Use metric and the hypercharge convention . Then the Higgs doublet has and transforms under electroweak gauge invariance as
The covariant derivative sign consistent with the requested expression is
A convention that instead calls the doublet hypercharge one puts in the charge generator and derivative; the physical coupling is the same. Here and the matrix-valued connection transforms as , making transform like .
In unitary gauge, the upper component of the derivative comes from the off-diagonal Pauli matrices:
The lower component is
Writing , , inversion of the neutral rotation gives and . Since , the coefficient of the photon vanishes, whereas . Thus
The zero photon coupling expresses the neutrality of the surviving radial Higgs boson.
The scalar Lagrangian density is . Adding gives the complete bosonic electroweak Lagrangian density. Its scalar and vector mass terms, after electroweak symmetry breaking, are obtained directly as
Indeed, the shifted quartic Higgs potential normalization gives . Comparing with a canonically normalized real scalar mass term, a complex vector mass term and a real vector mass term yields
The extra factor one half in this paper's Higgs potential is why is , rather than in another common convention. The tree-level electroweak gauge-boson masses give : measure the two vector masses and take their ratio. Beyond tree level this extraction requires a specified renormalization convention and radiative corrections.
Expanding the vector terms gives the cubic and quartic Higgs couplings to electroweak gauge bosons:
The four elementary Feynman diagrams and their all-incoming Feynman rules are shown below. Differentiating with respect to two identical fields supplies a factor two; differentiating with respect to two identical Higgs fields supplies another factor two in the quartic rules.
Figure 1.
Tree-level Higgs vertices with charged and neutral electroweak gauge bosons
. Details.
There are no elementary , , or vertices in this tree-level Lagrangian density. Loop-induced photon interactions are a different order. The scalar self-interactions, if included, have rules and .
The prime LEP2 search used the Higgs boson coupling to Z bosons through Higgsstrahlung, , shown in the first panel of the process figure in Question 3. This identifies an associated-production interaction, rather than an on-shell decay of a single into a heavier Higgs. The channel's historical role is documented in the LEP2 Higgs-search account.
For the free charged W boson, take , with the conjugate field carrying . In the action, multiplying the two field strengths gives . Therefore
To invert it, separate the transverse and longitudinal projectors , . The operator is , so
Since the quadratic action kernel is , its Proca propagator is
For all momentum components small relative to , the low-momentum limit is , with corrections of relative order or . This local limit leads to the Fermi interaction, with for the charged-current normalization used here.
The last panel of the preceding process figure shows deep inelastic scattering through a virtual photon. The blob represents the electromagnetic hadronic tensor response, with all final hadronic states included. With charges factored into and the hadronic current as in the question, a suitable scattering amplitude, up to an irrelevant overall phase, is
The electron fermion spin sum, before averaging the two initial spin states, gives the following normalization of the leptonic tensor:
The initial electron spin average is a separate factor . Equivalently one can absorb it into a tensor , but the prefactor in the requested formula uses the unaveraged trace . The massless Dirac equations imply , the relevant Ward identity.
In the target rest frame the incident flux is . This remains valid for a massive target because the electron is massless: the general flux reduces to that expression. The outgoing electron contributes , and the inclusive final-state sum is . Including the electron spin average therefore gives
The implicit hadron spin average in must not be inserted a second time.
For an unpolarized target, Lorentz invariance permits tensor structures formed from , and the metric. Hermiticity relates the two index orders. The electromagnetic response is parity even, excluding the pseudotensor . A possible ordinary antisymmetric term is excluded by current conservation. The symmetric part initially has four structures, , , and . Imposing both current-conservation conditions leaves the transverse decomposition of an unpolarized hadronic tensor:
For example, contracting into the first structure gives in the printed parametrization, and contracting into either parenthesis gives or . Since the two independent deep-inelastic structure functions are not generally linked by symmetry, transversality requires
There are only two invariant variables once is fixed; they may be chosen as and Bjorken x .
Now make the leading massless collinear parton approximation. In the hard parton calculation, use a lightlike collinear reference for , neglecting target-mass effects of relative order as well as quark masses. Literally combining a massive with an exactly massless constituent momentum would be inconsistent. The exact rest-frame flux derived above does not require this approximation; it is the following partonic response that does.
Let and . Strip the quark charge out of the current, since its square is already the factor in the parton convolution. Averaging the initial quark spin and summing the final spin gives the spin-averaged electromagnetic parton tensor
The spatial momentum delta fixes . The remaining one-particle Lorentz-invariant phase space, together with in the definition, supplies
Since and , the full parton response is
Terms with a free index vanish when contracted with the conserved leptonic tensor. Thus the part of contributing to the cross-section is
where denotes equality in that contraction, rather than an equality of the full tensors. The omitted terms are necessary for the full hadronic tensor to be transverse; the wording about contributing terms in the PDF is important here.
To prove the delta identity with the correct Jacobian, set . On physical support and . Factoring gives the positive-energy on-shell delta function identity
This is restricted to the positive-energy branch; the other root must not be included. Using the spatial momentum constraint and in the leading hard approximation,
The Dirac delta function change of variable therefore gives the parton on-shell delta identity
Here . This is the actual printed identity: the converted TeX's final is a transcription error. If target mass is formally retained in the delta argument, it becomes , so the stated simple root and Jacobian no longer apply.
Let . The parton integral collapses at , giving
The transverse decomposition of an unpolarized hadronic tensor, in the same contraction, is . Comparing the two independent structures yields
This derives the Callan-Gross relation from the spin-one-half trace and on-shell constraint. Antiquarks give the same symmetric response and therefore the sum . The result applies at leading order in the massless parton model; target masses, intrinsic transverse momentum and quantum chromodynamics radiative effects can generate a nonzero longitudinal deep-inelastic structure function and modify the relation.
Use units with . For the flat FRW metric, the Friedmann equation is , where is the Hubble parameter. The cosmological continuity equation for a separately conserved component with constant equation of state gives . Consequently radiation in cosmology scales as , pressureless matter as , and cosmological constant energy is constant. With , define the present critical density and cosmological density parameters by
The Hubble constant measures the expansion rate today. Here includes photons and relativistic neutrinos, includes baryons and cold dark matter, and measures the vacuum contribution. Spatial flatness implies . Thus
Since conformal time satisfies , we have . Multiplication by proves
For an exam-level estimate, with , , , and the specified radiation in cosmology gives . These are rounded illustrative flat-universe values; precision cosmological density parameters depend on the fitted model. For comparison, the base flat-model fit in Planck 2018 cosmological parameters gives and .
Before electron-positron annihilation in cosmology, photons contribute two helicity states; electrons and positrons contribute two spin states each. Each of the three light neutrino flavours contributes one active neutrino helicity and one antineutrino helicity. At a common temperature the effective number of relativistic energy degrees of freedom is therefore
Using and in the scaling formula alone gives . Including the explicit expansion coefficient from (ii), but setting the unknown rate coefficient to one, gives . Thus the warranted conclusion is a freeze-out temperature of order , above the electron mass. The omitted weak-rate coefficient prevents a more precise prediction from this estimate.
Neutrino decoupling occurs before most electron-positron pairs annihilate. Afterwards neutrinos redshift freely, , while the photons receive the pair entropy. For the still-coupled photon-pair gas, cosmological entropy conservation gives . Its entropy degrees of freedom drop from to . Comparing this with the freely cooling neutrinos gives
After annihilation, photon and neutrino temperatures differ. To write the total energy density as , the neutrino contribution must include that temperature ratio:
This is the paper's post-annihilation . Merely deleting the electron term while keeping all species at the same temperature would be incorrect. For comparison the entropy count, normalized to , is . These results assume instantaneous neutrino decoupling and relativistic neutrinos; the two counts represent different thermal moments.
A larger baryon-to-photon ratio favours bound nuclei at a fixed temperature through the equilibrium factor . In particular it helps deuterium survive photodissociation sooner: there are fewer energetic photons per baryon, and nuclear reaction rates per baryon also rise. A schematic deuterium bottleneck condition is , suppressing slowly varying powers of temperature. It gives
Thus higher permits burning at a higher temperature. During radiation domination that means earlier cosmic time, , leaving less time for free-neutron decay after freeze-out. More neutrons enter helium, so the final helium-4 mass fraction increases, ordinarily rather weakly. This is the baryon-density effect on primordial helium.
The equilibrium helium factor indicates the direction of the change but is not a prediction that the final helium abundance grows without bound as . Once almost all surviving neutrons are captured, the final primordial helium mass fraction is limited by their supply, as the shared neutron budget shows.
Let the incoming projectile momentum be . The stationary target has four-momentum , so the total incoming norm is
Here the relativistic energy-momentum relation eliminated . Write for the total energy in the centre-of-momentum frame; then . If , the relativistic collision mass threshold gives . Squaring and rearranging with yields the fixed-target production threshold
The actual incident total energy also obeys . Thus a negative algebraic reaction bound would not allow a negative-energy projectile.
For a photon, and , where is the Planck constant. The necessary bound becomes
In the usual massive multi-product channel with , conservation alone permits the threshold configuration in which all products are at rest relative to one another in the centre-of-momentum frame. Boosting that configuration supplies the required laboratory momentum. Hence the photon fixed-target production threshold is
For a multi-product channel with , there is no positive mass threshold: the lower limit of allowed positive frequencies is zero. The compact expression for that lower limit is ; it need not correspond to a zero-frequency incident photon.
For completeness, if the only product is one particle of mass , its invariant mass must match exactly. A positive incident frequency is possible only when , and is then fixed at ; frequencies above that value do not produce the same single particle while conserving four-momentum. If a multi-product channel includes massless particles, an all-products-at-rest configuration is impossible for those particles with nonzero energy, so the nominal massive threshold may be only an infimum. These qualifications distinguish the requested necessary inequalities from unrestricted claims of sufficiency.
Set . The angular integral of the electron-positron annihilation into a muon pair differential cross-section is
Therefore
The printed comparison of with a quantity in has inconsistent units: the high-energy condition means an energy large compared with particle masses, or equivalently an energy-squared large compared with their squared masses.
At leading order, inclusive electron-positron annihilation into hadrons proceeds through , as in the first panel below. The photon couples to each quark with strength ; the corresponding contribution is times the muon-pair rate per colour. Summing over the three orthogonal final colours and active flavours gives the hadronic R ratio
For massless flavours this gives , with charm included , and with bottom as well .
The approximation assumes unpolarized beams and negligible electron mass; active quark masses are small relative to , and heavy flavours below threshold are excluded. Photon exchange dominates, so exchange and photon- interference are neglected; this is appropriate sufficiently below the Z boson scale, not at arbitrary high energy. The coupling must be evaluated consistently in numerator and reference rate. We also neglect higher-order QED radiation. Relating the inclusive partonic calculation to hadrons invokes quark-hadron duality: the energy should be in a perturbative continuum region, away from thresholds and narrow resonances, with power-suppressed nonperturbative effects neglected. An exclusive hadron channel cannot be obtained merely by multiplying the parton rate by the colour count.
Figure 1.
Born hadronic production, real and virtual first-order QCD corrections, and their local counterterms
. Details.
At next order in QCD, the real-emission amplitudes are the two distinct diagrams for , with the gluon emitted from the quark or antiquark. They must be added before squaring, including their interference. Each amplitude is order at the hadronic current vertex and gives a relative order- contribution to the rate.
The virtual order- amplitudes consist of the gluon correction to the photon-quark vertex and the quark and antiquark self-energy/external-state normalization contributions. The figure also shows the corresponding local vertex and field counterterms. In an amputated on-shell calculation the external-leg terms are represented by wave-function factors, rather than counted as extra final states. There is no gluon attachment to an electron, since it carries no colour. Gluon self-energy insertions and additional non-Abelian vertices enter at higher orders here. The rate correction is the Born-virtual interference plus the integrated squared real-emission amplitude, not the square of the one-loop amplitude.
Use dimensional regularization, , to keep ultraviolet and infrared singularities in a common scheme. Ultraviolet divergences in the virtual quark and vertex contributions are removed by consistent wave-function renormalization and local counterterms; the conserved electromagnetic-current identity relates the vertex and field renormalizations. One uses a renormalized QCD coupling ; its running changes this first correction only at the next perturbative order. In the massless on-shell scheme some external self-energy integrals are scaleless and vanish, but that statement combines ultraviolet and infrared poles and must not be used to discard the associated normalization terms inconsistently.
The remaining infrared divergences occur when a gluon is soft, and collinear divergences occur when it is parallel to a massless quark. They appear in both virtual diagrams and the real-emission phase-space integral. For the fully inclusive total rate, unresolved final states are summed and real-virtual infrared cancellation in inclusive QCD removes their poles. A resolved jet rate instead needs an infrared-safe observable and a resolution prescription. An isolated real or virtual correction is not a finite physical inclusive cross-section.
Define the dimensionless constant with the conventional loop factor extracted. Then the requested form is
Fixed numerical and colour factors are contained in ; choosing another extracted prefactor simply redefines that constant. No explicit loop coefficient is required to establish the form.
The Born and virtual processes give two energetic particle jets. Hard, well-separated real radiation gives a three-jet event; unresolved radiation changes jet widths and event-shape distributions, while the combined terms correct the inclusive rate. Resolved three-jet events in electron-positron annihilation provided the direct gluon signature, observed at PETRA in 1979. Their interpretation is energetic quark, antiquark and gluon fragmentation, with approximately planar three-body momentum balance. The primary institutional account is www.desy.de/news/news_search/index_eng.html?openDirectAnchor=1643&printversion=1 .
Use for the neon-22 mass fraction, temporarily keeping it distinct from the earlier metallicity. Let be the baryon density, ignoring small nuclear mass defects. Equal masses of carbon and oxygen give
Carbon-12 and oxygen-16 each have equal proton and neutron numbers, while neon-22 has ten protons and twelve neutrons. The total proton and neutron numbers per baryon are consequently
Hence
The equal carbon/oxygen mass split cancels from this result: any mixture of these two symmetric nuclei has the same electron fraction. Taking the paper's metallicity symbol to mean gives its requested expression.
The literal pre-helium-burning nitrogen interpretation, however, needs a correction. Each initial nitrogen-14 nucleus receives two alpha particles, including eight additional baryons, before becoming neon-22; the intervening beta-plus decay also emits a neutrino. Thus, if the entire original metallicity is nitrogen-14 with mass fraction , conservation of the number of seed nuclei gives
This is neon-22 neutron excess from nitrogen-14. The two expressions are compatible only when their arguments are distinguished: the displayed law uses the final neon mass fraction, not literally the earlier nitrogen mass fraction. Treating those fractions as equal is an extra simplifying approximation, not a consequence of the stated capture chain.
A radioactively powered Type Ia supernova light curve rises to a broad maximum over roughly weeks as energy deposited in expanding ejecta diffuses out, then declines over the following weeks and months. Its power comes predominantly from the nickel-56 decay chain, first nickel to cobalt and then cobalt to iron. Gamma rays and charged decay products deposit heat, which is reprocessed into optical and infrared radiation. At later times, declining cobalt decay power and increasing gamma-ray escape shape the tail. It is not sustained nuclear fusion in the expanding ejecta. The amount of radioactive nickel, photon diffusion time and deposition efficiency all matter, so an uncorrected fixed luminosity is only an idealization.
For the requested two-isotope yield calculation, assume the same total processed iron-group mass, namely as inferred from the zero-neon reference. Treat the final freeze-out ashes as nickel-56 and iron-54, neglecting residual light particles and additional weak neutronization. If is the nickel mass fraction, conservation of electron fraction gives
Since , this reduces to the metallicity dependence of nickel-56 yield
Under the paper's intended identification ,
If instead denotes the earlier nitrogen mass fraction, retaining the actual capture stoichiometry gives and . The same temperature and density do not alone fix a total burned mass; equality of that mass is also implicit in the comparison. The two-isotope assumption is a bulk-ash approximation, not a complete equilibrium network with all free particles identically absent.
For otherwise comparable explosions, approximate the peak luminosity by a quantity proportional to the radioactive nickel mass. Let be the true distance to an extremely low-neon event, and use the solar calibration . Its measured flux is , but the inferred standard-candle distance is
The source is intrinsically brighter than the calibration, so the distance is underestimated by about , conventionally described here as about . Equivalently, , consistent with the supplied rounded factor . Using the literal nitrogen metallicity instead gives about a underestimate. These are conditional composition effects in this simplified model; real Type Ia distance estimation also standardizes light-curve shape and color.
Let be the magnitude of the incident particle's momentum. The relativistic energy-momentum relation gives
The stationary particle contributes rest energy and zero momentum. Conservation of four-momentum therefore gives equal photon energies . A photon has momentum magnitude , so if the two momentum vectors meet at angle ,
Substitution gives the angular relation for two-photon electron-positron annihilation, whose derivation depends only on the stipulated equal rest masses and equal photon energies:
All energies and the angle here are in the laboratory inertial frame.
For perpendicular photon trajectories, and hence . Since with Lorentz factor ,
For the small-speed limit, set and . The angle formula implies
Using therefore gives , so
At zero incident speed the momenta are equal and opposite, so , consistent with the expansion.
Use the free Maxwell Lagrangian in mostly-minus signature. In terms of the spatial electromagnetic four-potential, define and . Thus . Taking the Cartesian components of as coordinates gives the canonical momenta
This sign convention treats here as Cartesian spatial-vector labels; it is not a claim that covariant and contravariant four-vector components coincide.
The temporal momentum vanishes because no occurs. This is the primary momentum constraint of the electromagnetic potential, so one cannot treat all four components as independent unconstrained oscillators. The Legendre transformation for the spatial components gives . After integration by parts, the Hamiltonian is
Surface terms vanish for decaying fields or the corresponding regulated boundary conditions. The total constrained Hamiltonian also contains an arbitrary multiplier of . Preserving under time evolution requires
which is the Gauss law constraint in gauge theory. Both constraints are first-class constraints; they express the gauge invariance , . The electric and magnetic fields are unchanged, so different gauge potentials need not describe different physical states.
One consistent canonical quantization of the electromagnetic field first reduces this redundancy. Choose Coulomb gauge . In the absence of charges, the Gauss law constraint in gauge theory gives ; decay at infinity sets . Residual spatially constant gauge parameters do not change . The remaining variables are the transverse pairs . Their gauge reduction of the Maxwell Hamiltonian is
The two transverse coordinates for each nonzero momentum are the physical degrees of freedom. Treating the constraints as operator identities while retaining unconstrained componentwise commutators would be inconsistent: differentiating would give a nonzero right side even though .
The reduced Dirac bracket, promoted to a canonical commutation relation, instead gives the transverse equal-time commutator:
where
Indeed the spatial transverse projector of a vector field is symmetric, has and . Projecting both entries of the unconstrained canonical bracket onto the transverse subspace therefore produces , equivalently the constrained Dirac bracket. The spatial zero mode is excluded by the decay condition; in a finite-volume regulator it must be treated separately.
Choose two orthonormal transverse photon polarization vectors , so that
The canonical transverse photon field has mode expansion
Differentiate in time to obtain : the annihilation coefficient acquires and the creation coefficient . The oscillator canonical commutation relations are
Substitution into gives times the sum of the two Fourier kernels with phases . The polarization completeness relation and the evenness of make that sum exactly . This derives, rather than presumes, the correspondence between the oscillator and field commutators.
Substitute the mode expansions into . Spatial integration sets paired momenta equal or opposite. The and terms from the electric and magnetic energies cancel because and . The remaining terms are harmonic-oscillator energies. Removing the state-independent zero-point energy by normal ordering gives
The corresponding momentum operator is . These expressions imply and .
Define the Fock vacuum by . Applying creates a photon of energy , momentum , and one of two transverse polarizations. Its mass is zero because . The relativistically normalized state is , with inner product . Smearing these momentum eigenstates gives normalizable wave packets. Repeated commuting bosonic creation operators construct the symmetric multiphoton bosonic Fock space. Circular combinations of the two transverse photon polarization vectors transform with opposite phases under rotations about , giving the two physical helicities .
The same physical states can be obtained while retaining manifest Lorentz covariance through Gupta-Bleuler quantization. Add the Feynman gauge term and quantize four auxiliary oscillator polarizations. Their algebra has an indefinite metric, including a negative-norm temporal excitation. Impose and take the Gupta-Bleuler null-state quotient. Temporal and longitudinal excitations then do not survive as independent physical states. The result agrees with the positive, two-polarization space obtained by Coulomb gauge reduction; covariant gauge fixing is a different implementation of the same physical constraint, not four physical photon states.
Take and the hypercharge generator on the scalar. The two commuting factors of the electroweak interaction have independent invariant gauge kinetic terms and therefore independent coupling constants. Non-Abelian gauge invariance requires the same for all three generators, while the factor has its own ; no symmetry of this product group requires .
A nonzero Higgs doublet can be rotated by to
The fundamental representation acts transitively on normalized complex doublets, so this fixes an internal direction without changing the vacuum norm. A general infinitesimal generator annihilates this vacuum only if
For real parameters this means and . Thus the connected stabilizer subgroup is one-dimensional:
This proves the claimed electroweak symmetry breaking and identifies the unbroken electric charge generator.
The gauge covariant derivative is
Writing the connection as , its local transformation is . Direct substitution gives . Unitarity then proves
so the scalar kinetic term is gauge-invariant.
At the constant vacuum the gauge covariant derivative becomes
Consequently
where and
The factor is the canonical real-vector mass-term normalization; the displayed electroweak doublet gauge-boson mass matrix contains squared masses when the gauge kinetic terms are canonical.
The electric charge generator acts on gauge fields through the Adjoint representation, not through the scalar's two-by-two matrix. With , the brackets and give , , and neutral . Hence the electromagnetic charge matrix of electroweak gauge fields in the requested basis is
Choose positive gauge couplings by the gauge-field sign convention. Set and . The Weinberg angle rotation diagonalizes the neutral block, while obey . The physical electroweak gauge bosons are
The charges are in units of . Thus the tree-level electroweak gauge-boson masses satisfy , and the unbroken photon is massless.
The electron and neutrino form the left-chiral lepton doublet, while the right-chiral electron is a weak singlet. In four-component notation use chiral projectors and package
Here each entry can be obtained by projecting a Dirac field; only the indicated chirality propagates. The hypercharges follow from : gives , and gives . The minimal theory has no right-handed neutrino.
The gauge-invariant lepton kinetic Lagrangian is
If unprojected Dirac spinors are used as notation instead, insert in the first kinetic term and in the second. The inactive components are not additional physical degrees of freedom. Each term is invariant because the gauge covariant derivative transforms in the same gauge group representation as its field.
No bare Dirac mass term is possible: and vanish by opposite adjoint projectors, while a cross term has an uncontracted weak-doublet index and hypercharge . A neutrino Dirac mass would additionally require the absent right-handed field. A Majorana mass term pairs a chiral field with itself; has hypercharge and has , so neither is invariant. These statements concern quadratic masses before electroweak symmetry breaking, not masses involving scalar insertions.
For the Higgs conjugate doublet, put . The given identity exponentiates to for . Therefore
In particular its weak isospin remains while its hypercharge reverses. Since , both and transform in the trivial representation of the full gauge group. They remain a Lorentz spinor and its adjoint; gauge singlet does not mean Lorentz scalar.
Finally the Yukawa interaction
is gauge invariant: the first term has total hypercharge , and its doublet indices are contracted. At the Higgs field vacuum it becomes . Rephase to make the coefficient real and positive and assemble . Then
This explicitly generates the gauge-invariant electron Yukawa mass, without a bare mass in the unbroken theory.
Yes, at the weak-field accuracy of the experiment. The Pound-Rebka experiment measures gravitational redshift, which Nordstrom theory of gravitation predicts even though it does not predict bending of light.
In a static field, a stationary clock has . A photon has constant Killing energy , and an observer at rest has . Its measured frequency is proportional to . Emission at and reception at therefore give
An upward ray has when ordinary units are restored, so . This is the shift tested using the Mössbauer effect. The gravitational redshift follows from the physical clock rates; a claim that straight light paths imply no frequency shift would confuse two different observables.
For neighbouring comoving observers separated by a small physical distance , the recession velocity is , where is the Hubble parameter. During the photon's travel time , the local Doppler effect gives . Integrating along the ray gives the cosmological wavelength-redshift relation:
The same ratio stretches the arrival interval of successive wave crests and of successive emitted pulses: . Each photon loses a factor in energy because . Thus energy arriving through the sphere per unit observer time has one factor from cosmological redshift and one from time dilation:
This is the total power crossing the sphere; division by its area would give the observed flux.
Use metric signature , as required by the sign of the scalar product in this question. For a massive particle, the four-momentum is
For a photon of positive frequency and direction , the Planck constant gives and
A future-pointing timelike four-vector has and in this signature. The ordinary Euclidean Cauchy-Schwarz inequality yields
This is stronger than the requested nonnegative inequality. For an electron and a positron of rest mass , their future-pointing timelike four-momenta have . Thus
which cannot equal the null norm of a single photon. Four-momentum conservation forbids spontaneous photon decay into an electron-positron pair in vacuum. An external body or field able to exchange momentum would be a different system.
For , take the initial electron direction as the longitudinal axis and put . Incoming four-momentum conservation gives
The transverse components must cancel. In the noncollinear case the two transverse directions are opposite, and . Hence the ratio of longitudinal momentum times to energy is
Writing and , the last ratio is . It also equals whenever that denominator is nonzero. Since , the angular relation for two-photon electron-positron annihilation is
The positive root follows from . For noncollinear emission the positive momentum-to-energy ratio ensures , and ensures the stated denominator is positive.
The printed quotient needs a qualification for exactly collinear photons. The allowed configuration , has positive frequencies
which obey both conservation equations, but the printed left side is . Thus the quotient holds for noncollinear angles, or as its appropriate noncollinear limit. The undivided identity
remains true in the collinear case, where both sides vanish. The limit similarly requires care because the initial direction is then undefined and the photons are antiparallel.
For , the Lorentz transformation with coincident origins is
For two simultaneous events in , , so . Distinct spatial positions therefore generally give different times in the boosted frame: this is relativity of simultaneity.
Choose the emission events at and . After emission, the photon world lines are and . Applying the Lorentz transformation to either gives
Thus the two photons move at speed in on parallel lines whose intercepts differ by . Measuring their positions at the same after both emissions gives the photon separation under a collinear Lorentz boost:
This separation is constant. It is not the contracted distance between the stationary sources: the two emission events are not simultaneous in , and one photon has already moved when the other is emitted.
Take the muon mass to be , and use the quantum electrodynamics convention with . Let be the incoming muon and antimuon momenta and the outgoing photon momenta, so . External particles are on shell: and . The two tree-level Feynman diagrams are the two orders in which the photon legs attach to the muon line. There is no three-photon QED vertex, and therefore no single-photon annihilation diagram into two photons at this order.
The QED Feynman rules needed here are the vertex , the Dirac propagator
an incoming muon spinor , an incoming antimuon adjoint , and an outgoing photon polarization . At a vertex enforce four-momentum conservation. Spinor products are ordered along the fermion line; exchanging the external photons introduces no relative minus sign. Define and .
With the convention that a diagram contributes , the two muon-antimuon annihilation amplitudes are
Their denominators are respectively and , where , . A different consistent overall amplitude-phase convention has no physical effect.
A physical photon polarization vector obeys , and represents an equivalence class . For a real null momentum, adding preserves transversality. One can additionally choose transverse spatial vectors with and ; there are two independent physical polarizations. The equivalence class removes the unphysical longitudinal direction, rather than imposing four independent physical polarization states.
The invariance of the total amplitude is a two-photon fermion Ward identity. Replace by and put , . The external Dirac equations give
Away from propagator poles, ; the identity extends with the common Feynman prescription. Therefore
The two terms in the bracket then give and , which cancel. Exchanging photon labels proves the second Ward identity. Thus the sum is unchanged under for either photon. Neither diagram is generally gauge-invariant separately. Physically, longitudinal pure-gauge polarization does not couple to the observable scattering amplitude; only the two transverse photon degrees of freedom contribute.
For Compton scattering write the incoming momenta as and outgoing momenta as , with . The outgoing muon contributes , the incoming photon contributes without conjugation, and the outgoing photon contributes . The two tree-level Compton amplitudes are
These are the lower two diagrams. Their intermediate muon momenta are and , with denominators and . The first attaches the incoming photon before the outgoing photon along fermion flow; the second reverses that attachment order. Both contribute at order in the amplitude.
Compton scattering has one incoming and one outgoing muon and one photon on each side; annihilation has an incoming particle-antiparticle pair and two outgoing photons. Accordingly the external spinors/polarizations and physical Mandelstam channels differ, although both arise from the same two-vertex QED matrix element. Crossing symmetry relates them by continuing and one outgoing photon momentum , with the corresponding external wavefunction replacements. The annihilation channel becomes the Compton channel and the other channel becomes its channel. Identical final photons require a factor in an annihilation phase-space integral over an otherwise double-counted full final-state region; there is no analogous final-state identical-particle factor for the muon-photon Compton final state. Gauge cancellation holds for the summed Compton amplitude as well.
At weak freeze-out, photons, electrons, positrons and all four neutrino flavors are relativistic and approximately at the same temperature. The effective number of relativistic energy degrees of freedom changes from
The expansion rate at fixed temperature is larger by . Equating the supplied weak interaction time with the supplied age gives when is measured in MeV. Therefore
Earlier cosmological weak freeze-out at a higher temperature leaves more neutrons. With negligible chemical potentials, the neutron-to-proton ratio in equilibrium is , where . If almost all surviving neutrons enter helium-4, the primordial helium mass fraction before neutron decay is . Literal use of the given rate normalizations yields
Equivalently, the leading response is . This is a roughly one-percentage-point absolute increase in the helium fraction, rather than a one-percent relative increase.
The deuterium bottleneck delays nuclear burning, allowing free-neutron decay after freeze-out. If its end temperature is , and is the neutron mean life, a sharper instantaneous-freeze-out estimate conserves total baryon number and gives
This formula evolves the neutron fraction, not just the neutron-to-proton ratio, because each neutron decay also creates a proton. After electron annihilation, let . The radiation counts relevant to the age at fixed are
Consequently . Less time is available for neutron decay, adding to the helium increase. As an explicit illustrative completion, and give an increase of approximately in this toy model. The precise helium fraction requires the nuclear-burning temperature, baryon abundance and properly normalized weak rates; the question supplies only approximate time laws. In particular, the large no-decay fractions in the table must not be interpreted as precise predictions for the observed primordial abundance. The robust effect is extra relativistic energy raises the primordial helium fraction, with an absolute change of order for one thermally populated flavor.
Before electron-positron annihilation in cosmology, the pair has two spin states, just as photons do, and the fermionic number integral gives at equal temperature. The factor follows by expanding into an alternating exponential series: its integral is of the bosonic one.
After neutrino decoupling, cosmological entropy conservation in the photon-electron plasma changes its relativistic entropy count from to . The decoupled neutrinos do not share this heating. Hence
These counts include both the new neutrino and its antineutrino; another factor of two would double count them. This is the number density of a relativistic neutrino relative to photons, evaluated after photon heating.
They are nonrelativistic today, so the relic-neutrino energy density is dominated by rest mass:
The number follows from the supplied critical density, without a Hubble-unit convention. It is conditional on the thermal history stated above; a sterile, colder or nonthermally produced state need not have this abundance.
Use four-momentum with components , suppressing the identically zero third spatial component. The photon in the primed frame has
Its energy is and its spatial momentum has magnitude . Apply the same Lorentz transformation as for the spacetime coordinates. With ,
The time component gives the relativistic Doppler effect
The aberration of light follows by dividing spatial components by :
In particular
where the tangent expression is understood only when its denominators exist. The sine and cosine equations determine the correct quadrant and also cover directions where the tangent/secant expression is undefined.
For the photon-number half-cone under relativistic aberration, the forward half of the primed emission angles is . The aberration of light is monotone on this interval, and its endpoints have . Thus exactly half of a uniform angular photon distribution lies within the lab-frame cone
As , , so the cone becomes narrow. Here “half” counts emitted photons or ray directions; it is not a claim that half of the observed energy or power lies there, since the relativistic Doppler effect changes the photon energies with angle.