Aperture Created 2026-10-05 Updated 2026-10-13
An aperture is an opening that admits light into or through an optical instrument. Its shape and size select the transmitted light rays; an aperture alone does not bend them as an optical lens does. The aperture stop is the opening that most restricts the bundle from an on-axis object point. The entrance pupil is the image of that aperture stop formed by the preceding optical lens elements, viewed from the object side. Consequently the effective collecting diameter is the entrance pupil diameter, which can differ from the physical hole's diameter. For example, preceding optical lens elements that enlarge a aperture stop by a factor of two give ; measuring the physical hole alone would misidentify the focal ratio. [ref].
For an unobscured circular entrance pupil under a uniform beam normal to its plane, the collecting area and admitted radiant flux are
where is incident irradiance. Doubling quadruples admitted radiant flux. Obstructions, nonuniform illumination and losses after the entrance pupil require the actual illuminated area and transmission to be included. The same also sets an angular diffraction-limited resolution scale at wavelength . Collection and diffraction therefore answer different questions from field of view: an aperture selects the bundle from each object point, while the receiving plane's extent helps select which object directions appear in the image.
NASA/JPL's published pinhole demonstration uses two white cards, foil taped over a window in one card, and a small hole pierced in the foil. Sunlight passes through the hole onto the second card; the projected image is viewed on that card. The activity describes a larger image when the card separation increases, improved visibility when the receiving card is shaded, and a separate image from each of several holes. These are qualitative observations of image formation, rather than calibrated measurements of radiant flux or diffraction. [ref].
A proposed quantitative extension replaces sunlight by a steadily illuminated asymmetric target and puts the foil and a translucent receiving screen in a dark box. Record target distance , hole-to-screen distance , hole diameter , image height, orientation and edge blur. Measure screen brightness with a fixed photodetector, or record the screen with an optical camera whose integration time and gain stay fixed. Exchange centred foils of measured at fixed ; then vary with the same foil. Geometrical optics predicts an inverted image with transverse magnification and a point's geometric blur diameter . Thus a larger hole admits more radiant flux without changing the central image scale, whereas increasing enlarges the image. These are predictions to test, not reported data. Keep target illumination and detector position fixed, subtract a hole-covered dark reading, repeat the original foil to check drift, and avoid clipping the detector response. Foil thickness and ragged edges can block oblique light rays; at sufficiently small , diffraction invalidates the claim that ever smaller holes always sharpen the image. A lensless optical camera has no optical lens focal length: is a propagation distance, not that focal length.
Conjugate pinholes in confocal microscopy Created 2026-10-14 Updated 2026-10-20
Two planes are optically conjugate when an optical lens system images one onto the other. In confocal microscopy, an illumination pinhole is imaged onto the selected specimen point, and that specimen point is imaged onto the detection pinhole. Thus the two apertures select corresponding positions in different planes; they need not occupy the same physical plane. Modern laser instruments can supply the illumination point with an optical fiber or a suitable focused laser mode instead of a separate metal illumination pinhole. [ref]
A fluorescent emitter at the selected optical focus forms a compact point spread function at the detection aperture. An emitter displaced axially produces a broadened spot there through defocus; a smaller fraction of its collected light passes. The emitter still exists and still emits photons. Rejected photons strike the opaque mask or other parts of the instrument instead of contributing to the accepted detector channel. Neither a finite pinhole nor diffraction makes the accepted out-of-focus contribution exactly zero.
Figure 1.
Conjugate illumination and detection pinholes in confocal microscopy
. Original unfolded geometrical optics schematic, not a scale drawing of an instrument. The top panel images an illumination pinhole onto the specimen; the lower panel images the selected specimen point onto the detection pinhole. Dashed orange light rays from an axially displaced point strike the mask, while an axial orange light ray passes. Real spots have finite point spread functions through diffraction; the drawing's perfect green intersection is only a ray construction. A fluorescence instrument may fold both paths through the same objective optical lens using a wavelength-selective beam splitter. Details.
Etendue Created 2026-10-06 Updated 2026-10-14
Etendue measures how much position-and-direction space a bundle of light rays occupies. A small spot accepting a wide range of directions can have the same etendue as a large spot accepting a narrow range. This makes etendue useful for deciding whether an optical instrument can deliver an extended source's entire admitted radiant flux to a small receiver. For forward crossings of a surface, the geometrical optics definition is
where is the occupied set of surface positions and directions, is the local refractive index, is actual surface area, is solid angle, and is the angle to the forward unit normal. The cosine supplies the projected area. Opposite crossing directions must be counted separately with positive projected area, rather than cancelling them in a signed integral. [ref]
The shorthand assumes constant refractive index, a narrow nearly normal bundle, and the same admitted directions across the whole area . At larger angles, use the cosine-weighted integral; a position-dependent angular acceptance cannot generally be replaced by the product of two independent extents.
Suppose an extended source fills every position of the entrance aperture with a cone of half-angle , and all these light rays must reach a one-sided planar receiver. If the receiver accepts at most a cone of half-angle , its available etendue bounds the admitted etendue:
Consequently
This original derivation combines conservation of etendue with the exact cone integral; the second inequality allows the complete output hemisphere. It bounds capacity and does not prove that a chosen shape attains the bound.
Figure 1.
Aperture clipping discards etendue; full-flux concentration requires a larger output angular range
. Left: a stop transmits of the spatial disk with unchanged directional acceptance. Right: endpoint geometry for the ideal air-to-air input-cone bound, . Interior sides are only a symbolic connection between ports, not a designed reflector or a traced ray path. Details.
For the input cone with , : a entrance cannot deliver the entire filled bundle to a circular receiver smaller than in diameter. If the output half-angle is restricted to , and the receiver diameter must be at least . For a receiver medium with model refractive index , the full-hemisphere capacity bound instead gives ; that larger value also depends on transmitting the bundle into that medium.
Attempting in the air-to-air example forces rejection of some input. For the uniform radiance already specified, even filling the entire output hemisphere gives
The maximum mean irradiance gain remains . With nonuniform radiance, rejecting a given fraction of geometric etendue need not reject the same fraction of radiant flux.
These bounds use a filled extended-source bundle in passive reversible geometrical optics, comparing the same wavelength and the same radiation channels. An ideal optical point source does not fill that four-dimensional set. Diffraction, optical coherence, or coupling a Gaussian beam into an optical fiber require a physical optics calculation; the cone bound is not a universal guarantee for a single wave mode. Likewise, optical gain or fluorescence changes the propagation assumptions.
Geometrical optics Created 2026-10-05 Updated 2026-10-14
Geometrical optics describes propagation by rays and Snell's law, neglecting diffraction on scales much larger than the wavelength.
A light ray is a path in an approximation, not a physical thread of zero width. In a transparent, homogeneous, isotropic medium it is straight and perpendicular to a wavefront; boundaries redirect it by the law of reflection or Snell's law. The approximation is useful when the wavelength is small compared with relevant apertures, surface curvature scales, and distances over which the refractive index changes. For an illustrative wavelength of and a aperture, their ratio is . That small ratio supports ray tracing for image location, but does not eliminate diffraction when calculating the fine structure of a focused spot. At a wave caustic, geometrical optics can fail despite large optical elements. [ref].
The mechanism of refraction is a change in phase velocity. For transparent isotropic media at the chosen frequency, the refractive index is
where is the vacuum speed of light and the angles are measured from the interface normal vector. At a stationary planar interface the frequency and tangential wavevector match across the boundary. Since the wavenumber is , that matching gives Snell's law. The transmitted wavelength changes while the frequency stays fixed. Here uses phase velocity, which need not equal group velocity. [ref]. [ref].
Choose model air with and model glass with , without claiming these are exact values for every sample or wavelength. At , Snell's law gives
The transmitted light ray bends toward the normal vector; its phase velocity is , and its wavelength is two thirds of the air value. By reversibility of an optical ray, incidence from glass at returns the outgoing air angle .
Incidence from glass at is a different experiment. It would require , so there is no real transmitted angle. The critical angle for total internal reflection is
Above this angle, an ideal lossless glass-air boundary produces total internal reflection. The physical optics description still permits an evanescent wave in the air, although no propagating transmitted light ray crosses the boundary. [ref]. [ref].
Figure 1.
Refraction into glass and total internal reflection on incidence from glass; all angles are measured from the normal
. Details.
The usefulness of geometrical optics is that complicated instruments can be assembled from these local rules. Applying Snell's law at successive curved surfaces changes a spreading bundle into a converging one. The Fermat principle unifies the construction through stationary optical path length; stationarity does not require a global minimum. [ref]. Fang's MIT notes explicitly connect this principle to specular reflection, refraction, and thin lens imaging, providing a route from individual paths to complete instruments. [ref].
Grazing-incidence X-ray optics redirect X-rays by shallow specular reflections along mirror surfaces. Riccardo Giacconi's lecture describes coaxial paraboloidal and hyperboloidal mirrors using two reflections, and the later Einstein observatory's imaging capability. Focusing separates collecting area from detector area: the collected source signal can remain large while the detector background is drawn from a smaller region.[ref]
An ideal lossless geometrical optics calculation explains the shallow angle. Take vacuum refractive index one and a material with real refractive index , where . Let be the grazing angle measured from the surface. Snell's law written for angles from the normal requires . A propagating transmitted ray exists only if . Thus the ideal threshold is
The last step uses the Taylor series . For a chosen , radians, or . Absorption makes the refractive index complex and softens this ideal threshold; surface roughness and alignment errors also reduce throughput or worsen the point spread function. These are reasons to calibrate X-ray effective area and angular resolution, rather than assume that reflection is perfect.
The benefit can be quantified without specifying a historical telescope. Suppose a source retains fraction of its counts inside an extraction region, while a uniform detector background contributes counts over detector area . In the background-dominated limit of the same independent on-off model,
Reducing by a factor of 100 at fixed and X-ray effective area improves this ideal ratio tenfold. A collimator restricts admitted directions; focusing optics bring selected rays together. An image also separates nearby sources and identifies clean background regions, connecting optical design directly to a better constrained inverse problem.
For a positive refractive index in cylindrical coordinates, a light ray with constant radius and varying axial coordinate has the form when it exists. Fermat principle makes stationary. Conservation of the momentum conjugate to the cyclic angle makes constant along a constant-radius path. The radial Euler-Lagrange equation is then
giving the displayed formula. A nonzero real helix requires . If , gives a straight axial light ray; a generic radial profile need not support a constant-radius helix. Its helical pitch is . This ray model is useful for a graded-index optical fiber when the refractive index varies smoothly and geometrical optics applies; it does not by itself impose wave-mode quantization or boundary confinement.
Image formation 2026-10-13
Image formation assigns each object point a corresponding image point: outgoing light rays from that object point either converge there, giving a real image, or diverge as though they originated there, giving a virtual image. The requirement applies separately to each point. Bringing unrelated light rays together makes a bright patch, but does not preserve the object's pattern. This point-by-point correspondence explains how an optical camera records a scene. [ref].
Use the same convention as thin lens: place the optical lens at , with incident light travelling to the right and a real object at , . Write the image coordinate as , so for a real image and for a virtual image. Heights are positive above the optical axis and negative below it. In air, within the paraxial approximation, a thin lens obeys
Here is the signed focal length, positive for a converging optical lens and negative for a diverging optical lens; the expression for assumes . Object distance is positive even though the object's coordinate is negative. These coordinate rules describe transmission through the optical lens; a mirror reverses the outgoing direction, so do not identify its image distance with this same rightward coordinate. [ref].
The beauty of geometrical optics is that two convenient light rays can locate a point, while a whole admitted bundle forms its image. For a converging thin lens, an incident light ray parallel to the optical axis exits through the rear optical focus; a light ray through the centre continues undeviated. Real optical lens elements do not focus every admitted light ray exactly: optical aberrations and diffraction limit the point correspondence. The diagrams below are original ideal-model constructions, not measured data. [ref].
Light ray Created 2026-10-07 Updated 2026-10-14
A path of light propagation in the geometrical optics approximation. In a smoothly varying propagation speed, Fermat principle makes its travel time stationary.
Mie scattering 2026-10-06
The electromagnetic scattering solution for a sphere describes the transition between Rayleigh scattering and geometrical optics. Grain-size-dependent efficiencies can produce structure in the radiation-pressure coefficient.
A documented experiment uses curved illumination rather than the uniform Fresnel slit propagation model. Laboratory Exercise No. 4: Diffraction, MIT 6.237, Fall 2024, printed pp. 5–6, gives a helium–neon laser at , a microscope objective optical lens, a circular aperture and a screen 5–40 cm from the object. Preparation includes comparing central brightness in Fresnel diffraction and Fraunhofer diffraction. A 40× objective produces a nonplanar incident wavefront; the opening is placed less than 1 cm from it. With objective-to-screen distance fixed, students move the opening, sketch patterns, and record positions of consecutive central nulls to estimate aperture size. The Fraunhofer diffraction pattern supplies a regime comparison. A separate spherical-obstacle task observes a bright centre inside the shadow. The handout supplies procedures, rather than measured distances or profiles.[ref]
The circular-opening test probes cancellation of complex amplitudes at the centre while the source wavefront curvature changes. To interpret it, include that curvature in the aperture field and use a circular aperture, rather than substituting the plane-illuminated Fresnel slit propagation profile. Useful additional controls are to retain the same laser and opening, centre the illumination, repeat position readings and check background with the beam blocked. If a camera replaces the visual screen readout, avoid saturation and calibrate its position scale. Alignment, imperfect aperture edges, illumination variation and limited contrast near a null constrain the inferred size. A bright central obstacle spot illustrates why the sharp shadows of geometrical optics can fail; it does not imply that every Fresnel diffraction pattern has a bright centre.
Optical fiber acceptance angle Created 2026-10-14 Updated 2026-10-25
The optical fiber acceptance angle is the largest launch half-angle admitted by the specified guide model. For a flat entrance face perpendicular to the optical axis, external refractive index , and a straight step-index optical fiber, Snell's law at the entrance gives
At the core–cladding interface, the critical angle for total internal reflection satisfies
For a meridional ray, strict total internal reflection requires . At the limiting geometry , the refracted light ray is tangent to the interface, so
This identifies the numerical aperture with an entrance cone under these assumptions. With for air, the conventional inclusive boundary condition is
for a nonnegative launch angle ; a practical launch stays inside the boundary. If , this ideal model imposes no further restriction within the forward hemisphere, and must not be used. The light ray must also intersect the optical fiber core: a suitable angle alone does not correct a misplaced beam.
For an original example, take , and air at the entrance. Then
The internal limiting angle is only , while the critical angle for total internal reflection is . A launch has and , so it satisfies total internal reflection. A launch has and , so it fails this test.
This cone is a geometrical optics result for meridional rays. A single-mode optical fiber requires the spatial overlap of the incident electromagnetic wave with its guided normal mode; its numerical aperture does not impose an exact angular cutoff on arbitrary beams. Diffraction, finite cladding, and bends require a physical optics description.[ref]
Optical path length Created 2026-10-05 Updated 2026-10-14
An optical path length measures how much propagation wave phase a path accumulates, expressed as the distance that would accumulate the same wave phase in vacuum. A centimetre in a uniform medium with refractive index has optical path length , although its geometric length remains . This makes optical path length useful whenever two contributions must arrive with matching wave phases, from an optical lens to a Michelson interferometer. [ref]
For a specified path at fixed angular frequency , the optical path length is the line integral
Here is geometric arc length, and is the phase refractive index, evaluated at the same frequency everywhere. The propagation interpretation assumes a stationary linear medium with isotropy, a real positive scalar refractive index and negligible loss, on a valid geometrical optics branch. The path can curve; at sharp interfaces apply the appropriate matching conditions to each segment. A prescribed curve has a mathematical line integral, but it predicts a propagation wave phase only when it represents the physical branch. [ref] Optical fibers can require a mode wavenumber rather than the bulk refractive index along a guessed light ray. [ref]
Fix the vacuum wavelength , with frequency and vacuum wavenumber . In a locally uniform medium the wavelength is , while the frequency stays unchanged at a stationary interface. With the convention , propagation from a specified starting wave phase contributes
The relative reference includes launch wave phases and any extra wave phase from mirrors, beam splitters or coatings. Thus is a propagation contribution, not an absolute detector wave phase independent of the apparatus. If the reference contributions stay fixed, a change in optical path difference changes the phase difference by . Using the material wavelength again in this formula would count the refractive index twice. [ref]
A motivating measurement turns invisible optical oscillations into a slowly changing electrical signal. MIT's teaching experiment uses a laser, a beam splitter, two returning mirrors, an amplified photodiode, an oscilloscope and a calibrated mirror actuator driven by a function generator. The returning beams overlap on the photodiode; one channel records detector voltage and another the actuator drive. The measured observable is the changing light intensity, including its maxima and minima, rather than direct timing of an optical cycle. A calibrated displacement per drive voltage and the spacing of the extrema relate geometric motion to the phase difference. The guide infers the laser wavelength from known actuator calibration; conversely, with independently known vacuum wavelength and ambient refractive index, the same relation calibrates mirror motion. These two unknowns cannot both be inferred from fringe spacing alone. [ref]
For a proposed change-of-medium measurement, keep the mirrors fixed and put a transparent cell of internal length in one arm. Compare its contents at refractive indices and , leaving its windows in place. At normal incidence the two traversals give
Here is the signed number of whole interference fringe cycles plus any resolved fractional cycle, counted continuously. A mirror displacement instead gives ; distinguish this double-pass factor from a single pass in a Mach-Zehnder interferometer. OpenStax's gas-cell worked example provides the same double-pass reasoning; it is a teaching calculation rather than a published measurement dataset.[ref]
An exact toy calculation makes the sensitivity visible. Stipulate , and . Then and : a full interference fringe cycle, despite unchanged geometric lengths. For a continuous change , let and choose the initial detector phase difference to be zero. Equal coherent detected arm contributions of light intensity predict
The plot is this stipulated model: gives a minimum, restores a maximum, and the reference level is chosen by adjustment of the apparatus. It contains no measured values or assigned properties of a real gas. The equivalent mirror travel in vacuum is per cycle. A single endpoint light intensity cannot distinguish from ; the continuous fringe count carries the missing information.
For an interpretable cell measurement, establish the initial phase difference with a small calibrated mirror scan, then track slow changes through successive interference fringes. Measure the dark signal and each arm separately, keep photodiode gain within its linear range, align both beams on the same region and match their linear polarizations. Monitor interferometric visibility and keep arm delays within the useful optical coherence time. Record cell length, contents, pressure and temperature; return to the starting condition to check drift. Changes in window deformation, cell length, external air or mirror position also change optical path length, so a reference cell or an independently monitored mechanical path is needed to isolate the contents' refractive index. These controls are deductions from the model, not a claim that the illustrated apparatus was operated. Loss of fringe count leaves a whole-cycle ambiguity; at an intensity extremum the first derivative with respect to phase difference vanishes, so a scan around phase quadrature is more sensitive to small changes. Broadband illumination, unstable optical coherence, vibration and strong loss can invalidate a simple one-frequency inference.
A detector measures a signal, not a force. One proposed arrangement collects transmitted and scattered light onto a quadrant photodiode, using a normalized difference of opposite segments as a position-sensitive signal. A camera can supply an independent image and bead-height check. Near a chosen operating point, a voltage channel may obey , but its linear range and sensitivity must be measured at that bead size, focus and collection geometry. An arbitrary scattered-light intensity is not automatically proportional to displacement.
Figure 1.
Momentum transfer in optical tweezers and a proposed calibrated optical trap position readout
. Original functional schematic. Left: qualitative large-bead geometrical optics paths; more axial outgoing momentum produces a backward recoil contribution, competing with forward optical scattering force. Right: a proposed detector and stage arrangement distinguishes illumination, sensing, position sensitivity and force calibration; it is not the historical 1986 apparatus. Source. Details.
A useful proposed control sequence is to record detector offsets with illumination blocked, calibrate image scale against known stage travel, and test the detector response with independently known bead-relative motion. Moving a free trapped bead's chamber is not by itself a known bead displacement: fluid drag and trap stiffness determine the shift. Use a separate immobilized bead or an independently imaged trajectory for the position response, then check whether the response transfers to the actual trapped bead. Repeat the calibration after changing trapping power or optics.
Measure the acquisition frequency response and choose a sample rate that resolves , with sufficient signal bandwidth and control of aliasing. Compare thermal calibration of an optical trap with optical trap drag calibration, sweep small positive and negative flow speeds, inspect for multiple beads, and repeat at several wall distances. Check temperature and drift before interpreting a power-dependent stiffness: a changed fluid viscosity can change even at unchanged . These are proposed diagnostics of the model, not procedures attributed to the 1970 or 1986 papers.
Optical tweezers Created 2026-10-06 Updated 2026-10-18
Optical tweezers hold and move a small particle using the force exerted by a tightly focused beam of light, usually from a laser. They can position transparent beads in a liquid and manipulate suitable biological cells. Attaching a molecule to a trapped bead turns the bead into a handle: a measured bead displacement, together with a calibrated spring constant, reveals the force exerted on the attachment. This makes microscopic manipulation and measurement possible without a mechanical tool touching the bead. Living biological cells were manipulated with infrared beams by Ashkin, Dziedzic and Yamane in 1987; Svoboda and Block used trapped beads to measure forces from individual molecules in 1994. [ref] [ref].
Why can light pull a bead towards a focus? Light carries momentum. A transparent bead with a higher refractive index than the surrounding liquid bends transmitted light rays by refraction, changing their momentum; conservation of momentum requires an opposite transfer to the bead. In the geometrical optics picture, unequal illumination of a displaced bead produces a net restoring force towards the brighter region. For a particle much smaller than the wavelength, a physical optics description replaces that ray picture. The detailed force depends on particle size, refractive index, beam shape and wavelength; the qualitative attraction does not supply a universal formula for every particle.
The optical gradient force draws a suitable transparent bead towards high illumination, while the optical scattering force generally pushes along beam propagation. A stable three-dimensional optical trap needs a balance with a restoring force in each direction: transverse confinement alone does not ensure axial confinement. Strong focusing can make the backward axial gradient contribution large enough to balance the forward scattering contribution, with the equilibrium displaced from the focus. Higher refractive index alone is insufficient; absorbing particles, different index contrasts and different beam geometries can behave differently. [ref].
Historically, Ashkin's 1970 experiments accelerated and trapped particles using radiation pressure. The 1986 paper by Ashkin, Dziedzic, Bjorkholm and Chu demonstrated the single-beam gradient optical trap for transparent particles. These are distinct steps: the earlier work established optical manipulation, and the later work supplied the tightly focused single-beam arrangement. [ref] [ref].
Near a stable equilibrium, a harmonic optical trap behaves like a spring; thermal calibration of an optical trap uses its Brownian motion to determine the effective spring constant. The later passage through a translating optical trap sections instead consider a moving localized potential energy, which need not remain harmonic throughout a passage.
Optics Created 2026-10-05 Updated 2026-10-14
Optics studies light, its propagation, and instruments for forming images and measuring optical spectra.
The central question is how light carries information from a source to an observer. A useful description must explain both where the light goes and how its distribution changes. In geometrical optics, light rays locate paths and images; in physical optics, an electromagnetic wave has a wave amplitude and a wave phase, so overlapping contributions can produce wave interference and diffraction. These descriptions address different levels of detail within the same subject. [ref].
An image is especially interesting because a single object point emits light in many directions. An optical lens redirects part of that spreading bundle toward a corresponding image point; repeating this construction over the object preserves spatial information. Simply gathering more light is insufficient: light rays from distinct object points must arrive at distinct locations. This is why an optical camera needs both an optical lens and a correctly positioned receiving surface. The thin lens example below makes that correspondence quantitative. [ref].
Parabolic reflector 2026-10-25
A parabolic reflector has a paraboloidal reflecting surface. The law of reflection makes all incident light rays parallel to its optical axis pass through one focus in ideal geometrical optics. This removes on-axis spherical aberration and explains its use as a receiving antenna for distant sources.
Gravitational waves also exhibit diffraction: the geometrical optics ray description fails when a propagation structure or lens delay is not large compared with the wave's wavelength or period. For a compact lens of mass , a useful dimensionless parameter is ; of order one signals potentially appreciable wave effects, with cosmological lens redshift supplying an additional factor when needed. Astrophysical gravitational lensing can therefore produce diffraction and frequency-dependent amplification. Ordinary objects are poor opaque screens for gravitational waves, so everyday slit-and-screen demonstrations are implausible despite the large wavelengths, which are about km at Hz.
A local-wave description requires an identifiable smooth phase with and . Real propagating wavenumber and frequency must satisfy the chosen local branch of . In a geometrical optics or slowly modulated wavepacket approximation, these quantities and the amplitude vary on scales large compared with a local wavelength and period; for example and away from degenerate points.
The phase compatibility in geometrical optics means the local fields cannot be specified independently: equality of mixed phase derivatives requires , derived as wave conservation below. These phase and scale conditions justify the local dispersion relation; they alone are not a guarantee of an arbitrary-amplitude exact PDE solution. Amplitude transport and higher-order envelope terms must also be satisfied.
A ray leaving focus and reaching a boundary point has incoming unit direction . By the law of reflection, its normal component reverses and its tangential component stays fixed. The result just derived shows that the reflected direction is , pointing exactly from to focus . Thus all such in-plane rays from one focus converge to the other after one reflection, in the ideal geometrical optics model.
Moreover, every reflected path has the same total length . In a uniform medium their propagation times are equal as well, so different reflection points do not introduce a geometrical path-length spread. Finite wavelength, surface errors and incomplete reflecting coverage limit a real focus; the ideal argument concerns rays in the plane of the ellipse. It does not assert that an arbitrary three-dimensional surface with only one elliptical section focuses every out-of-plane ray.