Internal energy Created 2026-09-24 Updated 2026-10-18
Internal energy is the energy stored in the microscopic degrees of freedom of a thermodynamic system: random molecular kinetic energy, internal molecular excitations, and interaction potential energy. Its value requires a specified system and an energy reference. In thermodynamic equilibrium, internal energy is a state function; it records the present state, without remembering whether a previous change came from stirring, compression or heat transfer. This makes internal energy the common accounting quantity connecting mechanical experiments to thermal ones.[ref]
Heat and work describe energy crossing the system boundary during a process. They are not separately stored contents of the system. For a closed system whose bulk kinetic energy and external potential energy have unchanged endpoint values, the first law of thermodynamics givesHere is positive for incoming heat, and is positive for net work done on the system. Two routes between the same equilibrium states have the same , although their heat and work can differ. The infinitesimal notation distinguishes a state function change from path-dependent transfers.[ref]
For a calculated example, take one mole of a classical monatomic gas in the ideal gas regime, at fixed volume, from to . With stipulated molar gas constant , its internal energy change is . A purely thermal route supplies with . An ideal insulated stirring route supplies with , measured between equilibrium endpoints after the motion dies away. The same stored increment has two different transfer histories; neither history defines a separate kind of stored energy.
The familiar internal energy of an ideal gas is a useful special case. Neglect intermolecular interactions, hold the amount of substance and composition fixed, and suppose that independent quadratic terms per particle obey the classical equipartition theorem. Choosing the constant reference contribution as zero givesHere is absolute temperature, is the molar gas constant, and is the whole sample's heat capacity at constant volume. A monatomic gas has translational terms. A rigid diatomic molecule has when its two rotational terms are active and vibration is frozen; activating one harmonic oscillator vibration adds two terms, one kinetic energy and one potential energy, giving . The counting is of quadratic contributions, so a vibrational coordinate is not just one contribution.[ref]
This constant- formula applies only over a regime with those same active terms, classical translational statistics, nonrelativistic motion and unchanged composition. Quantum freezing, quantum degeneracy, chemical reactions or appreciable intermolecular interactions invalidate that simple counting. More generally, at fixed amount and composition an ideal gas can still have with varying heat capacity at constant volume, so use . A nonzero constant reference adds to without altering .
Internal energy of an ideal gas Created 2026-09-24 Updated 2026-10-14
For a fixed amount of substance and composition of classical ideal gas, internal energy depends only on temperature: , with no independent volume dependence. This does not require constant heat capacity at constant volume. Between equilibrium endpoints,Here is total heat capacity at constant volume, is molar heat capacity, and for sample mass is specific internal energy, whose change is . These endpoint relations apply even when the intervening process is not at fixed volume; they do not say that transferred heat always equals . With constant , the safe statement is . Writing additionally chooses the reference energy; it does not prove that a physical gas remains classical and ideal down to zero temperature. [ref]
https://www.feynmanlectures.caltech.edu/I_45.html#Ch45-S1. Richard Feynman, Robert Leighton and Matthew Sands, §45-1: internal-energy derivatives and heat capacity
A thermodynamic proof outline uses the first law of thermodynamics in equilibrium form, , and the Maxwell relation :The last step uses the ideal gas law and the molar gas constant , with fixed composition and amount of substance. Microscopically, separated ideal gas particles store no intermolecular interaction energy; their translational kinetic energy and any internal molecular energy are determined by temperature. Negligible intermolecular interactions still allow a molecule to have internal vibrational potential energy.
An original analytical model makes the distinction between an ideal gas and constant heat capacity concrete. Assume classical translation, two fully active rotational terms, and one independent quantum harmonic oscillator per diatomic molecule, with fixed angular frequency . Define the vibrational temperature scale , using the reduced Planck constant and Boltzmann constant . Summing its thermal occupations givesThe constant includes the chosen reference and zero-point energy, whose temperature derivative vanishes. When the vibrational contribution to heat capacity is exponentially small; when it tends to per mole. This model assumes rotations remain active throughout the interval and excludes dissociation, electronic excitation and real gas corrections. Its low- edge is not a model of rotational freezing or of an actual substance at absolute zero.[ref]
Temperature-dependent internal energy of an ideal gas, molar heat capacities and heat capacity ratio in a vibrational model
. Analytical illustration with active rotations and one quantum harmonic oscillator per molecule. Left: Mayer's relation keeps the capacity difference equal to . Middle: heat capacity ratio falls from toward . Right: the internal energy change from is an integral of varying heat capacity at constant volume; the dashed line suppresses the vibrational contribution. No measured gas curve or material-specific vibrational frequency is implied. Details.For this stipulated model, heating from to gives . Holding the frozen-vibration value throughout would give , underestimating the required internal energy increase by about of the model's full value. The integral measures all thermal storage activated along the interval. At fixed volume with only heat input, this is also the supplied heat; at fixed pressure, expansion work must be added through Mayer's relation.
Joule's free-expansion experiment tests the independence from volume in a different way: an insulated rigid vessel allows gas into an evacuated compartment, so no external work is delivered and ideally no heat is exchanged. The first law of thermodynamics gives ; positive then predicts equal initial and final equilibrium temperatures for the ideal gas. The apparatus, thermal-capacity controls and limitations of this inference are described in Joule's free-expansion experiment and temperature sensitivity of a free-expansion experiment. This endpoint test differs from the reversible adiabatic expansion of a loaded piston, which delivers work and lowers internal energy.
Maxwell relations 2026-10-14
Maxwell relations turn pressure, volume and temperature measurements into information about entropy. For example, the pressure rise when heating a rigid sealed vessel determines the entropy change when expanding the same sample isothermally:The quantities on the two sides describe different experiments, yet both are mixed partial derivatives of one Helmholtz free energy. This is the useful surprise: a mechanical measurement can reveal a thermal property. Similarly, the coefficient of thermal expansion gives . [ref]
For a simple compressible system, hold particle number and composition fixed, and allow only pressure-volume work. Write for internal energy, for enthalpy, for Helmholtz free energy, and for Gibbs free energy. Their natural-variable differentials areThus the first partial derivatives, with the subscript recording the variables kept fixed, areThe symmetry of second derivatives produces all four standard Maxwell relations, including their signs:For a brief derivation of the relation, differentiate with respect to and with respect to : . Each other row follows in the same way. Assume continuous second partial derivatives of the relevant thermodynamic potential in the region considered. At a phase transition, the equilibrium potential may lose this smoothness; apply the identities within each smooth thermodynamic phase, and handle latent heat and phase coexistence separately. If particle numbers vary, the potential differentials acquire chemical potential terms, so the fixed- constraints must remain explicit. [ref]
For an ideal gas with fixed , the ideal gas law gives . At fixed volume, heating changes the pressure at rate . Consequently an isothermal expansion at positive temperature hasFor one mole with and , this is . At , a reversible isothermal expansion absorbs and performs equal work, since its internal energy is unchanged. The entropy difference is a state function difference: the same equilibrium endpoints give the same in an insulated free expansion, although there and the process is irreversible.
The same Maxwell relations let thermal measurements determine the difference between constant-pressure and constant-volume heat capacities. In a smooth single thermodynamic phase,using heat capacity at constant volume, heat capacity at constant pressure, coefficient of thermal expansion and isothermal compressibility. Along fixed pressure, , soThus measured expansion and compression responses determine a heat capacity difference without measuring both heat capacities separately. They do not determine the absolute heat capacities or absolute entropy by themselves; an independent thermal measurement supplies that missing information. For an ideal gas, and reduce the result to , which is Mayer's relation.
When the necessary higher partial derivatives exist and commute, differentiating the Maxwell relations once more also givesIntegrating these slopes determines how a heat capacity changes with volume or pressure at fixed temperature. For an ideal gas, both right-hand sides vanish because the ideal gas law is linear in temperature at either fixed volume or fixed pressure. Consequently and depend only on temperature at fixed , although they need not be constant in temperature. [ref]
https://davidtong.org/teaching/statistical-physics/statmechhtml/S4#S4.SS4.SSS2. Tong, section 4.4.2: heat-capacity changes from thermal pressure and volume curves
Historically, James Clerk Maxwell's Theory of Heat, first published in 1871, presents these connections using the geometry of isothermal processes and reversible adiabatic processes. His fourth edition, page 167, explicitly relates expansion on heating at fixed pressure to heat emitted during an isothermal compression: the modern relation gives . This explains why a substance with positive coefficient of thermal expansion emits heat when compressed isothermally, whereas one with negative coefficient absorbs it. [ref]
https://www.cambridge.org/core/books/theory-of-heat/7052E2DAA4CD862126D5105ABBFFAD0F/listing. Maxwell, Theory of Heat, publication record and chapter IX
[ref]https://en.wikisource.org/wiki/Page:Theory_of_Heat,_James_Clerk_Maxwell,_Fourth_Edition.djvu/183. Maxwell, Theory of Heat, fourth edition, page 167
Mayer's relation 2026-10-14
Mayer's relation states that the difference between heat capacity at constant pressure and heat capacity at constant volume for a fixed-composition ideal gas isHere both capacities are total heat capacities in , is amount of substance, is the number of particles, is the molar gas constant and is the Boltzmann constant. In other normalizations the same statement isThe first is a difference of molar heat capacities, in ; the second uses specific heat capacities, in . Writing with total capacities would omit the sample's amount of substance. The relation holds pointwise even when the capacities depend on temperature. [ref]
https://openstax.org/books/university-physics-volume-2/pages/3-5-heat-capacities-of-an-ideal-gas. Samuel J. Ling, William Moebs and Jeff Sanny, University Physics Volume 2, §3.5: ideal-gas capacity difference
The proof outline is short: enthalpy is , and internal energy of an ideal gas is independent of volume at fixed temperature. Differentiating at fixed composition and amount of substance therefore gives . It uses the ideal gas law, rather than assuming any particular number of molecular degrees of freedom. At fixed pressure, the additional heat supplies expansion work, . The two processes can have the same temperature endpoints and equal while requiring different heat inputs.
For one mole of the rigid-rotation diatomic ideal gas model, and . Heating by with gives in a rigid sealed vessel and under a frictionless piston at fixed pressure. Both gain of internal energy, while the piston delivers approximately of work. This is a calculated model budget. If the capacities vary with temperature, the corresponding finite statement is stillunder the fixed-pressure and fixed-volume heating assumptions in heat capacity. Their final volume values generally differ. Combining Mayer's relation with heat capacity ratio also gives and locally; constant values cannot be extrapolated across intervals in which changes.
For a smooth stable single thermodynamic phase of a general simple compressible system, the broader Maxwell relation identity iswhere is the coefficient of thermal expansion and the isothermal compressibility, with composition fixed throughout. Substituting the ideal gas law gives ; a real gas need not do so. This distinction matters near a phase transition or when interactions appreciably change the equation of state. It explains why Mayer's relation is useful: thermal measurements under different constraints become linked to a mechanical response, while the difference retains a particularly simple value for an ideal gas.[ref]
Past exam of the condensed matter physics course of the University of Oxford 2019 2 a Solution 2026-10-25
The Einstein model of a solid replaces the vibrations of identical atoms by independent quantum harmonic oscillators with a common frequency . Each atom has three displacement directions; the restoring force is harmonic, coupling between different atoms is replaced by a fixed local restoring potential, and anharmonicity and frequency dispersion are neglected. The crystal volume and are held fixed when calculating the vibrational heat capacity at constant volume.
The one-oscillator partition function isConsequently, with ,Differentiating at fixed volume givesThe zero-point energy does not contribute to this derivative. The result tends to the Dulong-Petit law at high temperature and vanishes exponentially at low temperature; the latter is a limitation of the single-frequency model for a real acoustic spectrum.
Past exam of the mathematics course of the University of Cambridge 2008 ii Paper 3 34E Solution Created 2026-09-24 Updated 2026-10-14
At fixed particle number, expand the entropy differential in . The definition of heat capacity at constant pressure and the Maxwell relation giveSimilarly expansion in , using heat capacity at constant volume and , givesAt constant pressure, . Also , so . Equating the two entropy expressions at constant pressure yieldsFor a mechanically stable system with positive isothermal compressibility, this also gives .
Past exam of the mathematics course of the University of Cambridge 2020 ii Paper 2 36A Solution Created 2026-09-24 Updated 2026-09-29
For a simple system of fixed composition, the first law of thermodynamics andgiveThusEquality of mixed derivatives gives the Gibbs free-energy Maxwell relation
The heat capacity at constant volume and heat capacity at constant pressure areRegarding as a function of and differentiating along a constant-pressure curve givesThe Maxwell relation from the Helmholtz free energy isTherefore the difference between constant-pressure and constant-volume heat capacities is
Along the liquid-gas phase coexistence curve, the molar Gibbs free energies agree. Differentiating along the curve givesHence the Clausius-Clapeyron relation iswhere is the molar latent heat.
If and the gas is ideal, then , soFor constant , integration yieldswhere is constant over the range in which the approximations apply.
Past exam of the mathematics course of the University of Cambridge 2021 ii Paper 1 36C a Solution Created 2026-09-24 Updated 2026-09-25
For a fixed number of particles, the ideal gas equation of state isIts internal energy depends only on temperature, andWhen the heat capacity at constant volume is constant, a choice of the energy zero gives
Past exam of the mathematics course of the University of Cambridge 2023 ii Paper 3 35A b iv Solution Created 2026-09-24 Updated 2026-10-20
For , the preceding density of states hasWhen , the Bose-Einstein distribution has the classical approximationEach of the modes therefore contributes to the energy, so the Dulong-Petit law gives
When , the upper integration limit tends to infinity. The Bose integralthen yieldsHence the heat capacity at constant volume isso . The high-temperature constant is the classical equipartition theorem result, while the low-temperature power law makes as required by the third law of thermodynamics.
If for a twice continuously differentiable potential , then and . Equality of mixed partial derivatives gives the necessary condition for an exact differential:This condition alone does not ensure global exactness on a domain with holes.
For the Helmholtz free energy , use the stated identity for internal energy and the product rule:Thus and . Equality of mixed partial derivatives yields the Maxwell relationThe temperature and volume are the independent variables here, with composition and amount of gas fixed.
Next express and substitute its total differential into :Matching the coefficient of givesThis is the thermodynamic internal pressure identity: an equation of state determines how internal energy changes under an isothermal change of volume.
For the Dieterici equation, set while differentiating at fixed . ThenSubstitute into the thermodynamic internal pressure identity. The term proportional to cancels , leavingThe physical gas domain has and .
For the ideal gas instead, gives . Therefore is independent of volume at fixed amount of gas. Integrating the remaining condition , with constant heat capacity at constant volume, giveswhere is independent of both and and fixes the reference for internal energy.
Past exam of the mathematics course of the year 1 of the natural sciences course of the University of Cambridge 2003 Paper 2 9 b Solution Created 2026-10-18 Updated 2026-10-20
Differentiate at fixed pressure and subtract the heat capacity at constant volume:Now use and the multivariable chain rule along a constant-pressure path:Substitution cancels the fixed-volume derivative and gives the volume derivative form of the heat-capacity difference,For the ideal gas, the first term in brackets vanishes and , so . Consequently for the entire gas, with fixed particle number . The extra heat capacity accounts for expansion work at constant pressure.
Past exam of the mathematics course of the year 1 of the natural sciences course of the University of Cambridge 2005 Paper 2 7 a Solution Created 2026-10-18 Updated 2026-10-20
The required Legendre transform is the Helmholtz free energy, up to an additive constant. Its differential is , so and . Equality of mixed partial derivatives for a smooth thermodynamic state gives the Maxwell relationNext use the total differential . Along a fixed-pressure path, divide by to get . Substitute the Maxwell relation to obtainMultiplying by gives the usual difference between the heat capacity at constant pressure and the heat capacity at constant volume.
Temperature describes thermal state and determines the direction of spontaneous heat transfer. A quantity of heat is energy transferred because of a temperature difference. It depends on the process and is measured in energy units; it is not another name for temperature. Equal heat inputs need not produce equal temperature rises in different masses or substances.
For a specified process, the specific heat capacity isOver a modest range with nearly constant and no phase change, . For a gas the constraint matters: heat capacity at constant pressure and heat capacity at constant volume generally differ because expansion can do work.
In method-of-mixtures calorimetry, a body of known mass at is transferred into water of mass at in a calibrated calorimeter initially also at . If the final uniform temperature is , the vessel and immersed fittings have heat capacity , and losses are negligible,ThusStirring, quick transfer, a lid, a temperature-time record and allowance for surrounding heat exchange improve the inference. Ignoring the calorimeter's heat capacity systematically misattributes part of the energy uptake.
An alternative is electrical calorimetry: measure supplied to a heater and compare the temperature rise with a blank or separately calibrated vessel. At nearly constant properties, . An ice calorimeter instead measures the mass melted at a known phase-change temperature, using with appropriate corrections. Steam condensation similarly uses latent heat. These methods infer transferred energy from different measurable effects; a thermometer reading alone does not measure a quantity of heat.
Past exam of the physics A course of the University of Cambridge 2018 Paper 2 Section C C10 e Solution Created 2026-10-18 Updated 2026-10-20
Assume sodium supplies one conduction electron per atom. The supplied Fermi energy givesThe gas is strongly degenerate at room temperature. For one mole, and . Using the requested estimate,The supplied mass density determines the answer per unit volume: . ThereforeThe density is not needed for the molar heat capacity once is supplied. Using the precise Sommerfeld expansion coefficient instead gives .
Either electronic estimate is only about of the stated measured total. Most of the total heat capacity comes from lattice phonons, whose high-temperature Dulong-Petit law limit is . The remaining difference from need not be electronic: anharmonic lattice effects and the difference between heat capacity at constant pressure and heat capacity at constant volume also contribute. The paper does not specify the measurement constraint, so the two totals should not be equated exactly.
Past exam of the physics A course of the University of Cambridge 2021 Paper 2 Section D D9 b Solution Created 2026-10-18 Updated 2026-10-20
The Debye model approximates a three-dimensional crystal as an elastic continuum supporting quantized normal modes, or phonons. At long wavelengths, the acoustic phonon branches have approximately linear dispersion relations : one longitudinal branch and two transverse branches. Replace their complicated actual spectra by these linear forms, then introduce a cutoff chosen to preserve the total vibrational degrees of freedom for atoms. This is an approximation to the spectrum, not a claim that a real crystal has no non-acoustic branches.
For periodic boundary conditions in volume , each allowed wavevector occupies in the space of wavevectors. Counting a spherical shell for each branch gives the density of states per unit angular frequencyAn effective speed of sound can be defined by . In the single-speed Debye model, choose so thatThus the Debye wavevector, Debye frequency and Debye temperature satisfyHere has units of seconds when angular frequency is measured in ; its integral is the dimensionless number of normal modes. The spherical cutoff replaces the real Brillouin zone by an equal-count continuum construction.
Each phonon mode is a quantum harmonic oscillator. Since phonon number is not conserved at thermal equilibrium, the chemical potential is zero and its Bose-Einstein distribution gives mean thermal energy . The zero-point energy is independent of temperature in the harmonic, fixed-volume approximation and does not contribute to the heat capacity at constant volume. Excluding that constant term,Differentiating the first integral at fixed volume avoids losing the temperature-dependent upper limit in the second one. The resulting Debye heat capacity isFor , extend the upper limit to infinity. Expanding and integrating term by term gives . ThereforeThis law follows from the three-dimensional density of states and the availability only of low-frequency modes at low temperature. It is a central success of the Debye model.
For , the Bose-Einstein distribution reduces to the classical equipartition theorem: every mode contributes thermal energy . Consequentlythe Dulong-Petit law, or per mole of atoms. The simple model omits detailed phonon dispersion relation, distinct optical phonon branches, and anharmonic effects such as thermal expansion. In a metal, the low-temperature total heat capacity additionally contains a term approximately proportional to from electrons, so the lattice term should not be mistaken for the whole measurement.
For a reversible adiabatic process of an ideal gas, and . At fixed composition and constant sample heat capacity at constant volume ,Mayer's relation gives , so is constant andThe finite-path power law requires approximately constant heat capacities as well as reversibility. When rotational or vibrational populations change appreciably, use instead; the local isentropic pressure exponent remains .
For an intact heteronuclear diatomic gas, quantum excitation progressively activates molecular motion. With rotational and vibrational modes frozen, the three translational degrees of freedom give and . Two active rotations add , giving and . One active harmonic vibration contributes a further , through kinetic and potential terms, giving and .
For molecular moment of inertia , the rigid rotor levels are , so the rotational excitation scale isThe first gap corresponds to , so the crossover occurs at temperatures of that order. For bond force constant and reduced molecular mass , the vibrational scale isTypically . Real gases may condense at the low-temperature end or dissociate and excite electronic states at the high-temperature end; the three plateau values describe the ideal intact-molecule model.
Translational, rotational and vibrational regimes of the heat capacity ratio
. Original rigid-rotor and harmonic-oscillator calculation with an illustrative ratio of vibrational to rotational temperatures of 100. The three limiting heat capacity ratios are marked; detailed crossover shapes are not universal. Details.For the piston apparatus, mechanical equilibrium requires , hence . Let be a small upward displacement, so . The local isentropic compressibility givesConsequently the adiabatic gas-spring piston period isThis neglects friction, gas inertia, leakage and dissipation, with internal equilibration much faster than the oscillation and external thermal equilibration much slower. The small oscillation probes locally; it need not keep constant over a large temperature interval.
With , the supplied dimensions give and . ThusHelium is close to the monatomic ideal gas value ; NO is close to the diatomic gas value , with rotations active and vibration largely frozen. The numbers are approximate experimental inferences, rather than exact rational values.
Specific heat capacity at constant volume Created 2026-10-06 Updated 2026-10-14
The specific heat capacity at constant volume is the temperature derivative of specific internal energy at fixed density and composition: . It is the corresponding extensive heat capacity at constant volume divided by material mass.
The gas-only condition requires negligible heat exchange with the apparatus. If the insulated isolated system instead includes the walls, sensors and water, the first law of thermodynamics fixes their combined energy. Once everything returns to a common final temperature, a constant apparatus heat capacity givesDefine , the gas's internal energy increase for the same expansion evaluated at the initial temperature. For a small temperature change, linearizing at the final volume givesHere is the whole gas sample's heat capacity at constant volume at the reference state. Compared with an isolated gas sample's , the common final signal is reduced by . This energy accounting explains why a massive bath can conceal a real-gas effect. Fitzpatrick gives the corresponding apparatus correction for the Van der Waals equation. [ref]
For a toy calculation, stipulate , and , all constant in this example. The predicted cooling magnitude changes from for the gas alone to for the combined apparatus. An illustrative effective detection threshold of would miss the latter. These are chosen numbers, not Joule's measurements. In this approximation a null observation only bounds , where is the detectable temperature change after allowing for drift and other experimental uncertainties; a display's smallest digit is not automatically this threshold.
The historical limitation was recognized explicitly: Joule and Thomson later estimated that the common apparatus in Joule's experiment would cool by only about , explaining why the earlier external thermal effect was undetectable. This was a later calculation about the apparatus, not a measured cooling trace. [ref]
https://upload.wikimedia.org/wikipedia/commons/4/47/The_free_expansion_of_gases-_memoirs_by_Gay-Lussac%2C_Joule%2C_and_Joule_and_Thomson%3B_%28IA_cu31924012329300%29.pdf#page=75. Joule and Thomson, On the Thermal Effects of Elastic Fluids, Part II, reprint p. 63: estimated temperature change of the copper-and-water apparatus
Thermal equilibration of two finite bodies Created 2026-10-14 Updated 2026-10-20
Consider two rigid bodies forming an isolated system, with fixed composition and constant whole-body heat capacity at constant volume values and . Their initial temperatures are and . Assume each body remains internally uniform, their contact stores negligible energy, no phase transition occurs and no work is done or extracted. These are stipulated model values, not material measurements.
Because , write with arbitrary fixed reference constants . The conserved relative internal energy isThis is an energy reference convention, not a claim about actual heat capacities down to zero temperature. At thermal equilibrium the two temperatures equal , so the first law of thermodynamics givesThe larger heat capacity pulls the common temperature closer to its initial value: body 1 warms by , while body 2 cools by .
Two finite bodies approach thermal equilibrium at
. Ideal model with and and contact conductance . The weighted temperature stays at and the relative internal energy stays at ; the plotted curves are model predictions. Details.To predict a timescale, stipulate a constant contact conductance , the reciprocal of the contact's thermal resistance. The rate of heat transfer into body 1 is , givingAdding proves conservation of . Subtracting gives exponential decay of the temperature difference, with time constantand thereforeExact equality is approached as in this ideal model. Changing changes the rate but not : equilibrium and the speed of reaching it are separate predictions. Real bodies can have internal temperature gradients, changing heat capacities and contact losses, so the plotted is an assumed model timescale.
Take a closed system consisting of one mole of a classical monatomic gas, idealized as an ideal gas with constant heat capacity at constant volume . Stipulate amount of substance and molar gas constant for this calculation. Set initial temperature and volume , and define and . The specified equilibrium endpoints areThus has volume , temperature and pressure . The fixed material inventory and ideal gas law make these complete endpoint specifications for this model. All numbers below are calculated values, rather than measurements of a particular gas.
Use a frictionless piston, ignore bulk mechanical energy changes, and allow only pressure-volume work. Each step is the limit of a reversible thermodynamic process: adjust loads by infinitesimal pressure differences, and supply heat through infinitesimal temperature differences. Heating with changing temperature requires a succession of matching thermal reservoirs; contact with a single hotter heat bath would give an irreversible finite difference. On a fixed-volume leg the piston is locked. These assumptions justify using the actual equilibrium path's pressure inAn endpoint chord is not the path; substituting a guessed straight line would compute a different thermodynamic process.[ref]
Thermodynamics and Propulsion. Thermodynamics and Propulsion, §1.3.3, Figures 1.10–1.11: external pressure versus equilibrium gas pressure in boundary work
The upper route heats at fixed volume from to , then undergoes isothermal expansion at to . The lower route undergoes isothermal expansion at from to , then heats at fixed volume to . The tuples use the same ordering as the endpoints. Vertical legs do zero expansion work, and the two curved legs have different pressures at every shared intermediate volume.
Two reversible ideal gas paths connect the same equilibrium endpoints
. Original idealized pressure-volume diagram. The upper route is and the lower route is ; the shaded gap is the difference in work, not an experimental uncertainty. Both are reversible thermodynamic processes under the stated piston and thermal reservoir assumptions. Details.The internal energy of an ideal gas gives the same endpoint difference for both routes:On either fixed-volume heating leg, and . On each isothermal expansion, , so the first law of thermodynamics gives . The ideal gas law and the integral of then giveHere is the natural logarithm. Rounded to , the upper route has and the lower route has . Subtracting separately rounded entries can differ by ; the unrounded balances are exact in the stipulated model.
The shaded area between the curves explains the entire difference:Following the upper route forward and the lower route backward makes a thermodynamic cycle with this positive net work and matching net heat. Its internal energy change is zero. The two open routes themselves are reversible, so their different work outputs should not be mistaken for a loss caused by entropy production: they receive different heat transfers at different temperatures.
Two other state functions provide independent endpoint checks. With enthalpy in this model,To obtain the entropy change along either route, integrate on its heating leg, giving , and on its isothermal expansion, giving . Reordering the legs changes their heat totals but leaves the sum of their entropy changes unchanged. In particular, neither route's total divided by its final temperature equals , and neither total equals : both routes include an isothermal expansion, rather than a single fixed-pressure heating step.






