Assume independent normally distributed angle errors with known standard deviation . The relevant chi-squared test uses the sum of squared standardized residuals,
For the model through the origin, the predictions and residuals, expressed in milliradians, are
Consequently . There are statistical degrees of freedom. The upper-tail P-value is approximately ; equivalently the value greatly exceeds the critical value . The zero-intercept model is strongly rejected under the stated errors.
For the alternative linear regression, minimize . Setting both partial derivatives to zero gives the normal equations, whose solution is
For these data , , and . This yields
The new predictions are , with residuals . Therefore
The affine model is compatible with the data. Allowing for its additional fitted parameter, the decrease has a chi-squared distribution with one statistical degree of freedom under the nested zero-intercept hypothesis, corresponding to . Thus the model with a fitted intercept provides the better description, rather than merely lowering the residual by adding a parameter.
With the measurement variance treated as known, the coefficient uncertainties are
Hence , about standard deviations above zero. A positive constant systematic error in the angular zero, or an additional nearly constant torque, could account for it. Its presence is evidence against the ideal zero-intercept model; four points alone do not identify the physical cause uniquely. A calibration error in only rescales the inferred gravitational constant and cannot remove this residual pattern.
Using the fitted slope after allowing for this offset would give , with the period and slope errors combined in quadrature. This is conditional on the constant-offset model.
All four angle measurements have the same standard uncertainty, so ordinary least squares minimizes
Differentiation gives
Thus the unique minimum is
The overbars denote sample means over the four observations. Numerically,
so
The fixed have negligible uncertainty. Assuming independent errors in the four , propagation of uncertainty in quadrature gives
Hence
If the period measurement is independent of the angle measurements, including its calibration uncertainty gives
This last uncertainty includes the stated random measurement errors only. Whether the model describes the data must be checked before treating it as a reliable measurement of the gravitational constant.
Rearrange the given torsion balance equilibrium relation as
A useful choice, preserving equal measurement uncertainties on the vertical axis, is
With angle measured in radians, is dimensionless and has units , so has units , as required. The four values, in the order of the original table, are
The corresponding values are , each with standard uncertainty . The uncertainty of is negligible by assumption, making linear regression through the origin appropriate for the proposed model.
The original apparatus has two small masses at distance from the suspension axis. Neglecting the rod's moment of inertia, their total moment of inertia is , consistent with the supplied torsion pendulum period. Treat and as exact because no uncertainties are specified. Rearranging the period relation gives
The torsion constant is a restoring torque per unit angle. In dimensional calculations the radian is dimensionless.
Using first-order propagation of uncertainty, with the quoted period uncertainty interpreted as a standard uncertainty,
Consequently
Identical spin one-half particles are fermions. By fermionic exchange symmetry, the complete spatial-and-spin wavefunction must change sign when the two particle labels are exchanged. Define the normalized antisymmetric spin-one-half singlet state
and the three symmetric spin-one-half triplet states
The Hamiltonian is independent of spin, so these spin functions carry no additional energy.
Both particles can occupy if their spin factor is antisymmetric. The unique ground state wavefunction is
Two equal-spin particles could not share this orbital, by the Pauli exclusion principle.
At the first excited energy, , one orbital is and the other is with or . Define symmetric and antisymmetric normalized spatial functions
For each , all allowed wavefunctions are spanned by
There are orthonormal states, hence first-excited-state degeneracy . In each product, exactly one factor is antisymmetric, ensuring the required total fermionic exchange symmetry.
Put . The two-particle product energy eigenstates are
Because the particles are distinguishable, and are distinct when . Also, the signs of nonzero integers distinguish opposite angular momenta. The quantum degeneracy is therefore the number of ordered integer pairs at each sum of squares.
The first distinct energy levels are . This ordering matters: is the third excited level, while is the fourth excited level.
  • At , only occurs: .
  • At the first excited level, , the pairs are and : .
  • At the fourth excited level, , the pairs are and , with independent signs: .
  • At , the pairs are , contributing four, and , contributing eight: .
These counts concern energy eigenspaces; arbitrary quantum superpositions within each one do not create additional independent states.
Solving the time-independent Schrödinger equation with gives . The periodic boundary condition requires , hence . With the angular integration measure , wavefunction normalization gives
so a convenient orthonormal eigenbasis is
The ground state is nondegenerate. For each , and span a two-dimensional energy eigenspace; real sine and cosine combinations are an equally valid basis. These opposite-circulation eigenstates have angular momentum and .
If instead the wavefunction is normalized with respect to physical arc length , its expression is . The two conventions describe the same probability, since . The remaining parts use .
For a particle in a ring, the arc-length coordinate is . The tangential kinetic energy is
The constraint removes radial motion; the constant potential energy along the ring can be chosen as zero. The tangential momentum operator is , or equivalently the angular momentum operator is . Thus
Its physical domain has periodic boundary conditions, and . These make the Hamiltonian self-adjoint and reflect that and describe the same point. No magnetic flux or additional angle-dependent potential energy is present.
The specified energy requires , so the relevant energy eigenspace has the orthonormal basis
Applying the creation and annihilation operators gives
Thus its matrix in this ordered basis is
Writing , the characteristic polynomial gives . The possible angular momentum eigenvalues are therefore
For completeness, normalized simultaneous energy and angular momentum eigenstates are
Each value occurs once in this energy eigenspace. Equivalently, circular ladder operators of a two-dimensional oscillator give and . With , the difference can only be .
Set . Taking the Hermitian adjoint reverses the order of products, so . Complex conjugation also reverses the sign of , and therefore
Thus is a self-adjoint operator on the usual oscillator states.
Using the coefficients in part (a), products containing two position operators or two momentum operators cancel in the difference. Cross-coordinate operators commute, leaving
Hence
It is the component of orbital angular momentum perpendicular to the plane, with units (equivalently ). The rotational symmetry of the two-dimensional isotropic harmonic oscillator makes this a conserved observable; directly, each term in preserves , so .
The number operator commutators established above imply that is proportional to and to . Their norms determine the magnitudes of the proportionality constants:
Choose the phase of the normalized ground eigenstate once, then define recursively
This removes the otherwise arbitrary relative phases of the eigenstates. The Hermitian adjoint relation then fixes the lowering coefficient with the same positive sign, giving
At , the second expression means the zero vector, ; it does not introduce a physical state .
For either number operator , positivity follows from
Hence an eigenvalue cannot be negative. The commutators
show that , if nonzero, is an eigenstate with eigenvalue . For a normalized eigenstate, .
If were not an integer, successive nonzero lowerings would eventually reach an eigenstate with . Its next lowering would have nonzero norm but a negative eigenvalue, contradicting positivity. The ladder must therefore terminate at , with . Conversely, successive applications of the creation operator never vanish, because
The normalizable bottom state exists explicitly: solving gives . Thus the number operator has exactly the non-negative integer eigenvalues.
Since the two coordinate number operators commute, use the product eigenstates . Their energy eigenvalues are
At fixed , the allowed pairs are . Thus the energy level has quantum degeneracy , and the ground-state energy is .
Use the canonical commutation relations , with cross-coordinate commutators zero. For either coordinate,
Thus . To obtain the required Hamiltonian, the ratio of its position operator and momentum operator coefficients must be preserved:
where the positive root follows from the requested signs. Consequently
The annihilation operators are dimensionless; has units of inverse length and has units of inverse momentum. Operators belonging to different coordinates commute automatically. Writing the number operators as , substitution gives
The constant is the sum of the two zero-point energies of this two-dimensional isotropic harmonic oscillator.
The Debye model approximates a three-dimensional crystal as an elastic continuum supporting quantized normal modes, or phonons. At long wavelengths, the acoustic phonon branches have approximately linear dispersion relations : one longitudinal branch and two transverse branches. Replace their complicated actual spectra by these linear forms, then introduce a cutoff chosen to preserve the total vibrational degrees of freedom for atoms. This is an approximation to the spectrum, not a claim that a real crystal has no non-acoustic branches.
For periodic boundary conditions in volume , each allowed wavevector occupies in the space of wavevectors. Counting a spherical shell for each branch gives the density of states per unit angular frequency
An effective speed of sound can be defined by . In the single-speed Debye model, choose so that
Thus the Debye wavevector, Debye frequency and Debye temperature satisfy
Here has units of seconds when angular frequency is measured in ; its integral is the dimensionless number of normal modes. The spherical cutoff replaces the real Brillouin zone by an equal-count continuum construction.
Each phonon mode is a quantum harmonic oscillator. Since phonon number is not conserved at thermal equilibrium, the chemical potential is zero and its Bose-Einstein distribution gives mean thermal energy . The zero-point energy is independent of temperature in the harmonic, fixed-volume approximation and does not contribute to the heat capacity at constant volume. Excluding that constant term,
Differentiating the first integral at fixed volume avoids losing the temperature-dependent upper limit in the second one. The resulting Debye heat capacity is
For , extend the upper limit to infinity. Expanding and integrating term by term gives . Therefore
This law follows from the three-dimensional density of states and the availability only of low-frequency modes at low temperature. It is a central success of the Debye model.
For , the Bose-Einstein distribution reduces to the classical equipartition theorem: every mode contributes thermal energy . Consequently
the Dulong-Petit law, or per mole of atoms. The simple model omits detailed phonon dispersion relation, distinct optical phonon branches, and anharmonic effects such as thermal expansion. In a metal, the low-temperature total heat capacity additionally contains a term approximately proportional to from electrons, so the lattice term should not be mistaken for the whole measurement.
In a metal, a partially filled energy band or overlapping energy bands supplies electrons with nearby unoccupied states. At thermal equilibrium, oppositely directed group velocities are equally populated and the net electric current vanishes. An applied electric field distorts the occupation distribution, producing a small mean drift velocity. A filled energy band alone has no such low-field intraband response because its velocity contributions cancel over the entire Brillouin zone.
In the Drude model, let be the mobile electron number density, let be the elementary charge, and let be the momentum relaxation time. The mean motion obeys
The steady state is . The current density is opposite to the electron drift velocity:
This gives microscopic Ohm's law, with electrical conductivity in and electrical resistivity in . For a uniform wire of length and cross-sectional area , its electrical resistance is . The dissipated power per volume is , the Joule heating supplied by the external source.
The free electron model with Fermi-Dirac statistics improves the microscopic picture. The Pauli exclusion principle fills states up to the Fermi energy at low temperature. For a spherical, parabolic energy band with two spin states,
Only states near the Fermi surface change their occupation in a weak-field response; the large equilibrium Fermi velocity is not the small drift velocity. The same formula results for this isotropic parabolic model when is evaluated for transport near the Fermi surface. In a crystal, the energy band group velocity, effective mass and possibly direction-dependent scattering replace the simplest bare-particle picture. The mean free path is approximately .
A perfectly periodic static lattice is already included in Bloch states and does not by itself give a finite electrical resistivity. Momentum relaxation comes from defects, impurities, boundaries, and electron-phonon scattering. Independent scattering mechanisms approximately add their rates, giving Matthiessen's rule,
The approximately temperature-independent is the residual resistivity. In ordinary simple metals, the phonon contribution is approximately proportional to temperature at high temperature; a three-dimensional acoustic-phonon transport model gives a contribution well below the relevant Debye temperature. Other mechanisms can dominate in particular materials or regimes, so neither power law is universal.
The classical Drude model incorrectly treats the equilibrium carrier statistics. Fermi-Dirac statistics explains the small electronic heat capacity, while electrons carrying both charge and heat give the approximate Wiedemann-Franz law for degenerate carriers with appropriate nearly elastic scattering. Both the simple electrical conductivity formula and this thermal relation depend on the assumptions about energy bands and scattering, rather than being exact for all metals.
Twice the quadratic coefficient from the previous part is the band curvature . Thus the band effective masses are
Here and . In the weak-potential regime ,
Both have units of mass; their magnitudes are much smaller than in this asymptotic regime. The upper energy band has a local minimum and positive effective mass, while the lower energy band has a local maximum and negative effective mass. The exact lower-branch sign changes at in the two-wave formula; the intended weak-coupling limit lies below that threshold.
The physical meaning follows from the semiclassical equations for an electron wave packet in one energy band:
An upper-band electron near its minimum accelerates in the direction of the applied force, whereas a lower-band electron near its maximum accelerates opposite to it. At the extremum itself the group velocity is zero. A nearly filled lower energy band is conveniently described by electron holes with positive electric charge and positive effective mass . Negative curvature is a response of a crystal energy eigenstate, not a negative bare electron mass. These statements assume slow forcing that does not induce transitions across the band gap.
Set , , and . The two kinetic energies satisfy
Consequently the nearly-free electron dispersion near a one-dimensional band gap becomes
The Taylor expansion gives
For the paper's energy convention, set . There is no linear or cubic term because each branch is an even function of displacement from the crossing in this two-wave approximation. Each coefficient multiplying has units of energy times length squared, as required.
The expansion requires
a more restrictive condition than merely when the band gap is small. If , the square root is proportional to and this analytic expansion of the energy-ordered branches is unavailable.
Choose the Fourier series convention
For a real potential energy, . The symbol means the Fourier coefficient , with units of energy, rather than the pointwise value of at a position .
Retain the two plane waves and in the nearly-free electron model. Their kinetic energies are and . The matrix representation of a linear map for the Quantum Hamiltonian projected onto this two-dimensional basis is
Thus gives
Solving this quadratic equation yields
Choosing the zero of potential energy so that its spatial average is reproduces the requested expression. If that average has not been removed, both energy bands are shifted by ; no band gap, group velocity or effective mass is changed by this constant shift.
The two kinetic energies coincide at . Their coupling gives an avoided crossing with band gap . The result is exact within the projected two-wave Quantum Hamiltonian. It is an approximation to the full crystal problem, appropriate near this crossing for a weak periodic potential whose other Fourier coefficients do not cause strong mixing with remote plane waves. Small alone would not justify ignoring arbitrarily large other Fourier coefficients.
The crystal has periodic potential . By Bloch's theorem, an energy eigenstate may be chosen as
Expand the periodic factor in a Fourier series:
Multiplication by gives the stated plane-wave expansion. Here is position, is the primitive unit cell length, is the primitive reciprocal lattice wavenumber, runs over every integer, and are complex numbers specifying the component wave amplitudes. The wavevector labels the Bloch state modulo ; is its crystal momentum, rather than generally its measured free-space momentum.
The component is a plane wave of wavevector . All these components acquire the same phase factor under , since . Their mixing therefore respects the crystal's translation symmetry. The coefficients and energy eigenvalue follow from the Schrödinger equation; the expression is not a claim that the coefficients are equal or that only finitely many are nonzero. The energy band index is suppressed in the notation, so different energy bands at a common generally have different coefficient sets.
Let the source remain at and let the observation point be . The paraxial approximation to the source-to-aperture-to-observer optical path length is
Completing the squares gives
The point is where the straight source-observer line intersects the aperture. Define the four dimensionless edge positions
On the Cornu spiral , draw the directed chord from to , and a second directed chord from to . Denote their complex differences by and . The complex amplitude is proportional to their product: multiply their lengths and add their arguments, including the common propagation phase factor.
More explicitly, normalize by the unobscured field at this same observation point. The constant wave phase from completing the square is then already included in , and
Each directed chord is a one-dimensional Fresnel diffraction factor. One must multiply the two factors, rather than add the chords or use just one chord length for the square aperture. Setting recovers and the on-axis answer.

There are unlisted articles, also show them or only show them.