Use . The given state is a two-species uniform boson number state: only the mode of each species is occupied. Applying an annihilation operator to an unoccupied mode gives zero, while has eigenvalue . Thus
The two species have independent fixed occupation numbers, so mixed expectation values factorize. The inverse discrete Fourier transforms yield
In the momentum-space Hamiltonian operator, only contributes: each annihilation operator must remove an occupied boson, and each creation operator must restore it to the same mode. Hence
There is no replacement of by in this energy: in the real-space calculation the relevant neighboring-site commutator is zero. Both expressions assume distinct neighbouring sites, as in ii.
To match the prescribed spin length in the mean, impose . At fixed integer , the energy is minimized by maximizing . Consequently the best choices within this relaxed family are
When is even, and . When is odd, either assignment of gives . Without fixing , this auxiliary boson Hamiltonian operator has no lower bound: taking sends its expectation value to .
Next, . Each term changes the two species' occupation numbers, producing a state orthogonal to . Therefore
For distinct sites modulo , expand the product of the two spin operators. The terms and again have zero expectation value. The remaining terms give
Here and the Kronecker delta vanishes at distinct sites. Consequently
The same holds for the components. At the balanced choice and as , each transverse two-point correlation function tends to independently of separation, whereas the one-point transverse magnetization is zero. This is transverse spin order in a number eigenstate: the state has a definite total and retains the global U(1) symmetry of rotations about , yet has the transverse correlations of an ordered state with no selected common azimuth. The sum of the and correlations tends to , describing ferromagnetic long-range order within this approximation. The thermodynamic limit is understood with both the separation and growing, without identifying the two sites periodically.
Fixed-spin qualification. The proposed state is not actually in the physical fixed- Hilbert space for . It satisfies the local spin constraint in the Schwinger boson representation only in expectation value. For example, with ,
The nonzero component has local total occupation numbers and hence local spins , instead of . More generally the local total number operator has variance
Each species contributes a binomial distribution at a given site, with success probability , and the two contributions are independent. In the physical subspace that variance must be zero. The proposed state even has
by the Casimir operator identity from a. Thus the calculated energy is a relaxed mean-field theory estimate, not a Rayleigh-Ritz variational principle bound for the stated fixed- quantum XY chain. Projecting onto at every site would give a physical trial state and generally change its expectation values; in the two-site example the projected state has energy , whereas the unprojected value is . The calculated long-range order characterizes the supplied approximation and does not establish long-range order in the exact one-dimensional ground state.
Let be the box volume. The number operator is the sum of the occupation numbers of all momentum eigenstates, including the zero mode:
In the Fourier series for the contact interaction, the two creation operators supply phase and the two annihilation operators supply . Fourier orthogonality with periodic boundary conditions gives
The four normalization factors together contribute , leaving the momentum-space contact-interaction Hamiltonian
The Kronecker delta enforces momentum conservation. An equivalent expression that resolves the momentum transfer is
Both are already in normal ordering; no extra commutator constant is introduced.
The coherent state in the zero mode has mean occupation number . The other occupation numbers follow from part (c), giving exactly
Impose the fixed mean particle number by choosing
Here is the quantum depletion of a Bose condensate. The approximation requires , so remains positive and macroscopically large. The specified coherent state and multimode squeezed vacuum are not exact eigenstates of the total number operator; in this variational construction is their prescribed mean particle number.
Write . Substituting into the retained part of the interaction energy before truncating gives
The last two terms quadratic in have no explicit large- factor when the Bogoliubov transformation parameters are held fixed, and are discarded along with the nonzero-mode quartic contribution already omitted in part (c). This is the same truncation that underlies the number-conserving Bogoliubov quadratic Hamiltonian. Thus, defining the physical number density correctly as ,
Replacing by at the outset would give the wrong coefficient : expanding the leading condensate interaction energy supplies the necessary subtraction.
The printed definition is an error. In three dimensions the contact interaction coupling has units of energy times volume, so does not even have units of energy. There is a direct counterexample with no depletion: when , the specified coherent state has exactly . In fixed length and energy units, , and give , whereas the printed with gives . The requested formula and the minimization in part (e) hold with .
Use the standard canonical anticommutation relations for the two distinct fermionic orbitals. In particular , in addition to the relations explicitly listed in the paper; these mixed relations are part of the usual two-orbital fermionic Fock space interpretation. Normalize the original vacuum state by and fix the ordering
The canonical anticommutation relations give and . Consequently the number operator is an orthogonal projector:
The same holds for . Hence each eigenvalue obeys and is either or , expressing the Pauli exclusion principle. Also , so the two number operators have a simultaneous orthonormal basis of Fock states:
Each number operator has eigenvalues , each with state degeneracy two. For , the zero eigenspace is spanned by and the unit eigenspace by ; for , these are respectively and . Any normalized linear combination within one such eigenspace is also an eigenstate of that number operator.
The ordering convention will matter below: and
Let , and . Substitution of the Bogoliubov transformation, with normal ordering using and , gives
For example, the term in contributes ; these constants must be retained to obtain the ground-state energy. The two-orbital fermionic pairing Hamiltonian is consequently
To eliminate the pairing term, choose a canonical rotation of two fermionic modes satisfying
With , , take , so . Setting gives
This positive choice fixes a convenient convention for the vacuum state in part (d). It yields
Both number operators independently have eigenvalues . Hence the energy eigenvalues and state degeneracies are
There is one fermionic Bogoliubov quasiparticle of energy per occupied transformed orbital. The two Nambu spinor matrix eigenvalues should not be mistaken for two independently occupiable levels of opposite energy; the normal ordering constant and the two positive quasiparticle excitation costs give the four physical energy eigenvalues above.
An independent diagonalization of a matrix checks both the pairing sign and the additive constant. In the ordered orthonormal basis , the even-fermion parity block is
because and . Its characteristic polynomial is , giving . The odd-fermion parity Fock states are unaffected by pairing and both have energy .
Equivalently, with the Nambu spinor ,
Replacing by gives , reproducing the result by normal ordering.
Figure 1.
Pairing splits the even-parity levels and mixes the original vacuum with the occupied pair
. Original exact energy eigenvalues in units of , and the probability of finding both original orbitals occupied in the two-mode fermionic paired vacuum. The middle energy level remains twofold degenerate; both outside energy levels are nondegenerate. Details.
The canonical anticommutation relations make , so the proposed exponential function terminates exactly:
Use the inverse Bogoliubov transformation , , and the actions and . The two vacuum state conditions become
Both therefore require . Normalizing this quantum state gives . Choosing positive , which fixes an irrelevant overall global phase, yields because . Thus the two-mode fermionic paired vacuum is
The other sign for describes the same physical quantum state. The positive relative coefficient is fixed by the paper's pairing order and the convention .
As a direct eigenvector check, and imply
It is therefore the unique ground state, as also follows from positive quasiparticle excitation energy . It has definite even fermion parity but is not an eigenstate of the original total number operator: the empty-pair and occupied-pair probabilities are and . In particular . The pair amplitude is , consistently with .
For the limiting check at fixed positive , , , so . For at fixed positive , , , giving equal amplitudes for the empty and occupied pair. These checks also fix which branch of the Bogoliubov transformation produces the ground state.
The canonical anticommutation relations imply . Thus the number operator satisfies
It is a orthogonal projection, so its eigenvalues obey and are . The same argument gives . This is the Pauli exclusion principle for each orbital. The two number operators commute, so they have simultaneous eigenstates.
Take the vacuum state to have unit norm and fix the double-occupation convention . An orthonormal basis of the four-dimensional fermionic Fock space is
Each individual number operator has two-dimensional eigenspaces: for these are spanned by and ; for they are spanned by and . Higher occupation numbers vanish because the square of a fermionic creation operator is zero. Reversing the order of the two fermionic creation operators changes only the sign convention for .
Write and . Expanding the number operators and restoring the displayed order with the canonical anticommutation relations gives
The minus sign in the first line follows from . Substitution into the Hamiltonian operator yields
Let . A convenient real Bogoliubov transformation has
These obey , and . Equivalently , with and . The coefficient of vanishes, while the coefficient of is . The constant is
Thus the diagonalized two-mode fermion pairing Hamiltonian is
The two transformed fermionic occupation numbers independently take values zero or one. The energy eigenvalues and their eigenspace dimensions are therefore
The positive quasiparticle energy makes the transformed vacuum state the unique ground state. The constant is essential for the correct ground-state energy.
As a separate sign and spectrum check, use the original fermionic Fock space basis. Both singly occupied states are energy eigenstates with energy , since the pairing terms annihilate them. In the ordered even-fermion parity basis ,
The off-diagonal signs follow from and . Its characteristic polynomial is , giving the remaining two eigenvalues , in agreement with the Bogoliubov transformation.
The number operator is . The number state expansion gives by shifting the summation index; taking the adjoint gives . Thus the expectation value is
For the second moment, use :
Its expectation value in the coherent state is . Therefore
The variance equals the mean, exactly as for the Poisson distribution found in b. For the fractional standard deviation is , the usual photon shot noise scaling. For the vacuum state, both the mean photon number and its variance vanish; this does not imply zero optical quadrature fluctuations. At the fractional fluctuation is undefined.
In a globally static region, choose the time coordinate along the future timelike Killing vector field . A positive-frequency solution of the Klein-Gordon equation has , with . Assume appropriate boundary conditions and a Cauchy surface so that the conserved Klein-Gordon inner product is
For a real scalar, take the negative-frequency modes to be . Choose a complete normalized basis with
The negative norm of the conjugate modes is crucial; this is not a positive-definite inner product on all classical solutions.
Promote the real Klein-Gordon field to the operator
These canonical commutation relations implement the canonical field and conjugate-momentum commutator. The static vacuum state in a stationary spacetime satisfies , and the Hamiltonian is a sum of oscillators, before zero-point regularization. Continuous labels replace sums by correctly normalized integrals. For a complex charged scalar there are separate particle and antiparticle oscillators, with the same mode-mixing argument in each sector.
Choose independently normalized past and future bases, and use the matrix indices of the question. Complex conjugation of the future positive-frequency expansion immediately gives
Conservation of the Klein-Gordon inner product gives and in this column-index convention. These ensure preservation of the canonical commutation relations.
Let annihilate past modes and annihilate future modes. Extracting the future coefficient from the field gives the Bogoliubov transformation
The minus sign follows from . In the in-vacuum, only contributes to the expectation of the future number operator. Therefore
This is particle number from Bogoliubov coefficients: the intervening time-dependent geometry makes a past positive-frequency mode contain a future negative-frequency component. In infinite volume, localized wave packets avoid delta-function normalization artifacts; a common Fock-space implementation needs the usual square-summability condition on the creation-mixing coefficients.
For gravitational collapse, the initial vacuum can be defined before the hole forms, while late outgoing modes are defined using the asymptotic stationary time at future null infinity. The complete future basis also includes modes falling through the event horizon; exterior outgoing modes alone are not a complete basis of all propagated data. Tracing an outgoing mode backwards near a nonextremal horizon gives the exponential ray relation , where is late retarded time and is the surface gravity. An outgoing factor becomes proportional to in the early advanced coordinate, and contains both frequency signs when Fourier decomposed there. Their squared Bogoliubov-coefficient ratio is ; the canonical normalization then gives a Bose factor , multiplied by the greybody factor, the transmission probability through the exterior potential. Thus Hawking radiation has temperature in units , with greybody factor modifications to the spectrum. This is a free-field calculation on a fixed or slowly evolving background; eventual backreaction is an additional problem, and the nonextremal exponential map must not be blindly used when .
With a vacuum annihilated by all , define the particle and antiparticle occupation operators of a Dirac field
Each counts its corresponding occupied modes. The total positive particle count is
Commuting it through either creation operator gives and , so both kinds of one-particle states have eigenvalue one. In a normalized discrete mode, by the anticommutation relations, so its occupation eigenvalues are .
For a Dirac field there is also a distinct conserved signed fermion number. Inserting the mode expansion into the normal-ordered local density gives
Spatial integration makes the same-sector momenta equal. The cross terms vanish by ; normal ordering of supplies the minus sign for the antiparticles. Thus the density integral is not the total positive particle count. It generates the global phase symmetry, and for electron charge the electric charge is .
The free normal-ordered Hamiltonian is
so and are conserved in the free theory. In an interacting theory, pair creation can change the total count while preserving the signed charge. This distinguishes a positive occupation number operator from the charge behind Dirac fermion number conservation.
The commutator gives . Hence and . Starting with the normalized vacuum, repeated application gives , proving unit norm. The number operator then has eigenvalue , so
Different levels are orthogonal because the Hamiltonian is self-adjoint and their eigenvalues are distinct.
For the perturbation, the ground-state diagonal matrix element is zero, while . The nondegenerate second-order perturbation formula consequently gives
For , . The lower and upper intermediate levels contribute respectively and , giving to second order.
For the exact completion of the square is
The shifted operators , have the same commutator and are unitarily related to the original ones by a displacement operator. Their vacuum is the coherent state with amplitude . Therefore every exact level shifts by .
The stability of monomial ladder-operator perturbations gives a necessary qualification to the request for a lowest level for every . For and real nonzero , a coherent state of amplitude has energy expectation . Choose the phase so the last term is negative. As the expectation tends to minus infinity, so the perturbed Hamiltonian has no true ground state. The displayed second-order answer is then the formal perturbative coefficient of the branch from the unperturbed vacuum, not an exact lowest eigenvalue. For stability requires ; for the completed-square Hamiltonian is bounded below for every real .
Use a free real scalar field obeying a linear Klein-Gordon equation, for example . This linearity is the assumption that permits mode evolution by a Bogoliubov transformation. Work with a complete set of normalized modes, or normalizable wave packets when the spectrum is continuous. The stationary asymptotic regions supply time translations relative to which positive-frequency solutions and their complex conjugates can be distinguished.
For solutions define the conserved Klein-Gordon inner product
Here is a Cauchy surface with future-directed normal. Its conservation follows by applying the wave equation to the divergence of its current, provided boundary flux is included or vanishes. Let be a positive-frequency basis in the past and one in the future, each propagated as a solution through the intermediate geometry. Normalize them by , and , with the corresponding identities for the future basis. The two field expansions are
The canonical commutation relations give and . The in-vacuum satisfies , while the out-vacuum satisfies . They are generally different vacua.
Fix the coefficient convention by expanding future modes in past modes:
The minus sign is due to the negative norm of the conjugate modes. Taking the Klein-Gordon inner product with the field, which is antilinear in its first entry, gives
Both frequency sectors are needed: if , a future annihilation operator contains a past creation operator. This is the mechanism of particle number from Bogoliubov coefficients, not a classical nonzero mean field.
Computing and explicitly gives the canonical identities for a bosonic Bogoliubov transformation:
Completeness also gives the inverse . Thus the evolved past vacuum, viewed in the future Fock space, obeys
For a finite-mode treatment with invertible , solve this condition by a multimode squeezed vacuum:
The canonical identities make symmetric. Commuting through the exponential gives , which directly verifies the vacuum condition. Its normalization is . A general initial state is obtained by applying its initial creation-operator polynomial and expressing those operators in the future basis. In infinitely many modes, a common unitary Fock representation requires the creation-mixing coefficients to be Hilbert-Schmidt; finite wave-packet counts avoid treating delta-normalized modes as individual normalizable states. These are the bosonic mode mixing implementability conditions, rather than an assumption of arbitrary finite total creation over an infinite time interval.
For the requested number operator of one future mode, set . Expectations below are in the evolved past vacuum , equivalently in using the Heisenberg-mode operators above. Acting on the past vacuum gives , whose squared norm is
The mean particle number vanishes exactly when that mode has no negative-frequency mixing.
The second moment needs the anomalous contraction
The canonical commutation relations give . Moreover,
Its vacuum and two-particle pieces are orthogonal. Applying the commutation relations twice shows
The two pairings each contribute to the squared norm. Hence the full answer is
Thus . These are the out-mode number fluctuations in the in-vacuum. Omitting would assume a property not given in the general question. A thermal single mode has , giving . A single-mode squeezed vacuum state instead has , giving .
If the counted observable is the total number over a finite set of future modes, its moments follow by retaining cross-mode correlations as well. Define and . The same vacuum pairings give . Thus and , with and . Independent thermal counts cannot be assumed for a general correlated squeezed state.
For Hawking radiation, choose the incoming vacuum at past null infinity of a collapse spacetime and propagate late outgoing modes backwards. Near a nonextremal forming event horizon, the logarithmic tortoise-coordinate divergence leads to the Hawking exponential ray map
where is late retarded time, is an early regular affine null coordinate and is the final surface gravity. A late positive-frequency mode therefore becomes proportional to on rays escaping just before horizon formation. This is not positive-frequency with respect to : it has both frequency signs and hence nonzero .
The thermal factor can be seen directly. With , and a regulator , the relevant Fourier integrals are
As , the arguments of the two complex factors approach . Their squared-modulus ratio for the suppressed and enhanced frequency branches is . Thus the thermal ratio of Hawking Bogoliubov coefficients, combined with the canonical normalization, yields the bosonic occupation
in units . Scattering through the exterior potential multiplies the asymptotic occupation by the appropriate greybody factor.
A complete future mode description includes modes crossing the horizon as well as modes reaching future null infinity. The global incoming vacuum develops correlations between these sectors; restricting to the exterior gives approximately thermal outgoing occupation rather than a claim that the complete pure state became a thermal mixed state. This is the particle-production picture of a collapsing black hole, not an incoming thermal bath on an eternal geometry. Including backreaction turns the emitted positive energy into black-hole mass loss. The renormalized quantum stress tensor is not subject to the pointwise classical positivity used in the black-hole area theorem, so this does not contradict its classical proof.
Use the unitary normalization of the Fourier transform,
The Schwartz space consists of smooth functions for which every Schwartz seminorm is finite. Such functions and all their derivatives are integrable. Differentiating under the integral and integrating by parts give
Consequently
Expand the derivative by the product rule and insert the integrable weight ; the right side is bounded by finitely many Schwartz seminorms of . This proves continuity . The identical argument with the opposite sign proves continuity of .
For surjectivity and injectivity an inversion proof is needed. If , multiply by . Fubini's theorem and the elementary Gaussian integral give
The Gaussian has total integral one and its mass outside any fixed ball tends to zero. The right side therefore tends to , by uniform continuity of . On the left, , so dominated convergence gives . This proves . Reversing the signs in the same calculation proves . Thus
Its inverse is continuous by the seminorm estimate already proved. This establishes the requested bijection without assuming Fourier inversion as an unexplained theorem.
Inversion gives and the Parseval identity. Indeed, inserting the integral for into and using gives . Density of Schwartz functions in extends to a unitary operator on , the Plancherel theorem. Translation of becomes multiplication by a phase, modulation becomes frequency translation, and
These formulas explain why the Fourier transform diagonalizes constant-coefficient differential operators. By transpose it also defines a bijection of the tempered distributions: with the complex-linear distributional pairing, , since the Fourier kernel is symmetric in its variables.
The connection with creation and annihilation operators is especially transparent for the harmonic oscillator. On the common invariant dense domain , set
Integration by parts shows that these are formal Hilbert-space adjoints. They are closable unbounded operators; commutators below are computed on , avoiding undefined products on arbitrary vectors. The identity gives the canonical commutation relations
It also gives
The normalized vacuum satisfies . Define the Hermite functions
Moving annihilation operators past creation operators with the commutation relations proves
These same relations show that the Hermite functions are orthonormal: unequal occupations are orthogonal eigenvectors of one of the commuting symmetric number operators , and the ladder relations recursively give norm one.
For completeness, let be orthogonal to every . The Hermite polynomials have nonzero leading monomials and triangular lower-degree terms, so these orthogonality relations say that all polynomial moments of vanish. Its Fourier integral extends to an entire function of :
The Cauchy-Schwarz inequality, with the Gaussian absorbing every exponential linear weight and every polynomial, justifies differentiation uniformly on compact sets of . Every Taylor coefficient at zero is a vanishing moment, so the entire function is zero. Fourier uniqueness on follows here without circularity: if an function has zero Fourier transform, convolving it with gives zero by the Gaussian integral and Fubini, and the approximate-identity limit in gives the original function zero. Thus and . The Hermite functions form an orthonormal basis of .
Finally, the elementary Gaussian integral gives . The derivative and multiplication identities above imply
where the operators on the right act on the frequency variable. Hence
Thus creation and annihilation organize both the oscillator's spectral decomposition and the four possible Fourier eigenvalues. On Schwartz functions the oscillator powers control weighted derivatives, and Hermite coefficients decay faster than every power of ; conversely this rapid coefficient decay implies all Schwartz seminorms are finite. The Fourier phases preserve this decay, providing another explanation of the Fourier automorphism of Schwartz space.
The oscillator operators satisfy and . Substitution into the kinetic and potential energies gives
The number operator is nonnegative because . The commutators and lower and raise an eigenvalue by one. If an eigenvalue were a noninteger , repeated lowering would produce a nonzero eigenvector with eigenvalue between zero and one, and one further lowering would have negative eigenvalue; its norm is nonzero because . This contradicts nonnegativity. Thus only nonnegative integers are allowed. The normalized Gaussian solves , and raising it supplies every level, with
For the three-dimensional unperturbed oscillator the product states are , with energy .
Write the perturbation as , where . Its ground-state expectation is zero. Acting on the ground state, it produces , each with coefficient . They lie above the ground state, so second-order perturbation theory gives
In the first excited subspace with basis , the first-order perturbation matrix is . Its symmetric eigenvector has eigenvalue , while the perpendicular two-dimensional space has eigenvalue . Thus the lowest excited triplet splits into
As an independent check, diagonalizing the quadratic potential gives normal frequencies and twice; their small- expansions reproduce both results.
Use units , metric , and . Treat the complex scalar field and its adjoint as independent variables when varying the action. Their canonical momenta are
Canonical quantization in the Heisenberg picture imposes, at the same time ,
All other independent equal-time commutators vanish: in particular , together with the same-type field and momentum commutators. The Legendre transform gives the Hamiltonian density
The Euler-Lagrange equations are . The positive- and negative-frequency plane waves form a complete basis of solutions of the Klein-Gordon equation. Since the field is complex, their operator coefficients are independent rather than being adjoints of each other. Define the Lorentz-invariant phase space measure . A convenient expansion is
The minus sign is a phase convention: replacing by produces the usual plus-sign expansion without changing its commutators or number operator. The normalization is fixed by the canonical commutation relations. For example,
when . The cross commutators vanish and the other canonical relation follows by taking adjoints with the operator order reversed. Conversely these mode commutators can be obtained by Fourier inversion of the equal-time relations. This is canonical quantization of a complex scalar field.
Substitution into the spatial integral for makes the diagonal terms proportional to and . Terms creating or annihilating a pair have and a coefficient , so they cancel. The result before vacuum subtraction is
Commuting past leaves a divergent field-independent vacuum energy. The displayed zero-vacuum-energy form must therefore be understood as a normal-ordered Hamiltonian:
A regulator can be introduced before subtracting the constant. This is the normal-ordered Hamiltonian of a free complex scalar field; the unrenormalized Hamiltonian is not literally equal to this expression without that convention.
The scalar-field vacuum is annihilated by both annihilation operators. Their adjoints create two species of spin-zero bosons with the same positive energy and mass , because
Repeated creation operators give the bosonic Fock space. The negative-frequency part does not create a negative-energy physical state; it creates the antiparticle of positive energy. The charge distinguishes the two species.
For the global phase transformation , , Noether theorem gives . Its divergence is
With vanishing boundary flux, the integral of is a conserved charge. Substituting the modes gives, before charge normal ordering, . The pair terms cancel because their frequency difference is zero when their spatial momenta sum to zero. Taking the vacuum charge to vanish gives the complex scalar charge operator
The mode commutators imply and , so
Thus the particle carries charge , the antiparticle carries charge , and a state with occupation numbers has charge . Also and , agreeing with the phase transformation and charge conservation.
Fix a classical globally hyperbolic spacetime with metric signature ; in this solution take . A free real Klein-Gordon field can be specified by
where is its mass, its curvature coupling and the scalar curvature. Global hyperbolicity ensures a well-posed initial-value problem on a Cauchy hypersurface and the existence of retarded and advanced propagators. Thus compactly supported field and normal-derivative data determine a classical solution. This fixes the dynamics, but not a Fock vacuum.
For real solutions with suitable support or falloff, the symplectic form on scalar-field solutions is
with the future unit normal. The field equation makes the current conserved, so this symplectic form is independent of when boundary flux vanishes. Quantize the initial data by the canonical commutation relation: with and the delta function defined relative to , and the two equal-field commutators vanish. Equivalently, construct the field algebra using the causal propagator. A state on that algebra is additional input.
To construct a particle representation, complexify the classical solution space. Its conserved Klein-Gordon inner product is
It is indefinite on all complex solutions. Choose a complete positive-norm subspace and an orthonormal mode basis with , and . Such a choice is encoded by a compatible complex structure on the Klein-Gordon solution space. Its positive subspace gives the one-particle Hilbert space, and the associated bosonic Fock space contains symmetrized many-particle states. The field expansion is
The creation operator adds a particle in mode , the annihilation operator removes one, and the number operator is . For continuous mode labels the sums and Kronecker deltas become integrals and delta functions, or one can work with normalized wave packets.
The ambiguity is precisely that the field equation and global hyperbolicity do not select that positive subspace. A different normalized basis may mix and by a Bogoliubov transformation, and then its annihilation operators mix and . Its Fock vacuum and number operators differ. The Hadamard condition constrains physically acceptable short-distance singularities and allows local renormalization, but it still leaves many states. Hence there is generally no observer-independent particle count on an arbitrary dynamical geometry.
In a stable strictly stationary spacetime, a globally future timelike Killing vector field gives a preferred time translation. Fix its normalization and suitable boundary conditions, and choose positive-frequency solutions satisfying with . The corresponding positive spectral subspace gives the preferred vacuum state in a stationary spacetime. Unitary changes of basis within it leave the vacuum and the particle notion unchanged. This construction assumes a well-defined positive stationary generator; stationarity by itself is insufficient if becomes spacelike, as in a Kerr ergoregion, or if unstable or zero modes obstruct the ground-state construction. It selects a preferred ground state under the stated assumptions, not a unique state among all thermal and excited states.
If the geometry is suitably stationary in the asymptotic past and future, choose those preferred mode spaces separately, giving the in-vacuum and out-vacuum. Propagate the past modes through the intervening region using the field equation and compare them to the future modes using the conserved Klein-Gordon inner product. Adopt the convention
The canonical identities for a bosonic Bogoliubov transformation read and . Extracting the future annihilation operator with the same inner product gives
In the in-vacuum, only contributes to . Therefore the particle number from Bogoliubov coefficients is
Nonzero is the production of future particles from the past vacuum. Summing over future modes gives the total expected particle number when that sum is finite. For infinitely many modes, a Hilbert-Schmidt operator is the condition for unitary implementability between these pure bosonic Fock space representations; finite-volume or wave-packet calculations must respect the relevant measures and convergence. Particle production is determined by the negative-frequency mixing, rather than by identifying a single instantaneous vacuum throughout the time-dependent region.
From the number operator commutator ,
so is proportional to . Its squared norm is
With the conventional phase choice,
In units with , the quantum harmonic oscillator Hamiltonian and number operator are
The nontrivial commutators among the creation and annihilation operators and are
Their reversed commutators have the opposite signs, while the commutator of any operator with itself is zero.
The operator is self-adjoint because
Its eigenvalues are therefore real. Moreover, for every state ,
so every eigenvalue is nonnegative.
If , the commutator with gives
and
Repeated application of lowers the eigenvalue by one. It must terminate before producing a negative eigenvalue. If is the last occupied rung, then , and the norm identity forces . Hence
This is the integer spectrum of the number operator.
The conserved number operator is
Substitution of into the Landau-Ginzburg theory gives
The imaginary term is a total derivative, so
Thus is the number density and is the canonical momentum conjugate to . The canonical commutation relation is . Consequently, for in volume ,
Equivalently, the averaged phase obeys . This number-phase conjugacy means that a state of sharp has no sharp phase, whereas a phase-selected state exhibiting spontaneous symmetry breaking must superpose different number sectors. Such sectors become effectively degenerate in the thermodynamic limit.