Past exam of the physics A course of the University of Cambridge 2012 Paper 2 Section C C10 Solution 2026-10-20
In a periodic crystal potential, atomic levels broaden into bands of allowed bloch states. Coupling between states of the same symmetry opens avoided crossings, including Bragg-coupled states in the nearly free-electron picture. Bonding and antibonding combinations provide a complementary tight-binding picture. A semiconductor has a filled valence band and an empty conduction band at zero temperature separated by a forbidden energy interval; thermal excitation, light and doping provide mobile electrons and holes. The gap depends on the crystal's periodic potential, bonding and symmetry, not on a classical collision barrier. In a direct gap, the relevant extrema coincide in wavevector.
For the stated parabolic edges, take and . Negligible photon momentum and no phonon make the transition nearly vertical in versus . parabolic-band optical energy sharing divides the excess photon energy in inverse proportion to the effective masses:Thus the initial and final electron energies, relative to the valence-band maximum, areTheir difference is . The selected is about ; either sign gives the same energy in this symmetric approximation.
A shallow donor supplies an electron in a screened impurity potential, so its localized level lies just below the conduction edge. A shallow acceptor binds a hole and has an electron-occupation level just above the valence edge; thermal ionization supplies mobile holes. The level positions are measured relative to the relevant band edge, and deep impurities need not obey this hydrogenic approximation.
For the supplied bound-carrier mass and unit effective ionic charge, dielectric screening and effective mass change the hydrogen binding energy toThis corresponds to and an effective Bohr radius about . The binding is shallow compared with the band gap and typical atomic binding. Trivalent denotes chemical valence, not an unscreened hydrogenic charge of three. An acceptor physically binds a hole; the question's stated is used as its stipulated bound-carrier mass rather than silently replacing it by the separate band-edge .
Original direct-gap vertical transition with mass-dependent energy sharing, and separate schematic shallow donor and acceptor levels
. Details. Past exam of the physics A course of the University of Cambridge 2012 Paper 2 Section C C11 Solution 2026-10-20
With periodic boundary conditions, each state occupies volume and has two spin states. Filling a sphere gives andHere is density of states per volume and per energy; the extensive is . Both spin states are already included.
For divalent magnesium, , givingAt , only electrons within about of the Fermi surface change occupancy. The Sommerfeld heat capacity isEquivalently , with in kelvin, so at room temperature it is about . A temperature was not specified for the estimate; the linear coefficient is the general result.
At sufficiently low temperature, an ordinary nonsuperconducting metal has : electrons dominate at the lowest temperatures, acoustic phonons produce the cubic contribution, and the lattice approaches per mole as temperature exceeds its characteristic Debye scale. Anharmonic expansion can distinguish measured from . In the room-temperature regime, since , so electron excitation is strongly Pauli-limited. The free-electron estimate is only about of the classical lattice scale. Calling it negligible means small relative to the lattice contribution, not identically zero or negligible as . Real band structure and interactions can alter the coefficient.
Original illustrative metal heat-capacity regimes: Sommerfeld linear electrons and Debye phonons, with explicit dimensionless model parameters
. Details. A three-phonon normal process conserves crystal wavevector without a reciprocal-lattice shift, . An Umklapp process instead hasThe crystal can absorb the reciprocal-lattice momentum; after reduction to the first Brillouin zone the phonon drift transporting heat is relaxed. A normal process redistributes phonons while preserving their total crystal momentum, so it is not by itself the same resistive mechanism. energy must also be conserved in either process.
At low temperature, large-wavevector phonons are rare, suppressing Umklapp scattering. Boundary and defect scattering then limit the mean free path; with a nearly constant boundary-limited path, grows as . As temperature increases, heat capacity rises but Umklapp scattering shortens , often producing a electrical conductivity maximum. At sufficiently high temperature a simple anharmonic model has nearly constant and , giving . These are regime estimates, not a universal law for every material or size.
For degenerate carriers with approximately elastic scattering and a common transport relaxation time, and . Using and givesThis is the Wiedemann–Franz law. The same mobile electrons carry charge and heat, but Pauli statistics set the electronic heat capacity and hence the Lorenz number. The relation applies to electronic thermal conductivity, not automatically to total electrical conductivity including phonons. Inelastic electron-phonon scattering can relax energy and charge currents differently; nondegeneracy and strong energy dependence of scattering also limit the simple form.
A meaningful test combines a four-terminal electrical measurement with a steady thermal-gradient measurement on the same sample and temperature range. Contact heat resistance, parasitic heat leaks, phonon conduction and sample geometry must be controlled before interpreting a measured Lorenz ratio as an electronic departure from the law.
For a dilute linear diatomic gas with fixed molecular number, translation contributes molar . Rotational levels are with degeneracy :At rotational excitation is frozen out; at the partition function is proportional to , giving and . Nuclear-spin populations and molecular symmetry modify detailed low-temperature behaviour. The high-temperature result corresponds to two quadratic rotational degrees of freedom; a nonlinear molecule has three and contributes .
For each independent harmonic vibration, write . Its energy and heat capacity areThe contribution is exponentially small at low temperature and approaches per mode at high temperature. zero-point energy does not contribute to . Typically rotations activate before bond stretching, producing diatomic plateaus as temperature increases within the molecular regime; ideal-gas . Dissociation, electronic excitation and nonideal interactions eventually invalidate this simple sequence. Polyatomic gases sum over their distinct vibrational frequencies; no single activation temperature describes all modes.
A black body absorbs all incident radiation; a small opening into an equilibrated opaque cavity approximates it because internal reflections strongly suppress escape without absorption. Equilibrium radiation has zero photon chemical potential. Counting electromagnetic modes and assigning mean occupation gives the spectral energy densityAt low frequency this becomes the Rayleigh-Jeans law, ; using that limit at all frequencies gives the ultraviolet catastrophe. At high frequency the exponential suppresses the spectrum. Quantized mode energy resolves the classical divergence.
Integration gives . An isotropic radiation field sends outward flux through a small aperture, soDifferentiating the wavelength spectrum gives ; the frequency-spectrum maximum is a different transformed peak, not simply . A real surface has emissivity less than one and possibly dependent on wavelength. Cavity temperature uniformity, aperture geometry, calibrated detector response and background subtraction are necessary when testing the spectrum or inferring temperature from it.
temperature changes alter dimensions, resistances, refractive indices and offsets; gradients can generate thermoelectric voltages. Identify the dominant heat paths and the experiment's temperature coefficients before choosing insulation. Reduce convection with an enclosure or, where appropriate, vacuum; reduce conduction through supports and leads with suitable geometry and thermal anchoring; use thermal radiation shields and low-emissivity surfaces to reduce radiative exchange. vacuum alone does not remove heat conduction through wires or thermal radiation.
In first-order thermal isolation, a sample with heat capacity and thermal conductance to its surroundings obeysThermal mass and insulation suppress rapid fluctuations but only delay slow ambient drift: the zero-frequency gain remains one. Active temperature control, a stable reference environment, adequate equilibration time and an appropriate sensor location address long-term stability. Self-heating produces a steady offset ; increasing insulation can worsen that offset and settling time. Check temperature gradients rather than relying on a remote thermometer.
Match materials or use differential/reference measurements to reduce expansion and resistance drift; keep dissimilar-metal junctions isothermal to suppress thermoelectric offsets. Log temperature alongside the signal and deliberately vary environmental temperature to measure residual coupling, using a physically justified correction with uncertainty. Interleave calibrations and allow equilibration after changing power. Feedback must remain stable, and heater/sensor electronics should not introduce electrical interference into the measurement.
Past exam of the physics A course of the University of Cambridge 2013 Paper 2 Section C C10 Solution 2026-10-20
spin normalization in two-dimensional free-electron state counting. Treat the mobile electrons as independent particles in a constant interior potential, with parabolic dispersion , and impose confinement or periodic boundary conditions. electron–electron interactions and the detailed periodic ionic potential are neglected, while Fermi statistics are retained. Each spatial state occupies area in two-dimensional wavevector space. For spin degeneracy ,The printed coefficient is the per-spin density of states. Unpolarized spin-one-half electrons have , doubling it. Actual graphene near its Dirac points has approximately linear dispersion, so its energy-dependent density of states is not this parabolic-model result; the plane geometry alone does not establish the free-electron dispersion.[ref]
Two-Dimensional Gas of Massless Dirac Fermions in Graphene by Konstantin Novoselov and others. Abstract: massless Dirac charge carriers rather than a finite-mass parabolic band
Occupied disk and Fermi energy. At zero temperature fill the lowest states up to a disk of radius . State counting givesThus the physical spin-degenerate result is . If instead counts one spin species, the per-spin convention gives . Each occupied wavevector can contain one electron of each allowed spin, never two in the same complete one-particle state.
Original occupied wavevector disk and Fermi-Dirac occupations for a parabolic two-dimensional electron gas
. Details. Occupation probability and chemical potential of a two-dimensional ideal Fermi gas. A single fermion state permits occupation zero or one. In a grand canonical ensemble their relative weights are and . Normalizing givesThe chemical potential is fixed by the total particle number. Here the total density of states is constant above the band bottom. Integrating the occupation gives , and thereforeThe approach is exponentially close in this ideal two-dimensional constant-density-of-states model; a three-dimensional correction should not be inserted here. A narrow interval of width of order around is thermally smeared.
Past exam of the physics A course of the University of Cambridge 2013 Paper 2 Section D D12 Solution 2026-10-20
The Debye model replaces the crystal by a harmonic elastic continuum with acoustic dispersion . It counts three polarizations and introduces a cutoff so that the total number of vibrational modes is , where is the atom count. Periodic-box counting givesFor an isotropic average speed, . With cutoff frequency fixed by the mode count,This density of states is quadratic because a three-dimensional shell has volume proportional to and the acoustic dispersion is linear. The cutoff is a mode-counting device; it is not a claim that every actual branch stays linear to the zone boundary.
Each phonon mode has mean thermal energy , using Bose-Einstein statistics with zero phonon chemical potential. The fixed harmonic zero-point contribution has zero temperature derivative. With ,and differentiating at fixed volume givesFor , extend the upper limit to infinity. Expanding gives . integration by parts makes the heat-capacity integral , soOnly modes with are appreciably excited; their number scales as , explaining the power law physically. At high temperature every mode contributes , giving the Dulong-Petit limit .
The model assumes the harmonic approximation, a macroscopic three-dimensional solid and acoustic continuum behaviour for the thermally populated modes. Anisotropic sound speeds change the low-temperature coefficient rather than its cubic power. Real optical branches and nonlinear acoustic dispersion limit the full-temperature approximation; electronic excitations can add a linear term in a metal, and anharmonicity produces thermal expansion and distinctions between and . At temperatures below the lowest finite-sample mode, the bulk continuum law also fails. Thus the result is the low-temperature lattice contribution, not a universal total heat capacity for every solid.
Past exam of the physics A course of the University of Cambridge 2014 Paper 1 Section A 5 Solution 2026-10-20
Interpret the quoted r.m.s. as the root-mean-square fluctuation about the mean, namely the standard deviation . Standardization gives . The supplied cumulative Gaussian curve gives , henceThe exact Gaussian value is . A raw r.m.s. temperature of could not coexist with a mean of ; the spread interpretation is required.
Past exam of the physics A course of the University of Cambridge 2014 Paper 1 Section C C10 Solution 2026-10-20
Each electromagnetic normal mode is a quantum harmonic oscillator with . For its canonical partition function and occupation probabilities areThe geometric distribution is normalized and gives thermal mode energy . The zero-point term is not part of the thermally emitted black-body intensity. The equilibrium photon chemical potential is zero because photon number is not conserved.
Counting two transverse polarizations gives modes per volume per frequency interval. Thus the spectral energy density is . In an isotropic radiation field, spectral radiance is . Transforming the spectral measure, , givesHere intensity means radiance per wavelength and solid angle; the hemispheric spectral exitance of a black surface is . The extra Jacobian is essential: the wavelength peak is not found by simply converting the frequency peak using .
At short wavelength the exponential suppresses radiation. At long wavelength the Rayleigh-Jeans limit is ; using classical equipartition at every frequency instead would produce the ultraviolet catastrophe. The wavelength maximum solves , with nonzero root , yielding Wien's displacement law. For the specified temperature,Integrating the hemispheric flux gives the Stefan-Boltzmann law, . The plot uses the specified ideal temperature, rather than substituting a later measured value. The physical black-body description of the cosmic microwave background is tested by comparing the sky spectrum with an absolute reference blackbody and separating instrumental and Galactic contributions.[ref]
The Cosmic Microwave Background Spectrum from the Full COBE/FIRAS Data Set by Dale J. Fixsen and others. abstract; FIRAS comparison with a precise blackbody and limits on spectral residuals
Past exam of the physics A course of the University of Cambridge 2014 Paper 2 Section A 4 Solution 2026-10-20
The mean energy of a two-dimensional Fermi gas follows from its constant density of states for nonrelativistic quadratic dispersion. At zero temperature, states below are filled, so
Past exam of the physics A course of the University of Cambridge 2014 Paper 2 Section C C10 Solution 2026-10-20
The Pauli exclusion principle confines thermally excited conduction electrons to an energy interval of order around the Fermi surface. Their excess energy is therefore proportional to , giving an electronic heat capacity . More precisely, . In a three-dimensional Debye model, acoustic phonons have density of states proportional to ; their thermal energy scales as , givingper mole of atoms. This assumes a normal metal without a lower-temperature superconducting or magnetic anomaly.
For , the lattice approaches the Dulong-Petit value, so , usually dominated by . Each classical vibrational mode contributes through kinetic and potential equipartition. This is a high-temperature solid-state regime, not a claim that the solid persists to arbitrarily high temperature; anharmonicity and can matter.
The body-centred cubic cell has two atoms, so . Counting three acoustic branches gives . By the Debye-temperature definition,This is an effective Debye sound speed; separate longitudinal and transverse speeds are not determined. For isotropic branches, .
Past exam of the physics A course of the University of Cambridge 2015 Paper 2 Section A 4 Solution 2026-10-20
Count two electron spin states in each reciprocal-space cell of volume . Filling a Fermi sphere at zero temperature givesThe free electron model then givesThe energy zero is the bottom of the model's conduction band. The supplied carrier density already incorporates the one-electron-per-atom assumption; it must not be multiplied by another atomic count.
Past exam of the physics A course of the University of Cambridge 2015 Paper 2 Section C C10 Solution 2026-10-20
The free electron model replaces the microscopic ionic potential and interacting electronic motion by independent mobile electrons in a uniform neutralizing background, with approximately parabolic dispersion . Its quantum version fills states according to Fermi-Dirac statistics and the Pauli exclusion principle. Scattering is represented by a momentum relaxation time , rather than derived from the model's ideal free trajectories. This model explains a Fermi energy much larger than room-temperature thermal energy, an electronic heat capacity proportional to temperature at low temperature, and a Drude electrical conductivity. With appropriate scattering assumptions it also yields the Wiedemann-Franz law. It cannot by itself explain band gaps, detailed band anisotropy, strong correlations, or the microscopic temperature dependence of .
The inertial term is mass times the rate of change of mean drift velocity. The electric force is , taking the printed as the signed electron charge, and describes loss of directed momentum to scattering. electrons retain large microscopic velocities; this damping is of their mean directed motion. In a steady DC field,Both charge factors are negative for electrons, so the conductivity is positive. If instead denotes a positive charge magnitude, the force and current equations each require a minus sign and give the same result.
For AC response choose physical fields as real parts of phasors proportional to . Substitution givesThusThe real part decreases from to zero. The imaginary part starts at zero, reaches at , and falls as . The real part falls as at high frequency. With an convention, only the sign of the imaginary part changes. Positive gives positive cycle-averaged dissipation .
Past exam of the physics A course of the University of Cambridge 2015 Paper 2 Section D D12 Solution 2026-10-20
A completely filled valence band carries no net current: its occupied crystal-momentum states have velocities that cancel. Near a valence-band maximum, an almost full band is conveniently described by the few missing electrons, or electron holes. Removing an electron of charge , with , changes the charge relative to the filled band by . This is a quasiparticle description of electronic motion, not a mobile positive ion or a Positron.
For an isotropic parabolic maximum, . Assign the missing-electron state momentum and hole energyIt has positive effective mass . Its velocity equals the velocity of the missing electron state, and its positive-charge current replaces the negative of that state's electronic current. Semiclassical motion is thus . With momentum relaxation time , the low-field mobility is andIf electrons also contribute, : the two species' longitudinal conductivities add.
A Hall bar separates carrier concentration from mobility. Apply current density , magnetic field , and measure transverse electric field . For one isotropic hole population, transverse force balance gives , soFor thickness , the Hall-voltage magnitude is . A longitudinal four-terminal resistance measurement supplies independently. Use ohmic contacts, known conducting thickness, controlled temperature and low enough current to avoid self-heating. Reversing magnetic field removes even-in-field longitudinal offsets from contact misalignment; reversing current also helps reject thermoelectric offsets. These are central controls, rather than merely taking one transverse voltage reading.[ref]
Resistivity and Hall Measurements by National Institute of Standards and Technology. Sample Geometry; Resistivity Measurements; Definitions for Hall Measurements; Hall Measurements and Hall Calculations
The simple inference assumes one carrier type and a known Hall scattering factor. More generally , so measures Hall mobility rather than automatically the drift mobility. With two carrier populations at weak field,Its sign alone need not identify the more numerous carrier. A Hall experiment also cannot determine and separately: their ratio sets mobility. cyclotron resonance supplies an independent mass measurement by sweeping frequency or magnetic field through and detecting resonant absorption. The measured cyclotron effective mass can depend on band anisotropy and need not equal every curvature mass; the isotropic parabolic model identifies them. Its linewidth provides a scattering-time estimate only with a specified damping model.
semiconductor doping generates holes by adding acceptor impurities. In silicon, a substitutional group-III atom such as boron provides one fewer valence electron than silicon. A shallow acceptor level lies slightly above the valence-band edge: accepting a valence electron makes the dopant negatively ionized and leaves a mobile hole in the valence band. The impurity stays fixed in the lattice. charge neutrality and the nondegenerate equilibrium mass-action law giveFor fully ionized, uncompensated acceptors in the extrinsic regime, and ; with fully ionized donor compensation, while holes remain dominant. The Fermi level moves towards the valence band. At low temperature, semiconductor carrier freeze-out suppresses mobile electron holes; at high temperature intrinsic electron-hole generation can dominate. Increasing dopant density also changes scattering, so a conductivity increase alone cannot distinguish increased carrier density from changed mobility. Temperature-dependent Hall and conductivity measurements separate these effects, subject to the carrier and scattering qualifications above.
For a small longitudinal disturbance, let the equilibrium pressure and mass density be , their perturbations be , and the fluid velocity be . Linearizing conservation of mass and the inviscid momentum equation in one dimension givesWhen compression is adiabatic, the equation of state gives with . Differentiating and eliminating yieldsfor an ideal gas with heat-capacity ratio and molar mass . Compression raises temperature as well as density, explaining the factor compared with the isothermal value .
A rightgoing plane sound wave has pressure and particle velocity in phase, , and mean intensity for peak amplitudes. Particle displacement is a quarter-cycle out of phase with particle velocity: particles oscillate locally while the compression pattern transports energy. This continuum linear description requires wavelength much larger than the mean free path, small pressure perturbations and negligible viscous attenuation. Adiabatic propagation requires heat exchange across the compressed region to be slow on the oscillation time; strong thermal coupling would instead favour an isothermal response.
Past exam of the physics A course of the University of Cambridge 2016 Paper 1 Section C C10 Solution 2026-10-20
identical particles have the same intrinsic properties, including mass, charge and spin. Their labels are bookkeeping devices rather than measurable identities. When wave functions overlap, quantum mechanics supplies no observable trajectory that permanently identifies “particle 1” independently of “particle 2”. A many-particle description must therefore treat exchange consistently. The Hamiltonian and physical observables are invariant under relabelling identical particles.
For two particles, the exchange operator obeys . The usual three-dimensional symmetrization postulate selects states symmetric under exchange for bosons and antisymmetric for fermions. In relativistic quantum theory, the Spin-statistics theorem associates integer spin with bosons and half-integer spin with fermions under its locality and positivity assumptions; the connection is not derived merely from in elementary nonrelativistic mechanics. For orthonormal one-particle states and , the two-particle spatial combinations areThe sign concerns the complete state, including spin and other internal variables, not necessarily the spatial factor alone.
The antisymmetric state vanishes if both fermions occupy the same one-particle state: this is the Pauli exclusion principle. For fermions in orthonormal spin orbitals , the normalized Slater determinant supplies the required exchange sign. Bosonic occupation has no corresponding upper limit, and symmetrized products describe many bosons. Fermionic occupation is zero or one per complete one-particle state; two electrons can still occupy the same spatial atomic orbital with opposite spin.
Spin and spatial symmetry are linked. A two-electron spin singlet state is antisymmetric, so its spatial factor must be symmetric. A symmetric triplet state instead requires an antisymmetric spatial factor. Exchange then changes pair correlations and the energies available when interactions depend on particle separation, even without introducing a new classical “exchange force”. It contributes to atomic shell structure, bonding and magnetic behaviour.
Symmetric and antisymmetric two-particle spatial states have different joint-position correlations
. Source. Details. In an occupation-number description, bosonic creation and annihilation operators satisfy , whereas fermionic operators satisfy and anticommute among themselves. The latter imply . This formalism implements the same exchange constraints without assigning permanent particle labels.
For noninteracting particles in thermal equilibrium, the mean occupation of a state of energy isFermi-Dirac statistics produces a filled Fermi sea at zero temperature and degeneracy pressure; Bose-Einstein statistics permits macroscopic Ground state occupation when the density of available states and thermodynamic conditions allow condensation. The different statistics therefore have measurable collective consequences, not just different notation.[ref]
Statistical Physics by David Tong. Chapter 3, §§3.5–3.6: Bose and Fermi distributions, condensation and degenerate Fermi gases
When phase-space occupation is dilute, both distributions reduce to the Maxwell–Boltzmann statistics limit. Likewise, well-separated localized wave packets have negligible overlap and small exchange corrections, so effectively labelled classical trajectories can become a useful approximation. In two spatial dimensions more general exchange statistics are possible; the standard boson/fermion account here concerns ordinary three-dimensional particles and their total states.
Thermal agitation in a resistor produces Johnson-Nyquist noise, even without an applied mean current. In the classical low-frequency regime, its one-sided open-circuit voltage spectrum is and its equivalent short-circuit current spectrum is . In an Effective noise bandwidth ,For a matched load, available thermal noise power is . A resistor and load at the same temperature exchange noise power without a net heat flow.
Cooling reduces the rms amplitude as if Electrical resistance and bandwidth remain fixed. A cryogenic bath or refrigerator, thermal anchoring and controlled heat input can maintain a steady low temperature. Radiation shields, an insulating vacuum, thermally anchored leads and limited measurement dissipation reduce heat leaks and self-heating. Temperature sensing and stable feedback control reduce slow temperature-induced drift; keeping temperature constant does not remove microscopic thermal fluctuations.
At fixed resistance and bandwidth, thermal-noise power scales with temperature and rms amplitude with its square root
. Source. Details. Bandwidth restriction, suitable impedance and a low-noise amplifier complement cooling. Warm leads, contacts and the amplifier can otherwise dominate the observed noise. At fixed mean current, shot noise is not generally reduced merely by cooling, and low-frequency excess noise need not follow the Johnson law. At frequencies with , quantum noise expressions replace the classical approximation.[ref]
Op-amp Noise by Analog Devices. Distinction between resistor thermal noise, amplifier noise and current-noise contributions
The free electron model replaces the detailed periodic potential by a constant background, treating conduction electrons as mobile particles with approximately parabolic dispersion . It is useful to distinguish the classical Drude model from the quantum free electron gas. They share a simple transport picture, but differ fundamentally in occupation statistics.
With a momentum-relaxation time , both lead in a simple isotropic one-band approximation toThis explains approximately Ohmic longitudinal conduction and a carrier-density scale from the Hall effect. The relaxation time is phenomenological: introducing it does not itself predict scattering from defects or phonons. A four-probe resistance measurement separates the sample's longitudinal response from current-contact voltage drops; field and current reversals isolate the transverse signal.
The classical model incorrectly assigns roughly of electronic heat capacity, far too large in a degenerate metal. Fermi-Dirac statistics fixes this: most occupied states cannot change occupation after a small thermal perturbation because nearby low-energy states are already filled. Only a fraction of order near the Fermi energy participates. For ,The quantum model also gives a finite Fermi velocity even at zero temperature and Pauli paramagnetism. Under predominantly elastic scattering, its electronic heat and charge conductivities obey the Wiedemann-Franz law,This is a quantum success; classical equipartition does not give the correct small heat capacity and Lorenz number together.
Its limitations are equally instructive. Without the periodic potential it has no band gaps, so it cannot distinguish a filled-band insulator from a metal or explain semiconductor doping. The simplest single-electron Hall formula cannot explain positive Hall coefficients; band curvature and electron holes, or a multiband transport treatment, are needed. It neglects much Fermi-surface anisotropy and detailed optical interband absorption. Noninteracting electrons alone do not explain ferromagnetism or superconductivity, and lattice thermal behavior needs phonons. The nearly-free electron model, which allows reciprocal-lattice Fourier components of the potential to mix plane waves, provides a controlled first correction near Bragg planes.
Its main success is a simple quantitative baseline for degenerate conduction electrons; its main failure is treating the crystal and interactions as too featureless. A fit of conductivity alone is not a test of the whole model: compare heat capacity, Hall sign, optical response and temperature dependence using independently constrained parameters.







