Entropy at absolute zero. The third law of thermodynamics concerns the low-temperature limit of equilibrium states. In the zero-entropy formulation, the entropy of a perfect crystal with a nondegenerate ground state tends to zero as . The statistical interpretation is : a unique accessible ground state has . The entropy-difference formulation of the third law of thermodynamics states that entropy differences associated with regular changes of mechanical parameters tend to zero as absolute zero is approached. These statements require equilibrium and appropriate ground-state assumptions; a frozen disordered material or a degenerate ground state can carry residual entropy.
For a phase of fixed composition and pressure,
A finite limiting entropy constrains this integral. Ordinary equilibrium heat capacities therefore vanish as temperature approaches zero, with familiar examples for three-dimensional acoustic phonons and for a normal degenerate Fermi liquid. A constant positive heat capacity extrapolated to zero would give a logarithmically divergent entropy difference and is impossible in this regime. Discontinuous transitions and anomalous limits need separate treatment rather than extending a high-temperature approximation indefinitely.
Gibbs free energy. For fixed particle numbers,
Thus, when , the Gibbs free energy approaches its zero-temperature value with a horizontal tangent:
The equality uses the enthalpy ; neither limiting value needs to be zero. The low-temperature Gibbs free-energy expansion makes the approach quantitative. For with and ,
The second derivative is , although it need not tend to zero. For a reaction between such equilibrium phases, , and and approach one another. If a genuine residual entropy is retained instead, has limiting slope . A horizontal tangent cannot be asserted without the zero-entropy condition.
Why helium remains a liquid. Helium atoms attract each other weakly and are exceptionally light. Their zero-point energy is large compared with the binding that would localize them in a solid. Both helium-4 and helium-3 can therefore remain liquid down to the lowest temperatures at low pressure; substantial applied pressure is needed to solidify them. This is not a violation of the third law. A quantum liquid can have a unique low-entropy ground state, and zero-point motion does not itself imply thermal entropy. The third law does not require every substance to crystallize at atmospheric pressure.
A helium-4 atom has integer spin zero and is a boson. Below the lambda point near at saturated vapor pressure, its liquid is superfluid. Its strong interactions mean that it is not quantitatively an ideal Bose gas, and the condensate fraction need not equal the superfluid fraction. The two-fluid model of superfluidity separates an entropy-carrying normal component of a superfluid from the superfluid component, whose entropy is zero. At sufficiently low temperature the dominant thermal excitations are acoustic phonons: their linear dispersion in three dimensions gives , and . Higher-energy rotons are exponentially suppressed. Thus the normal component of a superfluid and entropy disappear as , while superfluid flow and quantum motion can persist.
A helium-3 atom has spin and is a fermion. Well below its Fermi temperature, but above its superfluid transition, liquid helium-3 is a degenerate interacting Fermi liquid. Only quasiparticles close to the Fermi surface are thermally excited, giving and . At temperatures of order a millikelvin, helium-3 also becomes superfluid through formation of Cooper pairs of fermions. This is not Bose-Einstein condensation of individual helium-3 atoms. Pairing reorganizes the low-energy excitation spectrum; in the fully gapped bulk B phase, the fermionic quasiparticle contribution to heat capacity is exponentially suppressed at temperatures well below the pairing gap. Gapless collective modes can still give thermal terms following a power law. The entropy nevertheless tends to zero. The normal Fermi-liquid law cannot be extrapolated through its pairing transition unchanged.[ref]
Helium-3 also illustrates the importance of nuclear spin entropy. Over an intermediate low-temperature range, localized spins in the solid can retain approximately of entropy per atom, while the degenerate liquid has much less. Reversible conversion of liquid to the higher-entropy solid then absorbs heat; adiabatic compression along the melting curve can cool the sample. This is Pomeranchuk cooling. At still lower temperature, interactions between the nuclear spins remove this nearly free-spin entropy, so a constant cannot be extrapolated to absolute zero.[ref]
Liquefaction and cooling methods. A gas must be below its liquid-gas critical point to form a distinct liquid phase by compression. Compression above the critical temperature alone cannot achieve ordinary liquid-vapour coexistence. Practical liquefaction removes the compression heat, cools the compressed gas in a heat exchanger and uses expansion to lower its temperature further.
A throttling valve operates approximately at constant specific enthalpy when kinetic-energy changes and heat leakage are negligible. The Joule-Thomson coefficient is
using consistent molar quantities, or consistent total quantities for a fixed amount. A pressure drop cools the gas if . An ideal gas has zero Joule-Thomson coefficient; real intermolecular interactions are essential. In particular, room-temperature helium warms on throttling, so it must first be brought into a region of positive Joule-Thomson coefficient. Expansion through an engine or turbine can instead remove work and produce approximately isentropic cooling.
A regenerative liquefier sends the cold returning gas through a counterflow heat exchanger to precool the incoming compressed gas before its next expansion. Expansion engines and external precooling can supply the initial cooling; repeated operation then produces liquid. Modern helium liquefaction commonly combines work-producing expansion with a final throttle. [ref]
Once liquid exists, pumping away vapour lowers its saturation pressure and boiling temperature. The escaping vapour carries latent heat away, cooling the remaining liquid. At still lower temperatures, a dilution refrigerator exploits the different entropy carried by helium-3 in concentrated and dilute helium mixtures; adiabatic demagnetization and Pomeranchuk cooling provide other routes.
Approaching zero. The unattainability formulation of the third law states that regular cooling operations with finite resources cannot reach absolute zero in finitely many stages. As the entropy available to remove becomes small and thermal couplings weaken, each method loses its ability to take the final step. An isentropic cooling trajectory starting at nonzero entropy cannot reach a common zero-entropy endpoint through regular finite changes of parameters. A fully general finite-time claim also requires assumptions about available controls and heat-transfer rates. Quantum liquids and refrigeration methods can approach while remaining consistent with vanishing equilibrium entropy; they do not provide a finite-operation route to absolute zero.
The units supplied for 130 indicate specific heat capacity, so the block's total heat capacity is . Treat it as constant, and the lake as a thermal reservoir at . The initial block temperature is .
Compute the block's entropy change using a reversible comparison path, even though the actual cooling is irreversible:
The lake receives at constant temperature, so
Therefore
This is entropy generated by cooling a finite body in a reservoir. The positive total is consistent with the Second law of thermodynamics, although the cooling block's own entropy decreases.
For liquid-vapor equilibrium, use molar quantities. At low vapor pressure the gas is dilute, approximately ideal, and has a much larger molar volume than the liquid. Hence
Substitution into the Clapeyron equation gives
If the molar latent heat varies sufficiently slowly to be treated as constant over the temperature interval, integration gives
The positive constant has pressure units and is an integration constant. It is not necessarily a real infinite-temperature pressure, since the approximations fail before that limit.
For mercury between and , the original plot places this range above the triple point and below the normal boiling and critical temperatures. Its vapor pressure is low relative to the critical pressure, making a dilute-gas description reasonable; the vapor's molar volume greatly exceeds that of the dense liquid. The interval is also far from the critical region where tends to zero, so a roughly constant latent heat is a useful first approximation. The approximations are not exact: Kirchhoff's law of thermochemistry gives, at fixed pressure, the temperature derivative of a transformation enthalpy as the difference between the two molar heat capacities, so a precise fit over a wide interval would allow to vary.
Using gives
The internal-energy identity from (b), followed by differentiation with respect to temperature at fixed moment of inertia, yields
For one mole of independent rotors, the rotational energy is and the rotational molar heat capacity is .
This agrees with the equipartition theorem. The given spectrum describes a linear rotor with two independent rotational degrees of freedom, each contributing to the high-temperature mean energy. Rotation about the molecular axis is not an additional degree of freedom of this ideal linear-rotor model, so the result is rather than per rotor. These are rotational contributions alone; translational and vibrational heat capacities have not been included. At low temperature the discrete excitation gap freezes rotational excitation out, so the rotational heat capacity tends to zero instead of remaining at its classical value.
(a) Treat the lake as a heat bath at fixed temperature and the block's heat capacity as constant. Its initial temperature is , and . Although the cooling is irreversible, entropy is a state function, so evaluate the block's change along an imagined reversible thermodynamic process:
The lake receives heat , and therefore
Adding the two contributions gives
The positive result is consistent with the Second law of thermodynamics for heat transfer across a finite temperature difference. The calculation uses exactly as printed in both the original PDF and the transcription; it does not replace the supplied value by a tabulated value for lead.
(b) The block starts and eventually finishes at the lake's temperature, so its net entropy change is approximately zero. Neglecting buoyancy, air resistance and the final immersion depth, the lost gravitational potential energy becomes internal energy in the lake after the motion and waves have dissipated. The lake remains at , giving
Temporary heating of the block or temporary storage in kinetic energy does not change this final energy and entropy balance once thermal equilibrium is restored.
This is the Brayton cycle. Assume fixed gas amount, constant heat capacities, and internally reversible adiabatic processes, as intended by the ideal engine model. Put and
Combining with the ideal gas law gives along either reversible ideal-gas adiabat. Therefore
During a constant-pressure process the heat supplied equals the enthalpy increase. If is the molar heat capacity at constant pressure, the positive heat input and output are
The insulated branches exchange no heat, so the first law of thermodynamics gives . Hence
An adiabatic process alone need not be an isentropic process; the relations used here also require internal reversibility. Dissipative compression or expansion would require extra information and would not, in general, obey this efficiency formula.
With microstate energies held fixed when differentiating,
Since ,
The canonical ensemble fixes volume and particle number, and any other external Hamiltonian parameters. Thus the derivative is ; pressure-fixed fluctuations would naturally involve enthalpy in a different ensemble.
The translational and two-level energy variance follows because translation and internal states factorize for this dilute classical gas:
Differentiating twice yields
The terms are independent translational and two-level binomial variances. At , excitation freezes out exponentially and translation dominates. At , the internal variance tends to while the translational variance grows as ; the internal heat capacity consequently tends to zero. Fractional total-energy fluctuations are of order for large . The low-temperature statement presumes translation is still nondegenerate; at strictly zero temperature the classical-gas model fails.
For equally nondegenerate levels, the partition function is . The mean energy per particle is , so the Schottky anomaly has heat capacity
At low temperature, because excitation is suppressed. At high temperature, because the two populations approach equality and the energy saturates. The peak is about at . The common offset does not affect heat capacity. Multiply by particle number for the total heat capacity, or divide by the corresponding mass for a mass-specific quantity.
Figure 1.
Two-level Schottky heat capacity and its low- and high-temperature suppression
. Details.
Differentiating at fixed length gives the heat capacity
The linear temperature dependence reflects the constant one-dimensional mode density, in contrast to the cubic dependence of a three-dimensional photon gas.
For a unit mass of ideal gas, the first law of thermodynamics in enthalpy form is . A reversible adiabatic displacement has , and the ideal gas law gives . Thus
The atmospheric profile approaches this dry adiabat when convection efficiently mixes potential temperature and there is no condensation or other strong diabatic source. The first law by itself determines a parcel path, not every possible environmental temperature profile; the convective mixing assumption is needed. Hydrostatic balance gives the corresponding height lapse rate .
For rigid linear molecules with translation and rotation active but vibration frozen, the molecular heat capacities are and , hence . Earth is dominated by the diatomic gases nitrogen and oxygen. Mars is dominated by carbon dioxide, which is triatomic but linear and has the same two rotational degrees of freedom. In the rigid-molecule approximation it therefore has the same ratio. The value is not exact for carbon dioxide when its bending vibrations contribute appreciably to heat capacity, and variable heat capacities give a nonconstant dry-adiabatic exponent. Here denotes , not the distinct adiabatic index .
For an ideal gas of fixed molecular composition, translational energy is supplemented by rotational, vibrational and eventually electronic excitations as their level spacings become thermally accessible. Activating more internal degrees of freedom generally increases the heat capacity. In a harmonic vibrational mode the contribution rises from nearly zero when to its classical limit when ; summing modes with different frequencies gives a smooth increase over an intermediate temperature range.
A monatomic gas has no molecular rotations or vibrations, so its mass-specific is nearly constant until electronic excitation or ionization becomes important: is then small. A simple diatomic gas can also have a small slope when its rotations are already active but its vibrational modes remain frozen. Large flexible polyatomic molecules have many internal modes, often with relatively low excitation energies, and can give a larger slope over their activation range.
The linear law is a local approximation, not an asymptotic result. A finite set of modes approaches finite classical heat-capacity contributions, whereas grows without bound. At still higher temperatures dissociation and ionization change the composition and gas constant, invalidating the fixed-molecule ideal-gas model as well. The constants have units and .
Take the convection to maintain a dry, nearly reversible adiabat, with specific gas constant . Hydrostatic equilibrium and an ideal-gas equation of state will be used separately to convert pressure to height. For an adiabatic displacement, the first law of thermodynamics in enthalpy form gives
The adiabat with linear heat capacity follows by integrating from the surface: this gives the monotone implicit temperature–pressure relation
An explicit form, using the positive real Lambert W branch, is
As , . At fixed ,
Larger heat capacity therefore keeps the upper atmosphere warmer at the same pressure. Equivalently becomes smaller. The original normalized sketch below shows the resulting family of profiles; no particular gas constants or surface temperature are assumed there.
The height equations are
Integrating the latter gives
The physically selected root starts at and decreases. Its formal upper boundary is
At that height and . The limit is . This finite-height zero is a property of the assumed polytropic-like model, not a claim that a real atmosphere reaches absolute zero: molecular heat capacities, composition, transport and the continuum ideal-gas description cease to support that extrapolation.
Figure 1.
Adiabats with increasing heat capacity and the limited-temperature latent heat inferred from an Antoine fit
. Original calculations. Adiabats use dimensionless parameters and ; the latent-heat plot distinguishes the stated fit range from an invalid extrapolation toward the known critical point. Details.
Let be the specific specific gas constants and the specific heat capacities of the noncondensible gas and vapour. Write for the saturation vapor pressure, for vapour mass per unit dry-gas mass, and . For a dilute ideal gas mixture,
The second equation is the Clausius-Clapeyron equation, neglecting condensed-phase volume and taking constant latent heat . The first law of thermodynamics for saturated ascent, with condensate removed and negligible condensate heat capacity, is to leading order
Since , the resulting moist adiabat has logarithmic slope
Consequently a sufficient dry adiabat criterion is
The first two conditions justify neglecting the vapour's effects on the gas law and sensible heat capacity; the last two suppress latent heating. With and , the latent conditions are and . Usually , so the squared-latent term gives the stronger condition. At sufficiently low surface temperature, the exponential smallness of makes these conditions hold and
These are local conditions along the column. They can be checked at the surface when : on this dry profile the strongest latent parameter is proportional to and decreases upwards. Without that restriction a surface-only test need not bound every altitude. If suspended condensate is retained, its own heat capacity and loading must also be negligible; saturation alone does not specify those quantities.
Assume an ideal gas dominated by carbon dioxide, constant mean molar heat capacity , and a dry convective adiabat connecting the stated emitting layer to the ground. Conservation of entropy gives , where is the universal molar gas constant. Thus
The estimate extrapolates across a pressure ratio of . It neglects radiatively stable layers, variable heat capacity, departures from an ideal gas and changes in composition; these approximations limit its accuracy. A brightness temperature observed from space cannot generally be equated to a unique material level, but this calculation uses the layer interpretation explicitly supplied by the question.
The cloud absorbs from below and emits from each face. It absorbs no stellar radiation. Its net radiative heating per unit area is therefore
For , a cloud with warms in the absence of other energy transfers; one with cools. For the thin pressure thickness , its initial temperature tendency is approximately if its sensible heat capacity dominates. Latent heat and changing condensate modify that conversion from heating to temperature change, but not the sign of the radiative input.
With fixed, pure radiative equilibrium requires
This equals the ambient dry-adiabatic process temperature precisely when
For ordinary dry air, , so the ratio is about . If , the cloud exchanges no thermal radiation and its radiation budget does not select any equilibrium temperature.
Write for the fixed surface temperature and . The heat capacity per unit volume is . Per unit horizontal area the layer stores sensible heat . Its increase equals the input less the output:
The same equation holds for because is constant. It assumes the supplied constant-property, fixed-thickness layer, without internal heat production, latent heat, or mechanical contributions to its heat budget. The infinite horizontal area is handled by taking the budget per unit area.
A persistent barrier to whole-mantle circulation adds an internal thermal bottleneck and permits the deep mantle to retain a larger temperature excess. In a single well-mixed layer there is one interior temperature and one surface heat-loss law. The coupled thermal histories of layered mantle convection arise because separately mixed layers can have different temperatures, exchanging heat through an interfacial boundary layer as well as losing heat at the surface. Their thermal histories then have coupled relaxation modes rather than the single mode in (c).
For example, let be lower- and upper-layer temperature excesses, their heat capacities per area, and
With no internal heating the budgets are and . At steady state,
Thus a fixed basal flux still leaves the surface eventually with , but the lower layer is hotter than it would be in the single-temperature model. For a given deep temperature instead, the extra interfacial drop reduces outward heat transfer. This favours delayed loss of deep primordial heat and distinct upper- and lower-mantle cooling histories. A numerical change in cooling time cannot be obtained from layer count alone: interface transport, layer thicknesses, temperature-dependent viscosity, internal heating, and whether material can cross the interface matter. Merely replacing by in (c) misses the added interface and is not a model of two-layer cooling.
Distinguish the depth-dependent mantle temperature from mantle potential temperature : the latter is the temperature a parcel would have after reversible decompression in an adiabatic process to a chosen reference pressure. A convecting mantle is approximately adiabatic through much of its interior, with steep thermal boundary layers near the surface and the core-mantle boundary. It is neither isothermal nor wholly molten.
Early accretion, large impacts and gravitational planetary differentiation supplied heat; metal segregation released gravitational energy and extensive melting could produce a magma ocean. Rapid surface heat loss then crystallized much of the silicate mantle. Subsequent evolution reflects competition between radiogenic heating, heat entering from the core and heat carried out through the upper boundary. In a schematic mantle energy balance,
Here is mantle heat capacity, mantle radioactive power and heat leaving the mantle; continental crustal radioactive production is not included in . The convective Urey ratio compares internal production with mantle heat loss. A value below one does not alone prove cooling, because core heat also enters; cooling requires . Radioactive decay reduces the heating supply, while mantle convection, plate tectonics, melt extraction and changing viscosity control the heat loss. A hotter mantle does not automatically imply proportionally faster plate motion: melting, dehydration and boundary strength can alter that relationship.
Figure 1.
Original schematic thermal histories and mantle geotherms; curves illustrate alternatives rather than reproduce observations or fit a particular thermal model
. Details.
The robust long-term picture is an energetic early Earth followed by substantial cooling and a presently mostly solid, convecting mantle. The shape of the solid-state history is less certain. Petrological reconstructions commonly place late-Archean ambient above modern values. One reconstruction infers about – at – Ga versus about today, and permits warming before that late-Archean maximum after the initial magma-ocean cooling.[ref] This is a model-dependent ambient-mantle history, not proof that the accreting Earth was cooler than the Archean mantle or that every mantle reservoir followed one curve. An early molten transient, subsequent solid-state heating or cooling, and later secular cooling must be distinguished.
A straight line in against means . Reading its intercept and slope gives approximately and ; the graphical precision is only a few percent. Hence the molar heat capacity is approximately
The linear electronic heat capacity comes from conduction electrons within energy of order of the Fermi energy; the Pauli exclusion principle prevents deeply occupied states from contributing freely. The cubic lattice term is the low-temperature Debye heat capacity of three-dimensional acoustic phonons, whose low-frequency density of states is proportional to frequency squared. These are molar coefficients, so the temperature powers carry the extra kelvin factors indicated.
This is the Joule-Thomson coefficient, , describing a temperature change during an isenthalpic pressure change. Here is enthalpy, is the heat capacity at constant pressure, and is volume, all for the same chosen amount of substance. Starting with and using the Gibbs free-energy Maxwell relation gives
Setting proves
In a steady insulated throttle or porous plug, negligible kinetic- and potential-energy changes make the upstream and downstream enthalpies equal. A positive coefficient gives cooling on a pressure decrease; a negative one gives warming. For an ideal gas, at fixed , so the coefficient is zero. Real-gas interactions permit cooling and an inversion curve, making the effect useful in gas refrigeration and liquefaction.
The measurement of the Joule-Thomson effect with a porous plug compares pressures and thermometers on the two sides of an insulated flow restriction. Suppressing external heat exchange and separating the readings from high-speed jets are part of making the enthalpy argument applicable; an arbitrary adiabatic expansion need not be isenthalpic.