Differentiate the Helmholtz free energy at fixed couplings. With from solution, the entropy per spin is
It is particularly useful to write
At , this is , so . For fixed , the first exponential dominates alone, giving . Hence the residual entropy is
The finite positive difference must be kept fixed in the second limit; taking it to zero first gives the other answer.
At high temperature, and , whence
All configurations become equally probable because their Boltzmann factors tend to one. The two available states per spin, rather than the coupling values, determine this entropy.
For one triangle, equal base spins give energy . Their minimum occurs at and is . Opposite base spins give energy , independently of the apex spin. The all-equal configurations have energy .
When , the six configurations with precisely one spin different from the other two all have minimum energy . For a fixed first base spin, there is one minimum choice if the next base spin is the same, and two choices of apex if it is opposite. The ground-configuration counting transfer matrix is therefore
This ground-state counting of the frustrated sawtooth Ising chain proves the extensive geometric frustration and the residual entropy .
When , . Every triangle must have equal base spins and the opposite apex spin. Shared base spins propagate that choice around the chain, leaving just two global ground states, of energy . Their entropy per spin is .
For couplings favoring ferromagnetism, write , with . Both orientations of an all-equal triangle minimize every bond simultaneously. The common base spins then make the whole chain uniform. There are two global ground states for either or , so no corresponding distinction in residual entropy occurs. This statement assumes all bonds remain nonzero.
For either phase, the entropy differential at fixed composition is
The pressure derivative uses the Maxwell relation from . Differentiating the equality of entropies along coexistence gives the general relation
For a differentiable coexistence curve with pressure varying, equality of Gibbs free energies also implies . Since , the two phases then share . Thus, with ,
This is the Ehrenfest entropy-continuity relation. Entropy equality alone would give without the shared-volume condition; a constant-pressure boundary or vanishing discontinuities needs separate limiting analysis.
Landau theory expands a thermodynamic potential in an order parameter, constrained by symmetry. For a scalar with sign-reversal symmetry, a useful free-energy density is
Here is the conjugate field. At , minimizing rather than merely finding stationary points gives
The symmetry-related minima represent spontaneous symmetry breaking, as for a simple uniaxial ferromagnet with magnetization as order parameter. An infinitesimal field selects one sign. Above , the susceptibility is ; below it the stable-branch susceptibility is . Minimization lowers by below , producing a heat-capacity density jump with continuous entropy.
Figure 1.
Landau minima
. Original normalized quartic free-energy curves above, at and below a continuous transition, with the two symmetry-related equilibrium order-parameter branches. Details.
A negative quartic coefficient requires a stabilizing with . It can produce a first-order transition before the quadratic coefficient changes sign: coexistence occurs at and . Odd terms are allowed when the assumed symmetry is absent. Landau theory predicts mean-field exponents; spatial fluctuations can change critical behaviour, especially close to a critical point in low dimensions. A gradient term extends the model to nonuniform order parameters but does not by itself supply dynamical equations.
For two localized energy levels with degeneracies , let . Canonical equilibrium gives
Here is the total upper-level occupation probability and are per unit. For nondegenerate levels the entropy rises from zero to , while the heat capacity vanishes at both low and high temperatures and has a Schottky maximum near . A spin one-half in a field, or a localized defect with two configurations, supplies an example. Higher levels must be thermally inaccessible; unequal degeneracies change the populations and peak. Distinguishable localized units have total partition function , unlike a gas of indistinguishable particles sharing just two orbitals.
For the magnetic atom, choose level labels with , . Put . Its partition function and exact entropy of a finite magnetic multiplet are
The ratio form has removable limit . Since is a function of only, it depends on field and temperature solely through . For fixed at small , symmetry removes the odd powers and the supplied sum of gives
For large , the expansion requires , not merely .
Figure 1.
Two-level heat and magnetic entropy
. Original Schottky heat-capacity curve and exact finite-spin entropies show the entropy deficit removed by isothermal magnetization. Quadratic high-temperature expansions are shown only over a limited small-field interval. Details.
For demagnetization with a linear-heat-capacity load, integrate its specified :
Isothermal magnetization at removes spin entropy; the bath receives the corresponding heat. During the following reversible, thermally isolated demagnetization, it is the combined entropy of spins and load that stays constant. At the minimum-field endpoint , the ideal independent spins reach . Therefore
The bracket is the initial magnetic entropy deficit. The PDF's intermediate equality uses the initial entropy itself instead; with its preceding definition of , that equality omits the maximum-entropy term. The corrected balance recovers its final temperature formula:
Without the small-field expansion, the exact independent-spin prediction is . As a check, zero initial field gives zero entropy deficit and no cooling. The incorrectly printed intermediate balance would fail this check.
The result requires the load law throughout the temperature interval, hence ; a small initial Zeeman splitting, quantitatively ; positive final temperature; negligible additional heat capacities and heat leaks; thermal equilibration between subsystems; and a reversible sweep slow enough to maintain equilibrium. A negative extrapolated temperature is a breakdown of this approximation, not a cooling prediction. Spins alone would keep fixed, but the attached load changes that adiabat by transferring entropy to them as it cools.
Interactions invalidate the product of independent one-site partition functions. The entropy must be computed from the many-body energy spectrum or a justified interacting approximation. Correlations and possible magnetic ordering introduce an interaction scale and can remove the independent-spin entropy available for cooling near zero field. Internal fields and ordering commonly limit practical demagnetization. The detailed correction and any residual entropy depend on the interaction Hamiltonian, dimensionality and frustration; neither a universal ordering temperature nor a numerical final-temperature correction is specified here.
Landau theory expands the free energy in an order parameter. For a scalar with sign-reversal symmetry and zero conjugate field, a useful sextic even Landau potential is
Equilibrium selects the global minimum; other local minima can be metastable.
For , the minimum changes continuously from to as passes below zero. This is a second-order transition at : the order parameter is continuous, there is no latent heat, and thermodynamic derivatives such as heat capacity can be discontinuous.
For , the sixth-order term stabilizes the free energy. Equality of the ordered and disordered minima, together with , gives
The order parameter jumps at . The entropy generally jumps too, giving latent heat; metastable branches and barriers permit hysteresis, though equilibrium coexistence itself does not require hysteresis. The special case is tricritical. Mean-field exponents can fail where fluctuations dominate.
Figure 1.
Original even Landau free-energy curves: continuous quartic ordering and sextic first-order coexistence with separated equal-depth minima
. Details.
Ensemble and applications. A grand canonical ensemble describes a system exchanging both energy and particles with a large reservoir. Its fixed control parameters are , while microstates with different have probabilities
Weak coupling allows the system's energy levels to remain meaningful; equilibrium fixes the reservoir temperature and chemical potential. The grand potential is , with now the mean population. It generates entropy, pressure and mean particle number by differentiation. This ensemble is convenient for gases in contact with particle reservoirs, independently occupied quantum levels and surface adsorption; its particle-number fluctuations are part of the description, not an error in counting.
Classical single-level limit. For the single-level grand partition function in the dilute limit, put . Empty and singly occupied levels contribute and . In the dilute classical limit , higher occupancies contribute only at order or beyond:
This truncation does not impose the Pauli principle on a classical gas. A fermion state has exactly , a boson state has , and Maxwell-Boltzmann occupancy weights give ; they all agree to this order. In particular, , with the classical Maxwell-Boltzmann result exactly .
grand potential and chemical potential. With , summing the single-level logarithms and using the stated density of states gives
Substitute , for which
Combining this with the density-of-states prefactor gives . Thus
Differentiating at fixed ,
Similarly , so . This is the grand-canonical chemical potential of a classical ideal gas. The condition states the classical regime. The supplied density of states counts one internal state; extra internal degeneracies would have to be included consistently rather than inserted at only one stage.
One adsorption site. Take the free-vapour energy reference as zero and the binding energy as . A site is either empty or singly occupied; the latter has vibrational partition function . Its adsorption-site grand partition function and mean occupation are
The chemical potential of an adsorbed species on equivalent sites follows by inverting the occupation ratio
The factor is the vacant-site probability. The binding reference and the energies included in must be chosen consistently, so that vibrational zero-point energy is not counted twice.
Isotherm. The vibrational factor in a Langmuir equilibrium constant is fixed by adsorption equilibrium, . Neglecting vapour internal degrees of freedom and writing its number density as gives . Therefore
This is the Langmuir isotherm: initially linear, increasing monotonically and concave down, approaching unit coverage. Half coverage occurs at . The coefficient has inverse-pressure units. It assumes equivalent independent sites, at most one molecule per site and no lateral interaction or multilayer adsorption. The molecular mass appropriate to the vapour determines .
Figure 1.
Original dimensionless Langmuir coverage curve with half-coverage and limiting behavior
. Details.
A real uptake measurement must separate adsorbed molecules from free gas in the apparatus. Langmuir's original mica experiment compared a mica-containing bulb with a similar blank and inferred uptake from calibrated gas volumes and pressures. His stated blank contribution and bath-temperature drift limited the inferred adsorption; a saturating curve alone does not establish ideal equivalent sites.[ref]
Take to be the magnitude of either spin projection's magnetic moment, so the independent magnetic levels are . Their partition function and magnetic energy are
where and . The canonical entropy is consequently
This independent-spin magnetic entropy counts the two orientation states of each independent moment; translational entropy and interactions are excluded.
Along the magnetic-entropy demagnetization adiabat, constant magnetic entropy fixes , hence is constant. Lowering the field therefore gives the ideal adiabatic demagnetization relation
A useful cycle first magnetizes isothermally while releasing heat to a reservoir, then thermally isolates the sample and lowers the field. Cooling the entire sample requires its other heat capacities and spin-lattice equilibration to be accounted for. Magnetic interactions, residual fields and heat leaks prevent extrapolating the independent-moment formula to an attainable zero temperature.[ref]
Figure 1.
Magnetic entropy decreases with B over T, while an ideal demagnetization adiabat has constant B over T
. Source. Details.
For the ideal dilute Maxwell-Boltzmann gas implicit in a single-particle partition function, indistinguishability gives . With Stirling's approximation,
Differentiate at fixed :
This is a thermodynamic-limit ideal-gas result; arbitrary interacting classical gases do not have .
Equilibrium constraints and the Gibbs minimum. The open-system equilibrium contacts allow exchange of heat, volume and matter. For unconstrained contacts without external-field or interface corrections, equilibrium requires equal temperatures, pressures and each exchangeable species' chemical potentials across the contacts. These conditions follow by maximizing total entropy under conserved total energy, volume and species amounts.
The next minimization statement fixes the system's particle number. For a system in a reservoir at , with fixed and only pressure-volume work, the reservoir entropy change gives
For candidate states at the imposed , , the expression in parentheses is . Thus the Fixed-particle-number Gibbs minimum selects stable equilibrium at fixed , with stationary first variation and nonnegative allowed second variation. If particle exchange remains unconstrained, is not fixed and this minimization statement must be replaced by one incorporating the particle reservoir; it is not a justification for minimizing over arbitrary .
The simple-compressible-system first law gives
For a homogeneous extensive single-component phase, the Single-component Gibbs Euler relation follows from , yielding . For a mixture, the corresponding identities are and . Surface effects or other nonextensive contributions require additional terms.[ref]
Reaction equilibrium. Let be an allowed reaction extent for the forward process, so and . At fixed ,
For an interior equilibrium allowing both reaction directions, the coefficient vanishes:
At fixed , minimizing gives the same condition. The reaction formula-unit conservation gives , not the total number of gas particles. This conservation law replaces fixed total particle number for the reacting mixture.
Using the stipulated single-particle functions,
The number-based dissociation equilibrium ratio is therefore
This number-based quantity has a factor of volume; the corresponding concentration ratio depends on temperature alone in the stated ideal model. A standard activity-based equilibrium constant would additionally specify reference states. No bond-energy factor is added to the functions given in the paper.
Define the dissociated fraction of original A formula units by . Then and , so
The dissociation fraction versus conserved density follows because the left side increases monotonically from zero to infinity on . At fixed , increasing decreases , hence decreases dissociation. Equivalently, at fixed compression raises and favours A. Association produces fewer independent translating particles; at high density the translational-entropy advantage of the two-particle side is smaller, so equilibrium shifts toward the one-particle side.
Figure 1.
At fixed temperature the dissociated fraction falls as the conserved formula-unit density increases
. Source. Details.
Gibbs free energy and its minimum. For fixed atom number , there are sites and
configurations with indistinguishable vacancies. Their configurational entropy is . Relative to the vacancy-free Gibbs free energy , creating vacancies costs energy and pressure-volume work . Put . Then
At leading thermodynamic order, Stirling's approximation gives
The minimum obtained from the stationary point below is
If the perfect crystal's internal energy and other entropy are chosen as zero, its pressure term is . More generally the information given fixes the vacancy contribution rather than the absolute bulk free energy. The pressure-volume term must be retained because the number of sites, and hence the volume, changes.
Equilibrium vacancy population. Differentiating the extensive free energy at fixed gives
The stationary point is consequently the unique interior minimum. Write ; its condition is , giving the requested thermodynamic result for equilibrium vacancies with variable lattice size,
Substitution back into cancels the terms containing and yields the boxed minimum. In the dilute-defect limit , . The Bose-like denominator is a consequence of the changing number of lattice sites and combinatorial entropy; it does not assert that vacancies here are an ideal gas of bosonic particles.
There is a finite-size correction to a variable-site vacancy model if “average” is interpreted exactly. The microscopic count written above gives the relative isothermal-isobaric sum
so
Its relative equilibrium free energy is . Thus the source's numerator is correct to leading extensive order, but is not the exact finite- mean for that stated configuration count. A free-energy minimum is likewise not generally identical to the mean of a finite distribution. These distinctions vanish relatively as .
Thermal volume. Each atom or vacancy occupies volume , so at the same thermodynamic accuracy
For the exact counting model, replace by in . The vacancy-free limit is as . This model isolates expansion from vacancies, taking and constant; it omits ordinary phonon thermal expansion. Its growth at high temperature should not be extrapolated to arbitrarily large vacancy fractions in a stable crystal, and is essential for a normalizable variable-site ensemble.
One particle. Use the classical phase-space normalization of one quantum state per volume , with no unspecified internal degeneracy. For and , the canonical partition function factorizes into momentum and position integrals:
The Gaussian momentum integral is . In spherical coordinates, put :
Therefore the classical ideal gas in a spherical linear trap has
Here is a force, in , so is a length and is dimensionless. A nonconfining would not give this finite spatial integral. As required by the classical phase-space approximation, the temperature must exceed the trap's discrete level scale.
Indistinguishable dilute particles. Independent labeled particles would give . In the classical dilute regime, division by removes the overcounting of permutations of identical particles:
This is the Maxwell-Boltzmann limit, not an exact quantum canonical partition function at high occupation. Exchange effects cannot be captured merely by continuing this formula beyond its dilute regime.
Free energy, energy and entropy. The Helmholtz free energy is
With leading Stirling's approximation, , this becomes
At fixed trap strength, . Differentiating gives the requested entropy,
The is : the first term comes from indistinguishability through Stirling's formula, and the second from the temperature dependence of . Without the large- approximation, . Independently,
The kinetic contribution is and the linear-trap potential contribution is , also obtained from generalized equipartition.
Entropy curves and reversible cooling. For a fixed and a reference pair , the dependence can be written without logarithms of dimensional quantities:
At each fixed , the entropy increases logarithmically and is concave downward in ; decreasing shifts the curve upward. Its formal classical divergence as marks failure of classical statistics, not a physical negative-infinite entropy.
Figure 1.
Original classical entropy curves for two linear-trap strengths; a horizontal constant-entropy arrow shows cooling on reversible decompression, within the dilute regime
. Details.
For a reversible adiabatic change, is constant at fixed , so
Hence reducing lowers the temperature: this is isentropic decompression of a spherical linear trap. The gas does work on the control that weakens the trap. Equivalently , with ; inserting gives the same relation. Reversibility requires an equilibrium sequence without heat input or entropy production. Because stays constant on this adiabat, also stays constant: this mechanism cools the cloud but does not by itself increase quantum degeneracy.
Chemical potential and quantum threshold. From the extensive free energy,
Thus the quantum gas fugacity is . Classical statistics requires ; quantum effects become important as the chemical potential comes within order of the lowest one-particle energy. With the semiclassical zero at the potential minimum, the quantum degeneracy threshold in a spherical linear trap is consequently
There are no numerical values of in the paper, so this parameter-dependent estimate is the requested atom number. It also follows from the peak density: , and degeneracy starts when is order one. The criterion is a crossover estimate, not an assertion that the classical formula remains valid at . For spinless bosons the continuum excited-state saturation is more specifically , while for fermions the onset is occupation constrained by exclusion. At temperatures comparable with the quantum trap spacing, the actual ground energy must be included consistently rather than identified exactly with the classical minimum.
Particles within each species are indistinguishable, while the two species are physically distinguishable and their numbers are fixed. Independence makes the canonical partition function factor by species:
Since at fixed volume, . The canonical entropy is therefore
For large species populations, Stirling's approximation gives the equivalent Sackur-Tetrode equation form
For structureless particles with the same translational partition function, , where is their common thermal de Broglie wavelength. More generally the supplied common constant factor in should be retained in the entropy.
Writing separates the total-number contribution from the composition term:
The last term is the entropy of mixing relative to separated ideal components at the same temperature and pressure. This is the entropy of a two-species classical ideal gas. Artificially labeling otherwise identical chemical atoms would not justify dividing by separate factorials or adding a mixing entropy. The pure-species limit is obtained by .
Order parameter and the free-energy landscape. In Landau theory, take a scalar magnetization component at fixed volume and composition. It is an order parameter: its nonzero spontaneous value distinguishes an ordered phase with ferromagnetism from the symmetric high-temperature phase. One first constructs a constrained order-parameter free energy at specified magnetization by summing over microscopic states compatible with it. An external magnetic field is an independent control, so it can also appear in that constrained function. For a total magnetic moment the conjugate term is ; if is a magnetization density, the total-energy term is , or in free-energy density. Minimizing over then yields the equilibrium thermodynamic potential as a function of the imposed field.
Thus treating both and as arguments of a Landau function does not treat them as independent natural variables of the already-minimized equilibrium free energy. The first is the fluctuating or constrained order parameter, and the second its conjugate field.
At zero field, reversal symmetry requires , excluding odd powers. Near a continuous transition, assume the homogeneous constrained free energy is analytic for small , that the quadratic coefficient crosses zero linearly, and that the quartic coefficient is positive. Then
The temperature is where the zero-field quadratic coefficient vanishes and spontaneous ordering begins in this approximation. Higher powers are negligible sufficiently close to it; spatial fluctuations are neglected in this mean-field treatment.
Stationarity gives . Above , the only minimum is at zero. Below it, zero becomes a maximum and two minima appear:
The two signs describe spontaneous symmetry breaking: they are the average magnetizations in the symmetry-broken pure phases. A strictly finite system at exactly zero field samples the two wells symmetrically and has ensemble average . A spontaneous pure-phase value is defined by selecting a phase, for example taking the thermodynamic limit before removing a small field. This qualification distinguishes a minimum's location from the average over a symmetric two-well distribution.
Figure 1.
Quartic Landau free energy above and below the transition, showing the disordered and symmetry-broken minima
. Details.
Minimum free energy and the heat-capacity jump. At a nonzero minimum, . Substituting this value gives
Hence
while above the transition. Take the temperature derivatives only after minimizing, so the equilibrium order parameter is allowed to change with temperature. With ,
Therefore
This is the heat-capacity jump in quartic Landau theory. The entropy is continuous at , so there is no latent heat. If denotes free-energy density rather than total free energy, these expressions denote heat capacity per unit volume with the same normalization.
Stabilizing a tricritical expansion. At a tricritical point, the quartic coefficient is tuned to zero at the same point where the quadratic coefficient changes sign. Reversal symmetry still excludes odd powers. The next available stabilizing term is therefore
A negative or vanishing leading sextic coefficient would not stabilize this truncation for large ; a higher positive term would then be needed and the present tricritical form would be insufficient. The ordinary quartic theory has a continuous transition for , while a stabilized theory with can have a first-order transition. Their meeting at zero field is what makes the simultaneous tuning tricritical.
The tricritical minimum. At zero field and , stationarity gives
The nonzero solutions are minima: their curvature is . Put . Since at stationarity,
Thus
The order parameter now vanishes as rather than the quartic theory's square root.
Heat-capacity singularity. Define , so the ordered-side singular free energy is . Its derivatives are
Consequently
This is the tricritical heat-capacity amplitude in a sextic Landau expansion. It is positive on the ordered side and diverges as , rather than remaining a finite jump. This value of the heat-capacity critical exponent is the mean-field result along the path keeping the quartic term zero; a detuning to ultimately restores ordinary quartic behavior. Fluctuation corrections to the mean-field theory are not included in the stipulated polynomial minimization.
Canonical probabilities. A canonical ensemble describes a system of fixed particle number and fixed external parameters such as volume, weakly coupled to a much larger thermal reservoir. They exchange energy and reach thermal equilibrium, while the reservoir's temperature stays effectively constant. The interaction energy is negligible in the state counting. The combined isolated system is described by equal probabilities for its accessible microstates.
If its total energy is , the probability of a particular system microstate is proportional to the reservoir multiplicity at . Writing that multiplicity as , expand its entropy:
The large-reservoir limit suppresses the higher terms. Normalization therefore gives
The sum counts individual microstates; when grouping them by energy, their state degeneracies must be included. This is the canonical partition function.
Classical orientational heat capacity. Hold the magnetic field fixed. Orientations of the magnetic dipole moment have the solid angle measure . With , the angular partition function is
Choosing a normalized angular measure would remove , with no effect on the energy derivatives. Differentiating at fixed ,
The angular average is the Langevin function. Since ,
This is the heat capacity of a classical magnetic dipole, in for one magnetic moment. The word specific here refers to that single moment; independent magnetic moments have times this heat capacity. At the energy is independent of orientation and , obtained by the continuous limit. At fixed nonzero , the classical low-temperature limit instead gives .
Equipartition and its proof. The equipartition theorem states that an independent quadratic term in a classical Hamiltonian, with , contributes to its mean energy. One needs a canonical measure that factors as times the measure of the remaining variables, convergence of the integrals, and vanishing boundary terms. The coordinate must not be restricted by a thermally important hard boundary or a coupled constraint.
For , integration by parts gives
Integrate over all other variables and divide by . It follows that
The same reasoning applies to quadratic momenta among the canonical variables. It is the number of quadratic energy contributions that is counted, not an unrestricted count of coordinate labels.
Two soft orientational directions. When , the moment is concentrated near alignment. Introduce local Cartesian coordinates in the tangent plane and . To leading order,
The two quadratic terms each contribute , so
This agrees with the exact angular calculation. Treating alone as one Cartesian quadratic variable would miss the measure and the second tangent direction. There are no extra rotational kinetic terms in the stipulated Hamiltonian; adding such terms would be a different model.
Quantum spin one. The spin projections are , with . Put , where is the gyromagnetic ratio. The three energies are , irrespective of the sign of . Relative to the ground state they are . Thus, with ,
Differentiation, or the canonical energy fluctuation identity , gives
In the requested limit,
This spin-1 paramagnet has a nondegenerate ground state and a finite spectral gap. Excitations are exponentially rare, so its heat capacity tends to zero. Classical orientational equipartition assumed a continuum of arbitrarily small excitation energies; that assumption fails when . This is a change in the accessible state spectrum, not a violation of the equipartition theorem within its classical domain.
Availability and total entropy. The reservoir changes by and . Its particle number and the system's particle number are fixed. The reservoir's first law of thermodynamics therefore gives
Add the system's entropy change. Because are constant,
Thus define the availability
An additive constant in is immaterial; its value above the equilibrium reference is the exergy. The Second law of thermodynamics gives , hence . A stable equilibrium maximizes total entropy over the allowed variations and therefore minimizes . The environmental enter this definition even when the system has not yet reached their values. Because both thermal and mechanical exchanges are allowed, equilibrium here includes mechanical balance; equality of temperatures alone does not ensure the minimum.
Probability and curvature. For a fixed value of a macroscopic coordinate , let count the compatible system microstates. The product of the system and reservoir multiplicities is
All factors independent of enter a normalization constant, giving
Here is the constrained or effective availability for this coordinate, including the multiplicity of any eliminated variables. A nonuniform coordinate measure must likewise be retained or incorporated in that effective availability.
At a stable interior minimum, and . Its Taylor expansion gives
Keeping the quadratic term yields a normal distribution,
This is availability curvature and equilibrium fluctuations. The quoted fluctuation formula holds at quadratic order in the Gaussian fluctuation approximation; it is not an exact identity for an arbitrary nonlinear . Higher terms can shift the mean away from its most probable value .
Bubble equilibrium. Keep the number of air molecules fixed and include the surface energy in the system's total internal energy. For constant surface tension , this contribution is , with no surface entropy under the stated approximation. Its differential is
Hence
Independent thermal and volume variations give and
The air pressure is evaluated at ; since the bubble is closed it generally depends on volume, so this equation is implicit until an air equation of state is supplied. For a sphere, , , and the pressure jump becomes , the Young–Laplace equation for a single gas–liquid interface. There is no second surface as in a thin soap film.
Isothermal volume fluctuations. With the air maintained at , eliminate its entropy in favor of its Helmholtz free energy:
The identity gives
Using the curvature result,
These are the volume fluctuations of a closed gas bubble. Stability requires the denominator to be positive. The negative surface contribution reflects the concavity of ; gas compression supplies the positive restoring curvature. For ideal air, , and mechanical equilibrium reduces the denominator to
The units are consistent: is pressure, so has units , the units of a volume variance. Holding externally fixed while varying would remove the gas-compression term and change this stability problem; that is not the fixed-particle-number situation here.
Numerical size of the fluctuations. The volume conversion is important:
Use the specified , and . Then
With the Boltzmann constant ,
Thus the fractional root mean square fluctuation and fractional variance are respectively
The absolute root mean square fluctuation is . The very small fractional value supports the local Gaussian fluctuation approximation. This estimate neglects exchange of dissolved air, variations of surface tension, shape fluctuations and temperature fluctuations, consistently with the prescribed fixed-number, isothermal bubble model.
Let be the coordination number of a lattice, the number of nearest neighbours of each cell away from boundaries. Define an effective chemical potential incorporating the cell's translational entropy:
Use for an unordered nearest-neighbour bond, counted once. The occupation Hamiltonian including the chemical-potential term is
Under , one bond contributes
In a regular lattice with periodic boundary conditions, the number of bonds is , and each spin occurs in linear bond terms. Therefore
The pair sum equals one half of the ordered sum used in the paper. Consequently the effective field is
Thus is the Ising model partition sum, including the displayed spin-independent constant if its absolute normalization is required. Dropping that constant changes by a multiplicative factor but leaves spin probabilities and the phase-transition argument unchanged. For simple cubic cells in three dimensions, and the first term in is . Open boundaries replace by the local coordination near the surface; the stated uniform field is the bulk or periodic-lattice result.
The Second law of thermodynamics states that total entropy of an isolated composite system cannot decrease. For a cyclic heat engine exchanging heat only with reservoirs at , it gives . Since ,
The bound is attained by a reversible heat engine: no friction, no finite-temperature-difference heat exchange and no other entropy production. A Carnot cycle provides an implementation with two reversible isotherms and two reversible adiabats. All temperatures in these ratios are absolute.
Let be the fixed gas amount, , , and let denote the heat capacity of the whole sample. First take the unregenerated Stirling cycle, so that heat rejected during isochoric cooling is not stored and returned during isochoric heating. The reversible quasistatic gas work is
while the heat inputs are and . Hence
The strict inequality follows because adds heat input without additional work. Quasistatic motion alone does not make heat exchange with a single hot or cold reservoir reversible while the gas temperature changes on an isochore. Indeed, using those two reservoirs gives total external entropy production per cycle.
The strict comparison requires the no-regeneration assumption. A perfect reversible regenerator stores during and returns it during ; only the isothermal heat transfers then enter the external heat budget, giving exactly. For example, perfect regeneration with , and gives . Thus the four gas paths by themselves do not enforce an efficiency strictly below the Carnot bound.
For the gas itself, the four entropy changes are
Expansion increases the available positional states; compression reverses that change. Isochoric cooling reduces thermal populations and isochoric heating restores them. The sum is zero because entropy is a state function. This does not imply zero total entropy production in the gas plus external reservoirs.
Taking as reference, the isotherms are horizontal on a – diagram. The isochore through state 1 obeys , and the isochore through state 2 is shifted right by . For the internally reversible quasistatic gas paths, , so
The enclosed area is the net work per engine cycle, with a clockwise orientation. It is not the total heat input.
Figure 1.
Stirling entropy cycle and the refrigerator's performance bound
. Original illustrative gas cycle with constant heat capacity, together with the predicted coefficient of performance of an unregenerated neon refrigerator. The stated performance lies above the reversible bound; no volume ratio can repair that conflict. Details.
For the refrigerator, the stated rates give the cooling coefficient of performance . But the absolute reservoir temperatures are and , so Carnot's theorem requires
At input the largest allowed cooling rate is only . Equivalently the stated heat rejection gives the reservoir entropy rate
a direct violation of the Second law of thermodynamics for this cyclic two-reservoir device.
The unregenerated neon model makes the algebraic obstruction explicit. With , reversing the cycle gives
Setting this to 19 produces , or , contradicting the required expansion ratio . Perfect regeneration can raise performance only to the Carnot bound and does not fix the problem. There is no physically admissible for the stated data.
For steady insulated flow through a porous plug, neglect changes of bulk kinetic energy and gravitational potential energy, and allow no shaft work. Each amount of gas brings flow work upstream and delivers downstream. The steady energy conservation balance is
Thus enthalpy is conserved in this Joule-Thomson effect. For an ideal gas, , so and as well. The entropy increases:
The porous-plug process is irreversible despite being slow and insulated; it is not the reversible expansion of the preceding part.
With a thermally insulating boundary, . If the slow piston motion is frictionless and reversible, it is an isentropic process:
The first law of thermodynamics gives , so expansion lowers the internal energy and temperature. For constant heat capacity ratio , and are constant combinations of state functions. Insulation alone does not guarantee constant entropy: an irreversible adiabatic process can produce entropy. The conclusion uses the intended reversible, quasistatic piston idealization.
A state function is determined by the equilibrium state, rather than the path used to reach it. Its differential is exact and its change around a closed thermodynamic cycle is zero. Internal energy, entropy and enthalpy are examples; transferred heat and work are not state functions.
For slow expansion in contact with a large thermal reservoir, the fixed temperature of that reservoir maintains an isothermal process. For a fixed amount of ideal gas, internal energy and enthalpy depend only on temperature, so
The ideal gas law also gives . For a reversible expansion the absorbed heat equals the work done by the gas, while its entropy increases by ; constant internal energy does not mean zero heat transfer.