Write for the one-particle Hamiltonian operator. The second quantization of the kinetic energy, external potential energy and repulsive contact interaction isThe factor counts each unordered particle pair once. Normal ordering excludes self-interaction: the interaction acts on two distinct bosons. The fixed particle number sector has . In three dimensions, this contact interaction is understood as a regulated low-energy interaction with a matched coupling, as in renormalization of a three-dimensional dilute-gas contact coupling; the finite-mode calculation below uses its projected matrix elements.
The normalized Hartree product state and its equivalent second quantization form areThe product is already symmetric under exchanging bosons; no additional belongs in the coordinate wavefunction. The factor in the second quantization expression instead normalizes repeated creation operators acting on the vacuum state. This is a fixed-number two-mode condensate, with every boson in the same normalized orbital.
Set and . Its binomial distribution of occupations givesThe expectation value of the Hamiltonian operator is thereforeKeeping rather than replacing it by retains the exact pair count of the trial quantum state. Equivalently, with , its interaction contribution is and its one-particle contribution is .
Choose the nonredundant parameter range , with modulo . For , minimizing over the relative phase gives . Putting , the remaining nonconstant energy is , which decreases with for the repulsive coupling . HenceThe optimal orbital is the symmetric . Both the quantum tunnelling term and the repulsive interaction favor this balanced occupation within the Hartree product state family. This result uses a variational method: for strong repulsion relative to quantum tunnelling, the true many-body ground state can have smaller occupation fluctuations than this fixed-number two-mode condensate.
The Hartree product state underlying the Gross–Pitaevskii equation has the factorized one-body coherence of a Hartree condensate. Choosing its nodeless ground state orbital real givesIn particular, the Thomas–Fermi approximation for a condensate from part (d) predictsThe curve starts at , decreases with zero slope at the origin, and reaches zero with an infinite slope at . Restoring the kinetic energy in the full Gross–Pitaevskii equation rounds that edge and produces a nonzero tail. This corrects the Thomas–Fermi approximation for a condensate, but the resulting one-body density matrix still factorizes.
The additional missing physics is quantum depletion. Interactions scatter pairs of bosons into orbitals outside the Bose-Einstein condensate even at zero temperature. In terms of the true Bose-Einstein condensate orbital the exact one-body density matrix decomposes asThe single-orbital Hartree product state sets and omits altogether. In a weakly interacting Bose gas, Bogoliubov theory adds a comparatively short-range noncondensed contribution near the origin, together with reduced weight in the broad Bose-Einstein condensate component. The central value remains the total number density, not just the condensate density. Its numerical shift relative to the original Gross–Pitaevskii equation solution also depends on the interaction-induced redistribution of number density; it is not fixed by the condensate fraction alone.
In the scalar two-particle model, the fermionic exchange symmetry and bosonic exchange symmetry conditions areFor particles with spin, exchange acts on all their labels; the stated coordinate-only model fixes the spatial symmetry sector. Define . Equal masses make the kinetic operator invariant under exchange, and the assumed potential is invariant too, so . Therefore implies . The componentsare respectively symmetric and antisymmetric eigenfunctions whenever nonzero. Their sum is the original nonzero quantum state, so at least one is nonzero. An eigenspace may contain both sectors if the energy is degenerate.
The normal modes of two harmonically coupled identical particles provide the separation. The coordinate transformation to is orthogonal, with absolute Jacobian one. Exchanging the particles leaves fixed and changes to . Hence bosonic quantum states are even and fermionic quantum states odd in the relative coordinate. The chain rule givesAlso and . Combining the two trapping potentials with the interaction therefore gives the separated Hamiltonian operatorThese are independent oscillators of frequencies and . Both frequencies are positive in the stated range. Their product eigenstates have energiesThe parity of an oscillator level is . Consequently bosons allow even and fermions odd , while is unrestricted.
The bosonic ground state uses , and the fermionic ground state uses . The oscillator length in the relative mode isUsing the normalized Gaussian for each mode givesIndeed by differentiating the Gaussian, so it is the normalized odd first excited state. The ground energies are and .
Choose normalized factors for a normalized product quantum state; this can always be done by reciprocal rescaling of its factors. Since the coordinate Jacobian has absolute value one,If the supplied factors are not individually normalized, the general expression has an additional factor ; choosing normalized factors is the convention in the displayed formula.
For the ground states, put . Then and . Thus, for differentiable with suitable Gaussian integrability and vanishing boundary terms,This is integration by parts, and every polynomial satisfies the required endpoint conditions. The relative-coordinate moments in even and odd oscillator ground states follow by substituting :For odd , both expectations vanish by parity, so this is an equality of zeros rather than an increase in signed mean separation. The even moments show the physical difference. In particular and , so the fermionic root-mean-square particle separation is times the bosonic value. The fermionic probability density vanishes at coincidence , expressing Pauli exclusion principle in this spatial symmetry sector. This is an exchange constraint on the wave function, not an additional classical force. As approaches , the relative oscillator softens and its width diverges; the excluded endpoint would no longer have this normalizable oscillator ground state.
For identical bosons the full wave function is symmetric under the particle exchange operator:In the given position-only model this is the spatial parity under the particle exchange operator. If additional spin variables are present, the symmetry applies to the complete state including them.
The orthogonal coordinate change preserves the kinetic energy and takes the particle exchange operator to . Thus the spatial wave function is even in for bosons and odd for fermions.
The total potential energy and Hamiltonian separate asAssume so the relative oscillator is confining. Its spectrum is , and its parity in the two-particle relative coordinate is .
The lowest boson state uses , whereas the lowest fermion state uses , . ThereforeFor an oscillator of frequency , . Since ,The factor three is the extra relative-coordinate excitation required by antisymmetry. The supplied oscillator wave functions correspond to kinetic energy ; the extra factor printed before that term in the hint is inconsistent with those functions and the stated energies. The calculation uses the conventional kinetic energy dictated by particle mass .
A permutation of identical particles multiplies a fermionic state by ; a bosonic state is invariant. Particle exchange keeps fixed and sends to . Consequently the spatial wave function is even in for the stated bosonic model and odd for the stated fermionic model. This assumes no additional spin variables in the supplied model; exchange of full particle states is the underlying rule.
The coordinate change is orthogonal, with unit Jacobian determinant, so the kinetic energy becomeson the square with zero boundary values. Product states have energyThe one-dimensional eigenfunction is even for odd and odd for even . Bosons therefore allow odd , whereas fermions require even . The lowest bosonic pair is ; its first excited pair is . The lowest fermionic pair is . ThusThe printed bosonic ground-energy claim omits the factor ; the value above follows directly from the supplied one-dimensional spectrum and kinetic energy.
The separation is . The normalized factor integrates out. In the fermionic ground state, the relative-coordinate density is , givingFor the bosonic ground state it is , givingBoth integrals follow by replacing squared trigonometric functions by their constant and cosine parts and integrating once by parts. Henceand the difference is . The odd relative state vanishes at coincidence, which increases its expected separation.
A permutation of identical particles multiplies a fermionic state by ; a bosonic state is invariant. Particle exchange keeps fixed and sends to . Consequently the spatial wave function is even in for the stated bosonic model and odd for the stated fermionic model. This assumes no additional spin variables in the supplied model; exchange of full particle states is the underlying rule.
The coordinate change is orthogonal, with unit Jacobian determinant, so the kinetic energy becomeson the square with zero boundary values. Product states have energyThe one-dimensional eigenfunction is even for odd and odd for even . Bosons therefore allow odd , whereas fermions require even . The lowest bosonic pair is ; its first excited pair is . The lowest fermionic pair is . ThusThe printed bosonic ground-energy claim omits the factor ; the value above follows directly from the supplied one-dimensional spectrum and kinetic energy.
The separation is . The normalized factor integrates out. In the fermionic ground state, the relative-coordinate density is , givingFor the bosonic ground state it is , givingBoth integrals follow by replacing squared trigonometric functions by their constant and cosine parts and integrating once by parts. Henceand the difference is . The odd relative state vanishes at coincidence, which increases its expected separation.
In the scalar two-particle model, the fermionic exchange symmetry and bosonic exchange symmetry conditions areFor particles with spin, exchange acts on all their labels; the stated coordinate-only model fixes the spatial symmetry sector. Define . Equal masses make the kinetic operator invariant under exchange, and the assumed potential is invariant too, so . Therefore implies . The componentsare respectively symmetric and antisymmetric eigenfunctions whenever nonzero. Their sum is the original nonzero quantum state, so at least one is nonzero. An eigenspace may contain both sectors if the energy is degenerate.
The normal modes of two harmonically coupled identical particles provide the separation. The coordinate transformation to is orthogonal, with absolute Jacobian one. Exchanging the particles leaves fixed and changes to . Hence bosonic quantum states are even and fermionic quantum states odd in the relative coordinate. The chain rule givesAlso and . Combining the two trapping potentials with the interaction therefore gives the separated Hamiltonian operatorThese are independent oscillators of frequencies and . Both frequencies are positive in the stated range. Their product eigenstates have energiesThe parity of an oscillator level is . Consequently bosons allow even and fermions odd , while is unrestricted.
The bosonic ground state uses , and the fermionic ground state uses . The oscillator length in the relative mode isUsing the normalized Gaussian for each mode givesIndeed by differentiating the Gaussian, so it is the normalized odd first excited state. The ground energies are and .
Choose normalized factors for a normalized product quantum state; this can always be done by reciprocal rescaling of its factors. Since the coordinate Jacobian has absolute value one,If the supplied factors are not individually normalized, the general expression has an additional factor ; choosing normalized factors is the convention in the displayed formula.
For the ground states, put . Then and . Thus, for differentiable with suitable Gaussian integrability and vanishing boundary terms,This is integration by parts, and every polynomial satisfies the required endpoint conditions. The relative-coordinate moments in even and odd oscillator ground states follow by substituting :For odd , both expectations vanish by parity, so this is an equality of zeros rather than an increase in signed mean separation. The even moments show the physical difference. In particular and , so the fermionic root-mean-square particle separation is times the bosonic value. The fermionic probability density vanishes at coincidence , expressing Pauli exclusion principle in this spatial symmetry sector. This is an exchange constraint on the wave function, not an additional classical force. As approaches , the relative oscillator softens and its width diverges; the excluded endpoint would no longer have this normalizable oscillator ground state.
A bosonic coherent state obeys and has expansion . Its occupation is Poisson distributed, with mean and variance . Its nonzero field amplitude makes phase coherence natural, although physically observable phase comparisons require a reference.
For paired fermions, the corresponding Cooper-pair pseudospin coherent state isIt coherently superposes empty and occupied pair states and has an anomalous average . It is not an ordinary complex-eigenvalue coherent state of a single fermion annihilation operator. The broken-symmetry state has indefinite particle number; number projection can restore a fixed-number description without discarding the underlying pairing correlations.
Hartree-Fock-Bogoliubov theory approximates a two-body interaction using both the normal density and anomalous pairing tensor . Direct and exchange contractions determine a normal one-particle field, while anomalous contractions determine the pair potential. The resulting quadratic Hamiltonian is diagonalized by a fermionic Bogoliubov transformation. In a homogeneous singlet case its Nambu block isThe fields are determined self-consistently, rather than selected independently of the quasiparticle state. For example,together with the particle-number equation. The pairing field extends ordinary Hartree-Fock theory to states with pair correlations. This mean-field treatment omits fluctuations beyond its self-consistent quadratic description.
For bosons, write the field as a coherent condensate plus fluctuations, . The same normal/anomalous strategy retains and , with a bosonic, commutation-preserving Bogoliubov transformation. In the leading weakly depleted contact-gas limit, the condensate density and effective coupling give , with . This Bogoliubov theory connects low-momentum sound to high-momentum particle excitations. More elaborate self-consistent truncations must respect the symmetry constraints needed for a gapless condensate mode.
In three dimensions an ideal Bose gas can saturate its excited-state population at chemical potential zero, with the remaining particles forming a Bose-Einstein condensate. The transition follows from the Bose-Einstein distribution integrated against its density of states; below the ideal-gas transition, . Condensation alone does not supply the finite Landau critical velocity of an interacting superfluid: the ideal quadratic spectrum has .
By contrast, a weak attractive interaction near a Fermi surface produces the Cooper instability and the BCS gap equation. Its logarithmic enhancement permits pairing at arbitrarily weak attraction in the ideal model. The low-temperature excitations have , and in weak coupling . This transition is controlled by pair formation when phase fluctuations are small; deeply bound pairs instead motivate a Bose-condensation description with their own density and effective mass.
For the given ellipsoidal dispersion, set , and . Then while the integration measure is . Thus the anisotropic ideal-gas density of states per unit volume and per internal state isThe full continuum momentum range is assumed; this is an anisotropic three-dimensional gas, not yet a discrete stack of two-dimensional bands.
At the Bose transition, substitute :The integral is . Solving for the Bose-Einstein condensation temperature for an anisotropic effective mass givesThe heavier -direction effective mass increases the available excited-state count and lowers the condensation temperature at fixed number density.
For a balanced two-spin Fermi gas, let denote total fermion number density and take to be the single-spin density of states used in the conventional gap equation. Counting the filled ellipsoid givesIf a spin-summed density of states is used instead, the coupling convention in the supplied integral must change accordingly; inserting a factor two into only one side would change the exponent incorrectly.
For , replace the density of states across the interaction window by . Writing , the zero-temperature integral becomesand thereforeThe second expression additionally requires . The explicit density dependence is . This mass-anisotropy enhancement of a weak-coupling BCS gap initially raises the pairing scale, while the ideal Bose condensation scale decreases as .
Formal anisotropy-dependent gap and Bose scales, with a schematic coherence-limited transition
. Details. Large anisotropy weakens transport and coherence in the heavy direction. The separation of pair formation and phase ordering then matters, so a large mean-field gap need not imply a large actual . A qualitative sketch has initially rising with the pairing scale and eventually turning down when coherence is the smaller scale. If preformed fermion pairs behave as bosons, use and pair mass about ; in this continuum model this gives .
The turnover cannot be located reliably by taking the weak-coupling formulas to : falls, grows, the narrow-window assumption fails and the pair chemical potential and mass require a self-consistent treatment. The smooth curve in the figure is explicitly an illustrative interpolation of two extrapolated scales, not such a calculation. If actual decoupled two-dimensional layers are approached, ordinary ideal-gas finite-temperature condensation is absent and interacting phase order requires a different analysis, including the Berezinskii–Kosterlitz–Thouless transition when appropriate.
The cuprates make the distinction between pairing and phase coherence relevant: they are layered and have anisotropic motion, but their strong correlations, lattice band structure and predominantly d-wave superconductivity are outside this attractive continuum -wave model. Anisotropy by itself is therefore not an explanation or quantitative fit of cuprate transition temperatures.
A bosonic coherent state is an annihilation-operator eigenstate,It has , a selected complex amplitude, and Poisson-distributed particle number. A coherent-field condensate variational state extends this construction to a spatial field with . Evaluating a normal-ordered interacting Bose Hamiltonian in that state gives a classical-field energy functional; its variational equation is the Gross–Pitaevskii equation. This connects a macroscopic phase to interference, quantized circulation and neutral Josephson effects. A fixed-number condensate instead has vanishing one-point field expectation; off-diagonal long-range order identifies the condensate without requiring exact number fluctuations.
The BCS ground state has the pair-coherent formIt is a product of Cooper-pair pseudospin coherent states: each paired momentum sector mixes its empty and doubly occupied configurations. The anomalous pair expectation is , while an ordinary single-electron expectation vanishes by fermion parity. Pair operators are not unrestricted canonical boson operators, so this state must not be identified with a naive oscillator coherent state of individual electrons. Number projection gives a fixed-even-number description with pair correlations. Phase differences between condensates enter the Josephson effect; in a charged condensate that phase difference must be gauge invariant.
A bosonic coherent state is an eigenstate of its annihilation operator,Its mean occupation is and its number variance is also , giving a Poisson number distribution. It has a well-defined complex mean field but fluctuating particle number. Its overlap with another coherent state is , so distinct amplitudes need not be orthogonal. For large occupation, a phase-space wave packet has small relative number fluctuations; this does not require an exact self-adjoint phase operator conjugate to a number bounded below.
For a bosonic field, a useful coherent-field condensate variational state isIt obeys . For a contact-interacting dilute Bose gas, its normal-ordered energy expectation isMinimizing gives the stationary Gross–Pitaevskii equation, . Its phase gradient determines superfluid flow, while weak-link phase differences give Josephson currents. The complex microscopic expectation supplies the order field used by a mean-field description of a bosonic superfluid.
An exactly fixed-number condensate can instead use the Hartree product state . Its one-point field expectation vanishes by number conservation, but its one-body density matrix has a macroscopic eigenvalue. Off-diagonal long-range order expresses that number-conserving criterion. Selecting a phase is a useful thermodynamic symmetry-broken description; it is not a claim that every finite isolated condensate literally has indefinite total number. A plain coherent product also misses interaction-induced quantum depletion, which needs correlations such as those in the Bogoliubov quasiparticle vacuum.
In a spin-singlet superconductor, the corresponding variational state is the BCS ground stateEach block superposes an empty and an occupied pair state. Where , it can be rewritten as , treating any fully occupied blocks separately. The exponential truncates within each block because a fermionic pair cannot be created twice in the same two modes. This is a Cooper-pair pseudospin coherent state, rather than a coherent state of unrestricted ideal bosons.
The one-electron expectation remains zero in a fermion-parity-even BCS state. Its nonzero microscopic order is the BCS anomalous average . For an attractive interaction written with matrix elements , the gap is . Minimization yields the coherence factors and gap equation. Fermionic coherent states using Grassmann variables are valuable integration tools, but they are not ordinary complex-eigenvalue electron states replacing this physical paired wavefunction.[ref]
Theory of Superconductivity by John Bardeen and others. 1957, variational paired ground state and elementary excitations
Near the transition, a slowly varying pair field connects the microscopic anomalous average to Ginzburg-Landau theory of superconductivity. The phenomenological complex field has pair charge , a phase that controls supercurrent and a magnitude whose normalization is model dependent. It is not the expectation of a single-electron field. Microscopic derivation of Ginzburg-Landau theory supplies this connection under its stated near-critical assumptions. Pair phase coherence, Josephson interference and flux quantization then become different manifestations of the same macroscopic paired order. Paired-fermion superfluids likewise use a pair order field, while bosonic atomic superfluids can use a one-particle condensate field.
Past exam of the theoretical physics II course of the University of Cambridge 2013 Paper 1 4 a Solution Created 2026-10-20 Updated 2026-10-20
There is a state-assumption issue. For a number-conserving Gaussian quantum state with no anomalous contractions, put , and the one-body density matrix . Wick's theorem pairs each creation operator with an annihilation operator. The direct pairing gives ; the exchanged pairing gives , with for bosons and for fermions. Hencenormal ordering removes the equal-position delta-function self-counting term. Fermionic occupation-number product states are Slater determinants and obey this Wick theorem. Independent thermal bosonic modes also obey it, with understood as mean occupations.
A bosonic Fock product state does not generally obey the asserted identity. The bosonic number-state corrections to Gaussian density correlations follow from and giveFor one occupied mode this is , whereas the uncorrected Gaussian expression gives . This counterexample disproves the asserted identity for arbitrary bosonic number-product states. The formulas below give both the Gaussian result, with its additional state assumption, and the exact bosonic number-state alternative. The ensemble distinction is also explicit in a later primary treatment of ideal-gas correlations.[ref]
Quantum Correlations of Ideal Bose and Fermi Gases in the Canonical Ensemble by Kazumasa Tsutsui and Takafumi Kita. Abstract: canonical reduced density matrices versus grand-canonical Wick factorization; 2016
The three-point density correlation of an ideal quantum gas follows first for a number-conserving Gaussian quantum state. There are six pairings, one for each permutation of three annihilation operators. The identity gives the product of densities; each transposition has sign ; both three-cycles have positive sign. ThusThe last two terms are complex conjugates. They equal , not an additional signed pair term. This is the permanent of a matrix for bosons and its determinant for fermions. Wick's theorem supplies the six terms only with the state assumption stated in part (a).
For completeness an exact bosonic Fock-state alternative can be given without that assumption. Let be a mode-occupation decrement with . Define as the sum of over all distinct ordered triples having these mode multiplicities. Acting three annihilation fields on the number state leaves mutually orthogonal states for different . ThereforeHere , with zero when . This expression includes repeated-mode occupation corrections absent from the Gaussian permanent; for a single mode it reduces to .
Choose orthonormal, flux-normalized incoming and outgoing channels and include all channels of this lossless scattering problem. Conservation of probability requires for every input vector. With ,For a square channel matrix this also gives . A submatrix obtained by omitting loss channels need not be unitary, but that is not the stated two-channel model.
The given real Hadamard matrix is symmetric, unitary and its own inverse. HenceThis same transformation preserves the canonical commutation relations for bosons and anticommutation relations for fermions. To extract probabilities one must use normalized number states, including their factorial factors, even when the supplied input expression is unnormalized.
For one spin channel, let and . The number-operator commutators giveMoving a boson from to raises the number difference by two. On a number-difference eigenstate , , while . ThusSubtracting the reversed products yieldsThis number-difference shift identity fixes the ordering. The placement of the coefficient to the left matters: it acts on the state after the hop. This spectral argument applies to any function defined on the accessible number-difference eigenvalues, without requiring a power-series expansion.
The second-order terms aresoHere is the first-order generator. The full second-order commutator includes terms changing the number difference by four. To retain only fixed site occupancies, keep the products and .
With and , the mixed commutators giveThus occupancy-preserving second-order bosonic hopping givesFor bosons, normal ordering givesConsequently an explicit form in terms of the supplied function isThe operator exchanges spin labels between sites while preserving their total occupancies. Defining dimensionless Schwinger-boson spins and similarly for ,No factor of is needed for these dimensionless spins; for physical spin operators it becomes . The spin exchange belongs in the occupancy-preserving part, whereas two hops in the same direction do not.
A linear number-difference energy gives only a one-body level renormalization. Let , with . Then is constant, so the exchange coefficient cancels. Since ,The same-direction commutators vanish as well, so this is the whole second-order term. This agrees with expanding the two-site single-particle splitting with the appropriate assignment of levels. A collection of noninteracting bosons remains noninteracting after a change of single-particle basis. The case is resonant and cannot be treated by this elimination.
A nonlinear energy generally makes the virtual denominators occupancy-dependent. Then and need not agree, and the occupancy-preserving effective Hamiltonian contains density-dependent shifts and a spin-exchange coefficientmultiplying . Its sign depends on the function and sector; nonlinearity alone does not fix a universal exchange sign. The full second-order result can additionally contain pair hopping between different occupation sectors.
For a concrete repulsive example, take , , and restrict to two bosons with one on each site. Here , , , givingThe triplet energy shift is and the singlet shift is zero. This is ferromagnetic bosonic superexchange in this example: the symmetric spin sector can lower its energy through virtual double occupancy. The sign must not be imported from the fermionic Hubbard problem. The example specifies an additional energy function solely to illustrate the general expression; it is not an asserted numerical input.
Past exam of the theoretical physics II course of the University of Cambridge 2017 1 a Solution 2026-10-18
In second quantization, expand the annihilating quantized field in a complete orthonormal basis of one-particle states, . At equal times, the canonical commutation relation for bosons and the canonical anticommutation relations for fermions are, respectively,andHere is a Dirac delta distribution. Multiplying by the basis wave functions and integrating gives for bosons, or for fermions; the two-annihilator and two-creator brackets vanish in the corresponding convention.
The mode number operator and total particle number operator areThe bosonic occupation numbers are . For fermions, and the canonical anticommutation relations imply , so the fermionic occupation numbers are only and , as required by the Pauli exclusion principle.
Keeping only two modes later is a projection: the projected field bracket is , rather than the full Dirac delta distribution.


