In ideal magnetohydrodynamics, the first-order electric field is . Retaining its product with both the background and first-order magnetic field gives the Poynting vector
The first term is transverse and oscillatory, with zero period average. The second is quadratic and transports wave energy. A potential quadratic ideal electric-field term vanishes here because the real traveling-wave fields are parallel or antiparallel.
For the branch, , so
For the opposite branch, its sign reverses. The averaged Poynting flux is the total wave energy density, including equal kinetic and magnetic shares, multiplied by the group velocity. This agrees with Alfvén wave energy transport. Although the flux in this expression is electromagnetic, it supplies the transport of both components of the coupled fluid-field wave.
Subtract the constant equilibrium magnetic energy density. Since , the perturbation densities are
The traveling-wave amplitude relation from part a gives
This is pointwise Alfvén wave energy transport for one traveling wave, not a claim that every superposition or standing wave has pointwise equipartition.
For the real fields written as and similarly for , the period averages are
The factors one half distinguish a sinusoid's peak amplitude from its mean squared value; the same complex-vector convention also covers circular polarization of waves.
Take the inviscid limit of the Navier-Stokes equation, neglect gravity, and use ideal magnetohydrodynamics. The governing equations are
The continuity equation also gives . Write the first-order magnetic perturbation as and linearize about the uniform stationary background:
For a nonzero-wavenumber plane wave proportional to , the two divergence constraints imply . The longitudinal momentum equation then gives for that mode, and gives for nonzero . Thus the propagating Alfvén wave is transverse. Its two independent transverse directions have the same dispersion relation.
The Linear Alfvén wave equations reduce to
Eliminating either amplitude gives
For , the branch traveling along has and . The opposite branch reverses that amplitude sign. Finite viscosity would additionally damp the motion; it is neglected in obtaining the real ideal dispersion relation.
Use the deterministic Hookean dumbbell model, with a zero-rest-length spring and negligible connector drag. For , its elastic forces on the two beads are
Here is the spring constant. No independent thermal forcing from Brownian motion or bead inertia is included. The unperturbed linear velocity field is , with by incompressibility.
The fluid velocity used in each bead's drag law is the imposed flow plus the disturbance from the other bead, with its own singular field omitted. At leading order in , the evenness of the Oseen tensor, , gives
These are the pair hydrodynamic mobility matrix relations. Their signs follow from balancing each spring force with , the fluid drag on that bead.
Adding the equations cancels both the direct spring slips and the cross-induced velocities, since . For the midpoint ,
The midpoint therefore follows the undisturbed linear velocity field. Subtracting the equations instead gives the hydrodynamic interaction of a Hookean dumbbell:
The dimensionless interaction matrix is
Its transverse and longitudinal eigenvalues are and , respectively. Since the spring force is longitudinal, the separation equation can also be written
The relative correction to the free-draining spring relaxation rate is therefore , explicitly proportional to . Entrainment by the other bead reduces their relative approach for given opposing spring forces.
This is a far-field hydrodynamic interaction, valid for ; it is not a near-contact law and omits higher reflections and lubrication. The printed target also fixes the spring's rest length implicitly. For an ordinary spring obeying Hooke's law with nonzero rest length , the elastic force would be , and every spring term above would acquire the factor . The displayed result uses the zero-rest-length spring convention appropriate to the ideal Hookean dumbbell model.
Neglect the inertia of the sphere and balance the applied force against Stokes drag. The sphere translates with , where . The applied force is also the net force transmitted to the fluid; the fluid's drag on the sphere has the opposite sign.
Translate the origin to . In the solution of part a, retain the terms of order and discard those of order . With ,
This is the Stokeslet, or equivalently the Oseen tensor acting on . The omitted finite-size velocity is of order , so the displayed term is the leading far field for . The singular Stokeslet must not be evaluated at its own centre to obtain a particle's self mobility.
Work in the laboratory frame, with the fluid at rest at infinity. Set
At , and , so the no-slip boundary condition is on the translating sphere. As , and the gauge-fixed pressure tends to zero.
It is also possible to check the exterior Stokes equations directly. Differentiating the radial functions gives
and
Thus the Newtonian fluid stress tensor satisfies throughout .
Let point away from the common centre on each concentric sphere. Applying the divergence theorem to the intervening fluid shell, whose inner normal is , yields
This is the force flux at infinity in Stokes flow. It is legitimate even though the stress tensor tends to zero pointwise, because the area of the large sphere grows as .
For an explicit evaluation, put and . The leading terms are and . Their velocity gradient is
After symmetrizing and subtracting the pressure contribution,
By rotational symmetry, . Hence
This is Stokes's law, with the force on the sphere opposite its velocity. For a component calculation with , the same integral is .
The common part of the magnetohydrodynamic-viscoelastic analogy is stretching and advection of a line element. With the component-first velocity gradient , the ideal tensor equation is
Its left side is an upper-convected derivative, the same deformation law that appears for a polymer conformation tensor when its relaxation is neglected.
There are two important physical differences. First, the solenoidal magnetic-field constraint prevents a magnetic field line from having an isolated source or sink inside the fluid. A polymer strand can have molecular endpoints, so there is no corresponding no-endpoint constraint on the strands. Second, a stretched polymer has a preferred relaxed distribution of configurations and a finite polymer relaxation time; it can recoil relative to the solvent through molecular drag and thermal motion. An ideal magnetic field has no analogous local tendency to return to a prescribed coil size. Real polymers also have a finite contour length, a limitation absent from the ideal field-stretching law.
For example, a normalized Hookean dumbbell conformation equation has the dissipative extension
This is local relaxation toward an isotropic thermal configuration. It remains nonzero for a spatially uniform stretched . By contrast, constant magnetic diffusivity adds to the resistive induction equation. The product rule gives the resistive evolution of the magnetic second-moment tensor:
The magnetic correction involves spatial gradients, vanishes for a uniform magnetic field, and does not create field-line endpoints: . It permits slippage and magnetic reconnection while preserving the no-monopole constraint. After averaging, its gradient-product term generally needs additional information beyond the averaged . One cannot replace it indiscriminately by the local polymer relaxation term, or even by alone.
Average the equations in part b and make exactly the prescribed scale-separation approximation: the retained perturbations vary on lengths much greater than , and perturbations at the tangle scale are omitted. Products of two retained perturbations can then be neglected. Writing , and , the linearized equations are
No unmodelled small-scale response has been inserted into this closure.
Introduce the fluid displacement by and choose . Integrating the magnetic second-moment tensor equation gives
where is a time-independent integration tensor set by the initial stress. For a pure oscillatory normal mode, . Its restoring force is therefore : the isotropic magnetic tangle has the same transverse response as an incompressible elastic medium with shear modulus .
For a plane wave proportional to , with , incompressibility gives . The tensor equation and magnetohydrodynamic momentum equation become
Dotting the second equation with yields for , since . Substitution then gives
There are two independent transverse polarizations. The phase speed is in every direction, and the two signs of give group velocities . These magnetoelastic waves in an isotropic magnetic tangle exist because a shear deformation distorts the second moment of the tangled magnetic field, producing a restoring magnetic tension even though its mean is zero.
For comparison, a uniform magnetic field with Alfvén velocity gives the incompressible Alfvén wave relation . Its frequency depends on the direction of , and energy propagates along . Here the averaged restoring response is isotropic: there is no preferred mean-field direction. Both systems resist transverse deformation through magnetic tension, rather than through compressive sound.
Figure 1.
Directional phase speeds for a magnetic tangle and a uniform magnetic field with the same mean-square strength
. The radial coordinate is phase speed divided by the tangle wave speed. The circular tangle curve is direction independent; the uniform-field curve is proportional to the absolute cosine of the propagation angle. These are phase-speed curves, not group-velocity trajectories. Details.
The propagating branch is not the entire perturbation space. For example, , and solve the linearized equations without propagation, for any small, slowly varying . Such a static stress perturbation in magnetoelastic wave equations balances a pressure gradient. Thus the requested wave conclusion applies to the oscillatory branch; it must not exclude stationary initial stress perturbations.
Take the trace of the statistically isotropic magnetic second-moment tensor. There are three spatial directions, so
Choosing the nonnegative speed,
Thus is the root-mean-square value of any one Cartesian magnetic field component in Alfvén velocity units. It is not the magnitude of the mean Alfvén velocity, which is zero here. Statistical isotropy fixes a second moment even when the first moment vanishes.
With zero velocity and no time dependence, the magnetic second-moment tensor equation holds automatically, but the magnetohydrodynamic momentum equation still requires
The magnetic tension must therefore be a pressure gradient. Locally, its necessary integrability condition is
on a simply connected region this is also sufficient for a scalar , subject to the global boundary conditions. In physical units the same balance is : the Lorentz force density is balanced by mechanical pressure, rather than necessarily vanishing. A zero mean magnetic field does not make the local magnetic tension zero, so an arbitrary tangle is not automatically a static equilibrium.
The magnetic second-moment tensor is . This is the magnetic dyadic called the Maxwell tensor in the paper; the isotropic part of the usual Maxwell stress tensor is already contained in the magnetohydrodynamic total pressure. The solenoidal magnetic-field constraint gives
Consequently the magnetohydrodynamic momentum equation in part a becomes , where is the material derivative. Applying its product rule and the ideal magnetohydrodynamic induction equation gives
Thus the evolution uses only , together with . To determine , take the divergence of the magnetohydrodynamic momentum equation. Since and ,
This is the pressure Poisson equation for incompressible flow, with boundary conditions supplied by the imposed normal acceleration and normal stress, or by periodicity or decay at infinity as appropriate. For example, the normal component of the magnetohydrodynamic momentum equation requires at a prescribed boundary. The pressure is determined up to a spatially constant function of time.
For equivalence to one resolved magnetic field, the initial must actually be for a divergence-free vector field. In particular it is a symmetric positive semidefinite matrix of matrix rank at most one. The tensor equations also admit more general stresses; the averaged in part d need not have matrix rank one.
Write the physical magnetic field as and use the constant mass density to introduce Alfvén velocity units, . If is the fluid's mechanical pressure, the magnetohydrodynamic total pressure per unit mass density is . The ideal magnetohydrodynamic equations then reduce to
The first equation is momentum conservation: the magnetic pressure has been included in , leaving magnetic tension explicitly. The second is the ideal magnetohydrodynamic induction equation, expressing magnetic flux freezing. The last two equations impose incompressibility and the solenoidal magnetic-field constraint.
The model assumes a smooth conducting-fluid continuum with constant mass density and constant magnetic permeability, nonrelativistic velocity, and scales on which a single-fluid description is appropriate. Negligible electrical resistivity removes magnetic diffusion; negligible viscosity removes viscous momentum diffusion. Equivalently, the magnetic Reynolds number and the Reynolds number are large on the scales being retained. The low-frequency approximation neglects the displacement current; Hall and other kinetic corrections to Ohm's law are absent. Incompressibility is an imposed approximation, commonly justified when the Mach number is small. There is no independently evolved thermodynamic pressure: enforces the incompressibility condition. We omit external body forces; a conservative one could instead be absorbed into .
The undisturbed ambient solution is smooth and free of body forces throughout the ball . Its Stokes equations imply
Taking the divergence gives , and a further Laplacian therefore gives
Each velocity component obeys the biharmonic equation in the whole ball.
Expand a component of at the centre and average over . The odd spherical moments vanish, while
Thus the spherical mean of a biharmonic function gives
The truncation is exact, not just a small-sphere approximation: all terms containing two or more Laplacians vanish. One can avoid any Taylor-convergence issue by letting . Since is harmonic, its spherical mean is , so
Integrating gives for every admissible .
Combining with the force-free result of part c proves Faxén's first law in the requested form:
The force-free qualification carries over. Local absence of ambient body forces and regularity inside the ball are also needed; if forcing or a singularity lies inside it, the harmonic-pressure and biharmonic-mean argument does not apply unchanged.
Let be the sphere surface, point from the sphere into the fluid, and write
Because the prescribed exterior body forces are unchanged, they cancel on subtraction: the disturbance is a homogeneous Stokes flow in the exterior domain. On the sphere the no-slip boundary condition is
allowing an arbitrary sphere rotation .
Use as auxiliary flow the translating-sphere solution of part b, with arbitrary test velocity . Its surface velocity is and its surface traction is . Applying the Lorentz reciprocal theorem on the exterior domain gives, after cancelling the common inner-normal minus sign,
The outer surface terms vanish for decaying disturbances: velocities are at most , stresses , and the integrated cross-work is .
There are no body forces inside the sphere in the original ambient problem. Thus the smooth ambient stress tensor has zero divergence there, and
Also , so the rotation term drops out of the left side. Consequently the reciprocal identity reduces to
Since is arbitrary, the result before imposing mechanical balance is
For a freely suspended sphere with negligible inertia and no applied external force, . Its sphere velocity as a surface average of ambient Stokes flow is therefore
The implicit force-free condition is essential. More generally, an external force gives . For example, an externally pulled sphere in the zero ambient flow has nonzero velocity, contrary to an unrestricted surface-average-only claim. No torque-free assumption is needed for this translational identity, because the auxiliary surface traction is constant.
Write the supplied velocity in the radial form
At , and , giving the no-slip boundary condition . At infinity and the supplied gauge-fixed pressure tends to zero. These are the laboratory-frame conditions for a sphere translating through otherwise quiescent fluid.
The exterior Stokes equations can also be checked directly:
and
To compute surface traction in translating-sphere Stokes flow, let point from the sphere into the fluid. At the surface, , and . Hence
Substitute into the Newtonian fluid stress tensor. Its viscous contribution to the surface traction is , so the normal part cancels the pressure contribution:
The vector is constant over the entire sphere in the stated pressure gauge. Integrating it gives the fluid's drag force on the sphere,
This is Stokes's law. On an exterior fluid domain the outward domain normal at its inner boundary is ; that distinction will matter in the reciprocal calculation.
Use the same constant dynamic viscosity for both incompressible Stokes flows, and let be body force per unit volume. Their equations and Newtonian fluid stress tensor are
where is the strain-rate tensor. Consider the cross-work flux
By the product rule,
The pressure terms vanish by incompressibility. Symmetry of the stress tensor removes antisymmetric velocity gradient contributions, leaving in both cross terms; they cancel. Apply the divergence theorem, with outward from , and rearrange:
This is the Lorentz reciprocal theorem with body forces. It depends on reciprocal linear viscous response in the same fluid; arbitrary unrelated constitutive laws would not supply the cross-term cancellation.
For a uniform axial magnetic field, the anisotropic Shear Alfvén wave is predominantly horizontally polarized, whereas the pseudo-Alfvén wave is predominantly vertically polarized. Without rotation both have characteristic frequency . Pressure projection makes the effective Coriolis acceleration couple these two transverse wave polarization states at the inertial-wave rate
Thus the useful comparison is not alone, nor anisotropy alone, but
In this limit rotational coupling of shear and pseudo-Alfvén waves is negligible on an Alfvén propagation time, so the two familiar linear polarizations are decoupled to leading order. The factor cancels: simply making both disturbances more anisotropic does not by itself remove their relative rotational coupling.
For a nonlinear reduction one must also make the rotational mixing slow compared with the nonlinear evolution being retained. Under Alfvénic critical balance, , the same inequality gives . Rapid rotation relative to the horizontal nonlinear rate can therefore coexist with leading Alfvénic decoupling in the window
High electrical conductivity makes magnetic diffusion slow, and the corresponding inviscid approximation is also assumed. If , rotational and magnetic restoring effects are comparable and the modes are mixed magneto-Coriolis disturbances; in the rotation-dominated limit they separate into fast inertial-like and slow magnetostrophic branches, rather than into independently evolving shear and pseudo-Alfvén polarizations.
At finite amplitude, independence is generally one-way in the usual anisotropic ideal magnetohydrodynamics reduction: the Alfvénic subsystem has no leading feedback from pseudo-Alfvénic perturbations, but it can still advect them. The small rotational-coupling condition removes an additional two-way coupling, rather than all nonlinear advection.
This is an asymptotic finite-timescale statement. The two nonrotating Alfvén polarizations are degenerate, so even a weak nonzero rotational coupling can rotate their superposition over the much longer time . Exact decoupling for arbitrarily long times does not follow from a small ratio alone. The strictly nonpropagating limit is separate.
Within the reduced equations for an anisotropic rotating fluid, a flow that remains purely horizontal has and . The second reduced equation therefore requires
Thus the retained horizontal motion is two-dimensional. This is a Taylor–Proudman theorem consequence in the slow balanced ordering; setting at only one instant would not suffice, because vertical motion could subsequently develop.
The word “exactly” applies to the reduced model. It is not a theorem for every finite-Rossby number solution satisfying only . For example, the full rotating Euler equation admits
It is an incompressible flow, has zero nonlinear advection, and obeys . It is purely horizontal but depends on , and can hold. This fast inertial oscillation lies outside the slow anisotropic critical balance used in part c; it shows why that ordering cannot be dropped from the conclusion.
Let and let be the common size of horizontal and vertical velocity perturbations, as found in part b. The linear inertial wave time and nonlinear advection time are
The critical balance in a rapidly rotating fluid is therefore
The Rossby number is of order . Horizontal geostrophic flow balances the leading pressure gradient against Coriolis acceleration, so
These are dimensionally comparable statements, rather than comparisons of a dimensional frequency with a dimensional velocity. Equivalently, use and as units. Then
Thus rotation stays in these units, while the motions evolve on the slower time. Vertical advection is smaller than horizontal advection by .
Write , with , and . At leading horizontal order,
Define the stream function , including its horizontally uniform part in this convention. Then
The next-order incompressibility condition is not zero horizontal divergence:
This term has size and is essential: its product with the large rotation rate is a leading contribution to the vertical vorticity equation.
To see that contribution explicitly, write . At the first horizontal inertial order,
Taking its vertical curl eliminates . The two-dimensional advection identity and the two divergence orders give
Equivalently the ageostrophic flow satisfies
whose divergence is . This explicitly verifies that the next-order divergence has the required sign.
The vertical momentum equation, at the same slow order, is
Finally , where the canonical two-dimensional Poisson bracket is . The reduced equations for an anisotropic rotating fluid are
The omitted vertical-advection, ageostrophic-advection and relative-vorticity stretching terms are smaller by in the equations retained here. Linearizing these equations recovers , the anisotropic limit of part a.
The group velocity, which gives wave-packet and energy propagation, is the gradient of the dispersion relation:
For this becomes
Thus for , energy travels almost along the rotation axis, with a small horizontal component. By contrast, the normal-to-phase-front phase velocity is almost horizontal. Indeed , so these phase and group directions are perpendicular. Specifying which meaning of propagation is intended matters for an inertial wave.
For the wave polarization, incompressibility and the equation in part a give
The horizontal component parallel to is small, but : the other horizontal and vertical components are in quadrature. More exactly, introduce the orthonormal transverse basis
Then . The physical velocity at a fixed point traces a circle in the plane perpendicular to ; its handedness reverses between branches. In the anisotropic limit this plane is nearly vertical. The group velocity and polarization of an inertial wave therefore have quite different geometric roles.
Figure 1.
Phase and energy propagation and circular velocity polarization of a low-frequency inertial wave
. The positive-frequency example has k parallel divided by k perpendicular equal to 0.15. Left arrows show normalized directions only: group velocity is nearly vertical and perpendicular to the wavevector, while phase velocity is parallel to it. The right panel shows the velocity circle in an orthonormal plane normal to the wavevector; its arrow follows increasing time. Details.

Pinned article: Introduction to the OurBigBook Project

Welcome to the OurBigBook Project! Our goal is to create the perfect publishing platform for STEM subjects, and get university-level students to write the best free STEM tutorials ever.
Everyone is welcome to create an account and play with the site: ourbigbook.com/go/register. We belive that students themselves can write amazing tutorials, but teachers are welcome too. You can write about anything you want, it doesn't have to be STEM or even educational. Silly test content is very welcome and you won't be penalized in any way. Just keep it legal!
We have two killer features:
  1. topics: topics group articles by different users with the same title, e.g. here is the topic for the "Fundamental Theorem of Calculus" ourbigbook.com/go/topic/fundamental-theorem-of-calculus
    Articles of different users are sorted by upvote within each article page. This feature is a bit like:
    • a Wikipedia where each user can have their own version of each article
    • a Q&A website like Stack Overflow, where multiple people can give their views on a given topic, and the best ones are sorted by upvote. Except you don't need to wait for someone to ask first, and any topic goes, no matter how narrow or broad
    This feature makes it possible for readers to find better explanations of any topic created by other writers. And it allows writers to create an explanation in a place that readers might actually find it.
    Figure 1.
    Screenshot of the "Derivative" topic page
    . View it live at: ourbigbook.com/go/topic/derivative
  2. local editing: you can store all your personal knowledge base content locally in a plaintext markup format that can be edited locally and published either:
    This way you can be sure that even if OurBigBook.com were to go down one day (which we have no plans to do as it is quite cheap to host!), your content will still be perfectly readable as a static site.
    Figure 5. . You can also edit articles on the Web editor without installing anything locally.
    Video 3.
    Edit locally and publish demo
    . Source. This shows editing OurBigBook Markup and publishing it using the Visual Studio Code extension.
  3. https://raw.githubusercontent.com/ourbigbook/ourbigbook-media/master/feature/x/hilbert-space-arrow.png
  4. Infinitely deep tables of contents:
    Figure 6.
    Dynamic article tree with infinitely deep table of contents
    .
    Descendant pages can also show up as toplevel e.g.: ourbigbook.com/cirosantilli/chordate-subclade
All our software is open source and hosted at: github.com/ourbigbook/ourbigbook
Further documentation can be found at: docs.ourbigbook.com
Feel free to reach our to us for any help or suggestions: docs.ourbigbook.com/#contact