In a local orthonormal frame, a massless neutrino has and . With degeneracy , kinetic theory gives the stress-energy tensor
Coordinate components follow by inserting the orthonormal-frame vectors on the indices.
For the perturbation , integration by parts gives
assuming the boundary term vanishes. Consequently the physical trace-free spatial stress is
The paper uses the opposite signed source, , consistently with its tensor equation having on the right. In that convention the neutrino tensor anisotropic stress is
All three interactions respect color charge; quark flavor is conserved by the strong interaction and the electromagnetic interaction, but can change in the weak interaction. These statements concern charges and net numbers, rather than an unchanging inventory of particles.
A quark transforms in the fundamental representation of the color charge gauge group . The strong interaction can change an individual quark's colour by exchanging a gluon, which itself carries color charge. For example, the colour flow is allowed: demanding that the outgoing quark remain red would be incorrect. At each interaction vertex the full colour flow is conserved. The colourless photon, W boson, and Z boson instead couple to a quark with an identity factor in colour space. A weak charged current can therefore change to , but cannot turn into without another coloured participant. External isolated hadrons are colour singlets; confinement prevents direct observation of a free coloured state.
For each quark flavor , define the net quark flavor number . The strong interaction and electromagnetic interaction preserve every : pair creation , for example, changes neither net strangeness nor any other . Their quark couplings are diagonal in quark flavor. The weak charged current contains , where is the Cabibbo-Kobayashi-Maskawa matrix, and changes these net numbers. Weak neutral currents are diagonal in tree-level Feynman diagrams; flavor-changing neutral currents can occur through higher-order Feynman diagrams.
The observed hierarchy of mean lifetimes and decay channels supplies evidence: associated strange-particle production through the strong interaction preserves net strangeness, whereas a kaon's weak interaction decay to pions changes it. The electromagnetic interaction process has zero net quark flavor before and after annihilation. Neutrino oscillations show that individual lepton family numbers are not exact conserved quantities. Within the usual effectively massless-neutrino approximation, charged current decays such as preserve family numbers only when the emitted neutrinos are counted.
Evidence for three colours includes the hadronic R ratio , the colour multiplicities in W boson decay widths, and three-jet events revealing gluon radiation. These test quantum chromodynamics and its colour structure together; they are not direct measurements of a named red or blue charge on a free quark.
Two mechanisms are a tau lepton pair with two leptonic decays, and a W boson pair with two leptonic decays. With equal beam energies, the laboratory is the centre-of-mass frame, and four-momentum conservation gives in natural units.
For the first mechanism,
There are four escaping neutrinos. Each tau lepton decay proceeds through a virtual W boson. The fixed-charge final state has branching fraction ; the factor two for the inclusive sample does not apply when the charges are specified.
For the second mechanism,
There are two escaping neutrinos. The leading Feynman diagrams comprise both -channel photon/Z boson exchange and -channel electron neutrino exchange. Their scattering amplitudes interfere; the complete set is needed for a consistent high-energy prediction. In particular, the neutrino-exchange diagram alone does not define an independently observable production rate.
Figure 1.
Tau-pair decay and the three leading W-pair production diagrams
. Details.
A tau lepton pair has enhanced production at the Z boson particle resonance, . The four-neutrino missing energy has a broad continuous distribution. To derive a useful schematic, neglect daughter masses and parent spin correlations. In an unpolarized tau lepton rest frame, the Michel spectrum for is
A Lorentz boost gives , with uniform on in this approximation. For , the charged-daughter probability density function in is
For two independent decays, has the convolution
and . It vanishes at both endpoints and peaks on the larger-missing-energy side. This is a shape illustration, not the exact polarized Z boson prediction; spin correlations, acceptance, and radiative effects alter it.
The W boson process turns on near . At exact on-shell production threshold, each neutrino has energy , so
The cross section vanishes at the ideal two-body threshold, so this narrow limiting spectrum must not be called the maximum-rate spectrum. The large W boson-pair rate occurs above threshold, around . There and each neutrino has
Thus
An isotropic independent-decay schematic is triangular, centered at , with endpoints approximately and at . Actual W boson particle polarizations and their correlations change this shape; their V-A interaction is not isotropic for a fixed helicity. The finite decay width, beam spread, and radiation also smear the edges.
Figure 2.
Missing-energy shapes for explicitly stated spin-averaged decay approximations
. Details.
The phrase “maximum rate” also needs a production regime: a Z boson peak is a resonant maximum, whereas pure photon-mediated tau lepton production has its continuum maximum near . Indeed, has . The displayed high-boost curve describes the resonant regime; at the continuum maximum use in the boost formula. An observed event-rate maximum additionally depends on collider luminosity and detection efficiency.
In ordinary perturbative Standard Model reactions all three interactions conserve electric charge, four-momentum, total angular momentum, baryon number, and total lepton number. The last two are accidental conservation laws of these perturbative processes, not exact nonperturbative statements: electroweak sphalerons violate while preserving baryon-minus-lepton number. Total color charge is respected throughout.
The strong interaction and electromagnetic interaction also conserve each net quark flavor number, including strangeness, charm and bottom flavour. The weak charged current can change them through the Cabibbo-Kobayashi-Maskawa matrix. Isospin is an approximate strong interaction symmetry in the small light-quark mass difference limit; the different electric charges of and break it in the electromagnetic interaction. Approximate flavor symmetry is distinct from exact net-flavour-number conservation by those interactions.
Parity conservation and charge conjugation symmetry hold for the electromagnetic interaction and, assuming a negligible strong CP parameter, the strong interaction. The weak interaction violates both, and also violates CP symmetry in suitable processes. CPT symmetry holds under the usual local Lorentz invariant quantum field theory assumptions. Individual lepton family numbers are conserved in the conventional massless-neutrino approximation but not in neutrino oscillations; an assertion of exact family conservation in all observed reactions would therefore be false.
A representative Feynman diagram annihilates into , producing and an off-shell ; the charged antilepton emits a photon and becomes the outgoing . The top panel below shows this contribution. A complete gauge-invariant decay amplitude includes radiation from the charged hadronic side, together with structure-dependent terms. The physical separation into inner bremsstrahlung, structure-dependent radiation, and their interference is explicit in the standard radiative pion decay description.[ref]
Here is an explicit finite model of phase space alone, with its assumptions exposed. Neglect the neutrino mass, treat the photon as massless, and replace the spin-summed invariant decay amplitudes by constants over the available Lorentz-invariant phase space. Write , , , and use natural units. The three-body phase space with one massive daughter follows by factoring through an intermediate invariant squared mass :
The two-body comparison has . Since , assuming gives
Here is a dimensionless constant encapsulating the assumed matrix element ratio, and is the fine-structure constant. If the two-body mode dominates, this ratio approximates the radiative branching fraction. Near , , displaying the extra phase space suppression.
This model is not a prediction of a physical uncut radiative branching fraction. Actual inner bremsstrahlung has a soft-photon singularity, so a count of events with a separately observed photon requires a positive photon energy cut. To see both the missing input and the mass dependence explicitly, the leading soft-photon result for is
The coefficient follows from the radiation factor : angular integration gives , where , and the soft energy integral is . Thus a finite physical number cannot be deduced from the two masses and phase space alone. The infrared divergence cancels only when the corresponding unresolved real radiation and virtual radiative corrections are combined in an inclusive observable.
Both -channel Z boson exchange and -channel annihilation occur. Replacing the incident neutrino by an antineutrino interchanges the two chiral angular weights. In the same contact-interaction regime,
At the factor is , between parts (i) and (ii). The comparison is energy dependent outside this regime: near , the annihilation channel has a W boson resonance, and the low-energy formula is inapplicable.
This is the charge-and-parity-conjugate reaction of part (i). There are -channel Z boson and crossed W boson contributions, with all fermion arrows reversed relative to part (i). For matched unpolarized kinematics and negligible CP violation,
Combining all four results in the regime specified in part (i),
In particular, conjugating both initial particles restores the part-(i) rate; conjugating the neutrino alone does not. Initial spin polarization and energies near a weak-boson mass require a separate comparison.
The observed dominant two-body transition is . Both baryons have valence quarks and the same strangeness; an electromagnetic interaction transition is therefore possible. Their mass difference is only about , below the lightest pion mass, so no additional on-shell strongly interacting particle fits. A photon is neutral and massless, and can carry the required angular momentum through a magnetic dipole transition between the two positive-parity spin- states. A single neutrino would violate lepton number and would not give the required fermion parity.
At rest, four-momentum conservation gives and . Thus
The result is slightly below because the Lambda baryon recoils; rounded masses give about .
The channels and are actually kinematically open: their total rest energies are about and , below . Their suppression is therefore not a decay threshold prohibition. Each changes strangeness from to zero and so requires a weak interaction. The much faster allowed electromagnetic transition makes such weak branching fractions extremely small. “Not observed” should be understood as overwhelming electromagnetic competition, not an exact ban in the Standard Model. The photon identification likewise uses the known low-energy spectrum and dominant transition mechanism, not neutrality alone.
beta decay is a weak charged current process. At quark level , with amplitude proportional to at low momentum transfer. A neutron in a nucleus can thereby become a proton:
The second reaction denotes an energetically allowed nuclear conversion, not a decay of an isolated free proton. In a nuclear beta transition the mass number stays fixed and the atomic number changes by one. baryon number and electric charge are conserved; the neutrino or antineutrino supplies the missing energy, momentum and angular momentum. The three-body final state produces a continuous electron spectrum rather than a single electron energy. Neglecting neutrino mass and recoil, an allowed spectrum in electron total energy is
The Fermi function accounts for the electron's Coulomb interaction with the daughter; is the electron total-energy endpoint. forbidden beta decay adds momentum-dependent nuclear shape factors. The V-A interaction violates parity: it couples left-chiral fermion fields, not an equal mixture of left and right currents.
For allowed beta decay the leading leptons have zero orbital angular momentum. Fermi transitions have ; Gamow-Teller transitions have with excluded. Both preserve nuclear parity. Higher lepton partial waves permit forbidden transitions with extra suppression. Nuclear matrix elements and phase space, as well as these selection rules, determine lifetimes. Particle-physics examples include free-neutron decay and pion beta decay, . semileptonic decays test quark mixing and the universality of the weak charged current. beta decay changes quark flavour through virtual W exchange; its continuous spectrum reflects an additional lepton in the final state.
For electron-positron annihilation into a muon pair the gauge diagrams are s-channel photon and Z exchange. For electron-positron annihilation into electron neutrinos there is s-channel Z exchange and t-channel W exchange, with interference. For electron-positron annihilation into W-boson pairs there are s-channel photon and Z diagrams and a t-channel electron-neutrino diagram. All three gauge amplitudes are required for the proper high-energy cancellation. Electron-Yukawa-suppressed s-channel Higgs diagrams can also produce the massive muon or W pair; they vanish in the usual zero-electron-mass approximation used for the leading gauge comparison.
Figure 1.
Lepton and W-pair gauge diagrams
. Details.
There is no energy-independent ordering. For unpolarized beams and inclusive Born cross sections the useful regimes are:
The Z-pole ratio follows . Treating every weak reaction as uniformly slower misses both the resonance and forward exchange.
A Feynman diagram specifies a term in the perturbative scattering amplitude, not a measured microscopic trajectory. Assign external spinors or polarization vectors, an interaction factor to each Feynman vertex and a propagator to each internal line; impose four-momentum conservation and integrate over independent loop momenta. Sum amplitudes for indistinguishable alternatives, then square, sum final spins and average unpolarized initial spins. A decay rate uses in natural units; a cross section also divides by incident flux. interference means probabilities of individual diagrams must not simply be added.
The electromagnetic fermion vertex is , with coupling proportional to ; it preserves fermion flavour. There is no elementary three-photon or four-photon vertex in quantum electrodynamics. The weak charged current has and vertices, with a left-chiral projector and a Cabibbo-Kobayashi-Maskawa matrix element at the quark vertex. The weak neutral current has vertices with vector and axial couplings; it includes neutrinos and is flavour diagonal at tree level. Electroweak gauge interactions also include , and quartic , , and vertices. Higgs-fermion and Higgs-vector interactions complete the mass-related scalar sector.[ref]
Quantum chromodynamics has vertices proportional to , plus three-gluon and four-gluon Feynman vertices because gluons carry color charge. A quark-gluon vertex preserves quark flavour. Internal particles need not be on their mass shells, but electric charge and four-momentum are conserved at each vertex. The figures below show representative leading flavour topologies; binding and hadronization are implicit, and additional strong-interaction contributions can modify hadronic amplitudes.
parity reverses spatial coordinates and polar vectors such as momentum, while leaving axial vectors such as angular momentum unchanged. The correlation is therefore parity odd. For polarized beta-emitting nuclei one can measure
where is measured from nuclear polarization, its magnitude and a decay-dependent coefficient. A nonzero spin–momentum asymmetry is incompatible with parity invariance.
The cobalt-60 experiment polarized nuclei at low temperature and compared beta emission along and opposite the polarization axis. Preferential emission on one side established weak-interaction parity violation. Reversing polarization tests whether the asymmetry follows nuclear orientation; warming the sample removes polarization, while gamma anisotropy monitors its loss. Detector acceptance, backgrounds and magnetic deflection of charged particles must be separated from a true emission asymmetry.[ref]
In the modern weak charged current, the V-A interaction couples to left-chiral fermion fields. In the massless limit this selects left-helicity neutrinos and right-helicity antineutrinos. Massive charged leptons need not be pure-helicity states, consistent with the factor . Strong and electromagnetic interactions conserve parity to the usual experimental approximation; parity violation alone should not be confused with CP violation or a failure of CPT.
The electroweak gauge group is . Left-handed fermions form weak-isospin doublets and right-handed charged fermions are singlets under . Before symmetry breaking the gauge fields are and , with couplings . A Higgs-doublet vacuum expectation value breaks the symmetry to electromagnetic .
In units , the physical combinations and tree-level relations are
The photon remains massless. charged currents change members of weak doublets, whereas the mediates weak neutral currents with parity-dependent couplings. At low energies exchange reduces to the Fermi contact interaction, ; the apparent weak suppression reflects the massive mediator. This unifies the gauge description, not the numerical equality of all low-energy couplings.[ref]
Neutral-current neutrino interactions and subsequent observation of massive weak vector bosons tested this structure. In a neutral-current neutrino experiment, an isolated hadronic interaction without an accompanying charged lepton is a candidate signal; entering neutral hadrons and missed charged-current leptons are important backgrounds. Gargamelle's neutral-current evidence supplied a direct experimental check beyond ordinary beta decay.[ref]
At energies far below the mass, replace its propagator by a constant. The modern V-A interaction form of Fermi's contact theory has, in units,
Nucleons are treated nonrelativistically within nuclear states. To leading order in their velocity, the vector charge and axial spatial current give the two nuclear operators
where here means neutron-to-proton conversion. (i) The scalar Fermi operator permits , including , without parity change. The rank-one Gamow–Teller operator permits without parity change, excluding . Both terms can contribute when the same nuclear states permit them; their strengths contain nuclear matrix elements, not just phase space.
(ii) Expand the lepton waves across the nucleus in powers of their momenta times nuclear radius. When , the constant spatial term gives allowed transitions. If its matrix element vanishes by spin/parity selection, higher terms supply lepton orbital angular momentum: “forbidden” means suppressed, not impossible. First-forbidden terms change parity and can have ; the rank-two case is unique first-forbidden. Higher orders carry additional small spatial factors and different energy-dependent shape factors. The contact approximation alone does not imply the allowed approximation.
For a single branch, neglect recoil and neutrino mass and first assume an energy-independent nuclear shape factor. Fermi's golden rule integrates the neutrino phase space with , while the electron momentum volume is proportional to . Including Coulomb distortion,
This momentum-bin Kurie ordinate is linear in kinetic energy and vanishes at its endpoint. If instead using counts per unit kinetic energy, in units; converting with recovers the supplied momentum-bin definition. No extra factor of should be left inside that definition of .
The graph's horizontal coordinate is , not in MeV. Its intercept is approximately –, so
For a ground-to-ground branch between bare nuclei, the emitted electron's rest energy must also be supplied:
For neutral atomic masses the mass difference instead equals approximately , neglecting small electron-binding corrections. The graph supports this approximate precision, not a precise evaluated isotope mass. Interpreting a branch to an excited daughter would require adding its excitation energy; the ground-state comparison assumes the ground-state branch intended here.
The shell-model prediction for yttrium-91 beta decay follows from shell filling: the proton orbitals above 28 fill with four protons and with six, reaching 38. Yttrium has its 39th proton in , giving . Its 52 neutrons include the closed 50-neutron core and a pair in , coupled to zero in the simple paired ground state. Zirconium has 40 paired protons and 51 neutrons, leaving an unpaired neutron, so . Therefore
The single-particle change is neutron to proton ; the parity change and rank two prevent an allowed Fermi or Gamow–Teller contribution.
The straight plotted line is a constant-shape idealization. For the shell-model transition just inferred, a leading unique-forbidden shape factor contains in units, with Coulomb/finite-size refinements. Consequently the uncorrected quantity specified in the paper is generally proportional to , not exactly linear. A consistent shape-corrected Kurie plot also divides its ordinate by . The source's exact straight-line construction and its forbidden-transition inference cannot both be exact with a Coulomb-only ; the approximate graphical endpoint can still be read as requested. Allowed and unique-forbidden spectral shapes are experimentally distinguishable.[ref]
Figure 1.
Original illustrative comparison of constant-shape and unique-first-forbidden Kurie ordinates with the same endpoint; no source data points reproduced
. Details.
Use natural units and invariant squared center-of-mass energy . For a massless incident neutrino and an initially stationary electron,
At the production threshold the final massless neutrino can have arbitrarily small center-of-mass energy, so the lower endpoint is . The charged-current neutrino-electron threshold is consequently
For the three flavours, using precisely the masses given in this part, the answers are for , for , and for . The zero threshold for the electron flavour is an infimum for elastic scattering; it does not imply a nonzero interaction rate at zero incident energy. The large heavy-lepton thresholds arise because most laboratory energy becomes center-of-mass motion against a very light target.
Beta decay converts a neutron to a proton or vice versa through the weak interaction, leaving the mass number fixed:
Inside a nucleus the full initial and final nuclear masses determine whether either process is possible. Electron capture, , is the related bound-electron process. The emitted charged-lepton spectrum is continuous because energy is shared with the neutrino and nuclear recoil.
For allowed beta decay, the lepton wavefunctions' leading spatial terms are constant over the nucleus. A Fermi transition has and no parity change. A Gamow-Teller transition has and no parity change, excluding . Thus a same-parity transition with nonzero initial and final spins and can contain both contributions. First-forbidden transitions change parity and permit ; the case is unique forbidden beta decay. Higher forbiddenness requires higher powers of the small lepton momentum times nuclear size. “Forbidden” denotes suppression of the leading allowed operator, not an impossible decay.[ref]
Fermi's golden rule expresses a rate as a squared nuclear matrix element times leptonic phase space. Neglecting charged-lepton mass and Coulomb distortion, a constant allowed matrix element gives
This is the approximate Sargent rule, for comparable allowed strengths; it is not an exact law across arbitrary transitions. Finite electron mass, the Fermi function, forbidden shape factors and nuclear structure change the comparison. A microscopic first-forbidden unique operator introduces additional momentum factors.
Using bare nuclear masses , the kinetic-energy release is
The daughter is different in the two cases: its charge is for beta minus and for beta plus. The relevant mass difference must exceed one electron mass. For neutral atomic masses, to leading order in small electronic binding corrections, the corresponding expressions are and . Electron capture is energetically possible approximately when , with available shell binding energy and daughter excitation included. Nuclear masses and atomic masses must not be mixed.
For neutrino-electron elastic scattering, work in the laboratory frame with a stationary electron and a massless incoming neutrino of energy . If the electron receives kinetic energy and momentum , its relativistic energy-momentum relation gives
conservation of energy fixes the outgoing neutrino energy to , and conservation of momentum fixes its momentum to . Its zero mass therefore requires
Substitution and cancellation give
For , this requires ; squaring must not introduce a backward-electron branch. Squaring, cancelling and solving gives
The expression increases with on the physical interval . Maximum transfer occurs for a forward electron and a backward outgoing neutrino:
The remaining is carried by the neutrino. An elastic collision cannot transfer the entire incident energy to a free massive electron.
The Standard Model is a gauge theory with group , matter quarks and leptons, gauge bosons and a Higgs field. It combines Quantum chromodynamics with the electroweak interaction. Its successes do not make its field content a complete account of nature. Established missing phenomena should be distinguished from theoretical questions about its parameters.
neutrino oscillation demonstrates nonzero mass-squared differences and mixing of flavor states. The minimal renormalizable Standard Model has no right-handed neutrino and no neutrino mass term. The atmospheric experiment compared zenith-angle distributions of muon-like and electron-like events in a large water Cherenkov detector. A direction-dependent muon-neutrino deficit, with different path lengths through Earth and comparison samples, discriminated against a uniform flux-normalization error.[ref] One extension adds right-handed neutrinos and small Dirac Yukawa couplings; another has a Majorana mass term and seesaw mechanism, with light eigenvalue of order . Oscillations alone do not decide whether neutrinos are Majorana neutrinos.
dark matter is inferred from gravitational observations such as galactic motions and gravitational lensing; Standard Model particles do not supply the required dominant cold component. Active neutrinos contribute some matter but cannot constitute all the cold dark matter. A new stable weakly interacting particle, an axion, or other hidden-sector states are possible explanations, with different scattering, production and astrophysical signals. Dark-matter evidence does not identify a particular new particle. The institutional account distinguishes gravitational evidence from proposed particle candidates.[ref]
The matter-antimatter imbalance poses a different problem. Dynamical baryogenesis needs Sakharov conditions, including baryon-number violation, CP violation and departure from thermal equilibrium. Although the Standard Model contains relevant ingredients in principle, they do not generate the observed asymmetry in its conventional thermal history with measured parameters. Additional CP phases, a stronger electroweak transition, or leptogenesis from heavy Majorana neutrinos are possible extensions. Each needs a quantitative mechanism.
gravity is absent as a dynamical quantum interaction, motivating quantum gravity and unification. The hierarchy problem asks why the Higgs mass scale is small compared with much higher scales when scalar masses receive sensitive quantum corrections. supersymmetry can cancel particular contributions between partner fields if its breaking pattern is suitable; compositeness gives another interpretation of the Higgs sector. Neither motivation proves that the corresponding new particles exist. The Strong CP problem asks why the allowed QCD CP-violating parameter is so small; an axion mechanism is one possible answer.
A grand unified theory embeds the separate gauge factors in a larger group and can relate couplings or fermion representations, sometimes predicting proton decay. Its tests differ from dark-matter or neutrino-mass searches. A useful extension must explain a specified deficiency, preserve successful low-energy predictions and supply distinguishable experimental consequences. Attractive new symmetries alone are not evidence.
The dominant interaction is weak. In panel (iv),
The quark vertex carries the Cabibbo-Kobayashi-Maskawa matrix factor . The down quark and anti-up quark form a color singlet pion. The pion bracket represents its bound-state matrix element, conventionally specified by the pion decay constant; it is not an additional weak vertex. The neutrino carries the initial tau lepton number.
Assume allowed beta decay, so the leading matrix element has negligible lepton-momentum dependence. Neglect nuclear recoil and neutrino mass. Let be the kinetic energy available to the electron and antineutrino, , and . The neutrino energy and momentum magnitude are .
Fermi's golden rule weights accessible final states. After angular integration, the momentum-space factors are and . The energy-conserving Dirac delta function removes the neutrino integral:
The constant includes the allowed nuclear matrix element, weak-coupling and angular factors. Including the usual Fermi function for electron-nucleus Coulomb distortion gives
For the kinetic-energy spectrum, instead yields
The two distributions differ by a Jacobian; forgetting it changes the shape.
A pure fifth-power law additionally neglects electron mass and Coulomb distortion and keeps the nuclear matrix element fixed. Then , , and
Two momentum powers come from each final particle and one from the remaining integration. This is the origin of the Sargent rule. Exact dependence requires the relativistic-electron, constant-matrix-element limit. For , the same approximation without Coulomb distortion has and instead scales as . Forbidden-transition factors, nuclear-structure changes and Coulomb distortion also modify the simple law.