Let be the observation time and normalize temporarily. In pure radiation domination, and . With , the proper speed is . Put in the preceding integral. Since ,
The small- limit is , the radiation-era particle horizon. For , the ratio is approximately , retaining the distance accumulated while the particle was faster.
There is a normalization qualification: in arbitrary fixed comoving coordinates the distance is , . The expression just derived is also the physical distance at observation. Thus it equals a comoving distance only when is used, as in the preceding part. To express it in today's convention , multiply by . This is the accumulated free-streaming distance in a radiation-dominated universe.
Write , where here is the dimensionless present Hubble constant. The supplied equality redshift gives , and . For the requested dimensionless ratio is
The Hubble rate in this formula is the radiation-era extrapolation used in deriving it. A unique numerical ratio cannot be chosen without .
The printed CMB temperature contains a factor-of-ten error. Its means , whereas the cosmic microwave background temperature in energy units is about , corresponding to . The temperature is supported by NASA's CMB measurements. Using the printed value gives ; using the corrected value gives . For the illustrative choice , so , these give respectively and , and distance-to-Hubble-radius ratios about and . This benchmark is an assumption for the estimate, not an extra parameter supplied by the paper.
For the present-day comoving length, use , the radiation contribution extrapolated to equality. Restoring for the conversion and using gives
For the same benchmark, this is about using the printed temperature and using the corrected temperature, in the prescribed representative-momentum radiation-era model.
At equality matter is no longer negligible, so these are transition-era estimates. The actual total is ; inserting it in the simple normalization would lower the length by , but would not constitute an exact integration through equality. An exact matter-plus-radiation treatment instead replaces the radiation integral by
with in the assumed model. This makes the order-one equality correction explicit. Real neutrino physical momenta in an FRW universe are distributed and their temperature need not equal the photon temperature; the calculation above follows the specified idealization.
Chemical equilibrium for implies , because equilibrium photons have zero chemical potential. Dividing the three nonrelativistic Maxwell-Boltzmann number densities therefore gives
The Hydrogen binding energy is in natural units. For ground-state hydrogen, with hyperfine splittings unresolved, and , so the degeneracy ratio is one. Equivalently one can omit nuclear-spin degeneracy consistently from both the proton and atom. Excited hydrogen levels are exponentially suppressed at recombination temperatures. Also , so its effect in the prefactor is negligible. Thus
The sign of the exponential follows from the smaller rest mass of the bound atom: cooling favours neutral hydrogen once translational entropy no longer compensates the binding energy.
There are about photons per baryon. Even when the typical photon energy is below the Hydrogen binding energy, the high-energy tail can provide abundant ionizing photons. The nonrelativistic electron's translational phase space also favours the ionized state. Quantitatively, the Saha equation contains both suppressing factors and . Recombination needs their tiny product to be overcome by , so must be several tens, not of order one.
For an illustrative , the supplied baryon-to-photon relation gives . With , direct evaluation gives
Thus the equilibrium ionization fraction reaches a few per cent just below , while at it is essentially unity. The exact temperature depends weakly on the baryon abundance and on the fraction used to define cosmological recombination. This is small baryon abundance delays hydrogen recombination. Recombination, photon decoupling and residual electron freeze-out are related but distinct: the last two involve rates and cannot be determined by chemical equilibrium alone.
Figure 1.
Hydrogen-only Saha ionization fraction during cooling, with the three-per-cent crossing near 0.28 electronvolts for baryon-to-photon ratio 5.36 times ten to the minus ten
. Details.
Use the flat matter-only Einstein-de Sitter approximation for the distance-redshift relation, neglecting radiation corrections at cosmological recombination. Let be the cosmological recombination redshift. Adiabatic photon cooling gives . The Hubble rate is , so the comoving radial distance to last scattering is
The angular diameter distance is . A proper Hubble radius therefore subtends the small angle
This is the angular Hubble-radius scale in an Einstein-de Sitter universe; the present Hubble constant cancels.
Taking and the literal printed gives and radians, or degrees. As noted above, that present CMB energy is too large by ten. With the corrected , and
which gives the familiar order-one-degree scale within the assumed cosmology. Using to mark a few-per-cent ionization fraction changes this only modestly. These numbers refer to the Hubble-radius scale, not its diameter. In a matter-only universe the particle-horizon radius is and would give twice the angle; the acoustic sound horizon is a different length again.
Follow successive photons from the same comoving source. Their comoving radial distance is fixed, so
It follows that . Taking the logarithmic derivative of , with both endpoints allowed to vary, gives
Therefore the observer-time redshift drift is
Holding the emission time fixed would omit the second term and would not compare successive observations of the same source.
The Lyman-alpha forest supplies many relatively narrow absorption features along each bright distant quasar sightline. These arise in intervening intergalactic hydrogen rather than in the quasar's rapidly varying emission region. A repeat high-resolution spectrum can be fitted against the same absorption template, and the information from many lines and many sightlines can be combined to estimate a common spectroscopic velocity drift. Diffuse intergalactic absorbers also generally have smaller peculiar accelerations than gas close to galactic nuclei, although their peculiar accelerations and changing line profiles still require control.
The preceding calculation requires a relative wavelength displacement over a decade. This is much smaller than one instrumental resolution element. Accurate line centroids can nevertheless be measured to a fraction of a resolution element when the signal-to-noise ratio and template information are sufficient. The real obstacles are long-term wavelength calibration, instrumental drift, sufficient photon counts and corrections for observer motion, along with astrophysical variability. Statistical averaging reduces independent errors; a common calibration error remains common to all lines. The Sandage-Loeb test therefore needs large collecting area, stable high-resolution spectroscopy and a long time baseline. The original absorption-forest strategy is described in Loeb's 1998 proposal.
The measurement is feasible in principle but demands exceptional long-term stability. It directly probes the change of redshift with observer time, giving rather than a distance inferred from a standard candle. Measuring its sign and redshift dependence would distinguish the expansion histories in part (ii).
In the nonrelativistic dilute regime, and the Fermi-Dirac distribution reduces to the Maxwell-Boltzmann distribution. Hence
Differentiating the Gaussian integral with respect to its coefficient gives . Therefore
The degeneracy factor here is the one in the supplied integral, namely one. Substituting , and dividing by the supplied photon density gives
At this is about . The relic is already nonrelativistic at decoupling and becomes still colder as its momenta redshift, making it a possible cold dark matter component if it is stable and interacts sufficiently weakly with light.
For orientation, write . Ignoring subsequent entropy transfer, its density relative to baryons would be . With the cosmological baryon-to-photon ratio of order , this is of order four, demonstrating the right cosmological scale. The measured dark-to-baryonic density ratio is likewise of order five; an observational reference is arxiv.org/abs/1807.06209 . This is a candidate abundance argument, not an exact relic-density calculation: photon heating after decoupling changes , and stability and interaction properties were not specified. The supplied mass and freeze-out parameter alone therefore do not establish a precise fit.
Statistical temperature is defined by , with entropy . Maximizing total entropy when two systems exchange energy makes their derivatives equal, explaining why equal temperature characterizes thermal equilibrium and why a thermometer can measure another system.
For a dilute monatomic ideal gas, Gaussian integration of momenta gives the classical partition function , with . Differentiating its logarithm gives
At fixed volume, gas pressure is proportional to absolute temperature; at fixed pressure its volume is proportional to temperature. A low-density gas thermometer therefore supplies an absolute calibration independent of the gas species in the ideal limit. A liquid-in-glass column responds to the difference between liquid and glass thermal expansion, which need not be exactly linear. Calibration against gas temperatures and correction for expansion nonlinearities improve a simple two-point column scale; an ideal-gas law is not a law of the liquid itself.
For blackbody radiation, the electromagnetic mode density is per volume and frequency interval, including two polarizations. For one photon mode, summing its occupation numbers gives . Differentiation of gives mean energy , so the Planck distribution follows. Converting to wavelength gives spectral radiance
At its maximum, satisfies , whose positive root is . Thus the Wien displacement law is
This calibrates a wavelength-based radiation thermometer and avoids identifying a subjective colour with a universal temperature. A peak per frequency interval has a different numerical location, so the spectral convention must be stated. Real objects require emissivity and atmospheric corrections; fitting a measured spectrum is more informative than choosing its visually brightest colour. Integrating the Planck distribution also gives energy density proportional to and radiative flux proportional to , supplying the complementary Stefan–Boltzmann law calibration.
Normal coordinates at an event have and first metric derivatives, equivalently connection coefficients, zero there. They describe freely falling frames in which nongravitational laws take their special-relativistic form to first order, expressing the Equivalence principle. Curvature and tidal effects cannot generally be removed throughout a neighbourhood.
For a covector, . The Levi-Civita connection is torsion-free, so
is an antisymmetric covariant tensor. Next expand using and . Cancelling the first two metric derivatives leaves
If has constant coordinate components, . Thus implies the metric is independent of and is a Killing vector. Its derivative is antisymmetric, yielding
For an affinely parametrized geodesic with tangent , differentiation gives
The first term vanishes by antisymmetry and the second by the geodesic equation, proving conservation in every coordinate system. A stationary metric requires the Killing vector to be timelike in the region concerned. For particle energy, the tangent should be future timelike for a massive particle, with affine parameter proportional to proper time, or future null with appropriate momentum normalization for a photon; normalize the future timelike Killing vector relative to the chosen stationary observers or at infinity. Then the conserved quantity is proportional to their Killing energy. A spacelike Killing vector instead represents momentum, not stationary time translation.
Let the photon momenta be , with . Four-momentum conservation gives total energy and total momentum for the pion. Its mass shell relation therefore gives
Since , the sine is nonnegative, and taking the positive square root yields
Use metric signature and average over the four initial spin states, summing over final spins and the quark color charge states. The electrons carry no color charge, so their initial color charge average is trivial. A final color charge average would not give the inclusive relativistic cross-section requested.
Photon exchange gives the tree amplitude, up to an irrelevant overall phase,
Massless spin sums give and . Therefore
The color charge multiplicity is , not . Each trace equals . Contracting them, the terms proportional to cancel, leaving . Thus
In the centre-of-momentum frame every energy is . Let be the angle between and . Then
Consequently .
The supplied two-body Lorentz-invariant phase space formula has a factor-of-two error. Deriving the normalization explicitly,
so the massless two-body scattering flux normalization is
For example, integrating the spatial Dirac delta in leaves ; its radial integral supplies the factor . The printed denominator would double the relativistic cross-section and cannot reproduce the requested result with the standard scattering amplitude.
The correctly normalized differential and total results for electron-positron annihilation into a quark pair are
and hence
At energies where photon exchange and the parton description apply, sum over kinematically accessible quark flavors. The produced quarks undergo hadronization, so the leading inclusive hadronic rate is
This is the hadronic R ratio. Perturbative QCD adds a leading relative correction ; thresholds, narrow resonances and, near the Z boson scale, electroweak exchange require additional treatment. The calculation is a photon-exchange, massless result from a tree-level Feynman diagram.
Quark mixing arises because the up-type and down-type quark Yukawa matrices need not be diagonal in the same weak interaction basis. In the Standard Model the three left-handed quark doublets transform as under , whereas and transform as and . With a Higgs doublet and its conjugate , the gauge-invariant Yukawa interaction is
The generation indices are matrix-multiplied. Electroweak symmetry breaking, , produces and .
Each complex fermion mass matrix admits a biunitary diagonalization,
where the diagonal entries are real nonnegative quark masses. Define and , and similarly for right-handed fields. The kinetic terms retain their canonical form because the transformations are unitary matrices. However, the weak charged current becomes
This unitary matrix is the Cabibbo-Kobayashi-Maskawa matrix. Its entries multiply transitions between up-type and down-type mass eigenstates. The minimal Standard Model has no analogous right-handed charged weak current.
Quark mixing does not introduce tree-level flavor-changing neutral currents. Photon, gluon and weak neutral current couplings are proportional to the identity within each fixed-charge quark sector, and . The single Higgs doublet also has diagonal neutral scalar field couplings after the same transformations that diagonalize the masses. At higher loop orders, flavor changes are possible. For example, an amplitude contains . Unitarity of the CKM matrix sets the sum of coefficients to zero, cancelling any mass-independent part. This is the GIM mechanism; mass splittings leave a suppressed, generally nonzero amplitude.
For generations a unitary matrix has real parameters: mixing angles and phases. Rephasing the up-type and down-type quark fields removes phases; a common baryon number phase leaves every matrix entry unchanged. Hence the physical numbers are
Two generations therefore give a real Cabibbo rotation,
with strangeness-changing charged-current transitions suppressed by . Three generations have three mixing angles and one irreducible weak CP phase. This counting assumes nondegenerate masses; degeneracies allow additional basis rotations.
Writing and , a standard exact parametrization is
Complex entries alone do not establish CP violation, because quark quantum field rephasings can change their phases. For nondegenerate quark masses the weak mixing sector conserves CP precisely when a basis makes real. A useful invariant test is the Jarlskog invariant,
A nonzero requires all three mixing angles and a nontrivial phase. If two same-charge quark masses coincide, the additional basis freedom removes the corresponding physical CP effect. The possible QCD theta angle is a separate CP parameter, not part of this weak-mixing count.
The Wolfenstein parametrization displays the hierarchy of quark mixing economically. Put , , and . Expanding the exact matrix gives
The observed pattern is predominantly diagonal, with - mixing largest and -, - mixing successively suppressed. The expansion implies . The truncated matrix must not be treated as an exactly unitary matrix.
Column orthogonality gives
The three complex numbers form a CKM unitarity triangle, with area . Dividing by puts its vertices at , and , where . The barred parameters include higher-order corrections to the Wolfenstein parameters. Comparing independent measurements of its sides and angles tests both quark mixing and the absence of additional flavor dynamics.
Semileptonic decay rates determine magnitudes of CKM entries through factors once hadronic matrix elements are controlled. Neutral kaon and neutral B-meson mixing constrain products of entries through weak box scattering amplitudes. CP asymmetries probe their invariant relative phases, with kaon mixing providing indirect CP violation and decay amplitudes providing direct CP violation. These processes complement tests of the unitarity constraints on rows and columns. The minimal three-generation Standard Model describes weak quark mixing by a unitary matrix with three angles and one physical CP phase; it does not predict the Yukawa couplings or their hierarchy.
Use left-chiral superfields throughout, abbreviating the conjugate singlets by , , and . The printed hypercharge convention is the negative of the usual one, so ; consequently is the down-type and the up-type Higgs doublet. Write for the weak-doublet contraction. Assign baryon number , , and lepton number , ; both Higgs fields have .
The baryon number and lepton number conserving homogeneous cubic superpotential is
Each term has zero hypercharge, is a color and weak singlet, and has . Higgs expectation values give the usual quark and charged-lepton Yukawa interaction masses and, here, Dirac neutrino masses. The complete remaining cubic part is
The first two terms have , the third has , the fourth has , and the last has . Their Hermitian conjugates reverse these signs. Commutativity of chiral superfields and the antisymmetric weak/color contractions give and ; can be taken completely symmetric. All other coupling tensors are unrestricted complex tensors.
To check completeness, a cubic color singlet containing a quark doublet and an antiquark singlet must contain a colorless weak doublet; the allowed hypercharges give , and . Three color-antitriplet singlets can form a singlet with , but hypercharge permits only . Three quark doublets cannot be a weak singlet. With no colored fields, an even number of weak doublets is necessary. Two doublets and a singlet give precisely , , and ; contractions of two identical Higgs superfields vanish. With no doublets the only neutral triple is . Thus is the most general homogeneous cubic superpotential for the printed fields, including their singlet neutrinos.
If “cubic” is intended to mean a polynomial of degree at most three, also add
The term conserves both charges; the other nonconstant terms have respectively . This distinction will matter for the printed claim about R-parity.
For squark-mediated proton decay, choose and with or . The same down-type singlet squark can appear in both vertices; would give by antisymmetry. The first term includes an electron/up-quark/squark vertex, and the second an up-quark/down-quark/squark vertex. Exchanging a squark of mass and expanding its propagator at momenta much smaller than produces the dimension-six effective operator
The left- and right-handed pairs are separately contracted spinor bilinears. This operator converts an up/down quark pair into a positron and an antiquark; the spectator up quark can combine with the antiquark into the neutral pion. Equivalently its hadronic matrix element between a proton and a pion is permitted, so it induces . Having both the baryon number and lepton number violating vertices is what enables this channel.
Since has mass dimension , dimensional analysis gives
The dimensionless includes the hadronic matrix element and two-body phase space; the pion mass changes this factor rather than the leading dimensions. Dimensional grounds alone do not give a precise hadronic coefficient. Using the lifetime supplied in the paper, rather than substituting a different bound, gives and hence
For an illustrative squark this is about when is rounded to . The bound constrains the relevant flavour product and depends on the exchanged mass; separate smallness of each coupling does not follow without an additional assumption.
Define matter parity and R-parity by
Every matter superfield has , whereas and the vector superfields have . For ordinary quarks and antiquarks, is odd and , so . For charged leptons, neutrinos and their antiparticles, is odd and , again giving ; the singlet neutrino fermion obeys the same rule. Gluons, the photon, and have and spin one, hence ; Higgs bosons have and also . Thus every Standard Model particle is R-even, including the corresponding antiparticles. Changing spin by one half within a supermultiplet reverses , so squarks, sleptons, gauginos and Higgsinos are R-odd.
Each conserving cubic term contains two R-odd matter superfields and one even Higgs superfield, so it is even under matter parity. Each term in has an odd number of matter superfields: three for , and one for . All are therefore forbidden. At the component level the two fermion spin factors in a Yukawa interaction multiply to , so the same selection rule follows directly from R-parity. This verifies all cubic baryon/lepton-number violating terms are forbidden while the Yukawa fermion mass terms survive.
The blanket assertion needs a qualification beyond homogeneous cubic terms. The Higgs term is even; and are odd and forbidden. But is even and permits a Majorana neutrino mass despite violating lepton number by two. Likewise the higher-dimensional operators and are even. Consequently R-parity alone does not enforce all-order conservation of baryon number and lepton number, or absolute proton stability; the stated precise exclusion holds for the violating cubic interactions above.
Two physical implications follow from multiplicative conservation of R-parity. Superpartners are produced in even numbers from an initial state consisting only of Standard Model particles, leading to pair production at the lowest threshold and parity-conserving cascades. The lightest supersymmetric particle is stable, since one R-odd particle cannot decay exclusively into R-even particles and no lighter R-odd state is available. A neutral weakly interacting lightest supersymmetric particle can therefore be a dark-matter candidate and produce missing-energy signatures; neutrality and a suitable abundance require further model assumptions.
Write for the cosmological baryon density in this hydrogen-only model, and for the hydrogen ionization fraction. By charge neutrality, , so the Saha ionization equation becomes
The baryon-to-photon ratio is , and the equilibrium photon number density is . At an order-one hydrogen ionization fraction, neglecting factors of order one therefore gives
Replacing inside the slowly varying logarithm by gives
With , and , this is . Solving the preceding implicit approximation instead gives . Both are reasonable estimates of the recombination temperature at the accuracy requested. The small baryon abundance delays hydrogen recombination: even when , the high-energy tail of the abundant photons can still ionize the much rarer hydrogen atoms.
Use the exact scalar-metric normalization specified by the preceding brightness equation:
The temperature source is therefore . Let , so and . The formula just derived becomes
For the last term may be integrated twice by parts:
No field equation beyond the supplied brightness relation has been used for this identity.
For scalar velocity the supplied photon continuity equation gives
The sign follows from division by : with the Fourier streaming term , the velocity projection has the plus term shown here. Combining it with the lower endpoint from the integrations by parts gives the complete endpoint terms in the synchronous Sachs-Wolfe formula:
The local observer bracket is an angular photon monopole plus photon dipole. Removing the local mean temperature and photon dipole, or restricting the result to measured multipoles , permits omitting that bracket. It must be retained for the literal full brightness amplitude. The limit should be taken in the original line-of-sight integral, rather than treating the separate inverse- endpoint terms as independently defined.
The final target formula printed in the PDF does not follow from its preceding equations. With the stated streaming and scalar conventions, the decoupling terms proportional to and have plus signs as derived above, not the printed minus signs. Moreover the integral has no additional outside factor when its bracket is . Equivalently one may retain an outside only if that bracket is doubled to . Omitting the observer photon monopole and photon dipole does not fix these discrepancies.
For a direct counterexample to the integral coefficient, take , constant, , and . A scalar emission velocity with satisfies the stated continuity equation; its projection along this transverse photon direction is zero. Keep so perturbation theory is valid. The original brightness equation or the line-of-sight integral gives
whereas the printed final expression gives . All observer terms vanish in this example, so an observer-term convention cannot remove the contradiction. The boxed corrected identity supplies the requested integration-by-parts result with every boundary contribution and its observable higher-multipole version specified.
Before decoupling, rapid Thomson scattering makes the photon distribution nearly isotropic in the local photon-fluid rest frame. A local blackbody temperature perturbation changes its energy density by . A first-order boost by the fluid velocity adds a temperature photon dipole ; it does not generate a photon quadrupole until second order in that boost. Thus the photon brightness perturbation at instantaneous decoupling is
Higher angular moments are suppressed by the photon mean-free-path to perturbation-length ratio in the tight-coupling approximation. The idealized equilibrium assumption neglects those finite-mean-free-path corrections, polarization effects and finite thickness of the last-scattering surface. It is not an assertion that collisionless photons remain isotropic after decoupling. The distinction between a fluid treatment and the subsequent hierarchy is discussed in the primary synchronous and Newtonian perturbation treatment.
Let and . Multiplication of the synchronous photon brightness equation by its integrating factor gives
Integration from to and division by four yield
For the real-space observation point , the corresponding background ray is . Fourier inversion gives the synchronous Sachs-Wolfe line-of-sight formula
Every source is evaluated at its appropriate point on the ray, rather than at the observation position. Here is photon propagation direction, opposite to the outward observer-to-source sky direction; changing that convention changes the written sign of the Doppler projection consistently.
The first term is the intrinsic photon temperature at last scattering. On wavelengths larger than the sound horizon, it retains primordial adiabatic information; inside that horizon the photon-baryon fluid has acoustic energy density oscillations, producing the acoustic temperature peaks. The second term is the Doppler effect from the fluid's bulk motion at emission. A regular long-wavelength velocity is gradient-suppressed; the Doppler contribution is important near and below the acoustic horizon, with its acoustic phase displaced from that of the energy density oscillation.
The integral is the gravitational energy shift produced by the changing spatial metric tensor along the photon path. In synchronous gauge it includes endpoint gravitational redshifts as well as evolving-potential effects. It must not be identified solely with the Integrated Sachs-Wolfe effect: in Newtonian gauge the same total separates into the ordinary last-scattering Sachs-Wolfe effect, local observer terms, and an integral of time-varying potentials. The ordinary contribution is important on scales outside the sound horizon at decoupling. A late integrated contribution is strongest on large angular scales when dark energy or curvature changes the potentials; evolution around matter-radiation equality also contributes near the first acoustic scales.
The relevant comoving sound scale is , while the projection distance is . Modes project roughly to photon temperature multipole , and the acoustic scale is , with successive peak spacing of order . At much shorter wavelengths Silk damping and the finite last-scattering thickness suppress energy density and velocity anisotropies; the instantaneous-decoupling approximation alone does not model that cutoff. These scale distinctions explain why the three terms cannot be assigned one common range of important wavelengths.
The comoving observer measures , so . Write . The null geodesic condition implies
The time component of the geodesic equation, using , is therefore
Differentiate . The homogeneous expansion terms cancel:
At zeroth order , with . The difference between coordinate velocity and physical unit direction is already first order and multiplies , so it can be discarded in this expression. We obtain the synchronous photon momentum redshift
In the unperturbed universe is constant and physical photon energy redshifts as ; the displayed term is the additional anisotropic first-order redshift.
To check the direction, let . Combining the spatial and temporal geodesic equations cancels their homogeneous Hubble terms and gives
Every remaining connection or explicit metric-derivative term is first order. A local orthonormal spatial frame defines the physical unit vector by . Its derivative adds only first-order terms, so
Consequently direction deflection multiplied by an already first-order temperature anisotropy is second order. The first-order brightness calculation may use a straight unperturbed ray without neglecting the first-order gravitational frequency change.
Set . Free propagation in the homogeneous expanding universe redshifts frequencies by and dilutes physical number density by . Number conservation in corresponding frequency intervals gives
Inserting the initial Planck spectrum, the factor becomes , while its exponent is . Hence
The shape is preserved even without collisions maintaining thermal equilibrium; it follows from redshift of an initially Planckian distribution.
For the total photon number density put . For the energy density include the energy of each photon. Then
where and . Both integrals are finite positive constants. Thus and , with the extra power supplied by photon-energy redshift.
The time-independent Schrödinger equation is . For the hydrogen atom, separate variables as . The spherical-coordinate Laplacian has radial part and angular part . A spherical harmonic obeys . The first displayed term is therefore radial kinetic energy; the second is the attractive Coulomb's law potential energy of electron and proton; the third is the angular kinetic energy, also called the centrifugal potential. Regular single-valued angular states have , with orbital angular momentum squared .
For , direct differentiation gives
Substitution into the Radial Schrodinger equation for the hydrogen atom and equality of the coefficients of , and the constant term give
The regular radial solution selects , rather than the singular branch . At , is locally square integrable but is still inadmissible as a regular Coulomb eigenfunction: its Laplacian has a point-source contribution at the origin. Bound-state decay requires . Thus, with the Bohr radius ,
These are the nodeless states with principal quantum number . Increasing raises the energy towards zero, so emission is from the state labelled to the one labelled . Using the Planck constant and photon energy , the frequency is
Choose the transverse axis so that the photon travels in the plane. Its energy-momentum four-vector is . A Lorentz boost of speed along , with and , gives
Because a photon has zero invariant mass, . Therefore
The first is the relativistic Doppler effect in angular form, and the second is relativistic aberration.