regular covering map in the deck-transitive sense. It is not bijective, since every nonzero has infinitely many logarithm values. It also meets the alternative convention in which “regular” merely requires an evenly covered neighbourhood at each base point.
A Serre fibration has the homotopy lifting property for every disc: given and with , there is a lift extending . Equivalently one may test this property on CW complexes.
For a map , its mapping-path fibration replacement is
Path spaces have the compact-open topology, with the usual compactly generated convention. The inclusion satisfies . Forgetting the path is a homotopy inverse to : shorten to , from its constant initial path at to the original path at . The equivalence here means a commuting triangle over the same base whose map of total spaces is a homotopy equivalence; it does not assert a fibrewise homotopy inverse over the base. Appending the successive segments of a moving base path gives the homotopy lifting property for , even for arbitrary parameter spaces, so is in particular a Serre fibration. Its ordinary fibre over is the homotopy fibre
For a based Serre fibration, with fibre inclusion , the long exact sequence of homotopy groups of a fibration is
The maps compose based sphere representatives with ; the maps on path components do the same with points. To define , represent a class by and lift the cube starting at on its bottom face, keeping its vertical sides at . The opposite face then gives . Relative lifting for a CW pair gives this construction; its based homotopy class is independent of choices. At it records the component of the endpoint of the lifted loop. The last terms are pointed sets rather than groups in general.
Now write and let be the collapse map. Inclusion of the -sphere is a section, so is surjective in every positive degree. Thus all connecting maps in its homotopy fibre sequence vanish. The fibre is path-connected, and
The section also gives the first assertion when , by killing the connecting map from .
The universal cover of consists of a line with an -sphere attached at each integer. It is homotopy equivalent to the wedge sum . This cover is -connected, so the Hurewicz theorem identifies its th homotopy group with its th homology. Choose a generator of the fundamental group whose action shifts the sphere indexed by to that indexed by . The resulting homotopy groups as modules over the fundamental group give
Every lifted sphere maps to with degree one. Consequently is the augmentation , with the trivial -action on . The inclusion of the fibre respects the fundamental group actions, so
The augmentation ideal of the infinite cyclic group is generated by : multiply a Laurent polynomial by a power of and use divisibility by when its value at one vanishes. Multiplication by is injective, giving the last isomorphism. This is a free module of rank one, whose underlying abelian group has countably infinite rank; its -action is not trivial.
The universal cover is simply connected. Hence the closed combinatorial path is null-homotopic in its two-dimensional CW complex. The van Kampen lemma supplies a finite disc diagram mapping to with precisely that boundary path.
Choose such a diagram with the smallest possible number of two-cells, and then with the smallest number of edges. If two adjacent cells formed a cancellable pair, removing that pair would preserve the boundary path and reduce the area, a contradiction. Thus
This does not assume that is simply connected. Only the loop's null-homotopy in is used. If the two boundary paths agree, a diagram with no two-cells is allowed; if they share initial or final segments, the diagram may have tree portions or cut vertices. A disc diagram need not be an embedded topological disk.
The two Lie groups have the same local infinitesimal structure, but different global topology. This difference determines which Lie algebra representations integrate to representations of each group.
An element of the SU(2) group is a unitary matrix of determinant one. Orthogonality of its columns and its determinant give the unique form
Thus its group manifold is the unit three-sphere in : this is SU(2) as the three-sphere. In particular it is compact, connected and simply connected. In terms of the Pauli matrices one may also write with real coefficients satisfying .
Differentiate and at . The tangent space consists of traceless skew-Hermitian matrices:
The Lie bracket of a Matrix Lie group is the matrix commutator. With , the Pauli matrix multiplication law gives
This derives the SU(2) Lie algebra as a three-dimensional real Lie algebra. The Hermitian physics generators instead obey ; they are times the skew-Hermitian tangent generators, so these are consistent conventions.
The SO(3) group consists of real orthogonal matrices with determinant one. Differentiating at the identity gives
The determinant condition gives no additional infinitesimal constraint because a skew-symmetric matrix already has trace zero. Define . The cross product identity implies
Therefore the SO(3) Lie algebra has the same structure constants and is a Lie algebra isomorphism.
The global relation is the Adjoint double cover from SU(2) to SO(3). For , define by
Conjugation preserves the real space of traceless Hermitian matrices and its inner product . Hence is orthogonal. Continuity and connectedness, together with , put it in . Composition of conjugations makes a group homomorphism. If , then commutes with every Pauli matrix, hence is scalar; unitarity and determinant one leave precisely . The differential sends to , so it is an isomorphism. More concretely,
induces rotation through angle about , by the Rodrigues rotation formula. Every three-dimensional rotation has such an axis and angle, proving surjectivity. Consequently
The matrices and are antipodal points on the three-sphere, so the SO(3) group manifold is Real projective space . Equivalently, the closed axis-angle ball has opposite boundary points identified. The fundamental group is , whereas . A rotation lifts from to ; a rotation returns to . Thus the covering is the universal cover and the groups are not globally isomorphic.
For representation theory, specify finite-dimensional complex continuous representations. Compactness permits an invariant Hermitian inner product, obtained by averaging against Haar measure, and therefore complete reducibility. Complexifying either real Lie algebra gives the sl2 Lie algebra. Its finite-dimensional irreducibles are indexed by , have highest weight , and have dimension . By integration of a Lie-algebra representation, since is simply connected, every such Lie algebra representation integrates uniquely. The resulting homogeneous polynomial representation of SU2 is
In the spin angular momentum notation , its Hermitian eigenvalues are . The central matrix acts on the symmetric power by , so descent of an SU(2) representation to SO(3) occurs exactly when is even. Hence
For a reducible representation, every summand must satisfy the descent condition. The spin-one-half doublet is a genuine representation of the covering group but does not define a single-valued representation of ; the spin-one triplet does and is its vector representation. The distinction is topological, rather than a difference in their isomorphic Lie algebras.
A unit-speed curve on a smooth embedded surface is a geodesic exactly when its acceleration is normal to the surface, equivalently when its tangential acceleration vanishes.
Every unit-speed geodesic on the cylinder through has the form
Indeed, unrolling the cylinder to its universal cover turns these curves into straight lines. Directly,
which is parallel to the cylinder's radial normal vector, verifying the geodesic characterization. Such a geodesic is closed exactly when ; its image is then the horizontal circle .
Yes. In polar coordinates on , use the Riemannian metric
The coordinate identifies this surface isometrically with the flat cylinder . Through each point, the circle is a closed geodesic, and every other geodesic has nonzero linear motion in and is not closed. Thus every point lies on a unique closed geodesic.
Suppose first that extends . Regarding as the boundary of the unit disc,
is a homotopy from to the constant map with value . Thus is null-homotopic. Conversely, if is a homotopy from to a constant, then is constant on and hence descends to the quotient
which is the cone on and is homeomorphic to . The descended map extends . This proves the extension-null-homotopy criterion for a sphere.
A universal cover of is a covering map whose total space is path-connected and simply connected. Let and be two universal covers. The lifting criterion for a covering space applies because
so has a based lift satisfying . Similarly there is a based lift of . Both and the identity are lifts of that agree at the base point, so uniqueness of lifts gives . Likewise . Hence is a homeomorphism. This is the uniqueness of a universal covering space.
Now let be universal with contractible. If an extension exists, functoriality of the fundamental group gives
Thus the required factorization holds with .
Conversely, suppose . We extend over the simplices of by dimension. The boundary of every 2-simplex is a loop in that becomes null-homotopic in , so its class lies in . The factorization gives
Hence is null-homotopic in and extends over the disc by the first part. Since distinct 2-simplices meet along the already fixed 1-skeleton, these extensions combine to a map on .
Inductively suppose the map is defined on for . For an -simplex , its boundary is , which is simply connected. The boundary map therefore lifts through by the covering-space lifting criterion. Its lift into the contractible space is null-homotopic, so the boundary map itself is null-homotopic and extends over . Extending over every -simplex and then every skeleton constructs . The weak topology on a simplicial complex makes the cellwise map continuous. This proves the extension criterion into a space with contractible universal cover.
The Bonnet-Myers theorem states that if a complete connected -dimensional Riemannian manifold satisfies
for some , then
In particular, is compact and has finite fundamental group.
By the Hopf-Rinow theorem, points are joined by a unit-speed length-minimizing geodesic . Choose a parallel orthonormal frame normal to and set
The endpoint-vanishing fields arise from fixed-endpoint variations. Since minimizes length, its Riemannian index form is nonnegative on each . Summing the second variation of Riemannian arc length gives
Using the Ricci curvature bound and integrating and yields
so . Taking the supremum over proves the diameter bound. Hopf-Rinow now makes the closed bounded space compact. Finally, the same bound applies to the complete universal cover; a compact universal cover has finite fibres over , so is finite.
Suppose for a contradiction that carries a complete Ricci-flat metric. Since is closed, the two subsets and are different unbounded components outside the compact set . Thus is disconnected at infinity and, by part (a), contains a line in a Riemannian manifold.
Its Ricci curvature is zero, so the Cheeger-Gromoll splitting theorem gives an isometry
The product Ricci tensor shows that is a complete three-dimensional Ricci-flat manifold. By the allowed fact, is flat, and hence so is .
The universal cover of a complete flat manifold is complete, simply connected, and has zero sectional curvature. The Hadamard-Cartan theorem therefore identifies it diffeomorphically with , so it is contractible. On the other hand, the universal cover of the product is
which deformation retracts onto . It is contractible only if is contractible, contrary to the hypothesis. Hence no such complete Ricci-flat metric exists.
Let be a finite combinatorial 2-complex satisfying , and let be a connected CW subcomplex of its universal cover with no missing shells. If the largest cell perimeter is , then is -quasiconvex in the universal cover's unit-edge 1-skeleton. Bound an ambient metric geodesic and an intrinsic metric geodesic of by a reduced disc diagram. A shell on the ambient side would shorten a metric geodesic. A shell on the intrinsic side belongs to and would shorten its intrinsic metric geodesic. Spurs are likewise excluded from side interiors. The Greendlinger ladder theorem forces a ladder between the two marked corners. Each cell gives a path of length at most half its perimeter from either side to the other.