Use material coordinates and write the placement as . The strain energy density in the printed convention is per unit reference mass. It is convenient to use the conventional first Piola-Kirchhoff stress tensor , so
Assume the undeformed reference state is stress-free. With and infinitesimal strain tensor , material isotropy and material frame indifference give the quadratic expansion
Consequently the Lamé parameters from hyperelastic energy Hessian are
Indeed, differentiating the quadratic expression twice gives
the elastic stiffness tensor of linear elasticity. A prestressed reference state requires the corresponding initial-stress corrections; the displayed formula concerns the natural state.
For a plane elastic wave, , put and . Balance of momentum without body force becomes
This is a material-coordinate equation: the reference density cancels between inertia and nominal stress. If , the first-order system has characteristic speeds and right eigenvectors . Along a characteristic curve with , its differential compatibility relation is
This follows by multiplying the system by the left eigenvector . It does not assert the existence of globally integrable Riemann invariants for an arbitrary three-component constitutive law.
There is a necessary qualification to the finite-amplitude transverse request. Set and , so . The longitudinal momentum equation requires
Thus arbitrary nonuniform pure transverse profiles are possible only if the compatibility condition for pure nonlinear transverse waves holds:
The third component vanishes by the reflection symmetry implied by isotropy and objectivity. The shear equation then closes:
General compressible hyperelastic material assumptions alone do not imply the required compatibility. For a concrete counterexample, take the Saint Venant–Kirchhoff hyperelastic energy
For , this becomes
At , . A varying shear therefore produces a longitudinal force and cannot preserve . Infinitesimal transverse waves do exist, because this coupling is second order, but a general pure finite-amplitude transverse wave does not.
The compatible nonlinear shear energy class is nonempty and can be genuinely nonlinear. Define , , and, for , take
This is objective and isotropic. Near , , so it has the specified Lamé parameters. On the plane deformation above, and . Hence at , while
For positive , the relevant incremental plane moduli are positive. This supplies an explicit stable pure transverse family and, when , amplitude-dependent wave speed.
For any compatible family, let
The equations and give the Riemann invariants
Consider the initially undisturbed half-space . A right-going simple wave has the incoming invariant , so . Denote the prescribed boundary nominal stress by . The physical boundary traction, whose outward normal is , is . Invert the monotone law to obtain . The wave state emitted at boundary time is transported along
Ahead of the leading front the state is zero. Before characteristic crossing, these equations determine the unique emission time for each disturbed point. The displacement itself is also determined, rather than just its derivatives:
Differentiating the implicit emission relation verifies and , so this is the complete pre-shock simple wave solution.
Write . The boundary-generated characteristic curves lose invertibility when
Thus the characteristic crossing in a boundary-generated elastic simple wave criterion is
Here . A smoothly increasing boundary stress therefore steepens into a shock wave only when later states travel faster: . Increasing stress alone is insufficient. For the compatible example with and , , so a nonzero increasing ramp produces finite-time crossing. For all rays are parallel and no such shock forms. This criterion locates the first gradient singularity; subsequent discontinuous evolution additionally requires the jump conditions and an admissibility condition.
For a general vector simple wave, replace the pure-shear line by an integral curve
Substitution gives , with the same emission construction and crossing criterion. Boundary tractions must lie on this one-family curve. Generic finite-amplitude quasi-transverse waves may contain longitudinal displacement; arbitrary vector boundary forcing need not generate a single simple wave.
Use the usual minor and major symmetries of the elastic stiffness tensor, positive density, and strong ellipticity in elasticity. For the plane elastic wave , substitution into momentum balance gives the acoustic tensor problem
The major symmetry makes a real symmetric matrix. Moreover for nonzero under strong ellipticity in elasticity. Hence its three eigenvalues are positive and the three positive wave speeds are real. Symmetry alone proves only reality of : an unstable isotropic tensor with negative shear modulus has negative transverse . The requested reality therefore uses stability as part of the physical elastic-solid assumption.
The elastic slowness surface consists of three sheets, with , satisfying
It is centrosymmetric. Sheets can meet at degenerate polarizations; they need not be spherical or convex in an anisotropic solid. The group velocity is normal to the corresponding smooth sheet: for a sheet tangent , differentiation of gives . The coefficient vector is proportional to the group velocity, so its scalar product with every tangent vanishes.
Fix horizontal slowness and put . Define
The symbol on a tensor index is an index, whereas is a horizontal slowness component. The vertical slowness equation is the vertical slowness sextic of an anisotropic solid
The leading coefficient is , so it is a degree-six polynomial with real coefficients. Nonreal roots occur in conjugate pairs, leaving between zero and six real roots counted with multiplicity. Generically the counts are ; a grazing repeated root can give an odd count of distinct real roots. Geometrically these are the intersections of a vertical line of fixed horizontal slowness with the three sheets.
All four generic counts are actually possible in a stable material. For example, take and orthotropic Voigt stiffnesses
The stiffness matrix is positive definite. For horizontal slowness , the three diagonal acoustic equations are
The choices give respectively six, four, two and zero real vertical roots.
For the general depth-dependent amplitude, substitution of the horizontal harmonic factor yields
For six simple roots , choose nonzero null vectors of the corresponding matrix. The complete solution is
Complex vertical roots give evanescent waves. At defective repeated roots the usual polynomial-in-depth factors multiplying exponentials must be included, or the solution can be defined by a limiting procedure.
To classify the modes, take positive downwards and . The reduced traction for a mode is
Mechanical energy crosses a plane at rate . Averaging the real harmonic fields uses . With velocity amplitude and traction amplitude , the time-averaged vertical acoustic energy flux is
For a real propagating mode, write its physical wavevector as . Differentiate in . The derivatives of cancel by the eigenvalue equation, while . Thus its vertical group velocity and flux are
Thus the elastic mode classification by vertical energy flux is upgoing if , downgoing if . In anisotropy, the sign of vertical phase slowness alone need not classify energy propagation. For evanescent modes, select for decay into a downward half-space and for decay into an upward half-space. Away from grazing and degeneracy, continuation from zero horizontal slowness, with a small radiation damping if needed, separates three outgoing modes on each side. Superpose only the appropriate three to construct the most general upgoing or downgoing field; limiting modes handle exceptional cases.
For a free surface at with solid occupying , let be a unit-amplitude incident upgoing mode. The reflected field consists of the three downgoing propagating or depth-decaying modes:
Frequency and horizontal slowness are common to all modes, by translation invariance of the surface. Zero surface traction imposes the three equations
Hence the free-surface anisotropic reflection amplitudes are
whenever is invertible. This specifies mode conversion as well as reflection. If is singular, a nonzero outgoing homogeneous surface mode exists; these are surface-wave poles, including Rayleigh waves in the isotropic case. At such parameters one must use the appropriate limiting radiation solution and check solvability instead of assuming a unique finite inverse.
Because is arc length, . Thus , where is the unit tangent to the elastic ray. In an isotropic medium this is also the wavefront normal. Consequently is the vector slowness, of magnitude ; locally , with the travel time and the wavevector.
For depth-dependent wave speed , the ray equation gives . The horizontal component of therefore has a fixed direction, and the elastic ray lies in the vertical plane determined by that direction and its initial point. A vertical elastic ray is the limiting case. If is the angle to the vertical, its conserved horizontal slowness gives
At a horizontal interface, matching the tangential wavevector at fixed frequency gives the same invariant on both sides: this is Snell's law.
For radial wave speed , take the cross product of position with slowness. The ray equations give
since the second vector is radial. A nonzero constant is perpendicular to every position on the elastic ray, so the ray lies in a fixed plane through the centre. Radial rays obey the same conclusion with a nonunique plane. The spherical elastic ray invariant is therefore
where is measured from the radial direction. Across a spherical interface the radius is common and tangential slowness is continuous, so this form of Snell's law survives an interface discontinuity.
In a homogeneous sphere a P wave follows the straight chord between the two surface points. If their principal angular separation is , its length is . For constant P wave speed ,
Now put and denote the mantle and core P wave speeds by . Equal incidence and reflection angles put the core-boundary reflection point on the angular bisector. Each mantle leg has length given by . Hence the core-reflected travel time is
The stated domain is essential. At the reflection point the incoming line approaches from the mantle only if . Otherwise it has already crossed the core boundary. The mantle-only direct chord also exists only for , with . In this interval,
so the reflected arrival is later. Its intercept is , whereas the direct intercept is zero. At grazing incidence the branches meet at , and both have slope . A continuation of the homogeneous-sphere direct formula beyond this endpoint is not a mantle-only arrival in the modified model.
The core-transmitted elastic rays consist of three straight legs. Their impact distances in mantle and core are and , respectively. At core entry,
Since , the elastic ray bends towards the normal on entry and away from it on exit. The mantle leg subtends at the centre, and the core chord subtends . Thus the total angular sweep along the transmitted path is . This sweep need not equal the principal separation if it exceeds ; the diagram uses a path with sweep below .
Figure 1.
Direct and core-reflected travel-time branches and refraction through a slower spherical core
. Details.
Use a linear, lossless arterial pressure wave model with an incompressible fluid of mass density , small wall displacement and negligible mean-flow advection compared with the wave speed. Let the parent vessel have equilibrium area and speed . Linearizing mass conservation and axial momentum gives and . With wall compliance , these imply . A stiffer wall therefore has larger wave speed. A downstream travelling pressure wave carries flux , where is the characteristic admittance of an arterial wave; a returning wave has .
Place the reflecting junction at . Treat the daughters as outgoing-wave loads, with combined admittance and no further returning waves. At the junction, pressure continuity and flux conservation give and . Thus the bifurcation reflection of an arterial pressure wave has
A decrease in total area gives if the parent and daughter wave speeds are equal. More generally this requires , an assumption about both area and stiffness. To isolate the effect of ageing, assume all relevant wave speeds increase by the same factor, so their ratios and hence stay fixed. Unchanged geometry alone does not ensure unchanged if the vessels stiffen by different factors.
At a station , put and , the round-trip phase to the reflector. The incident pressure harmonic and its reflection give
For time convention , the two phasors are and . Their maximum times are shifted by and , respectively. Hence the pressure-flow phase lag from one arterial reflection is
Indeed has the argument of . On the branch , this phase lag is positive: the pressure maximum follows the flow maximum. There is no cycle-wrap ambiguity on this branch because .
The age trend need not have the same sign at every station. Differentiating the phase gives
Increasing decreases . At a distal station with , the lag therefore decreases. At a more proximal, ascending-aortic station with , it increases. Thus one sufficient set of assumptions reproducing both trends is
As long as ageing keeps the stations in these ranges, the distal lag falls while the proximal lag rises. The effect is interference between pressure waves that add and flow waves that subtract, not merely the shortening of one travel time. The lag is largest at a round-trip phase of .
This is a conditional explanation, with fixed representative harmonic frequency, fixed reflector location, negligible attenuation, negligible additional reflections and common stiffness scaling. The given stiffness and geometry facts alone do not specify the phase ranges, so they do not force either age trend without these extra assumptions. Here the two stations lie on the incident-plus-reflected segment. A station beyond the sole junction in an ideal outgoing daughter has only a transmitted wave and zero pressure-flow lag in this model. Actual peripheral measurements beyond that junction require returning waves from further junctions or terminal loads; a single-reflector calculation cannot establish their lag. Non-sinusoidal waveforms, distributed viscosity, mean flow and differently evolving reflection coefficients can also shift peak times. These limitations matter when applying the harmonic explanation to a real arterial network.
Choose depth positive downwards and harmonic time dependence . At normal incidence, P waves and the two polarizations of S waves are independent scalar problems: a P wave uses the longitudinal modulus , and an S wave uses the shear modulus . In a uniform layer with wave speed and seismic impedance , write velocity and compressive traction as
At a perfectly bonded interface the velocity and traction are continuous. For incident velocity wave amplitude one from medium 1 into medium 2, these two conditions are and . Thus
Reflection is determined by seismic impedance, not by speed alone. A step to larger seismic impedance reverses the reflected velocity/displacement field waveform; the pressure reflection coefficient has the opposite sign. Its transmitted pressure coefficient is . Equal seismic impedance eliminates the reflection even when speed and wavelength change. At a free surface traction vanishes and velocity reflects with coefficient ; at a rigid surface velocity reflects with coefficient .
The mean elastic-wave energy flux is for positive real . Therefore the reflected and transmitted energy fractions are
A displacement field transmission coefficient greater than one is compatible with conservation of energy; its flux must be weighted by the receiving seismic impedance.
For many layers, use the seismic layer transfer matrix. A layer of thickness has wave phase thickness and
This follows either by eliminating between the two faces or by integrating and . For the complete stack put . With upper and lower half-space impedances , an outgoing lower wave satisfies . Solving this condition gives the input seismic impedance
Here is lower-face velocity divided by upper-face incident velocity, including the propagation wave phase. For lossless layers and real frequency, . This supplies a sensitive check on any spreadsheet or numerical implementation; it is not correct simply to multiply the individual interface transmissions and discard the elastic waves.
The physical reason is repeated wave interference. In one layer between media 0 and 2, let denote the velocity coefficients above and . The first transmitted wave has wave amplitude . Every extra round trip supplies . Summing the geometric series gives
In the time domain the successive arrivals are delayed by , producing reverberation. In the frequency domain the same delayed terms produce resonant maxima and minima. For a layer between identical half-spaces of impedance ,
At the layer transmits all the incident energy: the internally elastic waves cancel the direct reflection. Halfway between these resonances, a large impedance contrast gives strong reflection. For unequal exterior impedances, a quarter-wave layer with transforms its lower load to , again giving zero reflection at its design frequency. This matching is narrow-band.
Periodic alternation produces a periodic seismic multilayer stop band. For a cell of two layers with total thickness , the cell matrix has reciprocal eigenvalues , so
When the absolute value of this expression exceeds one, the infinite periodic medium has no propagating cell mode; a long finite stack has exponentially small transmission. The energy is reflected, not absorbed. Pass bands instead contain oscillatory transmission peaks, becoming more numerous as the stack length increases. Disorder removes the exact cell periodicity but not multiple scattering or frequency-selective interference.
For a concrete reproducible investigation, take , equal one-way travel times in both layer types, exterior impedance , and frequency coordinate . At each layer is a quarter wavelength; one cell has diagonal matrix entries . For cells,
It is about for one cell, for four cells and for eight cells. The infinite-cell stop band is . The accompanying calculation also shows the first transmitted arrivals for a single high-impedance slab: their wave amplitudes are at times . Their sum is one, consistent with unit zero-frequency transmission. These calculations illustrate both the spectrum and the pulse train without assuming access to the course's spreadsheet.
Figure 1.
Original transfer-matrix calculations showing a periodic stack stop band and the transmitted reverberation train of one slab
. Details.
Finally, as for a fixed finite stack, every , so the response approaches that of a direct interface between the exterior half-spaces. Equal exterior impedances give . For wavelengths much longer than a repeating cell, expansion of to first order instead gives an effective medium with averaged mass density and harmonic-mean modulus , where . Its speed is , not generally the arithmetic mean of the layer speeds. Attenuation makes the energy balance an inequality, while for a fixed oblique horizontal slowness the scalar SH calculation uses and . Oblique P-SV waves require coupled displacement field and traction matrices because of mode conversion at a planar elastic interface. Thick evanescent layers require scattering or impedance recursion rather than exponentially ill-conditioned transfer-matrix products.
Let the positive real material parameters depend on but not on time. Define the flux-normalized elastic characteristic amplitudes and logarithmic seismic impedance gradient
Write and . Then , , and direct substitution gives
For example, the first relation uses and ; the second uses . Adding and subtracting now proves
The original PDF has these two first-order equations. The TeX mistakenly combines them into ratios, which must not be used. A seismic impedance gradient couples forward and backward wave amplitudes even when the local wave speed is allowed to vary.
Take the wave speed and introduce characteristic coordinates , . The chain rule gives
The wave equation therefore says . Integrating first with respect to gives , and integrating with respect to gives with twice differentiable . Conversely substitution shows that every such sum solves the wave equation. The two terms are travelling waves of unchanged shape, moving respectively to the left and right at speed .
The zero initial displacement gives , and the initial velocity gives . Hence the D'Alembert formula with initial velocity is
For a classical twice differentiable solution one may take . Differentiation gives and directly. The coordinate calculation also works for any nonzero signed , with physical speed . If the printed constant is allowed to be , the equation instead gives and these initial data give ; the displayed travelling-wave representation requires .
For the wave equation with d'Alembert operator , the wave speed is one. The domain of dependence of is the initial ball . More precisely, two solutions whose Cauchy data agree on a neighbourhood of that ball have the same value at . Thus, if both Cauchy data have support in , finite propagation speed gives
The Strong Huygens principle is sharper in three spatial dimensions: only the initial data on the sphere contribute, including the first spatial derivatives of the initial displacement there. The Kirchhoff formula makes this precise:
In particular, if the Cauchy data have compact support in , then
For , the solution therefore vanishes behind the inward edge as well as outside . The absence of an interior tail is the additional content of the Strong Huygens principle.
For with the observation distance much larger than the scatterer, expand . The far-field pattern in the Born approximation for scalar wave scattering is consequently
This convention includes the factor in ; moving that factor into the outgoing-wave definition would change the pattern's normalization.
The absolute energy flux depends on what physical amplitude represents. For acoustic pressure in a homogeneous fluid of mass density and wave speed , the momentum equation gives the particle-velocity amplitude . The time average of harmonic power and acoustic intensity then give
The radial derivative of the outgoing factor is . Its imaginary current is therefore to leading order. The incident unit-amplitude plane wave has imaginary current . Hence, with ,
The scattered energy flux points along at leading order, and the incident energy flux along . If is a velocity-potential amplitude instead, both leading expressions use the common prefactor in place of . A normalized scalar current uses as the common prefactor. The paper does not specify this amplitude normalization; the ratio in part (c) is independent of that choice.
For ,
The Bromwich inversion formula gives
When , close the contour to the left. The residues at sum to . When , close it to the right, where there are no poles, and the integral vanishes. Hence
Equivalently, in terms of the Heaviside step function. The boundary oscillation travels to the right at wave speed without reflection or dispersion; a point at begins moving after the propagation delay .
For a classical solution take twice differentiable, so that the second derivatives exist. Direct use of the chain rule gives
with the two profile arguments as specified. Thus .
To prove generality, introduce characteristic coordinates , , whose Jacobian determinant is . For the differential operator is
The equation becomes . Integrating once in each variable yields
This is the countertravelling decomposition of the one-dimensional wave equation, with wave speed . Once differentiability alone is not sufficient for a classical second-order equation; the displayed argument uses the required second derivatives.
Write . The inverse coordinate formulas and are valid because . The multivariable chain rule gives
Applying these operators twice and using the symmetry of second derivatives,
Thus the wave equation is equivalent to
For each fixed , the partial derivative has zero derivative with respect to , so it is a function of alone. Taking an antiderivative in gives , where the integration constant may depend on . Hence
Conversely, direct partial differentiation verifies the wave equation for every twice differentiable pair . The two terms describe profiles moving left and right respectively at wave speed along the characteristic lines for the one-dimensional wave equation.
The string speed is . The characteristic impedance is the ratio of the forward-wave transverse force to transverse velocity, . With peak displacement amplitude , the mean power is
Displacement and transverse force are continuous at a massless junction. Since , the displacement amplitudes are and . Taking the incident amplitude real, the light-string motion is
In this standing-and-travelling decomposition of a reflected string wave, the first term travels and the second stands; the decomposition is not a separation into independent incident-power fractions because these fields interfere. The reflected wave has a phase reversal. power coefficients and standing-wave ratio are
For a uniform inserted matching section, unequal exterior impedances require a quarter-wave impedance transformer: and . At equal tension this means middle density and an odd-quarter-wavelength length in that section. Reflections at its two ends then cancel at the design frequency. An arbitrary density or an arbitrary half-wavelength segment cannot perfectly match these unequal exterior strings; the ideal match is frequency-selective.
amplitude scaling along a slowly tapered string instead follows from matching over an adiabatic frequency range. The source fixes frequency, while conserved power and the final characteristic impedance determine amplitude. In the heavy string,
Its wave speed halves. The no-reflection approximation needs small fractional characteristic impedance change over each local wavelength, rather than length alone for a taper containing abrupt features.
Reflection at the fixed edges combines waves with opposite into a transverse standing wave while retaining their common longitudinal propagation factor. The membrane waveguide scalar transverse displacement satisfies the wave equation and vanishes at both edges:
The sine gives no displacement. separation of variables gives
For a propagating branch with ,
Their product is . The phase velocity can exceed the material wave speed; energy transport follows the group velocity.
Here the cutoff sequence is . At only propagates, with for travel toward positive .
The characteristic impedance of a stretched string is , since its wave speed obeys . Put the endpoint at and use displacement complex amplitudes incident and reflected:
At the massless end, the string's transverse force balances the damper's force . Thus , or . This viscous termination of a stretched string has
Half the incident mean power is reflected when , giving two positive solutions:
They are approximately and , in . The smaller coefficient produces no reflected displacement-phase reversal; the larger produces a reversal. Both dissipate the remaining half of the incident power. Choosing the impedance-matched value would instead absorb all of it.
At an ordinary point or a massless join, the string is continuous, so
With no concentrated transverse force or point mass, transverse force balance requires
For the common tension in this problem, the slope is therefore continuous as well. A jump in linear mass density changes wave speed, but introduces no finite inertial force at a zero-length join. A point mass, external support force, or unequal tensions would require modified boundary conditions.
For a fixed transverse normal mode, define its cutoff angular frequency
The longitudinal phase velocity and group velocity, for propagation in , are
Thus , and . The large longitudinal phase velocity reflects the geometry of the transverse standing wave and does not imply faster transport of energy than the membrane wave speed.
The cutoff frequency of a membrane waveguide for mode is
At cutoff and ; the longitudinal phase velocity has no finite value. Below cutoff,
and a bounded field excited at decays as . It is an evanescent wave, rather than a freely propagating mode carrying net time-averaged energy flux down an indefinitely long uniform strip. A finite section can still transmit through coupling of evanescent fields.
Assume a hollow, perfectly conducting rectangular electromagnetic waveguide filled with air approximated by vacuum. Let its wider side be and its narrower side . The longitudinal propagation constant of a mode is
so the waveguide cutoff frequency is
For a mode with transverse electric polarization, one of may vanish, but they cannot both vanish. For a mode with transverse magnetic polarization, both must be positive. A single hollow conducting guide has no transverse electromagnetic mode with zero cutoff.
The lowest cutoff therefore belongs to the mode, varying across the wider side:
Strictly, a traveling mode transporting energy down the guide requires . At exactly , and the axial group velocity vanishes. Below cutoff the field is evanescent. A different dielectric filling would replace by the wave speed in that material.
Comparing with the standard wave equation gives the shallow-water wave speed
Twice differentiating the proposed standing wave multiplies its spatial factors by and , and its temporal factor by . It solves the wave equation precisely when
To obtain the local gravitational potential energy, integrate through a water column of height and unit horizontal area:
The time averages are and . Thus
The constant is retained because the specified zero of gravitational potential is the tank bottom. This is local time-averaged potential energy, not the sum of potential energy and kinetic energy.
The no-normal-flow wall conditions are Neumann boundary conditions. Differentiating the cosine factors at the opposite walls gives
Negative integers give the same cosine modes. The formal case has : it is a uniform change of the mean level, not a finite-frequency oscillation. In a closed tank with fixed water volume even that mean-level change is excluded from the oscillatory disturbance.
Since , the lowest finite frequency is the mode :
It is uniform across the shorter direction, has opposite-sign displacement antinodes at the two ends of the longer direction, and a displacement node midway along it.
Figure 1.
Original mode shapes for a closed rectangular tank and an ideal basin with one open end
. Details.
For the open-ended Bay of Fundy model, approximate the ocean mouth as a displacement node and the closed head as an antinode. The fundamental is a quarter-wave basin resonance, so its wavelength is and
Taking a roughly -hour semidiurnal tide gives . Using the principal lunar period of approximately gives . The idealized estimate is therefore about . The lunar period is half of a roughly -hour -minute lunar day.[ref]
This estimate treats the mouth as an ideal open boundary and replaces the real basin by a uniform depth. The supplied large tidal height motivates resonance; it is not enough by itself to determine damping or an amplification factor in this model.
In the three-dimensional Earth, a network identifies P- and S-wave arrivals and fits source coordinates and origin time using a travel-time model. Time differences constrain path lengths without requiring a common absolute clock zero; calibrated absolute times then fix the origin time. Real inversions trace refracted rays through a layered or heterogeneous velocity model and use many stations, azimuths, and phases, rather than literal circles at fixed wave speed. Residuals and the sensitivity matrix quantify uncertainty and expose poor station geometry or a poor velocity model.
Depth and origin time are often the weakest pair, especially for a shallow event observed by distant surface stations. In the homogeneous example,
If the depth sensitivities are small or nearly alike across the network, a deeper source's longer travel time can be offset by an earlier origin time. In contrast, horizontal displacement often gives opposite-sign residuals on opposite sides of an event and is better constrained by good azimuthal coverage. Nearby stations and depth-sensitive reflected phases can break the earthquake depth–origin-time trade-off; the ranking is not universal for every network or event depth.