The band effective mass is determined by the second derivative of the dispersion relation:
With the stated sign convention and , the band minimum is at . Expanding the cosine, or differentiating twice, gives
Comparison with a free electron's kinetic energy therefore requires
The hopping integral has units of energy. A negative would move the minimum to the edge of the Brillouin zone and give the same positive bottom-of-band effective mass with in this expression.
Different measurements reveal different aspects of electronic band structure; a convincing determination combines their constraints.
Angle-resolved photoemission. In angle-resolved photoemission spectroscopy, photons of known energy eject occupied electrons. Measuring their kinetic energy and emission angle reconstructs binding energy and the component of crystal momentum parallel to the surface:
Here is the sample work function when kinetic energy is referenced to the nearby vacuum; an analyzer energy scale requires its own work-function calibration. Momentum is conserved modulo a surface reciprocal lattice vector, neglecting photon momentum. Tracking the peaks maps occupied dispersion relations and the Fermi surface. The measured intensity also contains the matrix element, the Fermi-Dirac distribution and the spectral function, so an absent bright feature does not establish an absent band. For a three-dimensional solid, the perpendicular momentum requires a final-state model. Inverse photoemission spectroscopy probes unoccupied states by injecting electrons and detecting emitted photons.
Optical spectroscopy. Photon absorption and ellipsometry measure interband transitions, optical selection rules and the complex dielectric response. Because optical photon momentum is small on the scale of the Brillouin zone, direct transitions approximately preserve crystal momentum. Their onset constrains a direct band gap; a threshold involving a phonon can reveal an indirect band gap. Peak positions constrain energy differences between bands, but the response also depends on the joint density of states and optical matrix elements, so it does not uniquely determine every .
Quantum oscillations and cyclotron resonance. In clean samples at low temperature, the de Haas-van Alphen effect measures oscillations in magnetization and the Shubnikov-de Haas effect measures oscillations in electrical resistivity as the inverse magnetic field is varied. Their period in inverse magnetic field is , where Onsager quantization relates to an extremal Fermi-surface area perpendicular to the field:
Rotating the magnetic field maps the geometry of extremal orbits. The thermal damping determines the cyclotron effective mass,
with the appropriate magnitude for a hole orbit. Cyclotron resonance supplies the corresponding dynamical mass through . These are detailed probes near the Fermi level, rather than measurements of all occupied bands. Diffraction supplies the reciprocal lattice needed to label the measured momenta, but diffraction by itself is not a measurement of electronic dispersion.
In the nearly-free electron model, the free parabola is coupled to copies shifted by reciprocal wavevectors . The first degeneracy is at , where the counterpropagating waves have equal kinetic energy. Retaining their coupling gives two branches
Consequently a nonzero Fourier component opens a gap at the zone edge. The dispersion remains approximately free-electron-like away from the crossing, but the branches avoid crossing and their slopes flatten at the band edges. The horizontal axis can be labeled either wavevector , with edges at , or physical momentum , with edges at .
At the edge, an appropriate choice of spatial origin makes real. The eigenstates are equal-weight standing waves. In a normalization length containing an integer number of periods, representative real forms are
They come from the sum and difference of and , up to a global phase. Their densities have maxima and nodes displaced by relative to one another. Both wavefunctions change sign under translation by , as required by their zone-edge Bloch phase, while their densities are lattice-periodic.
Figure 1.
An illustrative nearly-free-electron gap and its two zone-edge standing waves
. Details.
For the figure's choice with , the potential minima occur at . The cosine state puts density there and is lower, while the sine state puts a node there and is higher. Reversing the potential's phase relative to the coordinate origin exchanges that assignment. Since the question supplies only the spatial period, it fixes the zone-edge locations and qualitative standing-wave structure, but not a numerical gap or an origin-independent choice of which drawn sine/cosine is lower.
The energy favoring spin polarization must compete with the increase in Fermi kinetic energy. Assume the usual three-dimensional zero-temperature parabolic conduction band at fixed and . Write the spin polarization as , so . The unpolarized Fermi energy is
The two spin populations have Fermi energies . Summing their individual mean kinetic energies gives
The specified interaction is an energy per electron, . Thus the energy change per electron near the unpolarized state is
The quadratic coefficient changes sign at the Stoner threshold for an interaction normalized per electron,
The positive quartic term gives a continuous onset in this model. More globally, . Convexity of makes this nonnegative for , so no lower polarized minimum appears before that threshold.
At fixed number density , the critical is independent of the total sample size. A comparison restricted to a fully polarized state gives a different numerical coefficient, , but the same requested density scaling; it misses the partially polarized onset. One must also distinguish this , with units of energy, from a contact coupling multiplying an interaction-energy density : here . Importing a differently normalized Stoner criterion would introduce an erroneous extra density factor.
A covalent bond is stabilized by shared electronic states extending across neighboring atomic nuclei. In a simple two-centre description, combining comparable atomic orbitals produces a bonding state with enhanced electron density between the nuclei and an antibonding state with a node there. For equivalent normalized orbitals with real overlap ,
Their energy ordering follows from the molecular Hamiltonian; constructive interference and reduced gradients help explain why the bonding combination can be lower. Opposite-spin electrons can occupy the bonding orbital together. The familiar molecular-hydrogen bond is a basic example, while extended covalent networks form solids such as diamond. Orbital shape and hybridization make covalent bonding strongly directional and constrain bond angles. Occupying antibonding states reduces the net bond strength.
Ionic bonding instead emphasizes electric charge transfer and the electrostatic attraction of the resulting oppositely charged ions. Removing an electron from one atom costs ionization energy and adding it to another gains electron affinity; these isolated-atom terms alone need not favor transfer. In a crystal, the electrostatic lattice energy can stabilize the ionic arrangement. For a schematic lattice of singly charged ions at nearest-neighbor distance ,
where the geometrical Madelung constant sums attractions and repulsions throughout the lattice. Short-range overlap repulsion prevents collapse and gives an equilibrium separation. Sodium chloride is an example of an extended ionic crystal, rather than isolated NaCl molecules in the solid.
Figure 1.
Original schematic covalent electron sharing and the extended charge arrangement of an ionic crystal
. Details.
Ideal ionic bonding is comparatively nondirectional, so packing, ion sizes and electric charge balance strongly influence coordination. ions cannot freely migrate in the ordinary solid; melting or dissolution can make ionic electric charge transport possible. Covalent materials do not obey one universal electrical conductivity rule: their electronic bands and filling determine whether mobile electronic carriers are available.
The two descriptions are limiting models, not a sharp classification of every bond. Unequal electronegativities can produce polar covalent bonds with partial electric charge transfer, and a material may contain both covalent groups and ionic interactions between those groups. Chemical bonding reflects a balance of electronic kinetic energy, electron-nucleus attraction, electron-electron repulsion and nuclear repulsion; it cannot be reduced to a force between two assigned point charges in every material.
Nondegenerate carrier product. Assume three-dimensional parabolic energy bands near their extrema, spin degeneracy two, and no additional uncounted valley multiplicity. Near the conduction edge, a Boltzmann approximation to the Fermi-Dirac distribution gives
Angular integration and the Gaussian radial integral yield
For valence electron holes, the empty-state probability is . Measuring electron hole kinetic energy downwards from similarly gives
The factors two count spin once in each band. Multiplying cancels the chemical potential and proves the semiconductor mass-action law:
In an intrinsic neutral semiconductor, . In a doped equilibrium semiconductor the same product holds under the stated nondegenerate assumptions, even when . Extra valleys or several valence branches must be included in the effective density-of-states factors rather than counted inconsistently.
Equilibrium junction. Put the p region on the left and the n region on the right. Before contact their majority carriers are electron holes and electrons, respectively. Diffusion initially sends electrons from n to p and electron holes from p to n. This leaves negative ionized acceptors on the p side and positive ionized donors on the n side, creating a depletion region and an electric field directed from n to p. At equilibrium this field balances diffusion, so the net electric current vanishes.
For a homojunction the gap remains constant while the conduction band and valence band edges bend downwards from p to n by . The equilibrium chemical potential is flat. Since , the electrostatic potential rises from p to n. The carrier profiles satisfy
With fully ionized nondegenerate dopants, the neutral p side has , , while the neutral n side has , . Thus the electron concentration rises across the junction and the electron hole concentration falls, with both small relative to the far-side majority densities in much of the depleted region. The ideal depletion approximation neglects these mobile populations when calculating the fixed space electric charge, but the actual equilibrium profiles are smooth.
Figure 1.
Equilibrium band bending, a flat chemical potential and complementary electron/hole profiles across a homojunction
. Details.
The built-in potential follows from these Boltzmann factors:
There is no applied terminal bias; the internal electrostatic potential variation does not contradict a constant electrochemical potential.
Opposing carrier fluxes under reverse bias. Use for the magnitude of reverse bias and for reverse electric current, as in the PDF. The junction barrier increases by . The Shockley diode equation in that orientation can be written
The reverse-directed contribution is supplied by minority electrons on the p side and minority electron holes on the n side. They reach the depletion edge by diffusion and are swept across by the built-in field. The opposing contribution is associated with majority carriers thermally crossing the barrier in the forward direction; reverse bias suppresses it by the Boltzmann factor. At zero bias detailed balance makes the two equal, while at large enough reverse bias the opposing flux becomes negligible.
In the ideal neutral-region diffusion model,
Here are minority-carrier diffusion coefficients, their diffusion lengths, and is junction area. The two terms inside this positive prefactor are the electron and electron hole contributions; both flow in the same reverse-current direction. This separates the two carrier-species contributions from the two opposing fluxes in the Shockley diode equation. Calling the saturation term a drift current refers to its passage across the depleted region, and does not eliminate the minority-carrier diffusion needed to supply it.
Reading the measured curves. At , the ideal equation gives , initially proportional to reverse electric potential difference. At , it approaches a plateau . The thermal electric potential differences at the three temperatures are about –, consistent with a rise at small reverse biases and near saturation at larger ones. Higher temperature produces a much larger plateau because thermal electron-hole excitation raises exponentially.
The lower-temperature curve has a noticeable residual electric potential difference dependence rather than a perfectly flat plateau. Depletion-region generation, surface leakage or other departures from the ideal diffusion model can contribute. The sharp upturn at the largest reverse electric potential differences is reverse breakdown, outside the unextended Shockley diode equation; the plot alone does not identify a unique microscopic breakdown mechanism. The original horizontal axis duplicates the final decade label, so a precise breakdown electric potential difference cannot be read reliably. Neither issue prevents estimating the gap from the intermediate-bias saturation region.
Band-gap estimate. Use plateau electric currents at a common intermediate reverse bias, away from both the small-bias rise and the breakdown upturn. Approximate readings are , –, and . Kelvin temperatures are required in the activation law.
For fixed effective masses, . If the remaining transport prefactor is approximately constant, extracting a semiconductor band gap from diode saturation current therefore uses
Using the widest temperature separation and the rounded readings gives
Neglecting all algebraic prefactors and fitting instead gives about . These differ by roughly , a material correction on the graph's precision scale. Thus an honest graph-based conclusion is
The nonflat low-temperature plateau, rough electric current readings, unprovided temperature dependence of , and possible gap variation prevent a more precise extraction. If depletion-region generation dominated rather than the specified mechanism, its activation slope could involve a different energy scale; the displayed estimate explicitly uses the diffusion-dominated saturation model requested here.
Noninteracting spectral line. Treat as a wavevector, so physical crystal momentum is . Write ; an energy zero at the chemical potential can be chosen throughout. The temporal factor of a noninteracting state is . With the Fourier transform convention ,
Thus its normalized frequency spectral function is
One should not square the delta distribution as if it were an ordinary finite-time transition amplitude. More precisely, the fermionic retarded Green function is . Its Fourier transform is , whose negative imaginary part divided by is the same delta peak.
Interactions and lifetime. Interactions change the dispersion through the real part of the self-energy and permit decay into other excitations through its imaginary part. In the simplest quasiparticle-pole model, exponential decay of the retarded amplitude gives
Performing the causal integral,
The corresponding Lorentzian quasiparticle spectral peak is
Its total frequency integral is one. The exponential amplitude lifetime is ; the probability lifetime is . Describing as a scattering rate therefore requires the lifetime convention to be specified. The energy half-width is .
A general interacting electron is more accurately described by near the pole. The coherent peak then integrates to the quasiparticle residue and an incoherent continuum carries the remaining weight. In an energy-unit self-energy convention,
Linearizing the real denominator gives and at the pole. The requested unit-weight Lorentzian is the normalized quasiparticle model, not the most general exact interacting spectrum.
Peak position and width. At fixed , put and . Differentiation gives
It is positive for and negative for , so the only maximum is at , with height . Setting to half this height gives . Therefore
In energy units the maximum is and the half-width is . Frequency dependence of the self-energy would require reconsidering both the shape and peak position.
Fermi gas and Fermi liquid. A noninteracting Fermi gas has a delta-function spectral line at its bare dispersion for every momentum. A normal three-dimensional Fermi liquid has a shifted coherent peak plus incoherent spectral weight; close to the Fermi surface its width scales as . At zero temperature the peak becomes arbitrarily sharp at the Fermi surface, while it broadens farther away. Spectral functions include addition and removal weight; occupied-only photoemission contains an extra Fermi factor.
Figure 1.
A free spectral line and broadened quasiparticle peaks, with a separate incoherent background
. Details.
Photoemission measurement. A photon of known energy ejects an electron. Measure its kinetic energy and emission direction. For binding energy below the Fermi level and the appropriate calibrated work function , conservation of energy gives
Conservation of momentum parallel to a periodic surface gives
where is a surface reciprocal-lattice vector. At suitable photon energies the photon momentum can be neglected; at higher energies it must be retained. The surface breaks perpendicular translation symmetry, so the perpendicular crystal momentum generally needs a final-state model. A two-dimensional band can be reconstructed directly from the parallel components.
Within the sudden approximation and electric-dipole approximation, photoemission intensity and spectral function are related by
Here is measured relative to the chemical potential. Instrumental resolution convolves the product and inelastic scattering adds background. Thus ARPES maps the occupied electron removal spectral function, weighted by a matrix element; it does not measure the full unoccupied spectrum or an unweighted spectral function automatically. Bright ridges give dispersions, and intrinsic widths give decay information after instrumental effects are removed.
Reading the supplied image. Its bright ridges form a graphene-like cone. The crossing near is the Dirac point, not in general the Fermi level. In the paper's plotted energy coordinates its energy is roughly –. A velocity follows from a branch slope independently of the energy zero:
For example, the lower branch moves by about between and . This gives and
Reading other points changes the estimate by tens of percent. The original exam image has unequal energy increments on nearly equally spaced labelled ticks, so it does not justify a precise fitted velocity. The value is an estimate of the cone slope extrapolated to the Fermi crossing, rather than a measured derivative exactly at a visibly identified Fermi cutoff.
To determine a Fermi energy, first calibrate the Fermi edge, then subtract the chosen reference energy. Neither a Fermi-level marker nor an explicit energy-zero convention is supplied in this crop. If its upper termination near is intended to represent the Fermi cutoff, the conditional graph answer is on that axis, or relative to the Dirac crossing. Identifying the crossing itself as the Fermi energy would incorrectly assume undoped graphene.
The research article cited by the exam identifies this as linearly polarized graphene ARPES and independently states for the substrate-doped sample. That resolves the relative energy when this external calibration is admitted.[ref] The crop alone does not uniquely fix an absolute Fermi energy; the source-supported relative value and the conditional axis reading should be distinguished.
Use a real, even interaction . Let and . In the Bogoliubov theory expansion, keep terms with zero or two noncondensed operators. The zero-momentum term gives . The terms with two noncondensed operators give
Here is the direct condensate interaction and is its exchange contribution. At fixed total particle number, , so
The second term cancels the direct normal term. Adding the kinetic energy yields the number-conserving Bogoliubov quadratic Hamiltonian
The constant is the condensate mean-field theory interaction energy; the normal term describes moving a particle out of the condensate, while the anomalous term creates or annihilates an opposite-momentum pair by exchanging two particles with the condensate. Total particle number remains fixed in the underlying theory; the condensate amplitudes in this notation are treated as classical amplitudes.
For condensate fluctuation power counting, put . Formal interaction-amplitude counting gives , cubic terms and quartic terms ; these are not uniform bounds on individual modes. Thus the latter are down by and relative to the quadratic interaction terms. The correction is relative . Homogeneity eliminates terms linear in nonzero-momentum operators. Small depletion and weak interactions, not low temperature alone, justify the truncation. [ref]
Use the contact-interaction Bose-gas field integral for a homogeneous three-dimensional weakly interacting Bose gas with repulsive short-range interaction as the standard model. Let particle mass be , scattering length , physical coupling and gas parameter . These are symbolic model definitions, not supplied numerical parameters. The grand-canonical coherent-state integral has periodic fields and action
The contact term is the normal symbol of . In three dimensions a contact interaction needs a regulator and coupling matched to the measured scattering length; the displayed is the low-energy physical coupling. This field integral is useful because an ordered saddle and its quantum/thermal fluctuations follow from the same action.
Stationarity with respect to gives the imaginary-time Gross–Pitaevskii equation. A uniform saddle exists at with and condensate density . Its arbitrary phase reflects global symmetry; a selected condensate fixes a phase in the thermodynamic symmetry-breaking description. Write after choosing that phase. Linear terms vanish, and the quadratic part is
With and the Fourier convention , the paired quadratic kernel is
The one-half in the Nambu spinor action removes pair double counting. Analytic continuation of the inverse kernel gives the Bogoliubov dispersion
At high momentum it approaches the free-particle kinetic energy plus its mean-field shift. The crossover scale is the healing length . Gaussian integration adds a fluctuation determinant to the saddle free energy. Expressed using the physical three-dimensional coupling, its zero-temperature integrand can be regularized as ; the subtraction follows from renormalization of a three-dimensional dilute-gas contact coupling, not discarding an infinite answer arbitrarily. The thermal contribution is . A calculation beyond mean field must keep that matching and its thermodynamic derivatives consistent.
The density-phase action of a Bose gas makes the physical content clear, . Up to a periodic density total derivative, the long-wavelength quadratic action contains
number-phase conjugacy pairs the density fluctuation and phase in the quadratic density-phase action. Dropping the density-gradient term only in the long-wave limit and completing the density Gaussian square gives the Bose-gas phase-only action
This has the same sound pole. A term is also present before restricting to the smooth zero-winding sector; although locally a total derivative, it cannot in general be ignored in topologically nontrivial sectors. The density and phase variables describe the same coupled Bogoliubov branch, not a second independent massive particle simply because the density has a static restoring cost.[ref]
A phase gradient carries superflow . Its energy cost defines the superfluid number density. At leading mean-field order the stiffness uses , but condensate density and superfluid number density are different observables: for a Galilean-invariant continuum gas at zero temperature the latter is the full density even when interactions deplete the condensate. Bogoliubov coefficients give and a small zero-temperature depletion of relative order in three dimensions. Large depletion or strong long-wavelength phase fluctuations would invalidate the small-fluctuation saddle approximation.
The Landau criterion for creating excitations is for this homogeneous dispersion. Thus repulsion produces a linear sound mode and a positive critical velocity from the Landau criterion, whereas an ideal quadratic gas has zero value of this criterion. Vortices, obstacles and nucleation can reduce an actual flow threshold below ; the criterion alone is not a complete theory of metastable flow. At finite temperature thermal quasiparticles reduce the superfluid number density. Dimensionality and finite size also matter: the uniform three-dimensional weak-depletion condensate expansion must not be transferred unchanged to a one- or two-dimensional thermodynamic system. The field integral provides systematic corrections only within its dilute, stable and sufficiently weak-fluctuation regime.
Write for the one-particle Hamiltonian operator. The second quantization of the kinetic energy, external potential energy and repulsive contact interaction is
The factor counts each unordered particle pair once. Normal ordering excludes self-interaction: the interaction acts on two distinct bosons. The fixed particle number sector has . In three dimensions, this contact interaction is understood as a regulated low-energy interaction with a matched coupling, as in renormalization of a three-dimensional dilute-gas contact coupling; the finite-mode calculation below uses its projected matrix elements.
For a uniform continuum gas with pair interactions depending on relative positions, a Galilean boost changes every particle momentum by and leaves the interaction energy unchanged. Write . The transformed many-body Hamiltonian operator is
The resting ground state has , so the Galilean boost energy of an interacting gas is
The mass here is the bare particle mass, because this is an exact transformation of the microscopic kinetic energy. Substituting the Fermi-liquid effective mass would omit the change in interaction energy encoded by the Landau quasiparticle energy functional. This conclusion requires the Principle of Galilean relativity; a gas in a lattice or a fixed external potential energy landscape need not obey it.
For each spin let contain the lowest tight binding energy levels, and set and . The normalized trial Slater determinant is
Its nearest-neighbour one-body density matrix is . By Wick's theorem, fermionic exchange symmetry subtracts the squared off-diagonal one-body density matrix from the direct contribution
This formula also specifies the finite- answer exactly, including partially filled terminal energy levels through the chosen occupied set. For consecutive allowed wavevectors, ; its phase locates the centre of that occupied interval.
Write . In the large- limit the Fermi sea is centred at for and for , with Fermi wavevector measured from . Consequently
The subtraction due to fermionic exchange symmetry is essential: replacing by would discard the suppression of neighbouring equal-spin occupation. A completely filled spin band has zero kinetic energy and interaction energy , as the formula also shows.
In the large- Gross–Pitaevskii equation, dropping the kinetic energy gives . The physical nonnegative Thomas–Fermi approximation for a condensate is therefore
where and is the cloud radius. Its particle number is
Thus the two-dimensional Thomas–Fermi condensate obeys
Here is a total particle number. Keeping the exact pair count in the fixed- Hartree product state would replace by in these formulas expressed in terms of .
The approximation is best at the centre, , and worst near the edge, . For example its omitted quantum pressure of a condensate, evaluated on the interior profile, is
It is smallest at the centre and diverges at the artificial sharp edge. The central healing length is much smaller than when , since . This is the bulk validity condition; the full Gross–Pitaevskii equation smooths the edge and gives a decaying tail outside .
The Hartree product state underlying the Gross–Pitaevskii equation has the factorized one-body coherence of a Hartree condensate. Choosing its nodeless ground state orbital real gives
In particular, the Thomas–Fermi approximation for a condensate from part (d) predicts
The curve starts at , decreases with zero slope at the origin, and reaches zero with an infinite slope at . Restoring the kinetic energy in the full Gross–Pitaevskii equation rounds that edge and produces a nonzero tail. This corrects the Thomas–Fermi approximation for a condensate, but the resulting one-body density matrix still factorizes.
The additional missing physics is quantum depletion. Interactions scatter pairs of bosons into orbitals outside the Bose-Einstein condensate even at zero temperature. In terms of the true Bose-Einstein condensate orbital the exact one-body density matrix decomposes as
The single-orbital Hartree product state sets and omits altogether. In a weakly interacting Bose gas, Bogoliubov theory adds a comparatively short-range noncondensed contribution near the origin, together with reduced weight in the broad Bose-Einstein condensate component. The central value remains the total number density, not just the condensate density. Its numerical shift relative to the original Gross–Pitaevskii equation solution also depends on the interaction-induced redistribution of number density; it is not fixed by the condensate fraction alone.
Figure 1.
Edge smoothing and quantum depletion give different corrections to the correlation
. Left: a numerical radial Gross–Pitaevskii solution at is compared with the Thomas–Fermi curve, each at the same . Right: an illustrative depletion correction reduces the broad component and adds a narrow contribution, with the central density held fixed for comparison. Its weight and width are schematic, not a calculation of the exact interacting gas. Solving the full Gross–Pitaevskii equation accounts for the left correction only. Details.
The orthogonal coordinate change preserves the kinetic energy and takes the particle exchange operator to . Thus the spatial wave function is even in for bosons and odd for fermions.
The total potential energy and Hamiltonian separate as
Assume so the relative oscillator is confining. Its spectrum is , and its parity in the two-particle relative coordinate is .
The lowest boson state uses , whereas the lowest fermion state uses , . Therefore
For an oscillator of frequency , . Since ,
The factor three is the extra relative-coordinate excitation required by antisymmetry. The supplied oscillator wave functions correspond to kinetic energy ; the extra factor printed before that term in the hint is inconsistent with those functions and the stated energies. The calculation uses the conventional kinetic energy dictated by particle mass .
Let . Multiplication of the radial equation by gives . With the constant terms cancel, leaving
The indicial equation is , with roots and . The usual physical Coulomb radial origin condition selects : it imposes the regular reduced radial boundary condition . Normalizability alone at the origin is insufficient to make this selection when an irregular branch is locally square-integrable, notably at .
Write . Coefficient comparison gives
A nonterminating regular series has the exponentially growing asymptotic branch, suggested by : it supplies an component, which the prefactor cannot normalize. Equivalently the regular confluent-hypergeometric solution grows unless its first parameter is a nonpositive integer. Thus a bound state requires the numerator to vanish at some , giving
This is series-termination quantization of the Coulomb radial equation. It requires for the assumed ; at there are no such negative-energy Coulomb bound states.
For , . The angular integral cancels when computing , while the radial volume element contributes . Consequently
The ratio follows by one integration by parts and remains valid for real ; no integer-only factorial identity is needed. Since now ,
For a classical particle with that negative total energy, nonnegative kinetic energy requires , hence . This is a necessary radial bound; extra angular momentum can impose a stronger restriction.
At , and the classical boundary is . The normalized radial probability density is . With , the exterior quantum probability is
The final integration gives . This is the nonzero quantum tail beyond the classical turning region.
A permutation of identical particles multiplies a fermionic state by ; a bosonic state is invariant. Particle exchange keeps fixed and sends to . Consequently the spatial wave function is even in for the stated bosonic model and odd for the stated fermionic model. This assumes no additional spin variables in the supplied model; exchange of full particle states is the underlying rule.
The coordinate change is orthogonal, with unit Jacobian determinant, so the kinetic energy becomes
on the square with zero boundary values. Product states have energy
The one-dimensional eigenfunction is even for odd and odd for even . Bosons therefore allow odd , whereas fermions require even . The lowest bosonic pair is ; its first excited pair is . The lowest fermionic pair is . Thus
The printed bosonic ground-energy claim omits the factor ; the value above follows directly from the supplied one-dimensional spectrum and kinetic energy.
The separation is . The normalized factor integrates out. In the fermionic ground state, the relative-coordinate density is , giving
For the bosonic ground state it is , giving
Both integrals follow by replacing squared trigonometric functions by their constant and cosine parts and integrating once by parts. Hence
and the difference is . The odd relative state vanishes at coincidence, which increases its expected separation.
A permutation of identical particles multiplies a fermionic state by ; a bosonic state is invariant. Particle exchange keeps fixed and sends to . Consequently the spatial wave function is even in for the stated bosonic model and odd for the stated fermionic model. This assumes no additional spin variables in the supplied model; exchange of full particle states is the underlying rule.
The coordinate change is orthogonal, with unit Jacobian determinant, so the kinetic energy becomes
on the square with zero boundary values. Product states have energy
The one-dimensional eigenfunction is even for odd and odd for even . Bosons therefore allow odd , whereas fermions require even . The lowest bosonic pair is ; its first excited pair is . The lowest fermionic pair is . Thus
The printed bosonic ground-energy claim omits the factor ; the value above follows directly from the supplied one-dimensional spectrum and kinetic energy.
The separation is . The normalized factor integrates out. In the fermionic ground state, the relative-coordinate density is , giving
For the bosonic ground state it is , giving
Both integrals follow by replacing squared trigonometric functions by their constant and cosine parts and integrating once by parts. Hence
and the difference is . The odd relative state vanishes at coincidence, which increases its expected separation.
Twice applying the creation operator or twice applying the annihilation operator changes the energy eigenvalue by , unless they give zero. The same orthogonality argument as in part (i) therefore gives
Also the factorization in part (a) gives
Now and . Squaring in the correct operator order yields
By part (i), the means are zero, so these are the variances. Taking positive square roots gives the requested standard deviations:
These harmonic-oscillator number-state second moments also show equal mean kinetic energy and potential energy, each . Their uncertainty product is , so the ground state saturates the Heisenberg uncertainty relation.
Apply the Frobenius method at the origin. The lowest power in is , with coefficient
The terms and start at power and therefore cannot cancel a nonzero coefficient. Because , the indicial equation is
Its roots are and . Since , their leading behaviors are respectively and . The physical choice is
This is the Coulomb radial origin condition. For , the other branch is not even locally normalizable: its radial probability integral behaves as , which diverges.
For , the singular behavior is locally square-integrable with the measure , so local wavefunction normalization alone would not reject it. The ordinary three-dimensional Coulomb potential problem additionally requires the regular boundary condition . A branch violates that condition and has divergent kinetic energy integral . Thus it is excluded from the physical energy domain as well. The regular choice gives in every case.